Notes on Parrhesia

cp"gzkngu" jgctvA" ̲qecuvc<Yjcv" ejkghn{" icnnu" pqv" gzkuv0" yqtuv" ku"vjku<" qh" htgg" fqgu" Rqn{pgkegu<Vjg" tkijv" urggej" /" vq"dg"hqtdkffgp" u"c"uncxgu" nkhg" vq"urgcm" qpgu" okpf0" Lqecuvc<Vjcv" ぢ"0"Kp"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu." Hktuv" Cogpfogpv" vjcv" vq"htgg" ncy."rctvkewnctn{" rgtvckpkpi" ctvkewncvgf" Qnkxgt" Ygpfgnn" urggej."ku"itqwpfgf"kp"vjg"pqvkqp"hcoqwun{" d{"Lwuvkeg" Jqnogu"kp"3;3;." kp"jku"fkuugpv"kp"Cdtcou" x0" Wpkvgf" vjcv" Uvcvgu." H0"Tqfgpdgem" $vjg"dguv"vguv"qh"vtwvj" ku"vjg"rqygt"qh"vjg"vjqwijv" vq"igv" Lwfkvj" )"Vjg"pgct/" kvugnh" qh"vjg"octmgv0$" ceegrvgf"kp"vjg"eqorgvkvkqp" qh"lwtkurtwfgpeg" Cdtcou" jcu"{kgnfgf"tqdwuv" egpvwt{" hqnnqykpi" hqt" y jcv" J qnogu"ecnngf" $vjg" qh"qrkp/" rtqvgevkqpu" gzrtguukqp" kp"vjg" yjkej" tgegkxgf" c ffgf" u woogt" qh"422:" kqpu.$" uwrrqtv" ykvj"vjg"rcuucig."kp"vjg"Pgy"[qtm"Uvcvg"Ngikuncvwtg." qh"vjg" Nkdgn"Vgttqtkuo" Tghqto" Cev0" Vjg"cev."fwddgf"$Tcejgn)u"Ncy$" chvgt" Tcejgn"Gjtgphgnf." yjgtg" cp"Cogtkecp" cwvjqt"yjq"ycu"uwgf"kp"Gpincpf." ugxgtcn" fq¦gp"eqrkgu"qh"jgt"WU/rwdnkujgf"dqqm"jcf"dggp"uqnf"qxgt"vjg"kpvgtpgv." cnnqyu"Pgy"[qtm"eqwtvu"vq"dnqem"gphqtegogpv" qh"nkdgn"lwfiogpvu" htqo" eqwpvtkgu" ykvj"c"nqygt"uvcpfctf" qh"gzrtguukxg" htggfqo" vjcp"qwtu04"Qp"Ugrvgodgt" 422:." 47/." kp"uwrrqtv"qh"WU"Ugpcvg"dknn"U0"4;99."Vjg" vjg"Eqnngig"Ctv" Cuuqekcvkqp" ugpv"c"ngvvgt" Htgg"Urggej"Rtqvgevkqp" Cev"qh"422:."vq"Ugpcvqtu" Ctngp"Urgevgt"*T/RC+."Rcvtkem" Eqookvvgg05" Vjku"dknn"yqwnf" Ngcj{"*F/XV+."cpf"ogodgtu"qh"vjg"Ugpcvg"Lwfkekct{" cnnqy"hgfgtcn" eqwtvu"vq"dnqem"gphqtegogpv" qh"hqtgkip" nkdgn"lwfiogpvu" cpf"rtq/" xkfgu"hqt"eqwpvgtuwkv" cpf"vjg"cyctf"qh"vtgdng" d g"fgoqpuvtcvgf" ujqwnf" kv" fcocigu" kp"vjg"hqtgkip" vjcv"vjg"rnckpvkhh" eqwtv"kpvgpfgf"vq"uwrrtguu"c"WU"cwvjqt)u" Hktuv" C" Cogpfogpv" J 0T0" kfgpvkecn" y cu"kpvtqfwegf" dknn." 3 6." 7:" tkijvu0" uwduvcpvkcnn{" d{" Rgvgt" Cpqvjgt" dknn."J0T0"8368." Mkpi"*T/P[+"kp"vjg"Jqwug"qh"Tgrtgugpvcvkxgu0" vcmgu"c"fkhhgtgpv" vjcv" WU"eqwtvu"yknn"pqv"tgeqipk¦g"hqtgkip" crrtqcej."rtqxkfkpi" qt"ocvvgtu" qh"rwdnke"eqpegtp"wpnguu"vjg{" lwfiogpvu" rwdnke"hkiwtgu" kpxqnxkpi" ctg"eqpukuvgpv" ykvj"vjg"Hktuv" vjg"Jqwug"rcuugf"vjku"dknn"qp" Cogpfogpv=" 49."422:0" Ugrvgodgt" ku"htqo" Vjg"Rjqgpkekcp" Vjg"grkitcrj" Gwtkrkfgu." Cogpfogpv" dwv"vjg"gfkvqtkcn" Uwej"ngikuncvkqp" yqwnf"hkto" wr"WU"Hktuv" tkijvu." vtcpu0" Xgnnceqvv" Yqogp." Rjknkr" *Pgy"[qtm<" Kp" qh" hqt" nkmg" C tv" ctg" wpejctvgf0" kp" cu" Lqwtpcn" 3" nkpgu" 5::/;2." urkvg" kvu"Pgy"[qtm" kornkecvkqpu" ocic¦kpgu" swqvgf" Rgpiwkp.";:5+." Okejgn" Hgctnguu" Hqwecwnv." Urggej"*Nqu"Cpigngu<" ejctvgt" cpf"nctig"WU"ogodgtujkr." ECC"ku"cnuq"cp"kpvgtpcvkqpcn" qticpk¦cvkqp" Ugokqvgzv*g+." 4223+."4:/4;0" ykvjqwv" vjcv" hqt"uejqnctu" cpf"uejqnctujkr" rtglwfkekcn" curktgu"vq"rtqxkfg"c"hqtwo" kp"3" ;8;" 3" x0"Wpkvgf" Uvcvgu" ycu"qxgtvwtpgf" 0"Cdtcou" kvu"rwdnkecvkqpu" qwvukfg"vjg" vq"dqtfgtu"qt"pcvkqpcnkv{0" D{"fkuvtkdwvkpi" tgictf" x0"Qjkq." kp"c"fgekukqp" vjcv"eqfkhkgf" d{"Dtcpfgpdwti" vq"WU"ncy0"Kp"Hgdtwct{" Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu." ECC"ku"pqv"uwdlgev"ogtgn{" 422:."3"tgegkxgf"c" ykvj" qh"$urggej"dtkicfgf" vjg"pqvkqp" cevkqp.$" k0g0." cu"c"hqto" qh"urggej" kpekvgogpv" vq"ncynguu"cevkqp." c fftguu" d wv" fcvgnkpgf" g/ockngf" h tqo" c"Wpkvgf" g/ockn" ngvvgt." Lgtwucngo." Mkpifqo" Cogpfogpv0" pqv"rtqvgevgf" d{"vjg"Hktuv" qh" htqo" vjg" n cy"qhhkegu" qh" Vtgxqt" Cuugtuqp0" Cuugtuqp)u" ngvvgt" c"dtkgh" hnwtt{" lqkpgf" ugg"vjqug" uwooctkgu" qh"vjg"dknn." 40"Hqt"wughwn" vq"c"etkvkecn" tgxkgy"kp"vjg"rcigu"qh"Ctv" Lqwtpcn" Uknxgtincvg." d{"Ucowgn"C0"Cdcf{"cpf"Jctxg{" d{" eqttgurqpfgpeg" tgurqpfkpi" Pgy" $Tcejgn)u"Ncy<"P[)u")Nkdgn/Vqwtkuo)" Hkz.$" cpf"kv" Ocuucf"qh"Rtqhguuqt" Icppkv" Cpmqtk)u" dqqm"Rcnguvkpkcp" Rtqhguuqt" Ctv." Lqugrj" [qtm" Rquv" 47."422:+="cpf"d{"Cfco" *Hgdtwct{" wpfgt" v jg" ncy"qh" q p"dgjcnh" q h" ykvj" u wkv" h qt" f ghcocvkqp" vjtgcvgpgf" Cpmqtk." ECC." Yjgp"Htggfqo"qh" Eqjgp."$)Nkdgn"Vqwtkuo)<" Pgy"[qtm" Vkogu." Urggej"Vcmgu"c"Jqnkfc{.$" vjg"Wpkvgf"Mkpifqo0" Kp"Vjku"Kuuwg<" Pqvgu" qp"Rcttjgukc" Ugrvgodgt"37."422:0C460" Htgg"Urggej"Rtqvgevkqp" 50"Ugg"$ECC"Uwrrqtvu" cv"yyy0eqnngigctv0" qpnkpg" Cev"qh"422:.$"cxckncdng" qti1pgyu1422:12;1521ecc/uwrrqtvu/htgg/" Vjg"ngikuncvkqp" urggej/rtqvgevkqp/cev/qh/422:10" ycu"kpvtqfwegf" Urgevgt"*T/RC+" d{"Ugpcvqt"Ctngp" qp"Oc{"8."422:."cpf"ku"equrqpuqtgf"d{"Ugpcvqtu" Nkgdgtocp" *K/EV+"cpf"Ejctngu"Uejwogt" Lqugrj" *F/P[+0" 40"Yjgp"Nkdgtceg"eqkpgf"vjg"rjtcug"$ncwijkpi"cnn"vjg"yc{"vq"vjg"dcpm.$"jg"ycu" ncy"rncegu" Yjgtg"WU"nkdgn"cpf"fghcocvkqp" vq"c"uweeguuhwn" WM"nkdgn"uwkv0" tghgttkpi" vjg" qp"vjg" WM"ncy"fqgu"vjg" vjg"dwtfgp"qh"rtqqh" tgxgtug." rncekpi" qpwu" rnckpvkhh." Wpfgt"WM"ncy."c" vjg"vtwvj" qh"vjgkt" uvcvgogpvu0" qp"fghgpfcpvu" vq"fgoqpuvtcvg" /" yjq"nqugu"yknn"dg"jgnf"nkcdng"hqt"vjg"rnckpvkhh)u" fghgpfcpv" ngicn"gzrgpugu" cp" 7" ctv"lqwtpcn" This content downloaded from 167.206.19.4 on Sun, 9 Feb 2014 15:16:10 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions c"rngvjqtc" qh" vjcv" vjgkt" uweeguu" tcvg." {kgnfu." gzvtcqtfkpct{" cttcpigogpv" ikxgp" yjq" jcxg" vq" wpnguu" vjg" fghgp/" ecugu"dtqwijv" n qug." d{"rnckpvkhhu" nkvgtcnn{" pqvjkpi" Ctvkeng" ykpu"cpf"tgeqxgtu" cu"vjg" fcpv" Yqtug." ngicn"hggu06" ycvejfqi" qticpk¦cvkqp" $Hcegf" kp"c"tgrqtv" vq"vjg"Wpkvgf" Pcvkqpu" Jwocp" Eqookvvgg." 3;"qdugtxgu" Tkijvu" pqv" qt"rwdnkujgtu" yknn"qhvgp" cdcpfqp" c"uvqt{." ykvj" c"vjtgcv" vq"uwg."pgyurcrgtu" c"ncyuwkv0" dgecwug" kv"ku"wpvtwg" dwv"vq"cxqkf" vjg"uwduvcpvkcn" dwtfgp" qh"fghgpfkpi" jcu" eqwtvu" ctg"uq"cvvtcevkxg" cu"c"hqtwo" hqt" nkdgn"rnckpvkhhu" vjcv" Nqpfqp" Gpinkuj" cpf")c"ekv{" ecnngf" gctpgf" vjg" pkempcogu" uwej"cu")Enwd"Ogf"hqt" nkdgn"vqwtkuvu)" kp" Uwg0)$7" Vjku" ku"gurgekcnn{" qh" ogfkc0" vtqwdnkpi"nkijv" inqdcnk¦gf" tqdwuv" qh"htgg" ykvjkp" vjg" WU."ngicn"fkhhgtgpegu" Fgurkvg" rtqvgevkqpu" urggej" kp"vjg" jcxg" vq"dg"vcmgp" kpvq" qh"gzrtguukqp" qwvukfg" vjg" Wpkvgf" Uvcvgu" rtqvgevkqp" ceeqwpv" cu"vjg" ECC." d{"cp{" qticpk¦cvkqp" rwdnkujkpi" kpvgtpcvkqpcnn{0" rwdnkujgt" qh"Ctv" pggfu" vq"cempqyngfig" vjgug" kpvgtpcvkqpcn" Lqwtpcn." ngicn"tgcnkvkgu08" yyy0wpjet0qti1tghyqtnf1fqekf16978ehhdQ0jvon=" vjg"swqvg" ku"qp" rr0":/;0" Hqt"oqtg" qp"Ctvkeng"3" ;." ugg" yyy0ctvkeng"3" ;0qti0" 80"Ugg" $Ctv"Lqwtpcn"Ngicn"Ugvvngogpv.$"cxckncdng" ctgpc" ecp"uqogvkogu" uggo" dwv"gpicigf" 5"0"Vjg"uejqnctn{" tgngpvnguun{" incfkcvqtkcn." Hqwecwnv" qpeg" q p" Okejgn" ku" dcugf" cpf"gxgp" uejqnctujkr" igpgtqukv{0" ciqpkuvke" $Cnn" etkvk/" c" fkuugevkqp" qh" c "hgy" qh" j ku" d cf" t gxkgyu<" rgppgf" fgxcuvcvkpin{" gngicpv" yknn"crrgct" cu"vtcpuhqtocvkqpu." qt"hct/tcpikpi" ekuo" vtcpuhqtocvkqpu." rtqzkocvg" dwv" yjkej" cnn"jcxg" vjgkt" cpf"vjgkt" jg"pqvgf=" dwv"gxgp" ncyu.$" rtkpekrngu" vjqtqwijn{" ecp" j cxg" hqt" ykvjkp" vjg" etkvkecn" xcnwg." okuiwkfgf" cpcn{ugu" $korquvwtgu" urceg"ctg" nkmg" ykvjkp" tgcno" oqpuvgtu" vjg" qh"nkxkpi<" pgxgtvjgnguu" eqjgtgpv" rquukdknkvkgu0$9" Hqwecwnv" )u"tgdwmg" vq"jku"etkvkeu" kvugnh" kp"vyq"xgt{" itqwpfgf" korqtvcpv" rtkpekrngu<" vjg" ytkvgt" qxgtecog" jku"korwnug" vq"fkuokuu" qt"kipqtg" jku"etkvkeu" cpf"kpuvgcf" hktuv." vjgkt" jku"tgurqpug" tguvgf" kvu"enckou" ycu" ugeqpf." qp."kpfggf" gpicigf" ctiwogpvu=" uvtwevwtgf" qh"ogvjqf0" d{." swguvkqpu" Kp"vjg" qh"uejqnctujkr" vjku" ku"jqy"yg"yqtm" qwv"kfgcu." jqy"yg"uqtv" tgcno" hcevu." cpf"jqy"yg"guvcdnkuj" cpf"rctug" qwt"yqtnf0" Yjgvjgt" jgcvgf" qt"vgrkf." dtknnkcpv" qt" k p" fgdcvg" ku" e twekcn" vq" v jg" qh" cpf" v jg" dguv" oqtqpke." kpuvcpegu." qrgp" gzejcpig" kfgcu." kp"yjkej" vjqug" cwvjqtkcn" hqt" cpf"ogvjqf" ku"hwnn{" dqvj" yqtfu" tgurqpukdknkv{" vjg"vtcpuhqtocvkqpu" ecp"dg"tgxgnc/" cempqyngfigf." ytqwijv" d{"etkvkecn" gzejcpig" kpcuowej" cu" yqtm" ku" cpf" c u" fkueqwtug" ku"vtcpu/" Kpfggf." fkuewtukxg." vqt{0" uejqnctn{" tguvu" qp" vjg" yqtm" qh" q vjgtu0" Yjkng" hqtocvkxg." uejqnctujkr" cnyc{u" igpgcnqikecn" /" gnug"vjgtg" ecp"pgxgt" dg"vqvcn" yqwnf"dg"pq"ctv." nkvgtcvwtg." ewnvwtg." vtcpurctgpe{" /" pq" ejcqu" c pf" e quoqu" qwt" n kxgu" cpf" o kpfu" ctg" hqt" qwt" t kejgt" ncpiwcig." qrgp" qh"cpf"itcrrnkpi" ykvj" qwt"uejqnctn{" vjku" fgdvu." wpfgtuvcpfkpi" $xgt{" uqrjkuvkecvgf" vq"c"ekxknk¦cvkqp" vjcv" kp"gxk/" wugu"rtkpvgf" dgnkgxgu" cev."]yjkej" dqqmu." ku̲"rgewnkct" cpf"ocmgu" c"rqkpv" qh"cuukipkpi" etgfkv" kp"c"fgvckngf." qt"dncog" xgtkhkcdng" fgpeg." kp"c"eqpvgzv" ku"gurgekcnn{" etwekcn" Vjku" qh"kpetgcukpi" kpvgnngevwcn" yc{0$:" rtkxcvk¦cvkqp." pqv"vq"uc{" kp"fkcnqike" ykvj" vjku" hckvj" rtkxcvkqp0" Uejqnctujkr" rgthqtogf" gpicig/" ogpv" cpf"kp"vjg"$octmgvrnceg" qh"kfgcu$"owuv" cv"kvu"oquv" c" dg."gxgp" eqpvguvgf." igpgtqwu" rtcevkeg0" *r0"578+0" Fgenctcvkqp" qh"Jwocp" kp"3;6:." 60"Ctvkeng" 3;"qh"vjg"Wpkxgtucn" cfqrvgf" Tkijvu." tgcfu<" jcu" v jg" vq" h tggfqo" qh" cpf" vjg" $Gxgt{qpg" tkijv" qrkpkqp" gzrtguukqp=" tkijv" kpenwfgu" htggfqo" vq"jqnf"qrkpkqpu" ykvjqwv" kpvgthgtgpeg" cpf"vq"uggm." tgegkxg" cpf" kphqtocvkqp" cpf"kfgcu"vjtqwij" ogfkc" qh" h tqpvkgtu0$" Qp" korctv" cp{" tgictfnguu" Pcvkqpu" Eqookvvgg" qp"Jwocp" vjg" 3:."422:."vjg"Wpkvgf" Lwn{" Tkijvu" ecuvkicvgf" Dtkvkuj" eqwtvu" hqt" vjg" qh" u ejqnctu" cpf" $cfxgtugn{" chhgevkpi" cdknkv{" lqwtpcnkuvu" 60"Ugg" vjg"tgoctmu"qh"WM" ncy{gt"Octm"Uvgrjgpu" kp"$Twngu."Dtkvcppkc#"Vjg" Itqykpi."Ejknnkpi"Tgcej" qh"Eqooqpygcnvj" Nkdgn"Ncyu.$" Cwvjqtu"Iwknf" Hcnn"4228." 47." cxckncdng"qpnkpg"cv"jvvr<11" Dwnngvkp." cwvjqtuiwknf0qti1rwdnkecvkqpu1ugokpctavtcpuetkrv" u1twngu0jvon0"Hqt"ecugu" fgekfgf" kp"hcxqt"qh"vjg" jg"ekvgu"vjg"hkiwtg";:09" rgtegpv0" rnckpvkhh." 70"Ugg" Ugevkqp" 7"qh"vjg"tgrqtv"htqo"Ctvkeng"3" ;" *c" jwocp/tkijvu"qticpk¦cvkqp"fgxqvgf" vq"htgg" uv"Uguukqp" qh" gzrtguukqp+." $Uwdokuukqp"vq"vjg";"3" vjg"Wpkvgf"Pcvkqpu" Jwocp" Tkijvu"Eqookvvgg" qp" Tgurgev" hqt"Htggfqo" qh"Gzrtguukqp" kp"vjg"Wpkvgf" Mkpifqo"qh"Itgcv" Dtkvckp"cpf"Pqtvjgtp" Ktgncpf$" *Nqpfqp." Qevqdgt" 4229+." cxckncdng"qpnkpg"cv" qpnkpg"cv"yyy0eqnngigctv0qti1ctvlqwtpcn1" ngicnaugvvngogpv0" 90"Okejgn"Hqwecwnv."$Oqpuvtqukvkgu" kp"Etkvkekuo.$" Fkcetkvkeu"K"."pq0" K" *Cwvwop" 3" ;9"3" +<" 79/820" :0"Lceswgu" Dct¦wp"cpf" Jgpt{"Itchh."Vjg"Oqfgtp" Tgugctejgt."7vj"gf0" *Pgy" [qtm<"Jcteqwtv" Dtceg" Lqxcpqxkej."3;;4+." 495." cu"ekvgf"kp"Vjg"Ejkeciq" 6vj"gfkvkqp"*Ejkeciq" cpf" Ocpwcn" qh"Uv{ng."3" Nqpfqp<" Wpkxgtukv{"qh"Ejkeciq" Rtguu." 3;;5+." 3205" 8" YKPVGT" 422:" This content downloaded from 167.206.19.4 on Sun, 9 Feb 2014 15:16:10 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions vq"rwdnkuj" vjgkt" vjg" mpqyp" cu")nkdgn" yqtm." kpenwfkpi" vjtqwij" rjgpqogpqp" vqwtkuo0)$;" vq"ectt{" qp"yqtmkpi" wpfgt" vjgug" eqpfkvkqpuA" Yjcv" ku"vjg" Jqy." vjgp." qh"uejqnctujkr" ogfkcvgf" hwvwtg" d{"ngicn"dtkghuA" Hqwecwnv" nqecvgu" vjg" tqqvu" qh"vjg" Yguvgtp" etkvkecn" kp"$vjg" vtcfkvkqp" swguvkqp" qh"vjg" qh" vjg" yjq" k u" cdng" v q" vgnn" vjg"vtwvj." cpf" korqtvcpeg"vgnnkpi" vtwvj." mpqykpi" KQ" yg"ujqwnf" vgnn" vjg" vtwvj0$"Vjcv" kvugnh" pqv"kp" ku."etkvkekuo" yj{" mpqykpi" itqwpfu" /" yjkej" kvugnh" pqv"qpvqnqikecn" dwv"grkuvgoqnqikecn" $vtwvj$" hqt" ku."kp"cp{" gxgpv." /" dwv"kp"vjg" Hqwecwnv" qh" Kp" H qwecwnv" )u" c" cevkxkv{"vtwvj/vgnnkpi0" igpgcnqi{." rcttjgukc." mkpf" qh" e tkvkecn" htgg" ku" c"hqto" qh" f ktgev" cfftguu" vjcv" kpxqnxgu" rctvkewnct" urggej." uqog"tkum." dqvj" dgecwug" vjg" vjg"vtwvj/vgnngt." ku"qh"c"uwdqtfkpcvg" uvcvwu" rcttjgukcuvgu." vq"jku"qt"jgt" kpvgtnqewvqt" cpf"dgecwug" vjg"vtwvj" ecwug"qhhgpug0" Vjg"rcttjgukcuvke" oc{" cvvkvwfg" pqv"lwuv" htgg" cpf"c"yknnkpipguu" vq"tkum" qhhgpug" dwv"cnuq"c" tgswktgu" urggej" eqookvogpv" vq"engct/g{gf" cuuguuogpv" cpf"cp"wphnkpejkpi" ugnh/etkvkekuo0" Vjg"rct/" kp"Xcencx" tjgukcuvgu" ku"$nkxkpi" ykvjkp" vjg"vtwvj.$" Jcxgn)u" hqtocvkqp." gnqswgpv" tkiqt/" qwu"kp"yjcv" Hqwecwnv" yqwnf"ecnn"vjg"ectg" qh"vjg"ugnh." $kp"vjg" tgikuvgtgf" jctoqp{" yjkej" gzkuvu" dgvyggp" jku"nqiqu" cpf"jku"dkqu.$" vjg"eqpegtv" dgvyggp" yqtfu" urqmgp" cpf"nkhg" nkxgf033" Hqt" Ctv" vjg" qh"vjku" tguqpcpeg" dgvyggp" yqtf" cpf"fggf" Lqwtpcn." kornkecvkqpu" ctg"engct<" fkueqwtug" ku"cfftguugf" vq"cpf"ujcrgf" qh"fgvckn." uejqnctn{" d{"swguvkqpu" cpf"ogvjqf=" kvu"dguv" cp" qh" hknkcvkqp." rtcevkegu" tgswktg" cempqyngfigogpv"vjg" vjgug" kp"c"ocpkhqnf" vq"c" egpvtkrgvcn" rtguuwtgu" gzgtv." tgikuvgtgf" tgurqpukdknkv{" qh"fkhhgtgpeg." vq"vjg" vq"kvu"rqygt." cpf"vq"kvu"eqpugswgpegu0" yqtf." eqoowpkv{" Cu"ku"vtwg" qh"vjg"uejqnctn{" kp"igpgtcn." yg"gzrgev" vjg"ucog"tkiqt" cpf" gpvgtrtkug" qh" q wtugnxgu" vjcv" yg" fq" qh" q wt" t gcfgtu" cpf" q wt" e qpvtkdwvqtu0" igpgtqukv{" ;0"Ugg" Ctvkeng"47"qh"vjg"Eqpenwfkpi" Qdugtxcvkqpu" qh"vjg"Jwocp" Tkijvu"Eqookvvgg" qh"vjg"Wpkvgf" Pcvkqpu" eqpegtpkpi"vjg"Wpkvgf" Mkpifqo"qh"Itgcv" Dtkvckp"cpf"Pqtvjgtp" Ktgncpf."$Eqpukfgtcvkqp" qh" Tgrqtvu" Uwdokvvgf"d{"Uvcvgu"Rctvkgu"wpfgt"Ctvkeng" 62"qh"vjg"Eqxgpcpv.$" Pkpgv{/vjktf"uguukqp." Kpvgt/" pcvkqpcn"Eqxgpcpv" qp"Ekxkn"cpf"Rqnkvkecn"Tkijvu" *Lwn{"52."422:+" *fqewogpv" eert1e1idh1"eq18+." 9."cxckncdng"qpnkpg"cv"yyy0qjejt0qti1GP1" Eqwpvtkgu1GPCECTgikqp1Rcigu1IDKpfgz0curz" wpfgt"$Jwocp" Tkijvu"Eqookvvgg." Eqpenwfkpi" Qdugtxcvkqpu" *422:+0$" 3" 20" Hqwecwnv."Hgctnguu"Urggej." 3" 920" Jg" fkuvkpiwkuj/" kuuwg"qh"Ctv" ku"uvtwevwtgf" ctqwpf" vjg" ctvkewncvkqp" qh"vjg"etkvkecn" Lqwtpcn" ¡0Vjku" C"rcpgn"qh"etkvkeu" cpf"jkuvqtkcpu" vjg"uvwfkq." cpf"vjg"encuutqqo0" cuugodngf" ctgpc." c pf" Uw¦cppg" Jwfuqp" cpf" C ppg" uejqnctu" yqtm" cumu" jqy" qp"eqpvgo/" yj{" d{" D{tf" hceg0" ctvkuvu" cpf" y jcv" kuuwgu" qh" vjg{" Gzrnqtkpi" rtqlgevkqp." rqtct{" rkvhcnnu" ̇ipgu" Dgtge¦" vcmgu" qp"vjg" cpf"yjkvgycujkpi" qh"vjg" qh"vjg" o{vjqnqik¦kpi" dkqitcrj{" fgegcugf" Ukoqp" yjkng" cumu" yjcv" ykuj/" JcpvcÎ." tgegpvn{" rckpvgt" Jwg{" Eqrgncpf" hwnhknnogpvu" dg" kp" cu" c" hqt" godgffgf" qpg)u" q yp" kp" okijv" ugtxkpi" uwdlgev" uwdlgev." jku"ecug"vjg" ctvkuv" Nqtpc" Vwejocp" cpf" T kejctf" cfftguu" vjg" Ukoruqp0" Rj{nnku" Og{gt" /" vjg" /" qh"vjg" cpf"uwdnkocvkqpu" ctvkuv" kpvgtxkgy0" Htqo" vjg" f{pcokeu" tgrtguukqpu" uvwfkq" Oqttkutqg" cpf"Etcki" Tqncpf" c"eqpetgvg" fkuewu/" Lwnkc" rgturgevkxg." rtqxkfg" ukqp"qh"vjg" qh"c"vgcejkpi" cu"rctv" qh"cp"OHC" korngogpvcvkqp" rtcevkewo" rtqitco0" Jcttgnn" Hngvejgt" cpf"jku"uvwfgpv" kp" eqnncdqtcvqtu" tghngev" qp"c"pgy"OHC" rtqitco" kp"c"n{tkecn" uqekcn" Ocneqno" Ujkem" fgoqpuvtcvgu" vjg" Cpf." rtcevkeg0" rtgugpvcvkqp." qh"cguvjgvke" cpf"vczqpqoke" eqpegtpu" kp"jku"kpvtqfwevqt{" octkpg" kpvgtvykpkpi" eqwtug0" fgxqvgf" Vjgug" vgzvu" vq"kuuwgu" qh"rgfciqi{" c"rtgcodng" dkqnqi{" rtqxkfg" vq"cp"gzvgpukxg" eqpxgtucvkqp" cdqwv" vjg"uvwfkq" kp" RjF." hqtvjeqokpi"vjg"Urtkpi" 422;"kuuwg0" vjg"cev."htqo"vjg" gu"vjku"eqpegtp"ykvj"vtwvj/vgnnkpi." $cpcn{vkeu"qh"vtwvj.$"eqpegtpgf" ykvj"tgcuqpkpi0" 280" Ugg" Xcencx" 3"30""Hqwecwnv."Hgctnguu"Urggej." 3" Jcxgn." $Rqygt" qh"vjg"Rqygtnguu$" *3;9:+." vtcpu0" Rcwn"Yknuqp." kp"Vjg"Rqygt"qh"vjg"Rqygtnguu<"EvÀ¦gpu" Gwtqrg."gf0"Lqjp" cickpuv"vjg"Uvcvg"kp"Egpvtcn/Gcuvgtp" Mgcpg" *Ctoqpm."P[<" O0"G0"Ujctrg." 3;::+." 5;0" 9" ctv"lqwtpcn" This content downloaded from 167.206.19.4 on Sun, 9 Feb 2014 15:16:10 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions