It Was One of Us - Cast

Name	Known for
Sarah Joy Brown Emily Winstead Emily Winstead See fewer	Big Momma's House 2 (2006)
Elisa Donovan Carson O'Conner Carson O'Conner See fewer	Clueless (1995)
Kira Clavell Wendy Hartman Wendy Hartman See fewer	The Recruit (2022)
Jim Thorburn Howard Winstead Howard Winstead See fewer	Robin Roberts Presents: Mahalia (2021)
Jordan Ladd Avis Monroe Avis Monroe See fewer	Death Proof (2007)
Marissa Jaret Winokur Dr. Theodora 'Teddy' Hohn Dr. Theodora 'Teddy' Hohn See fewer	Bupkis (2023)
Susan Hogan Mrs. Monroe Mrs. Monroe See fewer	Disturbing Behavior (1998)
Shawn Roberts George Watnick George Watnick See fewer	X-Men (2000)
Benjamin Ayres Javier Sarmiento (as Ben Ayres) Javier Sarmiento (as Ben Ayres) See fewer	Saving Hope (2012)
Stephen Huszar Caleb Caleb See fewer	Faces in the Crowd (2011)
Kurt Evans John Hohn John Hohn See fewer	iZombie (2015)
Roger Haskett Ron Ron See fewer	I, Robot (2004)
Jillian Fargey Rachel Rachel See fewer	Protection (2000)
Colin Lawrence Tom Tom See fewer	Virgin River (2019)
Stephen Powell Jim Carvell Jim Carvell See fewer	Faces in the Crowd (2011)
Lowela Jotie Rita Rita See fewer	Saving Silverman (2001)
Darien Provost Robert Winstead Robert Winstead See fewer	I Love You, Beth Cooper (2009)
Emma Karwandy Louisa Winstead Louisa Winstead See fewer	Shattered (2007)
Kirsten Alter Hannah (as Kirsten Williamson) Hannah (as Kirsten Williamson) See fewer	Designated Survivor (2016)
Joanna Reid Woman Woman See fewer	Tooth Fairy (I) (2010)
Jason Collins Bartender Bartender See fewer	Tortured (2007)