Animal Toxins
Animal Toxins
Animal Toxins
of Anaesthesia
REVIEW ARTICLE
Animal toxins
L.
KARALLIEDDE
320
Dendrotoxin (mamba)
Scorpion toxins
Mast cell degranulating
peptide (honey bee)
Apamin (honey bee)
~ Bungarotoxin
ro Conotoxin ro
Agatoxins
Funnel-web toxin
Rattlesnake venoms
j3 Bungarotoxin, notexin,
Crotoxin, taipoxin
Latrodectus (black widow
spider)
a. Bungarotoxin
Cobratoxin
Sea snake venom
a. Conotoxin
Other elapid venoms
Viper venom
Honey bee
Notexin
(myotoxin)
Scorpion toxin
Box jellyfish (blue bottles)
Portuguese man of war
Latrodectus (spider)
Latrodectus (spider)
Scorpion toxin
Sting ray
Viper venom
l.oxosceles (spider)
Scorpion toxin
Honey bee
Figure 1
Animal
toxins
321
pholipase A2 neurotoxins (e.g. beta bungarotoxin)
have been shown tu block potassium channels while
a component from the venom of the rattlesnake
(Grotalus atrox) affects caJcium channels [33].
Haemorrhagic syrnptoms are a frequent accom
paniment of bites by vipers and of some venomous
colubrids [12,34]. Venom procoagulants actvate
prothrombin, and factors V and X. Sorne venom
components have a direct thrombin-like effect.
Rattlesnake venoms can cause defibrinogenation by
activating the endogenous fibrinolytic system.
Thrombocytopenia may occur and platelet function
may be affected. Spontaneous systemic bleeding is
caused by haemorrhagins which damage the vascular
endothelium. Massive intravascular haemolysis lead
ing to renal failure follows envenomation by Russell's
viper (India [4,53], Sri Lanka [40]), which inhabits
10 South Asian countries. In Pakistan, India, Sri
Lanka, Bangladesh, Burma and Thailand it ranks
among the most important causes of snake bite
rnortaliry. The venom procoagulants activate the
clotting system with such speed and efficiency that
McFarlane was "left feeling it was too clever to be
true " [86]. Renal failure is the most devastating
effect of Russell's viper bite in Burma and Sri Lanka.
Deposition of microthrombi in the kidney contri
butes to the acute tubular necrosis which is the
commonest cause of death [6,36]. When the patient's
blood has become defibrinated and incoagulable, the
acriviry of the haemorrhagins, which damage the
vascular endothelium, and platelet abnormalities
[30] may lead to spontaneous systemic haemorrhage.
The saw scaled or carpet viper (Echis species)
probably causes more bites and deaths than any
other venomous snake worldwide [16]. Demon
stration of non-coagulating blood is the single rnost
important diagnostic test. The simple whole blood
clotting test developed in Nigeria by Warrell and
coIleagues [personal communication, 1993] should
be repeated every 6 h after the first dose of antivenom
until clotting is re-established. The test should then
be repeated daily for 3 days to ensure coagulability.
This simple aIl or nothing whole blood clotting test
proved a reliable way of identifying patients with
systemic envenomation (those that required anti
venom) [71]. The clot quality test [66,69] is of little
use in clnical management at presento After a bite
from RusseIl's viper it was found to be insensitive to
detect evolving systemic envenoming. The Malayan
pit viper produces minimal or no haemorrhagic
symptoms in spite of the fact that the patient's blood
may be incoagulable for days. This "defibrino
genation syndrome" (hypofibrinogenaemia) without
thrombocytopenia or fibrinolysis was studied ex
tensively by Reid, Chao and Thean [70] and the use
of this purified venom fraction has been under
clnical investigation as an anticoagulant [8,
84].
The smaIl scaled snake (inland taipan, Oxyuranus
microlepidotus) found in remete areas of Westem
Queensland lays good claim to being the most
venomous snake in the world, in view of its lethal
potency. The venom contains a presynaptic neuro
toxin and a prothrombin activator [56].
322
TREATMENT
Animal
323
toxins
combination
[15].
of
LV.
Scorpion venoms
Scorpion venom are known to enhance the ex
citability ofnerve and muscle cells [2]. Sorne venorns
appear to act preferentially on muscle cells [72] while
others have effects on neurones and neurotransmitter
release. Scorpion venorns have been shown to release
acetylcholine, noradrenaline and serotonin.
The alpha scorpion toxins delay inactivation of
sodium channels and thus prolong the action po
tential. The beta scorpion toxins affect activation in
addition to slowing inactivation of sodiuro channels.
The sodium channel opens at a membrane potential
level at which the channel would be normally closed
[42].
A component of scorpion venom was also found to
facilitate and then block neuromuscular transmission
in chick biventer cervicis preparations. It was shown
to induce spontaneous contractions, partIy by re
leasing acetylcholine frorn nerve endings and partly
by increasing the sodiuro permeability of muscle
membranes [76]. The first toxin that was shown to
block voltage-dependent potassium channels was
from the venom of a Mexican scorpion. Chloride
channels are important components of receptors for
inhibitory transmitters such as GABA and glycine
and a component of scorpion venom was found to
affect chloride channel activiry.
The effect of the venom in producing a contrae
ture, an initial increase in amplitude of electrically
induced muscle contractions
and spontaneous
twitching, has been attributed
to interference
with the stabilizing function of calciuro at the
muscle membrane [2]. Increased concentrations of
calciuro lessened the effects of the venom and lower
concentrations enhanced them. The venom has also
been shown to interact with receptors of the muscle
sarcoplasmic reticulum, Scorpion bites cause intense
local pain followed by sigo of autonomic nervous
system excitation
such as dilatation
of pupils,
hypersalivation, vomiting and diarrhoea. Generally,
cholinergic features are followed by adrenergic
features. Release of catecholamines produces hy
pertension, toxic myocarditis, arrhythrnias, heart
failure and pulmonary oedema. The latter is seen
following bites in India, North Africa and the Middle
East, Scorpions found in California and New Mexico
cause rnuscle fasciculations, spasms and respiratory
paralysis.
Pain requires local infiltration or ring blocks with
local anaesthetic. Antivenom is available. Aggressive
symptornatic treatment for cardiac and neurological
syrnptoms is a necessity. In patients who develop
severe adrenergic cardiovascular features, vaso
dilators (a blockers, calcium channel blockers or
ACE inhibitors) are useful. The role of cardiac
glycosides, ~ blockers and atropine is controversial.
Warrell [personal cornrnunication, 1993] advocates
antivenorn when available but this is also a subject of
vigorous debate. Serial echocardiography has been
recornrnended in the management of children after
scorpion envenomation as myocardial toxicity is a
Animal
325
toxins
References
l. Abogadie FC, Mena EE, Woodward SR, Hillyard DR, Cruz
W. Diversiry of conus neuropeptides. Scimce 1990; 249:
251-264.
2. Adam KR, Weiss eR. Actions of seorpion venom on skeletal
muscle. British foumal of Pharmacology 1958; 14: 334-339.
30. Gan ZR, Gould RJ, [acobs JW, Friedrnan PA, Polokoff MA.
Echistatin. A potent platelet aggregation inhibitor from the
venom of the viper Echis carrinatus. Journal of Biological
Chemistry 1988; 263: 19827-19832.
31. Glass TG jr. Early debridement in pit viper bites. Journal of
cm American Medical Association 1976; 235: 2513-2516.
32. Gueron M, llia R, Sofer S. The cardiovascular systern after
scorpion envenomation. A review. Clinical Toxicology 1992;
30: 245-258.
33. Harvey AL, Anderson Al, Rowan EG. Toxins affecting ion
channels. In: Harvey AL, ed. Natural and Synthetic Neuro
toxins. London: Academic Press, 1993; 129-163.
34. Hasiba U, Rosenbaeh LM, Rockwell D, Lewis JH. DIC like
syndrome after envenomation by the snake Crotalus horridus
horridus. Neu: England Jounwl of Medicine 1975; 292:
505-507.
35. Heap B}, Cowan GO. The epiderniology of snake bite
presenting to British Militaty Hospital, Dharan during 1989.
Journal of che Royal Army Medical Corps 1991; 137: 123125.
36. Hla-Mon. Paneros of acure renal failure in Burma. In:
Weatherall DI, Ledingham }GG, Warrell DA, eds. Oxford
Textbook of Medicine, 2nd Edn. Oxford: Oxford Universiry
Press, 1987; 18, 179.
37. Hmr ZS, Hyland KE, Kinzelbach R, Amr SS, Defosse D.
Scorpions et piqures de scorpions en [ordanie. Bulletin de al
Societe de Pathologie Exotique Filiales 1988; 1: 369-379.
38. Huang TT, Lynch JB, Larson DL, Lewis SR. The use of
excisional therapy in management of snake bite. Annals of
Surgery 1974; 179: 598--606.
39. Hurlbut WP, Ceccarelli B. Use of black widow spider venom
to study the release of neurotransrnitter. In: Ceccarelli B,
Clementi F, eds. Neurotoxins : Tools in Neurobtology, New
York: Raven Press, 1979; 87-115.
40. Jeyarajah R. Russels viper bite in Sri Lanka-A study of 22
cases. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
1984; 33: 506-510.
41. Johnson CA. Management of snake bite. American Family
Physician 1991; 44: 175-180.
42. jover E, Courand F, Rochet H. Two types of scorpion
neurotoxins characterised by their binding to rwo separate
receptor sites on rat brain synaprosomes. Biochemical and
Biophysical Research Communications 1980; 95: 1607-1614.
43. Karalliedde LD, Sanrnuganathan PS. Respiratory failure
following envenornation. Anaesthesia 1988; 43: 753-754.
44. Kawai N, Yamagishi S, Saito M, Furuya K. Blockade of
synaptic transrnission in the squid giant synapse by a spider
toxin OSTX). Brain Research 1983; 278: 346-349.
45. Krasnonos LN, Kovalenko AF, Ukolov NE. Sluehai rnasso
vykh ukusov karakurta v Uzbekistane. Meditsinskia Parazito
logia, Parazitarnye Bolemi (Moskva) 1989; 4: 39-42.
46. Kurnar EB, Soomvo RS, Hamdani AA, Shimy NE. Scorpion
venom cardiomyopathy. American HearcJournall992;
123:
725-729.
47. Kuo Tp, Wu CS. Clinicopathological studies on snake bites
in Taiwan. Snake 1972; 4: 1-22.
48. Lee C, Chen D, Katz RL. Characteristics ofnondepolarising
neuro-muscular block. l. Post junctional block by alpha
bungarotoxin. Canadian Journal of Anaesthesia 1977; 24:
213-219.
49. Lee CY, Chang CC, Chin TH. Pharmacological properties of
cardiotoxin isolated from fonnosan cobra venom. Naunyn
Schmiedebergs Archives of Pharmacology 1968; 259: 360-374.
50. Lucas S. Spiders in Brazil. Toxican 1988; 26: 759-772.
51. MeLennan H, Oikawa 1. Changes in function of the
neuromuscular junction occuring in tick paralysis. Canadian
Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology 1972; 50: 53-58.
52. Marltovic 0, Rexova L. The components of various types
of honeybee venoms. Chemicke Listy 1963; 17: 767-784.
53. Merchant MR, Khanna LB, Almeida AF, Aeharya VN,
Minal BV. Clinico-pathological study of acute renal failure
following viperine snake bite. Journal of che Associacion of
Physiciam of IndIa 1989; 37: 430-433.
54. Miledi R, Poner
L T. Acetylcholine
receptors
in
muscle fibers. Nature (London) 1971; 233: 599.
55. Milis AR, Passmore R. Pelagie paralysis. Lancec 1988; 1:
161-164.
56. Morrison 1, Pearn 1, Covacevich J, Tanner C, Coulter A.
Studies on the venom of Oxyuranus rnicrolepidotus. Journal
of Chemical TOXlCOlogy1983-1984; 21: 373-385.
Animal
toxins
327
wounds from pit vipers. Neui England Journa/ of Medicine
1983; 305: 443-447.
78. Snyder ee. Animal bite wounds. Hand Clinics 1989; 5:
571-590.
79. Sutherland SK. Deaths from snake bite in Australia 19811991. Medical Journal of Australia 1992; 157: 741-746.
80. Sutherland SK, Lovering KE. Antivenoros: use and adverse
reactions over a 12 month period in Australia and Papua New
Guinea. Medica! Journal of Australia 1979; ii: 671-674.
81. Swaroop S, Grab B. Snake bite mortality in the world.
Bulletin of che World Health Organizarion 1965; 10: 35-37.
82. Tiwari 1, Johnston WJ. Blood coagulability and viper
envenomation. Lancet 1986; 1: 613-614.
83. Tu AT. Biotoxicology of sea snake venoms, Annals of
Emergency Medicine 1987; 16: 1023-1028.
84. Viger IR, Glynn MFX. Ancrod (Arvin) as an alternative to
heparin anticoagulation for cardiopulrnonary bypass. Anes
thesiology 1989; 71: 870-877.
85. Warrell DA. Animal poisons. In: Manson-Bahr PEC, BeU
DR, eds. Manson's Tropical Diseases. London: Bailliere
Tindall, 1987; 855-898.
86. Warrell DA. Snake venoms in science and clinical medicine;
Russell's viper: biology, venom and treatment of bites.
Transactions of the Royal Soaety of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 1989; 83: 732-740.
87. WarreU DA. Venomous bites and stings. Medicine Inter
natumal 1992; 107: 4529--4533.
88. WarreU DA, Looareesuwan S, White NJ, Theakston RDG,
WarreU MJ, Kosakarn W, Reid HA. Severe neurotoxic
envenorning by Malayan krait Bungurus candidus (Lin
naeus): response to antivenom and anticholinesterase. British
Medical Journal 1983; 286: 678-680.
89. Wasserman SI. Mediators of irnmediate hypersensitivity.
Journa/ of Allergy and Clinical Immunology 1983; 72: 101-118.
90. Wan G, Padre L, Tuazon L, Theakstone RDG, Laughlin
LW. Toumiquet application after cobra bite. Delay in the
onser of neurotoxicity and dangers of sudden relesse.
American Journa/ of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 1988; 38:
618-622.
91. Wan G, Padre L, Tuazon L, Theakston RDG, Laughlin L.
Bites by the Philippine cobra (Naja Naja Philippinensis):
Prorninent neurotoxicity with mnimal local signs. American
Journalof Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 1988; 39: 3Ofr31 1.
92. Wan G, Theakston RDG, Hayes eG, Yambao ML, Sanga
lang R, Ranoa cr, Alquizalas E, WarreU DA. Positive
response to edrophonium in patients with neurotoxic enven
orning by cobras (Naja Naja Philippinensis). A placebo
controlled study. Neu: England [ournal of Medicin 1986; 315:
1444-1448.
93. Weber M, Changeux JP. Binding of Naja nigricollis (3H)
alpha toxin ro membrane fragments from Electrophorus and
Torpedo electric organs. l. Binding of the tritiated alpha
neurotoxin in the absence of effector. Molecular Pharmacology
1974; 10: 1-14.
94. White RR, Weber RA. Poisonous snake bite in Central
Texas. Possible indicators for antivenin treatment. Annals of
Surgery 1991; 213: 466-472.
95. Zova JA, Swanson Me, Yunginger JW. How common is
unrecognised Hymenoptera
venom allergy in the general
population? Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology 1984;
73: 139.