Fighting Islamic State' Is Not The Israeli Priority - Oped

FIGHTING ISLAMIC STATE IS NOT THE
ISRAELI PRIORITY OPED
By Nicola Nasser-DECEMBER 24, 2014

Defying a consensus that it is a priority by the world community comprising
international rivals like the United States, Europe, Russia and China and regional rivals
like Iran, Syria and Saudi Arabia, Israel, like Turkey, does not eye the U.S. led war on
the IS as its regional priority. Nor fighting Israel is an IS priority.
The Israeli top priority is to dictate its terms to Syria to sign a peace treaty with Israel
before withdrawing its forces from the occupied Syrian Golan Heights, Palestinian
territories and Lebanese southern lands.
For this purpose, Israel is determined to break down the Syria Iran alliance, which has
been the main obstacle preventing Israel from realising its goals. Changing the ruling
regime in either Damascus or Tehran would be a step forward. Towards this Israeli
strategic goal the IS could not be but an Israeli asset.
To defeat ISIS (The Islamic State in Iraq and Syria as the IS was previously known) and
leave Iran as a threshold nuclear power is to win the battle and lose the war, Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told the UN General Assembly last September.
Therefore, it should not come as a surprise that the (Benjamin) Netanyahu government
has not yet taken any immediate steps against IS, according to Amos Harel, writing in
Foreign Policy on September 15.

However, information is already surfacing that Israel is taking steps in the opposite
direction, to empower the IS and other terrorist groups fighting and infighting in Syria.
Israeli daily Haaretz on last October 31 quoted a senior Northern Command officer as
saying that the U.S. led coalition is making a big mistake in fighting against ISIS the
United States, Canada and France are on the same side as Hezbollah, Iran and [Syrian
President Bashar al-] Assad. That does not make sense.
Regardless, on September 8 Israeli daily The Jerusalem Post reported that Israel has
provided satellite imagery and other information to the coalition. Three days later
Netanyahu said at a conference in Herzliya: Israel fully supports President [Barack]
Obamas call for united actions against ISIS We are playing our part in this continued
effort. Some of the things are known; some of the things are less known.
Obamas call was the green light for Israel to support Syrian and non- Syrian rebels.
Syrian official statements claim that Israel has been closely coordinating with the rebels.
Israeli statements claim theirs is confined to humanitarian support to moderate
Syrian opposition, which the U.S. has already pledged to train and arm in Saudi Arabia,
Jordan and Turkey. A significant portion of the $64 billion earmarked for conflicts abroad
in the budget legislation signed by Obama on December 19 will go to these moderates.
Both Israel and the U.S. have no headaches about whether the moderates would
remain as such after being armed with lethal weapons or whether it remains appropriate
to call them opposition.
But the Israeli humanitarian claim is challenged by the fact that Israel is the only
neighbouring country which still closes its doors to Syrian civilian refugees while keeping
its doors wide open to the wounded rebels who are treated in Israeli hospitals and
allowed to return to the battle front after recovery.
IS close to Israeli borders

The Israeli foreign ministry on last September 3 confirmed that the U.S. journalist Steven
Sotloff whom the IS had beheaded was an Israeli citizen as well. In a speech addressed to
Sotloffs family, Netanyahu condemned the IS as a branch of a poisonous tree and a
tentacle of a violent Islamist terrorism.
On the same day Israeli Defense Minister Moshe Yaalon officially outlawed the IS and
anyone associating with it.
On September 10, Netanyahu convened an urgent security meeting to prepare for the
possible danger of the IS advancing closer to the Israeli border, a prospect confirmed by
the latest battles for power between the IS and the al Nusra Front on the southern
Syrian Lebanese borders and in southern Syria, within the artillery range of Israeli
forces.
On November 9, Ansar Bait al-Maqdis (ABM), which has been operating against the
Egyptian army, released an audio clip pledging allegiance to the IS to declare later the
first IS Wilayah (province) in the Egyptian Sinai Peninsula, south of Israel.
On last November 14 The Israeli Daily quoted Netanyahu as saying in a private defense
meeting that the IS is currently operating out of Lebanon close to Israels northern
border. We must take this as a serious threat.
However, in truth, as most of Israels intelligence community has been quick to point
out, there are no signs that anything of the sort is actually happening, according to Amos
Harel, writing in Foreign Policy five days later.
Moshe Yaalon told journalists in September that the organization operates far from
Israel and thus presents no imminent threat. Israeli peace activist Uri Avnery, on
November 14, wrote: The present and former generals who shape Israels policy can
only smile when this danger is mentioned.
Israel certainly does not see the group as an external threat and the Islamic State also
does not yet pose an internal threat to Israel, according to Israeli journalist and
Associate Policy Fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations, Dimi Reider,
writing in a Reuters blog on last October 21.
What Netanyahu described as a serious threat in the north does not yet dictate any
Israeli action against it because we must assume that Hizballah, which is allied to Syria
and Iran, does not have its house in order, according to the Israeli premier.
The presence of the IS Wilayah on its southern border with Egypt is preoccupying the
country with an internal bloody anti-terror conflict that would prevent any concrete
Egyptian contribution to the stabilization of the Arab Levant or support to the
Palestinians in their struggle to end the Israeli occupation of their land, let alone the fact
that this presence is already pitting Egypt against Israels archenemy, Hamas, in the
Palestinian Gaza Strip and creating a hostile environment that dictates closer Egyptian
Israeli security coordination.
Therefore, Israel is not going to interfere because these are internal issues of the
countries where it is happening. Israel is informally ready to render assistance, but
not in a military way and not by joining the (U.S. led) coalition against the IS, according
to the deputy head of the Israeli embassy in Moscow, Olga Slov, as quoted by Russian
media on November 14.
Jordan is another story

However, Israels eastern neighbours in Jordan and Syria seem another story.
Jordan feels threatened by IS. We will cooperate with them one way or another,
ambassador Slov said. Jordanian media has been reporting that more than 2000
Jordanians had already joined al-Qaeda splinter the IS, al-Qaedas branch al-Nusra Front
or other rebels who are fighting for an Islamic state in Syria. Hundreds of them were
killed by the Syrian Arab Army.
The Daily Beast on last June 27 quoted Thomas Sanderson, the co-director for
transnational threats at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, as saying that
Israel considers the survival of Jordan as a paramount national security objective.
If Jordan requested Israeli assistance in protecting its borders, Israel would have little
choice but to help, the Beast quoted the director of the Israeli National Security
Council, Yaakov Amidror, as saying.
As a precaution measure, Israel is building now a 500-kilometre security fence on its
border with Jordan.
While Israel is willing and getting ready to interfere in Jordan, it is already deeply
interfering in Syria, where the real battle has been raging for less than four years now
against terrorists led by the IS.
A few weeks ago The Associated Press reported that the IS and the al-Nusra had
concluded an agreement to stop fighting each other and cooperate on destroying the
U.S. trained and supported rebels (The Syrian Revolutionaries Front and the Hazm
movement) as well as the Syrian government forces in northern Syria.
But in southern Syria all these and other terrorist organizations are coordinating among
themselves and have what Lt. Col. Peter Lerner, a spokesman for the Israeli Occupation
Forces (IOF) called a gentlemans agreement with Israel across the border, according to
Colum Lynch in Foreign Policy on June 11.
Last October, Al-Qaeda branch in Syria, al-Nusra, was among the rebel groups which
overtook the only border crossing of Quneitra between Syria and the Israeli occupied
Golan Heights. Israel has yet to demonstrate its objection.
Many Sunnis in Iraq and the Gulf consider ISIS a bullet in their rifles aimed at Shiite
extremism, in their bid to restore their lost standing, Raghida Dergham, a columnist and
a senior diplomatic correspondent for the London based Arabic Al-Hayat daily, wrote
in the Huffington Post on September 19.
A political public agreement between Israel and the Gulf Arabs has developed on a
mutual understanding that the dismantling of the Syria Iran alliance as a prelude to a
regime change in both countries is the regional priority, without loosing sight of the
endgame, which is to dictate peace with Israel as the regional power under the U.S.
hegemony. The IS is the bullet in their rifles. From their perspective, the U.S. war on the
IS is irrelevant, for now at least.
Nicola Nasser
Nicola Nasser is a veteran Arab journalist based in Bir Zeit, West Bank of
Posted by Thavam

Fighting Islamic State' Is Not The Israeli Priority - Oped

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Fighting Islamic State' Is Not The Israeli Priority - Oped

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Fighting Islamic State' Is Not The Israeli Priority - Oped

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

FIGHTING ISLAMIC STATE IS NOT THE

ISRAELI PRIORITY OPED

By Nicola Nasser-DECEMBER 24, 2014

Foreign Policy on September 15.

IS close to Israeli borders

Jordan is another story

You might also like