Jump to content

Dalit: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
No edit summary
Line 22: Line 22:
==Social background and origins==
==Social background and origins==


In the context of traditional [[Hindu]] society, Dalit status has often been historically associated with occupations regarded as ritually impure: namely, any occupation involving killing, handling of animal cadavers or [[night soil]]. Engaging in these activities was considered to be polluting to the individual who performed them, and this pollution was considered to be 'contagious'. As a result, Dalits were commonly banned and segregated from full participation in Hindu social life (they could not enter the premises of a temple), while elaborate precautions were sometimes observed to prevent incidental contact between Dalits and other Hindus.
Dalit status is associated with occupations regarded as ritually impure: namely, any occupation involving killing, handling of animal cadavers or [[night soil]]. Engaging in these activities was considered to be polluting to the individual who performed them, and this pollution was considered to be 'contagious'. As a result, Dalits were commonly banned and segregated from full participation in Hindu social life (they could not enter the premises of a temple), while elaborate precautions were sometimes observed to prevent incidental contact between Dalits and other Hindus.


Historically, there may not have been clear demarcation between Dalit castes and the [[Shudra]] castes. Dalits are not a single identifiable race or caste. Instead, like the rest of the Hindu society, they are divided into various subcastes known as '[[jāti]]s.
Historically, there may not have been clear demarcation between Dalit castes and the [[Shudra]] castes. Dalits are not a single identifiable race or caste. Instead, like the rest of the Hindu society, they are divided into various subcastes known as '[[jāti]]s.

<ref>[http://jorde-lab.genetics.utah.edu/elibrary/Bamshad_2001a.pdf Utah, America, "Genetic Evidence on the Origins of Indian Caste Populations"] [[30 September]] [[2006]]</ref>
[One study] found some association between caste status and genetic markers seeming to indicate a more European lineage.

Dalit diversity may be due to newly outcaste individuals or communities over the years. It is noteworthy that '''sometimes''', regional tribes that are considered Dalits are sometimes seen by Indians as racially distinct. In both northern and southern India it is different. For example, in North India, in places such as Rajasthan they are usually lighter because Rajstahan was invaded several times by white tribes. In addition they also have different color of eyes and sometimes hair. As a result in superstition, it is said to never trust a ''cat-eyed'' person. Then, in South India, they are often regarded as more closely related to [[Tibetan people|Tibetans]], [[Myanmar|Burmese]], [[Khmer people|Khmers]], [[Thai people|Thais]], and other [[Southeast Asia|Southeast]] and [[East Asia]]ns.
Dalit diversity may be due to newly outcaste individuals or communities over the years. It is noteworthy that '''sometimes''', regional tribes that are considered Dalits are sometimes seen by Indians as racially distinct. In both northern and southern India it is different. For example, in North India, in places such as Rajasthan they are usually lighter because Rajstahan was invaded several times by white tribes. In addition they also have different color of eyes and sometimes hair. As a result in superstition, it is said to never trust a ''cat-eyed'' person. Then, in South India, they are often regarded as more closely related to [[Tibetan people|Tibetans]], [[Myanmar|Burmese]], [[Khmer people|Khmers]], [[Thai people|Thais]], and other [[Southeast Asia|Southeast]] and [[East Asia]]ns.


Many Dalits who have converted to other religions in the past few centuries continue to retain their Dalit heritage. In the [[1991]] census, Dalits numbered just over 130 million and constituted more than 16% of [[India]]'s population,.
Many Dalits who have converted to other religions in the past few centuries continue to retain their Dalit status or oppression in the eyes of the upper castes. In the [[1991]] census, Dalits numbered just over 250 million and constituted more than 25% of [[India]]'s population,.


Discrimination against Dalits is not limited to the Hindu community. This situation is exacerbated by the fact that non-Hindu Dalit groups have traditionally not been recognized as Scheduled Castes under hiring quota laws. The Dalit Muslims or "Arzal" (also called Mojahir in [[Pakistan]]), as well as Dalit Christians form an integral part of the caste system in South Asia among muslims and Christians. Many Dalit Muslims are discriminated against by the upper-caste "Ashraf" Muslims, and Dalit Christians discriminated against by upper caste Christian priests and Nuns.
Discrimination against Dalits is not limited to the Hindu community. This situation is exacerbated by the fact that non-Hindu Dalit groups have traditionally not been recognized as Scheduled Castes under hiring quota laws. The Dalit Muslims or "Arzal" (also called Mojahir in [[Pakistan]]), as well as Dalit Christians form an integral part of the caste system in South Asia among muslims and Christians. Many Dalit Muslims are discriminated against by the upper-caste "Ashraf" Muslims, and Dalit Christians discriminated against by upper caste Christian priests and Nuns.
Dalits and similar groups are also found in [[Nepal]], [[Pakistan]] and [[Bangladesh]].

Some Dalits have successfully integrated into urban Indian society, where caste origins are less obvious and less important in public life. In rural India, caste origins are more readily apparent and Dalits remain excluded from local religious life, though this exclusion in its severity is in fact fast diminishing due to changing social norms of acceptable behavior.

Dalits and similar groups are also found in [[Nepal]], [[Pakistan]] and [[Bangladesh]].


==Dalits and Indian politics==
==Dalits and Indian politics==
Line 99: Line 93:
[[Master Tara Singh]] himself helped uplift the Sikh Dalits. KP Singh a Dalit activist in UP was himself a Sikh. [[Kanshi Ram]] himself was of Sikh background although converted because he found that Sikh society did not respect Dalits and so became a neo-Buddhist. The [[Mazhabi]] are one Dalit of the [[Punjabi Dalits]] that are treated as outcastes from mainstream Sikh society and not allowed to enter Sikh temples. Jivan Singh, a friend of Guru Gobind Singh was a Dalit.
[[Master Tara Singh]] himself helped uplift the Sikh Dalits. KP Singh a Dalit activist in UP was himself a Sikh. [[Kanshi Ram]] himself was of Sikh background although converted because he found that Sikh society did not respect Dalits and so became a neo-Buddhist. The [[Mazhabi]] are one Dalit of the [[Punjabi Dalits]] that are treated as outcastes from mainstream Sikh society and not allowed to enter Sikh temples. Jivan Singh, a friend of Guru Gobind Singh was a Dalit.


===Christian Dalits===
===Dalits and Neo-Buddhism===
Converts to Christianity (facilitated by the influence of [[missionaries]]) have retained the caste system in their communities. The Dalit Christians are the lowest rung of that hierarchy.

A [[1992]] study [http://indianhope.free.fr/site_eng/article_5.php3] of [[Catholic]]s in [[Tamil Nadu]] showed that Dalit Christians face segregated churches, cemeteries, services and processions. They also face economic and social hardships due to the discrimination by upper-caste priests and nuns. One famous Dalit activist with the nom-de-plume of Bama Faustina has written books that provide a first-hand account of the discrimination against them by nuns and priests in [[South India]].<ref>http://www.hinduonnet.com/2001/09/16/stories/1316017m.htm</ref>

===Dalits and Neo-Buddhism===
In [[Maharashtra]] and a few other regions, Dalits have come under the influence of the [[neo-Buddhist]] movement initiated by [[Ambedkar]]. Some of them have come under the influence of the [[Neo-Buddhist]] and Christian [[Missionaries]] and have converted away from Hinduism into religions such as [[Christianity]] and [[Buddhism]] in what they have been told is an "attempt to eliminate the prejudice they face"<ref name="BBC"/>. Activists such as [[Udit Raj]] have claimed that such conversion will solve all discrimination problems faced by Dalits. Such claims have been criticized as "fragile at best" <ref>[http://web.archive.org/web/20030622160717/http://www.the-week.com/21nov18/events6.htm Conversion: Ram Raj's rally was probably just an exercise in self-promotion],''The Week''</ref>. The conversion attempts have also been criticized by Hindu advocacy groups as "unhelpful"<ref>[http://www.hinduamericanfoundation.org/media_press_release_dalit_hearing.htm HAF press release]</ref> as [[Indian caste system|Casteism]] is a complex dynamic that extends across all religions in India.However, the [[Constitution of India]] guarantees religious freedom and their right to choose their religion, although controversies related to mass-conversions have led to laws being passed against them in some states in India. Since then, several Christian converts have reconverted back into Hinduism as the conversions did not award them the financial rewards that the missionaries lured the with<ref>[http://www.tribuneindia.com/2005/20050219/nation.htm#9 3,500 poor villagers reconvert to Hinduism],''The Tribune''</ref>.
In [[Maharashtra]] and a few other regions, Dalits have come under the influence of the [[neo-Buddhist]] movement initiated by [[Ambedkar]]. Some of them have come under the influence of the [[Neo-Buddhist]] and Christian [[Missionaries]] and have converted away from Hinduism into religions such as [[Christianity]] and [[Buddhism]] in what they have been told is an "attempt to eliminate the prejudice they face"<ref name="BBC"/>. Activists such as [[Udit Raj]] have claimed that such conversion will solve all discrimination problems faced by Dalits. Such claims have been criticized as "fragile at best" <ref>[http://web.archive.org/web/20030622160717/http://www.the-week.com/21nov18/events6.htm Conversion: Ram Raj's rally was probably just an exercise in self-promotion],''The Week''</ref>. The conversion attempts have also been criticized by Hindu advocacy groups as "unhelpful"<ref>[http://www.hinduamericanfoundation.org/media_press_release_dalit_hearing.htm HAF press release]</ref> as [[Indian caste system|Casteism]] is a complex dynamic that extends across all religions in India.However, the [[Constitution of India]] guarantees religious freedom and their right to choose their religion, although controversies related to mass-conversions have led to laws being passed against them in some states in India. Since then, several Christian converts have reconverted back into Hinduism as the conversions did not award them the financial rewards that the missionaries lured the with<ref>[http://www.tribuneindia.com/2005/20050219/nation.htm#9 3,500 poor villagers reconvert to Hinduism],''The Tribune''</ref>.



Revision as of 21:44, 21 November 2006

You must add a |reason= parameter to this Cleanup template – replace it with {{Cleanup|October 2006|reason=<Fill reason here>}}, or remove the Cleanup template.
In the Indian caste system, a Dalit, often called an untouchable, is a person who does not have any varnas. Varna refers to the Hindu belief that most humans were created from different parts of the body of the divinity Purusha and according to which part they were created from it defines their social standing for issues such as who they can marry and what jobs they can do.[1]. Dalits fall outside varnas system and have historically been prevented from doing any but the most menial jobs.[1]They are also known as outcastes. Included are leather-workers (called chamar), poor farmers and landless laborers, scavengers (called bhangi or chura), street handicrafters, folk artists, clothes washers dhobi etc.

Terms associated with the Dalit caste

Dalit is the latest and currently most politically correct of many terms used for the caste. Offensive terms used mostly in the past include chura, bhangi, neech, kanjjar, and mirasi. Whereas the terms chura and bhangi are profession-based terms for scavengers, they can serve as general terms for the low-born; others are actual names of the caste. Harijan was a term for untouchable, coined by Mahatma Gandhi, which means Children of GodHari is another name for the god Vishnu. It is now considered patronizing. The term can also be attributed to Dalit castes of Pakistan called the haris, who are a group of mud-hut builders. Neo-Buddhist Dalits try to make 'Harijan' appear as a disgrace to all Dalits as it comes from a Hindu name. This term had already been used, in a different form, by the medieval philosopher Ramanuja who uplifted many backward caste peoples: as Thirukulattar, or People of Holy Clan. (He was probably the first to allow the untouchables into temples, albeit for limited periods.)

The word 'Dalit(a)' comes from the Marathi root dal, and means 'held under check', 'suppressed', or 'crushed', or, in a looser sense, 'oppressed'. Maharashtrian Dalit Activist and poet Namdeo Dhasal made it a symbol of pride to fight against social injustice. He said:

Yes, I do feel that the fight to eradicate caste has to be fought by Dalits and caste Hindus together carrying forward the tradition of Adi Shankara, which got broken somewhere in between[2].

It is possible that Dr. Ambedkar borrowed this term from Swami Vivekananda from his quote, "Deena-Dalita-Dukhi Devo Bhava!" ("Service to the weak, the down- trodden and the suffering masses itself is the worship of God")[3]

Another term used for the Dalits was Matanga named after Maharshi Matanga, a Matanga Bhil and guru of Bhakta Shabari. In fact, Dalits are often addressed as ‘Matanga ’in passages like Varaha Purana 1.139.91.

Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, a Dalit, and one of the leaders of the Indian independence movement, is considered the chief architect of the Indian Constitution, in which Article 17 abolishes untouchability. Ever since, under the aegis of the Constitution of India, a caste based 'Reservation System' (a form of affirmative action) has been implemented for the benefit of the 'Dalits'.

The terms scheduled castes/scheduled tribes (SC/ST) and non-caste tribes are also used in the Indian legal system to refer to this social group in India.

Social background and origins

Dalit status is associated with occupations regarded as ritually impure: namely, any occupation involving killing, handling of animal cadavers or night soil.  Engaging in these activities was considered to be polluting to the individual who performed them, and this pollution was considered to be 'contagious'.  As a result, Dalits were commonly banned and segregated from full participation in Hindu social life (they could not enter the premises of a temple), while elaborate precautions were sometimes observed to prevent incidental contact between Dalits and other Hindus.

Historically, there may not have been clear demarcation between Dalit castes and the Shudra castes. Dalits are not a single identifiable race or caste. Instead, like the rest of the Hindu society, they are divided into various subcastes known as 'jātis.

Dalit diversity may be due to newly outcaste individuals or communities over the years. It is noteworthy that sometimes, regional tribes that are considered Dalits are sometimes seen by Indians as racially distinct. In both northern and southern India it is different. For example, in North India, in places such as Rajasthan they are usually lighter because Rajstahan was invaded several times by white tribes. In addition they also have different color of eyes and sometimes hair. As a result in superstition, it is said to never trust a cat-eyed person. Then, in South India, they are often regarded as more closely related to Tibetans, Burmese, Khmers, Thais, and other Southeast and East Asians.

Many Dalits who have converted to other religions in the past few centuries continue to retain their Dalit status or oppression in the eyes of the upper castes. In the 1991 census, Dalits numbered just over 250 million and constituted more than 25% of India's population,.

Discrimination against Dalits is not limited to the Hindu community. This situation is exacerbated by the fact that non-Hindu Dalit groups have traditionally not been recognized as Scheduled Castes under hiring quota laws. The Dalit Muslims or "Arzal" (also called Mojahir in Pakistan), as well as Dalit Christians form an integral part of the caste system in South Asia among muslims and Christians. Many Dalit Muslims are discriminated against by the upper-caste "Ashraf" Muslims, and Dalit Christians discriminated against by upper caste Christian priests and Nuns.

Dalits and similar groups are also found in Nepal, Pakistan and Bangladesh.

Dalits and Indian politics

Mahatma Gandhi made it part of the Indian National Congress's mission to eradicate untouchability. For this reason, untouchability has been officially abolished in India, although the social practice still exists today, particularly in rural villages.

In these villages, Dalits are still not allowed to let their shadows fall upon a non-Dalit caste member (particularly a Brahmin, for fear of ritually contaminating them), and they are still required to sweep the ground where they walk to remove the 'contamination' of their footfalls. In some of these villages, rural Dalits are forbidden to worship in temples or draw water from the same wells as caste Hindus, and they usually live in segregated neighbourhoods outside the main village.

In urban areas and most villages the old concepts of a rigid caste system and untouchability usually no longer exist, though most Indians still voluntarily hold on to their caste origins, which is intended to reflect that their ancestors belonged to their castes with a sense of pride in the duties and responsibilities as required by the caste rules. In matrimonial matters, whether the wed couple is Dalit or non-Dalit, caste identity is a practical near-must. This is, however, ignored by inter-caste couples, who marry ignoring castes but due to an attraction on the basis of education or economic status, of either or both members of the couple.

While the Indian Constitution has duly made special provisions for the social and economic uplift of the Dalits, comprising the so-called scheduled castes and tribes in order to enable them to achieve upward social mobility, these concessions are limited to only those Dalits who remain Hindu. There is a demand among the Dalits who have converted to other religions that the statutory benefits should be extended to them as well as social relief to "overcome" historical injustices.

Another major politically charged issue with the rise of Hindutva's role in Indian politics is that of religious conversion. This political movement alleges that conversions of Dalits are due not to any social or theological motivation but to allurements like education and jobs. Critics argue that the inverse is true with laws banning conversion, and the limiting of social relief for these backward sections of Indian society being revoked for those who convert.Bangaru Laxman, a Dalit politician, was a prominent member of the Hindutva movement.

Another political issue is over the affirmative action measures taken by the government towards the uplift of the Dalits by implementation of quotas in government jobs and university admissions aimed at improving Dalit representation. About 8% of the seats in the National and State Parliaments are reserved for Scheduled Caste and Tribe candidates, a measure sought by B.R. Ambedkar and other Dalit activists in order to ensure that Dalits would obtain a proportionate political voice.

Dalits and religion

Hindu Dalits (Harijans)

Many Dalits continue to debate whether they are 'Hindu' or 'non-Hindu'. Missionaries have initiated several Dalit organizations. In some regions of India and Nepal, missionaries have been successful among the Dalits. both in Eastern India and Nepal, many Dalits have come under the combined influence of Maoists and the missionaries, even attacking and murdering Hindus [1]. Traditionally, Hindu Dalits or Harijans have been barred from many activities that were seen as central to Vedic religion and Hindu practices of orthodox sects. Among Hindus each community has followed its own variation of Hinduism. The wide variety of practices and beliefs observed in Hinduism makes any clear assessment difficult.

Some of the movements in Hinduism have welcomed Dalits into their fold. The Satnami movement was founded by Guru Ghasidas a Dalit himself. In addition, other Hindu groups have reached out to the Dalit community in an effort to reconcile with them, with productive results. On August 2006, Dalit activist Namdeo Dhasal engaged in dialogue with the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh in an attempt to "bury the hatchet"[2].

Another popular Harijan includes Babaji Palwankar Baloo, who joined the Hindu Mahasabha and was both a politician and a cricketer. He was an independence fighters.

However, extremist far-right militia groups such as the Ranvir Sena, largely run by upper-caste landlords in backward areas of the Indian state of Bihar, oppose equal treatment of Dalits and have resorted to violent means to suppress them. The Ranvir Sena is considered a terrorist organization[4].On the other side, extremist groups run by small minority of Dalits such as the "Dalit Panthers Movement" have committed violent acts against Brahmins and middle-caste people.

In Pakistan, a predominantly Muslim nation, more than 60% of the 1.4 million Hindu minority are Dalits.[5]

Muslim Dalits (Arzal/Muhajir)

Muslim society in India can also be separated into several caste-like groups. Descendants of indigenous lower-caste converts are discriminated against by "noble", or "ashraf", Muslims who can trace their descent to Arab, Iranian, or Central-Asian ancestors. There are several groups in India working to emancipate them from upper-caste Muslim discrimination [2][3]. The Dalit Muslims are referred to by the Ashraf and Ajlaf Muslims as Arzal or "ritually degraded". They are also referred to as "Mujahir" in Pakistan and euphemistically called "Bhaiya".They were first recorded in the 1901 census as those “with whom no other Muhammadan would associate, and who are forbidden to enter the mosque or to use the public burial ground”.They are relegated to "menial" professions such as scavenging and carrying night soil[6][7]. Babasaheb Ambedkar, a reknowned Dalit activist and the framer of the Constitution of India, wrote about the Dalit Muslims and was extremely critical of their mistreatment by upper-caste Muslims quoting that "Within these groups there are castes with social precedence of exactly the same nature as one finds among the Hindus" [8] [9]. Abdus Salam, a physicist well known for his work in the Glashow-Weinberg-Salam Electroweak theory, was a famous Dalit Muslim ("Mujahir").

In Pakistan, a predominantly Muslim nation, 80% of the Muslim farmers of Sindh or 24% of the total population are Mojahir [4]. There are estimated to be 6.8 million[citation needed] Mayazurs (bonded laborers) in Punjab and another 7.5 million in Sindh. Although the Pakistani Supreme Court has ruled bonded labor unconstitutional and the National Assembly has passed laws prohibiting it, these laws remain largely unenforced due to the influence of large landlords. [10]

Furthermore, the AIBMM is striving to achieve the SC status for India's Muhajirs.

Sikh Dalits

Master Tara Singh himself helped uplift the Sikh Dalits. KP Singh a Dalit activist in UP was himself a Sikh. Kanshi Ram himself was of Sikh background although converted because he found that Sikh society did not respect Dalits and so became a neo-Buddhist. The Mazhabi are one Dalit of the Punjabi Dalits that are treated as outcastes from mainstream Sikh society and not allowed to enter Sikh temples. Jivan Singh, a friend of Guru Gobind Singh was a Dalit.

===Dalits and Neo-Buddhism===

In Maharashtra and a few other regions, Dalits have come under the influence of the neo-Buddhist movement initiated by Ambedkar. Some of them have come under the influence of the Neo-Buddhist and Christian Missionaries and have converted away from Hinduism into religions such as Christianity and Buddhism in what they have been told is an "attempt to eliminate the prejudice they face"[1]. Activists such as Udit Raj have claimed that such conversion will solve all discrimination problems faced by Dalits. Such claims have been criticized as "fragile at best" [11]. The conversion attempts have also been criticized by Hindu advocacy groups as "unhelpful"[12] as Casteism is a complex dynamic that extends across all religions in India.However, the Constitution of India guarantees religious freedom and their right to choose their religion, although controversies related to mass-conversions have led to laws being passed against them in some states in India. Since then, several Christian converts have reconverted back into Hinduism as the conversions did not award them the financial rewards that the missionaries lured the with[13].

See Also

References

  1. ^ a b c BBC News Article: Low-caste Hindus adopt new faith, Last accessed 15 October 2006
  2. ^ a b Dalit leader buries the hatchet with RSS, Sangh Parivar insider's perspective
  3. ^ Sevabharati.net
  4. ^ Ranvir Sena,South Asia Terrorism Portal
  5. ^ http://www.countercurrents.org/dalit-sikand060304.htm
  6. ^ Dereserve these myths by Tanweer Fazal,Indian express
  7. ^ Faziur Rashid Khan (1979). "District town elites in Bangladesh". Asian Survey. 19 (5): 468–484. {{cite journal}}: Unknown parameter |month= ignored (help)
  8. ^ Ambedkar, Bhimrao. Pakistan or the Partition of India. Thackers Publishers.
  9. ^ Web resource for Pakistan or the Partition of India
  10. ^ http://www.antislavery.org/archive/submission/submission1999-08Pakistan.htm
  11. ^ Conversion: Ram Raj's rally was probably just an exercise in self-promotion,The Week
  12. ^ HAF press release
  13. ^ 3,500 poor villagers reconvert to Hinduism,The Tribune