| Offense |
| Position |
First team |
Second team |
| Quarterback |
Len Dawson, Chiefs (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) |
Jack Kemp, Bills (AFL, AP, NYDN)
George Blanda, Oilers (AFL)
Joe Namath, Jets (NEA)
John Hadl, Chargers (UPI) |
| Halfback |
Clem Daniels, Raiders (AFL, AP, NEA, UPI)
Bobby Burnett, Bills (NYDN) |
Bobby Burnett, Bills (AFL, AP, NEA, UPI)
Mike Garrett, Chiefs (NYDN) |
| Fullback |
Jim Nance, Patriots (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) |
Wray Carlton, Bills (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) |
| Wide receiver |
Lance Alworth, Chargers (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Otis Taylor, Chiefs (AP, NEA, UPI)
Art Powell, Raiders (AFL, NYDN)
Bob Scarpitto, Broncos (AFL) |
George Sauer Jr., Jets (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN)
Art Powell, Raiders (AP, NEA, UPI)
Otis Taylor, Chiefs (AFL, NYDN) |
| Tight end |
Fred Arbanas, Chiefs (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) |
Al Denson, Broncos (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) |
| Tackle |
Jim Tyrer, Chiefs (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Ron Mix, Chargers (AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Sherman Plunkett, Jets (AFL) |
Stew Barber, Bills (AFL, AP, NYDN)
Dick Hudson, Bills (AP, NEA, UPI)
Walter Suggs, Oilers (NEA, UPI)
Ron Mix, Chargers (AFL)
Sherman Plunkett, Jets (NYDN) |
| Guard |
Billy Shaw, Bills (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Wayne Hawkins, Raiders (NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Bob Talamini, Oilers (AFL)
Ed Budde, Chiefs (AP) |
Ed Budde, Chiefs (AFL, NEA, NYDN)
Bob Talamini, Oilers (NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Wayne Hawkins, Raiders (AFL, AP)
Sam DeLuca, Jets (AP, UPI) |
| Center |
Jim Otto, Raiders (AFL, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Jon Morris, Patriots (AP) |
Jon Morris, Patriots (AFL, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Jim Otto, Raiders (AP) |
|
| Defense |
| Position |
First team |
Second team |
| Defensive end |
Jerry Mays, Chiefs (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Ron McDole, Bills (AP, NYDN)
Verlon Biggs, Jets (NEA, UPI)
Larry Eisenhauer, Patriots (AFL) |
Verlon Biggs, Jets (AFL, AP, NYDN)
Larry Eisenhauer, Patriots (NEA, UPI)
Ron McDole, Bills (NEA, UPI)
Tom Day, Bills (AFL)
Ike Lassiter, Raiders (AP)
Ben Davidson, Raiders (NYDN) |
| Defensive tackle |
Houston Antwine, Patriots (AFL, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Buck Buchanan, Chiefs (AFL, AP, UPI)
Tom Sestak, Bills (NEA, NYDN)
Jim Dunaway, Bills (AP)
Tom Keating, Raiders (NEA) |
Tom Keating, Raiders (AFL, AP, UPI)
Buck Buchanan, Chiefs (NEA, NYDN)
Jim Dunaway, Bills (NYDN, UPI)
Tom Sestak, Bills (AFL)
Houston Antwine, Patriots (AP)
Jim Lee Hunt, Patriots (NEA) |
| Middle linebacker |
Nick Buoniconti, Boston (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) |
Sherrill Headrick, Chiefs (AP, NEA, NYDN)
Harry Jacobs, Bills (AFL, UPI) |
| Outside linebacker |
Bobby Bell, Chiefs (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Mike Stratton, Bills (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) |
E. J. Holub, Chiefs (AFL, AP, NYDN, UPI)
John Bramlett, Broncos (AP, NEA, UPI)
Frank Buncom, Chargers (AFL)
Johnny Baker, Oilers (NEA)
Larry Grantham, Jets (NYDN) |
| Cornerback |
Butch Byrd, Bills (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Dave Grayson, Raiders (AFL, NEA, NYDN)
Kent McCloughan, Raiders (AP, UPI) |
Speedy Duncan, Chargers (AFL, AP, NYDN, UPI)
Kent McCloughan, Raiders (AFL, NEA)
Dave Grayson, Raiders (AP, UPI)
Willie Brown, Broncos (NEA)
Johnny Sample, Jets (NYDN) |
| Safety |
Johnny Robinson, Chiefs (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Kenny Graham, Chargers (AP, NEA, UPI)
George Saimes, Bills (AFL, NYDN) |
Bobby Hunt, Chiefs (AFL, AP, NEA)
Kenny Graham, Chargers (AFL, NYDN)
Hagood Clarke, Bills (AP, NYDN)
George Saimes, Bills (NEA, UPI)
Willie West, Dolphins (UPI) |
|
