This is a really good post, so I wanna start by saying that before continuing. I think a lot of women do confuse themselves for being 'frigid' or 'asexual' when they really are just in bad situations, put themselves through sex they don't really want, aren't in touch with their desires (possibly closeted!).
So, my question is... what if you haven't experienced any of these, have healthy hormonal levels, and still rarely experience sexual arousal? Like... what if you actually are frigid?
Most information about this ends up being one of a few things:
- your hormones are out of whack
- your boyfriend needs to do the dishes
- you're a lesbian and you don't know it yet
- stop being depressed
- go to therapy to deal with sexual trauma
- you need to improve your bodily self-image
And none of these really apply to me.
I've been trying to find resources for people like me, who don't have trauma around sex, who nevertheless find it really difficult to get aroused by anything. People who can enjoy masturbation, and do, but don't ever feel horny enough to be driven to masturbate. The few times I've been able to be aroused, the arousal goes away relatively quickly, regardless of whether I'm looking at arousing material or not. I have found basically no articles or research on this phenomenon.
I think there's just... not enough research on the variations of female sexuality, either. And it's very embarrassing to discuss problems like this, even pseudonymously like I'm doing here, let alone in detail to researchers. There's a difficult time finding language for these sorts of situations, because it all gets flattened under "oh, you just have a low libido!"
And that's not even taking into account rare scenarios, like the fact that SSRIs can apparently permanently decrease your sex drive. Or the intersection between autism in women and sexuality.
I think a lot of women with 'abnormal' sexual response like I have end up in the asexual community because it's relatively welcoming and open to discussing these aspects of sexuality or lack thereof. A lot of it is just virgin teens or closeted gay people. But a lot is also adult women, especially autistic women, trying to make sense of what they're like and how to accept themselves in a world where you get one of those stock 6 responses.
It ends up going off the rails a lot of time with concepts like the romantic/sexual split. But we really do need more research on healthy and 'unusual' female sexuality, especially at the margins. Want to end by thanking OP again, sorry for this derail.