Homemade cookie butter recipes

This cookie spread (or cookie butter) takes minutes to prepare & makes for a delicious homemade food gift! There are 3 yummy versions!

You’ll enjoy making this deliciously creamy homemade sugar cookie butter because it is so simple and easy. What’s more? Use any crispy cookies you like.

The easiest Homemade Cookie Butter recipe ever! Creamy and decadent dessert spread made with Speculoos cookies, sugar, condensed milk, and evaporated milk.

This silky-smooth spread is as thick as creamy peanut butter, but packed with the caramelized flavor and aromatic spices of Belgian speculoos.

Cookies blended into a rich, creamy butter – what’s not to love!

This EASY Cookie Butter recipe is super smooth and ready in about 5 minutes. Pair with toast, english muffins, apple slices and so much more!

This easy cookie butter recipe is a copycat of the classic Trader Joe’s Speculoos Cookie Butter. A great quick and easy snack and ready in only 5 minutes.

This Brown Butter Cookie Company Recipe makes thick, buttery cookies with a nutty flavor and the perfect amount of sea salt on top.

It's easy to make your own homemade version of the delicious European cookie butter. Typically made using Belgian-style speculoos cookies, like Biscoff, this spread is great on fruit, crackers, or toast for a sweet treat.

These Biscoff butter cookies are soft and chewy with tons of cinnamon and brown sugar flavor from Biscoff cookie butter! There is cookie butter (or Speculoos) and Biscoff cookie pieces folded in the dough and more Biscoff spread dolloped on top for a gooey finish. This is a no-chill cookie recipe made in 1 bowl that comes together in just 25 minutes!