Skip to content

ulab: unexpected result of ulab.numerical.std(list) #4086

@bspsbee

Description

@bspsbee

Running the benchmark code from A Simple Benchmark

From adafruit-circuitpython-itsybitsy_m4_express-en_US-6.1.0-rc.0.uf2 forward, the result of ulab.numerical.std(nums_list) is larger than expected. 35358 instead of 3535.

First observed on Raspberry Pi Pico.

Tested release versions on ItsyBitsy M4:

adafruit-circuitpython-itsybitsy_m4_express-en_US-6.2.0-beta.1.uf2
traditional                    :    2.228ms [result=3535.843611]
ulab, with ndarray, some implementation in python :    0.284ms [result=3535.853624]
ulab only, with list           :    0.159ms [result=35358.531475]
ulab only, with ndarray        :    0.072ms [result=3535.853624]

adafruit-circuitpython-itsybitsy_m4_express-en_US-6.2.0-beta.0.uf2
traditional                    :    2.390ms [result=3535.843611]
ulab, with ndarray, some implementation in python :    0.288ms [result=3535.853624]
ulab only, with list           :    0.157ms [result=35358.531475]
ulab only, with ndarray        :    0.072ms [result=3535.853624]

adafruit-circuitpython-itsybitsy_m4_express-en_US-6.1.0.uf2
traditional                    :    2.318ms [result=3535.843611]
ulab, with ndarray, some implementation in python :    0.283ms [result=3535.853624]
ulab only, with list           :    0.159ms [result=35358.531475]
ulab only, with ndarray        :    0.072ms [result=3535.853624]

adafruit-circuitpython-itsybitsy_m4_express-en_US-6.1.0-rc.1.uf2
traditional                    :    2.386ms [result=3535.843611]
ulab, with ndarray, some implementation in python :    0.282ms [result=3535.853624]
ulab only, with list           :    0.157ms [result=35358.531475]
ulab only, with ndarray        :    0.071ms [result=3535.853624]

adafruit-circuitpython-itsybitsy_m4_express-en_US-6.1.0-rc.0.uf2
traditional                    :    2.316ms [result=3535.843611]
ulab, with ndarray, some implementation in python :    0.289ms [result=3535.853624]
ulab only, with list           :    0.159ms [result=35358.531475]
ulab only, with ndarray        :    0.071ms [result=3535.853624]

adafruit-circuitpython-itsybitsy_m4_express-en_US-6.1.0-beta.3.uf2
ImportError: no module named 'ulab.numerical'

adafruit-circuitpython-itsybitsy_m4_express-en_US-6.1.0-beta.2.uf2
ImportError: no module named 'ulab.numerical'

adafruit-circuitpython-itsybitsy_m4_express-en_US-6.1.0-beta.1.uf2
traditional                    :    2.258ms [result=3535.843611]
ulab, with ndarray, some implementation in python :    0.231ms [result=3535.853624]
ulab only, with list           :    0.262ms [result=3535.854340]
ulab only, with ndarray        :    0.061ms [result=3535.854340]

adafruit-circuitpython-itsybitsy_m4_express-en_US-6.1.0-beta.0.uf2
traditional                    :    2.305ms [result=3535.843611]
ulab, with ndarray, some implementation in python :    0.231ms [result=3535.853624]
ulab only, with list           :    0.260ms [result=3535.854340]
ulab only, with ndarray        :    0.060ms [result=3535.854340]

adafruit-circuitpython-itsybitsy_m4_express-en_US-6.0.1.uf2
traditional                    :    2.267ms [result=3535.843611]
ulab, with ndarray, some implementation in python :    0.229ms [result=3535.853624]
ulab only, with list           :    0.261ms [result=3535.854340]
ulab only, with ndarray        :    0.059ms [result=3535.854340]

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions