Gayet+Marshall+Sempere 1991 MZ-PC Vertebrates of Bolivia
Gayet+Marshall+Sempere 1991 MZ-PC Vertebrates of Bolivia
Gayet+Marshall+Sempere 1991 MZ-PC Vertebrates of Bolivia
OF BOLIVIA
AND THEIR STB2ATIGRAPHIC CONTEXT : A REVIEJN
MIREILLE GAYET", LARRY G. MARSHALL** & THIERRY SEMPERE***
*URA 11 du CNRS, Centre des Sciences de la Terre, Lyon I,2 7 4 3 boulevard du 11 novernbre. 69622 Villeurbanne, Fraice
** Itistitute of IIunian Origins, 2453 Ridge Road, Berkeley, California 94709, USA
***Convenio YPFB-Orstom (UR IH), Sanh Cruz de la Sierra, Bolivia.
Present addiess: Centre de GCologie GCnrale et Minire,
Ecole des Mines, 35 rue Saint-HonorC,77305 Fontninebleau, France
INTRODUCTION
Dolivia lias a rich nnd diverse record of fossil verkbratcs for the
Mcso7.oic aiid early Ceno7,oic. The majority of h e 56 knowii fossil
localities for this time interval occur in the soutlierri Altiplano and in
thc soutlicrii piut d the Cordillera 01ieiitnl (Figs. 1-4).
I n Illis pnpcr we review thc iniddlc Triassic llirougli 1)nlcocciic
fossil vertebrote record o f Bolivia in its strntigrnphic and
palcociiviroririicntal context aiid attempt to correlate tliese rocks aid
faunas with those in, adjaccrit Argeiitina, Brazil, Chile arid Pcru. As
documented below, tlie highlights of the Bolivian vertcbrale rccord
include: the taxonomically ricliest aiid best studied faunas of late
Cretaceous age (from tlie marine anti continental El Molino
Formation) aiid the spectacularly rich and only well known land
maminal fauna of e d y , but not earliest. Paleocene age (from the
Santa Luch Forination a l Tiupninpa) ti all of South Atiierica. We
show that many or tlie late Cretaceous taxa (especially selachians)
are of clironostratigrapliic value within the Andean basin. The
problem of tlie K/?; bouiidary in the Andean basin of Bolivia is
critically evaluated and based on this siudy is believed to occur
within the upper part of tIie middle mcinber of the EI Molino
Formation.
The following abbreviations are used: km, kilometers; 111, nieters;
Mil, nicgnniitiuin o r tiiillioiis of years ngo, n point in h i c ; Myr,
inillioiis of ycrus, a durntioii of tiine.
11:
~.
. . ....
303
394
ANDEAN DOMAIN
AGE
(Ma)
- O W
- 60 - 9 8
20
66.5
- 70 - 54
SUBANDEAN BELT
NORTHWEST
SOUTHEAST
ARGENTINA
PERU
Danian
Cajones i~
Maaslriclilian
- 80 - 90 -
u)
- 100 -
Conlaclan
Turonian
Cenoinnrii:rii
O
Q
Lu
I-
Albian
O
10-
-1
Aptlan
-120-
-130-
131
-140-
-150-
Yantata
-160-
o
-170-
u)
u)
3
7
lchoa
-180-
lchoa
-190Liassic
-200 -210-
-220-
210
I
!
Keuper
u)
u)
-230-
-240-
5
n
I-
Figure 1. Clironostratigrapllic chart showing vertebrate-bearing formations (*) of middle Triassic-Paleocene age in Bolivia, and in
adjacent Argentina and Peru.
395
-I
A. TACURU GROUP
Alilfcld & Brnnisa (1960) rcportcd rcinniiis of lurgc bones,
possibly of dinosaurs, from the Tacur Group in the Serrana de
Mandeyapecua. southeastern olivia. IIIthis area the Tacur Group
includes rocks of middle Triassic and Jurassic age, naiiiely tlie
Tnpccun, Cnslcll6ii aiid Ichoii forlnntiolis (Fig. 1).
U. CASI'ELLON FORMAlION
Scales and bones of semionotiform fishes were found in the late
Triassic-early Jurassic age CastelMn Formation on the western flank
of the Charagua anticline in tlie Quebrada de Charagua, 7 km west of
the town of Chbagua (Wenz, in Goi & Hoffstetter, 1964). Nothing
definite can be said of these bones, although a study of the scales
with Scanning Electron Microscopy (Gayet & Meunier, 1986) dnd of
their transverse sections permits reference to the family
Semionotidae, probably Lepidofes sp. (Gayet, 1991).
C . MIRAFLORES FORMATION
The Miraflores Formation is a marine limestone unit which, based
on knowledge of ammonites, bivalves, gastropods and echinoids,
was regarded as middle to late Ccnoiiinnian in age (ranisa et al.,
19GG; Jaillard & Scmpcrc, 1089), :itthough detailed scqucncc
sthtigrapliy now suggcsts that the entire rock unit spans Cenoinaniaii
and Turonian time (Jaillard & Sempere, in press). Near the locality
of Macha. 90 kni north-northwest of I'otos, L. Branisa found minute
pharyngeal teeth which are tentatively assigned to cf.
Cyprinodontiforines or Pycnodontiforrnes (Gayet, 1991).
I).AROIFILLA
396
FORMA'I'ION
1;
PERU
,I
,4
15"
100
km
.LA
PAZ
17"
*ChuIlDa Khasa
.COCHABAMBA
La Cabana*Parotan
pa,c~s~$~ipd
Est. Blanco Rancho
ORURO.
Arapampap
d!ilaVi'a
Lago Uru Uru
Torotoro-.
Tiupampa
-Rio Moile
USANTA CRUZ
DE LA SIERRA
19'
/-
*Chaup-Khocha
,f
echaragua
I
I'
*Calerias
*Tambo
Colorado
Salar de Uyi ni
*Camargo
Serrania
de
Manieyapecua
fI
,i
*Chocaya
21"
Chaupiuno
CHILE
Rancho Hovada-.
UTARIJA
*Villa Pacheco
Serpa\
.
((PARAGUI
'\
\
\
\
'
69"
67"
65"
63"
,
\'
F. EL MOLINO FORMATION
All three members of the E l Molino Formation have yielded
diverse vertebrate faunas which were long interpreted to indicate a
late Cainpanian-Maastriclitiaii age for this entire rock unit (Cappetta
1975, 1990; Muizon c/ al., 1983; Muizon, et al., 1984a; Marshall et
al., 1985; Gnyct, i986n, 19880; Cnrrnsco et al., 1989). However.
Palcoccnc palynological asscmblagcs ore rcportcd from the Tunal
Formation of northwestcrn Argentina (Quattrochio e/ al., 1986)
which is a stratigraphic equivalent of the upper EI Molino
Forniation, and securc Cretaceous age taxa arc rccognizcd only in
thc lower rncnibcr and basal rniddlc iricrnbcr of the EI Molino (scc
below). Van Valen (1988) has argued tliat at least some, if not all, of
the faunas of the l Molino Formation are of early, but not earliest,
Paleocene age. His arguments relied in large part on the belief by
Muizon et a l . (1983) and others, that the Tiupampa vertebrates all
come from the El Molino Formation. However, recent stratigraphic
studies conclusively demonstrate that the mammal-bearing level at
Tiupampa belongs to the Santa Luca Formation (Sempere and
Marshal, in press). For reasons documented below, the EI Molino
Formation as herein defined encompasses latest Campanian-early
Paleocene time (Fig. 1).
398
Cerro
Lama Chaqui
180
Torotor
Cruz Khasa
'
Ikm
'
Figure 3. Detailed map of tlie Torotoro area (for location, see Fig. 2) showing vertebrale localities in the CI Molino and'Santa Lucia
formations. The numbers correspond to those in Table 1. Based on Carta Nacional, Bolivia, Torotoro Quadrangle, Hoja 6439 IV,
serie 1731, 1/50,000, 1968 edition, Instituto Geogrhfico Militar, La Paz VIII-68; and San Vicente Quadrangle, Hoja 6439 I, serie
fi731, ,1/50,000, 1968 edition, Instituto Geogrhfico Militar, Ln Paz 111-68.
siluriforin (Ariidae, Rliineastes sp.) of very large size (more than 2 in
in total length). Vertebrae of Lepisosfeus sp. found in association
with the Siluriforines are also larger (more than 3 cm-long) than
those of Agua Clara (about 1cm-long). As in some levels at Agua
CI:lra, thc presence of sclaclii:ins, pycnodonti forms, tetradontiforins
and "saliiioniforins" (Enchodirs sp., ?Apateodirs sp.) testifies to some
conmunication to a sea (Gayet, 1991; Gayet et al, 1992).
Ten meters below the calcareous level just described, a restricted
conglomeratic unii was recently found with reinaius of Siluriformes
(Ariidae) and Teleostean indet. A little farher, at the crossing of the
Quebrada Saytu JoWiu with the road, are grey-green mudstones of
the upper EI Molino wilh remains of Clupeiformes (Casteroclitpea
branisai) and ostracods (Gayet, personal observation).
At Vilcapujio (=Wila Apacheta), at about hi 140 northwest of
Potosl on Uie Potosl-Challapata-Oruro road, is a bone bed probably
belonging to the basal middle EI Molino which yielded fishes
399
2. Uyuni Region
4. Cochabamba Region
At Torotoro, aboui 95 kin south-southeast of Cochabamba, several
fossil lcvcls NC known (Fig. 3).From thc iniddlc part of thc lowcr EI
Molino sonic 3 kin soulti-soutlicnst of Torotoro, Cnppctla (1975)
400
Figure 4. Detailed map of tlie Tiupampa area (for location, see Fig. 2) showing localities (1-9)from the principal vertebrate level of Ille
Santa Luca Formation, a n d localities in lhe middle (A) and upper (B) El Molino Formation. Tiupampa is the local name used by
Quechua indiuns for tlie urea shown on lhe mup. Bused on Cnrln Nacionul, Ihliviu, Sun Vicenle Quudrungle (see cuption lo Fig. 3).
(Coelurosauria; Marshall,, 1989b), indeterminate turtles. various
crocodiles nnd indeterminate trackways. At Blanco Rancho (upper El
Molino) were found Clupeirormes (Gusleroclupeu brunisui).
Siluriformes (Ariidae, RltineasfPs sp.), cf. Cyprinodontilormes,
turtles and numerous ostracods.
Trackways of small bipedal dinosaurs (Coelurosauria?) are
recorded from Abpampa at Cerrito de Llamachaqui, Departrnent of
Polosi (Leonardil 1981).
Fragments of large bones, possibly of dinosaurs, and "dientes de
tipo cnico simple" were observed in a level with gastropods in tlie
El Molino Formation near La Cabaa, north of Parotani and west of
the Ro Rocha about 35 km southwest of Cochabamba (Ahlfeld &
Branisa, 1960).
Leonardi (1981: 935) reports a series of six poorly preserved
footprints of a bipedal dinosaur in the Santa Luca Fonnation along
the Cochabamba-La Paz road near Parotani in the Suticollo Syncline,
Figure 5. Stratigrapliic sections of late Cretaceous-Paleocene rock units at Tiupampa, Pajclia Pata (+ Estancia
Ulanco Rancho), Torotoro (+ Caranota),' Potosl (road to La Falca and Cayara) and, in part, Agua Clara, showing
location of main fossiliferous levels. Undecompacted thicknesses. The base of the unconformable Cayara
Formation, is held horizontal. Fm, Formation; I, lower; m, middle; u, upper; Pz,Paleozoic: 1
,erosional surface; 2,
conglomerates; 3, conglomeratic sandstones; 4, sandstones; 5, fining and/or thinning-upward; 6, siltstones and
mudstones; 7, carbonates (mostly limestones); 8, coarsening and/or thickening-upward; 9, gypsum; 10, tuffite
bed; 1
1
,stromatolitic level; 12, dissolution breccia; 13, channels; 14, cross-bedding; 15, oiiids; 16, calcareous
cement; 17, rooting; 18, coalescent rhizolith-rich levels; 19, bioturbation; 20, red color predominant; 21, dinosaur
trackways; 22, vertebrate-bearing levels. All sections measured by T. Sempere, except parts of TorotoroCaranota and Potos (respectively by tlie Brigadas 10 and 9 of YPFU) and of Pajclia Pata and Agua Clara (by G .
Camoin and J. M. Rouchy); all were checked by the authors.
402
403
- VOL. I - VERIBBRMOS
1 and 2 , IfofJsfertericltrltyspucai and Incaiclirhys srrarezi),
Perciformes (Centropoinidnc), Polyptcriforines (Iolyptcridne,
Dajelella sudanicrictmn) and Dipiioi (Ccratodoiitidnc, Ccralodrts sp.
and cerntodont n. g., n. sp.; Lepidosirenidne, Lepidosiren cf.
paradoxa).
b) Amphibians (Rage, 1986, 1991a): Anura (Leptodactylidae);
Gymnophiona (family indet.).
c) Turtles (Broin, 1988, 1991): Podocnemididae, Roxockelys cf.
vilavilensis.
d) Lizards (Rage, 1991b): Lacertilia, ?Iguanidae and family indet.
e ) Snakes (Rage, 1991b): Aniliidae n. g.; Boidae, two species
indet.; ?Maqtsoiidae; Tropidopliiidae.
f) Crocodiles (Buffetaut, 1991; Buffetaut & Marshall, 1991):
Mesosuchia, Sebecidae, Sebecris querejazus; Dyrosauridae,
Sokorosucltus aff. iwiwilsoni. .
g) Mammals (Muizon el al., 1983; Muizon, el al., 1984a, b;
Marshall el al., 1983a, 1985. 1989; Muizon & Marshall, 1985,
198711, b, c. d, 1988, 1991. in press; Marshall, 1992: Marshall &
Muizon, 1988, 1992): Dcllotlicroidn (family indel,, J a ~ k h ~ d ~ / p l
ntinufus), Peradectia (Ieradcctidae, Peradectinae, Pcradcctes
a u s ~ r i n ~ n ~ ;Caroloainegliiiiiinne,
Roberllioffs~elleria
tiariotialgeograpliica), Microbiotheria (Microbiotheriidae, Kliasin
cordi llerensis), Did e l pli i ni or p Ii ia (Did e 1pli id oc, Did el pli i ri ne,
Piicadelpltys andinris, Incudelpliys anriqrrus, Mizquedelphys
pilpinensis; Eobrasiliinae, Tirilordia floresi), Sparassodonta
(H a t h 1i ac y n id a e, A I l qo k ir 11s a us I r a 1i s ) , Pa u c i tub e r c u 1at a
(Kollpaniidae. Kollpnnia fiupanipina), order and family indet.
(Andinodelpliys cochabanibensis), Leptictida (Palaeoryctidae?, cf.
Ciniofesles sp.), Pantodonta (Pantolambdidae, Alcidedqrbignya
inopinafa), Condylarthra (Hyopsodontidae, Mioclaeninae,
Tiuclaenus niinulus, Molinodus suarezi, Pucanodus gagnieri,
Andinodus boliviensis), and Notoungulata (cf. Henricosbomiidae or
Oldfieldthomasiidae, gen, et sp. indet.).
Criadero de Loro, a new locality about 1.2 km soutii-southeast of
the quarry at Tiupampa and from the sanie horizon (Fig. 4, locality
7). was discovered in 1989. The taxa seem to be the scarne as those
from the quarry and adjacent localities (Fig. 4, localities 1-6, 9) and
include, Siluriformes (Ariidae. Rhineasles sp.), Perciformes
(Centropornidae), Polypteriformes (Polypteridae, Dajetella
sudamericana), nu iiicrous 1a rgc lu iig fis li t ce t h (includi ti g
Ceratodoiitidiic and Lepidosircnidac), snnkcs (oidac sp. indct.),
turtles (?Roxochelys vilavilensis), crocodiles and a pantodont
(Alcidedorbignya inopinafa).
At Viln Vilb, om tin u p p x lcvcl lociilcd nbout LGO ni above the
base of tlie Cretaceous section (see Marshall el al., 1985, Fig. 4),
have come a turtle (Podocnemididae, ?Roxochelys vilavilensis;
Broin, 1971) and a crocodile (Sebecosuchia, Sebecidae, Sebecus
querejazus; Buffetnut & Marshall, 1991).
At Uie two newly discovered localities of Estancia Blanco Rancho
and Pajcha Pata, south of Cliza (Fig. 2), are bone beds of the lower
and/or upper members of the EI Molino described above, which are
overlain by red sandstones of the Santa Lucia Formation similar Lo
those at Tiupampa (Montao, 1968). A brief survey of Blanco
Rancho resulted in the recovery of numerous teleostean fishes
(Osteoglossiformes, Osteoglossidae; Siluriformes, Ariidae,
R liin ea st es sp., A n d i ni c li thy id ae , i nd e t er m i na te te leo st s),
amphibians, crocodiles (Dyrosauridae, complete skulls), turtles
TABLE 1. VERTEBRATE FOSSIL LOCALITIES OF MESOZOIC AND PALEOCENE AGE 1N BOLIVIA ARRANGED BY
STRATIGRAPHIC OCCURRENCE.
UPPER MEMBER
TACURU GROUP
1. Serrana de Mandeyapecua
31. Calazaya
32. Cayara (Cerro Muyurina)
33.* La Paka (Doliciwciranipsamininia level)
34, Pajcha Pata
35. Estancia.Blanco Rancho
36. RoFlora
37. Ro Moile
38. Tiupampa (Ro Pucnrani)
CASTELLON FORMATION
2. Quebrada de Charagua
MIRAFLORES FORMAIION
3. Macha
AROIFILLA FORMATION
4. Calerlas (dinosaur footprints)
INDEIXIMINAIE MEMUER
CHAUNACA FORMATION
5. Aguaclara
6. La Paka
EL MOLINO FORMATION
LOWER MEMBER
7. Aguaclara
8. Cayara (Cerro Muyurina)
9. Chocaya (Ro Angosto)
10. Hotel Cordillera near Wila Khasa; Quebrada Saytu Jokhu with
Gasteroclupea
11. La Palca (black shale level with Gasteroclupea, and below
stromatolites)
12. Pajcha Pata
13. Kanclio Hoyada (Quebrada Texisca)
14. Sayari (km 87)
15. Scvaruyo
16. Torobro (Ceiro Llama Chaqui. dinosaur footprink)
17. Torotoro (Uma Jalantn cave, dinosaur Foolprints)
18. Torotoro (Uma Jalantn road, dinosaur footprints)
19. Torotoro (pista de danzas. dinosaur footprints)
20. Torotoro (selachian level)
21. Vila Vila (Piccaprisky icvel)
22. Wila Kliasa (km 100)
23. Ro Flora
I
24. Parotani (=Santivaez) (dinosaur footprints)
IMIOKA FORMATION
55. Cliaupiuno
56. Villa Iachcco
MIDDLE MEMBER
404
CLASS SELACHU
Order Rajiformes
Suborder Sclerorhynchoidei
Family Sclerorhynchidae
Pucaprisris branisi Schaeffer, 1963
Iscltyrltiza Iturtenbergeri Cappetta, 1975
Scltizorkiza
slronwri Cappetta, 1975
' Order Myliobatiformes
Family Dasyatidae
Dasyaris branisai Cappetta, 1975
Dagtis molinoensis Cappetb. 1975
Dasyatis scltucfleri Cnppeltn. I975
Dasyaris nov. sp. 1
Dasyatis nov. sp. 2
Dasyalis nov. sp. 3
Family Rhoinbodonlidnc
Pucabah ltoflslelteri Cnppclln. 1975
Pucabah nov. sp.
un.
CLASS OSTEICHTHYI
Subclass Actinopterygii
Superorder "Holostei"
Order F'ycnodontiormes
Family Pycnodontidae
Coelodus roncoensis Benedetto & Sanchez, 1972
Pycnodontidae indet.
Order Semionotiformes
Family Semionotidae
Lepidoles sp.
nov. gen.
Order Ginglymodi
Family Lepisosteidae
Lepisosteus sp.
Superorder Tclcostci
Order Clupciforincs
.
Family Clupeidae
Gasreroclupeo branisai Signeux in Branisa et al. 1964
Order Osteoglossiformes
Fnrnily Oskoglossidse
Subfamily Phareodontinae
Pkaerodusiclitlzys tavrnei Gayet, 1991
Subfsinily Osteoglossinae
nov. gen.
Order "Salmoniformes"
Family Enchodontidae
Emhodis sp.
Suborder ichthyotringoidei
Family incertae sedis 1
? Apdeodus sp.
Superfamily Andiniclithyoidea
Family indef.
nov. gen.
Family Andinichthyidae
Andiniclttliys bolivianensis Gayet, 1988b
Family incertae sedis 1
Incaichfhyssuarezi Gayet, 199Ob
Family incerlae sedis 2
Hoffsfettericlitkys pucai Gayet, 19Wb
at least five gen. and sp. nov.
Superorder Atherinomorpha
cf. Order Cyprinodontiformes
gen. and sp. indel.
Superorder Acnnthopterygii
Order Perciformes
Suborder Percoidei
Family Centropomidae
gen and sp. indel.
Order Tetraodontifonnes
Family Eotrigonodontidae
Slepl~anodrrsniinintus Gayet, 1991
Subclass Sarcopterygii
Order Dipnoi
Family Ceratodontidae
Ceratodirs sp.
gen. and sp. indel.
Family Lepidosirenidae
Lepidosiren cf. paradoxa
406
FOSILES Y W a l s DE DOLMA
- VOL 1- VERIHBRAWS
CLASS AMPIIIUIA
Order A n u a
Family Lepldactylidae
gen. and sp. indel.
Order Gymnophiona
Family indel.
gen. and sp. indet.
Order Urodela
Family indel.
gen. and sp. indet.
CLASS REPTILIA
Order Ch,elonia
Family Podocnemididae
Suborder Lncertilia
Family ?Iguanidae
gen, and sp. indel.
Family indet.
gen. and sp. indel.
Suborder Ophidia
Family Aniliidae
gen. and sp. indet.
Family Boidae
gen. and sp. 1indel.
gen. and sp. 2 indel.
Family ?Madtsoiidae
gen. and sp. indel.
Family Tropidopheidae
gen. and sp. indel.
Order Crocdilia
Suborder Mesosuchia
Family Sebecidae
Sebecus querejazus Buffetaut & Marshall, 1991
Family Dyrosauridae
Sokotosukus aff. ianwilsoni Halstead, 1975
Suborder Eusuchia
Family Dolichochampsidae
Dolickoclmnpsa niininla Gasparini & Buffclnut, 1980
Order Saurischin
Suborder Tlieropda
Infraorder Coelurosauria
gen. and sp. indet.
Suborder Sauropodomorpha
Infraorder Souropoda
gen, and sp. indel.
Order Omithischia
Suborder Ornithopoda
gen. and sp. indel.
Suborder Ankylosauna or Ceratopsia
Ligabueiclinium bolivianum Leonardi. 1984
Order indef.
gen. and sp. indel.
CLASS MAMMALIA
Infraclass Metatheria
Order Deltatheroida
Family inder.
Jaskliadelphys niinutus Marshall & Muizon, 1988
Order Peradectia
Family Peradectidae
Subfamily Peradectinae
Peradectes austrinuni (Sig, 1971)
Sublamily Caroloamegluniinae
RobertlioffstetferianafionalgeograpliicaMarshall et al., 1983
Order Microbiotheria
Family Microbiotheriidae
Khasia cordillerensis Marshall k Muizon, 1988
7 Order 'Didelphimorphia
Family Didelphidae
Subfamily Didelphinae
Pucadelpliys andinus Marshall & Muizon, 1988
Incadelpliys untiqrrrrs M ~ ~ l i a&l lMuizon. 1988
M i z y r t e d e l ~ ~ l i y s p i l ~ ~ iM
n e~~~i sl i i &
i l lMuizoii, 1988
Subfamily Eobrasiliinae
Tiulordiafloresi Marshall & Muizon, 1988
Order Sparassodonta
Family Hathliacynidae
Aflqokirrlsaustralis Marshall & Muimn, 1988
Order Polydolopoidea
Family Polydo Iopdae
Epidolops sp.
Order Paucituberculata
Family Kollpaniidae
Kollpania fiupanipinaMarshall & Muizon, 1988
Order indef.
Family indef.
408
~~
~
~
TABLE 3.SYSTEMATIC LIST OF VERTEBRATES FROM THE MESOZOIC A N D PALEOCENE OF BOLIVIA WITH INDICATION OF LOCALITIES AND
STRATIGWHIC OCCURRENCE BASED ON INFORMATION IN TABLE 1 AND TEXT. Abbreviations: Ca. Castelln Formation; Mi, Mirdores Formation;
Ar, Aroifilla Formation; Ch, Chaunaca Formation.
TAXA
EI Molino Formation
Ca
Fm
-
Mi
Ar
Ch
Fm
Fm Fm
-
h s Sclachii
Order Rajiforms
Suborder Sclemrhynchoidei
Family Sdcmrhynchidae
Puraprisrir branis
lschyrhiza harrenbergen
Schizorhiza 4.srromcri
Order Myliobatifonnes
Family Dasyatidae
D q a r i s bradsat'
D q a r i s molinoemis
D q a r i s Schaeffer
D q a t i s nov. sp. 1
Dasyaris nov. sp. 2
D q a t i s nov. sp. 3
Family Rhombodontidae
Purabarir hoffsreneri
Purabatis nov. sp.
lass Ostcichthyes
;uklass Actinoptcrygii
Maclass "Holostei"
Order Pycnodontiformes
Family Pycnodontidac
Coelodur roncoqsis
gen. and sp. inder.
Order Sanionotiforma
Family Smiqnotidac
Lepidores sp.
gen. and sp. nov.
Order Ginglymodi
Family Lepisostcidac
LepisosteUr sp.
nfmclass Teleostei
Order Clupciformes
Family Qupcidae
Gasreroclupeabranisa
lower member
middle mb
11.12 14.20.21
2.25
25
7,11,20,21
7.11
Santa Luca
upper member
Fm
25
20
25
11.20
11.20
25.28
7
27
n
11.20.21
7
3?
12
7.12.13.21
25,27,30
S?
----
1.9.21
25
7,9,13
25.21
7.8.9,10,11,12,.15
25
3235.36, 37
51
Impora
Fm
El Molino Formation
~
TAXA
Mi
Fm
lower member
.
Order Osteoglossifo~es
Family Osteoglossidae
Subfamily Phareodontinac
Phareodurichthystavermi
Subfamily Ostcoglossinae
gcn. and sp.nov.
Ordcr "Sahoniformes"
Family Enchcdontidae
I, 13
Rhineasres sp.
Superfamily Andinichthyoidca
Family indet.
gen. nov.
Family Andinichthyidae
Andinichthys boiivianensis
rtndm'chrhys5p.
mpxa
Fm
-
49.51.52
2521
51
26
51
25
SuborderIchthyoiringoidei
Family inccmc sedis 1
?Apareo& sp.
Family incenac sedis 2
gen. and sp. indct.
M e r Cypriniforms
Family incenae sedis
Mdlim'chrhysinopinafus
Order Characiformes
Family Erylhrinidac
Hoplias nov. sp.
cf. Hoplias
Family Semsahidac
Subfamily Myle/e
gen. and sp. inder.
d Subfamily Senasalminac
gen. and sp. indef.
Family Characidae
SubfamilyTetragonopterinac
gen. and sp. inder.
cf. Subfamily Rhoadsiinae
gen. and sp. indef.
Ordcr Siluriformes
Family Ariidae
Fm
upper member
Enchodussp.
middle mb
Santa Luca
25
29
25
51
25
'
25.30
51
51
51
56
51
25
51
7,9, 12, 13, 14.21
75,21.30
33,35,38
41-52
56
51
12
34.35
51
49,51,52
51
51
TAXA
Superorder Athcrinomorpha
d.Order Cyprinodontiforma
gen. and sp. inder.
SuperorderAcanthoptcrygii
Order Percifoms
SuborderR a i d c i
Family Centropomidae
gen. and sp. ider.
OrderTetraodonrifomes
Family Eotrigonodontidae
Srephamdus m ' m h u
'ubdas Sarwptcrygii
Order Dipnoi
Family Ccratodontidae
Cerotodur sp.
Family Lepidcsiddac
Lepidosiren cf. paraaka
Ar
Fm
El Molino Formation
lower member
middle mb
...
25
7,12,22
Santa Luca
upper member
Fm
35
50.51.52
I, 13
25.27
53.54
51.52
12,21
SI.52
Order Polyptcrifoms
Family Polyptcridae
Dajetella sudamericana
21
ass Amphibia
Orderh u r a
Family Leptodactylidae
gen. and sp. inder.
Order Gymnophiom
Family inder.
gen. and sp. inder.
Order Urodcla
.Family inder.
gen. and sp. inder.
ES Reptilia
>der Chelonia
Family Podocncmididae
? Roxochelys vilavilensir
? Roxochelys cfi vilavilensis
Order Squamata
SuborderLacertilia
Family ?Iguanidac
gen. and sp. inder.
Family inder.
gen. and sp. inder.
Suborder Ophidia
Family Aniliidae
gen. and sp. inder.
51
51
12
14
30
33.35.38
4849.50
51-54
20.21
51
51
51
TAXA
Ca
Mi
Fm
Fm
Ar
Fm
Family Boidac
gen. and sp. inder. 1
gen. and sp. inder. 2
Family ?MvIatroiidae
gen. and sp. inder.
Family Tmpidopheidac
gen. and sp. inder.
Order Cmcodilia
Suborder Mesmuchia
Family Scbecidae
Sebeeu querejazu
lass Mammalia
nfraclassMetatheria
Order Deltathemida
Family inder.
Jmkhadelphys minufus
Order Peradmia
Family Peradcctidae
Subfamily Pcradeainae
Peradectes aurrrinum
Subfamily Camloameghh/mae
Roberrhoffsreneria nafionalgeographica
Santa Luca
El ?olino Form:
lower member
middle mb
upper member
Fm
51
51
51
1221
?.5,27,28,30
33, 38
51
48-50, 51 .
51
54
51
26
Family Dyrosauridac
S o k o i o s h off.iamviLrod
Suborder Eusuchia
Family Dolichochampsidae
Doliehochampsa minima
Order Saurischia
SuborderThcmpoda
Infraorder Coeiumsauna
gen. and sp. inder.
SuborderSaumpcdomorpha
&order Saumpoda
gen. and sp. inder.
Order Omirhischia
Suborder Omithopoda
gen. and sp. inder.
Suborder Ankylosauria or Ceratopsia
Ligabueichnium bolivianum
Order Inder.
gen. and sp. inder.
Ch
Fm
51
33
19
12,16,17. 18
19
19.3
'
19
51
51
51
Impora
Fm
TAXA
lower member
EMolino For
middle mb
_ _
Order Microbiotheria
Family Microbiotheriidae
Khasia cordil!eremis
Order Didelphimorphia
Family Diddphidae
Subfamily Didclphinae
Pucadelphys andinus
Incadelphys m q m
Mizquedelphys pilpinensis
Subfamily Eobrasiliinac
Tiuloraafroren'
Order Spalassodonta
Family Hathliacynidae
-Allqokim ausrrab
Oder Polydolopoidea
Family Polydolopidae
Epidolops sp.
Order Paucituberntlata
Family Kollpaniidae
Kollpam'a riupampina
Oder indct
Family inder.
Andinodelphys cochabambenris
Infmclass Euthcria
Oder Lcptictida
Family Palacoryctidae?
cfi Cimolesressp.
Oder Pantadonta
Family Pdntolambdidac
Alcidedorbignya inopinata
Order Condylanhra
Family Hyopsodontidac
Subfamily Moclaeninae
Tiuclaenm minurus
Moli~durs~lnrezi
h d ~ d uboliviensis
r
Pucanadur gagnien
Order Notoungulata
Family cf. Hennmsborniidae
or Oldfieldthomasiidae
gen. and sp. indct
Santa Luca
ition
upper member
Fm
.
.
.
. .
51
50
51
51
51
51
51
50
51
51
51
51,52
51
51
51
51
51
Impor:
Fm
H. IMPORA FORMATION
Fossil vertebrates of possible late Paleocene age were recovered
from two localities of lhe Impora Formation in the Camargo
Syncline. southern Bolivia. One is on the north side of Villa I'acheco
near the Ro San Juan del Oro, about 14 km norlh of Tojo, which has
yielded remains of siluriform fishes. Just north of this locality
rcntiiins of crocodics yid turtles were collected. The other localily is
at Chaupiuno, about 60 km norUiwest of Tarija. where indeterminate '
fish remains were found.
114
r-.
niid Mnrllin formations i n the Inruiil bnsin (Inle Crctaccous), tile
nnco Negro Infcrior in Pntngonin (middle Inlcocenc?), nnd ti~e
1. Late Cretaceous
From the Los Alamitos Formation at Estancia Los Alainitos in Rlo
Negro Province, southern Argentina, numerous vertebrate fossils
were found in Ulis mainly brackish-lacustrine rock unit which was
tentatively assigned a late Campanian-early Maastrichtian age
(Bonaparte el al., 1987). The taxa include: selachians (Batoidei,
indet.), holosteans (Semionotidae, Lepidoles sp.; Lepisosteidae, cf.
Alractoslerrs sp.), teleosteans (Siluriformes, cf. Diplomystidae, cf.
Ariidae; Percifohnes, Percoidei, inder.), Neopterygii indef.
(Lepidofes or Sparidae), Dipnoi (Ptychoceratodotitidae, Cerafodirs
iheringi), amphibians (Pipidae, cf. Xenopus sp.; Leptodactylidae,
indef.),turtles (Meiolaniidae, cf. Niolamia; Chelidae, indef.),snakes
(oidnc, Mndtsoniinnc. Alaniiropliis argenfiniis, Patagoniophis
parviis, RionegropIris ntadtsoioides), dinosnurs (Titnnosauridnc,
Aelosarirus rionegrinris?: Hadrosauridac, Krilosauriis auslralis),
and innminals including Symmetrodontn (Bondesiidne. Bondesiiis
fcrox; Inm. in de^., Casaniiyiielia riomgrina: ?Spalncotlicriidac,
Brandonin interdiedia; B arbereniidnc, Barberenia araiijoae,
Qrtirogaflteriirna niajor), Dryolestoidea (Dryolestidae,
Groeberllieriunr slipanicici, G. novaci, Leonardus ciispidaliis;
Mesungulatidae, Mesiingulaluni Iioussayi; Reigitheriidae,
Reigilheriuni bunodonla), Triconodonta (Triconodontidae,
Arislrotriconodon nickennai), Multituberculata (Ferugliotheriidae,
Ferugliofheriuni wiridltauseni) and two Gondwanatheria
(Gondwanntlieriidae, Gondwanafheririnipalagoniciinr, Vucefichia
gracilis) (Albino. 1987; Baez, 1987; Bonaparte & Soria, 1983,
1985; Bonaparte, 198Ga, b, c, 1987, 1990; Bonaparte & Pascual,
1987; Bonaparte & Rougier, 1987; Broin, 1987; Cione, 1987;
Mones, 1987; Powell, 1987). In northern Patagonia, some levels of
the Los Alamitos Fonnation are probably associated with a marine
transgression from the west (Andreis, 1987). The Los Alarnitos
Formation is overlain by the transgressive marine Roca Formation of
Mnastriclitian-Daniail age (Bonnparte, 1990) which probably
corrclatcs with thc cocvnl nnd trnnsgrcssive lower EI Molino
Forniution of Bolivin. c c n u s c of their chnractcristics and
stratigraphic positions, we thus propose temporal correlation of the
Los Alarnitos Formation with the Chaunaca Formation. Hence, the
Los Alamitos Formation is likely to be of Cnmpanian age.
The vertebrate faunas from the Adainantina and Marilia
formntions (Upper Baum Group) in. the northern part of tlie Paran6
basin, southcentral Brazil, include fishes (Lepisosteiformes,
Lcpisostcidnc, Lcpisosreus coniinatoi; Osteoglossiformes,
Osteoglossidac; Characifornies; Silurifornlcs, cf. Doradidae;
Perciformes. ?Percichdiyidae), lungfish (Dipnoi, Neoceratodontidae,
Neocet afodris sp.), frogs (Lcptodactylitlac, Ba~irirbafracliiispricei).
turtles (Podocnemididae, Roxoclielys irarrisi, cf. R . elegam, aff.
Podocnentis brasiliensis), lizards (Iguanidae?, Prisligiiana
brasiliensis), snakes (inder.), crocodiles (Baurusuchidae,
Barrrrisuclius pachecoi; Peirosauridae, Peirosaurus forminni;
Goniopholidae, ?Goniopholis paulislanrts; Trematosuchidae,
Itasrichus jesuinoi; family indel.. Brasileosaurus pacltecoi,
Splragesaiirus huenei), dinosnurs (Carnosnuria, Abelisnuridae.
415
A local fauna is known from tlie Banco Negro Inferior in the base
of the Ro Chico Formation about 1km southwest of Punta Peligro
(40 km norh-northeast of Comodoro Rivadavia along the Atlantic
coast) and another at Las Flores, 60 m above the Banco Negro
Inferior in the base of the Gran Barranca south of Lago ColhuHuap. Both local faunas are in the S a n Jorge basin, Chubut
Province, southern Argentina and were discovered in January 1979
during a National Geographic Society sponsored research program
under the direction of one of tlie authors (Marshall e l al.. 1981). The
fossils from Punta Icligro includc turtles (Chelidnc, at least four
taxa; roin, 1988), crocodiles (Scbecosuchia?; Crocodylidne.
Necrosirchus ionensis Simpson. 1937; Alligntoridac, Exainian sp..
Allognatosrichris? sp.), a possiblc edentnte or niultitubcrculate
Pnscuul.
i
(Sudnmcricidnc, Sudrinicrica cinrcghirioi Scilleto Ynnd
1985), condylarths (Arctocyonidae and/or Mioclncnidae) and several
indeterminate bone fragments (Marshall el al., 1981, n16; Pascual &
Ortiz-Jaurcguizar, 1991). Those from Las Flores include the
polydolopoid marsupial Epidolops sp. (Iascual C Bond, 1981). and
other taxa which show affinities with Itaboraian faunas in Brazil
(Poscunl & Ortiz-Jaureguizar, 1991). Many additional fossili of
marsupials and ungulates from Las Flores were collected by L. G.
Marshall and colleagues in 1979, and numerous unpublished
specimens from both Punta Pcligro niid Las Flores are now available
(Van Valen. 1988). The Banco Negro Infcrior is predominant& a
black bentonitic mudstone (Andreis el al., 1975). The Salamanca/Ro
Chico contact records a noteworthy marine regression which,
according to associated geochronologic age constraints (Marshall el
al., 198l), probably corresponds to the major regression identified
by Haq el al. (1987) in tlie early Thanetian (about 58.0-58.5 Ma).
The Itaborai fauna comes from fissure fillings in t h early
Pnlcoccnc (?) ngc SEO Jose de ltnbornf Forinntion locntcd about 25
kin eilst of Nitcr6i. stntc of Rio de Jnnciro, Brnzil. Taxonomic lists of
this exceptionally diverse fauna are provided by Paula Couto (1970).
Palma & Brito (1976) and Marshall el al. (1983). The vertebrates
wcre recovcred from numcrous karst cavitics in a lower liniestonc
unit and predate an upper limestone unit (Brito et al., 1972). For
most specimens, their association among themselves and/or with
specific cavities was never recorded. Although sonic nianiiiials
appear referable to what has been interprcted as middle Paleocene
time (i.e. the Itaboraian Land Maniinal nge; sensu Marsliall, 1985).
others appear more progressive and may represent faunas of late
Paleocene and possibly cai ly Eoccne iigc (i.e. the Kiocliican and
Casamayoran Land Mammal Ages, respectively; see Soria. 1987;
Van Valen, 1988; A. Cione, personal comunic?tion). In the
following discussion, we regard this fauna as middle Paleocene, but
caution that it may include taxa that accumulated between middle
Paleocene nnd early Eoccne time.
Although a hydrothermal origin has been clnssically favorcd for
the SEO Jose de Itabora lncustrinc limcstones (Francisco gZ Cunlin.
DISCUSSION
A. UIOSTRATIGRAPIIY
The Mesozoic and Ioleoccne age vertebrate fossil localities in
Bolivia (Fig. 2) are arranged in T a b l e 1 according Lo their
stratigraphic context. A systematic list of all the known fossil
vertebrates is given in Tables 2, and in Table 3 with indication of
locality and stratigraphic occurrence.
In this section we review the known occurrence of the taxa listed
in Tables 2 and 3 in order to identify their cluonostratigraphic ranges
and hence potential usefulness for calibratin8 the Bolivian rock
sequence. Of particular interest is the apparent position of the
Cretaceous/Paleocene (K/T) boundary.within the 81Molino
Formation (see below).
4. Cinglymodi
1. Selachians
416
10. Siluriformes
9. Characiformes
In Bolivia, this ordcr is rcprcscnlcd by the families Erytluinidac,
417
,
MIREIUE OAYIX. LARRY O.MARSIMLL EL IIIIBKRY SEMI'IJKC
16. hmphiblans
15. Lungfish
18. Lizards
14. Polypteriformes
19. Snnkes
The four faitlilies of snakes listed below are known only from the
Santa Luca Formation at Tiupampa in Bolivia.
In South Americn, Aniliidhe are first reported from the Umayo
Formation at Laguna Umayo in Peru (Rage, 1981) and middle
Paleocene at Itabora in Brazil (Rage, 1987).
The earliest Boidae are from the Maastrichtian of North America
(Estes & BBez, 1985), Europe (Rage, 1987) and India (Jain & Sahni,
1983), while in South America, previous to this work, they were first
reported in the middle Paleocene in Brazil (Rage, 1987) and early
Eocene of Argentina (Albino, 1986).
418
22. M,unimuls
419
2. Taxa from the EI Molino and Santa Luch formations (and their
stratigraphic cquivalcnls) which are "endemics" in the Andean basin.
Included are Gasteroclicpea bronisai (Clupcidae). Andinichtliys
bolivianensis , (Andinichthyoidea,
Andinichthyidae),
Hoffsterterichtliyspucai, Incaichthys suarezi (families incertae sedis)
and ?Roxochelys vilavilensis (Podocnemididae).
3 . Taxa known only from the lower and basal middle EI Molino
Fonnation which are currently regarded as late Cretaceous "guide
fossils" based on their records elsewhere in the world. Included are
Schizorhiza and Ischyrhiza (Sclerorhyncliidae), apparently Lepidot es
(Semionotidae) which has only o n e dubious record in the
Cretaceous/Paleocene of India, Enclzodiis (Enchodontidae),
?Apaleodris (family indet.), Ichthyotringoidei (gen. and sp. indet.),
Sleplranodiis (Eotiigonodontidae) and dinosaurs.
a. Semionotidae
d. Polypteridae
Pishes
Fishes have been divided into four main categories (Myers, 1938)
based on their tolerance to fresh or salt water: 1) primary freshwater
fishes found only in fresh water; 2) secondary freshwater fishes,
found normally in fresh water, but capable of entering and surviving
in marine water; 3) peripheral freshwater fishes, diadromous, which
420
e.
Lungfishes
a. Lepisosteidae
e. Characiformes
Most of the living Lepisosteidae are found in fresh water, but one
species may tolerate brackish or even marine conditions and is found
along Uie coast of the Gulf of Mexico (Sutlkus, 1963). Bccouse of
their Uiick scales covered with ganoine which are more resistan1 llinn
any oflier parts of th fish, the fossil Lepisosteidae are often reported
on scaks only, which may be transported far from their biotope
without damage. In Bolivia. Lepisosteidne are always found in
association with marine fislies including selachians, pycnodonts and
eotrigonodonts in the lower and basal middle members of the El
Molino Formation, but they are always disassociated, indicating
postmortem movement. In the only locality where no true marine
fishes were found (.e.Tiupampa), Lepisosteidae are absent but Ulis
absence may e the consequence of age (Paleocene) and not of
environment. episosteidae had a nearly world-wide distribution
during Cretaceous and early Tertiary times. Subsequently, they
disappeared from all the continents except North America where
they are now restricted to the southeastern part of the USA and
Central America. I
b. Clupeidae
Gasteroclicpea branisui is a Clupeiformes endemic to the Andean
basin. Clupeiform,es are generally marine fishes with the exception
of some South American li.ving genera (RnnmoRnsrer, frisrignsrcr;
G6ry. 1969; Cionc p l'ercirii, 1985). III Uic middle Eocene of tlic
Green River Formation (Wyoming, USA), Kniglrtia and
Diploniystus which are known to be marine, are reported in strictly
fresh water environments (Grande, 19820. b). Gaslerocfupea
branisui is reported at Tiupampa (Santa Lucia Formation) where no
marine fishes are found, and in some levels of the EL Molino
Formation (at Agua Clara) in association w i h marine fishes. In some
green marl levels a t Agua Clara, Gasferoclupea is found in
association only with brackish-water ostracods. Consequently,
Gasteroclupea may be considered, with some confidence, as a
secondary Jeshwater clupeid.
e. Centropomidae
'
f. Siluriformes
Most S i l u r i f o r m e s o c c u r i n fresh water. However; the
Plotosidae are an advanced marine family which today occur
around Auslralia and the Ariidae live along the coast or i n t e r
e s t u a r i e s and c o a s t a l rivers. T e r t i a r y S i l u r i f o r m e s were
reported in fresh water areas and/or in brackish water (see
.Gayet, 1991). In Bolivia, Andiniclithyoidea (3 families) are
known i n the Siinln Lucln Forincilion n t Tiupiiinpn aiid Rlnnco
Kiinclw (tlic ichtliyol'iiunii ol' the liiter lociility is not yet well
enough known to provide pnleoenvironmental interpretation);
they are not reported at Agua Clara o r Hotel Cordillera where
m a r i n e f i s h e s a r e p r e s e n t a n d may b e c o n s i d e r e d as
freshwater forms. Ariidae are reported everywhere in both
formations with or without marine fishes. They are present at
Tiupampa, but are few in number. At Hotel Cordillera they
a r e v e r y numerous a n d o c c u r in a s s o c i a t i o n with a few
marine taxa.
3. Marine fislies
a. Selachians
Selachians are, considered as marine fishes. Nevertheless, one
family of American batoids (Potamobygonidae) lives exclusively in
fresh waters. One pristid fish and a shark can also enter rivers or
421
MIKI?ILLI?tiAYE1. LARRY
U. MAWIIALL&'I'IIIBKKY SBMI't!KI!
b. I'ycnodontiformes
Pycnodonts, a purely fossil group, are considered to have been
marine fishes (Cione 8c Pereira, 1985). They were flat and high
rishcs that apparently swam slowly along the coast and were l i n k d
to the substratum for their alimentation. Some could probably enter
waters of lesser salinity. Wenz (1989) noted that the Brazilian lower
Cretaceous pycnodontid Ieninnja may have lived in fresh water.
Traquair (19 1O) thought that pycnodonts found at Bernissart
(Relgium) with thc rcptilc Igrrunodon were living in fresh water
without any connection with the sea. Nevertheless, these examples
are sporadic and pycnodonts are typically found in more or less open
marine environments in rocks of Jurassic and Cretaceous age (Hake1
and Ht1jula in Lebanon; Ein Jabrud i n Israel; Jebcl Tselfnt in
Morocco; etc.). In Bolivia. pycnodonts were reported i n the
Chaunaca Formation (only one tooth of no paleoenvironmental
significance) and in,the lower and basal middle EI Molino.
c. "Snlinoniformes"
422
IIiglier ver1el)rules
D. FALEOBIOGEOGRAPHY
Numerous vertebrate grou'ps in the late Cretaceous and Paleocene
of South America are also recorded in North America, and these
faunal "links" were used by paleontologists to postulate that a transCaribbean land bridge existed during part or all of this time interval
(see Gayet el al., in press; Marshall & Sempere, in press and
references therein). These concIusions have recently been
corroborated by geodynamic data (see Pindell ef d.,1988; Stephan
el ul., 1990). It now appears that the Caribbean plate began its eastnortheastward migration in Campanian time. The now submerged
Greater Antilles and the Aves Ridge formed a subaerial volcanic arc
established 'on the northe:istern edge of the Caribbean plate during
tlic late Crctaccous and early I'aleocciic. It is likely h a t this arc was
the land bridgc that providcd the pathway for dispersal of continental
(and fresh water) vertebrates. However, the land bridge provided by
the Aves Ridge was apparently strongly dependent on tlie inaginatic
and tcctoniC activity of this arc. and on sen level changes. Maginatictectonic quiescence and/or marine high-stand periods would have
promoted relative subsidence of part of the isthmus below sea level.
In view of the probable fragility of the Aves Ridge connection,
faunal interchange is likely to have occurred i n several "pulses"
beginning in the Campnninn until the land bridge finally disappeared
in late Paleocene time as is suggested by paleontological data. This
"pulse-IiypoUiesis" would have permitted opportunities for endemic
evolution of first-wave immigrants and for subsequent dispersal
during a later "pulse". For this reason, the direction of dispersal of
most groups is not certain (Marshall & Senipere, in press).
Some vertebrate groups which participated in this interchange(s)
include dinosaurs (Avisauiidae, Ceratopsidae, Hadrosauridae,
Titanosauridae), snakes (Anilioidea, Boidea). possibly lizards
(Teiidae) and sliore-dwelling turtles (Bohremydidae) (Gayet el al.,
423
CONCIJUSIONS
This paper is the first attempt to provide a detailed overview of h e
Mesozoic and Paleocene vertebrate faunas of Bolivia within Uicir
stratigraphic context. Much of the inforination presented here is new,
and includcs data obtuiiicd as a result of IIII iiitciise palcontological
program started in 1981 (M. G., L. G. M and others) and of geologic
studies initiated in 1984 (T. S. and others). Most of the fossils are
still being described and it will be many years before monographic
publications can be completed. In addition, magnetoslratigrapliic and
isotopic (Ar/Ar, K-Ar) studies of the El Molino and Santa Luca
formations and isotopic oxygen and strontium analyses on fishes Ne
in progress, and cornpletion of this gcochronologic program will
hopefully perinil secure calibrntioii of these rock units witti tlie
geologic time scale. Synthetic overviews for the biostratigraphy of
Argentinian, Chilean and Peruvian rocks in the Andean basin are
now urgently necdcd to permit refined correlation with those in
Bolivia.
Dcspile tlic fact tlint his is by iicccssity only ii "progrcss rclwri",
many advances in knowledge have been made 011 the Bolivian
Mesozoic-Paleocene scqucnce during the last few years, and in this
study we have been able to clarify some debated issues. The most
iinprtant of thcsc is thc apparcnt, although still ill-dcfincd, location
boundary and its position relative to Uic inanmal-bearing
of the
level at Tiupampa. Within the El Molino Formation, undoubted late
Cretaceous taxa occur only in Uie lower and basal middle members.
It therefore appears that the K/T boundary lies somewhere in the
upper part of the niiddlg member, while the upper member may be
regarded as earliest Paleocene based on the absence of diagnostic
Cretaceous taxa and on Uie palynological studies of a stratigraphic
equivalent in northwestern Argentina. The EI Molino Ihus appears to
range from latest Cainpanian to earliest Paleocene, while the
disconformably overlying Santa Luca Formation appears 'to be
early, but not earliest. Paleocene. Thus, confra Van Valen (f988),
the EI Molino dinosaurs were all late Cretaceous (apparently-early
Maastrichtian), while the land mammals from the Santa Luca
h
Fonnatioii at Tiupanpa were Paleocene.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
~ s l ) u~
r tilis
~ ~sttltiy
s
W C I C su1)l")ltcd I)Y rillitis fro111 IIIC cclltlc
National de la Keclicrclie Scientifique (UKA 12, Institut de
PalCoiitologie, Paris, 1981); ari "Action Spcifique" (1983 to 1989)
from the MusCuni National d'Histoire Naturcllc, Paris; National
Geographic Society (2467-82. 2908-84, 3381-86); URlH of Orstoni;
the Gordon Barbour Fund. Department of Geological and
Geophysical Sciences, Princeton University; and the National
Science Foundation (EAR-8804423). Logistic help was given by
Orstom, YPFB and VARIG. Fossil collecting was carried out under
the auspices of the Asociacin Boliviana de Paleontologa and
stratigraphic work under the YPFB-Orstom research prcgram on
Bolivian geology. Thanks to L. Barrios, J. Blanco, F. de Broiii,
E. Buffetaut. G. Camoin, H. Cappetta, R.' Cspedes, A. L. Cione.
J. Dejax, D. Dingerkus. E. Jaillard, M. Surez, R. SuBrez,
F. J. Meunier, J. Oller, J. C. Rage, B. Sig, C. de Muizon and S.
Wenz for help in aspects of Ulis study. Figures 1 to 4 were drawn by
E. Liebmm.
424
425
Aires.
DANIL'CHENCO. P. G . 1968. Ryby verklinego paleotsena
Turkmenii. In: Oclterki PO jlogenii isistentdike iskapaeniykli ryb i
bezsclieliustnykk ( D .V. Obruchev, ed.). Nauka Press; 113-156,
Moscow.
,
DARTEVELLE, E. & E. CASIER. 1949. Les poissons fossiles du
Bas-Congo e t des rCgions voisines ( d e u x i h e partie). Annales du
Muse dir Congo Belge. A . Minralogie, Gologie, Palontologie,
srie 3,2 (2): 201-256, Tervuren.
DARTEVELLE. E. & E. CASIER. 1959. Les poissons fossiles du
Bas-Congo et des rgions voisines (troisime partie). Annales du
Muse du Congo Belge. A . Minralgie, Gologie, Palontologie,
sCrie 3, 2 (3): 257-368. Tervuren.
,DAVILA, J. & V. PONCE DE LEON. 1971. La seccidn del Ro
Iiiambari en la faja subandina del Per y la presencia de sedimentitas
de,la Formacin CancaRiri (Zapla) del Silrico. Revista Tcriica de
YPFB, 1 (1): 67-85. La Paz.
D'ERASMO, G. 1934. Sopra iilcuiii iivanzi di vcrtcbrati fossili dcllii
Patagonia raccolti dal doll. E. Fcruglio. L'ittiofautia cretacea di
Comeno nel Carso triestino. Atti dellilccadentia di Scienzefisiclte e
naturale di Napoli, 2, 8: 1-136, Napoli.
DOLGOPOL DE SAEL, M. 1941. Noticiris sobrc pcccs f6silcs
argentinos. Siluroidcos tcrciarios del Chubut. Notas del Museo de La
Plata, 6: 451457, La Plata.
ESTES, R. 1983. Sauria terrestria. Amphisbaenia. Ifandbuch der
Palolterpetologie, Part 10A, xxii I- 249 p. G. Fischer Verlag,
Stuttgart/New York.
ESTES, R. & A. M. BAEZ. 1985. Herpetofaunas of North and South
America during the late Cretaceous and Cenozoic: Evidence for
Interchange? In: The Great Anierican Biotic Interchange (F. G.
Stelili & S. D. Webb, eds.), Plenrini Press: 139-196, New York.
ESTES, R. & L. PRICE. 1973. Iguanid lizard froin the upper
Cretaceous of Brazil. Science, 180: 748-751, Washington.
FERNANDEZ, J. 1976. Hallazgo de peces pulmoiiados fsiles
e n l a P u n a Jujeia. Anales d e la Sociedad Cientfica d e
Argentina, 201, S e r i e II,C i e n c i a s a p l i c a d a s , 41: 13-18,
Buciios Aires.
FERNANDEZ, J., P. BONDES10 & R. PASCUAL. 1973. Restos
de Lepidosircn / x i r ( h . w (Ostciclithycs. Dipiioi) dc In Foriiioci6ri
Luiiibrcra (Eogcno?, Eoccno?) dc Jujuy. hicgIii/iit~ti~~,
10: 152-172,
Buenos Aires.
FITCH, J. E. 1975. Vorhizia Frizzell, a living fossil. Abstract.
Program for Amcricaii Socicty of Ichtliyologists niid Hcrpctologists.
Annual Mcding: 96, Aiiii Arbor.
FRANCISCO, B. H. K. & F. L. de S. CUHNA. 1978. Geologia e
estratigrafia de Bacia de So Jos, Municipio de Itabora, RJ. Anais
da Acadniia Brasileira de Cincias, 50: 38 1 4 16.
FRIZZELL, D. L. 1965. Otoliths of a new fish (Vorhizia vulpcs, n.
gen., n. sp., Siluroidei?) from the upper Cretaceous of South Dakota.
Copeia, 2: 178-181, Ann Arbor.
GARDEWEG. M.& C. F. RAMREZ. 1985. Hoja Ro Zapaleri, II,
Regi611 de Antofagasta. Carta Geol6gica de Chile, escala 1: 250,000.
Servicio Nacional de Geologa y Minera, 66: 1-89. Santiago.
GASPARINI, Z. B. de. 1984. New Tertiary Sebecosuchia
(Crocodylia: Mesosuchia) from Argentina. Journal of Vertebrare
Paleontology, 4 (1): 85-95, Norinali.
426
.
I
'
428
- VOL. I - VERTEB~ADOS
Mammalogy, 2: 433-502.
MARTIN, M. l 9 8 4 . Rvision des Argonidontidds e t des
NBocratodontids (Dipnoi, Ceratodontiformes) du CrtactS africain.
Neues Jahrbuchfiir Geologie und Palontologie Abhandlungen, 169
(2):225-277, Stuttgart.
MARTINEZ, C. 1980. Structure et &volution d e la chane
hercynienne et de la chane andine dans le nord de la Cordillhe des
Andes de Bolivie. Travaux et Documents de I'ORSTOM, 119: 1-352,
Paris.
MAURY, C. J. 1930. O Cretlceo da Parahyba do Norte, Brasil.
MOnogr@a do Servio Gedgicoe Mineraldgico, 8 1-305.Rio de JoneirO.
MONES, A. 1987. GondwanaUieria, un nuevo orden de mamiferos
sudamericanos (Mammalia: Edentata: ?Xenmthra). Comunicaciones
Paleontolhgicas del Museo de Historia Natural de Montevideo, 18:
237-240.
M O N T m O , M. 1968. Estudio geol6gico de Anzaldo-Irata-Vilque
y proyecto de investigaci611petrogentStica en los miembros basales
d e la secuencia cretlcica. Unpublished Thesis, Universidad
Mayor de San A n d r b , Facultad de Ciencias Geoldgkas, 83
p., La Paz.
MOURIER, T., E. JAILLARD, G. LAUBACHER, C. NOBLET,
A. PARDO, B. SIGE 62 P. TAQUET. 1986. Dcouvertes de restes
dinosauriens et mammaliens d'ge crtStac6 suprieur ?
laibase des
couches rouges du synclinal de Bagua (Andes nord-pruviennes):
aspects stratigraphiques, sdimentologiques et palogographiques
concernant la rBgression fini-crtace. Bidletin de la Sociktll
Geologique de France, srie 8 , 2 (1): 171-175, Paris.
MOURIER, T., P. BENGTSON, M. BONHOMME, E. BUGE,
H. CAPPETTA, J.-Y. CROCHET, M. F. FEIST, K. F. HIRSCH,
E. JAILLARD, G . LAUBACHER, J.-P. LEFRANC,
M. MOULLADE, C. NOBLET, D. PONS, J. REY, B. SIGE,
Y. TAMBAREAU & P. TAQUET. 1988. The upper Cretaceouslower Tertiary marine to continental transition in the Bagua basin,
northern Peru. Paleontology, Biostratigraphy, Radiometry,
Correlations. Newsletters on Stratigraphy, 19 ( 3 ) : 143-177,
BerlinlStuttgart.
MUIZON, C. de & L. G. MARSHALL. 1985. Sur la piste des
premiers mammiRres d'Amdrique du Sud. La Recherche, 16 (167):
812-815, Paris.
MUIZON C. de & L. G . MARSHALL. 1987a. L e plus ancien
Pantodonte (Mammalia), du Crbtac6 Supdrieur de Bolivie. Comptes
Rendus Hebdomadaires des Sances de I'Academie des Sciences,
srie 2,304 (5): 205-208, Paris.
MUIZON C. de & L. G. MARSHALL. 1987b. Le plus ancien
condylarthre (Mammalia) sud-amricain (CrtStac Supbrieur,
Bolivie). Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Sances de
l'Acadmie des Sciences, sdrie 2,304 (13): 771-774, Paris.
MUIZON C. de & L. G. MARSHALL. 1987c. Deux nouveaux
condylarthres (Mammalia) du Maastrichtien de Tiupampa (Bolivie).
Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Sbances de I'Acadkmie des
Sciences, serie 2,304 (15): 947-950, Paris.
MUIZON C. de & L. G.MARSHALL. 1987d. El alba de la edad de
los mamiferos en Sudamerica. N Congreso Latino-americano de
Paleontologfa,Actas 2: 757-791, Santa Cruz.
MUIZON C. de & L. G. MARSHALL. 1988. Tiupampa (Bolivia),
un punto clave en la historia de los mamiferos sudamericanos. Actas
del Segundo Simposio de la Investigacbn Francesa en Bolivia: 5360. La Paz.
429
430
43 1
432
433