Critical Analysis of Pakistan Cement Industry
Critical Analysis of Pakistan Cement Industry
Critical Analysis of Pakistan Cement Industry
INDUSTRY
Army Public College of Management
Sciences
APCOMS
Group Members:
Mr. Tanseer Ali
Mr. Ali Abbas
Present
SWOT analysis
International trend of sector
Contribution of sector in economic growth of Pakistan (employment, export, tax)
Major decision about sector in budget 2008-2009
Effect on sector due to change in interest rate
Help or affect on sector due to change in related sector
Future
Ov er view :
At the time of independence in 1947, only one or two units were producing
grey cement in the country. During the decade of 1948-58, the number of
cement units increased to six. During the Ayub era the economy started to
grow and the construction activities underwent a boom. To meet the growing
demand of cement new units were set up. During the decade of 1958-68, the
number of cement units increased from 6 to 9. During the following period of
Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto all the industrial units, including cement industry, were
nationalized, therefore, no new unit was set up during 1971-77. During the
period of General Zia-ul-Haq, 1977-88, denationalization of
industrial units boosted the investments. Housing and
construction industries picked up and the demand for cement
increased. Thus, the number of cement units increased from 9
to 23 and finally 24.
The cement industry in Pakistan has become a long way since
independence when country had less than half a million tones
per annum production capacity. By now it has exceeded 10 million tones per
annum as a result of establishment of new manufacturing facilities and
expansion by existing units. Privatization and effective price decontrol in
1991-92 heralded a new era in which the industry has reached a level where
surplus production after meeting local demand is expected in 1997.
There are total number of units are 23, from which 4 units are in the public
sector while the remaining 19 units are owned by the private sector. Two of
the four units in the public sector had to close down their operations due to
stiff competition and heavy cost of production. The cement plants are located
in every province of Pakistan.
The province-wise distribution of cement plant is as under.
Three additional cement plants with installed capacity of over 2.1 million tons
are in the final stage of completion despite the available excess capacity in
this sector. The following table shows installation of new cement factories and
expansion of the existing facilities during the current decade.
The industry is divided into two broad regions, the northern region and the
southern region. The northern region has over 87 percent share in total
cement dispatches while the units based in the southern region contributes 13
percent to the annual cement sales.
The cement industry of Pakistan entered the export markets a few years back,
and has established its reputation as a good quality product. The latest
information is that India will import more cement from Pakistan. So far
130,000 tones cement has been exported to the neighboring country.
W hat I s Go ing in Rel ated Sector :
Pakistan has one of the highest population growth rates in the world, touching
3%. This has prompted a sizable demand for housing facilities in the country.
According to estimates of construction industry, there is a huge backlog of
about 6.25 million housing units in the country. Bulk of the current demand of
0.6 million units needed every year is for urban areas. With greater
urbanization the demand for cement is expected to grow at an average of
nearly 7% per annum..
The demand for cement for infrastructure units is expected to grow with the
commencement of work on motorways, power plants, and Islamabad New
City, Karachi Package and Ghazi Brotha dam. If all these projects are
implemented as per schedule, the demand for cement is expected to grow at
a higher rate.
Tax structure
Instead of providing any relief in the budget, the sector was further penalized
with a 3% increase in sale tax to 18%. So far, the manufacturers have been
able to pass on the increase to consumers but the situation is unlikely to
continue. However, the possibility of formation of a cartel cannot be ruled out.
Since massive investment has been made in the sector, any reduction in price
of cement can reduce profit margin of all the units.
Excise Duty
In budget 2008-2009 the federal excise duty on cement has been to Rs 900
per tonnes from the existing base of Rs 750 per tonnes.
3. Pioneer Cement
Pioneer cement ratio chart:
4. DG Khan Cement
DG KHAN Profit Ratio:
Net Profit After Tax Ratio 2007:
30.00%
25.00%
Lucky Cement
20.00%
Fauji Cement
15.00%
Pioneer
10.00% Cement
DG Khan
5.00% Cement
0.00%
Profit Ratio
Majo r Econo mica l Changes
1. 2003-2004: There was decline in the production during the FY03-FY04.
The sharp fluctuations in cement prices and relatively lesser demand
for cement have been responsible for the decline in the cement
production.
2. 2004-2005: At the end of 2004, there were 21 cement companies listed
with KSE. The cement industry was one of the best performing sectors
in the stock market. Its market capitalization increased from Rs 65.1
billion on June 2004 to Rs 75.5 billion in March 31, 2005. Recording a
growth of Rs 16.0 percent.
3. 2005-2006: The cement industry in the country has shown significant
growth. The rise in construction activity is equally shared by the private
construction sector and Public Sector Development Program (PSDP).
The total production of cement was recorded at 12.2 million tones
during the FY05-FY06 compared with 11.2 million tones in FY04-FY05;
a growth of 9.75% was recorded. The boost during the period (July-
March) 2005-06 in the performance of the cement industry activity is
because of the high level of construction activity in the country and
increased development expenditure by the Government. Due to an
enormous increase in demand of cement in recent years almost all of
the cement units working in Pakistan are on the path to future
expansions. Due to huge demand the retail price of cement was reach
on Rs. 430/ bag.
4. 2006-2007: Cement demand’s strong correlation with the GDP growth
rate and 7% GDP growth in FY07. During the FY07, cement sales
registered a growth of 31% to 17.53 million tones versus 13.35 million
tons sold in the corresponding period of last year. Local sales grew up
by 26 5 and reached at 15.38 million tons, while exports increased
massively by around 85%. The retail price of cement was decreased by
Rs. 430 to Rs. 315/ bag during the FY07.
SWOT ANALYSIS:
Strengths:
Weak nesses:
1. The stage of industrial development, in most of the segments, is still at
a very low level of technology and the existing industrial base is very
narrow and consists of very basic industries such as cement, sugar,
textile, cigarette, edible oil, fertilizer, soda ash, caustic soda, PVC etc.
2. Since cement is a specialized product, requiring sophisticated
infrastructure and production location. So, most of the cement
industries in Pakistan are located near/within mountainous regions that
are rich in clay, iron and mineral capacity. Structure of Cement industry
in Pakistan is as such that there is not much substitutability to buyers.
Which shows that the Cross elasticity of demand is negligible.
3. The customer has no choice at all to switch between two brands of
cement due to cartel of all of the cement manufacturers in Pakistan.
4. The freight charges are a massive 20% of the retail prices. The plants
located very close to each other and tapping the same market will have
to expand their markets which will increase their freight expenses.
Dandot, Pioneer, Maple Leaf and Garibwal are all located within a
radius of 100 kilometers and are selling bulk of their production in the
same areas and will thus face serious competition from each other.
5. Consumers face a tough decision with regards to prefer which brand
over which because of the similar pricing of cement industry. The
formation of cartel by the cement manufacturers have exploited local
consumers a lot and this has led to the concentrated degree of
oligopoly, where the firms are acting as a single unit to perform their
monopoly. Their combined market power is simply a diluted version of
the dominance that a single firm with a monopoly market share can
exert.
T hr ea ds:
1. Unanticipated increase in interest rates or less than expected demand
growth might create severe crises for the sector couple of years
forward
2. Lack of demand or depressed demand in future will prove to be lethal
for the sector that has just started to recover from the miseries of 90s.
Lack of demand forced cement units to operate at very low capacity
utilization in nineties. There was a fierce competition among cement
manufacturers.
3. A price war was witnessed which ended up with no conqueror. Similar
apprehensions exist for the future when there will be plenty of excess
capacity. Any hurdle in the growth of cement demand may force the
sector into the price war. Yet, we expect cement manufacturers to act
prudent and learn lesson from the history. Any mistake, similar to the
one made in the last decade, will again coerce the sector into the era
where all are losers with no winner.
4. Main component of the cost is fuel. Pakistan's cement industry has
converted their plants to coal considering it to be the cheapest fuel, but
its price in international markets has gone up by more than 300 per
cent in the last one year, which directly relate increasing the cost of
production.
5. The demand of cement falls heavily during rainy weather in the country,
which directly affects the running cost of a unit. It is only the rising
levels of cement exports, which are sustaining the industry.
6. Instead of appreciating the marketing skills of cement entrepreneurs to
explore new markets for cement, the industry is being pressurized
constantly without realizing that any reduction in cement exports from
Pakistan will not only deprive the country of foreign exchange ($2
billion this year), but will also result in losses to the industry.
7. The burden of increased input costs has to be borne by the consumers.
It is only the government, which can provide relief to the consumers by
cutting down or abolishing the central excise duty.
8. Problems of oversupply situation:
Following problems might arise with the oversupply situation in cement
industry:
• Lower capacity utilization will reduce benefits of economies
of scale. High leverage will also adversely affect profitability
of new plants.
• New plants will gain market share at the cost of older
players, which are not undergoing expansion. Large idle
capacity is will create panic in players and this may result in
price wars in the coming years.
9. IMF Package in Future can cause to decrease GDP and economical
development in Pakistan. Which will also be cause to stop
development of infrastructure. So it will have huge effect on cement
industry also.
JULY-MARCH
Item UNITS 2005-06 2006-07 %CHANGE
2006-07 2007-08
Cotton 000 tonnes 2546.5 2845.2 2132.6 2203.5 3.32
Yarn
Cotton Mln.Sq.Mtr 903.8 977.8 727.9 763.4 4.88
Cloth
Sugar 000 tonns 2960.0 3525.9 3247.6 4351.2 33.9
Cement 000 tonns 18564 22739 16448 194014 17.95
Cement At the end of 2007, there were 21 cement companies listed with the
KSE. During the period under review, the performance of cement sector
remained lackluster. Share index of cement declined by 17.8 percent during
July-April 2007- 08. Its market capitalization also declined by 0.2 percent in
the outgoing fiscal year. 2007 was a year of cement industry expansions. As a
result, supply has been enhanced, but depreciation and financial charges
have increased. A high interest rate scenario has made the situation
challenging for this highly leveraged sector.
During the first three quarters of the fiscal year 2007-08, the combined paid-
up capital of ten big companies was Rs. 91 billion, which constituted 13.17
percent of the total listed capital at KSE in which Fauji Fertilizer, DG Khan
Cement, Lucky Cement played major role.
Direct and Indirect Taxes Rs. 23.50 Billion
Value of Fixed Assets Deployed Rs. 85.21 Billion
Loans from Financial Institutions Rs. 79.53 Billion
Shareholders Equity Rs. 80.00 Billion
Employment (Direct & Indirect) 3%
106,62 106,62
2001-2002 - - - 100.00%
0 0
1,118,29
2003-2004 1,118,293 - - - 137.02%
3
(5-Months)
MONTHLY IMPORT AND EXPORT SCENERIO:
IMPORT DISPATCHES
2007-2008 2008-2009
Month Growt
s North South Total Months North South Total h(%)
EXPORT DISPATCHES
2008-2009
Mon |----------Cement----------| Clinker Mon |----------Cement----------| Clinker Total
Other Other
Afghan India (Sea) (Sea) Afghanis India (Sea) (Sea)
194,7 25, 268,33 54, 384,2 106, 813,0
July 221,028 - 39 330 July 4 300 10 159 02
260,4 49, 262,96 59, 370,8 93, 787,1
Aug 265,620 - 88 402 Aug 8 498 40 888 94
226,1 53, 219,20 75, 457,3 145, 896,9
Sept 257,354 11,316 58 804 Sep 2 221 07 198 28
194,7 35, 238,33 37, 509,4 214, 1,000,2
Oct 192,774 37,557 11 455 Oct 6 567 69 894 66
176,7 84, 275,41 67, 506,5 115, 964,8
Nov 257,598 47,363 38 955 Nov 0 534 55 387 86
1,052,8 248, 1,264,25 294, 2,228,3 675, 4,462,2
Total 1,194,374 96,236 34 946 Total 0 120 81 525 75
Growt 205.62 171.35
h-% 5.85% % 111.66% % 72.13%
Export Outlook
During FY05, cement export stood at 1.6 million tons, representing 40%
growth as compared to last corresponding year (154% increase in 2003-04).
Growth in cement export remained slow down during FY05 owing to the fact
that superfluous domestic demand has surpassed supply as most of the local
cement manufacturers were operating at 100% capacity and still weren’t able
to meet present demand. Presently some of the cement companies are
exporting cement to Afghanistan, Iraq and UAE only to maintain their
presence in these markets. After completion of major expansion plans in
Pakistan in 2007, there would be a surplus to export in these markets
however in the same period Iran would also be able to approach vigorously
these markets as its most of the cement plant will start to come online. At that
juncture there would be extreme competition between both countries to
capture these markets, especially the war-ravaged countries (Iraq and
Afghanistan). Iran would get benefit in terms of price as cement prices in Iran
is among the cheapest in the world as the price of cement in Iran remained
between $20-$25 per ton. On the other hand it is expected that being the US
ally, Pakistan would get most of the favor in order to keep its market share in
these markets given the fact that all the construction activities in Iraq and
Afghanistan would be taken by US. Despite the fact that cement constitutes
as one of the basic necessities for shelter, the policy makers have subjected
the cement sector to the highest taxation in the region. The levy of General
Sales Tax (GST) on cement is Rs660 per ton in Pakistan as compared to
Rs320 in India. In the light of this tax regime, it is said that Pakistan has one
of the highest tax rates on cement in the Asian region. The impact of such tax
and duty structure has resulted in almost 40 per cent increase in the cement
price per 50 kg bag when compared to India suppressing demand for
Pakistan cement.
Industr y Futur e:
This would negatively impact the margins and put pressure on local prices
that could lead to a price war among producers. The looming supply overhang
scenario in the sector could potentially worsen the situation. Profitability of the
sector has come under pressure due to high energy cost (comprising around
50% of total raw material costs) and increasing financial expenses.
8. Pakistan could save about $70 million on the import of furnace oil per
annum. This would result in a low price per bag of cement and would
ultimately encourage domestic demand for cement.
remain neutral on the sector because on hand expansion is the need of hour. Due to
expected growth in demand, current capacity appears inadequate. On the other hand,
expansion plans set up by the various players of cement sector to grab demand
expansion might cause sector to overflow. Along with risk of being oversupplied,
unanticipated increase in interest rates or less than expected demand growth might
create severe crises for the sector couple of years forward. Weighing risks and
official record. The association condemned this action and said it is against business
norms. They accused Commission for blaming cement manufacturers for making a
cartel for the last 10 years but could not able to prove it. The capital structure of
cement companies may change, as most of the expansions during last two to three
years have been debt financed and companies are expected to retire these debts
rapidly during next three to five years. Moreover, the slow down in economy may
occur due to political uncertainty, which might result in reducing cement demand in
future.
3. Top four players command 35% of market share in the industry that will be
increased to 46% in FY08.
4. World norm is that top four players have more than 60% market share
International Trend:
Although international energy prices have declined recently, any beneficial
impact on margins has largely been negated by substantial depreciation of
Pak Rupee. PACRA, therefore, believes that the performance of cement
companies could weaken further impacting their financial profile. Pakistan's
cement industry is poised to face a tough challenge as the regional markets,
mainly China and India, are likely to emerge as competitors in the export
market, following a slowdown in their domestic economies and enhanced
production capacity.
Employee issues
Pakistan is one of the countries having low labour cost as an advantage. But
like U.K, Pakistan also have minimum wage legislation, laws of prohibition of
child labour, working conditions at work, health and safety regulations and
labour rights Act, and termination of employment laws.
1. Lime stone:
This raw material is extracted from the near by mountains. Limestone
has the highest composition in the cement product. 75% to 80% of the
cement constitutes of limestone.
2. Clay:
Clay is another natural resource. This raw material is also companies owned.
15% to 20% of cement composition comprises of clay
3. Iron Ore:
Iron Ore is the only resource that is bought from contractors. Iron Ore is
added in small quantities and it helps to strengthen the cement.
4. Gypsum:
Gypsum acts as a retarding agent. It slows down the hardening process,
which in turn gives the constructor enough time to use it. Again it is taken
from nearest mountains.
5. Furnace oil:
It is used mainly for power generation. Initially the companies was relying
on WAPDA for power supply but now the companies have thier own
electricity generation plant that provides upto 50% of the total
requirements. With the increase of furnace oil prices the companies are
expected to move to adopt coal as a more cost efficient and
environmentally friendly fuel for kiln firing. Today the management is
exploring possibilities of alternative and cheaper fuel such as waste firing
etc.
People (Labor):
Pakistan is one of the countries having low labour cost as an advantage. The
direct labor that works in cement companies include both Skilled and unskilled
labors:
Land:
The land that has the factories and used for accommodation is owned by
most of companies. There is enough space to accommodate new plants if the
need arises.
Current Duty Rate & Subsidies Provided By Government:
Ministry of Science and Technology has levied an additional tax factor at 0.1%
of ex factory price which amounts to Rs. 3 per bag
References:
1. www.cement.com.pk
10. www.cementchina.net
12. www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/
13. www.finance.isixsigma.com/library/content/c050601a.asp
14. www.dawnnews.com.pk
15. www.expressnews.com.pk
16. www.finance.gov.pk
17. www.fccl.com.pk