Reviews
New Book Chronicle
Robert Witcher
Colonialism in the Americas
STEVEN A. WERNKE. Negotiated communities and
landscapes under Inka and Spanish colonialism.
xix+371 pages, 113 b&w illustrations, 20 tables.
2013. Gainesville: University Press of Florida; 9780-8130-4249-7 hardback $79.95.
CLAY MATHERS, JEFFREY M. MITCHEM & CHARLES
M. HAECKER (ed.). Native and Spanish New Worlds:
sixteenth-century entradas in the American Southwest
and Southeast (Amerind Studies in Anthropology
series). xii+382 pages, 26 b&w illustrations, 4 tables.
2013. Tucson: University of Arizona Press; 978-08165-3020-5 hardback $60.
MATTHEW LIEBMANN. Revolt: an archaeological history
of Pueblo resistance and revitalization in 17th century
New Mexico (Archaeology of Colonialism in Native
North America series). xiii+287 pages, 27 b&w
illustrations, 6 tables. 2012. Tucson: University
of Arizona Press; 978-0-8165-2865-3 hardback
$50.
MARK D. MITCHELL. Crafting history in the Northern
Plains: a political economy of the Heart River region,
1400–1750 (Archaeology of Colonialism in Native
North America series). xv+269 pages, 51 b&w
illustrations, 27 tables. 2013. Tucson: University
of Arizona Press; 978-0-8165-2129-6 hardback
$60.
This quarter, NBC
heads to the Americas of the sixteenth
and seventeenth centuries to assess a
crop of books on the
archaeology of colonialism; we start in
Peru. In Negotiated
communities and landscapes under Inka and Spanish
colonialism, STEVEN WERNKE examines Inkan and
Spanish colonialism in the Colca Valley of the
southern highlands. The book draws on field survey
around Yanque (the political centre of the Collagua
ethnic group) and excavation at an Inkan outpost—
subsequently converted into a Franciscan doctrina
or doctrinal settlement—called Malata. Wernke also
uses colonial visitas (administrative surveys) spanning
the period 1591–1617 to reconstruct the agricultural
landscape and the ayllus (kin groups) which controlled
them. He aims to dispense with ‘dyads’ (pre-/postconquest; coloniser/colonised) in order to understand
colonialism as an “improvisational order” (p. 8) full
of compromises and interdependencies.
During the Late Horizon period (AD 1450–1532),
Inkan colonial control was established across the area.
Most existing settlements continued to be occupied,
but some were remodelled through the addition
of great hall/plaza complexes—clear manifestations of
Inkan state power. Local authority, however, remained
in the hands of ethnic lords (kurakas); the demands
of the Inkan state were therefore “mere extensions of
traditional, kin-based relations of reciprocity” (p. 10).
With the arrival of the Spanish in the 1530s—
primarily small numbers of Franciscan friars—urban
centres were transformed again with the addition
of Christian chapels. By the 1570s, however, the
arrival of Viceroy Francisco de Toledo instigated
more profound efforts to remodel settlement and
society through a reducción programme intended to
resettle massive numbers of indigenous people into
new colonial towns.
Superficially, the effects of the Inkan and Spanish
colonial projects seem to contrast: continuity of preexisting settlement following the Inkan conquest,
but almost complete replacement during the Spanish
period. Wernke’s analysis, however, finds subtle
similarities between the two. This includes the
dependency of colonial strategies on pre-existing
social and political structures: from Inkan great halls
to Spanish demands for tribute and corvée labour—
all were referenced to earlier settlement and social
organisation. Wernke observes that “the assertion
of dominance ran up against the practicalities of
enacting an extractive program that depended on
the vested authorities of native elites” (p. 15).
But what about the reducción programme? Surely
the imposition of new settlements indicates a
C Antiquity Publications Ltd.
ANTIQUITY 87 (2013): 1250–1263
http://antiquity.ac.uk/ant/087/ant0871250.htm
1250
Reviews
This is a fascinating and innovative attempt to break
down barriers—whether between types of evidence,
conceptual categories or chronological periods. It
is squarely—though not uncritically—in the postcolonial camp and presents a rigorous methodology;
the GIS analysis, for example, employs network
analysis to assess the surveillance and shifting status
of households effected by colonial reconfiguration of
urban landscapes.
There are inevitable quibbles: the small grey-scale
images fail to do justice to the GIS analysis and, in
places, the language is unnecessarily convoluted with
some clunky expressions (“experience-near rendering
of place”, p. 37) and the occasional mixed metaphor
(“the vast palimpsest mosaic”, p. 144). Wernke also
puts repeated emphasis on the extent to which these
colonial projects depended on existing structures,
implying that either he is—or that he thinks we
should be—surprised. Wernke conceptualises this as
the “dilemma of analogy or erasure” (p. 7); that
is, colonial projects which find greater analogical
resonance with indigenous practices can achieve
greater “cultural purchase” (p. 7), or more effectively
inculcate new categories and routines; conversely,
colonial projects which aim to eradicate and replace
existing practices make less use of analogues and
achieve less cultural purchase. Or, put simply, the
most ‘effective’ colonial projects work with what
they find on the ground. For example, he notes
that Franciscan friars actively sought “nodes of Inka
administration as sites for the building of their
doctrinas” (p. 168). But is it really surprising that
missionaries should have initially established themselves at pre-existing centres? If the aim was to save
souls, evangelising in the middle of nowhere would
hardly have been effective. Without overwhelming
force neither Inkan nor Spanish colonisers had much
alternative but to work through existing structures.
Indeed, it is hard to think of comparative colonial
contexts in which at least the earliest stages were not
responsive to—and dependent on—existing social,
political and economic structures. Certainly, the other
volumes under review take such dependency and
its implications as given. Nonetheless Wernke quite
rightly calls attention to the fact that such dependency
modifies the coloniser as well as the colonised. But,
most importantly, he illustrates how all this worked
in reality—the messiness and unintended outcomes
of protracted negotiation.
Next we shift 4000km north to examine what was
happening during the sixteenth century as the Spanish
moved north from Mexico into the southern United
States. Native and Spanish New Worlds: sixteenthcentury entradas in the American Southwest and
Southeast edited by CLAY MATHERS ET AL. focuses
on the first century of native European contact in the
context of the expeditions (entradas) which set out
to explore new territories and to find the fabulously
wealthy—but mythical—Seven Cities of Cı́bola. The
15 papers here derive from sessions held at the Society
for Historical Archaeology conference in 2008 and
the Society for American Archaeology meeting in
2009. The volume is organised around key themes—
historiography, climate, disease, political organisation
and conflict—with additional introductory and
discussion chapters. Most of these sections contain
paired papers, dealing with the Southwest (especially
New Mexico and Arizona) and the Southeast (Florida,
Georgia and Alabama) reflecting the editors’ aim to
bring together scholars isolated by geography and
research traditions but working on similar themes.
The papers draw on documents, palaeoenvironmental
records, ethnohistory and newly discovered sites
and assemblages. Before the comparisons begin,
however, Dongoske & Dongoske contribute an essay
emphasising a native—more specifically, Zuni—
perspective. This includes a section on the apparently
surprising response of the Zuni Cultural Resource
Advisory Team to the authors’ questions about the
Zuni encounter with the Vásquez de Coronada
expedition of 1540: it “happened a long time ago
and. . .they did not have any particular thoughts about
the subject” (p. 41). Superficially this might appear
to conflict with other indicators—throughout this
volume and the others under review—about the real
importance attached to such historical encounters by
descendent communities; the Dongoskes consider the
possible explanations for this response and promise
further work.
The historiography papers deconstruct the evolution
of historical and contemporary understanding of
the entradas. For example, Flint & Flint argue
C
1251
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
Review
profound break with tradition? Here, Wernke uses
a sophisticated methodology, mapping the visitas
for the area around the reducción at Coporaque
to demonstrate that the new centre was located
with careful reference to the ayllu system and
hence to ownership of agricultural land. Rather
than arbitrary colonial imposition, Coporaque attests
the “highly localized negotiations between colonial
administrators and local interest groups” (p. 20)—
hence, the ‘negotiated settlements’ of the book’s title.
Reviews
that the Vásquez de Coronada expedition was far
from the regimented state-sponsored military force
often envisaged, and is better understood as a selforganised, makeshift militia, with as many speculators
as soldiers. The papers dealing with the influence of
climate make connections between various historical
events and climatic change: in both regions, megadroughts stressed the indigenous communities and
people on the entradas alike (during the following
century, the particularly cold 1660s and 1670s may
have contributed to the Pueblo Revolt, below). Both
the papers on disease tackle the orthodoxy that,
within a century of contact, European pathogens had
dramatically reduced indigenous populations. This
is a controversial subject—in his discussion paper,
Ewen argues that disease “appears to be a satisfying
explanation that accounts for all change and lets
everyone off the hook. . . no one suffers any blame.
It is an explanation we can all shake our heads sadly
about” (p. 283). Neither paper in the disease section
denies massive depopulation; rather, they argue, it
was attributable to multiple factors (including slave
raiding and population movement as well as disease),
was uneven across time and space, and was drawn out
over centuries, not decades.
The section on political organisation contains three
papers: Chapman tackles Spanish (mis)perceptions of
settlement in the Upper Middle Rio Grande Valley; he
argues that the large Pueblo settlements encountered
during the entradas led to deep misunderstanding
about the structure of Pueblo society. Specifically,
the Spanish assumed these settlements were occupied
year-round by hierarchical societies through which
they could extract tribute. Instead, these pueblos
were occupied flexibly with seasonal dispersal and
frequent relocations of households and whole villages.
In Wernke’s terms, the Spanish thought they had
found the analogy which would allow them to
exercise colonial power when, in fact, they had
badly misread the situation—the repercussions came
in 1680 (below). Things worked differently in
the Southeast; Ethridge & Mitchem consider the
Hernando de Soto entrada of 1539–43 which headed
north from Florida, deep into the Appalachians,
before turning west to Arkansas and finally back,
via the Mississippi, to the coast. Here, the Spanish
encountered chiefdoms and paramount chiefdoms,
finding social and political structures through which
they could extract submission and support—even if
not the great wealth they sought. Finally, Worth’s
paper focuses on Florida where he documents the
C
foundation of St Augustine—colonial in origins, but
evolving to become, in effect, a form of paramount
chiefdom on which the surrounding communities
depended.
The final section tackles conflict; Rodning et al.
explore how some native groups in the Southeast
exploited the entradas to advance personal or
community interests, leading to conflict between
indigenous groups as well as with the Spanish.
The volume concludes with two discussion papers.
Thomas draws interesting parallels between Hispanic
and Mississippian societies emphasising honour
and hierarchy, which allowed some degree of—in
Werkne’s term—cultural purchase. Indeed, Thomas
notes that “readily recognizing the lines of authority
and decision making, the Spanish could draw to a
large degree upon previous colonial experiences in
Peru” (p. 255). But ideas of honour and hierarchy
could also conflict, such as the materialist interests
of the Spanish versus the Mississippian emphasis on
status. Meanwhile in the Southwest, the different
social and political structure of Pueblo communities
leads Thomas to note: “if the nature of Pueblo
decision making and embedded sociopolitics has
confounded generations of academics, one can only
imagine the confusion and frustration experienced by
Vásquez de Coronada” (p. 270).
It is to the long-term consequences of that
‘confusion’—in the form of the Pueblo Revolt of
1680—that we now turn. MATTHEW LIEBMANN
lists at least 20 previous book-length treatments
of this topic; what makes Revolt: an archaeological
history of Pueblo resistance and revitalization different?
Liebmann sets out to re-evaluate the events leading
up to and following the revolt by putting them
into the comparative perspective of other resistance
and revitalisation movements and, especially, by
introducing the results of his recent fieldwork
in Jemez Province in north-central New Mexico.
His aim is to present “a work of historical
anthropology, investigating the recurrent phenomena
of subaltern resistance, cultural revitalization, and
the manipulation of colonial signs that characterize
colonized populations more generally” (p. 4).
Liebmann provides an account of the longer-term
context in which the revolt occurred, but the book
focuses on the period of Pueblo independence
from 1680 to 1694. Approaching such a short
chronological arc from an archaeological perspective
would be challenging in any circumstances.
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
1252
Reviews
The fieldwork on which the book builds was
conceived and conducted collaboratively with
contemporary members of the Jemez Pueblo tribe.
It was agreed that the project should not involve
invasive techniques such as excavation and that sites
should be left as found—even artefacts collected from
the surface were to be returned after study. The
project would also train Pueblo interns. All the work
was approved at each step by the Tribal Council—
including the resulting book—acting as “an additional
form of peer-review” (p. 22).
Following the revolt in 1680, the Spanish briefly
returned the following year. They did not reach
Jemez Province, but the Jemez took no chances;
they razed the missionary village of San Diego de
la Congregación—including their own homes—and
retreated to higher ground founding a new site at
Patokwa. Here, geophysical and surface survey has
identified a regularly planned twin-plaza complex
defined by ‘ladder-type’ roomblocks; within each
plaza was a kiva (subterranean room for religious
ceremonies). Using two different methods, Liebmann
estimates the population at around 600–900 persons.
When, in 1683, an attack on Patokwa came, it
was not by the Spanish, but by the nomadic Ute,
seemingly disgruntled that the revolt had disrupted
trade relations with the Europeans. As a result, a
faction left Patokwa and founded a more defensible
settlement at Boletsakwa on an isolated 150m-high
outcrop. Fieldwork here reveals a very similar layout
to that found at Patokwa (two plazas, two kivas),
though a smaller population of around 350–450.
Both sites attest centralised leadership, communal
labour and careful planning; both were also founded
directly next to earlier abandoned Pueblo sites—a
fact which Liebmann connects to the revitalisation
movement that helped foster the 1680 revolt under
the influence of the charismatic prophet Po’pay.
Settlement relocation was a rejection of Spanish
missions and congregación (forced resettlement), and
a return to ancestral places and architecture.
Liebmann also traces the revival or creation of
traditions through ceramics. Assemblages from preRevolt sites are dominated by Jemez black-onwhite pottery; the post-Revolt sites at Patokwa and
Boletsakwa have less than 2 per cent. Liebmann
sees this as the rejection of a type of ceramic
which had become ‘contaminated’ by association with
Franciscan missionaries. In its place came an entirely
new ceramic ware, Plain red, which was traded more
widely than pre-1680 pottery; there were also new
and widely-shared ceramic motifs. All these changes
both created and reflected pan-Pueblo ethnogenesis
which “was arguably the most important outcome of
all the colonial appropriations that occurred during
the Spanish interregnum” (p. 158).
The final section documents the breakdown of
revivalism and the Spanish reconquest. Expelled from
their pueblo by the returning Spanish in 1689, the
people of Zia and allies moved into Jemez Province
and founded a new settlement—Cerro Colorado—
next to the remains of the old Franciscan mission
at San Diego de la Congregación. Field survey at
Cerro Colorado demonstrates a very different
situation from Patokwa and Boletsakwa. Not only
did the site not reference an earlier Pueblo site, it also
lacked the idealised combination of twin-plazas and
kivas.
The closing act of this drama concerns the siege of
Astiaklakwa. With the return of the Spanish, relations
between indigenous groups broke down. Under
imminent threat of attack, the Jemez abandoned
their settlements, building the fortress-pueblo of
Astiaklakwa on an isolated site surrounded by 300m
cliffs. Field survey at the site—which was occupied
for just eight months during 1694—has revealed
structures hurriedly built and haphazardly dispersed.
When the assault came, it was not just the Spanish but
also the neighbouring Punames who attacked. Here,
and elsewhere, Pueblo independence came to an end.
This is an important book which presents
an original archaeological history of the revolt.
Liebmann demonstrates a lightness of touch, dealing
convincingly with the theoretical ideas whilst pushing
forward a highly readable—and human—narrative.
More than the other volumes under review here, he
is also conscious of not only what can be drawn
from comparison to other historical contexts, but
what the Pueblo example can contribute back to
wider understanding of resistance and revitalisation.
One area where it would have been fascinating to
know more of Liebmann’s thoughts concerns the
C
1253
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
Review
Liebmann, however, is able to draw on fieldwork
at an extraordinary sequence of newly built,
reoccupied and abandoned sites which literally
track the Jemez population as it moved around
the landscape working through the implications
of independence, ethnogenesis and—eventually—
reconquest (regarding the latter, Liebmann insists
that to view this, and other revolts, as failures is to
misunderstand them profoundly).
Reviews
(unmentioned) tension between the non-invasive
methodology and the information gleaned from
looting and illegal excavation. For example, Liebmann
notes that the geophysical survey could not identify
room size—a critical proxy for population. He was,
however, able to estimate room size based on evidence
from structures revealed by clandestine activity. This
is a conundrum any archaeologist might face, but
some discussion of the issue in this specific context
would have been very interesting.
Next, we head north once again, to the northern
middle Missouri in North Dakota, to examine
another perspective on what MARK MITCHELL labels
the ‘trans-Columbian’ period. Like the other volumes
under review, Crafting history in the Northern Plains: a
political economy of the Heart River region, 1400–1750,
sets out to combine documentary, ethnographic and,
especially, archaeological evidence to tell the story of
colonialism from a different perspective; in this case,
the focus is the Mandan people. Again, the aim is
to stress the local context within which colonialism
occurred and the agency that the native population
used to appropriate or resist colonialism. The main
focus is an analysis of the changing organisation of
craft production, settlement and exchange.
Mitchell starts with a review of the writing
of archaeological histories in colonial contexts;
this ranges widely and reveals multiple influences
including Giddens and Bourdieu, and Pauketat’s
historical processualism. Like Wernke, Mitchell
defines a unique combination of post-colonial ideas
and analytical methods. The core analysis concerns
lithic and ceramic assemblages from four villages:
Bypass, On-a-Slant, Double Ditch and Scattered. The
lithic study, for example, examines over 2000 stone
tools, analysing 37 variables. The results indicate
significant variation in lithic production between
the four sites in terms of the acquisition of raw
materials, the skill of producers (specialists versus
non-specialists) and the range of tools produced.
General trends include the expanded production
of arrowheads during the 1600s, and the increased
involvement of specialists in their manufacture.
Between 1200 and 1750, Mandan communities
were based exclusively in aggregated settlements
using flexible strategies of hunting (predominantly
bison), farming (predominantly maize) and trading.
Chapter 4 provides a comparison of ethnographic and
archaeological evidence for these activities, drawing
out correlations and emphasising the aspects which
are poorly recorded in the documentary sources.
C
From AD 1200 to 1400, villages, averaging c.
4ha with populations of around 300 persons, were
located on terraces overlooking the floodplain. Semisubterranean lodges (houses) were distributed in
irregular groups; around half of the settlements were
fortified. After 1400, village layouts became more
regular (e.g. plazas) and most were fortified. Although
mean settlement size remained static, the number
of lodges per hectare trebled, indicating significant
population growth; in addition, sites clustered closer
together. In turn, these developments necessitated
the emergence of supra-local leadership to manage
decision-making and conflict.
During this period, exchange networks also
expanded—with the hunter-gatherers of the
Northern Plains and with other hunter-farmers on
the Missouri. Trade items included ceramics, stone
for tool-making, maize, bison meat and copper.
Alongside this expansion of exchange came an
increase in craft specialisation (including arrowheads)
and an intensification of the hunting of bison (as
indicated by increased numbers of arrowheads), as
well as diversification to include smaller prey species;
maize production may also have intensified. As the
population was stable during the sixteenth and early
seventeenth centuries, this intensification represents
production for exchange.
Mitchell also reviews the evidence for the role of
climate observing that the expansion of exchange and
the aggregation of settlement pre-date the fourteenth
century mega-drought (though may have intensified
in response); in turn, these changes may have provided
resilience to the mega-droughts of the mid fifteenth
and mid sixteenth centuries.
Such subsistence-buffering (i.e. surpluses, exchange
networks) encouraged the emergence of social
differentiation and growing conflict within and
between communities. The resulting spiral of
increasing production, population and exchange
spanned two centuries before collapsing with the
smallpox outbreak of the 1770s and 1780s. Disease—
as the Mathers et al. volume reminds us—rarely
provides a complete explanation and Mitchell notes
that, had smallpox not struck, the horses and guns
acquired by the mobile hunters of the Northern Plains
were already undermining Mandan stability.
Mitchell demolishes the idea that economic
intensification and long-distance exchange were the
products of indirect (seventeenth-century) or direct
(eighteenth-century) colonialism; indeed, the success
of the European fur-traders depended largely on the
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
1254
Reviews
This “first-generation narrative” (p. 199) provides yet
another way of approaching and reading the evidence
for this turbulent period. The volume appears in the
‘Archaeology of Colonialism in Native North America’ series of the University of Arizona Press, but what
is striking is how colonialism is relegated to simply
one of many processes. This is surely appropriate,
not because colonialism was unimportant—on the
contrary—but because it probably better reflects
the reality of how colonialism played out across
decades and centuries.
These volumes concern four very different regions:
the Colca Valley of southern Peru, the Southwest
and Southeast USA, New Mexico and the middle
Missouri. What unites them is not strictly the
experiences of colonialism they describe—although
there are similarities—but the approaches of their
authors.
Binary categories (or dyads, if you must) are
everywhere under attack. This includes breaking
down ideas such as coloniser versus colonised (e.g.
recognising that the ‘Spanish’ entradas involved
Africans and indigenous allies, and that native
communities could be divided by status and
motivation). There is also emphasis on uniting
pre- and post-conquest narratives to appreciate
better the long-term and dynamic contexts within
which colonialism played out. All are aware of the
limitations of the documentary sources—the silences
and biases—and all are adamant that archaeological
evidence is a vital corrective, though there is perhaps
some disagreement as to whether the latter should be
afforded primacy or simply equal footing. Everyone
stresses the importance of adopting local and regional
perspectives in order that the nuances of colonial
relations can be appreciated; but all of the authors
are also conscious that these local details can only be
understood in the global context of colonialism.
The centrality of native agency is universally accepted,
as are the logical consequences, including recognising
the active roles played by native peoples in the colonial
process (this for example helps to explain the “ambivalence” of the Puname alliance with the Spanish
in their attack on Astiaklakwa; Liebmann p. 159).
The need for colonial powers to appropriate existing
social and political structures is documented in all
of these volumes, whether Franciscan friars at Inkan
centres or the evolution of St Augustine into a
paramount chiefdom. As a result, there is recognition
that the nature and effects of colonial control
were heavily influenced by native society—different
accommodations were reached in different areas.
Where the colonisers misunderstood pre-existing
structures or sought to bypass them, the effects could
be particularly devastating.
Clearly there are specific sensitivities amongst diverse
descendant communities and therefore different
approaches are appropriate in each case. All constitute
“good-faith efforts” (Mitchell p. 44). No one,
however, is bold enough to claim to speak for
the descendants of the colonised; most explicitly,
Liebmann is suspicious of “historical ventriloquism”
(p. 8).
Post-colonial theory is a universal inspiration for these
authors, though it is not always uncritically accepted;
Bourdieu and Giddens are de rigueur. Particularly
striking is how the authors are able to integrate highly
diverse theoretical and methodological approaches; I
struggle to think of comparable studies by European
scholars which so easily blend post-colonial theory
with chi-squared tests and standard deviational
ellipses. The results, however, are innovative and
rigorous ways to interpret data, whether using GIS
to understand surveillance or archaeometric traits to
document craft specialisation. The terminology varies
and the interpretation of detail is necessarily unique,
but these books are united by more than divides them.
Colonialism as but a chapter: the
Southeast USA
ELSBETH GORDON. Heart and soul of Florida: sacred
sites and historic architecture. xxii+350 pages, 65
colour and 175 b&w illustrations. 2013. Gainesville:
University Press of Florida 978-0-8130-4400-2
hardback $45.
ROBERT S. CARR. Digging Miami. xiv+296 pages, 88
illustrations. 2012. Gainesville: University Press of
Florida; 978-0-8130-4206-0 hardback $29.95.
VICTOR D. THOMPSON & DAVID HURST THOMAS
(ed.). Life among the tides: recent archaeology on the
Georgia Bight (Anthropological Papers 98). 494 pages,
184 colour and b&w illustrations, 59 tables. 2013.
C
1255
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
Review
networks which had developed two centuries earlier.
Mitchell suggests: “it is easy to imagine that the
Mandans and their contemporaries valued the same
entrepreneurial spirit, the same commercial drive,
motivated by the rewards of prestige and profit, that
the fur traders valued” (p. 207).
Reviews
New York: American Museum of Natural History;
978-0-9852016-1-6 paperback.
If some coherence can be claimed for the previous
quartet, we finish with a look at three volumes which
remind us that the archaeology of colonialism in
North America can be framed, studied and presented
in other ways. Specifically, it might be considered as
simply a single chapter in much longer narratives of
the past. We focus in on Florida and Georgia.
One striking aspect of all the books discussed so
far is the sparse—in some cases, inadequate—visual
material. Not so ELSBETH GORDON’s Heart and
soul of Florida: sacred sites and historic architecture
which is beautifully illustrated with an abundance
of plans, photographs and reconstructions of the
sites and architecture of Florida from 6000 BC to
the present—including some of those mentioned in
Mathers et al. I confess that the title—and indeed,
the dust jacket—of this volume did not recommend
it to me, but I was pleased to have looked inside—
and not just for the pictures. This is very much
an account of the architectural, rather than strictly
archaeological, heritage of Florida and it therefore
pursues very different aims and approaches from the
volumes already considered. It could not, for example,
be considered post-colonial in outlook; indeed, be
warned, there are ‘mysteries’ out there. Nonetheless,
there is much, especially in the first half of the
book, which can be set profitably alongside the
previous volumes, for the general reader at least. I
was particularly struck by the observation that “when
authors write that Philadelphia is the first planned
community in the United States. . .it means they
have not looked far enough into the past to see
the comprehensive sixteenth-century Spanish townplan of St Augustine” (p. 282). This comment—
and the book as a whole—is a reminder of the
competition between Spanish, French and English
colonialism in the creation of the US foundation
story, as well as the way in which individual states
incorporate their unique combinations of cultural
C
heritage—from prehistoric mounds to an apparent
rash of twenty-first-century neo-Gothic churches—
into coherent narratives of identity.
A more explicitly—but not necessarily traditional—
archaeological account is Digging Miami by ROBERT
CARR, the first county archaeologist of Miami-Dade
County. The book takes the form of a highly
readable chronological narrative of the evidence
gathered during three decades of largely developmentled archaeological investigation across the county.
Carr cleverly weaves together the wider historical
framework with stories of individual archaeological
investigations and description and interpretation
of the sites and artefacts recovered. There is not
much by way of introduction—and certainly no
theoretical discussion citing Bourdieu. Instead, we
are carried along by Carr’s detailed knowledge of—
and passion for—Miami’s archaeology. The book
comprises four chronological sections which take
the reader from the evidence of the earliest human
activity, through the sites of the Tequesta people, the
‘failed’ colonial settlements of the Europeans, and
the sites of the Seminole people and nineteenthcentury pioneers, concluding with the twentieth
century; discoveries of the latter date include
Coca-Cola bottles and—disturbingly—the graves of
African Americans which “somehow had disappeared
from community consciousness” (p. 228) until
accidentally rediscovered in 2009. Each section
focuses around the stories of individual sites, their
discovery, and how they changed understanding,
including a section on the ‘Miami Circle’, a series of
pits arranged in a circle 11.5m in diameter, dating to c.
AD 50. Discovered in 1998 and declared a sacred site
by the Five Indian Nations of Oklahoma, the precise
form and function of the site is still under debate.
Digging Miami defies easy categorisation. It is personal
but rigorous; it is data-rich but engagingly written; it
is about the past peoples of Miami-Dade County but
also about their discovery in the present. Regardless
of what label is deserves, it works.
The final book under review, Life among the tides:
recent archaeology on the Georgia Bight contains 17 papers derived from the Sixth Caudwell Conference held
on St Catherine’s Island, Georgia, in 2011. The papers
are edited by THOMPSON & THOMAS and divided into
four main sections: analytical approaches to time and
exchange, modelling coastal landscapes, architecture
and village layout before contact, and mission-period
archaeology, plus a preface and discussion chapter.
The authors report the results of field and laboratory
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
1256
Reviews
300 sites distributed along the coast of northern
Georgia, Thompson et al. document a dramatic
decline in the occupation and use of both the
mainland and the barrier islands at the transition
between the Late Mississippian and Altamaha periods
(i.e. at the initiation of Spanish contact). This is
ascribed to a combination of demographic decline and
increased mobility of the Guale—the former under
the influence of disease and the latter as an active
strategy to resist and/or cope with Spanish control.
Summing up, Disney’s recent—though less than
successful—Hollywood treatment of The Lone Ranger
reminds us that there are still colonial dragons to
slay. The books under review this quarter demonstrate
that, despite geographical distance and some variation
in terminology, we can detect a strong commitment
to post-colonial themes and values which unite
the practice of the archaeology of colonialism in the
Americas. How these themes and values play out
in North Dakota, New Mexico, Florida or Peru
varies according to local concerns, specific research
questions, and the techniques deployed; similarly,
how the resulting narratives are assembled and
presented also varies, but they all represent ‘good faith’
attempts to deal with the messiness of empire.
Books received
The list includes all books received between 1 June
2013 and 1 September 2013. Those featuring at the
beginning of New Book Chronicle have, however, not
been duplicated in this list. The listing of a book in
this chronicle does not preclude its subsequent review
in Antiquity.
General
GRÉGOIRE AYALA (ed.). Lyon, Saint-Georges:
archéologie, environnement et histoire d’un espace
fluvial en bord de Saône (Documents d’Archéologie
Française 106). 436 pages, 322 b&w illustrations,
85 tables. 2013. Paris: Éditions de la Maison des
sciences de l’homme; 978-2-7351-1125-1 paperback
€74.
PETER BELLWOOD. First migrants: ancient migration
in global perspective. xvii+308 pages, 37 b&w
illustrations. 2013. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell;
978-1-4051-8909-8 paperback £19.99.
C
1257
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
Review
work focusing on St Catherine’s Island—a 90km2
barrier island of tidal marsh and woodland—but the
volume also includes several broader contributions
examining the Georgia coastline. Papers in the
first two sections include analysis of the 14 C
reservoir effect, reconstruction of palaeocoastlines,
and a complex GIS-based palaeoeconomic model of
resource exploitation from 4500–300 BP. In the latter,
the terminal date is selected because the introduction
of new food sources by the Spanish may have
significantly altered subsistence strategies; the date
format—300 Before Present—contrasts starkly with
the Gregorian calendrical form used in all the other
volumes discussed and usefully flags the distinctive
environmental and technical approaches presented
in the first half of the volume. The two papers
in the third section present evidence for settlement
dating to the Late Mississippian/protohistoric (or
Irene) period (c. AD 1300–1450) and consider
the issues of if, and how, these can be related
to the ethnohistorically attested Guale population.
The four papers of the final section return us to
the focus of this review, the colonial period (or the
historic mission or Altamaha phase). Given the
sponsor and publisher of the volume—the American
Museum of Natural History—and the technical and
thematic focus of the papers in the first half of the
volume, I expected that the approach of the final
papers would present a rather different perspective
on colonialism from the books reviewed above. Not
so. Each is thoroughly immersed in the agency
and practice theory employed by Wernke et al.
(yes—Bourdieu gets a mention!). Even in studies
of this most distinctive and challenging of physical
landscapes, there is room for ‘entanglement’ as well as
environment. Three of the papers focus on surveys
and excavations of individual sites: Missions San
Joseph de Sapala, Santa Catalina de Guale, San
Buenaventura and Santa Cruz de Guadalquini. The
results of geophysical survey, excavation and shovel
pit testing are presented in pursuit of questions such
as: “how can the social entanglements that must be
correlates of mission aggregation [congregación] be
explored archaeologically?” (p. 388). In contrast to
a focus on individual sites, the paper by Thompson
et al. presents an analysis of the effects of colonialism
at a regional scale, explicitly arguing that “historical
archaeology has, for the most part, undervalued
regional survey and analysis” (p. 437)—though not a
comment which could be extended to work in South
and Meso-America. Using a database of more than
Reviews
JENNIFER BIRCH (ed.). From prehistoric villages to cities:
settlement aggregation and community transformation.
xiv+225 pages, 32 b&w illustrations, 2 tables. 2013.
New York: Routledge; 978-0-415-83661-6 hardback
£80.
DUCCIO BONAVIA. Maize: origin, domestication, and
its role in the development of culture. xviii+586 pages,
24 b&w illustrations. 2013 (first published as El
Maı́z. Su origen, su domesticación y el rol que ha
cumplido en el desarrollo de la Cultura in 2008).
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 978-1-10702303-1 hardback £70 & $115.
PIERRE BONNECHERE & RENAUD GAGNE (ed.). Sacrifices humains: perspectives croisées et représentations/
Human sacrifice: cross-cultural perspectives and
representations. 266 pages, 17 colour and b&w
illustrations. 2013. Liège: Presses Universitaires de
Liège; 978-2-87562-021-7 paperback €33.
CHRIS DALGLISH (ed.). Archaeology, the public and
the recent past. x+179 pages, 32 b&w illustrations,
2 tables. 2013. Woodbridge: Boydell; 978-1-84383851-7 hardback £30.
MATTHEW I.J. DAVIES & FREDA MKIROTE
M’MBOGORI (ed.). Humans and the environment: new
archaeological perspectives for the twenty-first century.
xxxii+348 pages, 38 b&w illustrations, 15 tables.
2013. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 798-0-019959029-2 hardback £75.
NATHAN RICHARDS & SAMI KAY SEEB (ed.). The
archaeology of watercraft abandonment. xiii+375
pages, numerous colour and b&w illustrations. 2013.
New York: Springer; 978-1-4614-7341-1 hardback
£117.
STEFANIE SAMIDA & MANFRED K.H. EGGERT.
Archäologie als Naturwissenschaft? Eine Streitschrift.
126 pages, 3 b&w illustrations. 2013. Berlin: Vergangenheits; 978-3-86408-154-5 paperback €12.90.
MICHAEL BRIAN SCHIFFER. The archaeology of science:
studying the creation of useful knowledge. xvi+204
pages, 25 b&w illustrations. 2013. Heidelberg:
Springer; 978-3-319-00076-3 hardback £90.
SARAH TARLOW & LIV NILSSON STUTZ (ed.). The
Oxford handbook of the archaeology of death and burial.
xix+849 pages, 115 b&w illustrations, 6 tables. 2013.
Oxford: Oxford University Press; 978-0-19-9569069 hardback £115.
CHRISTOPHER WATTS (ed.). Relational archaeologies:
humans, animals, things. xiii+254 pages, 44 b&w
illustrations, 5 tables. 2013. Abingdon: Routledge;
978-0-415-52532-9 paperback £24.99.
C
Method
ADAM BRIN, FRANCIS P. MCMANAMON & KIERON
NIVEN (ed.). Caring for digital data in archaeology: a
guide to good practice. 83 pages, 9 b&w illustrations.
2013. Oxford & Oakville (CT): Oxbow; 978-178297-249-5 paperback.
FLORINDA NOTARSTEFANO. Ceramica e alimentazione
l’analisi chimica dei residui organici nelle ceramiche
applicata ai contesti archeologici (Quaderno 10). 175
pages, numerous colour and b&w illustrations. 2013.
Bari: Edipuglia; 978-88-7228-642-5 paperback €40.
PETER PEPE & JOSEPH W. ZARZYNSKI. Documentary
filmmaking for archaeologists. 230 pages, 22 b&w
illustrations. 2013. Walnut Creek (CA): Left Coast;
978-1-61132-202-6 paperback $32.95.
European pre- and protohistory
QUENTIN BOURGEOIS. Monuments on the horizon. The
formation of the barrow landscape throughout the 3r d
and 2nd millennium BC. xi+239 pages, numerous
colour and b&w illustrations and tables. 2013.
Leiden: Sidestone; 978-90-8890-104-1 hardback
£45.
HARRY FOKKENS & ANTHONY HARDING (ed.).
The Oxford handbook of the European Bronze Age.
xxxi+979 pages, numerous b&w illustrations, 17
tables. 2013. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 9780-19-957286-1 hardback £120.
DIMITRA PAPAGIANNI & MICHAEL A. MORSE. The
Neanderthals rediscovered: how modern science is
rewriting their story. 208 pages, numerous b&w
illustrations. 2013. London: Thames & Hudson;
978-0-500-05177-1 hardback £18.95.
DIETER SCHÄFER (ed.). Das Mesolithikum-Projekt
Ullafelsen (Teil 1). Mensch und Umwelt im Holozän
Tirols (Band 1). 553 pages, numerous colour and b&w
illustrations. 2011. Innsbruck: Philipp von Zabern;
978-3-8053-4375-6 hardback €85.90.
Mediterranean archaeology
ANDREW BEVAN & JAMES CONOLLY. Mediterranean
islands, fragile communities and persistent landscapes:
Antikythera in long-term perspective. xix+280 pages,
31 colour and 46 b&w illustrations, 6 tables. 2013.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 978-1-10703345-0 hardback £65 & $99.
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
1258
Reviews
ROBERTA CASCINO, HELGA DI GIUSEPPE & HELEN
L. PATTERSON (ed.). Veii: the historical topography of
the ancient city. A restudy of John Ward-Perkins’s survey
(Archaeological Monograph 19). xi+429 pages, 143
colour and b&w illustrations, 35 tables. 2012.
London: British School at Rome; 978-0-904152-630 hardback £85.
MICHAEL C. HOFF & RHYS F. TOWNSEND (ed.). Rough
Cilicia: new historical and archaeological approaches.
xii+315 pages, numerous b&w illustrations. 2013.
Oxford & Oakville (CT): Oxbow; 978-1-84217-5187 hardback £65.
BERNARD KNAPP. The archaeology of Cyprus: from
earliest prehistory through the Bronze Age. xx+640
pages, 138 b&w illustrations, 3 tables. 2013.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 978-0-52172347-3 paperback £60 & $99.
GIOVANNI MASTRONUZZI. Il luogo di culto di Monte
Papalucio ad Oria. La fase arcaica (Quaderno 12). 334
pages, numerous colour and b&w illustrations. 2013.
Bari: Edipuglia; 978-88-7228-695-1 paperback
€50.
THOMAS F. TARTARON. Maritime networks in
the Mycenaean world. xvii+341 pages, 95 b&w
illustrations, 11 tables. 2013. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press; 978-1-107-00298-2 hardback £65
& $99.
JEAN MACINTOSH TURFA (ed.). The Etruscan world.
xlv+1167 pages, numerous b&w illustrations. 2013.
Abingdon: Routledge; 978-0-415-67308-2 hardback
£150.
JENNIFER M. WEBB & DAVID FRANKEL. Ambelikou
Alertri: metallurgy and pottery production in Middle
Bronze Age Cyprus (Studies in Mediterranean
Archaeology 138). xx+245 pages, 208 colour and
b&w illustrations, 14 tables. 2013. Uppsala: Åstroms;
978-91-7081-250-7 hardback €80.56.
STEPHANE VERGER & LIONEL PERNET. Une
Odyssée gauloise: parures de femmes à l’origine des
premiers échanges entre la Grèce et la Gaule. 399
pages, numerous colour and b&w illustrations.
2013. Arles: Errance; 978-2-87772-538-5 paperback
€35.
The Classical and Hellenistic
worlds
GREGORY S. ALDRETE, SCOTT BARTELL & ALICIA
ALDRETE. Reconstructing ancient linen body armor:
unraveling the linothorax mystery. viii+279 pages,
numerous colour and b&w illustrations and tables.
2013. Baltimore (MD): Johns Hopkins University
Press; 978-1-4212-0819-4 hardback £15.50.
SOPHIE BOUFFIER & ANTOINE HERMARY (ed.).
L’Occident grec de Marseille à Mégara Hyblaea: hommages à Henri Tréziny (Bibliothèque d’Archéologie
Méditerranéenne et Africaine 13). 296 pages,
numerous colour illustrations and tables. 2013. Arles:
Errance & Centre Camille Jullian; 978-2-87772-5538 paperback €39.
GUNNEL EKROTH & JENNY WALLENSTEN (ed.). Bones,
behaviour and belief. The osteological evidence as
a source for Greek ritual practice (Skifter utgivna
av Svenska Institutet i Athen 4◦ , 55). 272 pages,
numerous colour and b&w illustrations and tables.
2013. Stockholm: Svenska Institutet i Athen; 97891-7916-062-3 hardback.
JOHN MA. Statues and cities: honorific portraits and
civic identity in the Hellenistic world. xxv+378
pages, 73 b&w illustrations. 2013. Oxford: Oxford
University Press; 978-0-19-966891-5 hardback £90.
PASCAL PAYEN & ÉVELYNE SCHEID-TISSINIER (ed.).
Anthropologie de l’Antiquité. Anciens objets, nouvelles
approches. 441 pages. 2012. Turnhout: Brepols; 9782-503-54697-1 paperback €80.
The Roman world
ALAN BOWMAN & ANDREW WILSON (ed.). The
Roman agricultural economy: organisation, investment,
and production (Oxford Studies on the Roman
Economy 3). xvii+333 pages, 86 b&w illustrations,
25 tables. 2013. Oxford: Oxford University Press;
978-0-19-966572-3 hardback £75.
MARTIN JEHNE & CHRISTOPH LUNDGREEN (ed.).
Gemeinsinn und Gemeinwohl in der römischen Antike.
220 pages. 2013. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner; 978-3-51510327-5 paperback €44.
SIMON KEAY (ed.). Rome, Portus and the Mediterranean
(Archaeological Monograph 21). xv+439 pages, 173
colour and b&w illustrations, 35 tables. 2012.
London: British School at Rome; 978-0-904152-654 hardback £90.
C
1259
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
Review
CYPRIAN BROODBANK. The making of the Middle Sea:
a history of the Mediterranean from the beginning to
the emergence of the Classical world. 672 pages, 410
colour and b&w illustrations. 2013. London: Thames
& Hudson; 978-0-500-05176-4 hardback £34.95.
Reviews
GONTRAN MUNIER & PIERRE ANDRE KANAPE (ed.).
Les Germains. De la conquête romaine aux grandes
invasions (Collection “Histoire Vivant”). 95 pages,
numerous colour illustrations. 2013. Arles: Errance;
978-2-87772-545-3 paperback €27.
REBECCA J. SWEETMAN (ed.). The mosaics of Roman
Crete: art, archaeology and social change. xxii+378
pages, 82 colour and b&w illustrations and tables.
2013. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 9781-107-01840-2 hardback £70 & $110.
JERRY TONER. Roman disasters. ix+220 pages, 18
b&w illustrations, 5 tables. 2013. Cambridge &
Malden (MA): Polity; 978-0-7456-5102-6 hardback
£20.
Anatolia, Levant, Middle East
JOAN ARUZ, SARAH B. GRAFF & YELENA RAKIC
(ed.). Cultures in contact: from Mesopotamia to the
Mediterranean in the second millennium BC. xvii+354
pages, numerous colour and b&w illustrations. 2013.
New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art; 978-0-30018503-4 paperback £35.
PETER FIBIGER BANG & WALTER SCHEIDEL (ed.). The
Oxford handbook of the state in the ancient Near East
and Mediterranean. 555 pages, 27 b&w illustrations,
5 tables. 2013. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 9780-19-518831-8 hardback £95.
STEPHANIE DALLEY. The mystery of the Hanging
Garden of Babylon: an elusive world wonder traced.
xviii+279 pages, 17 colour and 70 b&w illustrations.
2013. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 978-0-19966226-5 hardback £25.
ELSPETH R.M. DUSINBERRE. Empire, authority, and
autonomy in Achaemenid Anatolia. xxvi+374 pages,
150 b&w illustrations, 3 tables. 2013. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press; 978-1-107-01826-6
hardback £65 & $105.
DENIS GENEQUAND. Les établissements des élites
omeyyades en Palmyrène et au Proche-Orient
(Bibliothèque Archéologique et Historique 200).
xviii+462 pages, 391 colour and b&w illustrations, 5
tables. 2012. Beirut: Presses de l’Ifpo; 978-2-35159380-6 hardback €100.
ÖMÜR HARMANŞAH. Cities and the shaping of memory
in the ancient Near East. xix+351 pages, 60 b&w
illustrations, 4 tables. 2013. Cambridge: Cambridge
C
University Press; 978-1-107-02794-7 hardback £65
& $99.
PAOLO MATTHIAE & NICOLÒ MARCHETTI (ed.). Ebla
and its landscape: early state formation in the ancient
Near East. 535 pages, numerous colour and b&w
illustrations. 2013. Walnut Creek (CA): Left Coast;
978-1-61132-228-6 hardback $129.
D.T. POTTS. The Oxford handbook of ancient Iran.
xxx+1021 pages, numerous b&w illustrations and
tables. 2013. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 9780-19-973330-9 hardback £105 & $175.
SCOTT REDFORD & NINA ERGIN (ed.). Cities
and citadels in Turkey: from the Iron Age to the
Seljuks (Ancient Near Eastern Studies supplement
40). x+346 pages, numerous colour and b&w
illustrations. 2013. Leuven: Peeters; 978-90-4292712-4 hardback €86.
EBERHARD SAUER, TONY J. WILKINSON, HAMID
OMRANI REKAVANDI & JABRAEL NOKANDEH (ed.).
Persia’s imperial power in late antiquity: the Great Wall
of Gorgan and the frontier landscapes of Sasanian Iran
(British Institute of Persian Studies Archaeological
Monograph 2). xvi+712 pages, numerous colour
and b&w illustrations, and tables. 2013. Oxford
& Oakville (CT): Oxbow; 978-1-84217-519-4
hardback £85.
EVELINE VAN DER STEEN. Near Eastern tribal societies
during the nineteenth century: economy, society and
politics between tent and town. xvii+302 pages, 2
b&w illustrations. 2013. Sheffield & Bristol (CT):
Equinox; 978-1-908049-83-4 hardback £70 & $110.
PAUL YULE. Late Antique Arabia. Zafar, capital of Himyar: rehabilitation of a ‘decadent’ society. Excavations of
the Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg 1998–2010
in the highlands of Yemen. xxvii+310 pages, 159 colour
and b&w illustrations, 43 tables. 2013. Wiesbaden:
Harrassowitz; 978-3-447-06935-9 hardback €98.
Asia
SHINU ANNA ABRAHAM, PRAVEENA GULLAPALLI,
TERESA P. RACZEK & UZMA Z. RIZVI (ed.).
Connections and complexity: new approaches to the
archaeology of South Asia. 430 pages, 103 b&w
illustrations, 19 tables. 2013. Walnut Creek (CA):
Left Coast; 978-1-59874-686-0 hardback $89.
JOHN CARSWELL, SIRAN DERANIYAGALA & ALAN
GRAHAM. Mantai: city by the sea. 552 pages, numerous
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
1260
Reviews
colour and b&w illustrations and tables, CD.
2013. Aichwald: Linden Soft; 978-3-929290-39-4
hardback €65.
JULIA SHAW. Buddhist landscapes in central India.
Sanchi Hill and archaeologies of religious and social
change, c. third century BC to fifth century AD.
359 pages, 291 b&w illustrations, 20 tables.
2007. London: British Association for South Asian
Studies & the British Academy; 978-0-9553924-4-3
hardback $99.
KENNETH G. HIRTH & JOANNE PILLSBURY (ed.).
Merchants, markets, and exchange in the pre-Columbian
world. vii+469 pages, numerous colour and b&w
illustrations. 2013. Washington, D.C.: Dumbarton
Oaks Research Library and Collection; 978-0-88402386-9 hardback £51.95.
SARAH E. JACKSON. Politics of the Maya court: hierarchy
and change in the Late Classic period. xviii+173
pages, 50 b&w illustrations, 8 tables. 2013. Norman:
University of Oklahoma Press; 978-0-8061-4341-5
hardback $29.95.
ALAN L. KOLATA. Ancient Inca. xvii+298 pages,
80 b&w illustrations, 2 tables. 2013. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press; £60 & $99 paperback.
PETER FRENCH. The Anubieion at Saqqara III:
pottery from the Archaic to the Third Intermediate
period (EES Excavation Monograph 103). 467
pages, 98 b&w illustrations and numerous tables.
2013. London: Egypt Exploration Society; 978-085698214-9 paperback.
ELENA A.A. GARCEA (ed.). Gobero: the no-return
frontier. Archaeology and landscape at the SaharoSahelian borderland (Journal of African Archaeology
Monograph 9). xviii+293 pages, 196 colour and
b&w illustrations, 61 tables. 2013. Frankfurt: Africa
Magna; 978-3-937248-34-9 hardback €69.80.
JEFFREY R. PARSONS, CHARLES M. HASTINGS &
RAMIRO MATOS M. (ed.). Prehispanic settlement
patterns in the Upper Mantaro, Junı́n, Peru: volume
2, the Wanka region (Memoirs 53). xxvi+374 pages,
549 colour and b&w illustrations, 65 tables. 2013.
Ann Arbor: Museum of Anthropology, University of
Michigan; 978-0-915703-81-4 paperback $39.
ALEXEI VRANICH, ELIZABETH A. KLARICH & CHARLES
STANISH (ed.). Advances in Titicaca Basin archaeology
III (Memoirs 51). xvii+318 pages, 342 b&w
illustrations, 18 tables. 2012. Ann Arbor: Museum
of Anthropology, University of Michigan; 978-0915703-78-4 paperback $34.
TIMOTHY INSOLL, RACHEL MACLEAN & BENJAMIN
KANKPEYENG. Temporalising anthropology: archaeology
in the Talensi Tong Hills, Northern Ghana (Journal
of African Archaeology Monograph 10). 270
pages, numerous colour and b&w illustrations.
2013. Frankfurt: Africa Magna; 978-3-937248-35-6
hardback €55.
ROBERT LLOYD WILLIAMS. The complete Codex
Zouche-Nuttall: Mixtec lineage histories and political
biographies. xvii+348 pages, 84 colour plates
and numerous b&w illustrations. 2013. Austin:
University of Texas Press; 978-0-292-74438-7
hardback $60.
Americas
Oceania
DOMINIQUE BONNISSENT (ed.). Les gisements
précolombiens de la Baie Orientale. Campements du
Mésoindien et du Néoindien sur l’ı̂le Saint-Martin
(Petites Antilles) (Documents d’Archéologie Française
107). 245 pages, 152 b&w illustrations, 27 tables.
2013. Paris: Éditions de la Maison des sciences de
l’homme; 978-2-7351-1124-4 paperback €46.
MIKE T. CARSON (ed.). First settlement of Remote
Oceania: earliest sites in the Mariana Islands. xi+149
pages, 76 b&w illustrations, 1 table. 2014. Cham:
Springer; 978-3-319-01046-5 paperback $49.99.
CLAUDIA BRITTENHAM & MARY MILLER. The spectacle
of the late Maya court: reflections on the murals of
Bonampak. xxii+261 pages, numerous colour and
b&w illustrations. 2013. Austin: University of Texas
Press; 978-0-292-74436-3 hardback $75.
ROBERT J. HOMMON. The ancient Hawaiian state.
x+322 pages, numerous b&w illustrations, and
tables. 2013. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 9780-19-991612-2 hardback £45.
MIKE SMITH. The archaeology of Australia’s deserts.
xxv+406 pages, 91 b&w illustrations, 45 tables.
2013. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 9780-521-40745-8 hardback £60 & $95.
C
1261
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
Review
Africa and Egypt
Reviews
Britain and Ireland
NICHOLAS J. HIGHAM & MARTIN J. RYAN. The AngloSaxon world. xv+477 pages, 292 colour illustrations.
2013. New Haven (CT) & London: Yale University
Press; 978-0-300-12534-4 hardback £30.
MIKE MCCARTHY. The Romano-British peasant:
towards a study of people, landscapes and work during the
Roman occupation of Britain. xii+164 pages, 60 b&w
illustrations, 9 tables. 2013. Oxford & Oakville (CT):
Oxbow; 978-1-905119-47-9 paperback £29.95.
NICKY MILNER, BARRY TAYLOR, CHANTAL CONNELLER & TIM SCHADLA-HALL. Star Carr: life
in Britain after the Ice Age. xi+112 pages, 53
colour illustrations. 2013. York: Council for British
Archaeology; 978-1-902771-99-1 paperback £13.
STUART NEEDHAM, DAVE PARHAM & CATHERINE J.
FRIEMAN. Claimed by the sea: Salcombe, Langdon Bay,
and other marine finds of the Bronze Age. xxvii+212
pages, 96 colour and b&w illustrations, 12 tables.
2013. York: Council for British Archaeology; 978-1902771-95-3 paperback £18.49.
MICHAEL SADGROVE. Landscapes of faith: the Christian
heritage of the North East. 208 pages, numerous colour
illustrations. 2013. London: Third Millennium; 9781-906507-89-3 hardback £29.95.
BARNEY SLOANE. The Augustinian nunnery of St
Mary Clerkenwell, London (Museum of London
Archaeology Monograph 57). xvii+278 pages, 149
b&w illustrations, 47 tables, CD. 2013. London:
Museum of London; 978-1-901992-04-5 hardback
£24.
Byzantine, early medieval and
medieval
ANNA LEONE. The end of the pagan city: religion,
economy, and urbanism in Late Antique North Africa.
xxii+319 pages, 49 b&w illustrations, 5 tables. 2013.
Oxford: Oxford University Press; 978-0-19-9570928 hardback £70.
ROBIN NETHERTON & GALE R. OWEN-CROCKER
(ed.). Medieval clothing and textiles, volume 9.
xii+170 pages, 18 b&w illustrations, 9 tables. 2013.
Woodbridge: Boydell; 978-1-84383-856-2 hardback
£35.
Heritage, conservation &
museums
PETER F. BIEHL & C. PRESCOTT. Heritage in the
context of globalization: Europe and the Americas.
x+125 pages, 5 colour and b&w illustrations. 2013.
New York: Springer; 978-1-4614-6076-3 paperback
£44.99.
TAMI BLUMENFIELD & HELAINE SILVERMAN (ed.).
Cultural heritage politics in China. xviii+297 pages,
30 colour and b&w illustrations, 2 tables. 2013. New
York: Springer; 978-1-4614-6873-8 hardback £90.
ROBERT J. SHEPHERD. Faith in heritage: displacement,
development, and religious tourism in contemporary
China. 179 pages, 18 b&w illustrations, 2 tables.
2013. Walnut Creek (CA): Left Coast; 978-1-61132074-9 paperback $34.95.
Other
ANNEMARIE WEYL CARR & ANDRÉAS NICOLAÏDÈS
(ed.). Asinou across time: studies in the architecture and
murals of the Panagia Phorbiotissa, Cyprus. xii+431
pages, numerous colour illustrations. 2012. Washington, D.C.: Dumbarton Oaks Research Library and
Collection; 978-0-88402-349-4 hardback £55.95.
JAMES GRAHAM-CAMPBELL. Viking art. 208 pages,
220 colour and b&w illustrations. 2013. London:
Thames & Hudson; 978-0-500-20419-1 paperback
£9.95.
RICHARD HODGES, SARAH LEPPARD & JOHN
MITCHELL. San Vincenzo Maggione and its workshops
C
(Archaeological Monograph 17). xxviii+500 pages,
401 colour and b&w illustrations, 27 tables. 2011.
London: British School at Rome; 978-0-904152-586 hardback £80.
MATTHEW DENNISON. Queen Victoria: a life of
contradictions. xiii+189 pages, 15 colour illustrations.
2013. London: William Collins; 978-0-00-750457-2
hardback £16.99.
NICHOLAS KARN (ed.). English Episcopal Acta 42,
Ely, 1198–1256. cxiv+329 pages, 4 b&w plates
and illustrations. 2013. Oxford: Oxford University
Press for the British Academy; 978-0-19-726550-5
hardback £90.
ROY HATTERSLEY. The Devonshires: the story of a family
and a nation. xv+477 pages, 24 colour and b&w
illustrations. 2013. London: Chatto & Windus; 9780-701-18624-1 hardback £25.
Antiquity Publications Ltd.
1262
Reviews
HUGH KOLB. Foxes from the gods: the mythology and
symbolism of the fox in the Middle East and Europe
over the past five thousand years. xii+276 pages, 46
b&w illustrations, 2 tables. 2013. Aboyne: Fox Star;
978-0-9575644-0-4 hardback.
Paperback, second and
subsequent editions
MICHAEL D. COE & REX KOONTZ. Mexico. From the
Olmecs to the Aztecs. 256 pages, 189 colour and b&w
illustrations. Seventh edition, 2013 (first published
1962, subsequent editions in 1977, 1984, 1994,
2002, 2008). London: Thames & Hudson; 978-0500-29076-7 paperback £14.95.
ROBERT FARRINGTON. The killing of Richard III.
xi+401 pages. 2013 (first published 1971 by Chatto
& Windus). London: Sphere; 978-0-7515-5278-2
paperback £7.99.
MARK JOBLING, EDWARD HOLLOX, MATTHEW
HURLES, TOOMAS KIVISILD & CHRIS TYLER-SMITH
(ed.). Human evolutionary genetics. xviii+670 pages,
numerous colour illustrations. Second edition, 2014
(first published 2004). New York: Garland Science;
978-0-8153-4148-2 paperback £49.
MELISSA MÜLLER. Anne Frank: the biography. xv+458
pages, 42 b&w illustrations. 2013 (first published
1999). London: Bloomsbury; 978-1-4088-4209-6
hardback £25.
CLIVE ORTON & MICHAEL HUGHES. Pottery in
archaeology. xx+340 pages, 62 b&w illustrations, 9
tables. Second edition, 2013 (first edition published
1993). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 9781-107-40130-3 paperback £65 & $99.
ARMIN SCHMIDT. Geophysical data in archaeology: a
guide to good practice. 83 pages, 9 b&w illustrations.
Second edition, 2013. Oxford & Oakville (CT):
Oxbow; 978-1-78297-144-3 paperback £15.
PATRICIA SOUTHERN. Roman Britain: a new history
55 BC–AD 450. 432 pages, 95 colour and b&w
illustrations. 2013 (first published in hardback 2011).
Stroud: Amberley; 978-01-4456-1190-7 paperback
£12.99.
JOYCE TYLDESLEY. Tutankhamen’s curse: the developing
history of an Egyptian king. xx+316 pages, 16 colour
and 22 b&w illustrations. 2013 (first published in
hardback 2012). London: Profile; 978-1-86197-1661 paperback £9.99.
BARBARA WATTERSON. Women in ancient Egypt.
157 pages, 35 b&w illustrations. 2013 (first
published 2011). Stroud: Amberley; 978-1-44561020-7 paperback £9.99.
Review
BARRY KEMP. The city of Akhenaten and Nefertiti:
Amarna and its people. 320 pages, 287 colour and
b&w illustrations. 2013 (first published in hardback
2012). London: Thames & Hudson; 978-0-50029120-7 paperback £19.95.
C
1263
Antiquity Publications Ltd.