Cultural depictions of Edward I of England

Edward I of England has been portrayed in popular culture a number of times.

Literature

Edward's life was dramatised in the Famous Chronicle of King Edward the First, a Renaissance theatrical play by George Peele.

Edward I was often featured in historical fictions written in the Victorian and Edwardian Eras. Novels featuring Edward from this period include Truths and Fictions of the Middle Ages (1837) by Francis Palgrave, G. P. R. James's Robin Hood novel Forest Days; or Robin Hood (1843), The Lord of Dynevor: A Tale of the Times of Edward the First (1892) by Evelyn Everett-Green, Simon de Montfort; or, The third siege of Rochester Castle by Edwin Harris (1902), and De Montfort's squire. A story of the battle of Lewes by the Reverend Frederick Harrison (1909) ^[1] The Prince and the Page: A Story of the Last Crusade (1866) by Charlotte Mary Yonge, is about Edward's involvement in the Ninth Crusade, and depicts Edward as chivalrous and brave.^[1]^[2]

The play The King's Jewery (1927) by Halcott Glover deals with Edward's relationship with England's Jewish community. ^[3] The Baron's Hostage (1952) by Geoffrey Trease depicts Edward as a young man, and features Edward taking part in the Battle of Evesham. ^[4]

Edward is unflatteringly depicted in several novels with a contemporary setting, including the Brothers of Gwynedd quartet by Edith Pargeter, where Edward is depicted as the antagonist of the novel's Welsh heroes. ^[5] Edward I also appears in The Reckoning and Falls the Shadow by Sharon Penman, The Wallace and The Bruce Trilogy by Nigel Tranter, and the Brethren trilogy by Robyn Young, a fictional account of Edward and his involvement with a secret organisation within the Knights Templar. ^[6] In the Hugh Corbett historical mystery novels by Paul C. Doherty, the titular hero is employed by Edward I to solve crimes. ^[7]

Hungarian poet Janos Arany's ballad The Bards of Wales retells the legend of the 500 Welsh bards, who were burned at the stake by King Edward I of England for refusing to sing his praises during a banquet at Montgomery Castle, following the Plantagenet conquest of Wales.^[8]

The poem was meant as a veiled attack against Emperor Franz Joseph and Tsar Nicholas I of Russia for their roles in the defeat of the Hungarian Revolution of 1848 and for the repressive policies in the Kingdom of Hungary that followed the end of the uprising.^[9]

Film and television

Edward I has also been portrayed by Michael Rennie in the 1950 film The Black Rose, based on the novel by Thomas B. Costain.
Edward was portrayed by Patrick McGoohan as a psychopathic tyrant in the 1995 film Braveheart, in which he is referred to as a 'pagan'.^[10] Though the film exaggerates Edward's brutality, his physical and mental abuse of his son and heir before the whole court, as well as his disdain for the Scots, is for the most part accurately depicted.
Edward was played, as an idealist by Brian Blessed, in the 1996 film The Bruce.
Edward was played by Donald Sumpter in the 2008 BBC TV comedy-drama Heist.
Edward was played by Stephen Dillane in the 2018 Netflix historical drama film Outlaw King.
Edward I served as an inspiration for Tywin Lannister in the HBO television series Game of Thrones.

Radio

Edward was played by Noel Johnson in a 1958 BBC Home Service Children's Hour adaption of Trease's The Baron's Hostage. ^[11]
Edward was played by Philip Jackson in Mike Walker's BBC Radio 4 series Plantagenet.^[12]

Video games

Edward is featured as the main antagonist in the cutscenes of the tutorial campaign of the 1999 video game Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings. He is featured as the protagonist of his own campaign in the Age of Empires II: Definitive Edition expansion Lords of the West. ^[13]

Citations

^ ^a ^b Ernest A. Baker, A Guide to Historical Fiction. London : G. Routledge and Sons, 1914.(pp. 22-3)
^ Mike Horswell, The Rise and Fall of British Crusader Medievalism, c.1825–1945 .Abingdon-on-Thames, Oxford; Routledge. ISBN 9781351584258 (pp. 68-70).
^ "Mr. Glover is a modernist both in form and in feeling. Consequently when he treats...race prejudice in England at the time of Edward I in "The King's Jewery," he does so with a radiant straightforwardness..." "The New Books: Drama". The Saturday Review, July 23, 1927, (p. 997)
^ Myron J. Smith, War Story Guide: an annotated bibliography of military fiction. Scarecrow Press, 1980. ISBN 978-0810812819 (p. 41)
^ Janet Husband, Jonathan F. Husband Sequels: An Annotated Guide to Novels in Series. American Library Association, 2009. ISBN 0838909671 (p. 528).
^ ""The Brethern Trilogy: The Fall of the Templars" by Robyn Young. Reviewed by Phyllis T. Smith. Historical Novel Society. Retrieved 19 July 2019.
^ Anne McKendry, Medieval Crime Fiction: A Critical Overview. McFarland, 2019 ISBN 1476666717 (pp. 53-55).
^ "kfg moore | Poet | A Walesi Bárdok / The Welsh Bards". kevin-moore.co.uk.
^ "Tale of Welsh bards' massacre taught to generations... in Hungary". 2013.
^ Traquair, Peter. Freedom's Sword: Scotland's Wars of Independence. HarperCollins, 1998, ISBN 9780004720807 (p. 147)
^ Children's Hour:The Baron's Hostage" BBC Home Service Basic, 17 September 1958. Retrieved 2 June 2021.
^ "Classic Serial:Plantagenet" Mahoney, Elisabeth. The Guardian,30 May 2011. 2 June 2021.
^ "Pre-Order Age of Empires II: DE – Lords of the West, coming January 26th! – Age of Empires". www.ageofempires.com.

[eab-1] Ernest A. Baker, A Guide to Historical Fiction. London : G. Routledge and Sons, 1914.(pp. 22-3)

[2] Mike Horswell, The Rise and Fall of British Crusader Medievalism, c.1825–1945 .Abingdon-on-Thames, Oxford; Routledge. ISBN 9781351584258 (pp. 68-70).

[3] "Mr. Glover is a modernist both in form and in feeling. Consequently when he treats...race prejudice in England at the time of Edward I in "The King's Jewery," he does so with a radiant straightforwardness..." "The New Books: Drama". The Saturday Review, July 23, 1927, (p. 997)

[4] Myron J. Smith, War Story Guide: an annotated bibliography of military fiction. Scarecrow Press, 1980. ISBN 978-0810812819 (p. 41)

[5] Janet Husband, Jonathan F. Husband Sequels: An Annotated Guide to Novels in Series. American Library Association, 2009. ISBN 0838909671 (p. 528).

[6] ""The Brethern Trilogy: The Fall of the Templars" by Robyn Young. Reviewed by Phyllis T. Smith. Historical Novel Society. Retrieved 19 July 2019.

[7] Anne McKendry, Medieval Crime Fiction: A Critical Overview. McFarland, 2019 ISBN 1476666717 (pp. 53-55).

[8] "kfg moore | Poet | A Walesi Bárdok / The Welsh Bards". kevin-moore.co.uk.

[9] "Tale of Welsh bards' massacre taught to generations... in Hungary". 2013.

[10] Traquair, Peter. Freedom's Sword: Scotland's Wars of Independence. HarperCollins, 1998, ISBN 9780004720807 (p. 147)

[11] Children's Hour:The Baron's Hostage" BBC Home Service Basic, 17 September 1958. Retrieved 2 June 2021.

[12] "Classic Serial:Plantagenet" Mahoney, Elisabeth. The Guardian,30 May 2011. 2 June 2021.

[13] "Pre-Order Age of Empires II: DE – Lords of the West, coming January 26th! – Age of Empires". www.ageofempires.com.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

v t e Cultural depictions of English and British monarchs
Kingdom of the English 886–1066	Alfred the Great Edward the Elder Æthelflæd Ælfweard Athelstan the Glorious¹ Edmund the Magnificent¹ Eadred¹ Eadwig the Fair¹ Edgar the Peaceable¹ Edward the Martyr Æthelred the Unready Sweyn Forkbeard Edmund Ironside Cnut¹ Harold Harefoot Harthacnut Edward the Confessor Harold Godwinson Edgar the Ætheling
Kingdom of England 1066–1649	William I William II Henry I Stephen Matilda Henry II² Henry the Young King Richard I John² Henry III² Edward I² Edward II² Edward III² Richard II² Henry IV² Henry V² Henry VI² Edward IV² Edward V² Richard III² Henry VII² Henry VIII² Edward VI² Jane² Mary I² with Philip² Elizabeth I ² James I³ Charles I³
Commonwealth of England, Scotland and Ireland 1653–1659	Oliver Cromwell⁴ Richard Cromwell⁴
Kingdom of England 1660–1707	Charles II³ James II³ William III and Mary II³ Anne³
Kingdom of Scotland 843–1707 (traditional)	Kenneth I MacAlpin Donald I Constantine I (II) Áed Giric Eochaid Donald II Constantine II (III) Malcolm I Indulf Dub Cuilén Amlaíb Kenneth II Constantine III (IV) Kenneth III Malcolm II Duncan I Macbeth Lulach Malcolm III Canmore Donald III Duncan II Donald III Edgar Alexander I David I Malcolm IV William I the Lion Alexander II Alexander III Margaret John Robert I David II Robert II Robert III James I James II James III James IV James V Mary I James VI ⁵ Charles I⁵ Charles II⁵ James VII⁵ Mary II⁵ William III⁵ Anne⁵
British monarchs after the Acts of Union 1707	Anne George I George II George III George IV William IV Victoria Edward VII George V Edward VIII George VI Elizabeth II Charles III
¹Overlord of Britain. ²Also ruler of Ireland. ³Also ruler of Scotland and Ireland. ⁴Lord Protector. ⁵Also ruler of England and Ireland. Debatable or disputed rulers are in italics.