UNDER PALE BLUE STARS
MATTHEW OLIVAS
University of California, Riverside, 2020
Fiction
2
ABOUT A DECADE AGO you shot an opossum with a cross bow. You shot it two
more times to finish the job, all in quick succession. You didn’t want to prolong its
suffering. It needed only to die. Still, it felt like forever – its little silent sighs into
stillness.
It happened on a Friday night a little after nine o’clock. You remember this
because you’d just won another football game, you hadn’t yet torn your ACL. The
victory was contagious and the whole town was infected by then with cheering down
the streets, and the faraway blare of the marching band beyond the neighborhood.
You’d be going to playoffs. You had a date that night too, with Thalia Carson from
Physics. It would be your first date, though not for a lack of trying, not many girls –
or other kids your age for that matter – cared for the movies you did. Superhero
movies weren’t in anymore, too childish. But Thalia thought it was a sweet idea and
you’d never been called sweet by a girl before, so you should have been getting ready
for that date.
Instead you had been summoned to the back yard by your frantic mother,
ordering you to get your crossbow. Out there, November air cooling your damp hair,
you found your mom and your younger brother Julian. You hadn’t even had time to
take off your jersey. Your fingernails still caked under with mud.
Julian was pointing a shovel at the wall, frantic but laughing. “It’s right over
here! It’s got nasty little vampire teeth! Truly an Olympic champion at being horrible.”
Julian was being Julian about it.
“It’s going to eat my chickens,” you mom said, “you have to kill it.”
Your mom shined a light on it and it, whatever you thought it would be, was
perched on the fence, fanged and hissing like Satan: an opossum.
Your mom wasted no time at all, she said to you plain and simple, “Kill it.”
You and your brother had shared a look. He was so much like a smaller you it
was scary, down to your mom’s eyes and black hair and dark skin. You turned back to
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
3
your mom but she was already in the house, gone, and you tuned to the opossum, still
hissing and still very small. That’s when it dawned on you.
It wasn’t funny anymore.
“Hurry up, dude, it’s cold as balls,” Julian rubbed his hands together.
You had a date, and not much time for this. So you aimed, and it hissed at the
end of the scope. You hesitated – once – twice –shot it on the third. Three thumps
was all you heard. The distance band music had stopped. There was a cricket or two,
and nothing more. That was the first time you killed something.
You remember you rushed to get clean after that. You had the urge to scrub
yourself down, and pick out the dirt in your nails, scrape the clumps off your scalp
but grains tangled in your hair, and you scrubbed your shoulders raw – by the end of
it you felt as dirty as you’d started. The grime wouldn’t come off so you did it again.
Scrubbed again. And again, until your mom knocked at your door saying you’d be late
and you had to force yourself out.
You got dressed you mom stepped into your room and gave you a look “You’re
pale,” she said, “and are those scratches?”
Of course, that was some time ago.
That long ago murder came to your mind, and you’re not sure why. It wasn’t
something you spoke about. You had omitted it from your mind. What memory you
did keep from that night was the date, and you would bring it up over and over, at
your wedding day and all the other times you told the story of how you met your
wife. You told that story so many times but even that story has gotten old.
Married for six years, Thalia and you, right out of Junior College, and into the
glum apartment you two share now. You want to be back in your apartment, with her,
smelling her lilac hair and in your memory foam mattress gone flaccid. It was better
than the heat. The scorching heat as you march along in desert twilight. You passed
an opossum that was shriveled up and dead about five yards back. It’s rare seeing
animals so far south, nothing lives out there in the desert. At least not anymore.
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
4
Never mind, you don’t pay it any attention, can’t let these things get to you. You’re
working.
Tonight you hunt immigrants.
The dead opossum, your brother, and your wife you force in the back of your
head.
You stay focused. In front of you are the footprints of the runaways. You’re
stepping in them, matching foot with footprint, careful not to slip – just as the ones
who made the prints had been - until you walk up to a vantage point at the side of a
hill. The sun pokes over the horizon. It won’t be long until the sun is down and you
lose visibility and a fall from this high will kill you.
Lucien isn’t far behind, you hear him coming. He’s huffing through his
rebreather mask, in and out, it’s the only sound for miles.
The Arizona desert stretches for miles and the shadows try to keep up.
Mountains line the distance, black and small, and sound doesn’t travel out there.
Gravely footsteps don’t echo either, they just die out once the sound is made,
stretched thin and wide in every direction until they are just another nothing the
desert consumes. As it does everything.
If it was up to you wouldn’t work out there. You wouldn’t work for the private
sector helping the US government bulk up the southern wall, you’d be in a city or a
town or somewhere north and not scorching. You would be a police officer like you
father, probably have gotten the job sooner, and maybe even had a child – or two! But
you are not a police officer, even though you are your father’s son.
You’re standing at a mountain top overlooking the desert with goggles that
make you think Owl. There. Through the green lenses, you spot the ruin of a town at
the base of the hill, three beams of light shine amongst the wreck.
You get into a squat, despite the heat. Stay still. Be silent. You won’t be seen.
It won’t be long now, until the sun is down and the stars blanket the sky from
east to west.
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
5
What was once an aggressive orange will fade to black and what was blue will
go to violet, and soon, black also. But with that will come the stars! You can take
comfort in that, no matter how dark it was, you just had to look up, take off those
goggles and see the stars that have always just been there.
“How many?” A muffled voice breaks the silence. You turn to Lucien in his
own insolation poncho, wearing his own rebreather mask, not unlike yours. He
watched you through owl goggles.
You take off your rebreather, “Four flashlights,” you tell him. You put the mask
back on. None of you like the masks, but its company policy. Filters the toxic air –
the radiation. Bombs went off yeah, there was radiation too, sure, but that was
further south, deeper in Mexico. Lucien kept his mask on “just to be safe”.
He looks like a wraith – you both do. It’s too intimidate.
“Cool,” he says. “’Bout two miles from here, huh? Well we’ll make it before
back up, but hey something fun for once.” He slaps your chest, makes his was down
the mountain. “Come on, Gonzo!”
You are Jacinto Gonzales. But Lucien likes to call you Gonzo. It irks like nails
on scraping chalk board, and they even call you that back at the precinct. You
swallow it though. You stay silent and follow Lucien. Honestly, you’ll be used to it.
It’s the not being referred to at all that’s worse. That scares you… At least this way
you know they like you.
The town looks peaceful from far away. You approach it now, slowly, and its
skeletal buildings become all the more clear.
You used to wonder why so many people didn’t like you. You don’t any more.
You accept it for how it is. It’s not like you ever did anything wrong to them. Never
intentionally. That can’t be said for most people.
You were nothing but courteous to your brother, even if you hated him all your
life - though when you started really hating him you didn’t know. It couldn’t have
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
6
happened all at once, you would have remembered that date or time or place. No. It
was slow, methodical, and brutal like a disease.
There were key events obviously, when he started calling cops pigs in high
school. Pigs - as if that didn’t make him half hog himself then. There was the time he
quit his job in college and said it was because a cop had aimed a gun at him. You’d
seen your brother scared, he was always so… snarky – cavalier. He didn’t seem so
distraught when he told you the story, only sullen and meek, but still smiling as if it
had all been a part of some “I told you so plan.”
“If you didn’t do anything wrong, you should have been fine,” you told him.
You just knew he did something, maybe back talk, maybe sass – what was it about
Gonzales’s that made people dislike them? You still pitied him.
You even loved his daughter, Nina. More than just loved. How someone so
terribly liberal managed to have a daughter so genuinely kind, you’ll never know. You
knew she was worth it though, worth putting up with him for years and doing your
best to make idle talk with his equally liberal, rich, wife about anything that wasn’t
politics just to be able to steal Nina away and take her to the movies to watch
cartoons and superheroes or anything primary colors. None of the girt that everyone
your age seemed to prefer. She actually appreciated them, like you.
You used to sit with her after the movies, taking her home late because one, it
upset Julian, and two, the better reason, it made her happy. Nina would tell you about
whatever drama it was that kid’s had those days, and even share with you the jokes
she’d written down – she wanted to be a comedian.
You even told her about becoming a police officer, something she liked even if
Julian didn’t. Sometimes, just maybe, you thought maybe Julian didn’t mind it either.
But that was Julian.
One night Nina asked about your last physical test. It was your fifth one, for a
fifth try at a fifth academy – it was also the fifth rejection. It wasn’t any fault to you
though. Just as you told her, it was always down to the same thing, the same thirty
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
7
four millimeter liability of a reconstructed ACL. Shown only by a faded pale scare on
your left knee.
Nina had traced her finger over it inquisitively, it tickled. “You can be a
firefighter, probably a great one,” she said. You only looked at her, puzzled. “Well
some just came to our school a few days ago for the first and second graders. They
passed out red hats and that adorable bear came out on stage – you could be that
bear, uncle.” She swept her hand across the air, squinting at whatever she imaged in
front of her. “You’d be a big one too. You’d tell people -” she gruffed her voice for that
bit – “Only you can stop forest fires.”
“Prevent,” you correct her. She furred her brow. “It’s prevent forest fires.”
“Fine. Fine.” She waved you off.
She was right about one thing through – you would be a great one, but Nina
didn’t know your father. No one did, not even Julian. He was too young to remember
much about your father, or even the world for that matter. For him there was no time
before the planet warmed and migrants poured in in the thousands… but that’s not
the point. The point is that only you really seemed to remember you who your dad
was. You had spent hours during his funeral listening to the stories of better men and
how your father changed their lives. People you didn’t even know. Faces that now
only come off as peripheral, spun stories he never told you about. You remember that
feeling, that giddiness in a sea of grief, hope – one man did a job and after decades,
people actually said it: What he did mattered.
You almost said yes to Nina. You were on her porch by that point, ready to
ring the bell and for Julian to claim her again, and you just had to say the word to her:
yes. Yes I will be a firefighter. But you didn’t. “That’s not me,” you said to her.
You were, and are your father’s son. If you couldn’t be a cop, well, then what
would you be.
Exactly.
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
8
You just have to do this, you tell yourself, cold, in the desert of the night. You’re
marching through the ghost town. Just a bit longer. Soon you won’t have to, you could
get enough money, get a real home, and transfer to a real precinct, as a real officer of
the law. This was just temporary – no, necessary.
You don’t get the name of the town as you walk through. All the signs are
faded. You wonder how old it is, if it was abandoned long ago in the eighteen
hundreds, or more recent, when everyone escaped the heat. There are so many ruins
at the southern border, it’s always so hard to tell. It’s sad almost, this forgotten place,
alone.
Like you.
Your ear piece picks up rustling. Your gun, already in your hands, scans the
shadows. You heart’s pounding. It’s so hot. Lucien has his drawn too and he’s moving
with you, back to back, and following the sound of gavel and the shattering of glass
up ahead.
“Remember, there’s five,” he tells you.
Armed, you remember.
Five illegals had slipped away under the watch of a detainment center eight
miles south. They told you this back at the precinct, the fugitives killed two guards
and took a gun. They are armed. They were heading north. Still holding onto that
notion, so they are still desperate also, and desperate men kill.
So many people died when the mass migrations happened. Raids and riots, and
shooting from police and civilians alike for people who had and might not had been
threats. Julian wouldn’t remember living on food rations, he was too young. You tried
to tell him this long ago. It’s different now, you tried to explain. “ICE was bad back
then, we need order now.” But he was stubborn. How was he supposed to know?
Let him think you’re wrong, you had decided. You know what your doing is
right, so it didn’t matter if he or your family or the world said you were wrong. As
long as you don’t say it yourself.
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
9
Because if you did then what would you be?
You kick open the door of the church. Lucien follows in after you, and inside
at the foot of the alter steps you spot one of them. You approach. Moonlight steams
through broken windows, as shadows maybe lurk outside. You think you see
something out the corner of your eye.
The man waits for you two at the steps in a puddle of his sweat. He’s tired and
breathing deep, and then, once your close enough, you see his face; his sunken black
eyes, his olive skin, not unlike yours. An itchy restless urge grips you, gently, as if ants
had slowly crawled one by one into your skin and now all you can to is scratch to get
clean.
There are still four out there, and the two of you are partially lined up and
waiting.
“Hands up,” Lucien shouts. “Stay down, hands in the air. NOW!” He’s so loud.
Think of something quiet, drown it out.
You think of all the times you sat in silence. A lot of the time you’re alone and
just out of the way enough. It would be at baby showers, or Thanksgiving dinners, or
even the last Easter Gathering (where you last saw Julian). You would, and had, and
failed at talking to your own family. Those little clusters. You chimed in here and
there, mostly nodding, laughing along at the edge of circles. It wouldn’t be until you
spoke more, and they gave you looks, you cousins you’d known all your life, uncles
and aunts too, they would nod and move on, with polite smiles. Was it something you
said, maybe? That’s when you feel most alone, when you’re surrounded by so many
people and you’re still so quiet.
You close off the sounds and in silence Lucien lashes out, grabbing the man by
his collar and toss him aside. The man’s talking, but Lucien doesn’t speak that
language. You do though, and you heard him say his name was Oliver. You heard him
asking for forgiveness. Mercy.
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
10
Pushing Lucien aside, you get down on your knee, your hand palm up and
stretched out to him. He just had to take it.
You ask him, in your mother’s tongue, where the others were. He says he can’t
tell you. You tell him you’re trying to help. “I need you to cooperate,” you say in Spanish.
He says he doesn’t want to die here and you think of the widows whose husbands
Oliver and his party killed on their way out to freedom. You saw the widows on the
TV that afternoon, as you got ready. They seemed so gone. Dazed and answering
questions in-between sniffles. Your mom’s a widow too.
“But I don’t want you to die,” You tell him, honestly. “Just tell me where they are.”
He begs you not to send them back, even if it’s what he deserves. Even if you
know that’s death enough. You almost take him then, you can just hold his hand, and
go far away and come back later, but you’re mad.
“Gonzo.” Lucien watched you and Oliver and the two of you look like little
green aliens in his goggles.
You’re mad. Mad that Oliver looks like you. That you look like him. The
thought passes, what would you do in his position, and it’s consumed by the desert. You
wouldn’t kill people like that, leaving wives to grieve in that way you watched your
mom grieve a life time ago. So you don’t think what you would do in his spot, you
wouldn’t have gotten there in the first place.
He insults you when he speaks in your mom’s language. Everything he says just
makes you sick, and worse, and shit.
You want to cry.
You don’t. You haven’t since you were a boy at your father’s funeral.
Please, Oliver said. Please. I know you’re a good man. You have good eyes. He
touches your goggles, looking through them.
You get up. You turn around, tell Lucien, “I hear something,” and leave the
church, and leave Oliver to Lucien, whatever Lucien will do.
You did all you could. You did all you could.
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
11
“Just look at the stars,” you say, under your breath. You do. You stumble out
into the night heat and you peel away the green with your goggles. You take your
mask off and breathe in, and out. You look up to the sky and the pale blue stars are
right there.
Did all you could.
You take off your head set too, as to not hear the fumbling from Lucien’s end.
You’re alone out there.
“Is that it, then?” The voice came from your memories. Lucien?
It wasn’t an old memory. It wasn’t one you tried to shake out, and focus on the
stars, but it came back to you in full force like a freight train: “Do you want to be an
officer to help people or because you want to enforce the law?” Julian had been
worked up that he was red in the face.
You didn’t get a chance to answer, you could only blink with surprise, and
maybe guilt. You opened your mouth but he had kept going, “Is it really that
important? Being a big man with a gun? You’re going to get someone killed, or
worse.”
“What is to you if I die?” you heard yourself saying. It’s not like they liked you
anyways. They like me at the precinct though, they call me Gonzo.
“No. You’re going to kill someone else.”
“Shut up!” You shot out of your chair in a violent jolt. You had tried too hard
to be a cop, so hard to get in. You weren’t like him with novels and tenure and a
house. There wasn’t anything else you could do that mattered. Why couldn’t you just
tell him that? Maybe he would have understood. “Just Shut. Up!”
You punched the refrigerator. You pulled your hand away and a dent matched
where it had been. “Come on, let’s go.” Julian left with Nina, slowly, shuffling out of
the kitchen and out the front door. You listened to the car engine drift away.
Your mom was sitting idly at the end of the dining table. “Mom?” you croaked.
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
12
She sighed. “I can’t tell you what to do. I just know that your father never
killed someone. Whatever you do, Jacinto, you have to do good. Or you might not
come back.”
Why did you have to remember that?
You pinch your brow. The memory leaves you weak. It’s still so hot and musky,
and you want to go home. You wander through the town, scratching your arms when
whispers prickle at your ear - a figure darts by in front of you.
You scream into your hands. The other aims your trembling gun. The whispers
are audible enough to know they’re not in your head, and you’re coming from the
house you’re right out front of. You go in.
Inside, you step over an old photograph of a boy in a sports jersey. The glass
crackles. Maybe you would have been a football player, in another life - where you
didn’t tear your ACL. Its scar is deceitfully small. You mom had been happy about it
though. You had overheard her in the back of the car, on the way out of your surgery.
Rain was tapping the roof of the car. She was talking to Julian, and you should have
still been asleep from the anesthetic.
You repeat her words in that vacant had-been home. “He never would have
been a good player. Too kind – too gentle.”
“Huh?”
The voice came from just under the floorboards, where you stood. You drop
your gun, and get down. By the time you’re done with it, your hands sting but the
pain is dull and far away. Your skin is raggedy, blood drops from where your fingertips
had been splintered away. But the hole in the floor is big enough now. Lifting the last
wooden plant, the floors mouth gaping at you, breathing in the heavy air, you spot
the little eyes staring up at you in the dark.
You jump down in front of them, how many there are you can’t tell – you don’t
have your goggles. They’re just things – moving within the darkness. But by the
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
13
sounds of their wipers you know they’re young, kids. You reach for the gun you left on
the floor, “Don’t move.”
The voice comes from behind you. The cold barrel of a gun jams into your
back – you’re on your knees. The dirt burns, and you don’t want to die, not down
here. The man behind you speaks in a heavy accent, “Don’t fucking move.”
“Don’t! He’s barely a man, look at him!” someone calls form the dark.
Another shadow darts across the black, and stars chattering too quick for you
to follow. The stranger ignores it and shouts at them to get away from there. To run
north and hide, and that he’ll slow them down. Them. He means you.
Those widows on the TV – would Thalia join them tomorrow? The tagline
would read about a window’s highs school sweet heart, just turned thirty. The
stranger pulls the trigger.
Gears crunch - you don’t die, the guns doesn’t fire. You turn around and for the
first time look him in the face, and he’s no older than you are: a clean face. He
mutters, “Oh.”
You fall into a frenzy with him, kicking up gusts of orang sand. He clawed at
your face and pulled at your mask, tightening it around your throat. You pound on
him to get him off you, he’s not moving. You knee him – once – twice – he screams at
the third one. He rolls off, and somehow you managed to grab your pistol and get to
your feet. He doesn’t.
He’s unarmed and on the ground. “Wait,” He chokes, “Wait.”
He’s so young.
Something cold and wet streams down your cheeks. Everything’s blurry.
You don’t have to shoot him. Your fingers are on the trigger, you don’t want to
die. It won’t be long through, there are sirens outside. They’ll be coming for you.
They won’t tell you apart from them, they’ll drag you out, throw you down – chain
you down. The kids would still be down here, but they still have time right now. They
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019
14
can go and run far, far away. You want to tell them that, you’re so close to opening
your mouth.
You almost throw down your gun.
The world teeters on a razors edge – But Lucien comes. He peers into the dark
still hole, where he can’t make you out and the boy is right in front of you scared out
of his mind. Lucien doesn’t see him, he just see’s you and your gun through green
goggles. His gun is raised, and you, well you just have to open your mouth.
————————————————————————————————————————
The Foundationalist Volume IV, 2019