Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Hormones and Behaviour

1949, BMJ

Malaria was the chief disease, being highly endemic, and it therefore received first attention. But filariasis was also important and the appearance of yellow fever always a possibility, so that operations included action against C. fatigans and Aedes aegypti. It is interesting to note that the use of D.D.T. is far from being a purely routine matter with no call on the results of research, and the author expressly notes, if success is to be attained, the absolute necessity of close research into the habits of the adult, just as antilarval operations require research into the selective breeding habits of the different species. S. R. CHRISTOPHERS. PREFERENCE JUDGMENTS Evperinentelle Triebdiagniostik (Experimental Diagnosis of Imitpulsive Disorders). By L. Szondi. lPp. 308. 68 Swiss francs.

484 MARCH 19, 1949 REVIEWS Malaria was the chief disease, being highly endemic, and it therefore received first attention. But filariasis was also important and the appearance of yellow fever always a possibility, so that operations included action against C. fatigans and Aedes aegypti. It is interesting to note that the use of D.D.T. is far from being a purely routine matter with no call on the results of research, and the author expressly notes, if success is to be attained, the absolute necessity of close research into the habits of the adult, just as antilarval operations require research into the selective breeding habits of the different species. S. R. CHRISTOPHERS. PREFERENCE JUDGMENTS Evperinentelle Triebdiagniostik (Experimental Diagnosis of Imitpulsive Disorders). By L. Szondi. lPp. 308. 68 Swiss francs.) Berne: Medizinischer Verlag Hans Huber. The author of this somewhat formidable work is concerned to introduce a new psychodiagnostic method, obviously inspired by the Rorschach technique. The material consists of six sets of eight full-face photographs of various types of psychopathic individual, and is provided with the volume. Each set is presented in turn to the subject, who is required to indicate which of the individuals portrayed he finds most attractive and which most distasteful. The preference judgments thus obtained are recorded as a profile from which, it is claimed, certain concltisions of psychodiagnostic import can be drawn. The bulk of the volume consists in a description of the profiles made by a variety of psychotic and psychoneurotic individuals and an attempt to interpret them in the light of the author's reading of contemporary psychopathology. It appears rather unlikely that Dr. Szondi's method will commend itself to clinical psychologists in this country. Although the analysis of preference judgments is a matter of some psychological interest, especially in so far as it may furnish a clue to the operation of deep-seated unconscious tendencies, the existing findings are too slight to justify the elaborate interpretations which Dr. Szondi puts on them. His test photographs, too, are so antiquated and repellent as to deter all but the most hardy and humourless of psychometrists. From the theoretical standpoint, the book appears to contribute little that is new to our understanding of personality, normal or deranged. It is turgid, verbose, and representative of the worst aspects of neo-Freudian psychopathology. One may fervently hope that the " Szondi test " will not beconme the focus of yet another esoteric cult in the psychological fraternity. 0. L. ZANIGWILL. MEDICAL JOURNAL BOOKS RECEIVED here of books recently receivedl Essen unid Wissen. By H. Bircher-Rey. 2nd ed. (Pp. 203. No price.) Zurich: Rascher. 1948. A book on dietetics intended for laymen as well as medical men. [Review is not precluded by niotice Histopathology of the Peripheral and Central Nervous Systems. Chicago: By G. B. Hassin, M.D. 3rd ed. revised. (Pp. 612. $8.50.) The Author. 1948. A textbook wits illustrations and extensive bibliographies. By E. Libman, M.D.. and Subacute Bacterial Endocarditis. C. K. Friedberg, M.D. 2nd ed. (Pp. 113. 21s.) New York and London: Geolfey Cumberlege. 1948. A review in the light of recent knowledge; reprinted from the Oxford Loose-Leaf Medicine. Change of Life in Women. By Medica. (Pp. 76. 5s.) London: Delisle, Ltd. i 1948. A simply written account for women by a medical practitioner. A Surgeon's Domain. By B. M. Bernheim, M.D. (Pp. 217. 9s. 6d.) Kingswood, Surrey: The World's Work (1913), Ltd. 1949. Reminiscences and opinions of the Associate Professor of Surgery at Johns Hopkins Medical School. Zinzc Ions in Ear, Nose, and Throat Work. By A. R. Friel, M.D., F.R.C.S.I. (Pp. 59. 5s. 6d.) Bristol: John Wright. London: Simpkin Marshall. 1948. An account of zinc electrolysis and ionization. Children in Need. By M. Schmideberg, M.D. (Pp. 196. 12s. 6d.) London: George Allen and Unwin. 1948. The author describes psychiatric and social methods of treating difficult children and their parents. The Structure of Medicine and its Place Among the Sciences. By F. M. R. Walshe, M.D., D.Sc., F.R.C.P., F.R.S. (Pp. 26. ls. 6d.) Edinburgh: E. and S. Livingstone. 1948. The 1948 Harveian Oration. Handbook of Surgery. By E. C. Mekie, M.B., Ch.B., F.R.C.S.Ed., F.I.C.S., and I. Mackenzie, M.B.E., M.B., Ch.B., F.R.C.S.Ed. 2nd ed. (Pp. 764. 20s.) Edinburgh: E. and S. Livingstone. 1949. Intended particularly for medical students; the text has been extensively revised for this edition. The Scotsman's Food. By A. H. Kitchin, M.B., and R. Passmore, M.A., D.M., F.R.S.Ed. (Pp. 86. 3s. 6d.) Edinburgh: E. and S. Livingstone. 1949. HORMONES AND BEHAVIOUR A historical introduction to modern food administration. Hormones and Behaviour. A Survey of Interrelationships Psychological Medicine. By D. Curran, M.B., F.R.C.P., D.P.M., between Endocrine Secretions and Patternis of Overt Response. By Frank A. Beach. Foreword by Earl T. Engle. (Pp. 368. and the late E. Guttmann, M.D., M.R.C.P. 3rd ed. (Pp. 249. $6.50.) New York: Paul B. Hoeber, Inc. London: Hamish 12s. 6d.) Edinburgh: E. and S. Livingstone. 1949. Hamilton. 1948. A practical guide for the non-specialist. The author of this painstaking book gathers into one voilume By A. Nelson, B.Sc., Ph.D., D.Sc. an almost staggering amount of information about the effects Introductory Botany. of the endocrine glands on the behaviour of fishes, amphibia, (Pp. 479. 22s. 6d.) Edinburgh: E. and S. Livingstone. 1949. reptiles, birds, the lower mammals, and the primates, inclhding A textbook for medical students. man. If the last receives less attention than he himself would Birth. By A. F. Guttmacher, M.D. consider to be his fair share, that is his own fault in failing The Story of Huuman to control scientifically his experiments on himself and in (Pp. 201. 7s. 6d.) London: Sigma Books. 1949. degrading too often the proper study recommended by Pope An account for the layman. into an improper study. Courtship, mating, bisexuality, oviMetabolism. By M. Stephenson, Sc.D., F.R.S. 3rd ed. position, parturition, parenjal behaviour, migration, aggression, Bacterial 30s.) London: Longmans, Green and Co. 1949. 398. (Pp. territorial defence, the ac4bisitlon of learning, metamorphosis, of the essential chemical processes accompanying the A description metabolism, are all fully considered-considered but not discussed, for the weakness of the bbok lies in its paucity of life of bacteria. (Dr. Stephenson died in December,' 1948.) critical discussion of the results reported. Neurological Anatomy in Relation to Clinical Medicine. But if we are inclined to condemn this book as a scissors- By A. Brodal. (Pp. 496. 42s.) Oxford: Geoffrey Cumberlege. and-paste compilation we have at once the author's reply 1948. " Most books, it seems to me, develop in one of two ways . . . A textbook for clinical neurologists by the Prosector of Anatomy, the second type . . . has a well-defined function to fulfil. Oslo University. Its role is not the exposition of a thesis, but the supplying Swire, S.R.N., of a body of facts and references. It is not a living organism A Handbookfor the Assistant Nurse. By M. E. but an inanimate tool- and as a tool it may play a useful and S.C.M. (Pp. 308. 10s. 6d.) London: Bailli6re, Tindall and Cox. 1949. important part." Not "may "-" will." A textbook intended to cover the syllabus for assistant nurses. RAYMOND GREENE.