Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Exogenous ochronosis in Asians

2010, International Journal of Dermatology

AI-generated Abstract

The article addresses the occurrence of exogenous ochronosis in Asian patients, specifically highlighting a case study of an Indian female affected by hydroquinone-induced pigmentation. The authors critique a previous paper by Tan et al. for failing to reference their earlier report on the subject. They emphasize the potential prevalence of exogenous ochronosis in melasma patients who use hydroquinone in Asian countries, advocating for more rigorous studies and awareness among clinicians regarding this condition and its management.

Correspondence Exogenous ochronosis in Asians We read with admiration the article by Tan et al.,1 who reported two patients with hydroquinone-induced hyperpigmentation of the face. In the first patient suffering from melasma, various skin whiteners containing 4% hydroquinone had been applied for 6 years. A reticulate, lace-like, macular pigmentation was noted on the bilateral cheeks and sides of the face. In the second patient, also suffering from melasma, skin whitening creams containing 4% hydroquinone had been applied for 5 years. A reticular, curvilinear, macular pigmentation was noted on the cheeks. Tan et al.1 stated that, to their knowledge, ‘‘exogenous ochronosis has not been reported in Asians in the English medical literature.’’ We wish to draw the authors’ attention to our previous report on a 30-year-old female Indian farmer who developed a bluish-black pigmentation on the bilateral malar region after application of 4% hydroquinone cream for 3 months for melasma.2 Histopathology of the involved malar skin revealed exogenous ochronosis with brownish clumps in the papillary dermis. Swollen and homogeneous collagen fibres were also noted. Our report was written in English, and was readily searchable on Medline using the entry ‘‘exogenous ochronosis.’’ It was unfortunate that Tan et al.1 omitted our publication in this area. Nevertheless, we trust that such an omission was entirely unintentional, and are not offended by it. On the basis of our reported case and other subsequent cases of exogenous ochronosis in melasma seen in our department, we agree strongly with Tan et al.1 that, as topical hydroquinone is being widely used in the treatment of melasma in Asian Exogenous ochronosis in Asians I refer to the letter from Professor Vijay Zawar regarding our article ‘‘Exogenous ochronosis in Asians,’’1 and wish to convey my sincere apologies to Professor Zawar and Dr Antonio Chuh for having inadvertently missed their article in our Medline search on the subject. I acknowledge that our report was, indeed, not the first reported case of exogenous ochronosis in Asia. Indeed, a further search has revealed another earlier article2 from Thailand reporting a series of patients with exogenous ochronosis. In addition, five more cases of histologically proven exogenous ochronosis have been diagnosed in our clinic since ª 2010 The International Society of Dermatology countries, exogenous ochronosis is likely to be prevalent, but underdiagnosed and under-reported. We advocate further studies in this area in Asian countries by experts such as Tan et al., with a view to alerting dermatologists and other clinicians to the importance of distinguishing between exogenous ochronosis and melasma. We also recommend that randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews should be performed on the use of hydroquinone and other management strategies in melasma, with an emphasis on exogenous ochronosis. Potential adverse reactions of these treatments, including exogenous ochronosis, should be highlighted as one of the outcome measures in prospective studies, because the management of exogenous ochronosis is not easy and, in our experience, may not be completely reversible. Prevention in the form of the judicious and rational use of bleaching agents might be a better approach than attempting to cure the condition. Vijay Zawar, MD, DNB, DV&D Antonio Chuh, MD, FRCPE, FRCPI Nashik, India and Shatin, Hong Kong References 1 Tan SK, Sim CS, Goh CL. Hydroquinone-induced exogenous ochronosis in Chinese – two case reports and a review. Int J Dermatol 2008; 47: 639–640. 2 Zawar VP, Mhaskar ST. Exogenous ochronosis following hydroquinone for melasma. J Cosmet Dermatol 2004; 3: 234–236. the publication of our article, suggesting that the condition may be much more common than realized. S. K. Tan, MD, FAAD Singapore References 1 Tan SK, Sim CS, Goh CL. Hydroquinone-induced exogenous ochronosis in Chinese — two case reports and a review. Int J Dermatol 2008; 47: 639–640. 2 Preya K, Suwirakorn O, Suwit S. Exogenous ochronosis and pigmented colloid milium induced by bleaching skin cream. Environ Dermatol 1998; 5: 20–25. International Journal of Dermatology 2010, 49, 101–110 101