Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

5G-SA: cell configuration for Band n78: ERROR: Coreset0 index=6 is not compatible with DL ARFCN 630000 in band 78 #975

Closed
chris5g opened this issue Aug 31, 2022 · 14 comments

Comments

@chris5g
Copy link

chris5g commented Aug 31, 2022

Issue Description

I am not able to configure Band n78 with srsRAN v220401 in rr.conf for 5G SA.
Other bands (e.g. n3, n71) are ok (at least srsenb is starting).
I can't figure out what coreset0 index is working.....for Band n78.
When starting srsenb I get the following ERROR:

ERROR: Coreset0 index=6 is not compatible with DL ARFCN 630000 in band 78
ERROR: Deriving SSB parameters

Setup Details

nr_cell_list =
(
// no NR cells
{
rf_port = 0;
cell_id = 1;
root_seq_idx = 1;
tac = 7;
pci = 500;

/*
// FDD:
dl_arfcn = 368500;
coreset0_idx = 6
band = 3;
*/

// TDD:
dl_arfcn = 630000;
band = 78;
coreset0_idx = 6;

}
);

Any help would be appriciated.

@strongcourage
Copy link

Hi @chris5g, I tried also to configure Band n78 for the NR cell as my Samsung S20 worked with 5G NSA network. However, for 5G SA network, I faced the same issue as yours. I'm wondering whether you've figured out the solution? Or we really need to buy a new phone in the list of tested phones. Thanks.

@chris5g
Copy link
Author

chris5g commented Sep 5, 2022

Hi,
unfortunately not. I found some note in the srsRAN docu:
"Currently, srsRAN only supports the use of FDD bands for 5G SA." Since n78 is TDD I fear that n78 is currently not supported. any confirmation would be appriciated.

btw. I have a Samsung S21 and SA is not working for me currently. ( I guess firmware update is needed). however at least the 5G signal can be seen.

hope that helps,
br,
chris

@strongcourage
Copy link

Thanks @chris5g . How did you check this "at least the 5G signal can be seen"?

@chris5g
Copy link
Author

chris5g commented Sep 5, 2022

I searched for network operators manually in the mobile network menu of the phone and I could saw the MCC,NDC from the 5GSA.

@chris5g
Copy link
Author

chris5g commented Sep 5, 2022

Just to let know and not confuse u. The Samsung S21 was used with another radio not with srsRAN when I mentioned to see the 5g SA signal.

@iman432
Copy link

iman432 commented Sep 6, 2022

i also have this issue even by FDD , for example in my case band is N28 :

IMG-20220904-WA0046

@chris5g
Copy link
Author

chris5g commented Sep 6, 2022

@iman432: With this setting gnB is starting:
dl_arfcn = 156000;
band = 28;
coreset0_idx = 6;

@strongcourage
Copy link

@chris5g How did you know the correct value of dl_arfcn? Is there any official document about this parameter for each band? Also, I've tried to modify the value of coreset0_idx for band 78, but had no luck.

@iman432
Copy link

iman432 commented Sep 6, 2022

@iman432: With this setting gnB is starting: dl_arfcn = 156000; band = 28; coreset0_idx = 6;

Thank you, my version is 22.04 and i think its solved in 22.04.1 as below :

Change Log for Releases

22.04.1

  • Various bug fixes in RLC AM and PDCP for NR
  • Fix crash when UE attempted to reestablish in SA
  • Remove fixed coreset0 index for SSB === should be related to this
  • Add support for SIB5 and SIB6 transmission in LTE

@chris5g
Copy link
Author

chris5g commented Sep 6, 2022

@iman4332: Yes I using v22.04.01.

@strongcourage: there a several sites available. e.g. https://www.sqimway.com/nr_band.php/

@iman432
Copy link

iman432 commented Sep 19, 2022

Seems bands after N71, have issue with coreset.

N78 :

n78

N77 :

n77

N74 :

N74

@robertfalkenberg
Copy link
Contributor

Currently for 5G-SA, TDD bands with 30kHz SCS (e.g. n78, n77) are not supported.

@BouazzaEhm
Copy link

Hello i have the same issue using 5G NSA can someone help me please

@BouazzaEhm
Copy link

nr_cell_list =
(
{
rf_port = 1;
cell_id = 0x02;
tac = 0x0007;
pci = 500;
root_seq_idx = 204;

// TDD:
//dl_arfcn = 634240;
//band = 78;

// FDD:
dl_arfcn = 368500;
band = 3;
coreset0_idx = 6

}
);

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

5 participants