Testing Methods Required To Maintain Electrical Equipment
Testing Methods Required To Maintain Electrical Equipment
Testing Methods Required To Maintain Electrical Equipment
Ronald W. Quade, PE
Megger
February 12, 2013
1
LEGAL DISCLAIMER
This presentation is offered for informational
purposes only and shall not be relied upon for any
work in the field
Only fully qualified personnel shall work on
electrical equipment
Electrical equipment shall only be worked on in a
de-energized state
All tables have accompanying footnotes that have
been removed for brevity
QUESTIONS
What is an acceptable power reliability?
What are some of the things that could interrupt the
continuous flow of power?
Is maintenance an income or an expense?
Why do we test?
Who should test?
3
WHY DO WE TEST?
Personnel safety arc flash protection assumes
equipment will interrupt precisely as intended
Fire safety NFPA National Electrical Code
Insurance company required
Regulatory NERC/FERC
Aging infrastructure
Equipment manufactured to precise specifications
(i.e. no fluff)
Increase life cycle and defer the need for capital
investment
RESOURCES
AVO Training Institute - Substation Maintenance
IEEE - Color Book Series (Yellow Book - Guide for
Maintenance, Operation, & Safety of Industrial & Commercial
Power Systems)
NETA Standard for Acceptance/Maintenance Testing
Specifications
NETA Level II, III and IV test technicians
NFPA 70B: Recommended Practice for Electrical Equipment
Maintenance
ANSI, NEMA, IEC
Manufacturers of apparatus
Authors such as Paul Gill - Electrical Power Equipment
Maintenance and Testing
9
RESOURCES (Continued)
Manufacturers of test equipment:
Megger
Doble
Omicron
Vanguard
Flir
Fluke
Many more
10
REGULATORY
NFPA National Fire Protection Association
NFPA 70: NEC National Electrical Code
NFPA 70E: Standard for Electrical Safety in the
Workplace
NESC National Electrical Safety Code
OSHA Occupational Safety & Health
Administration
11
12
CMMS
Computerized Maintenance Management Systems
PERSONNEL QUALIFICATIONS
Technicians must be trained and experienced for
apparatus being tested
Only qualified persons should attempt maintenance
NETA - Levels II, III and IV test technician
www.netaworld.org/certification
Manufacturer certified
Union specific training
15
Mechanical testing
Visual inspections
Verifications
Terminations
Sequencing
Levels
Etc.
16
17
19
20
@ 10
@ 1
DIELECTRIC WITHSTAND
High Potential, Hi-Pot
DC test applied at 60Hz crest voltage 2 X RMS
Overpotential Go / No Go or Pass/Fail test
Used for dielectric absorption
Good insulation should show increase in resistance
Because absorption current decreases
23
POWER FACTOR
Doble test
Dissipation Factor (tan )
AC test
Non destructive
100
24
Defects in manufacturing
Faults in windings
Problems with Load Tap Changers
Abnormal core grounds
25
goes to zero
+20%
-4%
-20%
Positive
polarity
+1%
+4%
-1%
Negative
polarity
-100%
26
27
28
CTs
Control wiring
Relay
Trip Unit
29
First trip
30
31
32
33
34
35
SWITCHGEAR/SWITCHBOARD
DANGER!!!
Thermographic survey under full load
Test bolted electrical connections with low resistance ohmmeter
Conduct dielectric withstand for each section of bus - phase-toground with phases not under test grounded (optional)
36
SWITCHGEAR/SWITCHBOARD (Continued)
Test insulation resistance on all control wiring (optional)
37
38
39
40
41
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Test turns ratio on in-service tap (all taps on first test) (optional)
Should not deviate more than % from average or from calculated ratio
42
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Should not deviate more than % from average or from calculated ratio
43
44
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Should not deviate more than % from average or from calculated ratio
Correct to 20C
Consult Doble, Megger, etc. or transformer manufacturer
Representative values from NETA Table 100.3
Investigate bushing values differing by more than 10%
45
Remove oil sample and send for complete tests per ASTM D 923
47
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Test insulation resistance winding-to-winding and each winding-toground for any off-neutral positions
Should not deviate more than % from average or from calculated ratio
Correct to 20C
Consult Doble, Megger, etc. or transformer manufacturer
Representative values from NETA Table 100.3
Investigate bushing values differing by more than 10%
48
Remove oil sample and send for complete tests per ASTM D 923
Pass / Fail or Go / No Go
49
50
51
52
53
54
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
55
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
56
DC insulation resistance
Partial discharge
Online
Offline
57
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Test insulation resistance on each pole, phase-to-phase and phaseto-ground with breaker closed and across each open pole
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar breakers
58
59
60
61
62
63
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Test insulation resistance on each pole, phase-to-phase and phaseto-ground with breaker closed and across each open pole
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar breakers
64
65
Compare trip time and trip-coil waveform to manufacture data and prior results
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Test insulation resistance on each pole, phase-to-phase and phaseto-ground with breaker closed and across each open pole
66
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar breakers
67
Conduct dielectric withstand test with breaker closed and poles not
under test grounded (optional)
68
69
Compare trip time and trip-coil waveform to manufacture data and prior results
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Test insulation resistance on each pole, phase-to-phase and phaseto-ground with breaker closed and across each open pole
70
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar breakers
71
Conduct dielectric withstand test with breaker closed and poles not
under test grounded (optional)
72
Compare trip time and trip-coil waveform to manufacture data and prior results
Perform time-travel analysis (unlike air & vacuum breakers, this test
required) Why?
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Test insulation resistance on each pole, phase-to-phase and phaseto-ground with breaker closed and across each open pole
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar breakers
73
Remove oil sample and send for complete tests per ASTM D 923
74
Power factor test with breaker open and closed (unlike air & vacuum
breakers, this test required)
Conduct dielectric withstand test with breaker closed and poles not
under test grounded (optional)
75
Compare trip time and trip-coil waveform to manufacture data and prior results
Perform time-travel analysis (unlike air & vacuum breakers, this test
required) Why???
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Test insulation resistance on each pole, phase-to-phase and phaseto-ground with breaker closed and across each open pole
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar breakers
76
77
Per manufacturer
Pass / Fail or Go / No Go
78
79
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Test insulation resistance on each pole, phase-to-phase and phaseto-ground with switch closed and across each open pole
80
81
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
82
83
84
BATTERIES
Test bolted electrical connections with low resistance ohmmeter
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
For flooded lead acid & vented nickel-cadmium should be within .05V of each other
For valve-regulated lead-acid per manufacturers data
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
85
BATTERIES
For vented nickel-cadmium measure voltage positive-to-ground and
negative-to-ground
86
PROTECTIVE RELAYS
Test insulation resistance on each circuit to frame
87
51 Time Overcurrent
55 Power Factor Relay
59 Overvoltage Relay
60 Voltage Balance Relay
63 Transformer Sudden Pressure Relay
64 Ground Detector Relay
67 Directional Overcurrent Relay
79 Reclosing Relay
81 Frequency Relay
85 Pilot Wire Monitor
87 Differential
88
CURRENT TRANSFORMERS
Test bolted electrical connections with low resistance ohmmeter
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
1000V
Run test for 1 minute
NETA Table 100.5
Correct to 20C per NETA Table 100.14
For solid-state components follow manufacturers recommendations for applied
voltage
89
90
91
92
POTENTIAL TRANSFORMERS
Test bolted electrical connections with low resistance ohmmeter
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
93
Error for revenue metering .1% for ratio and .9mrad (3 minutes) for angle
Error for other 1.2% for ratio and 17.5mrad (one degree) for angle
94
CCVT TRANSFORMERS
Test bolted electrical connections with low resistance ohmmeter
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Measure capacitance
95
Error for revenue metering .1% for ratio and .9mrad (3 minutes) for angle
Error for other 1.2% for ratio and 17.5mrad (one degree) for angle
96
GROUNDING SYSTEMS
Test bolted electrical connections with low resistance ohmmeter
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
IEEE Standard 81
NETA: Resistance 5 for commercial/industrial
NETA: Resistance 1 for generating or transmission stations
NEC: Single electrode with Resistance > 25 should be augmented by one
additional electrode
Values should be .5
97
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Should be > 90% of pickup setting and < 1200A or 125% of pickup
Measure time delay at value 150% of pickup
55% for AC
80% for DC
98
SURGE ARRESTERS
Test bolted electrical connections with low resistance ohmmeter
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
99
Investigate values which deviate >50% from lowest value of similar connections
Correct to 40C
per ANSI/IEEE Standard 43
> 200HP run test for 10 minutes and calculate polarization index
Perform Polarization Index and compare to prior values; should not be < 1
200HP run test for 10 minutes and calculate dielectric absorption ratio
100
101
Correct to 40C
Per ANSI/IEEE Standard 43.
102
103
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
104