Most recent addition: Opening Night
Each of these movies has nostalgic significance, makes me feel warm and fuzzy, makes me cry even on a second or third or fourth viewing, or has one or more scenes that I can quote from memory. (there are even a select few that do all of the above)
Anything I give 5 stars almost automatically gets added to this list, 4.5 stars means it has about a 80% chance of making it, and 4 stars is 50/50.
My top four is always pulled from this list, and it changes on a whim based on aesthetics or current obsessions