Numerical Calculation of Simultaneous Ab
Numerical Calculation of Simultaneous Ab
Numerical Calculation of Simultaneous Ab
1991,30, 2598-2603
Literature Cited J. Am. Oil Chem. SOC.1973,50,31-38.
(9) Mark, H. F.; Othmer, D. F.; Overberger, C. G.; Seaborg, G. T.,
(1)Ahmed, M. U.;Hussian, S. K.; Ahmed, M.; Osman, S. M. Cy- Eds. Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology; Wiley Interscience:
clopropenoid fatty acids in seed oils of Sida acuta and Sida New York, 1978; pp 1-15.
rhombifolia (Malvaceae). J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 1976, 53, (10)Mark, H. F.;Othmer, D. F.; Overberger, C. G.; Seaborg, G. T.,
698-699. Eds. Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology; Wiley Interscience:
(2)Bharucha, K.E.; Gunstone, F. D. Vegetable oils IV-A new me- New York, 1978;pp 111-176.
thod of determining the component acids of oils containing epoxy (11)Official and Tentative Methods of American Oil Chemists’
and/or hydroxy acids. J. Sci. Food Agric. 1955,6,373-380. Society, 3rd ed.; AOCS: Champaign, IL, 1973;Vol. 11, Methods
(3)Bharucha, K.E.; Gunstone, F. D. Vegetable oils Part VI-The Da 15-48and Da 16-48.
Component acids of Ergot oil. J. Chem. Soc. 1957, Part 1, (12)Schneider, E. L.; Loke, S. P.; Hopkins, D.T. Gas liquid chro-
610-614. matographic analysis of cyclopropenoid acids. J. Am. Oil Chem.
(4)Daulatabad, C. D.; Hosamani, K. M.; Desai, V. A. Cyclopropenoid SOC.1968,45, 585-590.
fatty acids in the Plumbaginaceae plant family. Chem. Znd. 1987,
126-127.
(5) Davis, E. N.; Wallen, L. L.; Goodwin, J. C.; Rohwedder, W. K.; * To whom correspondence should be addressed.
Rhodes, R. A. Microbial Hydration of cis-9-Alkenoic Acids. Lip-
ids 1969,4,356-362. Chirag Mahmood Jehan D. Daulatabadl
(6)Fioriti, J. A.; Sims, R.J. A spray reagent for the identification Vijayaraj A. Desai, Kallappa M. Hosamani
of epoxides on thin layer plates. J. Chromatogr. 1968, 32, Department of Chemistry
761-763.
(7)Harris, J. A.; Magne, F. C.; Skau, E. L. Cyclopropenoidfatty acids Karnatak University
11-A step-wise hydrogen bromide titration method for cyclo- Dharwad 580 003, India
propenoid and epoxy derivatives. J. Am. Oil Chem. SOC.1963,40,
718-720. Received for review May 20, 1991
(8)Kleiman, R.;Spencer, G. F. Gas Chromatography-Mass Spec- Revised manuscript received September 3, 1991
trometry of methyl esters of unsaturated oxygenated fatty acids. Accepted September 16, 1991
dx2
+ d2[C032-]
dx2
cannot be safely extended to the more complex case of
multiple-gas absorption presently considered. total sulfur balance
d2[H2S]
Chemistry
When H2S and C02 are being absorbed in a hydroxide
+-d2[HS-]
dx2
solution, the following reversible reactions should be con-
sidered (Astarita and Gioia, 1965): total hydroxide balance
C02 + OH- HC03- (1) d2[OH-]
D-= R1+ Rz + R3 + R4
H2S + OH- + H2O
HS- (2) dx2
At the gas-liquid interface, x = 6, the following equations For given values, [H2S]iand [C021i,of the gas concen-
hold: tration on the interface, (7), (11)-(13), and (23)-(25) con-
stitute the system to be solved. The unknowns are the
7)
Nco, = -D( d[CO2l enhancement factors fi and f2 and the concentration of
i each component across the liquid film.
dx dx
ion concentration, M, as the characteristic concentration
and the film thickness 6 as the characteristic length. The
=0 (17) fundamental dimensionless group appearing is the reac-
i
tion-diffusion parameter A, given by
A = kMa2/D (27)
where tD = a2/Dis the characteristic diffusion time. For
+
dx dx
-1
d[HCO3-] d[S2-]
-
i
(18)
a reasonably well mixed liquid, tD varies within a relatively
narrow range (Astarita et al., 1983):
4 x 10-3 < tD< 4 x io-* (28)
Relations 15 and 16 equate the transfer rates at the gas The system is solved numerically by discretizing the
and liquid sides for COPand H2S, respectively. Equation equations to N + 2 points across the liquid film. In this
17 states that no carbon-containing ions pass the interface, formulation, the unknowns are the concentrations of each
nor can they be converted infinitely fast into C02. of the seven species at the N + 1 points (point 1 is at the
Equation 18 is a budget of [OH-] ions at the interface and edge of the liquid film) and the two enhancement factors,
is the outcome of the following arguments Since no [OH-] a total of [7(N + 1)+ 21. Equations 11-13 and 23-25 are
ions cross the interface, the diffusion-induced flux and the applied to each point across the film, giving 6(N 1) +
surface rate of consumption at the interface s u m up to zero. equations. Two equations are provided by specifying the
H2Sand C02concentrations on the interface and another
N by applying (7) to the N interior points of the film. To
this end, the derivative in (7) is approximated by central
finite differences.
where Ril,Riz,Ri3,and Ri4are the surface rates of reactions The last equation needed is provided by applying (7) at
1,2,3, and 4 respectively, right on the interface. It is noted the point N + 2, right on the interface. Boundary con-
that the surface rate of consumption can be nonzero only dition 15 is discretized at point N + 2 by a central finite
for instantaneous reactions; therefore Ril = 0. The other difference formula, and the hypothetical concentration at
surface rates are calculated by writing down appropriate point N + 3, outside the gas-liquid interface, is used to
budgets at the interface for each instantaneous reaction derive the following expression for the second derivative
separately, as follows: on the interface:
[HZSli,kmol/m3
[CO& kmol/m3
S, kmol/m3
25 OC
0.060
0.019
0.5
225 OC
0.060
0.019
0.5 E
20 11 J H2S
C, kmol/m3
M, kmol/m3
0.5
2.0
0.5
2.0 -
L
a 10
-IO1
-5 0 5 10 15
log(A/M)
" Figure 2. HzS and COSenhancement factors as a function of the
E
e
reaction-diffusion parameter, using the equilibrium constants at 225
O C and bulk concentrations indicated in Table I.
c
5
"Ea
0 5
log(AIM)
10 15
kB
Figure 1. H2S and COz enhancement factors as a function of the
t
b
reaction-diffusion parameter, using the equilibrium constants at 25
"C and bulk concentrations indicated in Table I.
f
8
liquid concentration of the reaction products is zero. This
permits comparison with the approximate analytical results
of Astarita and Gioia (1965). The outcome indicates that 0.0 0.3 0.6 0.9 1.2 15
the approximate model overestimates the absorption of
Xi6
C02, a discrepancy which diminishes as the C02reaction
rate approaches infinity. The most serious drawback of Figure 3. Concentration profiles across the film for parameter
that model, however, is its neglect of reversibility effects. values indicated in Table I (225 "C)and very fast COz reaction. The
Forced desorption cannot be predicted by the Astarita- concentrations are scaled by the factors indicated on the figure to
permit presentation on the same plot. A maximum in the COz con-
Gioia model, and it is under conditions favoring such centration close to the interface, indicative of forced desorption, is
phenomena that the model is expected to fail. observed.
Following the above comparisons, absorption into a
liquid with nonzero concentration of the reaction products takes over for values of A I M above lo8.
is considered and the effect of two parameters, reaction The effect of the second dissociation of CO, is illustrated
rate and temperature, is, studied in detail. by setting K3 = K4 = 0 and recalculating the enhancement
(a) Effect of t h e Rate of Reaction. To illustrate the factors. The results, which appear as dashed lines in
effect of the reaction-diffusion parameter, A , the following Figure 1, indicate that the second dissociation has a fa-
two cases are considered: The equilibrium constants used vorable effect on the selective absorption of H2S. For a
are those corresponding to the reactions taking place (case large range of reaction rates, inclusion of the second dis-
i) at 25 "C and (case ii) at 225 "C. These parameters, as sociation leads to an increase of the H2S enhancement
well as the bulk concentrations used, are given in Table factor with an even more significant decrease of the C 0 2
I. For the specific system and conditions considered the enhancement factor. This is expected, since in the absence
reaction-diffusion parameter is fully specified. The com- of C032- ions there is a single reaction plane for both gases
putations, however, are performed by varying A as a pa- defined by the depletion of OH-ions.
rameter in order to illustrate its effect on the absorption It is interesting to contrast this observation with the
-
rates. It should be noted that, in the limit of instantaneous
reactions (A a),selective absorption of CO, is favored
in case i and that of H2S is favored in case ii.
well-known negative effect of the CO2-ions on the ther-
modynamic selectivity of H2S (Astarita et al., 1983). This
is an example of the case where factors influencing the
The results for case i are presented in Figure 1. With thermodynamic selectivity in one way could have the op-
decreasing reaction rate, there is a transition from a posite effect on the kinetic selectivity.
thermodynamic selectivity favoring the absorption of CO, The results for case ii are presented in Figure 2. The
to a kinetically imposed selective absorption of H2S. It C02enhancement factor first increases with reaction rate,
is interesting to note that kinetic selectivity in favor of H2S reaching a maximum at some intermediate value. The Ha
is still dominant for values of A I M as high as lo6 (corre- enhancement factor exhibits a minimum in the same range
sponding to C 0 2 reaction rate constant of lo8 m3/(kmol of reaction rates and then asymptotically reaches a plateau,
s)) and thermodynamic selectivity in favor of COP only with CO, dipping to large negative values.
2602 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 30, No. 12,1991
Table 11. Enhancement Factors for H$3 and Cot here is incorporated in a computer code, which will be used
Absorption as a Function of Temperature in the interpretation of data from experiments already
temD. O C H,S enhancement CO, enhancement under way.
25 20.3 1.2
75 50.0 2.7 Acknowledgment
125 68.0 6.4
175 76.5 -23.1 Financial support for this work has been obtained from
225 80.6 -92.7 the European Economic Communities (program VALO-
REN), from the General Secretariat for Research and
The behavior in the limit of large values of the reac- Technology of Greece, and from the Greek Public Power
tion-diffusion parameter is an example of forced desorp- Corporation (PPC).
tion, discovered by Cornelisse et al. (1980)and analyzed
for irreversible reactions by Astarita and Savage (1982). Nomenclature
Indeed, the concentration of C02 in the bulk is much A = dimensionless reaction-diffusion parameter, A = kMa2/D
smaller than on the interface and an overall driving force C = total carbon concentration, kmol/m3
for absorption exists. Reversibility effects close to the D = molecular diffusivity, m2/s
interface, however, overshoot to COPconcentration above = enhancement factor of gas j
the interface value, leading to desorption. A concentration
profile for such a case is shown in Figure 3.
fi= ionic strength of solution, kion/m3
k = reaction rate constant, m3/(kmol s)
(b) Absorption at High Temperatures. Some con- K . = equilibrium constant of reaction j , m3/kmol
cern has been expressed in the literature (Hohlfeld, 1980) d = total metallic ion concentration in solution, kmol/m3
about the efficiency of selective absorption of H2S by Nj = molar flux of species j , kmol/(m2 s)
scrubbing with hydroxide solutions at elevated tempera- Rj = volume rate of reaction j , kmol/(m3 s)
tures, in view of the increased reaction rate of the com- R , = surface rate at the interface of reaction j, kmol/(m2s)
petitive absorption of COO. However, the above results S = total sulfur concentration in solution, kmol/m3
indicate that the process could still prove efficient. T = absolute temperature, K
To further investigate the effect of temperature on the x = distance, measured from the edge of film toward the
selectivity of the system at hand, a series of runs is carried interface, m
y, = COzconcentration at location j across the film, kmol/m3
out with bulk concentrations S = 0.5, C = 0.5, and M =
2.0 and temperatures ranging from 25 to 225 "C. The gas Greek Letters
phase is assumed to consist of H2S and C02,with partial 6 = film thickness, m
pressure of 0.5 atm each. The reaction rate constant, as Registry No. H@, 7783-06-4;C02, 124-389NaOH, 1310-73-2.
given by (5b), is used and the dependence of Henry's law
and equilibrium constants on temperature is also taken Literature Cited
into account. The results, which are presented for selected
temperatures in Table 11, indicate a monotonic increase Al-Ghawas, H.A.; Sandall, 0. C. Modeling the simultaneous trans-
in the H2S enhancement factor with temperature. The port of two acid gases in tertiary amines with reversible reactions.
Sep. Sci. Technol. 1988,23,1523-1540.
behavior of C02 is more interesting. An increase in the Astarita, G.; Gioia, F. Simultaneous absorption of hydrogen sulfide
enhancement factor with temperature is observed first, and carbon dioxide in aqueous hydroxide solutions. Ind. Eng.
attributable to the increase of the kinetic constant. At high Chem. Fundam. 1965,4,317-320.
temperatures, however, reversibility effects come into play Astarita, G.; Savage, D. W. Simultaneous absorption with reversible
and finally forced desorption of C02 occurs. Actual ab- instantaneous chemical reaction. Chem. Eng. Sci. 1982, 37,
sorption rates for C02 are adversely affected, as noted by 677-686.
Astarita, G.; Savage, D. W.; Bisio, A. L. Cas Treating with Chemical
Yu and Astarita (1987),even at lower temperatures by the Solvents; Wiley: New York, 1983;pp 36,93,and 253.
combined effects of the increase in C02 back-pressure and Barbero, J. A.; McCardy, K. G.; Tremaine, P. R. Apparent heat
Henry's law constant with temperature. On the basis of capacities and volumes of aqueous hydrogen sulfide and sodium
the results presented, it can be argued that the selectivity hydrogen sulfide near 25 "C. The temperature dependence of H a
in H2S absorption will initially deteriorate with tempera- ionization. Can. J. Chem. 1982,60,1872-1880.
ture, possibly reaching a minimum before 100 "C, but will Change, C. S.; Rochelle, G. T. Mass transfer enhanced by equilib-
rium reactions. Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam. 1982,21, 379-385.
improve dramatically at higher temperatures. Cornelisse, R.; Beenackers, A. A. C. M.; Van Swaij, W. P. M. Si-
multaneous absorption of two gases in a reactive liquid, one gas
Conclusions reacting instantaneously. Chem. Eng. Sci. 1977,32,1532-1535.
Absorption of H2S and COPin aqueous hydroxide solu- Comelisse, R.; Beenackers, A. A. C. M.; Van Beckum, F. P. H.; Van
tions is studied numerically. A computational scheme is Swaij, W. P. M. Numerical calculation of simultaneous mass
transfer of two gases accompanied by complex reversible reac-
developed for this complex system, which is shown to tions. Chem. Eng. Sci. 1980,35,1245-1260.
converge for any possible value of the parameters involved. De Leye, L.; Froment, G.F. Rigorous simulation and design of col-
In particular, varying the reaction rate of the noninstan- umns for gas absorption and chemical reaction-I1 Plate columns.
taneous reaction over more than 15 orders of magnitude Comput. Chem. Eng. 1986,10,505-515.
causes no convergence problems and the correct asymptotic Glasscock, D. A.; Rochelle, G. T. Numerical simulation of theories
results (pure diffusion at one end and instantaneous re- for gas absorption with chemical reaction. AIChE J. 1989,35,
1271-1281.
action at the other) are recovered. This scheme can easily Goettler, L.A.; Pigford, R. L. Computational studies of the simul-
be adapted to a different set of reactions. taneous chemical absorption of two gases. AIChE J. 1971,17,
Kinetic selectivity toward H2S is observed for a wide 793-800.
range of values of the C02 reaction rate constant. It is Hohlfeld, R. W. Selective absorption of Ha from sour gas. J. Pet.
demonstrated that the second dissociation of C02further Technol. 1980,32, 1083-1089.
enhances this phenomenon. Finally, forced desorption of Onda, K.; Sada, E.; Kobayashi, T.; Fujine, M. Gas absorption ac-
companied by complex chemical reactions-I. Reversible chem-
COP,possibly leading to very high selectivity, is shown to ical reactions. Chem. Eng. Sci. 1970a,25,753-760.
become important at temperatures well above 100 "C. Onda, K.; Sada, E.; Kobayashi, T.; Fujine, M. Gas absorption ac-
In forthcoming work, the numerical scheme presented companied by complex chemical reactions-111. Parallel chemical
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 30,No. 12,1991 2603
reactions. Chem. Eng. Sci. 1970b,25, 1023-1031. Yu, W.-C.; Astarita, G.Selective absorption of hydrogen sulfide in
Ramachandran, P. A. Simultaneoue absorption of two gases accom- tertiary amine solutions. Chem. Eng. Sci. 1987,42,419424.
panied by reversible htantaneouschemical reaction. Chem. Eng.
Sci. 1971,26, 349-355. Vasilis Bontozoglou, Anastasios J. Karabelas*
Ramachandran, P.A.;Sharma, M. M. Simultaneous absorption of Chemical F’rocess Engineering Research Institute
two gases. Trans. Inst. Chem. Eng. 1971,49,253. and Department of Chemical Engineering
Roper, G. H.;Hatch, T. F.; Pigford, R. L. Theory of absorption and Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
reaction of two gases in a liquid. Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam. 1962, P.O. Box 1517, GR 54006 Thessaloniki, Greece
2 , 144-152.
Van Krevelen, D. W.; Hoftijzer, P. J. Kinetics of gas-liquid Received for review April 1, 1991
reactions-I. General theory. R e d . Trau. Chim. 1948, 67, Revised manuscript receiued September 17, 1991
563-586. Accepted September 27, 1991