Amish church cookies

Savor the classic, rich flavor of Amish Brown Sugar Cookies, a soft and chewy treat with a perfect balance of sweetness and warmth.

These buttermilk sugar cookies remind me of the ones Amish women give to their children to keep them quiet during church. (Works for me!)

These 13 traditional Amish cookie recipes are the epitome of simplicity, but that doesn't mean they're short on flavor–you'll love these sweet treats!

Bake a batch of love with these Classic Amish Sugar Cookies. Soft, chewy, and packed with a delightful blend of vanilla and buttery sweetness, these cookies capture the essence of tradition. Decorate them with colorful frosting or savor their simplicity - either way, they're a timeless treat.

Our buttery soft Amish sugar cookies are a vintage recipe that you will be glad you discovered once you take a bite.

Amish church services can be three hours long. This can make for some restless children (and adults) so at many Amish church services a plate of cookies are passed around to the children during the service. Nothing satisfies the soul more for a kid than a cookie. Of course once the sugar begins coursing through...Read More

Just one batch of these easy cookies is enough to feed a crowd! Plus these cookies freeze beautifully so you can bake once and enjoy for months!

Rediscover an old classic with these irresistible Amish buttermilk cookies. They're soft and melt-in-your-mouth buttery, with a sweet and dreamy glaze.

Grab the recipe for these rich, decadent, Amish Maple Iced Cookies that are the perfect addition to that holiday cookie platter!

These Amish Ginger Snap Cookies are a delightful treat with a rich molasses flavor and warm spices. They are soft and chewy with crisp edges.