Make colorbar draw edge with facecolor around the faces. #1178
Conversation
…nged when matplotlib#901 and was merged, to allow different edgecolors, due to the way get_edgecolors behave. This restors the original behavior of colorbar in both mpl and the axisgrid1 toolkit by setting the edgecolor to 'face'
|
I've always wondered what caused those. Thanks for looking into this. |
|
Caution: you have identified a real problem and a possible solution, but it might not be the best one. Coloring the edges tends to have bad effects when alpha is not 1; and even when alpha is 1, it leads to a subtle position shift. Are you sure that prior to the #901 merge, the edgecolor was being set to "face"? |
|
Yes I am. If you look at the draw_quad_mesh code in backend_bases.py before the merge of #901 you can see that only two options exist. Either the edge is draw in black if showedges is true otherwise edgecolor is set equal to facecolor. We might consider changing the default in axes.py back to none and only change it to face in the colorbars. |
|
This problem of boundary effects keeps cropping up, and your proposed solution will help in some circumstances and hurt in others. Fundamentally, I think that not drawing edges is the correct procedure, and so I think the problem is in the implementation of the drawing. This may be partly in mpl, and partly in external renderers such as pdf viewers. Wherever we can find places in mpl where we are handling this wrong, such as by making patches overlap by one pixel, or have a gap of one pixel, we should fix it. |
|
This is a problem in the renderer (the viewer), in the sense that when displaying the pdf, the stripes move around as the figure is resized; so the stripes are not embedded in the pdf. It seems to be a truncation error; it looks like aliasing. |
|
This solution also has problems with colorbar extensions rendering outside the black edges. I can confirm that rebuilding libpoppler with the fix indicated in #1188 fixes the problem here. If anyone are interested I build a new version of libpoppler here with the patch for ubuntu 12.04. https://launchpad.net/~jenshnielsen/+archive/ppa Other viewers that seem to suffer from the same problems are svg rendering in firefox and chrome as well as pdfs in mozillas pdf.js. |
the colorbar. Resolve problems with white lines in colorbars. Not enabled by default. See matplotlib#1178 and matplotlib#1188
This was changed when #901 and was merged, to allow different edgecolors,
due to the way get_edgecolors behave. This restores the
original behavior of colorbar in both mpl and the axisgrid1 toolkit by setting the edgecolor to 'face'
Without the edge color set to facecolor the colorbars have white stripes in pdf. See the attached files for an example. The rendering in pdf might be viewer dependent. The png screenshots illustrates the rendering in evince on linux
Pdf before fix
http://ubuntuone.com/7YrairHdLJAaskzIC215KI
Pdf after fix
http://ubuntuone.com/1qNZvSFlXzZNRDqMAafxBJ
Screenshot before
http://ubuntuone.com/3RRIM3P6j3rqgLnXpTI2c1
Screenshot after
http://ubuntuone.com/5Dd7x4gwRXAWyPswZRfOdk