Water Jet Machining
Water Jet Machining
Water Jet Machining
Introduction
Water Jet Machining (WJM) and Abrasive Water Jet Machining (AWJM) are two non -traditional or
non-conventional machining processes. They belong to mechanical group of non -conventional
processes like Ultrasonic Machining (USM) and Abrasive Jet Machining (AJM). In these processes
(WJM and AJWM), the mechanical energy of water and abrasive phases are used to achieve
material removal or machining. The general grouping of some of the typical non-traditional
processes are shown below:
o Mechanical Processes
USM
AJM
WJM and AWJM
o Thermal Processes
EBM
LBM
PAM
EDM and WEDM
o Electrical Processes
ECM
EDG
EJD
o Chemical Processes
Chemical milling
Photo chemical machining
Fig: 1 Water Jet cutting
A water jet cutter, also known as a waterjet. is a tool capable of slicing into metal or other
materials using a jet of water at high velocity and pressure, or a mixture of water and an abrasive
substance. The process is essentially the same as water erosion found in nature but greatly
accelerated and concentrated. It is often used during fabrication or manufacture of parts for
machinery and other devices. It is the preferred method when the materials being cut are sensitive
to the high temperatures generated by other methods. It has found applications in a diverse
number of industries from mining to aerospace where it is used for operations such as cutting,
shaping, carving, and reaming. [1]
1|P a g e
2. History
Waterjet cutting can be traced back to hydraulic mining of coal in the Soviet Union and New
Zealand. Water was collected from streams and aimed to wash over a blasted rock face carrying
away the loose coal and rock. This method of mining was redeveloped in South Af rican gold mines
to remove blasted rock from the work area into a collection drift or tunnel. In the California Gold
Country between 1853-1886, pressurized water was first used to excavate soft gold rock from the
mining surfaces. The pressurized water allowed the miner to stand further back from the face being
washed. This was safer because there was less danger of being covered by a collapsing wall of
blasted rock. By early 1900s this method of mining had re ached Prussia and Russia. In these two
countries the pressurized water was used to wash blasted coal away.
In the 1930s it was Russia that made the first attempt at actually cutting the rock with the
pressurized water. A water cannon was used to generate a pressure of 7000 Bars.
In the 1970s technology was developed in the USA that was capable of creating a 40,000 Bar
pressure. Most of the waterjet mining growth after this involved combining a drill with the waterjet.
In 1972 Professor Norman Franz of Michigan worked with McCartney Manufacturing Compan y to
install the first industrial waterjet cutter. The equipment was installed in Alton Boxboard. Flow
industries also began to market industrial waterjet cutting equipment. It was Flow Industries who
added sand to a pressurized cleaning system to give metal a white finish. After this it was
demonstrated that abrasive waterjet systems could cut through metal and ceramics. From here the
waterjet cutting industry took off. [2]
2|P a g e
An abrasivejet starts out the same as a pure waterjet. As the thin stream of water leaves the jewel,
however, abrasive is added to the stream and mixed. The high-velocity water exiting the jewel
creates a vacuum which pulls abrasive from the abrasive line, which then mixes with the water in
the mixing tube. The beam of water accelerates abrasive particles to speeds fast enough to cut
through much harder materials.
3|P a g e
4. Classification
Water jet machining process may be classified as follows:
1. Pure water jet cutting,
2. Abrasive water jet cutting,
3. Dynamic water jet cutting.
5|P a g e
Simple to fixture
Low cutting forces (under 1 lb. while cutting)
One jet setup for nearly all abrasive jet jobs
Easily switched from single to multi-head use
Quickly switch from pure waterjet to abrasive waterjet
Reduced secondary operations
Given the challenges of stream lag and taper, the development of Flow's Dynamic Waterjet with
Active Tolerance Control was essential to the advancement of abrasive waterjet. Invented and
patented by Flow in 2001 to counteract stream lag and taper, Dynamic Waterjet allows you to cut
at top speed and to high precision .Stream lag and taper are no longer an issue in the waterjet
process, and the most versatile cutting tool has bee n transformed into a system that is highly
competitive with alternative cutting methods in accuracy, precision, and speed. [3]
6|P a g e
LP booster pump
Hydraulic unit
Additive Mixer
5B
Intensifier
Accumulator
Flexible high pressure
transmission line
On-off valve
5A
Orifice
Mixing Chamber
3
Point A
2
Fig: 10 Schematic set-up of AWJM
7|P a g e
displacement hydraulic pump. The power packs in modern commercial systems are often controlled
by microcomputers to achieve programmed rise of pressure etc.
The hydraulic power pack delivers the hydraulic oil to the intensifier at a pressure of p . The ratio of
h
large
small
Thus, pressure amplification would take place at the small cylinder as follows.
pw
pw
ph
Fig: 11 Intensifier schematic
phAlarge=pwAsmall
pw = ph(Alarge/Asmall)
pw = phAratio
Thus, if the hydraulic pressure is set as 100 bar and area ratio is 40, p = 100 x 40 = 4000 bar. By
w
using direction control valve, the intensifier is driven by the hydraulic unit. The water may be
directly supplied to the small cylinder of the intensifier or it may be supplied through a booster
pump, which typically raises the water pressure to 11 bar before supplying it to the intensifier.
Sometimes water is softened or long chain polymers are added in additive unit.
Thus, as the intensifier works, it delivers high pressure water (refer Fig. 11). As the larger piston
changes direction within the intensifier, there would be a drop in the delivery pressure. To counter
such drops, a thick cylinder is added to the delivery unit to accommodate water at high pressure.
This is called an accumulator which acts like a fly wheel of an engine and minimizes fluctuation
of water pressure.
High-pressure water is then fed through the flexible stainless steel pipes to the cutting head. It is
worth mentioning here that such pipes are to carry water at 4000 bar (400 MPa) wit h flexibility
incorporated in them with joints but without any leakage. Cutting head consists of orifice, mixing
chamber and focusing tube or insert where water jet is formed and mixed with abrasive particles to
form abrasive water jet.
8|P a g e
Typical diameter of the flexible stainless steel pipes is of 6 mm. Water carried through the pipes is
brought to jet former or cutting head. [4]
5.2 Tubing
High pressure tubing used to transport fluid from one system component to another is thick walled,
with the ratio of the outside to inside diameter at least 5 and sometimes as high as 10. The tubing
may be made from a stainless steel wall or a composite wall with stainless steel inside and carbon
steel as a jacket. Tubing may be used to constrain fluids at a pressure g reater than the yield stress
of the tube material by the use of a process known as autofrettaging or self hooping.
5.3 Tube-fittings
A metal to metal line contact is usual technique for achieving a fluid seal in high pressure tube
fittings, accomplished by drawing a cone shape into a rounded socket. The cone may be machined
directly onto the tubing or a cone shaped insert may be used. At the highest pressures, the
replaceable cone design is the most workable.
5.4 Valves
Most high pressure valves are of the needle type. The main flow passage is controlled by a cone
shape on the end of the needle fixed into a seat. A gland seal is usually required to eliminate leaks
along the stem.
5.5 Nozzles
Nozzles meant to convert the high pressure liquid to a high velocity jet present a severe challenge
to the designer. For minimum erosion, the nozzle material should be extremely hard. Yet to allow
the formation of smooth contour, the material should be ductile and easily machinable. Nozzles
made of sintered diamond or sapphire are available and they can be used as inserts in a steel holder
that provides needed strength and ductility. Diamond, tungsten carbide and special steels have also
been used successfully for making quality nozzles.
A nozzle with an exit diameter of 0.05-0.35 mm gives a coherent jet length up to 3-4 cm. A method
of increasing this length is to add to the cutting water up to 1 percent of long chain polymer, such as
polyethylene oxide with a molecular weight of four million, which produces m uch higher fluid
viscosities. With such an additives, coherent jets of up to 600 diameters in length have been
achieved.
In abrasive water jet systems use the same basic two-stage nozzle as shown in the FIG. First, water
passes through a small-diameter jewel orifice to form a narrow jet.
9|P a g e
1 - high-pressure
water inlet
2 - jewel (ruby or
diamond)
3 - abrasive (garnet)
4 - mixing tube
5 - guard
6 - cutting water jet
Fig: 12 Diagram of nozzle
7 - cut material
The water jet then passes through a small chamber where a Venturi effect creates a slight vacuum
that pulls abrasive material and air into this area through a feed tube. The abrasive particles are
accelerated by the moving stream of water and together they pass into a long, hollow cylindrical
ceramic mixing tube. The resulting mix of abrasive and water exits the mixing tube as a coherent
stream and cuts the material. It's critical that the jewel orifice and the mixing tube be precisely
aligned to ensure that the water jet passes directly down the center of the mixing tube. Otherwise
the quality of the abrasivejet will be diffused, the quality of the cuts it produces will be poor, and
the life of the mixing tube will be short. [5]
Water jet
Mixing
chamber
Trajectory of an
abrasive particle
Interaction with
focussing tube
Focusing
tube
Tungsten carbide is used for its abrasive resistance. Abrasive particles during mixing try to enter the
jet, but they are reflected away due to interplay of buoyancy and drag force. They go on interacting
with the jet and the inner walls of the mixing tube, until they are accelerated using the momentum
of the water jet.
Mixing process may be mathematically modelled as follows. Taking into account the energy loss
during water jet formation at the orifice, the water jet velocity may be given,
11 | P a g e
where,
= Coefficient of vena-contracta,
During mixing process as has been discussed both momentum and energy are not conserved due to
losses that occur during mixing. But initially it would be assumed that no losses take place in
momentum, i.e., momentum of the jet before and after mixing is conserved.
The momentum of air before and after mixing will be neglected due to very low density. Further, it
is assumed that after mixing both water and abrasive phases attain the same velocity of v
wj .
Moreover, when the abrasive particles are fed into the water jet through the port of the mixing
chamber, their velocity is also very low and their momentum can be neglected.
12 | P a g e
5.7 Catcher
Once the abrasive jet has been used for machining, they may have sufficiently high level of energy
depending on the type of application. Such high-energy abrasive water jet needs to be contained
before they can damage any part of the machine or operators. Catcher is used to absorb the
residual energy of the AWJ and dissipate the same. Fig. 14 shows three different types of catcher
water basin type, submerged steel balls and TiB plate type.
2
Fig: 14
13 | P a g e
The top of the kerf is wider than the bottom of the kerf. Generally the top width of the kerf is equal
to the diameter of the AWJ. Once again, diameter of the AWJ is equal to the diameter of the
focussing tube or the insert if the stand-off distance is around 1 to 5mm. The taper angle of the kerf
can be reduced by increasing the cutting ability of the AWJ. [4]
14 | P a g e
7. Process Parameters
For successful utilization of WJM process, it is necessary to analyze the following process criteria:
1) Material Removal Rate (MRR)
2) Geometry and finish of work piece.
3) Wear rate of nozzle
However, the process criteria are greatly influenced by various process parameters as enumerated
below:
a) MRR depends on the reactive force F of jet.
Again, Reactive force=Mass flow rate (m) Jet velocity(V)
Hence MRR m V
And the velocity depends on fluid pressure whereas mass flow rate depends on both- nozzle
diameter (d) and fluid pressure (P).
Hence, MRR d P
British Hydromechanic Research Association have found following empirical relationship:
V=14.1P (1/2)
Q=0.67 K N d 2P (1/2)
HHP=K N d2 P (3/2)
F=0.079 K N d2 P
Where,
V=maximum water jet velocity at nozzle outlet (m/s),
Q=water flow rate through the nozzle,
HHP=hydraulic horsepower of jets (W),
F=reactive force of jet nozzle (N),
K=nozzle discharge co efficient (dimensionless),
N=no of nozzle used (dimensionless),
15 | P a g e
16 | P a g e
8. Machining characteristic
Results of the tests conducted confirm the following:
1) Cutting or piercing ability of jets is most eminent when impinged perpendicularly on the work
piece surface.
2) Value of specific stock removal energy in cutting has been found to be lower than that in
piercing. This fact can be explained by assuming the groove generated in cutting allows for counter
flow of the jet to escape freely and lessens it tendency to build a liquid cushion .
3) Opening of the groove cut or the hole pierced becomes enlarged and irregular in shape with the
increase of SOD.
However, as stated earlier, the material removal rate increases as SOD is increased within a certain
range. It has been found that MRR is maximum for SOD between 3 to 5 mm.
17 | P a g e
Extrapolation of this figure indicates that there is threshold pressure below which little or no cutting
can be achieved. For example, mild steel requires about 6 Kbar pressure to produce effect.
Variation of MRR with P indicating that the MRR varies approximately with P(3/2) and consequently
to the working power of a jet, except for the material which are less machineable at these pressure
levels, e.g. steel and brass. The working power E of a jet is the energy carried by a is density of liquid
and a is the cross sectional area of the jet. It is interesting to observe that the curve lead is
discontinuous and consist of two parallel lines. The value of specific stock removal energy (i.e. the
energy required to erode unit volume of the work material) changes from 3.310 to 0.5910^6
J/cm^3 at a pressure between 4 to 6 Kbar. Observation of the wall surfaces of the groove cut by the
jets of higher velocities suggests the occurrence of brittle fracture and is supposed to bear a certain
relation to the velocity of plastic waves propagating in the material.
process lagging behind the impacting phenomenon. The depth of groove has also been reported to
decrease with increase in feed rate. [6]
18 | P a g e
9. Applications:
Aerospace
Application
Titanium bodies for military aircraft
Engine components (aluminum, titanium, heat-resistant alloys)
Aluminum body parts
Interior cabin panels
Custom control panels and structural components for special purpose aircraft such as crop dusters and float planes
Rough trimming of turbine blades on jet engines
Aluminum skin, struts, seats, shim stock, brake components, titanium & exotic metals used in
manufacturing landing gear
Industries
Aerospace, Tool & Die, Job Shop
Application
To cut floor medallions, tabletop inlay, Wall inlay, metal inlay, out door stone, Border Tiles,
Artistic & Architectural designs, murals, Stone furniture, Kitchens countertops etc in ceramic
and stone segment.
Metal art work such as out door, Theme park , Special lighting, Museum art work etc,
For profile cutting of Stained glass such as Crafts, Church Mosaics, and Lamp Shades etc.
Components for architectural trim and window systems
19 | P a g e
Industries
Architecture, Signage, Ceramic, stone, Marble, Granite, glass, Metal, Job Shop, Institute
Automotive
Application
For cutting Interior & Exterior trims such as headliners, carpets. Liners. Dumpers. Door and
instrument panels, seats, composite parts and castings
Robot waterjet can cut an automobile interior in any angles and separate Scraps
automatically
Flanges for custom exhaust systems
Specialty metal gaskets for antique automobiles
Specialty clutch components for racing cars
Specialty brake disks and components for racing cars
Custom skid plates for off-road motorcycles
Intricate decorative brackets and fittings for custom cars and motorcycles
Copper head gaskets for racing engines
Short run production for the model shops
JIT inventory control for piece parts on High Performance Radiators
Custom motorcycle bodies
Industries
Automotive, Marine, Job Shop
20 | P a g e
Electronic
Application
Circuit boards (Populated & unpopulated)
Cable stripping (Insulation coverings)
Custom and short run electrical enclosures and control panels
Custom designed elevator control panels
Industries
Electronics, Solar, Machine Shop, Job Shop
Application
In Manufacturing elevators, service lifts, Dumb waiters for various profiles cutting
To Manufacture architectural components and metal fittings for elevators
Industries
Elevator Manufacturer, lifts, dumb waiters
21 | P a g e
Application
Components (primarily from stainless steel and plastic) for food processing lines
Guards, enclosures, food handling and packaging equipment
Custom food processing equipment
Beverage manufacturing equipment
Specialty liquid filling equipment
Industries
Food Services, Chemical, Electronics, Packaging Plants, Tool & Die, Machine Shops, Job Shop etc.
Gasket
Application
Gaskets of Asbestos, Rubber, Teflon, Copper, Titanium, etc for end users & O.E.M industries
like automotive, marine, Engineering, Aerospace and many more
Industries
Customized Gaskets industry, Marine Industry, Job Shop etc.
22 | P a g e
Glass
Application
To cut Special shaped window panels for cabinets and doors
To cut Lens blanks from glass and quartz
To cut Glass components used in the electronic and medical industry
To cut Optical laser parts for various high tech industries
To cut Custom glass panels for the space shuttle
To cut Replacement glass for antique autos
To cut Art deco mirror designs
To cut flat glass with numerous contours, Stained glass, Bullet proof glass, Optical glass
Industries
Electronics, Carpentry, Glass, Aerospace, Lighting, Art, Job Shop etc.
Medical/Surgical
Application
Blanking out surgical instruments from special steel alloys
Cutting artificial limb components from carbon fiber
Composites
Manufacturing carbon braces and orthopedic appliances
Making prototype medical devices for test and evaluation
Industries
Medical, Surgical, Job Shop [7]
23 | P a g e
24 | P a g e
3) With Milling
Key Milling Strength
A well-understood familiar technology
Able to make three-dimensional parts
Rapid production if set up and programmed for long-run parts
4) With Laser
Key Laser Strength
Very fast production with thin, non-reflective materials such as sheet steel
Accuracy to 0.001" (0.025 mm) or better in thin material
25 | P a g e
The key reasons laser shops and laser users buy a precision abrasivejet is it typically costs 1/3 the
capital price of a laser and can work a much wider variety of materials, particularly aluminum and
stainless steel over 1/2 inch (13 mm) thick. A shop that previously farmed out work to a laser house
can afford to buy an abrasivejet and perform the work in-house, saving money and improving
scheduling and flexibility. This also means a laser house can afford to purchase a precision
abrasivejet solely to work in thicker aluminum and stainless steel and in material that a laser can
not cut (such as composites, ceramics, titanium, etc).
26 | P a g e
27 | P a g e
No mechanical stresses
Waterjet machining does not introduce any stresses into the material.
Environmentally friendly
As long as you are not machining a material that is hazardous, the spent abrasive and waste
material become suitable for land fill. The garnet abrasive is inert and can be disposed of with your
other trash.
If you are machining lots of lead or other hazardous materials, you will still need to dispose of your
waste appropriately, and re cycle your water. Keep in mind, however, that very little metal is
actually removed in the cutting process. This keeps the environmental impact relatively low, even if
you do machine the occasional hazardous material.
In most areas, excess water is simply drained to the sewer. In some areas, water treatment may be
necessary prior to draining to sewer. In a few areas, a "closed loop" system that recycles the water
may be required.
The pumps do use a considerable amount of electricity, though, so there is some additional
environmental (and cost) impact due to this.
29 | P a g e
11.2 Disadvantages
Among various cutting methods, Waterjet cutting is one of the most useful machining processes
that can be readily substituted for many other cutting methods; however, this method too has
some limitations to what Steel Profiles it can cut.
1. By using waterjet metal cutting method only a limited number of materials can be cut
economically. Thus being one of the main disadvantages of waterjet cutting. While it is possible to
cut tool steels, and other hard materials, the cutting rate has to be greatly reduced, and the time to
cut a part can be very long. Because of this, waterjet cutting can be very costly and outweigh the
other advantages that it offers.
2. One more disadvantage of waterjet cutting method is that it is not possible to cut very thick parts
with waterjet cutting as there may be problems in maintaining the dimensional accuracy of the
metal to be cut. If the part is too thick, the jet may dissipate some, and cause it to steel cut on a
diagonal, or to have a wider cut at the bottom of the part than the top. It can also cause a ruff wave
pattern on the cut surface.
3. Taper is also a problem with waterjet cutting in very thick materials. Taper is when the Steel
Cutter jet exits the part at a different angle than it enters the part, and can cause dimensional
inaccuracy. Decreasing the speed of the head may reduce this, although it can still be a problem.
[10]
30 | P a g e
Eye protection
You can put splash guards on the nozzle and cover it with rags and you will still get the occasional
splash of water mixed with abrasive. You do not want to get abrasive in your eye,although it's inert,
it's still abrasive and will irritate your eyes and possibly scratch your cornea.
Ear protection
When you are cutting above water always wear ear protection. The water exits the nozzle at about
the speed of sound and makes a lot of noiseenough noise to damage your hearing. When cutting
underwater, the noise level is much lower, but depending on your shop environment, you may still
want to use ear protection. [9]
31 | P a g e
14. Conclusions:
A variety of material can be cut by this process. Some of the material which have been successfully
cut at the British Hydromechanics Research Association (BHRA) using high pressure water jets are,
asbestos cement board, break shoe material, cordu roy, erepe, high density polyethylene, leather,
news print, fabric, plywood, polypropylene gasket material etc. The Japanese engineers too are
doing considerable researches in the field. It is expected that a safer and more effective tool for
quality cutting will emerge in the next few years with WJM opening up a new era in modern
machining.
32 | P a g e
References
1. Water jet cutter- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_jet_cutter dated-13.02.2011
2. Waterjetcutting-http://www.mfg.mtu.edu/cyberman/machining/non_trad/waterjet/
dated-13.02.2011
3. Waterjet cutting machines & product- www.flowwaterjet.com dated-25.02.2011
4. Journal-Water jet machining & Abrasive water jet machining-Version-2 ME,IIT Kharagpur
nptel.iitm.ac.in/courses/Webcourse-contents/.../pdf/LM-37.pdf dated-06.02.2011
5. Modern Machining Process-P.C.Pandey & H.S.Shan
6. Non-conventional machining-P.K.Mishra
7. Application-http://www.waterjet.co.in/waterjet-applications.htm dated-16.02.2011
8. Waterjet cutting machines- http://www.omax.com/compare-waterjet.php dated25.02.2011
9. The most complete waterjet resources on the web- http://www.waterjets.org/ dated16.02.2011
10. Disadvantages of waterjet cutting method-http://www.articlesbase.com/industrial-articles/disadvantages-of-waterjet-cutting-method-1236554.html dated-16.02.2011
11. Google Images
33 | P a g e