The Chosen One Trope Doesn't Have to be Boring
We recently discussed favourite and least favourite tropes on the WWF discord, and The Chosen One trope came up right away for least favourite. We talked about how it tends to take away a character's agency and personality... But it doesn't have to. Here's how to use the Chosen One trope without falling into those common pitfalls:
1. Don’t rely on it for characterization
What other characters think and feel about your protagonist is only a small percentage of who they are. Chosen Ones tend to lean heavily on this factor, but then don’t have additional characterization that would earn them the respect and love of those around them.
Being chosen for a destiny should be something that comes after they’ve already lived a life and created a unique personality, and while it may change them in a certain way (maybe it goes to their head, or they get crushed under the weight of the responsibility), that change is still an indication of who they were in their “before” life.
2. Don’t take away their agency
Even if they are forced to go on this quest, that doesn’t mean that they have no agency. Conflicts that arise while the protagonist is on their quest should rely on them as individuals and their strengths outside of being a chosen one. They should also prey on their weaknesses. This forces the protagonist to make decisions based on who they are, and will thus still hold consequences for them and those that they love.
To achieve these first two points, it will be helpful if you...
3. Give them an actual Motivation
There tends to be two kinds of chosen ones. The reluctant ones, who try to run away or avoid their destiny (Katniss Everdeen at no point ever wants to be the Mockingjay) And the heroes who take their chosen one status in stride (like Moana).
But it’s important to consider why your character would fall into either category. If they are reluctant to fulfill their destiny, what about it scares them? Or threatens them? Or maybe they feel inadequate or insecure about their new status? There should be an internal and external reason why they don’t want to do this.
If they are super jazzed to go, why? Yes, there’s the draw of being special—but try to come up with a deeper and more personal reason why someone would be happy about having a quest forcibly placed onto them. For Moana, it gave her a chance to fulfill her dream of travelling the ocean (internal), and she felt responsible for saving her island (external).
4. Subvert it
The chosen one is a pretty common trope, so consider ways you can subvert it to make it unique to your writing. Some subversions I’ve seen in the past is the “chosen one was a lie” (such as in the first Lego Movie), the destiny they’re chosen for is evil, they die and someone else finishes their quest, the Chosen One is actually not the Chosen One, there are multiple chosen ones (could Frodo have ever completed his quest without Sam?) Are there any other subversions you can think of?
What’s your favourite and least favourite trope?