Scientific Articles
Sesquiterpenoides - the holy fragrance ingredients
Michael Zviely* and Arcadi Boix-Camps**
Incense is an aromatic substance which is obtained from
certain resinous trees and largely employed for purposes of
religious worship. The word is also used to signify the smoke
or perfume arising from incense when burned.
In ancient times, incense was furnished by two trees, viz. the
Boswellia sacra of Arabia Felix, and the Boswellia papyrifera
of India. Mention is made of it in the Bible: “Why do I need the
Frankincense that comes from Sheba, and the good cane from
a distant country? Your burnt offerings are not acceptable, and
your sacriices are not pleasant to Me”,1 and “Spikenard and
Saffron, Calamus and Cinnamon, with all Frankincense trees,
Michael Zviely completed his Ph.D. and
Post-Doc at the Hebrew University. He
then headed a research group for TAMI
(ICL) for almost ten years, and then spent
eleven years as Global VP for Research,
Development and Science of Frutarom
Ltd. After that, he worked three years
in China as the CTO for Research and
Development of O'Laughlin Industries
Ltd. (Shanghai), a company specializing
in aroma chemicals - flavor and fragrance
ingredients, botanical extracts, cooling
agents and UV sunscreen ingredients,
followed by a period as VP for Research
and Development of Virdia Inc. (HCL CleanTech Ltd.) in Israel and in
the USA, on lignocellulose originated bio-materials. In parallel, he
held a visiting professorship at Jiangnan University in China for five
years. Today Dr. Zviely is a consultant on technology and strategy of
specialty chemicals (fragrance and flavor ingredients).
Myrrh and Aloes, with all the chief spices”.2 It was procured
from the bark much as gum is obtained at present. To enhance
the fragrance and produce a thicker smoke various foreign
elements were added. These ingredients generally numbered
four, but sometimes as many as thirteen, and the task of
blending them in due proportion was assigned under the oldlaw ordinances to particular families.
One important group of fragrance ingredients are found
in incense of different origins – sesquiterpene related
molecules. Sesquiterpenes are a class of terpenes that consist
of three isoprene units and have the molecular formula C15H24.
Sesquiterpenes may be acyclic or contain rings, including
many unique combinations. Biochemical modiications such as
oxidation or rearrangement produce the related sesquiterpenoids.
Sesquiterpenes are found naturally in plants and insects.
Frankincense is the gum or resin of the Boswellia Serrata tree,
used for making perfume and incense. The Hebrew word for it is
lavonah לבונה, which means “white,” referring to the gum’s color.
The essential oil of frankincense is produced by steam distillation
of the tree resin. The oil’s chemical components are 75% monoterpenes, sesquiterpenes, monoterpenols, sesquiterpenols, and
ketones. It has a good balsamic and sweet fragrance. Some
Frankincense characteristic sesquiterpenoids are shown below:
Name of
Ingredient
Structure
Organoleptic
Characteristics
Sweet, green,
herbal, fruity,
tropical, minty
d-Viridiflorol
Arcadi Boix-Camps began his career as a
perfumer at Firmenich, the 2nd biggest
fragrance and flavor company, and for
the last 23 years he is the president and
master perfumer of Auram International
Co., Ltd., a modern company enjoying
a world respected technology active in
high level creative fragrances both for
functional and fine toiletries, sweet flavors
and savory flavors. Auram is also top
supplier of agarwood oils from different
origins being the largest producer in the
world and produces its own essential oils
mostly used in house to make specialties.
Arcadi is an author of many publications on perfumery and wrote
several books, e.g. “Perfumery Techniques in Evolution” providing
a constructive and open analysis of new perfumery materials and a
profound knowledge in the use of perfumery materials in both new
and traditional formulas.
OH
1S-cis-Calamenene
*
**
Herbal, spicy
CIC; mzviely@cathay-israel-chemistry.com
Auram International Co., Ltd.; www.auraminternational.com; aboix@
auraminternational.com
Issue 1, September 2015, Tishrei 5776
The Israel Chemist and Engineer
27
Scientific Articles
Myrrh comes from a small thorny tree. Commiphora myrrha,
is the most species rich genus of lowering plants in the
frankincense and myrrh family, Burseraceae was cultivated
in ancient times in the Arabian Peninsula. The grower made a
small cut in the bark, where the resin would leak out. It was then
collected and stored for about three months until it hardened
into fragrant globules. Myrrh was used raw or crushed and
mixed with oil to make a perfume. Myrrh oil is steam distilled
directly from the myrrh resin. Its aroma is woody, earthy
and a bit balsamic. Myrrh is occasionally used as lavoring
agents. Somalia and Ethiopia are by far the largest producers
of Myrrh.3 Some Myrrh characteristic sesquiterpenoids are
shown below:
Name of
Ingredient
Structure
Organoleptic
Characteristics
O
Typical myrrh,
balsamic, woody,
musty
Furanoedusma1,3-diene
Name of
Structure
Ingredient
α-Santalol
Typical myrrh,
balsamic, woody,
musty
Lindestrene
Dihydropyrocurzerenone
O
A resinous
myrrh odor, best
represents the
odor of myrrh by
itself
OH
OH
β-Santalol
Structure
28
The Israel Chemist and Engineer
Typical
sandalwood
odor, with
powerful
woody, milky
and urinous
tonalities6
Organoleptic
Characteristics
O
4S,5R-Dihydrokaranone
Strong woody,
slightly
camphoraceous,
fumigating note,
remarkable,
intense, woody8a,b
O
Woody, amberlike, elegant8a,c
4S,5R-Karanone
O
One of the oldest incense materials, Sandalwood, has been
in use for at least 4,000 years. The sandal tree, botanically
known as Santalum album belongs to the family Santalaceae.
The sandal tree grows almost exclusively in the forests of
Karnataka, followed by Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Andhra
Pradesh, Timor Islands of Indonesia etc. The Sandalwood
appears in the Bible as one of the Temple building materials
– Almog אלמוג: “Also Hiram’s ships that delivered gold from
Ophir, brought from Ophir a huge quantity of Almog-wood
and precious stones”.4
Sandalwood oil mainly consists of a number of closely related
sesquiterpenoids. α-Santalol and β-santalol amount to more
than 90% of the oil, β-santalol being the most important
character impact compound. Some Sandalwood characteristic
sesquiterpenoides are shown in the following table;
A relatively
weak, slightly
woody odor
reminiscent of
α-cedrene5
Agarwood is the resinous heartwood of the Aquilaria tree, a
genus belonging taxonomically to the Thymelaeaceae. The
essential oil is a highly demanded ingredient in ine perfumery
for its warm, unique balsamic notes with sandalwood–
ambergris tonalities.7 In this review7 Regula Neff describes a
group of sesquiterpenoides with warm, woody characteristic
odor,8a which are the heart constituents of agarwood volatiles,
some of them are shown below:
Name of
Ingredient
O
Organoleptic
Characteristics
Eremophila9,11-dien-8-one
Sweet, woody, like
dihydrokaranone,
important
oriental,
fumigating
character9
Bursera graveolens is a deciduous tree of the Burseraceae family
that is distributed from Mexico to Peru. Its woody material has a
strong characteristic spicy, sweet and balsamic odor, and is used
as incense in churches where it is called “Palo Santo”. Palo Santo
oil was used during the time of the Incas for its reputed spiritual
purifying properties. Many members of the Burseraceae family
produce a strong fragrance, demonstrated by the use of resin of
plants from the Boswellia genus historically as a prominent raw
material in the production of frankincense, and the usage of the
resin of Commiphora molmol and closely related species as myrrh.10
Issue 1, September 2015, Tishrei 5776
Scientific Articles
The following four sesquiterpenoids were isolated from
Burseragra veolens:
OH
OH
(-)-Juneol
Dihydrojuneol
O
OH
6b-Hydroxy-4(15)eudesmen-1-one
O
OH
6β-Hydroxy-eudesman-4-one
All four have a characteristic weak sweet, woody and herbal
odor.
The sesquiterpenoid molecules described above are a part
of this important F&F natural ingredients, e.g. valencene,11
nootkatone,12 α- and β-vetivones and khusimone13 discussed
elsewhere.
There seems to be a relation between sesquiterpenoids and
essential oils used for religious ceremonies. In the former
short review discussing sesquiterpenoids, naming them the
holy fragrance ingredients, we presented Frankincense,
Myrrh, Sandalwood, Agarwood and Palo Santo.a
In this part, several different Agarwood oils and ingredients
will be discussed more deeply, mostly their sesquiterpenoid
aroma molecules. The Agarwood species studied herein are
Aquillaria Agallocha, A. Crassna, A. Baillonii, A. Beccariana,
A. Malaccencis, A. Microcarpa, A. Subintegra, A. Banaensis,
A. Rugosa and A. Yunnanensis.
These agarwood oils smell extremely different on their top notes,
namely coriaceous, animal, fecal, fruity, extremely leathery
(being the most leathery those coming from Papua New Guinea
and Indonesia’s Irian Jaya regions, which are called Jayapura
and Mereke), cheesy, phenolic but when evaporating in the skin
after 7 to 8 hours, all of them change to create the most noble,
extraordinary, unexpected, surprising, amazing and astonishing
woody note that has existed in the world. All of these oils
converge-whatever the quality - to the same precious woody
note. Studies have been done to understand the reason why
and the answer seems mostly to derive amongst the important
sesquiterpenoids described herein.
The dry down became all the same. Many of the molecules
found in Agarwood oils were smelled, from those simple
like benzyl acetone, furfural, frambinone methyl ether,
p-cresol, furfuryl alcohol, creosol, styrene, p-vinyl anisole,
etc., molecules which are not important at all. some olfactory
important acid molecules as butyric, 3-methylvalerianic,
caproic, caprilic, cyclohexanoic etc., and those believed to be
really “keys” in the fabulous smell sought for a millennium
and being the favorite smell of Asian aristocrats in Vietnam,
China, Japan, Thailand or the Indian Maharajas.
It seems that the top note differences in the oils are created
by unimportant ingredients while the “treasure” is in the
ingredients almost nobody knows. Why do so many different
oils have such a different top note, very often unpleasant, and
suddenly its odor changes to impart the extraordinary woody
note that is so resinous, fragrant, radiant and delicate.
The oils which are fecal, cheesy are less preferred by some of the
perfumers. These are mostly the cheesy ones (Boyas from India,
Bangla Desh, Laos) or the oils ex A. Agallocha or A. Khasiana.
The more accepted oils are from Malaysia, Indonesia, Papua
New Guinea, and those from Thailand (Prachinbury ex A.
Subintegra, Tratex A. Crassna and those from Cambodia ex A.
Baillonii and A. Crassna too (called in the market KohKhong).
These seem to be the best Agarwood oils.
Why do all these oils become so woody and treasure the best
smell in the world on its dry down? It is very risky to reply
but there are some “key” ingredients than make the miracle
as shown below:
One of the best aroma molecules,
being powerfully woody, resinous,
timbered extraordinarily diffusive
and not easy to forget once known
and smelled. This seems one of the
best woody chemicals existing.
The synthesis of (+)-(4αS,5R)Dihydrokaranone
is described
(+)-(4αS,5R)-Dihydrokaranone
below.
O
H
Its smell is very strong, as the
previous one extremely long
lasting, with orris sub notes,
clean, radiant, diffusive, bright,
woody ambery, smelling a bit
of Ambrocenide, Ambrostar,
dextro Nor Limbanol, Ambermax,
Cachalox, Z-11 and Limbanol whose
greatness is to make feel harmony.
O
O
O
(-)-Guaia-1(10),11-dien-15,2-olide
OH
A storm of the noblest woods, a
moving smell, sensitive, receptive,
insightful that cannot be described,
but providing an extremely rich
creativity to every good and skilled
perfumer.
Jinkohol (2-epiprezizaan-7β-ol)
Issue 1, September 2015, Tishrei 5776
The Israel Chemist and Engineer
29
Scientific Articles
Softer than Jinkohol or
Dihydrokaranone but imparting a
special sweetness which combines
extremely well with those
described before and especially
mixed with (-)-Guaia-1(10),11-dien15-al. The accord of these aroma
molecules brings the smell of the
mysterious woodiness of Agarwood
oils, which bring the same results
regardless of the different top note.
O
(8,12)-Epoxyeremophila9,11(13)-diene
It is extremely woody but with
very important amber gris notes
as important as the woody ones.
Karanone would mix extraordinarily
well with pure amber chemicals
such as Ambroxclassique (the
original one containing ambrols)
and by far the best, α-Ambrinol,
Limbanol, Ambrostar, LaevoCetalox,
Super Ambrox, Amber Xtreme,
Ambrocenide, Cachalox,
Ambrinoloxide, Dehydroambrox,
Dihydro-γ-ionone, Timbersilk,
Dextro Nor Limbanol, Trisamber, etc.
O
(+)-(4αR,5S)-Karanone.
O
O
2-(2-Phenylethyl)chromenone
The best smoke comes from woods also rich on diepoxytetrahydro-2-2-phenyethyl-chromones.b These chromones
stabilize and harmonize the smell provided by the volatile
ingredients present in the wood and in the oils.
O
O
O
O
DIepoxy-tetrahydro-2-(2-phenyethyl-chromones
OH
Very woody and smelling of
Agarwood smoke
Jinkohol II
Jinkohol II character is somehow quite strange because when
the oils are distilled, no more than 35 chromones present in the
woods are detected. The presence of chromones is what makes
the smell of the smoke richer, exalted, splendid, high, lofty and
even glorious. The chromones do not come on the distilled
products and only on the extracted ones by acetone, benzene,
supercritical CO2, etc., being the most important ingredients
for the smoke of Agarwood. Among them 2-(2-phenylethyl)chromones and 2-(2-phenylethyl)-tetrahydrochromenones are
more mysterious that the other ones mentioned before.
O
O
It seems the amount of chromones is what will make the
fragrance successful, mostly by Royals, since a wood with
65% of chromones does not burn the same as a wood with only
10%. The chromones have nothing to do with the oils but the
burning of these high noble ingredients with the chromones,
produces spiritual peace and being in a “Platonic Pink Cloud”
as described elsewhere by the author.2
O
Having a lovely smell as other
Agarwood ketones
Eremophila-9,11-dien-8-one
Eremophila-9,11-dien-8-one is a very unstable chemical and
very dificult to detect through GC/MS since most of isomerizes
to form more Dihydrokaranone during the conditions of the
GC injector, being the noblest ingredients as happen in Vetiver
too where the best smell is given by α-Vetivone, Dihydroβ-vetivone, Didehydro-β-vetivone, Didehydro-α-vetivone,
Dihydro-α-vetivone, Khusimone, β-Vetivone, etc. Both oils
are deined as noble “ketone” oils.3
2-(2-Phenylethyl)chromone
30
The Israel Chemist and Engineer
Issue 1, September 2015, Tishrei 5776
Scientific Articles
References
H
a.
This molecule mixes very well with
epoxieremohilladiene and has a
beautiful note of β-Damascenone
b.
c.
OHC
(-)-Guaia-1(10),11-dien-15-al
The beautiful note of (-)-Guaia-1(10),11-dien-15-al which
is very rare on these chemical structures but also an orrisydiffusive and radiant smell with reminiscences of Irones and
Dihydroirone. Its woodiness it is extremely soft, almost having
soul and spirit. The studies made on the above sesquiterpenoids
showed quite certainly that they are the most important when
trying to rationalize this turning of the oils from their original
and so diverse top note to the common precious woody note.
A novel diastereoselective route to (4aS,5R)-4,4a,5,6,7,8hexahydro-4a,5-dimethyl-2(3H)-naphthalenone has been
developed. The key step involves an asymmetric Michael
addition of the corresponding chiral secondary enamines
derived from (S)-(-)-1-phenylethylamine and (3R)-2,3dimethylcyclohexanone to 1-buten-3-one. This enone
was successfully transformed into the eremophilane-type
sesquiterpenoid (-)-Dihydro-karanone.c
O
(3R)-2,3-Dimethylcyclohexanone
+
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
N
9.
(-)-((S)-?-Methylbenzyl)amine
10.
(2,3-Dimethyl-cyclohexylidene)-(1-phenylethyl)-amine
11.
12.
13.
O
O
(-)-Dihydrokaranone
1-Buten-3-one
Sesquiterpenoides – The Holy Fragrance Ingredients – Part 1
M. Zviely and L. Ming, Perfumer & Flavorist (2013) 38(6), 52.
The volatile and semi-volatile constituents of agarwood, the
infected heartwood of Aquilaria species: a review. Naef,
Regula; Flavour and Fragrance Journal (2011), 26(2), 73-89.
A practical and eficient preparation of (-)-(4aS,5R)4,4a,5,6,7,8-hexahydro-4a,5-dimethyl-2(3H)-naphthalenone:
a key intermediate in the synthesis of (-)-dehydrofukinone;
Schenato, R. A.; dos Santos, E. M.; Tenius, B. S. M.; Costa, P.
R. R.; Caracelli, I.; Zukerman-Schpector, J. From Tetrahedron:
Asymmetry (2001), 12(4), 579-584.
Jeremiah, 6:20
Song of Songs, 4:14
Myrrh – Commiphora Chemistry, Lumír O. Hanuša, Tomáš
Řezankab, Valery M. Dembitsky, Arieh Moussaieff; Biomed.
Papers 149(1), 3–28 (2005)
Kings I, 10:11
Müller PM, Lamparsky D. Perfumes: Art, Science &
Technology. Amsterdam, New York: Elsevier; 1991.
Bauer K, Garbe D, Surburg H. Common fragrance and lavor
materials: preparation, properties and uses. 2nd ed. Weinheim:
VCH; 1990. OBS:
The volatile and semi-volatile constituents of agarwood, the
infected heartwood of Aquilaria species: A review; Regula
Naef, Flavour Fragr. J. 2011, 26, 73–89.
(a) T. Nagashima, I. Kawasaki, T. Yoshida, T. Nakanishi, K.
Yoneda, I. Miura.;IXth Int. Ess. Oil Congress, Singapore, 1983,
p.12.; (b) M. Ishihara, T.Kitaura. JP 2004189643, 2004; (c) M.
Ishihara, T. Kitaura. JP 2004231519, 2004
M. Ishihara, T. Tsuneya, K. Uneyama. Phytochem. 1993, 33,
1147
Eudesmane-Type Sesquiterpenoids in the Volatile Oilfrom
Burseragraveolens; Chiyoki Yukawa, Hisakatsu Iwabuchi,
Sadao Komemushi and Akiyoshi Sawabe; J. Oleo Sci., Vol. 53,
No. 7, 343-348 (2004)
M. Zviely and C. Hong; Perfumer&Flavorist (2009), 34(1), 26.
M. Zviely; Perfumer &Flavorist (2009), 34(12), 20.
M. Zviely; Perfumer &Flavorist (2012), 37(2), 46.
O
HO
O
O
3-(1-Hydroxy-1-methyl-ethyl)-4a,5-dimethyl4,4a,5,6,7,8-hexahydro-3H-naphthalen-2-one
2,3-Dimethyl-2-(3-oxo-butyl)-cyclohexanone
O
Acetone
O
(4aS,5R)-4,4a,5,6,7,8-Hexahydro-4a,5-dimethyl
2(3H)-naphthalenone
Issue 1, September 2015, Tishrei 5776
The Israel Chemist and Engineer
31