Skip to content

RejectionRationale

Jump to bottom Edit New page
Beman edited this page Mar 22, 2013 · 2 revisions

LEWG Reasons for rejecting a paper

Front matter

Thank you for sharing your ideas with us, but the committee has decide to close your proposal without taking any action. The rationale for this decision includes the following concerns.

Duplicate

Your proposal duplicates work already underway by the committee. Add reference to document or issue

Beyond the scope of standardization

Breakage of existing code

Narrow problem domain

Lack of committee expertise

Dependencies on other libraries

Prefer a different or competing technical approach

Lack of motivation

Lack of technical details

Lack of comparison with other work

Lack of existing practice

Lack of reference implementation

Lack of user experience

Add a custom footer
Add a custom sidebar
Clone this wiki locally