Top 10 Most Expensive Beanie Babies In The World
Barry Elad
Updated · Jan 27, 2025
TABLE OF CONTENTS
- Introduction
- History of Expensive Beanie Babies
- Components Used in Beanie Babies
- Most Expensive Beanie Babies Cost Comparison
- Types and Production Analysis
- Top 10 Most Expensive Beanie Babies In The World
- #1. Princess Diana Bear
- #2. Peanut the Elephant
- #3. Attic Treasures
- #4. Garcia the Bear
- #5. Iggy the Iguana
- #6. Millennium Bear
- #7. Peace Bear
- #8. Kicks the Bear
- #9. Valentino the Bear
- #10. Claude the Crab
- What Factors Make Beanie Babies Much Expensive?
- Conclusion
Introduction
Most Expensive Beanie Babies: Beanie Babies are small stuffed animals that became super popular in the 1990s. Created by Ty Warner, these toys were soft and cute and often came with a little heart-shaped tag. While they were initially affordable, some became rare and valuable over time. Collectors began paying huge amounts for specific Beanie Babies, especially those with unique features, limited production, or factory errors.
Today, certain Beanie Babies are worth thousands of dollars, and people continue to search for them to add to their collections. This list will introduce the top 10 most expensive Beanie Babies ever. Each one has an interesting story behind why it’s so valuable. Let’s dive in and explore!
History of Expensive Beanie Babies
- Beanie Babies was first created by Ty Warner, the founder of Ty Inc. and launched in 1993. The original collection had nine animals, including a frog, a bear, and a platypus.
- They were filled with small plastic beads, making them soft and flexible, which was different from regular stuffed animals.
- Ty Inc. retired certain Beanie Babies to create rarity, causing collectors to rush to buy them before they were gone.
- By the late 1990s, Beanie Babies became a massive collector’s trend.
- Rare Beanie Babies like “Princess Bear” (a tribute to Princess Diana) sold for thousands of dollars. Some were even valued at USD 5,000 or more.
- Limited editions and rare errors, like misprinted tags or unique colors, made some Beanie Babies worth up to USD 10,000 or more. From 1998 to 1999, Beanie Babies made up nearly 10% of eBay’s sales during their peak years, showing how popular they were.
- By the early 2000s, demand for Beanie Babies fell, and most lost their value.
- Some rare Beanie Babies, like “Claude the Crab” or “Valentino Bear,” still sell for high prices, with values reaching tens of thousands of dollars.
- Beanie Babies are remembered as one of the biggest toy crazes of the 1990s, and they taught a lesson about the risks of collecting for investment.
Components Used in Beanie Babies
| Component | Materials | Description |
| Outer Fabric | Soft plush material is used for the body. |
Made of polyester or synthetic fibers. |
|
Bean Filling |
Small plastic pellets inside the body for weight and shape. | Typically weighs about 3-6 ounces. |
| Stuffing | Polyester fiber for softness and structure. |
Makes up about 60-70% of the filling. |
|
Eyes |
Plastic button eyes securely attached. | Size ranges from 5mm to 10mm. |
| Nose and Mouth | Embroidered or plastic features for expression. |
Stitching often includes 3-5 colors. |
|
Tag |
Heart-shaped swing tag for identification and info. | Includes birth date and poem. |
| Tush Tag | Fabric tag for brand and washing details. |
Usually measures 1-2 inches long. |
|
Colors |
Bright, vibrant, or patterned plush. | Over 1,000 variations exist globally. |
| Theme/Design | Based on animals, events, or characters. |
Examples: Bears, cats, or holiday themes. |
Most Expensive Beanie Babies Cost Comparison
- The generation of a Beanie Baby affects its value. For example, the Millennium Bear from the 5th generation has been listed for up to USD 500,000.
| Names | Generation | Estimated Value (USD) |
| #1 Bear | Limited |
5,000 |
|
Chef Robuchon the Bear |
Limited | 5,000 |
| Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant | 3rd |
3,000 |
|
Humphrey the Camel |
1st | 1,700 |
| Flutter the Butterfly | 3rd |
900 |
|
Fine Maned Derby the Horse |
3rd | 700 |
| Garcia the Tie-Dyed Bear | 3rd |
170 |
|
Peace Bear |
4th | 20 |
| Princess Bear | 5th |
8.99 (New) |
Types and Production Analysis
| Beanie Baby Names | Types | Production Number (Approx.) |
| Valentino | Bear (Red with Heart) |
2,000,000+ |
|
Princess |
Bear (Purple) | 1,000,000+ |
| Peanut | Elephant (Blue) |
500,000+ |
|
Bubbles |
Fish (Blue) | 500,000+ |
| Garcia | Bear (Tie-dye) |
500,000+ |
|
Iggy |
Iguana (Green) | 500,000+ |
| Millennium | Bear (Gold) |
1,000,000+ |
|
Peace |
Bear (Tie-dye) |
1,000,000+ |
Top 10 Most Expensive Beanie Babies In The World
- Princess Diana Bear
- Peanut the Elephant
- Attic Treasures
- Garcia the Bear
- Iggy the Iguana
- Millennium Bear
- Peace Bear
- Kicks the Bear
- Valentino the Bear
- Claude the Crab
You May Also Like To Read
- Most Expensive Airlines
- Most Expensive Private Jets
- Most Expensive Pens
- Most Expensive Laptops
- Most Expensive Cigarettes
- Most Expensive Colognes
- Most Expensive Alcoholic Drinks
#1. Princess Diana Bear
- Introduction Date: October 29, 1997
- Retirement Date: April 13, 1999
- Colour: Purple
- Tag Line: “In memory of Princess Diana”
- Poem on Hang Tag: “Princess Diana, born July 1, 1961. Died August 31, 1997. She will always be remembered.”
- Stuffing Material: Varied between PVC and PE pellets
- Country of Origin: Produced in multiple countries, including China and Indonesia
- Common Versions: Typically range from USD 5 to USD 20.
- In 2024, the value of a Princess Diana Beanie Baby in mint condition is generally between USD 5 and USD 10.
#2. Peanut the Elephant
- Birthday: January 25, 1995
- Style Number: 4062
- Colour: Light Blue
- Material: Polyester fibre and plastic pellets
- Size: Approximately 9 inches tall
- Tag Generation: The presence of a yellow star on the hang tag indicates a 4th or 5th generation Beanie Baby, which is less valuable.
- Similarly, a 3rd generation hang tag without the yellow star is considered more desirable.
- This variant is among the rarest and most valuable and it can command prices up to USD 400.
- However, due to its limited production and high desirability, some listings have been priced as high as USD 5,000.
#3. Attic Treasures
- Attic Treasures, introduced by Ty Inc. in 1993, is a line of jointed plush animals distinct from the original Beanie Babies.
- Design: Jointed limbs and heads for possibility and crafted from high-quality materials, differing from the fabric used in Beanie Babies.
- Size Variations: Include 7.5 inches, 8 inches, 9 inches, and 12 inches.
- Each Attic Treasures piece is tagged with a unique name and birthdate.
- Common Attic Treasures like “Baron the Bear” (9 inches) are listed at around USD 5.99.
- Larger or rarer pieces, such as “Bessie the Black & White Cat” (12 inches), may be priced at USD 44.99.
#4. Garcia the Bear
- Introduction Date: 1995
- Retirement Date: May 11, 1997
- Size: Approximately 8.5 inches
- Material: Polyester fiber and PVC pellets
- Name Origin: Garcia is named after Jerry Garcia, the lead guitarist of the Grateful Dead.
- Color Scheme: Multicolored tie-dye pattern; each bear’s colouration is unique due to the tie-dye process.
- Poem (Original): “The Beanies used to follow him around
Because Garcia travelled from town to town
He’s pretty popular as you can see
Some even say he’s legendary!” - 4th Generation Hang Tag with 3rd Generation Tush Tag: Typically valued around USD 10, unique or vibrant color patterns can increase the value to approximately USD 20 or more.
- 3rd Generation Hang Tag with 2nd Generation Tush Tag: Generally more valuable, with prices ranging from USD 100 to USD 200.
#5. Iggy the Iguana
- Introduction Date: 1997
- Retirement Date: 1998
- Size: Approximately 9.5 inches
- Material: Plush fabric with a tie-dye pattern
- Features: Green scales, Red eyes and mouth, Felt spine and Swing and tush tags
- Poem (on the swing tag): Sitting on a rock, basking in the sun
Is this iguana’s idea of fun
Towel and glasses, book and beach chair
His life is so perfect without a care! - Average Value: Approximately USD 65.56
- Price Range: Between USD 1.99 and USD 3,249.00
- High-Value Sale: A rare Iggy with tag errors sold for USD 20,000.00.
#6. Millennium Bear
- The Millennium Bear is a highly sought-after Beanie Baby that was introduced in 1999 by Ty Inc. to commemorate the turn of the century.
- Color: The bear features a purple, blue, and white color scheme, symbolizing the New Millennium.
- Tagline: The bear’s tag reads: “1999, the Millennium Bear, celebrates the year 2000. A time of new beginnings, new hopes, and dreams for everyone!”
- Material: Soft, plush fabric with a unique blend of colors and a smooth finish.
- Size: Approximately 9 inches (22.86 cm) tall.
- Rarity: The Millennium Bear was sold in limited quantities, which contributes to its collectable value.
- Unique Features: The Millennium Bear’s design includes a 2000-style stitched “Happy New Year” ribbon, a feature that sets it apart from other bears.
- Price Ranges: Mint condition (with tag): USD 50 – 100 and used condition (without tag): USD 10 – 30
#7. Peace Bear
- Introduction Date: 1997
- Retirement Date: 1999
- Material: Tie-dyed fabric, resulting in each bear having a unique colour pattern.
- Size: Approximately 8.5 inches in height.
- Factory Stamp: Bears with a red factory stamp inside the looped tush tag, especially numbers 108 or 113, can be valued between USD 50 to USD 125.
- Color Pattern: Unique and aesthetically pleasing colour patterns can increase the bear’s value.
- Unique Appearance: Due to the tie-dye process, no two Peace Bears are identical, making each one distinct.
#8. Kicks the Bear
- Release Date: 1998
- Retirement Date: Retired (specific date not provided)
- Color: Light green
- Size: Approximately 8.5 inches tall
- Features: Black button eyes, black nose and embroidered soccer ball on the chest.
- Common Market Value: Generally, “Kicks the Bear” is considered common among Beanie Babies, with typical selling prices around USD 5 or less.
- Notable Listings: Some sellers list “Kicks the Bear” with tag errors at prices as high as USD 1,500.
#9. Valentino the Bear
- Introduction Date: 1994
- Retirement Date: 1999
- Style Number: 4058
- Physical Features: White plush fabric, a red embroidered heart on the chest, brown or black nose and red ribbon around the neck
- Dimensions: Approximately 8.5 inches tall
- Common Versions: Typically valued between $1 and $10, depending on condition and tag presence.
- Rare Variants: Certain versions with unique features or errors can command higher prices:
- Market Trends: While some rare variants fetch high prices, the majority of Valentino bears are common and valued modestly.
#10. Claude the Crab
- Style Number: 4083
- Introduction Date: 1996
- Birthday: September 3, 1996
- Size: Approximately 7.5 inches in length
- Material: Tie-dyed fabric featuring earth tones such as browns, dark blues, and deep greens; cream-coloured underside
- Features: Black eyes, thread feelers and a unique tie-dye pattern ensure each piece is distinct.
- General Value: The average value of Claude the Crab is approximately USD 6.57, with sold listings ranging from USD 0.01 to USD 800.00.
What Factors Make Beanie Babies Much Expensive?
- Beanie Babies produced in limited quantities or as special editions are often more valuable due to their scarcity. For example, the “Chef Robuchon the Bear,” created as a tribute to French chef Joël Robuchon, was released in extremely limited numbers and has been listed for as much as USD 35,000 on eBay.
- The state of the Beanie Baby significantly impacts its value. Items in mint condition, with intact tags and no signs of wear, are more sought after.
- Tag Generations: The design and generation of the swing and tush tags can indicate a Beanie Baby’s age and rarity. Early generations, particularly the 1st through 3rd, are often more valuable.
- Once a Beanie Baby design is retired, it is no longer produced, increasing its scarcity and potential value.
- Errors and Variations: Manufacturing errors, such as misspelt tags or unique colour variations, can make certain Beanie Babies more valuable. For instance, some versions of the “Millennium Bear” have tag errors, contributing to listings as high as USD 500,000.
- Beanie Babies representing popular animals or characters tend to be more desirable. For example, “Patti the Platypus,” one of the original designs, has been listed for up to USD 20,000.
- The overall demand for specific Beanie Babies can fluctuate, affecting their market value. High demand coupled with low supply typically drives prices up.
- Beanie Babies with a well-documented history or those previously owned by notable individuals can fetch higher prices.
- Genuine Beanie Babies, as opposed to counterfeits, maintain their value. Collectors often seek authentication services to verify the legitimacy of rare items.
- Beanie Babies associated with significant cultural events or figures can be more valuable. “Princess the Bear,” created in memory of Princess Diana, remains one of the most valuable Beanie Babies to date.
Conclusion
The most expensive Beanie Babies are rare, limited-edition toys that are highly sought after by collectors. Factors like condition, the generation of tags, and unique errors or variations can significantly increase their value. Popular characters and those with cultural significance, like Princess the Bear, also tend to be more valuable.
While the market fluctuates, some Beanie Babies are worth thousands or even hundreds of thousands of dollars, especially if they are in mint condition. To get the best value, it’s important to understand these key factors when buying or selling Beanie Babies.
Sources
FAQ.
How can I tell if my Beanie Baby is valuable?
To check if your Beanie Baby is valuable, look for its rarity, condition, tag details, errors, and popularity.
Where to sell Beanie Baby?
You can sell Beanie Babies on eBay, Facebook Marketplace, Etsy, or specialized online collectable stores like Bonanza.
Are all Beanie Babies worth a lot?
No, not all Beanie Babies are valuable; only rare ones with unique traits can be expensive.
Do Beanie Babies increase in value over time?
Some Beanie Babies increase in value over time, especially rare ones in good condition.
How do Beanie Babies compare to other collectables?
Beanie Babies are unique because they’re plush toys, while other collectables can be coins, cards, or art.
Barry Elad
Barry Elad is a tech enthusiast passionate about exploring various technology topics. He collects key statistics and facts to make tech easier to understand. Barry focuses on software and its benefits for everyday life. In his free time, he enjoys creating healthy recipes, practicing yoga, meditating, and walking in nature with his child. Barry's mission is to simplify complex tech information for everyone.
