Sardinian nationalism

From Infogalactic: the planetary knowledge core
Jump to: navigation, search
Traditional flag of Sardinia
File:Europe location Sardinia.png
Location of Sardinia

Sardinian nationalism is a social, cultural and political movement in Sardinia promoting the protection of the island's environment and the re-discovery of Sardinian culture. It also calls for more autonomy, or even independence, from Italy.

Even though the island has been characterized by periodical waves of ethnonationalist protests against Rome,[1] the contemporary Sardinian movement has its origins on the left of the political spectrum;[2][3] attempts for Sardinian self-determination countered in fact Rome-centric Italian nationalism and fascism (which would eventually manage to contain the autonomist and separatist tendencies[4]). Over the years many Sardist parties from different ideological backgrounds have emerged, all being in the minority, and with some of them making government coalitions with the statewide Italian parties. For instance, that also happened in the 2014 Sardinian regional election,[5] where the combined result of all the nationalist parties would have been 26% of the votes.[6]

Overview

In 1720, the Kingdom of Sardinia was definitely ceded by Spain to the House of Savoy after a plurisecular period of Spanish rule and a short-lived reconquest, abiding by the treaty of London that followed the War of Spanish Succesion. The Savoyard kings, who were forced to accept this island in place of the much more populated and developed Sicily, were not pleased with the exchange to the point of making them want to dispose of what Cavour called "the third Ireland" later, according to Mazzini who denounced the plot, by selling it to France.[7][8][9] For a long time, Sardinia would be ruled in the same way as it was during the Spanish period, with its own parliament and government being composed exclusively of men from the mainland. The only exception to this has been an outbreak of political unrest against the local Piedmontese notables in 1794, led by Giovanni Maria Angioy, that ended only in the first years of the 19th century. In 1847, some fractions of the Sardinian elites from Cagliari and Sassari, guided by the unionist Giovanni Siotto Pintor, demanded the so called Perfect Fusion, aimed at getting the liberal reforms Sardinia could not have because of its separate legal system. The king Charles Albert agreed to the request; however, he also removed what little self-governing capacity the island had in the process, and Sardinia would continue to be left to its own devices, further aggravating its peripheral condition.[10] The episode would lead Pintor himself to regret having made that proposal (Errammo tutti, "we all made a mistake"),[11][12] and would raise the "Sardinian Question" (Questione Sarda)[13][14][15] from then on, a broad term used to cover a wide variety of issues regarding the difficult relationship between Sardinia and the mainland.[16][17] The Savoyard kings then proceeded to expand their domains through the Unification of Italy: Sardinia, being already part of the Piedmontese Kingdom from the very beginning, automatically joined the new polity, that changed its name to become the Kingdom of Italy in 1861.

The first two Sardist parties, the Sardinian Action Party or PSd'Az (one of the oldest stateless nationalist parties in Europe,[18] being founded in 1921) and the Sardinian League (LS), were launched between the two world wars. The PSd'Az, which was pretty strong in the 1920s (e.g. 36% of the popular vote in 1921 regional election[19]) as well as in the 1940s, establishing itself as the most important nationalist movement in Sardinia, experienced a comeback in the 1980s. In the 1984 regional election the party peaked at 30% in Cagliari and over 20% in Sassari and Oristano, gaining overall 13.8% of the vote: therefore, due to its pivotal role in the newly elected Regional Council, Sardist Mario Melis was President of Sardinia from 1984 to 1989.[20] Ever since, that result has not been repeated yet by any independentist party.

The Sardinian nationalist movement is in fact rather disjointed and lacking in unity nowadays:[21] it is composed mostly of several local and scattered grassroots organisations across the island that do not have a clear central policy-making authority, and besides, the different nationalist subgroups often disagree with each other on many key issues.[22] Sardinian nationalists address a number of issues, such as the environmental damage caused by the Italian, NATO and U.S. military forces[23][24][25][26][27][28][29] (in fact, 60% of such bases in Italy are located on the island),[30] the financial and economic exploitation of the island's resources by the Italian state and mainland industrialists,[31] the lack of any political representation both in Italy and in the European Parliament[32][33] (due to an unbalanced electoral constituency that still remains to this day,[34] Sardinia has not had its own MEP since 1994)[35] and the ongoing process of depopulation and Italianization that would destroy the Sardinian indigenous culture.[36]

Sardinian nationalism is a pacific movement that does not advocate violent revolution, proposing instead to achieve its goals within a liberal democratic framework. However, as an exception to the rule, there had been some issues in the past strictly related to separatist tendencies, the most worth mentioning being essentially three. First, the actions planned in 1968[37] by Giangiacomo Feltrinelli to turn the island into the Cuba of the Mediterranean and "liberate it from colonialism" by making contact with several local nationalist groups;[38] in the end, the attempt of the famous communist thinker to strengthen the pro-independence militant lines, divided into the socialist Fronte Nazionale de Liberazione de sa Sardigna (FNLS) and the rightist Movimentu Nazionalista Sardu (MNS),[39] was nullified by the Italian secret military intelligence.[40] Secondly, there had been in the 1980s the question of the so-called "separatist conspiracy", a secret plan apparently set up by some local activists to reach the island's independence in collaboration with Gaddafi's Libya;[41][42][43][44] according to some reconstructions of the facts, the supposed Sardinian separatist conspiracy might have been a machination of the Italian secret services seeking to discredit the rising nationalist wave in the island.[45] There were also separatist militant groups,[46] like the Movimento Armato Sardo (Sardinian Armed Movement[47]), claiming assassinations and several kidnappings.[48][49][50][51] Finally, it should be mentioned the case of a number of bombings,[46][52][53] the most notable of which being that in 2004 against Silvio Berlusconi in his visit to Porto Rotondo (Olbia) with Tony Blair;[54] the responsibility has been apparently claimed by some unknown anarcho-separatist militant groups,[50][55][56] the presence of which never to be seen again.[57]

In 2012, a vote in the Sardinian Assembly to pass an independence referendum bill failed by one vote.[58]

In 2014, another independentist group launched a campaign, called Cantonmarittimo ("Maritime Canton"), in order for Sardinia to reach its independence by joining Switzerland as a Canton.[59][60][61][62][63]

Political support

In the '70s, around 38% of the Sardinian population expressed a favourable view on independence.[64] According to a 2012 survey conducted in a joint effort between the University of Cagliari and that of Edinburgh,[65][66][67] 41% of Sardinians would be in favour of independence, whilst another 46% would rather have a larger autonomy within Italy; 13% of people would be content to remain part of Italy without any autonomy.[68][69][70][71][72][73] Besides, the same survey reported that a growing number of younger Sardinians (26% of the population) self-identify as non-Italian, while 37% of Sardinians would identify as Sardinian first and Italian second; 31% would class themselves as both Sardinian and Italian, while 5% said they consider themselves more Italian than Sardinian and 1% Italian only.[74][75] These numerical data have been exposed by Carlo Pala, a political scientist at the University of Sassari.[76] Even other polls, published by professional organizations for public opinion research, contribute to corroborating, more or less, these findings and their accuracy.[77]

However, this support has heretofore failed to translate into electoral success for pro-sovereignty Sardinian forces and a more vigorous political action.[1] In fact, the nationalist movement has a well-documented history of ideological factionalism:[21][78] all attempts to unify the nationalist subgroups have so far failed; thus, the Sardist movement still suffers from being highly fragmented into a large number of political subgroups pushing different policies. All the Sardist parties put together usually win around 15-20% of the vote in regional elections, with not a single one managing to emerge as a serious competitor to the statewide parties.

It should also be noted that, unlike other European regions with nationalist tendencies, even the local branches of statewide parties have incorporated some of these elements in their political discourses, thus assuming somewhat of a regionalist façade and undermining the distinctive Sardist demands:[19][79] it is to be mentioned, for example, Francesco Cossiga's failed constitutional bill n. 352 to recognize Sardinia as a distinct nation within Italy.[80] The nationalist parties have disjointedly responded to this long-term accommodation strategy: they either refused to join their fragmented Sardist forces or tried to work with the pro-Italian parties as coalition partners, in the hopes of applying further pressure from within to favour increased devolution; either choice has been met with diffidence by the Sardinian electorate, leading the various Sardist parties to play a marginal role in Sardinian politics.

In the 2014 regional election, for instance, more than a dozen Sardist parties of different connotations took part to the electoral competition, but yet again, because of their number and political fragmentation,[6][81][82][83] they did not manage to win as many seats as they were initially supposed to, some[84] think even because of a tactical mistake by the ProgReS-sponsored list, which was then led by the novelist Michela Murgia.[85][86][87] Despite the combined result of all of the nationalist parties being around 26%[88] (dropping to 18% for the pro-independence forces[89]), they won only eight seats in the Sardinian regional council.[6][90][91][92][93]

Here is a summary of the results of the 2014 regional election for regional parties:

The list does not include the Christian Popular Union (1.7% of the vote and 1 regional councillor elected) because the party, despite being based in Sardinia and having rarely participated in general or regional elections outside Sardinia, claims to be an Italian national party.

See also

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 Pala, C. 2015. Sardinia. The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of Race, Ethnicity, and Nationalism. 1–3. Abstract
  2. ↑ Hechter (M.), The Dynamics of Secession, Acta Sociologica, vol. 35, 1992, p. 267.
  3. ↑ Entrevista a Marcel Farinelli: “Córcega y Cerdeña forman un archipiélago invisible al tener sus islas nacionalismos de signo opuesto"
  4. ↑ La Sardegna durante il ventennio fascista, Università di Tor Vergata
  5. ↑ Sardegna, proclamati presidente e Consiglio regionale a un mese dalle urne - La Repubblica
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 Galassia sardista al 26 per cento - La Nuova Sardegna
  7. ↑ Proceedings of History Week 2005, pp. 47-60. Malta : The Malta Historical Society, 2005
  8. ↑ La terza Irlanda. Gli scritti sulla Sardegna di Carlo Cattaneo e Giuseppe Mazzini, Condaghes, Cagliari 1995, pp. 166-169.
  9. ↑ Onnis, Omar. La Sardegna e i sardi nel tempo, Arkadia, pp.174
  10. ↑ Onnis, Omar. La Sardegna e i sardi nel tempo, Arkadia, pp.172
  11. ↑ Una data infausta per la Sardegna, Francesco Casula - Il Manifesto Sardo
  12. ↑ Un arxipèlag invisible: la relació impossible de Sardenya i Còrsega sota nacionalismes, segles XVIII-XX - Marcel Farinelli, Universitat Pompeu Fabra. Institut Universitari d'Història Jaume Vicens i Vives, pp.299-300
  13. ↑ Francesco Cesare Casula, Breve Storia di Sardegna, p. 245; op. cit.
  14. ↑ La “fusione perfetta” del 1847 aprì una nuova era per l’isola, La Nuova Sardegna
  15. ↑ M. Brigaglia, La Sardegna nel ventennio fascista, p. 317
  16. ↑ Glossario di autonomia Sardo-Italiana, Francesco Cesare Casùla, Presentazione del 2007 di Francesco Cossiga
  17. ↑ Sardegna, isola del silenzio, Manlio Brigaglia
  18. ↑ Elias (A.) et Tronconi (F.), From protest to power. Autonomist parties and the challenges of representation, Vienna, Braumüller, 2011
  19. ↑ 19.0 19.1 Hepburn, Eve. The Ideological Polarisation and Depolarisation of Sardinian Nationalism, Regional and Federal Studies Vol. 19, No.5. (2010)
  20. ↑ Regional Council of Sardinia
  21. ↑ 21.0 21.1 Michela Murgia, la scrittrice si candida a guidare la Sardegna. L'eterno ritorno dell'indipendentismo sardo - L'Huffington Post
  22. ↑ Scottish vote reignites Sardinia separatist parties' for independence - The Wall Street Journal
  23. ↑ Sardegna, la protesta contro le servitù - Rai.tv
  24. ↑ Così in Sardegna si è riacceso l’indipendentismo, Nicola Mirenzi - Europa Quotidiano
  25. ↑ In chiave antimilitarista, nel quadro del tradizionale attivismo contestativo contro la presenza di strutture militari sul territorio nazionale, a fronte del tono minore che ha caratterizzato l’impegno dei comitati siciliani contro il sistema satellitare MUOS, si è rilevato un innalzamento della tensione mobilitativa in Sardegna, ove espressioni dell’antagonismo e dell’indipendentismo sardo hanno rivitalizzato la protesta contro le esercitazioni nei poligoni e nelle installazioni militari dell’Isola, reclamando la smilitarizzazione del territorio. - Relazione sulla politica dell'informazione per la sicurezza, pg.69
  26. ↑ Sardegna, il 13 settembre indipendentisti a Capo Frasca contro l’occupazione militare
  27. ↑ Oltre 5mila per dire no ai poligoni, festa identitaria davanti ai cancelli - La Nuova Sardegna, 14/09/2014
  28. ↑ Indipendentismo sardo, questo sconosciuto - Adalgisa Marrocco
  29. ↑ Italy: Sardinia Island protesters target NATO Trident Juncture exercise
  30. ↑ Mattu, Katjuscia. Internal colonialism in Western Europe: the case of Sardinia
  31. ↑ I fondamenti storici dell'indipendenza sarda - Lacanas
  32. ↑ Parties, associations ask for direct representation of Sardinia in European Parliament, Nationalia
  33. ↑ Europee, in Sardegna campagna “Eu non voto”. C’è anche Zappadu - Il Fatto Quotidiano
  34. ↑ Il Senato affonda il collegio Sardegna, per l’Isola nessun europarlamentare, Sardiniapost.it
  35. ↑ Eve Hepburn, New Challenges for Stateless Nationalist and Regionalist Parties, Routledge, 2010, pp.121
  36. ↑ Sardegna: Paradiso turistico o la lenta morte di un popolo? - di Marco Oggianu - (German translation of the same article)
  37. ↑ Minahan, James. Encyclopedia of the Stateless Nations S-Z, pg. 1664
  38. ↑ Cabitza, Giuliano. Sardegna: rivolta contro la colonizzazione. Milano, Feltrinelli Editore.
  39. ↑ Cultura e identitade - Sardinna, January - April 2002
  40. ↑ Morto Pugliese, l' ex ufficiale del Sid che «fermò» nel '60 il latitante Mesina - Corriere della Sera
  41. ↑ Italian Court convicts 16 as Sardinian separatists - The New York Times
  42. ↑ Agguati, guerriglia, sequestri: ecco il complotto separatista sardo - La Repubblica
  43. ↑ Separatismo sardo, condannati i capi - La Repubblica
  44. ↑ Vittorfranco Pisano, The Dynamics of Subversion and Violence in Contemporary Italy, Hoover Institution Press (1987), p.143
  45. ↑ Melis e il complotto separatista: "macchinazione degli 007 italiani"
  46. ↑ 46.0 46.1 Paola Sirigu, Il codice barbaricino, La Riflessione (Davide Zedda Editore), 2007, pp.225-234
  47. ↑ Terrorism in Italy: an update report 1983-1985, U.S. Department of Justice, pp.11-12
  48. ↑ Lua error in package.lua at line 80: module 'strict' not found.
  49. ↑ Shao Chuan Leng, Coping with Crises: How Governments Deal with Emergencies, University Press of America
  50. ↑ 50.0 50.1 Memorial Institute for the Prevention of Terrorism. "Sardinian Autonomy Movement" (MAS)
  51. ↑ Giovanni Ricci, Sardegna Criminale, Newton Compton, 2008
  52. ↑ OIr:<<la bomba era nostra>> - RaiNews24
  53. ↑ Assessment for Sardinians in Italy - Minorities at Risk
  54. ↑ Sardegna, blitz antiterrorismo: in manette dieci indipendentisti - La Repubblica
  55. ↑ Criminologia del terrorismo anarco-insurrezionalista, Marco Boschi, pag.63
  56. ↑ Bomb found near Berlusconi villa after Blair visit
  57. ↑ Un magistrato in prima linea sul fronte eversione - Unione Sarda
  58. ↑ Bocciata la mozione Psd’Az su indipendenza Sardegna - AlgheroEco
  59. ↑ In Sardinia, Secessionists Want to Leave Italy and Join... Switzerland? - The Wall Street Journal
  60. ↑ Italy's separatist spirit takes new shape as Sardinians push to become Swiss - The Guardian
  61. ↑ Separatisten auf Vormarsch in Europa - Arte
  62. ↑ New proposal for a Swiss-Sardinian maritime Canton
  63. ↑ Il deputato svizzero Troillet: sì all’intesa con la Sardegna - La Nuova Sardegna
  64. ↑ Pintore (G.), Sardegna, regione o colonia?, Milano, Mazzotta, 1974
  65. ↑ What next for independence movements in Europe? - Eve Hepburn
  66. ↑ Identità e autonomia in Sardegna - FocuSardegna
  67. ↑ La Sardegna che vorrebbe l’indipendenza come i catalani - La Stampa
  68. ↑ Focus: La questione identitaria e indipendentista in Sardegna - University of Cagliari, Ilenia Ruggiu
  69. ↑ Riforme - (SAR) REGIONE. PIGLIARU: INDIPENDENTISTA IL 40% DEI SARDI (Conferenza delle Regioni e delle Province autonome
  70. ↑ La Sardegna vuole l'indipendenza, favorevoli quattro sardi su dieci - Controcampus.it
  71. ↑ Il 40% dei sardi è per l'indipendenza; il resto è per la la sovranità - Gianfranco Pintore
  72. ↑ I giovani non si sentono più italiani - Regione Autonoma della Sardegna, 31.05.2012
  73. ↑ Push in Sardinia for online vote on independence from Italy - Russia Today
  74. ↑ Lua error in package.lua at line 80: module 'strict' not found.
  75. ↑ L'esempio della Catalogna, i sardi sono più «identitari» - L'Unione Sarda
  76. ↑ Indipendentismo, secessionismo, federalismo: conversazione con Carlo Pala
  77. ↑ L'indipendenza delle regioni - Demos & Pi
  78. ↑ «Siamo sardi, non italiani. Adesso vogliamo la nostra indipendenza» - L'Inkiesta
  79. ↑ Lluch, Jaime. Constitutionalism and the Politics of Accommodation in Multinational Democracies
  80. ↑ DDL Costituzionale n. 352
  81. ↑ La Babele del sardismo - Sardiniapost
  82. ↑ Idea secessione, gli indipendentisti sardi: «Sì al referendum, ma non ora» - La Nuova Sardegna
  83. ↑ Italian centre-left wins Sardinian election, Murgia's pro-sovereignty coalition left outside Council - Nationalia.com
  84. ↑ Sardegna Possibile non esiste! Le amministrative svelano il bluff (e Michela Murgia tiene tutti in ostaggio) - Vito Biolchini
  85. ↑ A Fight to Steer Sardinia - New York Times
  86. ↑ 2014: la Primavera Sarda? - Vilaweb
  87. ↑ Lua error in package.lua at line 80: module 'strict' not found.
  88. ↑ It should be noted that parties like "Sardinian Reformers" and "The Base Sardinia" are federalist rather than outright separatist.
  89. ↑ A coligación independentista, terceira forza nas eleccións de Sardeña - Sermos Galiza
  90. ↑ El independentismo, fuerza al alza en Sardinia - Sortu
  91. ↑ Vuit diputats sobiranistes entren per sorpresa al parlament sard - VilaWeb
  92. ↑ L'independentisme sard fa un bon paper però guanya el centreesquerra - El Punt Avui
  93. ↑ Tèrratrem en Sardenha - Jornalet, Gaseta Occitana d'informacions

Bibliography

  • Simon-Mossa (A.), Le ragioni dell’indipendentismo, Quartu Sant’Elena, Alfa, 2008 (original edition: 1969).
  • Sergio Salvi - (1973) Le nazioni proibite, Vallecchi, Firenze
  • Farnè (R.) - (1975) La Sardegna che non vuole essere una colonia, Milano, Jaca Book.
  • Antonio Lepori, Antonello Satta e Giovanni Lilliu Sardigna on MINORANZE num. 4, Milan, trimestre 1976.
  • Antonello Satta - (1977) L'autonomia della Sardigna come mistificazione.
  • Imma Tubella i Casadevall e Eduard Vinyamata Camp - (1978) Les nacions de l'Europa capitalista - La Magrana, Barcelona.
  • Melis (G.) - (1979) Dal sardismo al neosardismo: crisi autonomistica e mitologia locale, Il Mulino, XXXVIII, n° 263.
  • Gerdes (D.) - (1980) Aufstand der Provinz. Regionalismus in Westeuropa, Frankfurt s.M. and New York, Campus.
  • Rokkan (S.) and Urwin (D.W.) - (1982) The Politics of territorial identity : studies in European regionalism, London, Sage.
  • Rokkan (S.) and Urwin (D.W.) - (1983) Economy, territory, identity : politics of West European peripheries, London, Sage.
  • Rolando del Guerra e Genoveva Gómez - (1986) Llengua, dialecte, nació, ètnia (Llengua i poder a Itàlia) - La Magrana, Col. Alliberament, 19 Barcelona.
  • Valle (N.) - (1988), L’idea autonomistica in Sardegna, Cagliari, Il Convegno.
  • Gianfranco Contu - (1990) La questione nazionale sarda - Quartu Sant'Elena, Alfa Editrice
  • Hechter (M.) - (1992) The Dynamics of Secession, Acta Sociologica, vol. 35
  • Petrosino (D.) - (1992), National and regional movements in Italy : the case of Sardinia, in Coakley (J.), The social origins of nationalist movements, London, Sage
  • Contu (A.) - (1996), Il pensiero federalista in Sardegna, Cagliari, Condaghes
  • Xosé M. Núñez Seixas - (1998) Movimientos nacionalistas en Europa en el siglo XX - Ed. Síntesis, Col. Historia Universal Contemporánea, 26 Madrid.
  • Eve Hepburn - (2007). The New Politics of Autonomy: Territorial Strategies and the Uses of European Integration by Political Parties in Scotland, Bavaria and Sardinia 1979-2005. European University Institute, Department of Political and Social Sciences.
  • Eve Hepburne - (2008) Island Nations in a ‘Europe of the Peoples’: Corsica and Sardinia compared
  • Pala (C.) - (2008) La sopravvivenza prima di tutto : voti ed eletti di due partiti etnoregionalisti in Sardegna e Bretagna, Quaderni dell’Osservatorio Elettorale, vol. 60, n° 2.
  • Bachisio Bandinu - (2010) Pro s'Indipendentzia - Edizioni il Maestrale
  • Pala (C.) - (2010), Quando il cleavage etnoterritoriale si addormenta : la “connessione disorganica” degli attori regionalisti in Sardegna e Bretagna, Partecipazione e Conflitto, vol. 2, n° 2
  • Elias (A.) et Tronconi (F.), - (2011) From protest to power. Autonomist parties and the challenges of representation, Vienna, Braumüller
  • Ilenia Ruggiu, Francesco Mola, Gianmario Demuro - (2013) Identità e Autonomia in Sardegna e Scozia - Maggioli Editore
  • Roux (C.) - (2013) La nationalisation des périphéries. Fragments du processus de construction nationale en Corse et Sardaigne, Paris, L’Harmattan
  • Adriano Bomboi - (2014) L'indipendentismo sardo. Le ragioni, la storia, i protagonisti - Cagliari, Edizioni Condaghes
  • Franciscu Sedda - (2015) Manuale d'indipendenza nazionale - Cagliari, Edizioni Della Torre
  • Carlo Pala (2015). Sardinia. The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of Race, Ethnicity, and Nationalism. 1–3.
Retrieved from "https://infogalactic.com/w/index.php?title=Sardinian_nationalism&oldid=723145108"