Journal of Psychiatric Research: Niki Antypa, Marco Antonioli, Alessandro Serretti
Journal of Psychiatric Research: Niki Antypa, Marco Antonioli, Alessandro Serretti
Journal of Psychiatric Research: Niki Antypa, Marco Antonioli, Alessandro Serretti
a r t i c l e i n f o
a b s t r a c t
Article history:
Received 14 May 2013
Received in revised form
31 July 2013
Accepted 7 August 2013
Patients with Bipolar Disorder (BD) have high rates of suicide compared to the general population. The
present study investigates the predictive power of baseline clinical, psychological and environmental
characteristics as risk factors of prospective suicide events (attempts and completions). Data was
collected from the Systematic Treatment Enhancement Program for Bipolar Disorder (STEP-BD) study.
3083 bipolar patients were included in this report, among these 140 (4.6%) had a suicide event (8 died by
suicide and 132 attempted suicide). Evaluation and assessment forms were used to collect clinical,
psychological and socio-demographic information. Chi-square and independent t-tests were used to
evaluate baseline characteristics. Potential prospective predictors were selected on the basis of prior
literature and using a screening analysis of all risk factors that were associated with a history of suicide
attempt at baseline and were tested using a Cox regression analysis. The strongest predictor of a suicide
event was a history of suicide attempt (hazard ratio 2.60, p-value < 0.001) in line with prior literature.
Additional predictors were: younger age, a high total score on the personality disorder questionnaire and
a high percentage of days spent depressed in the year prior to study entry. In conclusion, the present
ndings may help clinicians to identify patients at high risk for suicidal behavior upon presentation for
treatment.
2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords:
Bipolar
Suicide
Prospective
Predictors
STEP-BD
1. Introduction
Bipolar Disorder (BD) is characterized by a high risk of suicide
attempts and completions, resulting in a 15-fold higher risk
compared to that in the general population (Harris and
Barraclough, 1997). Approximately 10% of BD patients die from
completed suicide (Harris and Barraclough, 1997). Studies show
rates of attempted suicide up to 30% among BD patients (Novick
et al., 2010), and rates of suicidal ideation up to 56% for those
with an adult rst episode, and w74% among patients with a pediatric rst episode (Carter et al., 2003). To date, retrospective and
cross sectional studies have proposed many risk factors for suicidal
behavior in BD patients. These include demographic factors (female
gender (Nivoli et al., 2011), age of rst depressive episode (Song
et al., 2012)), comorbidities (such as anxiety disorders
(Baldassano, 2006), borderline personality (Neves et al., 2009),
substance abuse (Finseth et al., 2012) or eating disorder (McElroy
et al., 2011)), clinical features (feelings of hopelessness (Acosta
et al., 2012; Johnson et al., 2005), number of mood episodes,
1801
1802
Table 1
Demographic and clinical characteristic of patients at baseline, stratied by history of suicide attempt(s).
Characteristics
Demographics
Age
Male
Race
White or Caucasian
African Americans
Native Americans, Eskimo or Aleut
Asian
No primary race
Martial status
Single
Married/living together
Divorced/separated/widowed
Baseline clinical characteristic
Age onset BD
Age >45 years
Age 30e45
Age 20e30 or <15
Age 15e19
Age Mania 1st episode
Age Depression 1st episode
Longest period of remission
YMRS total
MADRS total
Negative life events (total)
Positive life events (total)
PDQ total
Quality of life total
Cigarettes packet/day
Smoking onset-age
Bipolar subtype
BP1
BP2
BPNOS
Family history of suicide (Positive)
N Manic Episodes
0e4
5e9
10
N Depressive Episodes
0e4
5e9
10
NEO-FFI scores
Neuroticism
Openness
Conscientiousness
Extroversion
Agreeableness
a
Days Depressed Last year
a
Days Anxious Last year
Suicide ideation
1861
1860
1859
Mean/N
SD/%
40.9
862
13
46.3%
1023
1022
1022
40
348
12.1
34.1%
924
60
13
13
6
90.4%
5.9%
1.3%
1.3%
0.6%
346
345
321
34.2%
34.1%
31.7%
1702
77
6
44
14
91.6%
4.1%
0.3%
2.4%
0.8%
667
745
428
36.3%
40.5%
23.3%
1012
1074
45
237
936
667
21
17.4
6.0
6.3
14.6
13
4.7
32.4
43.1
0.3
17.3
2.4%
12.6%
49.6%
35.3%
12.2
12.0
8.23
6.34
10.5
11.3
5.5
16.1
11.4
0.8
6.8
1193
563
136
260
62.2%
29.4%
7.1%
21.1%
631
264
791
37.4%
15.7%
46.9%
539
283
888
31.5%
16.5%
51.9%
40.9
41.6
39.3
37.7
42.1
39.6%
31.0%
128
8.8
7.0
8.0
4.8
7.2
30.4
32.8
6.7%
1710
1089
1089
1089
993
989
760
760
648
702
1036
346
1091
667
965
15
74
545
440
18.6
14.8
4.4
7.9
18.7
16
5
40.8
39.5
0.5
16.6
1.4%
6.9%
50.7%
41.0%
11.01
9.4
6.3
6.9
11.0
11.7
5.8
15.4
11.1
1.2
6.7
772
241
58
209
70.9%
22.1%
5.3%
31.3%
220
143
602
22.8%
14.8%
62.4%
132
137
693
13.7%
14.2%
72.0%
45.2
41.2
37.6
37.0
40.1
48.7%
39.4%
153
8.0
7.3
8.1
5.1
7.1
29.0
33.8
14.1%
972
1137
1868
1850
1918
t/c2
SD/%
1887
1230
1686
Analysis
Mean/N
1840
1918
1918
1918
1805
1816
1304
1304
1135
1223
1837
425
1919
1.8
40.9
18.1
df
2227.1
1
5
0.071
<0.001
0.03
25.6
<0.001
31.3
<0.001
5.6
6.5
6.0
6.0
9.7
5.6
1.1
10.9
6.8
4.9
1.4
27.7
2448.6
2719.5
2758.7
1891.2
2803
2062
2064
1398
1923
1496.8
769
4
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
0.263
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
0.138
<0.001
24.1
69.1
1
2
<0.001
<0.001
121.8
<0.001
665
1056
1043
1088
10.6
1.2
4.2
3.1
5.8
6.4
8.1
44.7
1497.6
1800
1800
1800
1800
2110.7
2279.3
1
<0.001
0.23
<0.001
0.03
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
SD: Standard Deviation; df: Degrees of freedom; BP1: bipolar type 1; BP2: bipolar type 2; BPNOS: bipolar not otherwise specied; MADRS: MontgomeryeAsberg Depression
Rating Scale; YMRS: Young Mania Rating Scale; NEO-FFI: Neuroticism Extroversion Openness Five Factor Inventory; PDQ: Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire.
a
Percentage of days spent depressed/anxious in the year prior study entry.
year prior to study entry, suicide ideation at baseline and psychiatric comorbid disorders (post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD),
generalized anxiety disorder (GAD), obsessive compulsive disorder
(OCD), social phobia, agoraphobia, panic disorder with or without
agoraphobia, schizoaffective disorder, alcohol dependence/abuse,
drug dependence/abuse, bulimia nervosa purging/non-purging
type, anorexia nervosa restricting type); (ii) psychological factors:
PDQ, NEO-FFI and family history of suicide event (the latter entered
in this model due to a better log-likelihood statistic compared to
other models and on the basis of a diathesis rationale) (iii)
environmental factors: negative life events, cigarette smoking
(packets per day), QOL total score, and marital status.
We tested the validity of the predictors for each cluster separately using a Cox Regression Hazard Model, with the number of
days since study entry as time value, and suicide events
(attempted or completed suicide) as outcome. The last observation
was taken for patients without any suicide event. Since we tested a
large number of predictors that could overlap in terms of variance
explained, we ran multi-collinearity tests among variables within
each cluster. If multi-collinearity was observed, the model was run
separately for the correlated predictors. The best-t model was
maintained (evaluated using the log-likelihood statistic of the
model and the higher number of patients as criteria). The predictors
that resulted as signicant from the models of each of the three
1803
1804
Table 2
Clinical, psychological and environmental predictorsa of prospective suicide events in the STEP-BD.
B
SE
p value
OR
95.0% CI for OR
Lower
Upper
0.01
0.23
0.25
0.004
0.004
0.012
0.014
0.017
0.169
0.151
0.395
0.43
0.373
0.213
0.21
0.319
0.005
0.621
<0.001
0.01
0.954
0.792
0.884
0.082
0.96
0.244
0.21
0.126
0.97
0.779
0.174
0.216
0.97
1.12
3.86
1.01
1.00
1.003
1.002
0.97
0.99
1.19
0.61
0.52
0.99
0.94
1.33
1.48
0.95
0.72
2.38
1.003
0.993
0.979
0.975
0.938
0.712
0.887
0.281
0.223
0.474
0.62
0.882
0.794
0.99
1.75
6.25
1.019
1.007
1.028
1.03
1.004
1.38
1.601
1.323
1.204
2.049
1.431
2.008
2.774
0.292
0.481
182.8
0.334
0.376
0.486
0.439
0.319
0.294
0.314
0.458
0.355
0.273
0.014
0.096
0.96
0.017
0.925
0.404
0.096
0.152
0.177
0.051
0.404
0.048
0.84
2.05
2.23
0.00
2.21
1.04
0.66
2.08
1.58
0.67
1.84
1.47
2.02
0.95
1.157
0.868
0.00
1.15
0.496
0.257
0.878
0.846
0.378
0.996
0.597
1.006
0.554
3.629
5.71
4.476
4.264
2.163
1.728
4.908
2.949
1.196
3.409
3.596
4.049
1.616
0.264
0.456
0.301
0.733
1.102
0.246
0.255
0.253
0.253
0.272
0.338
0.324
0.233
0.212
0.838
0.153
0.682
0.645
0.298
0.026
0.786
0.848
0.172
0.422
0.356
0.155
1.389
1.098
1.539
0.741
0.602
0.774
1.763
0.934
0.953
1.45
1.312
1.349
1.392
0.829
0.45
0.852
0.176
0.069
0.477
1.07
0.568
0.58
0.851
0.676
0.715
0.883
2.33
2.682
2.778
3.114
5.217
1.254
2.907
1.534
1.565
2.472
2.547
2.545
2.197
0.32
0.01
0.02
0.317
0.047
0.682
1.38
1.02
1.01
0.74
1.00
0.96
2.59
1.05
1.06
0.01
0.07
<0.001
0.58
0.97
1.04
0.96
0.90
0.99
1.21
0.32
0.28
0.561
0.518
0.83
1.20
0.44
0.69
1.56
2.08
Abbreviation: PDQ: Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire; PTSD: post-traumatic stress disorder; GAD: general anxiety disorder; YMRS: Young Mania Rating Scale.
a
Signicant predictors are in bold.
b
Model includes same demographic and clinical predictors as the previous model with current comorbidities: in the model with lifetime comorbidities, from the clinical
predictors the only signicant ones were age, history of suicide attempt and % of days spent depressed last year.
c
N 2171 (suicide event: N 99, no suicide event: N 2072).
d
N 2179 (suicide event: N 99, no suicide event: N 2080).
e
N 1074 (suicide event: N 46, no suicide event: N 1028).
f
N 1981 (suicide event: N 93, no suicide event: N 1875).
1805
Table 3
Comorbid psychiatric disorders in patients with and without a history of suicide attempt at baseline.
Psychiatric disorder
Current comorbidities
Lifetime comorbidities
N (%)
PTSD
GAD
OCD
Social Anxiety Disorder
PD with Agoraphobia
PD without Agoraphobia
Agoraphobia without PD
Schizoaffective disorder
Alcohol dependence
Alcohol abuse
Drug dependence
Drug abuse
Bulimia nervosa PT
Bulimia nervosa NPT
Anorexia nervosa RT
Anorexia nervosa BE-PT
Psychotic disorder
Schizophrenia
Schizophreniform disorder
Psychotic disorder NOS
Delusional disorder
Brief psychotic disorder
Patients SA
Patients SA
91
259
115
207
89
52
60
9
118
139
68
85
12
7
2
1
9
3
0
9
1
0
113(11.2%)
215 (21.3%)
91 (9.0%)
216 (21.3%)
122 (12.0%)
55 (5.4%)
72 (7.1%)
12 (1.2%)
97 (9.6%)
102 (10.1%)
63 (6.2%)
73 (7.2%)
25 (2.5%)
8 (0.8%)
2 (0.2%)
3 (0.3%)
9 (0.9%)
2 (0.2%)
1 (0.1%)
5 (0.5%)
0 (0%)
1 (0.1%)
(5%)
(14.3%)
(6.3%)
(11.4%)
(4.9%)
(2.9%)
(3.3%)
(0.5%)
(6.5%)
(7.7%)
(3.8%)
(4.7%)
(0.7%)
(0.4%)
(0.1%)
(0.1%)
(0.5%)
(0.2%)
(0%)
(0.5%)
(0.1%)
(0%)
c2(1)
p value
36.77
22.57
6.8
49.84
47.83
11.69
21.03
4.18
8.72
4.88
9.06
7.93
16.42
2.01
0.35
2.67
1.6
0.04
1.8
0.00
0.56
1.8
<0.001
<0.001
0.009
<0.001
<0.001
0.001
<0.001
0.04
0.003
0.027
0.003
0.005
<0.001
0.16
0.55
0.102
0.206
0.843
0.180
0.998
0.456
0.180
N (%)
Patients SA
Patients SA
240
356
181
347
189
133
116
17
454
560
276
365
60
12
25
15
40
5
0
25
2
4
297
289
140
303
199
103
103
20
365
406
255
296
104
21
38
15
25
4
1
13
0
1
(13.2%)
(19.7%)
(10.0%)
(19.1%)
(10.4%)
(7.3%)
(6.4%)
(0.9%)
(25.1%)
(30.9%)
(15.2%)
(20.1%)
(3.3%)
(0.7%)
(1.4%)
(0.8%)
(2.2%)
(0.3%)
(0%)
(1.4%)
(0.1%)
(0.2%)
(29.4%)
(28.6%)
(13.8%)
(29.9%)
(19.6%)
(10.2%)
(10.2%)
(2.0%)
(36.1%)
(40.2%)
(25.3%)
(29.3%)
(10.3%)
(2.1%)
(3.8%)
(1.5%)
(2.5%)
(0.4%)
(0.1%)
(1.3%)
(0%)
(0.1%)
c2(1)
p value
109.93
29.49
9.59
42.58
47.57
6.79
12.89
5.47
38.24
24.68
42.58
30.53
57.59
11.22
16.81
2.65
0.210
0.3
1.8
0.04
1.11
0.54
<0.001
<0.001
0.002
<0.001
<0.001
0.009
<0.001
0.019
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
0.001
<0.001
0.104
0.647
0.587
0.180
0.842
0.291
0.462
Abbreviations: Patients SA: patients with a history of suicide attempt(s), Patients SA: patients without a history of suicide attempt(s), OCD: obsessive compulsive disorder,
PTSD: post-traumatic stress disorder, GAD: generalized anxiety disorder, PD: panic disorder, PT: purging type, NPT: non-purging type, RT: restriction type, BE-PT: binge-eating
purging type, NOS: not otherwise specied. Note: Signicant differences are indicated in bold.
Table 4
Final joint model of predictors of prospective suicide events.a
B
Age >40
Gender
History of suicide attempt
% of days spent depressed
last year
Obsessive compulsive
disorder
Current alcohol abuse
Agoraphobia
Lifetime drug dependence
b
High PDQ
Negative life events
a
SE
p value
OR
95.0% CI for OR
Lower
Upper
L0.56
0.19
0.957
0.011
0.01
0.24
0.252
0.004
0.015
0.416
<0.001
0.012
0.57
1.21
2.603
1.011
0.364
0.762
1.588
1.002
0.897
1.931
4.266
1.019
0.518
0.312
0.096
1.679
0.911
3.095
0.547
0.391
0.466
0.674
0.009
0.313
0.362
0.252
0.286
0.01
0.08
0.28
0.064
0.018
0.336
1.728
1.479
1.594
1.963
1.009
0.936
0.727
0.973
1.121
0.991
3.189
3.009
2.612
3.435
1.028
Our results also show that substance use disorders may also increase risk for suicidal behavior (although these predictors reached
a trend level of signicance in the nal model). Other studies have
also shown a worse suicide outcome for bipolar patients with substance disorder comorbidities (Cassidy, 2011; Finseth et al., 2012).
Among a group of depressed patients, comorbid substance dependence increased risk for suicide, compared to depressed patients
alone (Dumais et al., 2005). Our ndings support the proposition
that a positive history of drug dependence or current alcohol abuse
may increase the risk of future suicide event(s).
We also observed that the comorbidity of OCD was a suggestive
prospective predictor of future suicide events (predictor reached
trend level of signicance in the nal model). Indeed, bipolar patients with comorbid anxiety disorders had a history of more suicide
attempts compared to BD patients without comorbidity (Lee and
Dunner, 2008). Specically, comorbid OCD in bipolar patients has
been associated with higher incidence of prior suicide attempts
(Kruger et al., 2000) and obsessive compulsive tendencies have been
correlated with suicidal tendencies (Lester and Abdel-Khalek, 1999).
Despite the large amount of studies showing a protective effect
of lithium on suicide risk in bipolar patients (Baldessarini et al.,
2006; Cipriani et al., 2005; Young et al., 2010), this association was
not signicant in our model. Our nding is in line with a previous
study that was designed to examine the impact of pharmacotherapy
on prospective suicide attempts in STEP-BD subjects (Marangell
et al., 2008). One explanation could be that STEP-BD study is an
open study, not a comparison or randomized clinical trial, so clinician choice may have biased the effect of lithium treatment.
4.1. Limitations
A smaller number of suicide events (4.6%) was observed in the
STEP-BD sample in comparison to other samples (32.4% in retrospective and 19.8% in prospective studies assessing suicide attempts) (Novick et al., 2010). One explanation for the low suicide
rate may be that the cohort of patients in the STEP-BD study was
1806
Fig. 1. Survival curves of Bipolar Disorder patients over the course of the STEP-BD study, stratied by baseline presence of major predictors of prospective suicide events. Abbreviations: PDQ: Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire. *Prior to study entry A: no history of suicide attempt (events: 43; censored: 1875; total: 1918), history of suicide attempt(s)
(events: 51; censored: 633; total: 684), history of suicide attempt(s) high PDQ scores (events: 41; censored: 364; total: 405), B: no history of suicide attempt (events: 43;
censored: 1875; total: 1918), history of suicide attempt(s) (events: 51; censored: 545; total: 583), history of suicide attempt(s) age<40 (events: 54; censored: 452; total: 506), C:
no history of suicide attempt (events: 43; censored: 1875; total: 1918), history of suicide attempt(s) (events: 21; censored: 414; total: 435), history of suicide attempt(s) high %
days depressed (events: 71; censored: 583; total: 654).
5. Conclusions
Our ndings suggest that prior history of suicide attempts is the
strongest predictor for future suicide events in Bipolar Disorder.
Moreover, bipolar patients of younger age, with personality disorder traits, as well as with long periods spent in depressed mood
may have a higher risk for future suicidal behavior. These characteristics are potentially identiable when the patient presents for
treatment and can be addressed with intensive care by clinicians.
Role of founding source
The STEP-BD project was funded in whole or in part with
federal funds from the National Institute of Mental Health
(NIMH), under contract N01-MH-80001. Details of past and current STEP-BD participants can be found at www.stepbd.org/
research/stepacknowledgmentlist.pdf. The work of Niki Antypa
1807
1808
Song JY, Yu HY, Kim SH, Hwang SS, Cho HS, Kim YS, et al. Assessment of risk factors
related to suicide attempts in patients with bipolar disorder. The Journal of
Nervous and Mental Disease 2012;200:978e84.
Valtonen HM, Suominen K, Mantere O, Leppamaki S, Arvilommi P, Isometsa E.
Suicidal behaviour during different phases of bipolar disorder. Journal of Affective Disorders 2007;97:101e7.
Wilkowska-Chmielewska J, Szelenberger W, Wojnar M. Age-dependent symptomatology of depression in hospitalized patients and its implications for DSM-5.
Journal of Affective Disorders 2013;150:142e5.
Young AH, McElroy SL, Bauer M, Philips N, Chang W, Olausson B, et al. A doubleblind, placebo-controlled study of quetiapine and lithium monotherapy in
adults in the acute phase of bipolar depression (EMBOLDEN I). Journal of
Clinical Psychiatry 2010;71:150e62.
Young RC, Biggs JT, Ziegler VE, Meyer DA. A rating scale for mania: reliability, validity and sensitivity. British Journal of Psychiatry 1978;133:429e35.