The First Doctor's Era

1.5M ratings
277k ratings

See, that’s what the app is perfect for.

Sounds perfect Wahhhh, I don’t wanna
companion-showdown
companion-showdown

Who is your favourite companion?

12 images of Doctor Who characters, on the top row left to right is Brian the Ood, Andy Davidson, Barbara Wright, Liv Chenka, Alison Cheney, and Bill Potts, and on the bottom, Oliver Harper, Steven Taylor, River Song, Yasmin Khan, K9, and Fitz Kreiner, text in the centre reads tiebreak round only 1 will advanceALT

TIEBREAK: Only the top companion will proceed

Brian the Ood

Andy Davidson

Barbara Wright

Liv Chenka

Alison Cheney

Bill Potts

Olicer Harper

Steven Taylor

River Song

Yasmin Khan

K9

Fitz Kreiner

Brian the Ood and Andy Davidson tied, giving the best performing losers a chance to return

TOURNAMENT MASTERPOST

Propaganda

Barbara Wright

  • one of THE OGS!!!!!! and theeeee reason the doctor is who we know them as now - she told him off for being an asshole in story THREE!!! can we get a wahoo!!!!!!

Bill Potts

  • She's kind, she's curious, she's intelligent, she's funny, she's gay. What more could you ask for in a companion?

Oliver Harper

  • Brilliant extended universe companion of the First Doctor. His story is both something that is both true to how the 60s were and yet could never have been explored by the TV series at that time. A perfect combination and a wonderful addition to the First Doctor and Steven's history. Very well played and I wish he could come back for more. (@hartnellwho / @elden-12 )

Steven Taylor

  • He suffers so much I want him thrown out the window!!! He’s see all his friends die in front of him and is constantly getting tortured and being hurt. He should be shot in the face and survive I love him so much!!!
  • What if there was a man who could never win. What if there was a man who had so much love in his heart but nobody to give it to because they all kept dying. What if there was a man who was such a bitch. What if he was mentally ill. And bisexual. And missing 28 episodes. And did I mention that everyone around him is constantly dying. This is Steven Taylor. I haven't made it past the first doctor's era because I got too attached to him and sobbed and wailed when he left. He's a single mother (to dodo) he's a big brother (to vicki) he's a wifeguy (to sara) he hates his fucking grandpa (the doctor). I'm shaking (@abominandus )

River Song

  • Don't be fooled by her skills & accomplishments, this is the disaster to bi all & end all (not a typo). Brags about sneaking around her husband to his face bc she doesn't recognise him. Gets a gun pointed at her by mum bc she dramatically withheld an identity reveal for the drama, dramatically. Wouldn't know 'subtlety' if it crashed a spaceship in front of her. Also Alex Kingston's smugsmirkface is a thing of glory 😍😍😍 (@buggreawlthys )

K9

  • Who doesn't love a talking dog with sass?

Fitz Kreiner

  • Silly smoking hot goober who takes the doctor up the arse
hartnellwho

Barbara, Steven and Oliver all in the same tiebreak poll and only one can go through? Are you trying to break my heart here? Oof! :p

I think I’m gonna have to go Barbara because she was there from the start and made the Doctor who he is. But not being able to vote for the others is killing me. *sob*

Barbara is currently in second place, so if you’re a One era fan and haven’t voted yet: she’s your best choice.

Barbara Wright Oliver Harper Steven Taylor polls Classic Who Big Finish Doctor Who
elden-12
companion-showdown

Who is your favourite companion?

Two images of companions from Doctor Who, on the left is Molly O’Sullivan and on the right is Oliver HarperALT

ROUND 3: Molly O'Sullivan vs Oliver Harper

Molly O'Sullivan

Oliver Harper

TOURNAMENT MASTERPOST

Propaganda

Oliver Harper

  • Brilliant extended universe companion of the First Doctor. His story is both something that is both true to how the 60s were and yet could never have been explored by the TV series at that time. A perfect combination and a wonderful addition to the First Doctor and Steven's history. Very well played and I wish he could come back for more. (@hartnellwho / @elden-12 )
hartnellwho

Oliver Harper is one of the very best EU companions, a brilliant example of a companion whose story fits perfectly as a blend of being so inherently tied to the 60s but could only have been made in the present. He's wonderful.

Certainly better than the irritating non-entity who spent 90% of her first boxset saying "taaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhdy box" and who had so little personality and characterization that the Doctor had to mention her Dark Eyes every. single. fucking. time. he spoke to her. because there was basically nothing more to her.

hartnellwho

Oliver is currently on 48.3% that's really close, especially as this poll has less voters than the Barbara one.

Even if you've not heard Oliver (his poll has around 200 voters less than the Barbara one) please, please vote for him anyway. He is brilliant and such a perfect addition to the First Doctor's era and fits in to it seamlessly. He deserves your vote. Please. 🥺

elden-12

It's 50/50 right now. This is so tense. Come on anyone who hasn't yet. Give Oliver and out right win not a tie!

Oliver Harper polls Doctor Who Big Finish Classic Who
elden-12
companion-showdown

Who is your favourite companion?

Two images of companions from Doctor Who, on the left is Barbara Wright and on the right is Romana IIALT

ROUND 3: Barbara Wright vs Romana II

Barbara Wright

Romana II

TOURNAMENT MASTERPOST

Propaganda

Barbara Wright

  • one of THE OGS!!!!!! and theeeee reason the doctor is who we know them as now - she told him off for being an asshole in story THREE!!! can we get a wahoo!!!!!!
hartnellwho

The teacher who taught the Doctor how to be a good person. Go vote for Barbara!

hartnellwho

Barbara is currently on 49% we can do this, go vote if you haven't yet.

elden-12

She's on 49.5% now. Come on Barbara fans! Let's get her over the line!

Barbara Wright polls Classic Who Doctor Who
hartnellwho
x-salem-x

IF YOU HAD TO PICK

TWO+JAMIE

IAN+BARBARA

image
image
hartnellwho

Look, I love Two and Jamie as much as the next gay. But Barbara and Ian are icons and perfect... and currently on just under 35%. Go fix this everyone!

hartnellwho

Barbarian have gone up to 37.5%… we’ve got nearly a week, hopefully we can make this closer or even win as they deserve.

Barbarian Barbara Wright Ian Chesterton OTP polls Doctor Who Classic Who
companion-showdown
companion-showdown

Who is your favourite companion?

Two images of companions from Doctor Who, on the left is Ace McShane and on the right is Ian ChestertonALT

ROUND 3: Ace McShane vs Ian Chesterton

Ace McShane

Ian Chesterton

See Results

TOURNAMENT MASTERPOST

hartnellwho

Oof, this is already looking like it’s gonna be a massacre. But Ian deserves your vote. He and Barbara literally taught the Doctor how to be a decent person and the character we now know and love.

Ace is brilliant but Ian and Barbara are the best.

Ian Chesterton Classic Who polls Doctor Who
companion-showdown
companion-showdown

Who is your favourite companion?

Two images of companions from Doctor Who, on the left is Vislor Turlough and on the right is Ian ChestertonALT

ROUND 2: Vislor Turlough vs Ian Chesterton

Vislor Turlough

Ian Chesterton

See Results

TOURNAMENT MASTERPOST

Propaganda

Vislor Turlough

  • The worst assassin in the entire universe who honestly has some of the funniest lines in the Fifth Doctor's era. Just a Strange Guy™️. (@gothicacetheatrekid )
  • he's a self-professed selfish coward of COURSE he's the kindest and bravest person you'll ever meet
    (remember that time he went back alone to face off the creatures that literally had him CATATONIC with ancestral trauma based fear half an hour earlier, giving away his only good luck charm as he went?! And people still think he's a selfish coward! Please! it's a mask!!!)
    stunning character development
    snark absolutely off the charts. you like Donna Noble? try Vislor Turlough! also the real first unambiguous redhead companion
    total freak. he once paused while SCUTTLING (only word for it) away from monsters for his life in order to rebutton his jacket, the jacket that is the school uniform from a school he utterly and openly HATED, which for some incomprehensible reason is the only thing he wears. There's nobody else in the universe like Vislor Turlough
  • There are so many angles I could take with this. He's a bitchy gay alien and the least deadly assassin. He is a meme. Also he's the first Fifth Doctor companion to get a sort of happy ending. In the constant tragedy of Five's era, he finds his brother and makes it home safe. He is a rare moment of hope in a very grim, cynical era of the show, while also being the last person you'd expect to be a moment of hope. (@cringecompanionapologist )
companion-showdown

#ian my beloved#poor man just wanted to check in on his student and got kidnapped by an asshole old man#he put up with one being a jackass#one never got his name right#he was sold into slavery in rome that one time#hes kind of gay for alexander the great (@illyriashade56)

hartnellwho

While Ian is currently in the lead this is far closer than it should be. Go vote for him.

polls Ian Chesterton Classic Who Doctor Who
companion-showdown
companion-showdown

Who is your favourite companion?

Two images of companions from Doctor Who, on the left is The Brigadier and on the right is KatarinaALT

ROUND 2: The Brigadier vs Katarina

The Brigadier

Katarina

See Results

TOURNAMENT MASTERPOST

Propaganda

The Brigadier

  • This man should get an award for the amount of Doctor-related nonsense he put up with in his life. He met the second Doctor while fighting yetis in the London underground, was the third Doctor's boss, and went on to put up with many of his other incarnations (mostly against his will). Despite how much the Doctor annoys him, he's one of the Doctor's oldest friends and is always there to help them if they need it. He also built UNIT from the ground up.

Katarina

  • She is Katarina and she is dead. She is the first to die and from the moment she entered the TARDIS she knew she was dead. Doom from the start. She saw the Doctor as a god taking her to the afterlife. And he took her there. She died 5000 years for when she was born alone in the Vacuum of space. Her death was written the moment she met Vicky, Stevan and the Doctor. And she knew it. She was the First of many Companions to die. Her name is Katarina and she is dead. (@familyparadox )
hartnellwho

Katarina! I know she has no chance against the Brig, but… she’s such a poor tragic character. Stuck in a world she doesn’t understand, believing she’s already dead and giving her life to save the universe. How can you not like her?

Katarina Classic Who polls Doctor Who
companion-showdown
companion-showdown

Who is your favourite companion?

Two images of companions from Doctor Who, on the left is Dodo Chaplet and on the right is Romana IALT

ROUND 2: Dodo Chaplet vs Romana I

Dodo Chaplet

Romana I

See Results

TOURNAMENT MASTERPOST

Propaganda

Dodo Chaplet

  • "Dodo's annoying" "Dodo sucks" SHUT UP EVERYBODY SHUT UP RIGHT NOW. Those who believe Dodo to be one of the worst companions ever will not see the light of heaven. There are literally worse companions. Dodo is just some guy. She waltzes into the TARDIS and is like "Oh, it's a Time Machine? Okay! yaaaay!" Right after Steven has had the worst year of his life. Dodo provides much needed joy and whimsy after an ESPECIALLY dark era of the 60s. She's silly and fun and gets along great with both the Doctor and Steven, but also holds her own! Threatening Doc Holliday at gunpoint into taking her back to Tombstone? GO GIRL GIVE US EVERYTHING. YES she gave a future society the plague, it was an accident. YES she was all over the place during the Toymaker, you would be too if you had all those rules to follow and undiagnosed ADHD! She's a sweetheart she's the world she deserved such a better ending than she got. Who Killed Kennedy is not canon in my heart and her audios rule. Please listen to The Secrets of Det-Sen. She commands a Yeti army. Dodo Chaplet get behind me (@abominandus )

Romana I

  • I LOVEEEEE ROMANAAAAA!!!! Shes so green and haughty when she comes to the TARDIS but grows and learns while never letting the Doctor get away with anything!! Her eyebrows could write NOVELS. Her all white aesthetic makes her one of the most striking companions of all time in m y opinion. Also I couldnt find the clip by itself but in her first episode, The Ribos Operation, my absolute fave Romana moment: https://youtu.be/O6J6xYB030s?si=4cbrzBsLJvvEGl3N at about 15:10 of the video, her and the Doctor discuss her name and she wants to be called Fred 🤣🤣🤣 THE OG GENDER NONCONFORMING TIME LORD
hartnellwho

Go vote Dodo. We’ve probably got no chance with the current margins. But she’s brilliant and deserves a chance to go through.

Dodo Chaplet polls Classic Who Doctor Who
companion-showdown
companion-showdown

Who is your favourite companion?

Two images of companions from Doctor Who, on the left is Oliver Harper and on the right is Cass FermazziALT

ROUND 2: Oliver Harper vs Cass Fermazzi

Oliver Harper

Cass Fermazzi

See Results

TOURNAMENT MASTERPOST

Propaganda

Oliver Harper

  • Brilliant extended universe companion of the First Doctor. His story is both something that is both true to how the 60s were and yet could never have been explored by the TV series at that time. A perfect combination and a wonderful addition to the First Doctor and Steven's history. Very well played and I wish he could come back for more. (@hartnellwho / @elden-12 )
hartnellwho

Cass not only refused to travel with the Doctor (so not a companion) but even purposely got him killed in the process.

Vote for Oliver Harper. A brilliant actual companion with an amazing story and fitting perfectly in to the First Doctor’s era.

Oliver Harper polls Classic Who Big Finish Doctor Who