@Tsche , if you want your real name to appear in the git commit history, please configure it in the github profile settings.

@jwakely, does this need an LWG issue?

I'll do some archaeology and see if it's been discussed or just forgotten (probably the latter)

@Tsche , if you want your real name to appear in the git commit history, please configure it in the github profile settings.

Thanks. I'd prefer committing it under this pseudonym instead if that's okay with you.

@jwakely I've done some digging but could not find any discussion about this in old meeting minutes. P0088r3 and earlier versions thereof already miss the throws clause on that ctor.

It looks like this defect is an artifact of a change between P0088R0 and P0088R1. Note how in R0 neither one of the emplaced_type_t/emplaced_index_t (as they were then called) + initializer_list constructors have a throws clause. In R1 only one of them gained it.

This seems like a simple oversight to me. How would you like to proceed?