An Advanced Optimal Approach For High Voltage AC Bushing Design
An Advanced Optimal Approach For High Voltage AC Bushing Design
An Advanced Optimal Approach For High Voltage AC Bushing Design
461
Abstract
This paper proposes a new and advanced methodology for finding the optimum
electrical design of high voltage ac capacitive graded bushings using an improved
genetic algorithm approach as an effective meta-heuristic method. A case study has
been conducted on a 145 kV oil impregnated paper (OIP) bushing and the IEC 60137
tests have been performed to evaluate its performance. Condenser-bushings contain
concentric conductive foils which are isolated from each other. The partial capacitances
between conducting cylinders can be modified by adjusting the number, diameter,
place and length of these cylinders as well as the thickness of insulating material
between foils. As a result, the voltage drop and also the electrical stress in the core and
along the surface will change. This paper finds optimal value of bushing design
parameters to achieve well-distributed electric stress with the lowest possible maximum
value and also a constant voltage drop for different layers by using an improved genetic
algorithm optimization method subject to practical and technological constrains. The
proposed method of this research work has been applied to a 145 kV OIP bushing. The
performance of optimal designed 145 kV OIP bushing under IEC 60137 tests is very
promising.
Index Terms High voltage techniques, modified genetic algorithm, insulators,
dielectric breakdown, IEC.
1 INTRODUCTION
IN todays competitive market, there is a need for the bushing
manufacturing industry to improve bushing efficiency and to
reduce costs; because high-quality low-cost products and
processes have become the key to survival in the global economy.
On the other hand, with the increase of electrical energy demand,
the voltage levels of electric transmission systems have increased
rapidly within recent years. The reliability of equipment and
facilities used in a power system is an essential precondition of
the energy transmission security. Bushing failure is one of the
leading causes of transformer failures [1, 2].
Researchers have reported various aspects of high voltage
bushing design in the literature. In [3], Lachman et al
proposed the application of the sum current method to on-line
diagnostics of high-voltage bushings and current transformers.
Guoqiang et al applied evolution strategy for optimal design of
high voltage bushing electrode in transformers [4]. In [5],
Lampe from Swedish Transmission Research Institute
reported the measured electric field along HVDC bushings
Manuscript received on 13 April 2007, in final form 15 August 2007.
462
M. R. Hesamzadeh et al.: An Advanced Optimal Approach for High Voltage AC Bushing Design
Zero layer
Intermediate layers
Side1
Last layer
Side
E .d l = 0 , D .d A = Q
E : Vector
(1)
stress
of electrical
d l : Vector of element
d A : Vector
and D = E
of integration
of elemement
path
of area
+
(
1
Dev
)
((
)
1
)
(
Dev
)
(
)
amount of raw materials and lower cost of manufacturing
DsNo
Max Erad 1
MRS
process along with higher performance of condenser bushings Min.
k
MaxErad 2 MRS
(1 Dev) (( Min) k
1) + (Dev) (
)
Erad
2
Max
MRS
Such that:
1. Min Max
2. Nfl Min Nfl Nfl Max
3. D int Min D int D int Max
(2)
(3)
463
k
Maximum Radial Stress. In this process, when MaxErad
1
becomes lower than MRS, then the Dev variable takes zero
value and the minimization process is done on the
Min k
(
) Erad 1 1) term. From that point, the minimization process
Max
8. Lp 2 Min Lp 2 Lp 2 Max
k
( Min Erad
1 ). The reason is that the best exploitation of the
insulating material in view of its insulating strength is
achieved when the radial stress is kept constant. However, it
should be noted that this concept can not be achieved in
practical cases. But, this process is attempted in the design
phase to achieve an optimum solution. In this paper, this
process is embedded in its suggested objective function.
464
M. R. Hesamzadeh et al.: An Advanced Optimal Approach for High Voltage AC Bushing Design
Sp2
145 kV
50 Hz
275 kV
800 A
(p.u.)
(p.u.)
(p.u.)
0.1
0.4
0.1
Nfl
Dint
Dext
Lx
Conventional
0.0283
22
42
106
1300
Optimum
0.0283
26
40
104
1497
Lp1
Sp1
Lp2
Sp2
Conventional
315
30
130
15
Optimum
305
15
197
10
DU1
DU2
Erad1(2)
DU1(2)
STD
%
improvement
0.42
2.67
0.45
Optimum
%
improvement
Conventional
0.08
2.66
0.07
80.95
0.37
84.44
0.54
2.64
0.62
0.10
2.62
0.09
81.48
0.75
85.48
Optimum
%
improvement
Conventional
0.43
3.81
0.66
0.09
3.22
0.10
79.07
15.48
84.84
0.55
3.81
0.91
Optimum
0.11
3.22
0.12
%
80
15.48
86.81
improvement
Maximum Radial Stress in Different Layers of side
1(2)
Voltage Drop on Different Layers of Side
1(2)
Standard Deviation
|Conventional Value Optimum Value|/
Conventional Value
3.5
Conventional
Optimum
%
improvement
Conventional
Optimum Design
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
0
10
15
20
25
30
Layer Number
Figure 4. Maximum radial electrical stresses for each capacitive layer for
conventional and capacitive layer for conventional and optimum design
6
Erad2
465
Conventional Design
Optimum Design
10
15
Layer Number
20
25
466
M. R. Hesamzadeh et al.: An Advanced Optimal Approach for High Voltage AC Bushing Design
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
7 CONCLUSION
High voltage bushing breakdown is one of the major
contributors to the transformer failures. Since the electrical
design of the HV bushings is the most important part of their
manufacturing process, finding an algorithm for the electrical
design of bushings in an optimum way is very important.
This paper proposes an advanced method for finding optimum
electrical design of capacitive grading bushings. The proposed
method finds the best values of decision variables
(parameters) in the design of a capacitive grading bushing
according to a technological objective function with its
corresponding constraints. This is done by using an improved
genetic algorithm (GA) as a powerful meta-heuristic
optimization method. For in-feeding the practical experiences,
the GA starts from a set of available design parameters for
similar bushings. Promising performance indices and
laboratory test results were obtained by applying this method
to a typical 145 kV oil impregnated paper bushing.
REFERENCES
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[15]
[16]