Engine Room Ventilation: Application and Installation Guide
Engine Room Ventilation: Application and Installation Guide
Engine Room Ventilation: Application and Installation Guide
GUIDE
ENGINE ROOM
VENTILATION
Contents
Engine Room Ventilation ................................................................. 1
Sizing Considerations .................................................................... 2
Cooling Air................................................................................. 2
Combustion Air.......................................................................... 2
Ventilation Airflow...................................................................... 2
Calculating Required Ventilation Airflow............................... 3
Engine Room Temperature .................................................. 4
Atmospheric Heat Rejection Correction Factor .................... 4
Radiant Heat......................................................................... 5
Ventilation Fans ............................................................................. 7
Fan Types ................................................................................. 7
Fan Location ............................................................................. 7
Fan Sizing ................................................................................. 7
Exhaust Fans ............................................................................ 7
Two Speed Fan Motors............................................................. 8
Routing Considerations ................................................................. 9
General Routing Principles........................................................ 9
Single & Dual Engine Applications ..................................... 10
Multiple Engine Applications............................................... 14
Special Application Routing ................................................ 17
Marine Exhaust Ejector – Automatic Ventilation
System................................................................................ 24
Additional Considerations ....................................................... 24
Radiator Sizing ................................................................... 24
Radiator Fan Sizing ............................................................ 24
Moveable Louvers .............................................................. 25
Refrigeration Equipment..................................................... 25
Exhaust Pipe Insulation ...................................................... 25
Test With Doors and Windows Closed ............................... 25
Ducting Considerations ...................................................... 25
Cold Weather Considerations ................................................. 26
Air Cleaner Icing ................................................................. 26
Extreme Cold...................................................................... 27
Boost Control...................................................................... 27
Foreword
This section of the Application and Installation Guide generally describes Engine
Room Ventilation for Caterpillar® engines listed on the cover of this section.
Additional engine systems, components and dynamics are addressed in other
sections of this Application and Installation Guide.
Engine-specific information and data is available from a variety of sources. Refer
to the Introduction section of this guide for additional references.
Systems and components described in this guide may not be available or
applicable for every engine.
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
SECTION CONTENTS
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 1
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
Sizing Considerations
A system for exhausting ventilation air
Cooling Air from the engine room must be
A portion of fuel consumed by an included in the ventilation system
engine is lost to the environment in the design.
form of heat radiated to the
surrounding air. In addition, heat from Combustion Air
generator inefficiencies and exhaust Combustion air is discussed in detail in
piping can easily equal engine- the Air Intake Systems section
radiated heat. Any resulting elevated of the Application and Installation
temperatures in the engine room may Guide. Some aspects of the intake air
adversely affect maintenance, system are discussed in this guide
personnel, switchgear, and engine or because they significantly impact the
generator set performance. engine room ventilation system
design.
Engine room ventilation air (cooling
air) has two basic purposes. In many installations, combustion
air is drawn from outside the engine
• To provide an environment that
room via ductwork that is designed to
permits the machinery and
move a large amount of air with very
equipment to function properly with
little restriction. These installations
dependable service life.
have very little impact on engine room
• To provide an environment in ventilation design. Other installations,
which personnel can work however, require that combustion air
comfortably and effectively. be drawn directly from the engine
It is important to note that cooling air is room. In these installations,
needed for more than just the engine; combustion air requirements become
the generator intake also requires cool a significant ventilation system design
clean air. The most effective way to do parameter. Approximate consumption
this is to provide a ventilation air of combustion air for a diesel engine is
source low to the ground at the rear of 0.1 m3 of air/min/brake kW (2.5 ft3 of
the package. air/min/bhp) produced. Engine-specific
combustion air requirements can be
The use of insulation on exhaust found using the resources mentioned
pipes, silencers, and jacket water in the foreword of this guide.
pipes will reduce the amount of heat
radiated by auxiliary sources. Ventilation Airflow
Radiated heat from the engines Required ventilation airflow depends
and other machinery in the engine on the desired engine room air
room is absorbed by engine room temperature as well as the cooling air
surfaces. Some of the heat is and combustion air requirements
transferred to atmosphere or, on outlined above. While it is understood
marine installations, to the sea through that total engine room ventilation
the ship’s hull. The remaining radiated airflow must take all equipment and
heat must be carried away by the machinery into account, the following
ventilation system. sections provide a means for
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 2 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
estimating the airflow required for the permissible rise in engine room
successful operation of Caterpillar temperature of 11°C (20°F).
engines and packages.
Solution:
Calculating Required Ventilation The estimated engine room ventilation
Airflow required for this arrangement:
Engine room ventilation air required for 659
Caterpillar engines and packages can V= +0 x1
1.099 x 0.017 x 11
be estimated by the following formula.
V = 3206.61 m3/min
H
V= + Combustion Air xF
D x CP x ∆T
37478
V= +0 x1
0.071 x 0.24 x 20
Where:
V = 109970.7 cfm
V = Ventilating Air (m3/min), (cfm)
H = Heat Radiation i.e. engine, Proper ventilation is heavily dependent
generator, aux (kW), (Btu/min) on the path of the ventilation air.
D = Density of Air at air temperature Applications involving high load factors
38°C (100°F). The density is and continuous full power operation
equal to require a rigorous approach based on
1.099 kg/m3 (0.071 lb/ft3) classical heat transfer calculations
accounting for radiant heat and
CP = Specific Heat of Air
allowable room temperature rise and
(0.017 kW x min/kg x °C), (0.24
adjusting with a ventilation routing
Btu/LBS/°F)
factor.
∆T = Permissible temperature rise in
engine room (°C), (°F)
(Note: Max engine room temperature
is 120°F)
F = Routing factor based on the
ventilation type discussed in the
Routing Considerations section
of this guide.
Note: If combustion air is supplied
to the engine through dedicated duct
work, “Combustion Air” should be
omitted from the formula.
Example:
The engine room for a 3412 DITA
genset has a Type 1 ventilation routing
configuration and a dedicated duct for
combustion air.
It has a heat rejection value of
659 kW (37,478 Btu/min) and a
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 3
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 4 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 5
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 6 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
Ventilation Fans
Except for special applications, natural Fan Sizing
draft ventilation is too bulky for Fan sizing involves much more than
practical consideration. Adequate just selecting a fan that will deliver the
quantities of fresh air are best supplied airflow volume needed to meet the
by powered (fan-assisted) ventilation cooling air and combustion air
systems. requirements. It requires a basic
Fan Types understanding of fan performance
The following types of ventilation fans characteristics and ventilation system
are typically used. design parameters.
Similar to a centrifugal pump, a fan
• Vane-axial
operates along a specific fan curve
• Tube-axial that relates a fan’s volume flow rate
• Propeller (m3/min or cfm) to pressure rise
(mm H2O or in. H2O) at a constant fan
• Centrifugal
speed. Therefore, fan selection not
(squirrel cage blowers)
only requires that the volume flow rate
The selection of fan type is usually be known, but also that the ventilation
determined by ventilation air volume, distribution system
pressure requirements and space be known in order to estimate
limitations within the engine room. The the system pressure rise. This
fans have various qualities that make information allows the optimum
them better suited to certain fan to be selected from a set of
applications. manufacturers’ fan curves or tables.
Fan Location Exhaust Fans
Fans are most effective when they Ventilation air exhaust systems should
withdraw ventilation air from the be designed to maintain a slight
engine room and exhaust the hot air to positive or negative pressure in the
the atmosphere. However, ideal engine room, depending on the
engine room ventilation systems will specific application.
utilize both supply and exhaust fans.
This will allow the system designer the Positive pressure should normally not
maximum amount of control over exceed .050 kPa or (0.2 in. H2O). This
ventilation air distribution. positive pressure provides the
following advantages.
The fan motors should be mounted
outside the direct flow of hot ventilating
air for longest motor life. The design of
centrifugal fans (squirrel cage blowers)
is ideal in this regard, but their size,
relative to the vane-axial or tube-axial
fans, sometimes puts them at a
disadvantage.
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 7
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 8 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
Routing Considerations
the hottest air in the engine room
General Routing Principles with incoming cool air, raising the
Correct ventilation air routing is vital average engine room temperature.
for proper operation of Caterpillar This also leaves areas of the
engines and packaged units. engine room with no appreciable
Maintaining recommended air ventilation.
temperatures in the engine room is
• For installations where
impossible without proper routing
engines draw combustion air from
of the ventilation air. The following
inside the engine room, the routing
principles should be considered when
should provide the coolest
designing an engine room ventilation
possible combustion air to the
system.
turbocharger inlets.
• Fresh air inlets should be located • For marine and offshore
as far from the sources of heat as applications, the potential exists for
practical and as low as possible. seawater to be drawn into the
• Ventilation air should be exhausted ventilation air supply; systems
from the engine room at the highest for these applications must be
point possible, preferably directly designed to prevent seawater from
over the engine. being drawn into the air intake
• Ventilation air inlets and outlets filters and ingested by
should be positioned to prevent the turbocharger. Generator
exhaust air from being drawn into cooling air must also be filtered to
the ventilation inlets (recirculation). minimize the ingestion of salt.
• Ventilation air inlets and outlets These general routing principles, while
should be positioned to prevent driven by the same basic principles of
pockets of stagnant or recirculating heat transfer, will
air, especially in the vicinity of the vary with the specific application. This
generator air inlet. section discusses the general
considerations relating to single and
• Where possible, individual exhaust dual engine applications, multiple
suction points should be located engine (3+) applications, and several
directly above the primary heat special applications.
sources. This will remove heat
before it has a chance to mix with
engine room air and raise the
average temperature. It must be
noted that this practice will also
require that ventilation supply air be
properly distributed around the
primary heat sources.
• Avoid ventilation air supply ducts
that blow cool air directly toward
hot engine components. This mixes
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 9
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
Single & Dual Engine Applications Outside air is brought into the engine
Single and dual engine applications room through a system of ducts.
are arguably the most common These ducts should be routed between
applications encountered, regardless engines, at floor level, and discharge
of engine market. air near the bottom of the engine and
generator as shown in Figure 1.
These applications will generally
require smaller engine rooms, which Ventilation air exhaust fans should be
are especially challenging in regard to mounted or ducted at the highest point
the use of good routing practices. in the engine room. They should be
directly over heat sources.
Recommended ventilation systems for
these applications, presented in order This system provides the best
of preference, are Type 1, Type 2, ventilation with the least amount of air
Type 3 and Type 4. required. In addition, the upward flow
of air around the engine serves as a
Ventilation Type 1 (Preferred
shield which minimizes the amount of
Design)
heat released into the engine room. Air
Note: In ventilation airflow
temperature in the exhaust air duct will
calculations, Type 1 systems have
be higher than engine room air
a Routing Factor of 1.
temperature.
Ventilation Type 1
Figure 1
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 10 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
Ventilation Type 2
Figure 2
Ventilation Type 3 (Alternate Note: In ventilation airflow
Design) calculations, Type 3 systems have
If Ventilation Type 1 or Type 2 a Routing Factor of 1.5.
is not feasible, an alternative As shown in Figure 3, outside air
is Type 3; however, this routing is brought into the engine room
configuration will require utilizing fans or large intake ducts. The
approximately 50% more airflow than inlet is placed as far away as practical
Type 1.
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 11
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
from heat sources and discharged into Engine heat will be dissipated with this
the engine room as low as possible. system, but a certain amount of heat
The air them flows across the engine will still radiate and heat up all
room from the cool air entry point(s) adjacent engine room surfaces.
toward the sources of engine and If the air is not properly routed, it will
equipment heat; these include the rise to the ceiling before it gets to the
engine, exposed exhaust components, engines.
generators, or other large sources
of heat. This system will work only where the
air inlets circulate the air between the
Ventilation air exhaust fans should be
engines, for dual engine applications.
mounted or ducted at the highest point
Air inlets located at
in the engine room. Preferably, they
the end of the engine room will provide
should be directly over heat sources.
adequate ventilation to only the engine
closest to the inlet.
Ventilation Type 3
Figure 3
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 12 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
Ventilation Type 4
Figure 4
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 13
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
Incorrect Airflow
Figure 5
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 14 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
Correct Airflow
Figure 6
Incorrect Airflow
Figure 7
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 15
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
Bottom-to-Top Airflow
Figure 8
Bottom-to-Top Airflow
Figure 9
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 16 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
Figure 10
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 17
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
Figure 11
Figure 12
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 18 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 19
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
Figure 14
1. Caterpillar D/G Set 5. Fuel/Water Separator
2. Radiator 6. Fuel Tank
3. Switchgear 7. Vertical Discharge Chute
4. Silencer
Figure 15
1. Caterpillar D/G Set 5. Fuel/Water Separator
2. Radiator 6. Fuel Tank
3. Switchgear 7. Partition Wall
4. Silencer
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 20 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
Figure 16
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 21
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 22 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
Figure 18
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 23
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 24 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
6096 cm/s (12,000 fpm) is a good to the engine which can cause
choice for meeting noise legislation shutdown.
requirements and cooling system
Refrigeration Equipment
performance requirements. The When refrigeration equipment is
maximum acceptable fan blade tip installed within the engine room space,
speed is 7620 cm/s (15,000 fpm) for ensure its location is such that any
Caterpillar fans. refrigerant leakage will not be drawn
Moveable Louvers into the engine’s combustion airflow.
If moveable louvers are used, specify Refrigerant chemicals, such as
those which open in a positive Freon® and ammonia, become highly
manner. Pneumatic and electric- corrosive acids in engine combustion
actuated louvers are satisfactory. chambers. This corrosion will cause
Refer to Figure 20. severe damage. Locating refrigerant
compressors near an engine room air
exhaust area is appropriate.
Exhaust Pipe Insulation
Long runs of hot, uninsulated exhaust
piping can dissipate more heat into the
engine room than all other machinery
surfaces combined.
Completely insulate all exhaust piping
within the engine room area. All hot
surfaces within the engine room
should be insulated if high air
Figure 20 temperatures are to be avoided. Do
Louver Operation not insulate engine turbochargers.
• Louvers which open from the Test With Doors and Windows
discharge pressure of the radiator Closed
fan are discouraged. Rain, ice and Ventilating systems must be designed to
snow can render them inoperative provide safe working temperatures and
within a short time and result in adequate airflow when windows, doors,
engine overheating and shutdown. and other normally closed ports are
• Do not wait to activate the louvers secured for bad weather conditions.
until the engine warms up. In an Test the ventilation system fully secured
emergency, the engine will be for bad weather. This condition will
loaded immediately and require full reflect the most severe test of the
airflow. Open the louvers as soon ventilation system. Remember that a
as the engine starts and install small room suction can exert a large
them to open fully in case of an pressure on an entrance door
emergency. or window.
• Heat sensors needlessly Ducting Considerations
complicate the system and their Design all ducting to withstand
malfunction can reduce airflow extremes of vacuum or pressure
and still maintain tight joints.
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 25
Engine Room Ventilation Application and Installation Guide
Figure 21
©2008 Caterpillar®
Page 26 All rights reserved.
Application and Installation Guide Engine Room Ventilation
Figure 22
©2008 Caterpillar®
All rights reserved. Page 27
LEBW4971-02 ©2008 Caterpillar Printed in U.S.A.
All rights reserved.