BR0 P10761 B01 Public 01113120101
BR0 P10761 B01 Public 01113120101
BR0 P10761 B01 Public 01113120101
57669
Executive Summary
Background:
Karnataka State Highways Improvement Project (KSHIP) is a road upgrading and rehabilitation initiative
by Government of Karnataka under the World Bank loan to undertake improvement of 3411 km of roads
consisting of State Highways and Major District Roads.
The Project will be implemented in different phases. Based on the Feasibility study, GoK has selected
269 Km of roads for up gradation in a phased manner under KSHIP-ll, EPC Package on priority. The
total estimated project cost is 650.75 Crores. This will be funded by World Bank and Government of
Karnataka.
The present Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Report relates to the corridors mentioned below
selected for up gradation under EPC Package as per the guidelines of the Ministry of Environment and
Forests (MoEF) of the Government of India (Gol) and World Bank's operational policy OP 4.01. One
consolidated Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Report and link wise Environmental Management
Plans (EMPs) are prepared as per the EIA Notification and World Bank guidelines and are available for
review in the official web site of www.kpwd.gov.in.
Project Description:
EPC Package of eight project road links has been divided into five Contract Packages and these have been
broken into smaller road links. The project corridors selected under this exercise are given in the
following table.
Contract
Package
Link
ID
Location of Roads
Length
(Km)
SHNo.
67A
23.50
82
67B
M7D
T8
28.90
43.46
31.80
82
1&69
2
WEP3
21B
Dharwad - Saundatti
38.50
34
WEP4
13A
13B
WEP5
6C
32.45
41.35
28.63
268.59
61
15
22
WEPI
WEP2
Districts
Bangalore
(R) & Kolar
Kolar
Haveri
Haveri
Belgaum&
Dharwad
Raichur
Raichur
Gulbarga
The work involved pavement design, highway design, and design of structures and environmental and
social impact evaluation of the project. The expected contract period for construction work is 36 months.
The design life (or operation period) of the project is 20 years from the start of operation.
Key environmental laws and regulations:
All Environmental acts, Policy guidelines of both State as well as Central Government are applicable to
KSHIP. The Constitutional Provisions like Article 48 and 51-A (g) and 74th Amendment to the
Constitution serve as principle guidelines of environmental protection. Further, The Indian Forest Act,
1927; Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980; National Forest Policy, 1952, 1988 (Rev.); The Forest
Conservation Rules, 1981; The Karnataka Forest Act, 1963; The Water (Prevention and Control) Act,
1974; The Air (Prevention and Control) Act, 1981 ; Environmental (Protection) Act, 1986, and Rules,
1987-2006 (various); EIA Notification, 1994; 14th September 2006; February 2009; Wildlife (Protection)
Act, 1972; Hazardous Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 1989 & 2006; National Environment
Tribunal Act, 1995; National Environment Appellate Authority Act, 1997; Public Liability Insurance Act,
1991; and Chemical Accidents (Emergency Planning, Preparedness and Response) Rules, 1996; Motor
Vehicular Act, 1988; Central & State Motor Vehicles Rules; Noise Pollution Control Act, 1990; The
Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958; Coastal Management Zone (CMZ)
Notification, 2009; The Factories Act 1956; Labour Act, 1986 and other guidelines and norms related to
road construction such as Guidelines for Rail, Road and Highways Projects, 1989 and Indian Road
Congress with respect to environmental protection including IRC:I04-1988; IRC:36-1974; IRC:1O-1961;
IRC:36-1970; IRC:43-1972; IRC:72-1978; IRC:33-1982; etc are also applicable.
Categorization and clearance status of the project roads:
The Environmental Clearance for these proposed project roads is governed by EIA Notification 2006. The
following table shows categorisation of KSHIP project roads with respect to EIA Notification of MoEF.
Environmental clearance for all the project roads has been obtained from State Environmental Impact
Assessment Authority (SEIAA).
Link
ID
67A
67B
M7D
T8
2IB
13A
13B
6C
Length
(Km)
23.50
28:90
43.46
31.80
38.50
32.45
41.35
28.63
Category under
MoEF Notification
*
*
Cate~ory
B
B
Cate~ory B
Category B
Category B
Cate~ory
Length Status of
(km)
Clearance
<30Km. Obtained
<30Km. Obtained
>30Km. Obtained
Obtained
>30Km
>30Km. Obtained
>30Km
Obtained
>30Km
Obtained
<30Km. Obtained
Clearance for forest land diversion is required for links 67 A, 13A, M7D and T8 Applications for
diversion have already been moved.
Baseline Environment:
Information on baseline environment was collected from secondary source of data for the environmental
parameters like climate, physiography (Geology and geomorphology), biological and socio-economic
environment of the project influence area. The environmental details have also been collected from
Primary source of data such as base maps prepared by reconnaissance survey, extrapolation of
environmental features on the proposed design, tree enumeration, Analysis for environmental parameters
such as Air, Water, Noise and Soil quality on the project road.
Stakeholder Consultation:
Consultation process during feasibility and environmental assessment has been conducted with the
objective of involving local affected communities and institutional stakeholders in the project planning
(participatory planning). Involvement of stakeholders and execution of suggested improvement from
stakeholders creates the sense of ownership among the communities of the region and eases the
implementation process. During the consultations specific suggestions, issues, and concerns were on bus
shelters, road safety, speed breakers, dust control, bypasses & realignments, foot paths, compensation
paid to the PAPs, Plantation of trees, conservation of natural water resources, etc.
Analysis of Alternatives:
The constituent road links of the EPC package were finalised after consideration of no project scenario,
project with alternative, project with mitigations were considered for exercising analysis of alternatives.
Options such as bypasses/realignments to avoid the places of congestion and human settlements;
realignments to avoid significant old trees, utilities and environmentally sensitive areas (forest lands,
erosion prone areas, flood regions, etc); different construction material options keeping in view traffic
condition, obligatory points, geometric designs, congestions and socio economic viability and other
environmental aspects of the region were also given due consideration during the impact assessment.
Environmental Impacts from the project road:
The objective of the project being up-gradation of the existing State Highways and Major District Roads
involve lesser to moderate impacts on surrounding environment and these situations do not call for full
scale Environmental assessment but do require impact identification, mitigation and a certain aspects of
compliance, monitoring and documentation.
The possible impacts of the project on the environment during the construction as well as operation of the
road include land consumption, removal of vegetation, fragmentation of natural habitat, removal
of buildings, loss of soil productivity, soil erosion, destabilization of slopes, side- tipping of
spoils material, loss of properties and temporary diversion of natural surface water flows,
vehicular emissions during construction and operation phase, release of hazardous gases due to
explosions/leak from the hazardous chemicals carrying transport trucks, impact during
construction activities due generation of fugitive dust from crusher units, and air emissions from
hot mix plants and vehicles used for transportation of materials; Impact on surface water flow
modification; Impact on ground water table modification; Impact on water quality degradation
(surface & ground water); Impact due to discharge of wastewater generation from the temporary
project camps/offices; effect of noise levels on nearby habitation during the construction and
operational phases of the project; Changes in water quality, soil profile, noise and air pollution
which may affect the nature and character of habitats; Loss of forest resources; Displacement of
human settlement from proposed site; Impact on community resources; Increase in road
accidents; Impact due to accelerated urbanization; positive impacts on the present status of
livelihood, economy of the region; etc. Impacts due to project may be summarized along with positive
impacts as follows.
Environmental Attributes
Physical
Environment
Air
Biological
Environment
Water Noise
Flora
~. Construction Phase
ILabour Camp_ Activities
-veil
lQuarrying!Burrow malerials
-velt
-velt
!Malerial Transport & Slorage
-veil
-veIl
IDrilling and Blasli~
-velt
-velt
lPavemenl works
-veIl
-veIl -veIl
~se of Construclion Equipmenl
-velt
-velt -velt
~ulting of Trees
IPlanlation
+ve/p
+ve/p
!Drainage Works
~ulvert and Bridge Construction
-veIl -veIl
~tripping of Topsoil
lDebris Generation
Pil and Grease
-veil
I. Operational Phase
~ehicular Movemenl
+velp
+velp
Note: t - Temporary; p- Permanent.
Impacts indicated in bold letters are Significant Impacts.
Fauna
-veIl
-veIl
-veIl
-veIl
Geology
Natural
and
Draina2e' ISoil
Topography
-veIl
-veIl
-velp
-veIl
-veIl
-ve/p
-velp
+velp
+ve/p
-velp
-velt
-veIl
+ve/p
-veIl
-veIl
+velp
Project link wise data on Environmental impacts are given in the following table.
Project road link ID
No. of trees 10 be felled (Nos.)
Hand pumps {No.)
Bore wells (No.)
Waler cislem/Pump House (No.)_
Waler taps (No.)
Impacl on Religious struclures
(No.)
Impacl on Communily structures
(No.)
ForeSI land 10 be acquired (Ha)
Electric Poles 10 be shifted (No.)
Transformers 10 be shifted (No.)
Telephone Poles 10 be shifted
(No.)
67A
1,556
2
2
10
1
Environmental Impacts
67B
M7D
T8
2881
1761
2870
7
0
9
1
17
5
10
4
5
2
II
0
21B
320
1
0
4
1
13A
1397
17
6
6
1
13B
1370
16
20
2
1
6C
2164
6
1
7
7
II
15
10
10
14
10
0.2400
410
20
0.8750
370
18
0.1316
339
II
225
11
0.5718
249
4
152
9
266
7
277
7
36
23
28
11
12
19
67
It is necessary to have a good environmental mitigation and enhancement measures for road projects.
A voidance has been taken as the principal means to minimize project impact. Most of the construction
works in the project shall be confined to the existing right of way. During various surveys, consultations
and site investigations, a number of environmental issues were identified. Though effective measures for
avoidance and impact mitigation were considered, the generalized mitigation measures have been planned
for the environmental aspects shown below.
A venue plantation and compensatory afforestation against impact on existing avenue plantation.
Conservation of fertile topsoil, slope stabilization and soil erosion control measures.
Noise barriers for schools, hospitals and other noise sensitive receptors.
Rehabilitation of Hand pump, public water supplies, wells and other sources of drinking water.
Compensatory afforestation and avenue plantation against the total impacted trees due to project.
Impact mitigation and rehabilitation measures for religious structures and cultural properties.
Mitigation measures for forest areas, eco-sensitive areas and wildlife/traffic conflict.
Environmental enhancement measures for oxbow lands and other left over lands along the corridor.
Summary of link wise impact mitigation measures proposed are given in the following table.
67A
678
M7D
7
7
5360
3112
6
10
10
5200
5762
5
8
8
3060
3522
14
12
10
218
13A
138
6C
10
6
6
6720
640
5
14
14
1920
2794
9
17
17
4720
2740
9
18
18
2000
4328
8
24
16
16
10
1'8
13
13
5360
5740
Length
(Km)
Conclusion:
The project aim being limited to up-gradation of existing State Highways, involves lesser environmental
impacts and more of positive aspects. Further, most of the adverse impacts of road project occur during
construction period and they are temporary and manageable in nature. Most of these impacts can be
minimized through engineering solutions incorporated into the project design and by implementing
adequate and timely mitigation measures as included in the Environmental Management Plan. So, the
overall findings of the EIA are that the proposed works are unlikely to cause any significant adverse
environmental impacts.
'
.r;
'S
~:J
:J
~
is
a..
-.
.
"
'
.-.....
.,...
"0
Q)
.~
0
.r;
'S
:J
I/)
0
(3
I/)
is
.2
:3
:J
a..
.......
.--
".
.....-
E2436
V1
...- "....
,-
'"
,~
""
..
>
..
', ;
"
,"
Prepared for:
...
Govt of Kamataka
PUblic Works
Dept.
(PIU,KSIDP)
....
,"
~ ... '
April 1009
.----------------------------------------------------------...
- - - - ... ~ ... A
Yn7'T'
Tn
List of Abbreviations
BIS
BOQ
PUC
PWD
R&R
RAP
RCC
RHS
RoW
RPM
SEAC
SH
SIA
SOS
SPM
SSD
IDS
TMC
TP
TSP
UPPS
WMM
WS
WWF
EXECunvES~RY
1.
Project background:
The Karnataka State Highways Improvement Project (KSHIP) is an initiative by the Public Works
Department (PWD) of the Government ofKarnataka (GoK), under the proposed World Bank loan, to
undertake improvement of 4887.5 km of roads consisting of State Highways and major District
Roads. These roads were selected on the basis of a Strategic Option Study (SOS) carried out in 2003.
To facilitate this job the Government of Karnataka has appointed MIs Scott Wilson Kirkpatrick UK
and Scott Wilson Kirkpatrick India as the Project Coordinating Consultants (peC) to carry out the
Feasibility study for the road up gradation. Based on the Feasibility study, the GoK selected 268.59
Km of roads for up gradation in a phased manner under KSHIP-II, EPC.
The scope of the feasibility study included preparation of an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)
Report on the roads selected for tip gradation in KSHIP-ll, EPC as per the Guidelines of the Ministry
of Environment and Forests (MoEF) of the Government of India (Gol) and to meet the requirements
of the World Bank as per its operational policy OP 4.01.
2.
Objectives:
The main objective of the study would be to alleviate the unsafe condition and congestion of the
existing selected road network connecting the villages and towns by enhancing the capacity and
quality of the roads to the users in a sustainable and environment friendly manner. MoEF, Gol, has
enforced Environment (Protection) Act 1986 and recent Notification on Environmental Impact
Assessment dated 14th September 2006, to avoid, mitigate & prevent the environmental impact from
various projects or activities or expansion and modernization of existing projects. In line with these
guidelines the Environmental Impact Assessment Report has been prepared for 269.40 km road under
KSHIP, EPC. The reportJdentifies, predicts, interprets and communicates infonnation about impacts
of the proposed project on the environment along with mitigative and management measures for the
indicated impacts.
3.
The scope of Environmental Assessment includes screening and scoping, environmental assessment
and environmental management plan for the individual project roads as required The Enviroomental
assessment process also envisages developing a broad environmental management framework for the
project
Interpretation and Applicability of the MoEF Notification dated 14th September 2006, for KSIDP-ll,
EPC road links is as follows.
Schedule I
Genera) Conditions
CateKoryA
Cate20ryB
(f) i) New National High i) New State High ways; Any project or activity specified in
7
Highways
ways; and
and
Category 'B' will be treated as Category
A, if located in whole or in part within
ii)
Expansion
Expansion
of ii)
of 10 Ian from the boundary of: (i)
National High ways National
I
State Protected Areas notified under the WIld
greater than 30 KM, Highways greater than Life (Protection) Act, 1972, (ii)
involving
additional 30
involving Critically Polluted areas as notified by
Ian
right of way greater than additional right of way the Central Pollution Control Board
20m involving land greater
20m from time to time, (iii) Notified Ecothan
acquisition and passing involving
land sensitive areas, (iv) inter-State
through more than one acquisition.
boundaries
international
and
State.
boundaries.
Project
On the basis of above categorization, the 8 road links have been grouped as follows with respect to
Environmental Clearance.
Group I: Roads having length of> 30 km length and located within 10 km distance from interstate
border or National Park or Sanctuary. There are no road links grouped under Category' A'.
Group IT: Roads having length of> 30 km and average new land requirement for improvements is <
20 m are grouped under Category 'B' and environmental clearance (NOC) is obtained from the State
Environmental Impact Assessment Authority, OoK.
LinkID
Description of the links
M7D ~gal- Tadasa
IHaveri (NH-4) - Hangal
T8
pharwad - Saundatti
Ifhinthini - Chinchodi - lalhalli - Karegud Pevadurga
lDevadurga - Masarkal- Gabbur - Kalmala
2lB
13A
13B
Group
2008.
m:
LinkID.
67A
67B
6C
4.
Length in Kms
43.50
31.78
38.57
32.45
41.40
Roads < 30 kIn, which are not under the purview of EIA Notification 141b September
LenEth in Kms
23.50
23.90
29.28
The corridors selected for improvement under KSHIP II. EPC are distributed allover the state of
Karnataka. Other details of the project discussed under this head include, location of the corridors
with respect to districts they traverse; Right of Way of each link; proposed contract packages
(grouping 8 road links into 5 contract packages); present and projected traffic details by vehicle type
pertaining to the project roads; improvement alternatives considered; design speed of the links;
various treatment alternatives; options on road construction materials such as rocks, gravel, sand,
embankment fill, asphalt; the major material location for aggregates, murrum and sand in the project
area; options on bypass; design cross sections, road widening and improvements; details of bridges
and culverts; etc,.
S.
The Constitutional Provisions like Article 48 and 51-A (g) and 74th Amendment to the Constitution
serve as principle guidelines of environmental protection. Further Regulations, Acts, Policies
applicable to sustainability arid environmental protection is as follows.
The Indian Forest Act, 1927
The Kamataka Forest Act, 1963
The Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 (as amended in 1988)
The Forest Conservation Rules, 1981
The Wildlife Protection Act, 1972
The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986
The Water (Prevention and Control) Act, 1974
The Air (Prevention and Control) Act, 1981
6.
After revie~g the various applicable acts and stanites, as mentioned above, it is suggested that some
clearances and pennission are required for various corridors of the project. A summary of clearances
required for the present project is shown in the foUowing table.
SL
No.
1
Subject
Forest Clearance
2 ' Environmental
Clearance
Authority
Wben
Granting
required
Clearance
Karnataka State Before
Forest
Construction
Department.
Kamataka State Before
Environmental
Construction
Appraisal
Corridors
requiring
clearaDce5
Should be supported By 67A, 13A &
finalized alignment and M7D
exact extent of land
required for acguisition
Supported by EIA, M7D,T8.
Project . 21B, 13A&
EMP
and
13B
Report
Remarks
Committee
4
5
7
8
Before
Construction
Before
Acquisition
Before
Cutting
Before
Construction
Before
Construction
Before
&
during
construction.
Before
Construction
During
SI.
No.
10
11
Subject
Management and
regulation during
operation
Clearance of
Police Department
blasting & keeping
explosives at work
sites
Crossing railway
Indian Railways
lines
12
Installation of
Generators
13
Clearance for
cutting &
soil
Permission for
extraction of
boulder
]4
IS
16
Labour camps
17
Clearance for
crossing other
waterways
18
If water has to be
taken from river I
Reservoir
7.
Autbority
Granting
Clearance
Wben
required
Remarks
Corridors
requiring
clearances
Construction
During
Construction
Before
Construction
Kamataka
Before
Electricity
Installation
company of
respective regions
Department of
Before
Quarrying
Mines I Local
Bodies
Department of
Before
Mines & Geology. Quarrying
Government of
Karnataka
Commissioner of During
Explosives &
Construction
KSPCB
District Health
During
Officer
Construction
Irrigation
During
Department, GoK. Construction
at the
specific site
Irrigation
During
Department, GoK. Construction
at the
specific site
None
Should be supported by
detailed designs and
drawings
None
All road links
Whereever
the necessity
arises.
Baseline Environment:
Information on baseline environment was collected from secondary source of data for the macro
environmental parameters like climate, physiography (Geology and geomorphology), biological and
socio-economic environment of the project influence area, PIU, respective district offices of the
project. roads. The micro-environmental details within the Corridor of Impact (Col) have been
collected from Primary source of data such as base maps prepared by reconnaissance survey,
extrapolation of environmental features on the proposed design, tree enumeration, Analysis for
environmental parameters such as Air, Water, Noise and Soil quality on the project road.
8.
Stakeholder Consultation:
Consultation process during pre-feasibility, feasibility and environmental assessment stage has been
conducted with the objective of involving local communities in the project planning (participatory
planning). Vcry often suggestion and option given by people improves technical and economic
efficiency of the project. Execution of suggested improvement from stakeholders also generates the
sense of ownership among the communities of the region and eases the implementation process.
The stakeholders of the project included affected communities (within the corridor of impact) and
institutional stakeholders such as Pollution Control Board, Local bodies, Department of Water
Resources, Department of Mines and Geology, Deparbnent of Forest, etc.
During the consultations specific suggestions, issues, and concerns were sought from the local
communities and stakeholders. Summary of issues during consultation process is as follows.
Main issues raised dunnE project specific consultations
Provision for new parking areas
Foot path
Speed breakers
Public comfort station
Rain shelter
Sign boards
Bus bays
Crash baniers/parapet
Bypasses and realignments
Dust control
Drainage
Proper compensation paid to the PAPs
Road
should
be
more
safe
for
the
road
Availability of water for construction.
users
Wildlife presence
Road side tree planting
Plantation of trees
Solid
Noise
Barriers
to
insulate
noise.
The constituent road links of the KSHIP n, EPC were selected after fmalization of various
alte1natives such as bypass, to avoid the places of congestion and human settlements; realignments,.to
avoid significant old trees, utilities and environmentally sensitive areas (forest lands, erosion prone
areas, flood regions, etc); different construction material options keeping in view traffic condition,
obligatory points, geometric designs, congestions and socio economic viability and other
environmental aspects of the region. Tbeobjective of this chapter is to highlight some of the salient
issues considered for exercising options such as project with alternative, project with mitigations, no
project scenario.
10.
The road improvement project along with positive impacts may also cause significant negative impact
on nearby communities and the natural environment. Impacts due to project may be summarized as
follows.
Physiea)
EnVironmeat
Environmental
Attributes
Air
Biological
EaVironmeat
Geology
Topo
grapby
Remarks
11 Construction Pbase
iLabour Camp
Ruarrying
~al Transport
~Storage
Drilling and
Blastin
.
g
Pavement works
-velt
~ctivities
-ve/t
-velt
-velt
-velt
-ve/t
-ve/t
-veJt
-velt
-velt
C~7
-velt
-velt
-velt
-veJt
-veJt
-velt
-velp
Environmental
Attributes
Physical
Environment
Air
Use of
Construction
-velt
~ui~_ment
Geology
Drainage Works
Plivert and
!Bridge
Construction
Stripping of
rropsoil
Debris Generation
Oil and Grease
1I. Operational Phase
Vehicular
-velp
Movement
Section 7.8.2
Chapter 7
Section 7.8.2
Chapter 7
Section 7.5 Chapter 7
+ve/p +velp
+Velp
-velt -velt
Section 7.5,7.5.1
Chapter 7
-velp
-velt
-velt
-velt
Remarks
7.5 Chapter 7
-ve/p
+velp
Topo
graphy
-velt -velt
~utting of Trees
iPlantation
Biological
Environment
-velt
-velp
-velt
-velt
11.
This chapter narrates the different remedial measures to be taken up for avoidance of negative
environmental impacts. Impacts can be avoided completely for certain stretches by no project
alternative. Reduction in the intensity of impact is possible by taking mitigation measures and changes
in the design, construction methodology, construction materials, etc. Some of the generalized
mitigation measures include.
Safe debris and construction waste disposal with compaction and turfing.
Conservation of fertile topsoil.
Dust mitigation measures during the construction phase.
Slope stabilization and soil erosion control measures.
Conservation of surface water bodies along the project corridor.
Provision of solid or vegetative noise barriers for silent receptors such as schools, hospitals
and civil courts.
Environmental monitoring for air, water, noise and soil during the construction and
operational phases.
Compensatory aforestation against the total impacted trees due to project.
Rehabilitation ofhand pumps, public water supplies an(i wells.
Impact mitigation for religious structures and other cultural properties.
Provision of required number of cross drainage structure to retain the original surface
hydrological flows.
Biodiversity conservation.
Reuse or safe disposal of hazardous waste materials such as scarified bitumen.
Environmental enhancement measures for oxbow lands and other left over lands along the
corridor.
12.
Environmental Management Plan (EMP) deals with the implementation procedure of the guidelines
and mitigation measures recommended to avoid, minimize and mitigate foreseen environmental
impacts of the project. It also includes management of measures suggested for enhancement of the
environmental quality along the proposed roads.
For each negative impact of the project the mitigation measure, its timeframe implementation and
overseeing I supervision responsibilities are discussed.
13.
The budgetary provision for the implementing EMP of the road project has been made under two
categories based on the responsibility of the execution.
A) EMAP to be implemented under civil works contract
B) EMAP to be implemented by Government Departments!Agencies as per the regulatory
requirements
The works to be undertaken have been quantified and quantities included in the respective BOQ
items. Items such as safe disposal of unserviceable materials with suitable top soil treatment; dust
mitigation during construction phase; recharge pits; silt fencing; sign boards for ecologically sensitive
areas; safe disposal of scarified bitumen in pits; construction of noise barriers for silent receptors;
monitoring of air, water, noise and soil qualities; oil interceptors; personal protective equipments for
labours to be implemented under civil works contract and redevelopment of oxbow lands and other
leftover lands; raising median plantations; compensatory afforestation; compensatory provisions in
terms of Net Present Value (NPV) for diverted forest lands; providing environmental management
training at all levels are discussed under mandatory works to be implemented by Government
Departments or other agencies as per the regulatory requirements.
supervision
Consultants
Executive Summary
Scott Wilson
Executive Summary
Resettlement Action Plan
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Kamataka State Highways Improvement Project (KSHIP) - II, initial priority roads cover 826.6
kms. The aim of the project is to improve the performance of the State's road transport network by
improving road conditions and capacity, and to improve the State's capacity to plan, develop and
maintain the Kamataka roads network. The roads have been categorised in two for engineering and
contracting purpose. The KSHIP II consists of 269.4 kms of EPC roads consisting of 5 packages and
557.3 kms of roads under annuity contract consisting of 4 packages. All these road are planned for
upgradation with a 7 m carriage way . The 826.6kms 'o f roads will serve 14 districts and 30 taluks.
According to the categorization of taluks given in the High Power Committee for Redressal of
Regional Imbalances Report of 2002, the KSHIP -II Stage I covers (i) 8 most backward taluks (ii) 6
more backward taluk (iii) 8 backward taluks and (iv) 8 relatively developed taluks. The KSHIP -II
Stage I roads have been selected based on the Feasibility Study conducted by the PWD for proposed
KSHIP-n.
Census socio- economic surveys were conducted on the upgradation roads, for a Corridor of Impact
between 16 m and 22 m keeping in view the design requirements. According to the census survey
there are 3361 PAFs and 14739 PAPs. There are 266 women headed households. The 180 tribal PAFs
identified. Of the total Project Affected Families (PAFs), major impact is on 1805 families, and minor
impacts are on 1555 PAFs. The project will impact 1646 community structures. There is no impact on
archaeological sites. All community structures will be relocated by the project authorities before
demolition.
The Land Acquisition Plan has been completed for the EPC" packages. Land acquisition for the
project is estimated at 179.983 hectares of private land which needs to be acquired and 6.4 hectares of
government land which has to be transferred from other Government Departments.
Public consultations were held in all the packages, focusing. on areas of impact due to widening, at
places congestion with impacts on buildings and where major common property resources are getting
affected- such as any religious structures etc. The out come of the consultations were used to prepare
the Social Impact Assessment and for analysis of alternatives and minimizing negative impact of the
project. Outcome of consultations were incorporated at the Policy level and through designs. 25
meetings have been held covering around 2500 participants. The consultations have helped in not only
achieving the social assessment objectives, but also assisted in gathering suggestions for mitigation of
adverse impacts, improvement in designs and facilitating inputs for the resettlement plan preparation
and implementation.
The GOK will adopt a Resettlement and Rehabilitation (R&R) Policy for KSHIP- II to address the
adverse impacts arising out of this project on the line of National Policy of Resettlement and
Rehabilitation 2007. The policy adopted for the project is consistent with the World Banks
Involuntary Resettlement Policy. This RAP is prepared in accordance with the stipulations and guidelines provided in Public Works Departmental Code Government of Kamatakat, and the project
specific Resettlement and Rehabilitation: - Principles and Policy Framework for the Karnataka State
Highways Improvement Project, The National Resettlement and Resettlement Policy 2007 and The
World Bank Policy as given in Operational Policy 4.12. In addition to the above measures, realizing
the need of infrastructure development like roads in timely manner, the PWD GOK has decided to
acquire the land through the legislation called "The Kamataka Highways Act 1964"(KHA,1964). The
KHA, 1964 provides the opportunity to acquire the land through consent award. It is expected that
I
land acquisition under this Act will help the PAPs to receive the market price/replacement cost of land
as compensation. The GOK has already initiated the process of establishing the Negotiation
Committee. The role of the committee will be to negotiate the price of land with the beneficiary. The
guidance value of the land will be considered for negotiation. Minimum negotiated price for the
Districts of Bangalore Urban, Bangalore Rural, Chikkaballapur, Kolar, Ramnagaram, Mysore,
Davangere, Belgaum and Dakshin Kannada will be 1.5 times the Guidance Value. For all the other
districts other than those mentioned the minimum price will be 2 times the guidance value
Some of the entitlements include payment of compensation through negotiation according to the
KHA; additional 25% compensation for those becoming marginal farmers; eligibility of bagar hukum
land losers; grant for replacement of cattle .shed; alternative house or developed plot +construction
cost for those losing house; additional 25% compensation for partially affected structures towards
reconstruction; income generating assets up to Rs.75,000 for those losing commercial structures;
Rental allowance for tenants; non titleholders to get alternate house or developed plot + construction
cost, for commercial structures alternate shop or income generating asset; employees losing
livelihood will be given a one time payment; vulnerable groups including physically challenged and
those above 60 years will be given a lump sum amount as assistance; and all community assets will be
replaced and reconstructed.
This RAP will be implemented by Kamataka PWD-PIU Social Development Resettlement Cell with
support from NGOs. The Special DC LA will be responsible for land acquisition activities and the
Chief Administrative Officer will be responsible for all Resettlement and rehabilitation works. A
grievance redressal cell will be constituted. The grievance redressal process specifies procedures for
registering and addressing complaints including appeal mechanisms. The Government of Kamatlika
has initiated the process of establishing a 3 member Grievance Redressal Committee (GRC) with the
Deputy Commissioner as the Chairman in ea~h project district. An independent agency will be hired
for Monitoring and Evaluation support. Concurrent Evaluation will be only for mid term evaluation.
End evaluation will be carried out at the end of implementation which will be done by a different
independent agency.
The RAP provides the implementation schedule which is linked to the commencement of civil works.
The civil works for the first milestone will commence in December 2009. The R&R and land
acquisition for milestone - 1 is targeted to be completed by November 2009. The RAP will be
implemented over a period of 3 years starting from 1st October 2009. Implementation activities
include land acquisition process, relocation and rehabilitation and monitoring. Various income
restoration schemes have been identified during the course of social survey and the public
consultations, which have been integrated for income restoration
The estimated total budget for the implementation of RAP is Rs. 147.83 Crore.
CHAPTER I - INTRODUCTION
Background
1.1. The Kamataka State Highways Improvement Project (KSHIP) - II, initial priority roads cover
826.6 kms. The roads have been categorised in two for engineering and contracting purpose. It
consists of 269.4 kms of EPC roads consisting of 5 packages and 557.3 kms of roads under
annuity contract consisting of 4 packages. All these road are planned for upgradation with a 7 m
carriage way. Upgradation will have direct lindirect impact on the population along the project
corridor. Common property resources, residential structures, commercial structures are likely to
be affected. Non-titleholders within the ROW are likely to be displaced.
The 826.6kms of roads will serve 14 districts and 30 taluks. According to the categorization of
taluks given in the High Power Committee for Redressal of Regional Imbalances Report of
2002, the KSHIP -II Stage I covers (i) 8 most backward taluks (ii) 6 more backward taluk (iii) 8
backward taluks and (iv) 8 relatively developed taluks. The KSHIP -II Stage I roads have been
selected based on the Feasibility Study conducted by the PWD for proposed KSHIP-II. The
826.6 km of roads for upgradation were selected through a detailed economic, sociai2 (the
details of selection process of roads can be seen from Social Impact Assessment report),
environmental and technical criteria using the Highway Design Module programme (HDM-IV),
covering 4887 kms. The location Map of the packages has been provided in Annex 1.1.
T
' Rd
a be l.l :l P
rOJect
oa s
Contract
Package
WEPI
Link
67A
67B
WEP2
WEP3
WEP4
M7D
T8
21B
13A
WEP5
13B
6C
WAPI
63A
Description of Links
Hoskote - H Cross (Hindgnala Cross)
H Cross - ChinatmaniBypass (Corridor 65F
Junctn)
Hangal- Tadasa
Haveri (NH4) - Hangal
Dharwad - Saundatti
Tinthini - Chinchodi - Jalhalli - Karegud Devadur~a
23.5
Proposed
Treatment
EPC
29.0
EPC
43.5
31.8
38.5
EPC
EPC
EPC
EPC
Length
(KM)
32.45
41.4
29.3
269.4
22.8
EPC
EPC
ANNUITY
Along the project roads the ST population is already integrated with the general population, rather than living in distinct and isolated
communities.
Any disadvantages suffered by the ST population were already taken into account as regional imbalances.
Contract
PackaRe
WAP2
WAP3
WAP4
63B
Maddur - Huliyurdurga
27.5
Proposed
Treatment
ANNUITY
63C
Huliyurdurga - Kunigal
21.1
ANNUITY
63D
Kunigal - Tumkur
35.2
ANNUITY
63E
Tumkur - Koratagere
27.9
ANNUITY
64F
Koratagere - Madhugiri
20.0
ANNUITY
64G
Madhugiri - Pavagada
35.8
ANNUITY
19A
Mudhol - Mahalingapura
19.2
ANNUITY
19B
19C
42.4
18.4
19D
Mahalingapura - Kabbur
Kabbur - Chikodi
Chikodi - (NH-4 cross) Nippani
23.9
ANNUITY
ANNUITY
ANNUITY
Link
Description of Links
Length
(KM)
T21
32.2
ANNUITY
M7A
49.8
ANNUITY
M7B
45.3
ANNUITY
M7C
lOA
lOB
26.2
61.0
48:6
557.3
826.6
ANNUITY
ANNUITY
ANNUITY
(Expansive Soil). The roads covered in this region are: Package WEP5, Chowdapur Gulbarga, WAP2, Mudhol- Mahalingapur, Mahalingpur - Kabbur, Kabbur - Chikodi, Chikodi
- Nippani and WAP4, Managuli - Talikota and Talikota - Devapur. In this region, major crops
grown are Tobacco, Sugar cane, Jawar, Sunflower, Toor, Groundnut, Soya bean and maize.
1.5. Central Karnataka Plateau: Central Karnataka Plateau covers the districts of Bellary,
Chikkamagalur, Chitradurga, Davanagere, Dharwad, Gadag, Haveri, Raichur, Koppal and
Shimoga. The region represents the transitional surface between the Northern Karnataka Plateau
with relatively higher surface. By and large, this region represents the area of Tungabhadra
basin. The general elevation varies between 450 and 700 meters. However, this transitional
ground is broken by several sets of parallel ridges mainly made up of Dharwar system of rocks.
The height of such residual hills is about 900 meters above mean sea level. The general slope of
this region is towards the east. The roads covered in this region are: WEP2, Hanagal - Tadasa,
Haveri - Hanagal, WEP3, Dharwad- Saundatti, WEP4, Tinthini - Devadurga and Devadurga Kalmala. The major crops growing in these places are Sunflower, Paddy, Maize, Groundnut,
Cotton, Flowers, Wheat, Ragi,. Bajra, Chillies, Coconut and Arecanut.
1.6. Southern Karnataka Plateau: Southern Karnataka Plateau covers the districts of Bangalore,
Bangalore Rural, Hassan, Kodagu, Kolar, Mandya, Mysore, Chamarajanagar and Tumkur. This
region largely covers the area of the Cauvery basin lying in Karnataka. It is bounded by 600
meters contour and is characterized by a higher degree of slope. In the west and south it is
enclosed by the ranges of Western Ghats and the northern part is an interrupted but clearly
identifiable high plateau. In the east the valleys of the Cauvery and its tributaries open out to
form undulating plains. The general elevation of the region varies from 600 to 900 meters.
However residual heights of 1,500 to 1,750 meters are found in the Biligirirangan hills of
Mysore district and the Brahmagiri range of Kodagu district. The roads covered in this region
are: WEPI, Hoskote - H Cross, H Cross - Chintamani, WAPI, Malavalli -Maddur, MaddurHuliyurdurga, Huliyurdurga - Kunigal, Kunigal- Tumkur, Tumkur - Koratgere, Koratgere Madhugiri and Madhugiri - Pavagada. In this region major crops grown are Sugarcane, Paddy,
Ragi, Coconut, Areca nut, Vegetables, Groundnut, Mulbury plants and Maize. Kolar district is
famous for sericulture, diary and Gold mining.
1.7. Karnataka Coastal Region: The Karnataka Coastal Region, which extends between the
Western Ghats edge of the Karnataka Plateau in the east and the Arabian Sea in the west, covers
Dakshina Kannada, Udupi and Uttar Kannada districts. There are no roads under this projects in
the coastal region
Magnitude of impacts
1.8. The project will impact 14735PAPs and 3361 PAFs. Of the total affected families major impact
of the project is on 1739 families and minor impacts on 1547 families. Major impacts are where
the PAF is either displaced due to the loss of house or has lost his means of livelihood, either
agricultural or commercial; this category also includes those like to become marginal farmers
due to the impact of the project. The total private land acquisition for the project is 176.79 ha,
and Govt. land to be transferred is 7.13 .
Table 1.2: Summary Tables on Impacts
Contract
Package
Land
AcquisitionPrivate(ha)
WEPI
WEP2
WEP3
WEP4
WEP5
0.S2
5.69
7.10
O.SO
2.46
Land
TransferGovernment
( ha)
0.26
1.19
0.00
0.00
0.S4
Major
Impact
-PAFs
Minor
impact
-PAFs
Community
Assets
(Nos)
41
311
58
152
29
IS
402
121
60
25
70
116
47
125
57
PAFs
PAPs
72
337
4695
997
715
301
773
179
212
55
Contract
Package
WAPI
WAP2
WAP3
WAP4
TOTAL
Land
AcquisitionPrivate(ba)
Land
TransferGovernment
( ba)
Major
Impact
-PAFs
Minor
impact
-PAFs
Community
Assets
(Nos)
PAFs
PAPs
78.43
33.42
35.55
0.00
165.46
5.68
0.00
0.00
0.00
7.69
346
343
215
244
1739
409
130
325
57
1547
736
165
222
106
1646
755
473
540
302
3361
3349 587*
1690 570
1706 593
151*
945
14735 1901*
*This is estimated to help assess the likely PAFs losing land for Annuity contracts only. Also used for budget
estimates. For the EPC all information is inclusive of structure and land losers!
10
1.12. The Right of Way is the lawful1y acquired corridor of public land owned by the State
Government and administered by the PWD for the transit of the existing road. Using available
records with the PWD and the Revenue Department, the social team verified the boundaries of
private properties within and in the vicinity of likely corridor of impact. The preparation of the
Land Acquisition Plan is being facilitated through the verification of land records, updated
records for the ownership of land.
1.13. For this project, preparation of RAP associated with displacement is limited to the corridor of
impact. The corridor of impact is the width required for the actual construction of the road,
including carriageway, shoulder, embankments and longitudinal drainage. Within this corridor
there should be no structures or hindrances. The objective of social input to project design is to
ensure that the corridor of impact is reduced, within acceptable design principles and standards,
to minimise displacement and other project impacts. Those affected between the Corridor of
Impact and Right of Way during the lifetime of the project will be assisted in line with this
project Entitlement Policy, if they are required to be affected for any additional work required
for this project.
11
Executive Summary
al
.~
~
~
::J
VI
..
"0
VI
is
.~
:0
::J
a..
..
_ ..........-
-'
; L..
..........
..
...
....\
"5
r .. ... . . . .
..
"
--
- -
...
7.:7::"I)'~
~ ...,,;-
~~
alN ..
V7
- .:~~-(~~~....~..
"
.;::
---.
E2436
..
..,- ......
'-
_ _ .. .,.,)It
...
~.
1"--
--.
...
::J
:g -
""''""''
"0
VI
is ...
.~
" '
."
..
,--
\"
::J
a.. .....
....
'
Prepared for:
Govt of Karnataka
Public Works
.. ,
Dept.
(Pill, KSHIP)
April 2009
""
f . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. . .' ._ _ _.....li1i1~_
\ . '_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
.
r.
iI
INTRODUCTION
1.1
Project Background
The Kamataka State Highways Improvement Project (KSHlP) is an initiatiye by the Public Works
Department (PWD) of the Government of Kamataka (GOK), under the proposed World Bank loan, to
undertake improvement of 4887.5 km of roads consisting of State Highways and major District
Roads. These roads were selected on the basis of a Strategic Option Study (SOS) carried out in 2003.
To facilitate this job the Government of Kamataka has appointed Ws Scott Wilson Kirkpatrick UK
and Scott Wilson Kirkpatrick India as the Project Coordinating Consultants (pCC) to carry out the
Feasibility study for the road up gradation. Based on the Feasibility study, the GOK selected 268.59
Km of roads for up gradation in a phased manner under KSHlP-II, EPC Package.
r:
[
r
L
[
r
L
[:
L
L
The entire road project has been divided into five contract packages. Each contract package is defined
as Route. Keeping in mind the length of routes for easy analysis and understanding of the various
attributes, these have been broken into smaller links. InEIA report the general impact & mitigations
of all the link roads in KSHlP-ll, EPC have already been explained. This volume contains project
specific Environmental Management Plan (EMP) for 21 B road link so as to facilitate the easy
execution of EMP works of the project
Table 1: Road sdected for Improvemeat In KSHIPIl, EPC
Link
Description of Llnk
ID
67A Hoskote - H Cross (Hindgnala Cross)
678 H Cross - Chinatmani B..mass (Corridor 65F Junctn)
M7D Hanagal - Tadasa
T8 HaveriQlli41 Han2al
21B Pharwad - Saundatti
13A iI'inthni - Chinchodi - Jalhalli - Karegud - Devadurga
13B Oevadurga - Masarkal Gabbur - Kalmala
6C ~howdapur - Gulbarga
Total length
1.2
Length
(Ian)
23.5~_
29.00
43.50
31.78
38.57
32.45
41.40
28.67
268.59
Contract Package
..
.
II'
.'
WEP 1
WEP2
WEP3
'"
WEP4
WEP5
lilt
The scope of environmental Assessment includes screening and scoping, environmental assessment
and environmentaI management plan for the individual project roads as required. The Environmental
assessment process also envisages developing a broad environmental management framework for
each of the project roads.
Interpretation and Applicability of the MoEF Notification dated 14111 September 2006, for KSHIPn,
EPC road links is as follows.
Schedule I
General Conditions
Project
CategoryB
Category A
(I) i) New National i) New State High Any project or activity specified in
7
ways; and
Category 's' will be treated as
Highways High ways; and
ii) Expansion of ii)
Expansion of Category A, if located in whole or in
National High ways National
/
State part within 10 km from the boundary
greater of: (i) Protected Areas notified under
greater than 30 KM, Highways
involving additional than 30 km involving the Wild Life (protection) Act, 1972,
right of way greater additional right of (ii) Critically Polluted areas as notified
than 20m involving way greater than 20m by the Central Pollution Control Board
land from time to time, (iii) Notified Ecoland acquisition and involving
sensitive areas, (iv) inter-State
passing
through acquisition.
international
boundaries
and
more than one State.
boundaries.
SconWtlson
On the basis of above categorization, the proposed improvement of road link with greater than 30 Km
length and additional right of way less than 20m involving land acquisition, has been .grouped in to 7
(f) Higbways category B. The project needs to obtain environmental clearance from State
Environmental Appraisal Committee, Kamataka. The length and RoW details of the proposed road
link are as follows.
..
Link
ID.
..
-,.
'.
...
"
.
~
...
SHNo.
Location of Roads
Average acquisition
Length in Kms width required (M)
34
38.57
2.00
To achieve the environmental management standards, EMP has been prepared for the road project as
per the requirements of World Bank OP 4.01. Mitigation measures have been devised in such a way
that the contractor would be able to execute accurately. All studies relating to the project has finally
come out with an implement able environmental mitigation & enhancement plans. This plan has been
recommended for feasible and cost-effective measures to avoid, prevent or reduce significant negative
imj)acts to acceptable levels. Apart from mitigation of the potential adverse impacts on the
environmental components, the EMP identified opportunities that exist for the enhancement of
cultural properties along the corridor; some road user facilities such as bus Jaybys and waiting sheds
(part of civil work) and parking areas. In order to implement the environmental management plan
contractor need to prepare specific plans for, Debris (Muck) disposal plan (Includes collection,
transportation, haul roads and disposal); Construction phase water management plan; Management
plan for construction camp, Labour camps; Management plan for plant sites (WWM plant, Hot mix,
Crushers etc.,); Accidents, Safety and Traffic management plan. EMP includes detailed specifications,
bill of quantities (BOQ), execution drawings and contracting procedures for execution of the
environmental mitigation and enhancement measures suggested. Since the project is to be
implemented under ICB contracting, highest standards of project planning, project management and
project implementation are to be maintained. Therefore the contractor needs to resort to international
good practices not only in the implementation of EMP but also in the construction activities. The
success of the project management is directly linked to the effective implementation of the EMP
measures. AU mitigation measures, avoidance m.:asures and environmental enhancement measures
recommended are to be implemented in a timely and phased milIlIler. Proper understanding of all
environmental management measures especially the EMAP is a pre-requisite for an those working
from the contractor's side.
The institutional arrangements required at the PWD, contractors and the esc (Construction
Supervision Consultant) have been dermed properly for the smooth implementation of the project
components. A positive attitude from the project management and the individual professional or staffs
are always a prerequisite for success of the EMP implementation.
The EMP specifies the environmental supervision, monitoring and auditi~g requirements. The
monitoring programmt' specify parameters, reference standards, monitoring method. frequency,
duration, location, reporting responsibilities, and other inputs (e.g., training). The EMAP on the other
h~ p~ovides an action plan showing the mitigation measures, time 6f in'plementation, who will
implement, at what locatim and who will supervise etc., This is provided for pre-construction,
construction and post construction stages. The EMPlisted all mandatory government clearance
condition, and the statutes for procuring clearances.
.,
.
Detailed Project Report
Volume IV - Part I: EMP Repro
I'
1.4
,.
The project road considered need to obtain all the necessary clearances required prior to construction
phase. The clearances to be obtained are as shown in the Table 2.
I.
Environment
AkfWaterl
Noise related
Water
(impacts and
construction
r
No
EIAIEMP
required
No
No
SPCB&
SEIAA
Yes
State Forest
Dell.t.
No
Yes, under
Water,
Noise &
AkAct
Yes
No
Approval
asperOp
IrrIgation
Dei!t.
No
Approval
asperOp
No
BodIes
No
~ties
No
No
Yes
No
Yes (RAP
required)
Yes
For
Forest
land
No
No
No
..
Approval
as per Op
Water for
drinking!
4.01
constructi
, on
Approval No
asperOp
Approval
underOP
No
Yes
For
disposa
I sites
Yes
(e.g.
4.20,4.11
Parlcing
and 4.30
areas)
No
Yes
Yes
Department
State Forestry department
ReSJ)ODSibUity
KSHIP
KSPCB
KSHIP/Contractor
KSPCB
Contractor
Contractor
Contractor
PoliceD
t
Labour D~artment
Road transport department
Contractor
Contractor
Contractor
KSPCB
Contractor
trees
L
l.
L
L
II-
4.01
Land
acquisitions
and
rehabilitation
Private
Local
4.01
Disposal
WB
4.01
ts)
Debris
I"
MoEF
Contractor
.,
.'
....
WI
....
"",
Kamataka State Highways Improvement Project - n
Consultancy Services for Preparation of DPR, Bid Documents
2.
SUMMARY OF IMPACTS
The project impacts during various phases of the implementation on all the environmental parameters
like Air, Noise, Water, Land and Socio economic factors are discussed in brief in this chapter. The
Table 2.9 provides a Summary of the project impacts.
I'
I
i
Air Environment
Air quality is generally good whole along the project road except along the poorly maintained areas.
These areaS are highly dust prone and require sprinkling of water for suppression of the dust. There
are no polluting industries in PIA or adjoining areas. The project road has extensive agricultural areas
on both sides.
2.1
I.
L
L
L
L
L
I
t
Air quality along the project road alignment will be adversely impacted at oongested locations and
major urban settlements locations like Dharwad and Saundati,. The area will be impacted by air
pollution both during construction and operation stages. Construction stage impacts will be of short
term and have adverse impacts on the construction workers as well as on the settlements adjacent to
the alignment, especially those in the downwind direction. Operation stage impacts will not be as
severe as the construction stage impacts and these will be confined generally to a ribbon development
close to edge of the pavement. However, there will be continued enhancement of air pollution due to
increase in number of vehicles in the roads. It is difficult to predict the pollution level from Vehicle
since it is not known how the adoption of new technology vehicles would proceed. It is however,
possible to assess the future pollution load on the assumption that the old technology vehicle would
persist. The unit load of pollutants from different type of vehicles have been estimated uDder the same
assumption by the Indian Institute of Petroleum which is presented in Table2.1
Table 2-1: Emlalon facton of different vebldes (aIKm)
Types ofVeh.ide
LIDkI
l.
I..
IL
NOx
SOX
Pb
0.004
0.0117
0.009
TSP
Table 1-2: PoBUtiOD Load of PoRutants aloOl the project Route (ID ToDllKm)
I'
HC
Two Wheeler
8.3
5.16
0.013
Cars
24.03
3.57
1.57 0.053
7.77
Three Wheelers
12.25
0.029
Buses-Urban
0.275
1.327 8.281 1.441
4.381
Trucks
0.45
3.425
1.327 . 6.475 1.127
Light Commercial Vehicles
1.3
0.4
0.5
2.5
0.1
.
Source: Indian Institute of Petroleum, 1985
Based on this factor, the current loads of vehicular pollution in respective links of project area for the
year 2006 as well as those expected in 2012 have been estimated in TtlbIe 2.2.
I.
CO
Route
2IB
Year
CO
HC
2006
2012
0.011832
0.01993
0.008328
0.015221
Panmeters
Pb
SOX
0.007169 0.001736 0.000011
0.012542 0.002889 0.000023
NOx
TSP
0.0005
0.0008
Note: TSP: Total Suspeuded Particulate, CO: CarboD Monoxide, HC Hydrocarbons, NOx: Oxides of NltJ"o&eD, Sox:
Sulphar dloxIde, Pb: Lead.
2.1.1
Increased Suspended particulate matter and emissions of gases like, Oxides of Sulphur, Oxides of
Nitrogen, Carbon monoxide and Hydrocarbon will be Generated during these stages due to: Enhanced
air pollution due to use of heavy equipme:nts and machinery etc; Diversion of traffic from the traffic
enroute. During loading and unloading of raw materials at sites; Emissions from the hot mix plant and
.
..
..
."
..
too
.
..
..
..
...
..
Ito,
.
....
diesel generators; stone crushing unit operations in the stone quarries and Handling and storage of
aggregates and sand at locations of batch mixing plants
It can be observed from the ambient air quality of the project area Except increase in suspended
particulate .matter all other air quality parameters such as RPM, NOx, SOx, Pb, CO and HC are within
the limits of ambient air quality standard.
2.1.1
...
...
Operation Stage
The introduction of new pavement will smoothen and widen the road, so the generation of fugitive
dust is reduced during the operation stage and with suitable pitching and embankment turfing will
control the erosion and dust emission.
The levels of S02, HC and NOx are likely to come down to greater extent by the operations of new
roads with extensive savings in consumption of fuel. There will be reduction of toxic gases being
released. There may be localized impact from pollution with increase in number of vehicles running
on the road, adulterated fuel supply and poor maintenance of vehicles.
...
...
.a
..
-...
....
,..,
...
The measures for the avoidance and mitiption measures for controlling the air pollution are in table
3.1 Environmental mitigation plan. The increase in the Width of pavement and landscaping decreases
the dust levels created by traffic will decrease during operational phase.
2.1
Noise Environment
The baseline noise levels monitored in the project area indicate baseline noise level, which exceeds
.the permissible limits for silence areas SI:lCh as schools, courts and hospitals. For other land uses the
noise levels are well within the specified limits. But noise levels would increase significantly during
construction phase due to movement of construction machinery and vehicles during construction &
operation respectively. Thus, noise is a major area of concern, especially since a number of sensitive
receptors have been located within Impact zone and are close to RoW.
The impacts on noise due to the project will be of significance in both the construction as well as the
operation stages.
2.2.1
Noise levels during the pre construction stage are mostly expected to be indicative of prevalent
baseline levels apart from localised noise levels at locations where pre construction stage activities
such as establishment of workers camps, stockyards are taking place. There will be increased noise
levels due diversion of traffic on unpaved roads only for a short duration during the pre construction
stage. Moreover, as these activities are not likely to be placed near settlement locations the increased
noise impact is bound to be negligible.
Various activities of road construction will increase noise levels in impacts zone of the project
conidor. The construction activities includes the excavation fOr foundations and grading of the site and
the construction of structures and facilities, mowment of hP.tlvy vehicles, 1..>8ding, transportation and
unloading of construction materials and also there will be indirect influence which will be cumulative
to ambient noise level due to activities such as blasting at stone quany sites, crJShing plants, asphalt
production plants, proch:ce significant noise during construction stage.
Enhancement in noise levels depend on many key factors such as traffic intensity, type and condition
of the vehicles plying on the road, acceleration/deceleration/gear changes by the vehicles depending
on the level of congestion and smoothness of road surface (iRe: 104-1988).
..
Kamatak.a State Highways bnprovement Project - n
Consultancy Services for Preparation ofDPR,Bid Documents
and Associated Safeguvd Instnunmts - EPC Packages Funded by World Bank
2.l.2
With the introduction of new pavement, road will be smoothened and widening of road at congested
locations, reduces the generation of noise level during the operation stage. However, there will be
negligIble impact from usage of poorly maintained vebicles and old vehicles.
r
1.
Based on noise level factor, the cmrent noise level of vehicular traffic as well as those expected in
future level bave been estimated and given in Table 2.3
Table 1-3: Noise level due to Trame along the project Road
LInk
ID
Year
d(M)
(MUes/Br)
".
L (dB(A
21B
2006
26.448
2.910
121.3
15
71.326
2012
5,206
216.9
50.000
79.3835
15
The adverse impacts from the increase of noise during coostruction phase on the near by community
will be reduced by several construction pbase mitigation plans. All posSIble mechanical and
administrative controls will be practiced to reduce the adverse impacts on the workers. In unavoidable
situations personal protective equipments (PPE) such as earmuffs and earplugs will be provided to the
workers based on the nature of works.
r.
I
L
l'
Number of sensitive receptors for the construction of noise barriers bas been identified and the details
are presented in Appendix -6. These locations bave been identified based on proximity of the sensitive
receptors (Schools and Hospitals) to the road traffic and the abseoce of.wall or the inadequate height
of the existing walls. Provision bas been made for additional barriers identified during construction
pbase. In all areas of identified noise barriers. public will be advised how the noise levels can be
reduced by barriers such as solid walls and vegetative noise barriers. The project does not recommend
expensive double glazed windows as an economically viable impact mitigation measure.
2.3
Water Environment
The water environment is generally good but is being polluted by the large-scale horticultural
activities prevailing in the PIA. In the PIA area, agriculture is the main land use. Agriculture requires
application of pesticides and Fertilizers. This is a major contamjnation source for the Ground water in
the project road. Otherwise the water quality has been good in above road link.
.
.
",
...
III
L
I
l.
There are no major rivers in the impact zone..There are two tributaries of Tupari stream in the
impact zone. There are a few ponds and canals along the project road. To facilitate the crossdrainage structW'es have been proposed including improvements in the existing structures not
to affect the existing drainage system in the project implementation area. The surface water
flow in the project area is predominantly from the west to east.
The lCK:al community js using ponds for washing. cattle feeding, and Malaprabba river for other daily
needs. Some of these will be slightly impacted during the CODS1rUCtion of road. The general ground
water contour lies at 600 Mt above Mean Sea Level. Local community is depCndant on the hand
pumps, tube wells and wells and those which will be impacted due to widening needs tobe relocated
before the project starts. Number of water supply units likely affected is given in Tabk 2.4.
Table 1-4: Water supply 1ID1ts IUceIy affected along the project area
L
L
Water
Route
fLink
Locadon
Band
Pump
Bore
Wells
Dbarwad - Saundatti
clsteml
Pump
Water
Taps
Water
Unes
1 House
2IB
..
.,
-e.
Over
Read
TanklGL
Reservoir
Public
ToBeti
Man
hole
Contractor needs to keep a copy of the EA and EMP in the site office. Other than the construction
water issue, no major pollution points have been identified through out the length. No construction
waste shall be disposed off in to the water bodieslvalley/nala. The construction vehicles arc prohibited
from entering the water bodies for any purpose (including cleaning) other than the legitimate
requirements to avoid major pollution points due to Petroleum oil and lubricants.
It is very fundamental to conserve the water by way of constructing recharge pits wherever feastble in
along the project road. These recharge pits harvest rainwater from road surface to improve the ground
water table. Refer Appendix -2 for typical drawing.
...
..
The construction water requirement could be an issue during construction at certain stretches of the
project road. As a part of the planning, contractor has to prepare a contractors construction water
management plan as per the guidelines provided inAppen4ix -15.
III
2.4
Land Environment
..
..
.
Most of the available stone material along the project area is Slates, Phyllites, Schists, Charnockites
and gneisse. The metals required for the road construction is available very close to road emoute. Use
of explosive is absolutely necessary to break open the aggreptes in stone quarry in order to use these
materials, Contractor will have to establish a number of crushers along the project route impact will be
vecy large and permanent in nature.
There will be exploitation of natural resources and it also reduces natural beauty of the landscape and
alters contours of the geographical region. There will be formation of deep and large depression from
the quarry operations. This will be fatal for both the animals and humans in case fiill in to depressions
from surrounding habitat. Some times there is possibility of flying fragments of stones .from
uncontrolled blasting using explosives surrounding to quarry area prevails
...
-....
.,.
."
..
,.
Suspended particulate matter generated leads to degeneration of plant species and retards the growth
of plant species as it reduces the transpiration process and also there will be considerable impact over
the occupational workers in the quarries. During monsoon there will be collection of water in deep
ditches this serves as breeding sites for mosquitoes.
Borrow material includes gravel, murrum and sand. Generally gravel is collected from the wasteland,
which is notified from Government or with the consent of farmers in case of Wmland. Sand will be
collected from river valleys this alters the course of flow and velocity of flow of water. in rivers.
Transport of the borrow materials to the construction sites is of significance, as almost all such areas
are accessible through dirt tracks. Spillage and compaction of soil along these tracks will be a
significant impact. Special transport facilities with special measures are required to transport
bituminous material from the refineries to work sites, as they are highly inflammable and to control
accidental spills. Proper protection measures need to be worlced out for the minimjzing of such
impacts during the haulage of borrows materials. A major source of dust during the construction stage
is from stone crushing operations from the crusher and the vibrating screen. The dust, in addition
causes an eyesoN, reduces visibility thereby increasing safety concems. Rehabilitation of borrows
areas from which earth bas been excavated, is a potentia1problem, which needs to be addressed and
need to comply with managem.cnt plan Appendix - 17. m r.dditionto visual light. safety issues shall
also be considered. The major sites that likely affected from the proposed road development are given
in Table 2.5.
,..
Kamataka State Highways Improvement Project n
Consultancy Services for ~on ofDPR, Bid Documents
and Associated Safeguard Instruments - EPC Packages Funded by World Bank
Quarry
Name of the
Quarry/Source
No
Cbalnage
(Km)
Appx
Location
Area,A,
>(Ha)
Appx Depth, D
(m), >
HiDoc
k
fI .
Type of
Below
EGL
Material
tO+OOO
At a distance of
0.7 Ian on RHS
15.0
10+000
At a distance of
3.0 Ian on RHS
15.0
21+500
At a distance of
5.0
2.5 Ian on RHS
Quarry
Unauthorized
Qu-1A-36 Stone Metal
Quarry
2tB
Unauthorized
Inamhongal Stone
Qu-1A-37
Metal~_
Malada Gudda
Stone Metal
Qu-1A-48
33+800
Malada Gudda
StoneMeta1
QuotA-49
~&Cru.sher
t.
5.0
5.0
At a distance of
3.0
0.2 Ian on RHS
39+800 . At a distance of
0.2 Ian on UlS
5.0
10.0
Granite
Trap
Metal
Granite
Trap
Metal
Granite
Trap
Metal
10.0
12.0
Goesis
Granite
Gnesis
..
Type of
Material
Muurum Locations
L
l
Link
No
2tB
Quarry
No
Name of the
Quarry/Source .
Cbalnage
(Km)
MD-tAto
10.00
7.00
Mll-tA-
11
Appx
Location
At a distaJlce of
3.00 on UiS
At a distance of
10.50 on UiS
Area,A,
> (Bee)
.>
Granite
Appx Depth, D
(m), >
Hilloc
k
Below
EGL
10
Mumun
4.0
Mumun
..
...
l'I.
,
Link
No
Quarry
No
I .
L
L
l.
I. .
I.
Name of the
Quarry7Source
Cbalnage
(Km)
Location
5.00
At a distance of
70 lanfrom
Dharwad
HarihaIa &
2tD
Su-1A-21
Chunchanw Sand
near Munavalli
Type of
material
Sand
All borrow areas will be operated and redeveloped in accordance with the IRC 10:1961.MoRllI and
applicable EMP clauses (Appendix -.17) as provided in the contract documents includingEMP.
In addition to the above arrangements, Contractor will have to establish dedicated environmentally
compatible crusher units to generate adequate sand and aggregates so as to effectively utilim the
excavated materials during Construction.
...
..
.
..
productive purposes. Mitigation related to land acquisition and resettlement will be undertaken as
specified by the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP).
2.4.1.1 Land use Impact at Construction pbase
During construction phase contractor activity will go beyond Building line. Even in secondary
construction sites like borrow areas, quarry sites and water resource points the contractor's activity
will cross the limit depending upon the demand for material aVailability. These will create demand and
disturbances to the near by agricultural area, built up area etc. In case of any such issues it should be
cleared within shortest period. Potential community impact related to economy growth are closely
related to land acquisition, aesthetic and landscape considerations; noise, air quality etc., Other than
the mitigation in these area no additional mitigation actions are warranted.
..
Immediately after the construction phase it is necessary to ensure that no further deterioration or
major land use change such as n"bbon development will take place.
2.5
Biological Environment
'..
2.5.1
Flora
...
l .
..
..
..
...... .
-..
..
,
Total number of trees to be felled in the project area for the road expansion is presented in Table 2.6
Table 2-6: List of Impacted Trees due to Proposed Project road
Link
Link
Description of Link Length
ID
(Km)
2.5.2
:
..
126
106
88
320
Fauna
There are no notified National parks and Wild life sanctuary identified within the boundary of
10 km from the proposed road link. There are no endangered, critically endangered and
threatened categories of fauna in the near by vicinity of the project roads.
The common traffic - animal conflict or accidents by rash driving or break down of vehicles .leads to
death of cattle and domestic animals these conflicts are in minor in nature which can be resolved with
cash compensation pay to cattle owners. Some times there will chemical spill or indiscriminate .
disposal of bituminous materials in the forest area these toxic foreign materials may enter surrounding
water bodies and prove detrimental to local fauna. It is necessary to comply with Hazardous Waste
Hateria! Handling Rules, 1989 to protect animals by consuming such contaminated water.
2.6
"
38.57
All trees of girth size more than 30 cm cut and removed will be accountable as per the Forest
laws and efforts will be maintained to plant two times the number of trees cut according to
compensatory afforestation guidelines.
There are no forested sections along the project road.
The widening proposed in the non-forest locations will consume the productive agricultural
land, which has potential to grow crops. The increase in suspended particulate matter has
significant impact over the productivity of the crop during construction.
1_
The s(lcio economic environment has considered the land use changes, impacts to drinking water
sources, impact to land & properties and impact to cultural properties.
Chapter 2: Summary of ImpaclS
A variety of utilities serving the regional needs are CUITeIltly within RoW. The Categories of such
utilities are as follows Table 2. -;
LIDk
Number
21B
r.
LlnkName
IDharwad - Saundatti
Eleetrieal
Poles
225
Transformen
DP
Telephone Poles
11
14
12
The required mitigation measure would be to ask in advance the relevant owners of these utilities to
shift those before construction start to avoid disruption of regional services. h is the PWD's
responsibilities to make the land available for construction free of all encumbrances.
...
Project bas integrated several mitigation, avoidance and enhancement . plans relating to socio
economic aspects that include provision for parking areas, bus bays, rain Shelters etc., in to the
engineering design to improve the quality of life in these areas.
..
2.6.1
Cultural properties
r"
Temples and other community assets locat~ along the project roads with in RoW) are directly or
indirectly impacted from the roa4 project. Those that require shifting will be dealt in the ReSettlement
Action Plan (RAP). In order to avoid community conflicts, contractor will have to discuss with the
local community prior to taking up of the construction work at such sites. The community assets,
which are getting affected, are given in the following tllble - 2.8
f.
Table 2-8: CommUDlty Anets Getting Affeeted along the proposed road
Link.
2
3
4
7
1
5
6
8
9
10 11 12 13 14 15 Total
ID
4
2IB
0
1
6
2
4
1
1
1
2
0
0
0
22
47
3
.
Codes of Community Assets: l.High School, 2.Primary School, 3.Temple, 4.Shnne, 5.A.ralllratte,
6.Bus shelter, 7.Hand pump. 8MWS tan1c, 9. Samadhi, 1O..Anganwad~ II.Mosque, 12.Grazing land,
.13. well, 14.Hospital.
IS. Othen: Basement, Bore well, Compound wall, Fence, Flog pole. Govt. Land, Public toilet, Pump
house, School toilet, Water tank, Water tap, Sign board, Grave yard, Statues, APMC checlc points.
t.
r:
L
L
L
I.
2.6.1.2
Archaeological Structures
2.7
This section summarizes impact of propOsed improvements on existing environment. Keeping in view
traffic density, human (ruralIurban) congestion, socio economic viability, environmental safety,
religious structures, obligatory points and other design parameters, options such as bypass,
realignment, formation and caniageway width have been given due consideration
...
...
.'
.'.
.i
..
..
"
..
Addressed In Design
..
..
..
...
'....
...
,<II
..'.
....
Addressed In implementation
Addressed In
ODeradon staRe
protection
Slope
measures Maintenance of all
identified and inoolJlOrated in the drainage clwme1s
design and BoQ.
clean and slopes
identified
for
protection.
~ contractor sba11 prepare a ~ disposed areas
Debris Disposal Plan.
need
to
be
The excess excavated material maintained
by
during the road construction strengthening
of
safely
would
be
stored, turfing
and
transpOrted and disposed of in the vegetation over the
identified debris disposal areas.
disposed sim to
avoid erosion of the
disposed materials.
No action required
Traffic
emissions
control as per the
legal requirements.
Regular air sampling
and
during
monitoring
operation
stage.
Noise pollution
...
Water
Land
requirements
."
Impacts! Issues
Addressed In Des1gn
Aggregate and
sand
L
L
L
L
L
I
1.
Borrow areas
flooding
drainage
and
Addresied In Implementation
actual requirement. Reinstate
work areas on completion of
works.
RAP implementation to involve
an NGO to ensure that the
policies are adhered to.
Addressed In
Operation sta2e
new
coDS1nJction
shall be mfliciently
away
fiom
the
project road_edge.
Monitor and evaluate
(M&E)
the
effectiveness of RAP
implementation.
...
..
..
.
.
..
....
'
...
Executive Summary
-.
E2436
V5
Prepared for:
Govt of Kamataka
Public Works
Dept.
(pIU, KSHIP)
.,..
.-
..-'
,
/.
1~
-/"
April 2009
FILE COP.Y
2.
SUMMARY OF IMPACTS
The project impacts during various phases of the implementation on all the environmental parameters
like Air, Noise, Water, Land and Socio economic factors are discussed in brief in this chapter. The
Table 2.9 provides a Summary of the project impacts.
2.1
Air Environment
Air quality is generally good whole along the project road except along the poorly maintained areas.
These areas are highly dust prone and require sprinkling of water for suppression of the dust. There
are no polluting industries in PIA or adjoining areas. The project road has extensive agricultural areas
on both sides.
Air quality along the project road alignment will be adversely impacted at congested locations and
major settlements locations like Jalahalli and devadurga. The area will be impacted by air pollution
both during construction and operation stages. Construction stage impacts will be of short term and
have adverse impacts on the construction workers as well as on the settlements adjacent to the
alignment, especially those in the downwind direction. Operation stage impacts will not be as severe
as the construction stage impacts and these will be confined generally to a ribbon development close to
edge of the pavement. However, there will be continued enhancement of air pollution due to increase
in number of vehicles in the roads. It is difficult to predict the pollution level from vehicle since it is
not known how the adoption of new technology vehicles would proceed. It is however, possible to
assess the future pollution load on the assumption that the old technology vehicle would persist. The
unit load of pollutants from different type of vehicles have been estimated under the same assumption
by the Indian Institute of Petroleum which is presented in Table2.1
Table 2-1: Emission factors of different vehicles (g/Km)
Types of Vehicle
CO
HC
Two Wheeler
8.3
5.16
Cars
24.03
3.57
Three Wheelers
12.25
7.77
Buses-Urban
4.381
1.327
Trucks'
3.425
1.327
Light Commercial Vehicles
1.3
0.5
Source: IndIan InstItute of Petroleum, 1985
NOx
1.57
8.281
6.475
2.5
SOx
0.013
0.053
0.029
1.441
1.127
0.4
Ph
0.004
0.01l7
0.009
TSP
0.275
0.45
0.1
Based on these emission factors, the current loads of vehicular pollution in respective links of project
area for the year 2006 as well as those expected in 2012 have been estimated in Table 2.2.
Table 2-2: Pollution Load of Pollutants along the project Route (In Tons/Km)
Link
ID
Year
13A
2006
2012
CO
0.006150
0.010421
HC
0.004572
0.008352
Parameters
NOx
SOx
0.001809
0.003173
0.000384
0.000621
Pb
0.000006
0.000012
TSP
0.000110
0.000174
Note: TSP: Total Suspended Particulate, CO: Carbon Monoxide, HC Hydrocarbons, NOx: OXIdes of NItrogen, Sox:
Sulphur dioxide, Pb: Lead.
2.1.1
Increased suspended particulate matter and emissions of gases like, oxides of sulphur, oxides of
nitrogen, carbon monoxide and hydrocarbon will be generated during these stages due to enhanced air
pollution by the use of heavy equipments and machinery etc; diversion of traffic from the traffic
enroute. During loading and unloading of raw materials at sites; Emissions from the hot mix plant and
Chapter 2: Summary ofImpacts
Scott Wilson
diesel generators; stone crushing unit operations in the stone quarries and Handling and storage of
aggregates and sand at locations of batch mixing plants.
It can be observed from the ambient air quality of the project area except increase in suspended
particulate matter all other air quality parameters such as RPM, NOx, SOx, Pb, CO and HC are within
the limits of ambient air quality standard.
2.1.2
Operation Stage
The introduction of new pavement will smoothen and widen the road, so the generation of fugitive
dust is reduced during the operation stage and suitable pitching and embankment turfing will control
the erosion and dust emission.
The levels of S02, HC and NO, are likely to come down to a greater extent by the operations of new
roads with extensive savings in consumption of fuel. There will be reduction of toxic gases being
released. There may be localized impact from pollution with increase in number of vehicles running
on the road, adulterated fuel supply and poor maintenance of vehicles.
The measures for the avoidance and mitigation measures for controlling the air pollution are in table
3.1 Environmental mitigation plan. The increase in the width of pavement and landscaping decreases
the dust levels created by traffic during operational phase.
2.2
Noise Environment
The baseline noise levels monitored in the project area indicate baseline noise level, which exceeds the
permissible limits for silence areas such as schools, courts and hospitals. For other land uses the noise
levels are well within the specified limits. But noise levels would increase significantly during
construction phase due to movement of construction machinery and vehicles during construction &
operation respectively. Thus, noise is a major area of concern, especially since a number of sensitive
receptors have been located within Irnpact zone and are close to RoW.
The impacts on noise due to the project will be of significance in both the construction as well as the
operation stages.
1.1.1
Noise levels during the pre construction stage are mostly expected to be indicative of prevalent
baseline levels apart from localised noise levels at locations where pre construction stage activities
such as establishment of workers camps, stockyards are taking place. There will be increased noise
levels due diversion of traffic on unpaved roads only for a short duration during the pre construction
stage. Moreover, as these activities are not likely to be placed near settlement locations the increased
noise impact is bound to ,be negligible.
Various activities of road construction will increase noise levels in impacts zone of the project
corridor. The construction activities includes the excavation for foundations and grading of the site and
the construction of structures and facilities, movement of heavy vehicles, loading, transportation and
unloading of construction materials and also there will be indirect influence which will be cumulative
to ambient noise level due to activities such as blasting at stone quarry sites, crushing plants, asphalt
production plants, produce significant noise during construction stage.
Scott Wilson
Enhancement in noise levels depends on many key factors such as traffic intensity, type and condition
of the vehicles plying on the road, acceleration/deceleration/gear changes by the vehicles depending
on the level of congestion and smoothness of road surface (IRe: 104-1988).
1.1.2
With the introduction of new pavement, road will be smoothened and widening of road at congested
locations, reduces the generation of noise level during the operation stage. However, there will be
negligible impact from usage of poorly maintained vehicles and old vehicles.
Based on noise level factor, the current noise level of vehicular traffic as well as those expected in
future level have been estimated and given in Table 2.3
Table 2-1: Noise level due to Traffic along the project Road
Link
ID
13A
Year
2006
2012
Total Vehicle
q
/day (No.) (Vehicles/Hr)
1,312
2,358
54.7
98.3
d
(M)
u
(Miles! Hour)
L
(dB(A)
15
15
22.357
50.000
66.4068
75.9439
The adverse impacts from the increase of noise during construction phase on the near by community
will be reduced by several construction phase mitigation plans. All possible mechanical and
administrative controls will be practiced to reduce the adverse impacts on the workers. In unavoidable
situations personal protective equipments (PPE) such as ear muffs and earplugs will be provided to
the workers based on the nature of works.
Number of sensitive receptors for the construction of noise barriers has been identified and the details
are presented in Appendix -6. These locations have been identified based on proximity of the sensitive
receptors (Schools and Hospitals) to the road traffic and the absence of wall or the inadequate height
of the existing walls. Provision has been made for additional barriers identified during construction
phase. In all areas of identified noise barriers, public will be advised how the noise levels can be
reduced by barriers such as solid walls and vegetative noise barriers. The project does not recommend
expensive double glazed windows as an economically viable impact mitigation measure.
2.3
Water Environment
The water environment is generally good but is being polluted by the large-scale horticultural
activities prevailing in the PIA. In the PIA area, agriculture is the main land use. Agriculture requires
application of pesticides and fertilizers. This is a major contamination source for the ground water in
the project road otherwise the water quality has been good in above road link.
There are a few tributaries in the impact zone. There is only one major krishna river in the
influence zone. There are no ponds, lakes (lentic water bodies) across the project road. To
facilitate the cross-drainage structures have been proposed including improvements in the
existing structures not to affect the existing drainage system in the project implementation
area. The surface water flow in the project area is predominantly from the west to east.
The local community is using these sources of water for their daily needs. Some of these will
be impacted during construction phase of project road. The general water contours varies
from 400 to 600 Mt above Mean Sea Level. The project area has low ground water table due
to scanty rainfall and over extraction of ground water for irrigation utilities. Local community
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
is dependent on the hand pumps, tube wells and wells and those that are within RoW will be
impacted needs to be relocated before the project starts. Number of water supply units likely
affected along the road link is given in Table 2.4.
Table 2-1: Water supply units likely affected along the project area
Link
ID
13A
Location
Hand
Pumps
Bore
Wells
Water
cistern
Water
Taps
Water
Lines
Over Head
Tank/GL
Reservoir
Public
Toilet!
Man hole
17
Contractor needs to keep a copy of the EA and EMP in the site office. Other than the construction
water issue. no major pollution points have been identified through out the length. No construction
waste shall be disposed off in to the water bodies. The construction vehicles are prohibited from
entering the water bodies for any purpose (including for cleaning) other than the legitimate
requirements to avoid major pollution points due to petroleum oil and lubricants used in vehicles and
construction equipments.
It is very fundamental to conserve the water by way of constructing recharge pits wherever feasible
along the project road. These recharge pits harvest rain water from road surface to improve the ground
water table. Refer Appendix -2 for typical drawing.
The construction water requirement could be an issue during construction at certain stretches of the
project road. As a part of the planning, contractor has to prepare construction water management plan
as per the guidelines provided in Appendix -15.
2.4
Land Environment
Most of the available stone material along the project area is basaltic trap, sand stone, shale, slate,
gneiss and granitic schist. These metals required for the road construction is available very close to
road enroute. Use of explosive is absolutely necessary to break open the aggregates in stone quarry. In
order to use these materials, contractor will have to establish a number of crushers along the project
route impact will be very large and permanent in nature (Chapter Environmental Impacts of EIA
report).
There will be exploitation of natural resources and it also reduces natural beauty of the landscape and
alters contours of the geographical region. There will be formation of deep and large depression from
the quarry operations. This will be fatal for both the animals and humans in case fall in to depressions
from surrounding habitat. Some times there is possibility of flying fragments of stones from
uncontrolled blasting using explosives surrounding to quarry area prevails.
Suspended particulate matter generated leads to degeneration of plant species and retards the growth
of plant species as it reduces the transpiration process and also there will be considerable impact over
the occupational workers in the quarries. During monsoon there will be collection of water in deep
ditches this serves as breeding sites for mosquitoes.
Scott Wilson
Borrow material includes gravel, murrum and sand. Generally gravel is collected from the wasteland,
which is notified from Government or with the consent of farmers in case of farmland. Sand will be
collected from river valleys, altering the course of flow and velocity of flow of water in rivers.
Transport of the borrow materials to the construction sites is of significance, as almost all such areas
are accessible through dirt tracks. Spillage and compaction of soil along these tracks will be a
significant impact. Special transport facilities are required to transport bituminous material from the
refineries to work sites, as these require special measures to control accident spills, as this materials
are highly inflammable. Proper protection measures need to be worked out for the minimizing of such
impacts during the haulage of borrows materials. A major source of dust during the construction stage
is from stone crushing operations from the crushers and the vibrating screens. The dust, in addition
causes an eyesore, reduces visibility thereby increasing safety concerns. Rehabilitation of borrows
areas from which earth has been excavated, is a potential problem, which needs to be addressed and
need to comply with management plan Appendix - 17. The major sites that likely affected from the
proposed road development are given in Table 2.5.
Table 2-1: Major Borrow Material Regions along the route
Qu1A-10
13A
Qu1A-ll
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Amarapur Stone
Metal Crusher
Unit & Quarry
Veeresh Stone
Metal Crusher
Unit & Quarry
Appx. Depth,
D(m), >
Belo
Hillock
w
EGL
Chaina
ge (Km)
LoctnlDistance
Appx
Area,
A,>
(Hec)
21+800
At a distance of
3.8 kmonRHS
5.0
10.0
Granite
Gnesis
0+000
At a distance of
3.1 km on LHS
10.0
20.0
Granite
Gnesis
Type of
Materi
al
Murrum Locations:
Link Quarry
ID
No.
Mu- 1A-12
13A
Mu-1A-13
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Road side
Murrum borrow
pit
Road side
Murrum borrow
pit
Chaina
ge
Location
(Km)
2+000
14.50
2.95
17+500
7.85
4.95
Murram
Murram
Quarry
No.
Su-1-A-6
13A
Su-1-A-7
Name of the
Quarry/Source
LocationIDistance
Type of
materia
I
32+300
Sand
22+500
Sand
Chainage
(Km)
All borrow areas will be operated and redeveloped in accordance with the IRC 1O:1961.MoRTH and
applicable EMP clauses (Appendix - 17) as provided in the contract documents including EMP.
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
In addition to the above arrangements, contractor will have to establish dedicated environmentally
compatible crusher units to generate adequate sand and aggregates and effectively utilize the
excavated materials during construction.
2.4.1
The major land use in the project area is extensive agriculture and existence of settlements at locations
of village and small towns having active commercial and economic activity along the roadside. The
accurate surveys and accurate markings and negotiations will determine land use changes and finalize
the alignment to minimize acquisition procedure. Any additional land available must be put to use for
productive purposes. Mitigation related to land acquisition and resettlement will be undertaken as
specified in the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP).
Biological Environment
2.S.1
Flora
Total number of trees to be felled in the project area for the road expansion is presented in Table 2.6
Table 21: List of Impacted Trees due to Proposed Project road
Link
ID
Link Description
732
450
155
60
139"
All trees of girth size more than 30 cm cut and removed will be accountable as per the Forest laws and
efforts will be maintained to plant two times the number of trees cut according to compensatory
afforestation guidelines.
There is a forested section along the project road. The detail is as given in the following table.
Link ID
13A
Remarks
0.5718
Veergot R. F.
The widening proposed in the non-forest locations will consume the productive agricultural
land, which has potential to grow crops. The increase in suspended particulate matter has
significant impact over the producti vity of the crop during construction.
Scott Wilson
2.5.2
Fauna
There are no notified National parks and Wild life sanctuary identified within the boundary of 10 Jan
from the proposed road link. There are no endangered, critically endangered and threatened categories
of fauna in the near by vicinity of the project roads.
The common traffic - animal conflict or accidents by rash driving or break down of vehicles leads to
death of cattle and other domestic animals. These conflicts are minor in nature which can be resolved
with cash compensation pay to the owners. Some times there will be chemical spill or indiscriminate
disposal of bituminous materials in the area. These toxic foreign materials may enter surrounding
water bodies and prove detrimental to local fauna. It is necessary to comply with Hazardous Waste
material Handling Rules, 1989 to protect animals by consuming such contaminated water.
2.6
The socio economic environment has considered the land use changes, impacts to drinking water
. sources, impact to land & properties and impact to cultural properties.
A variety of utilities serving the regional needs are currently within RoW. The categories of such
utilities are as follows Table 2.7
Table 2-1: Shifting of electrical and telephone poles
LinkID
13A
Link Name
IThinthini - Devadurga
Electrical
Poles
249
Transformers
DP
Telephone Poles
The required mitigation measure would be to ask in advance the relevant owners of these utilities to
shift them before construction starts to avoid disruption of regional services. It is the PWD's
responsibility to make the land available for construction free of all encumbrances.
Project has integrated several mitigation, avoidance and enhancement plans relating to socio
economic aspects that include provision for parking areas, bus bays, rain shelters etc., in to the
engineering design to improve the quality of life in these areas.
2.6.1
Cultural properties
Link
7
9
10 11 12 13 14 15 Total
1
2
3
4
6
5
8
ID
13A
0
0
5
1
3
6
17
7
1
0
0
2
0
21
0
63
Codes of Community Assets: I.High School, 2.Primary School, 3.Temple, 4.shrine, 5.Aralikatte,
6.Bus shelter, 7.Hand pump, B.MWS tank, 9. Samadhi, IO.Anganwadi, I I. Mosque, 12.Grazing land,
13. well, 14.Hospital,
15. Others: Basement, Bore well, Compound wall, Fence, Flag pole, Govt. Land, Public toilet, Pump
house, School toilet, Water tank, Water tap, Sign board, Grave yard, Statues, APMC check points.
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
2.6.1.2
Archaeological Structures
There are no notified archaeological properties identified along the project road
2.7
This section summarizes impact of proposed improvements on existing environment. Keeping in view
traffic density, human (rural/urban) congestion, socio economic viability, environmental safety,
religious structures, obligatory points and other design parameters, options such as bypass,
realignment, formation and carriageway width have been given due consideration.
Table 2-1: Summary of Environmental impacts and Issues
Impacts!
Issues
Tree removal
Erosion
Debris
disposal
Religious and
Archaeological
sites
&
Properties
Addressed in Design
Addressed in Implementation
Noise
pollution
Slope
protection
measures
identified and incorporated in
the design and BOQ.
Addressed in
Operation stage
After planting check
its survival rate
Maintenance of all
channels
drainage
slopes
and
clean
for
identified
protection.
The disposed areas
need to be maintained
by strengthening the
vegetation over the
disposed site to avoid
the
erosion
of
disposed materials
emissions
Traffic
control as per the
legal requirements.
Regular air sampling
monitoring
and
operation
during
stage.
Monitor noise levels
periodically
to
the
understand
deviation from the
No action required
Scott Wilson
Impactsl
Issues
Addressed in Design
as schools, hospitals etc ..
Water
Land
requirements
Displacement
of PAPs
Road safety
EIAJEMP
documents
required at the
contractors
office
Aggregate and
sand
Borrow areas
slide,
Land
slips,
land
flash flooding
and drainage
Addressed in Implementation
wherever necessary. Siting of
secondary work areas away from
sensitive receptors.
In acute water scarcity areas, the
use of potable water for dust
suppression should be reviewed
regularly.
Regular
water
sprinkling
required
for
suppression of dust.
the
During implementation,
planned requirements will be
reviewed and implemented to
the actual requirement. Reinstate
work areas on completion of
works.
Addressed in
Operation stage
benchmarks.
safety,
Implement a road
accidents
and
traffic
management plan that has been
prepared and approved by the
CSc. Display road safety board
in the camp with no of accidents
till date and the reason for the
accidents.
Shall use during the phase. Must
keep one copy of all relevant
EIAJEMP documents including
the Environmental clearance
documents at the contractor's
project site office under direct
control of the Project mana,ger.
Use the excavated materials
obtained during widening as far
as possible.
No action required
Scott Wilson
Executive Summary
"C
.~
.s::.
"5
<t:
13
Q
.!:2
:0
:::::I
fI)
fI)
:::::I
a...
-.
- .-.o...;;..o:.;;.(
.. ...
. ._-r
- - --. ..u-...
/
. ~~
I
..
...........
V2
"'
E2436
.........
.....
..,-.-
t"A'U",
"C
~
.;::
.s::.
"5
<t:
e
:::::I
fI)
13
fI)
Q
!:2
:0
:::::I
a...
'-.
"
.,
Prepared for:
--
Govt of Kamataka
Public Works
.. 0' I-"~
. . ! .. ,
--'
"
.~
.-.,
.....
.,
.;
Dept.
(PIU, KSIllP)
April 2009
'. 1
2.
SUMMARY OF IMPACTS
The project impacts during various phases of the implementation on all the environmental parameters
like Air1 Noise, Water, Land and Socio economic factors are discussed in brief in this chapter. The
Table 2.9 provides a Sununary of the project impacts.
Air Environment
2.1
Air quality is generally good whole along.the project road except along the poorly maintained areas.
These areas are highly dust prone and require sprinkling of water for suppression of the dust. There
are no polluting industries in PIA or adjoining areas. The project road has extensive agricultural areas
on both sides.
.i
Air quality along the project road alignment will be adversely impacted at congested locations and
major urban settlements locations like Gulbarga. The area will be impacted by air pollution both
dwing construction and operation stages. Construction stage impacts will be of short term and have
adverse impacts on the construction workers as well as on the settlements adjacent to the alignment,
especially those in the downwind direction. Operation stage impacts will not be as severe as the
construction stage impacts and these will be confined generally to a n'bbon development close to edge
of the pavement. However, there will be continued enhancement of air pollution due to increase in
number of vehicles in the roads. It is difficult to predict the pollution level from vehicle since it is not
known how the adoption of new technology vehicles would proceed. It is hOwever, possible to assess
the futW'e pollution load on the assumption that the oldtecbnology vehicle would persist. The unit load
of pollutants from different type of vehicles have been estimated under the same assumption by the
Indian Institute of Petroleum which is presented in Table1.1
-I
-I
1'ypes of Vehicle
BC
Two Wheeler
8.3
5.16
24.03
Cars
3.57
7.77
Three Wheelers
12.25
Buses-Urban
4.381
1.327
Trucks
3.425
1.327
Light Commercial Vehicles
1.3
0.5
Source: Indian Institute of Petroleum, 1985
- I,
_i
I
I
CO
NOx
1.57
8.281
6.475
2.5
SO:l
0.013
0.053
0.029
1.441
1.127
0.4
-.
-
TSP
0.275
0.45
0.1
Based on this factor, the CUIl'ent loads of vehicular pollution in respective links of project area for the
year 2006 as well as those expected in 2012 have been estimated in Ttlble 2.2.
Table :Z-l: PoUutlon Load of PoUutaDh along the project Route (ID ToDSlKm)
Year
CO
BC
6C -
2006
2012
0.021705
0.038656
0.008315
0.013763
.I
_ JI
NO:l
SO:l
Pb
0.003775 0.000815 0.000010
0.006246 0.001273 0.000018
TSP
0.0002
0.0003
Note: TSP: Total Suspeaded Par1kulate, CO: Carbon Moa.oxIde, HC Hydrocarbons, NOx: Oxides of NItrogen, Sox:
Sal~ur
2.1.1
Increased Suspended particulate matter and emissions of gases like, Oxides of Sulphur, Oxides of
Nitrogen, Carbon monoxide and Hydrocarbon will be Generated during these stages due to: Enhanced
air pollution due to use of heavy equipments and machinery etc; Diversion of traffic from the traffic
enroute. Owing loading and unloading of raw materials at sites; Emissions from the hot mix plant and
..
,.
-..
...
-
Parameten
Link!
Route
...
til
Pb
0.004
0.0117
0.009
.I
.1
Scott Wilson
..
diesel generators; stone crushing unit operations in the stone quanies and Handling and storage of
aggregates and sand at locations of batch mixing plants.
It can be observed from the ambient air quality of the project area Except increase in suspended
particulate matter all other air quality parameters such as RPM, NOx, SOx, Pb, eo and He are within
the limits of ambient air quality standard.
2.l.l
Operation Stage
The introduction of new pavement will smoothen and widen the road, so the generation of fugitive
dust is reduced during the operation stage and suitable pitching and embankment turfing will control
the erosion and dust emission.
The levels of S02, He and NOx are likely to come down to greater extent by the operations of neW
rl)ads with extensive savings in conswnption of fuel. There will be reduction of toxic gases being
r:leased. There may be localized impact from pollution with increase in number of vehicles running
(.n the road, adulterated fuel supply and poor maintenance of vehicles.
The measures for the avoidance and mitigation measures for controlling the air pollution are in table
3.1 Environmental mitigation plan. The increase in 'the"width of pavement and landscaping decreases
the dust levels created by traffic during operational phase.
l.l
,
,
Noise Environment
The baseline noise levels monitored in the project area indicate baseline noise level, which exceeds the
:;>ennissiblelimits for silence areas such as schools, courts and hospitals. For other land uses the noise
levels are well within the specified limits. But noise levels would increase significantly during
~truction phase due to movement of constJUction machinery and vehicles during construction &
operation respectively. Thus, noise is a major area of concern, especially since a number of sensitive
receptors have been located within Impact zone and are close to RoW.
The impacts on noise due to the project will be of significance in both the construction as well as the
operation stages.
2.2.1
"~I
,,.
Noise levels during the pre construction stage are mostly expected to be indicative of prevalent
baseline levels apart from localised noise levels at locations where pre construction stage activities
such as establishment of workers camps, stoclcyards are taking place. There will be increased noise
levels due diversion of traffic on unpaved roads only for a short duration during the pre construction
stage. Moreover, as these activities are not likely to be placed near settlement locations the increased
noise impact is bound to be negligible.
Various activities of road construction will increase noise levels in impacts zone of the project
conidor. The construction activities includes the excavation for foundations and grading of the site and
the construction of structures and facilities, movement of heavy vehicles, loading, transportation and
unloading of construction materials and also there will be indirect influenc::e which will be cumulative
to ambient noise level due to activities such as blasting at stone quarry sites, crushing plants, asphalt
production plants, produce significant noise during construction stage.
Enhancement in noise levels depend on many key factors such as traffic intensity, type and condition
of the vehicles plying on the road, acceleration/deceleration/gear changes by the vehicles depending
on the level of congestion and smoothness of road surface (IRe: 104-1988).
Scott Wilson
2.2.2
With the introduction of new pavement, road will be smoothened and widening of road at congested
locations, reduces the generation of noise level during the operation stage. However, there will be
negligible impact from usage of poorly maintained vehicles and old vehicles.
Based on noise level factor, the current noise level of vehicular traffic as well as those expected in
future level have been estimated and given in Table 2.3
Table 2-3: Noise level due to Tramc along the project Road
,
~.
LlnkID
Year
u
(MJIes/Br)
(M)
L
(dB(A)
55.1006
23.350
2,137
2006
89.0
15
77.7342
3,561
2012
148.4
15
50.000
The adverse impacts from the increase of noise during construction phase on the near by community
will be reduced by seveml construction phase mitigation plans. All possible mechanical and
administrative controls will be practiced to reduce the adverse impacts on the workers. In unavoidable
situations personal protective equipments (PPE) such as ear muffs and earplugs will be provided to
the workers based on the nature of works. .
6C
.'
...
Number of sensitive receptors for the construction of noise barriers has been identified and the details
. t
are presented in Appendix -6. These locations have been identified based on proximity of the sensitive
receptors (Schools and Hospitals) to the r.oad traffic and the absence of wall or the inadequate height
of the' existing walls. Provision bas been made for additional barriers identified during construction
phase. In all areas of identified noise barriers, public will be advised how the noise levels can be
reduced by barriers such as solid walls and vegetative noise barriers. The project does not recommend
expensive double glazed windows as an economically viable impact mitigation measure.
2.3
..
..
Water Environment
III
The water environment is generally good but is being polluted by the large-scale horticultural
activities prevailing in the PIA. In the PIA area, agriculture is the main land use. Agriculture requires
application of pesticides and fertilizers. 1bis is a rwijor contamination source for the ground water in
the project road otherwise the water quality has been good in above road link.
.J
.j
lit
...
There are no major rivers in the impact zone. There is only one tributary of river Bhima in the
influence zone. There are no ponds, lakes and other streams along the project road. To
facilitate the cross-drainage structureS have been proposed including improvements in the
existing structures not to affect the existing drainage system in the project implementation
area. The surface water flow in the project area is predominantly from the west to east.
The local community is using canal water from the Bhima river for their daily needs. Some of these
will be slightly impacted during the construction phase of project road. The general ground water
contours varies from 400 to 500 Mt above Mean Sea Level. Local community is dependant on the
hand pumps, tube wells and wells and those which will be impacted due to widening needs to be
relocated before the project starts. Number of water supply units likely affected is given in Table 2.4.
Table 2-4: Water supply UDits likely affected along the project area
,I
Link
lD
6C
Location
Hand
Pumps
Bore
Weill
Chowdapur-
Water
c:lstern!Pump
House
7
Water
Taps
Water
Lines
OverHead
TanklGL
Reservoir
Public:
ToBeUMa
nbole
--.
-..
Gulbarga
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
Contractor needs to keep a copy of the EA and EMPin the site office. Other than the construction
water issue, no major pollution points have been identified through out the length. No construction
waste shall be disposed off in to the water bodies/valley/nala. The construction vehicles are prohibited
from entering the water bodies for any purpose (including cleaning) other than the legitimate
nquirements to avoid major pollution points due to Petroleum oil and lubricants.
It is very fundamental to conserve the water by way of construltting recharge pits wherever feasible
a.ong the proj~ road These recharge pits harvest rainwater from road surface to improve the ground
water table. Refer AppeNlix -2 for typical drawing.
The construction water requirement could be an issue during construction at certain stretches of the
project road. As a part of the planning, contractor has to prepare a contractor's construction water
nanagement plan as per the guidelines provided in AppelUlbc -1 s.
1.4
Land Environment
Most of the available stone material along the project area is basaltic trap, Sand stone, Quartzites,
Shale, 'slates, limestones and dolomites. Some of the metals required for the road construction is
available very close to road enroute. Use of explosive is necessary to break open the aggregates in
stone quarry iri order to use these materials, contractor will have to establish a number of crushers
2long the project route impact will be very large and pennanent in nature.
There will be exploitation of natural resources and it also reduces natural beauty of the landscape and
1I1ters contours of the geographical region. There will be formation of deep and large depression from
the quarry operations. This will be fatal for both the animals and humans in case fall in to depressions
from surrounding habitat. Some times there is possibility of flying fragments of stones from
uncontrolled blasting using explosives surrounding to quarry area prevails.
Suspended particulate matter generated leads to degeneration of plant species and retards the growth
of plant species as it reduces the transpiration process and also there will be considerable impact over
the occupational workers in the quarries. During monsoon there will be collection of water in deep
ditches this serves as breeding sites for mosquitoes.
Borrow material includes gravel, murrum and sand. Generally gravel is collected from the wasteland,
which is notified from Government or with the consent of farmers in case of farmland. Sand will be
collected from river valleys this alters the course of flow and velocity of flow of water in rivers.
TranspOrt of the borrow materials to the construction sites is of significance, as almost all such areas
are accessible through dirt tracks. Spillage and compaction of soil along these tracks will be a
significant impact. Special transport facilities with special measures are required to transport
bituminous material from the refineries to work sites, as they are highly inflammable and to control
accidental spills. Proper protection measures need to be worked out for the minimizing of such
impacts during the haulage of borrows materials. A major source of dust during the construction stage
is from stone crushing operations from the crusher and the vibrating screen. The dust, in addition
causes an eyesore, reduces visibility thereby increasing safety concerns. Rehabilitation of borrows
areas from which earth has been excavated. is a potential problem, wbich needs to be addressed and
need to comply with manageineot plan Appendix 17. In addition to visual light. safety issues shall
also be considered. The major sites that'likely affected from the proposed road development are given
in Tilble 2.5.
'".
,,..
Scott Wilson
LInk
ID
Nameoftbe
Quarry/Source
Cbainage
Location
(Km)
Appx Depth, D
(m), >
Appx
Area,A,
>(Ha)
Hillock
Below
Type of
Material
EGL
Qu-IA-I
6C
Qu- IA-2
32+700
Qu-lA-3
32+700
Qu-IA-4
32+700
Qu- IA-5
32+700
.J
At a distaDce of
1.8 monRHS
0+000
1.5
At a distance of
10.8 km on
1.7
RHS
At a distance of
11.1 moo
2.0
RHS
At a distance of
11.6kmon
2.S
RHS
At a distance of
7.8kmonRHS
'
2.2
Black
Trap
Metal
Black
Trap
Metal
Black
Trap
Metal
Black
Trap
Metal
Black
Trap
Metal
15.0
16.0
30.0
22.0
..-.
17.0
' )
Murrum Locations
J
LInk
No
_i
'1
_1
6C
'J
.I
Quarry
No
Name of the
QuarrylSource
Appx
Cbalnage
Location
(KID)
Mn-I -AI
32+700
MII-I-A1
31+700
MIl-I-A3
32+700
Area, A,
>(Hee)
At a distance of
11.18 km from 5.00
project road
At a distance of
6.00
10.8kmon
RHS
At a distance of
11.1lcm on
RHS
6.50
Appx Depth, D
(m), >
Hillock
Below
Type of
Material
EGL
3.00
Murram
3.50
Murram
3.70
Murram
-,
LInk
No
.1
'\
-j
6C
Quarry
No
SII-I-AI
Su-I-A2
Quarfy
Cbainage
(Km)
Location
Type of
material
37+200
At a distance of 27
km from project road
Sand
0+000
At a distance of 7.1
km from project road
Sand
All borrow areas will be operated and redeveloped in accordance with the IRe 10: 1961.MoRTH and
applicable ~ clauses (Appendix - 17) as provided in the contract documents includingEMP.
In addition to the above arrangements, Contractor will have to establish dedicated environmentally
compatible crusher units to generate adequat~ sand and aggregates so as to effectively utilize the
excavated materials during construction.
.J
I
.1
"..
$'
....
..
..
...
....
."
----.
ScouWilson
2.4.1
Land useImpaet
The major land use in the project area is extensive agriculture and existence of settlement at locations
of village and small towns having active commercial and economic activity along the roadside. The
accurate surveys and accurate markings and negotiations will determine land use changes and finalize
the alignment to minimize acquisition procedure. Any additional land available must be put to use for
productive purposes. Mitigation related to land acquisition and resettlement will be undertaken as
specified by the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP).
2.4.1.1
During construction phase contractor activity will go beyond Building line. Even in secondary
construction sites like borrow areas, quarry sites and water resource points, the contractor's activity
will cross the limit depending upon the demand for material availability. These will create demand and
disturbances to the near by agricultural area, built up area etc. In case of any such issues it should be
cleared within shortest period. Potential community impact related to economy growth are closely
related to land acquisition, aesthetic and landscape considerations; noise, air quality etc., Other than
l1c mitigation in these area no additional mitigation actions are warranted.
1.4.1.2
Immediately after the construction phase it is necessary to ensure that no further deterioration or
major land use change such as ribbon development will take place.
2.5
Biological Environinent
1.5.1
Flora
Total nwnber of trees to be felled in the project area for the road expansion is presented in Table 2.6
Table 2-6: LIlt of Impacted Trees due to Proposed Project road
Link
ID
Description of Link
Link
(<3Ocm to
Lengtb
fiOcm)
60cmto
9Ocm)
(<90tmto
lSOcm)
Trees
Girth
Total
(>lS0cm)
29.28
1366
634
155
9
2,164
6C iChowdapur - Gul})arg8
All trees of girth size more than 30 cm cut and removed will be accountable as per the Forest laws and .
efforts will be maintained to plant two times the nwnber of trees cut according to compensatory
afforestation guidelines.
There are no forest sections along the project road.
The widening proposed in the non-forest locations will conswne the productive agricultural
land, which has potential to grow crops. The increase in suspended particulate matter has
significant impact over the productivity of the crop during construction.
, . ".
,.
2.5.2
Fauna
There are no notified National parks and Wild life sanctuary identified within the boundary of
10 km from the proposed road link.
are no endanSered, critically endangered and
threatened categories of fauna in the near by vicinity of the project roads.
There
'''''
-.
The common traffic - animal conflict or accidents by rash driving or break down of vehicles leads to
death of cattle and domestic animals. These Conflicts are in minor in nature which can be resolved
with cash compensation pay to cattle owners. Some times there will chemical spill or indiscriminate
disposal of bitwninous materials in the forest area these toxic foreign materials may enter surrounding
Scott Wilson
water bodies and prove detrimental to local fauna. It is necessary to comply with Hazardous Waste .
Material Handling Rules, 1989 to protect animals by consuming such contaminated water.
2.6
The socio economic environment has considered the land use changes, impacts to drinking water
sources, impact to land & properties and impact to cultural properties.
A variety of utilities serving the regional needs are currently within RoW. The Categories of such
utilities are as follows Toble 2.7
Table 17: Shifting of e1ectrlcal.ad telephone poles
" \
LinkID
UnkName
powdapur. Gulbarga
6C
Electrical
Poles
TraDlformen
DP
Telepbone Poles
277
67
The required mitigation measure would be to ask in advance the relevant owna-s of these utilities to
shift those before construction start to avoid disruption of regional services. It is the PWD's
responsibilities to make the land available for construction free of all encumbrances.
.1
,
1 .
I
i
Project has integrated several. mitigation, .avoidance and enhancement plans relating to socio economic aspects that include provision for parking areas, bus bays, rain Shelters etc., in to the
engineering design to improve the quality of life in these areas.
2.6.1
Cultural properties
Table 2-8: Commwdty Assets Gettial Affected along the proposed road
Link
,.I
10
11
11
13 14
15
Total
0
0
2S
57
0
0
1
0
S
4
S
5
0
0
6
6
6C
. Codes of CommuDity Assets: I.lIJgh School. 2.Primary School. 3. Temple. 4.Shnne. 5.Arali1catte.
6.Bus shelter. 7.Hand pump. 8.MWS tank. 9. Samadhi. IO.Anganwadi. II.Mosque. 12. Grazing land.
2.6.1.1
There are no notified archaeological properties identified along the project rOad.
2.7
This section summarizes impact of proposed improvements on existing environment. Keeping in view
traffic density, human (rural/urban) congestion, socio economic viability, environmental safety,
religious structures, obligatory points and other design parameters, options such as bypass,
realignment, fonnation and carriageway width have been given due consideration.
.J
..
..
II
III
Archaeological Structures
.
..
-.
...
.!
J
Scott Wilson
Erosion
Debris disposal
Religious and
Archaeological
sites &.
Properties
Demolition of
Retaining wall,
breast wall etc.,
close to
structures
especially
houses.
Air pollution
Addresltd in
Operation Itage
Roadside trees, which are be A tree plantation programme bas After planting check
impacted due to widening are been prepared to implemenL
its survival rate
mostly confined to the
existing RoW, This is largely
unavoidable
Identification of crodable Slope
protection
measures Maintenance of all
soils and erosion prone identified and inCOlpOrated in the drainage
channels
stretches. Treatment of design and BoQ.
clean and slopes
embaDlcment slopes.
identified
for
protection.
Debris disposal bas been The CODIractor shall prepare a The disposed areas
given adequate importllnCe to Debris Disposal Plan.
to
be
need
by
the level it requin:s. There The excess excavated material maintained
are many number of disposal during the road CODItruction strengthening
of
be
safely
locations luch as burrow would
stored, turfing
and
areas identified along the transported and disposed of in the vegetation over the
disposed site to
proposed road in consultation identified debris disposal areas.
with the local commuaities.
avoid erosion of the
Guidelines
for
the
disposed materials.
preparation of the Debris
disposal plan ....-.......l
Cultural properties will be Provide enhancement measures Other than the safety
impacted. lAcal community according to the cultural property monitoring
and
consultations &. alignment rehabilitation programme. The maintenance of the
changes to mjDimize the project will follow up the parking area no other
impacts.
implementation
of
the action would be
enhancement measures with the required.
pm:mission from DepL
All such unstable areas win An effective sequencing of the No action required
be rehabilitated especially construction work would be
those in the vicinity of the required
residential buildings.
Adclreued In Dedp
Noise pollution
Water
Land
requirements
Addressed In Implementation
Scott Wilson
Impaetsl Issues
Addressed iD DesIgn
Addressedln Implementation
,,
.J
~
)
Borrow areas
j
,
I
- I
i
!
Addressed iD
Operltion stage
developments. All
new
construction
shall be sufficiently
away
from
the
project road edge.
Monitor and evaluate
(M&E)
the
effectiveness of RAP
implementation.
Scott Wilson
.
...
...
'
....
1M
.,
.
.....
....'
..
III
---
Executive Summary
"0
~
.;::
.c
::::J
VI
(3
VI
C5
.2
~
j5
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _
::::J
-.
E2436
V3
."
.. -
,.
.~
"
~
;:WU __
...
..- ~
...-~"'......
. _..
.
:;)
".......-
'-"'
....
.--
.,J
... ..
......
--
"
Prepared for:
Govt of Karnataka
Public Works
"
....
......
I
Dept.
(Pill, KSHIP)
April 1009
mE COpy
2.
SUMMARY OF IMPACfS
The project impacts during various phases of the itpplementation on all the environmental parameters
like Air, Noise, Water, Land and Socio economic factors are discussed in brief in this chapter. The
Table 2.9 provides a summary of the project impacts.
2.1
Air Environment
Air quality is generally good whole along the project road except along the poorly maintained areas.
These areas are highly dust prone and require sprinkling of water for suppression of the dust. There
are no polluting industries in PIA or adjoining areas. The project road has extensive agriculturaI areas
on both sides.
Air quality along the project road alignment will be adversely impacted at congested locations and
major urban settlement location like Hanagal. The area will be impacted by air pollution both during
construction and operation stages. Construction stage impacts will be of short term and have adverse
impacts on the construction workers as well as on the settlements adjacent to the alignment, especially
those in the downwind direction. Operation stage impacts will not be as severe as the construction
stage impacts and these will be confined generally to a ribbon development close to edge of the
pavement. However, there will be continued enhancement of air pollution due to increase in number of
vehicles in the roads. It is difficult to predict the pollution level from vehicle since it is not known how
the adoption of new technology vehicles would proceed. It is however, possible to assess the future
pollution load on the assumption that the old technology vehicle would persist. The unit load of
pollutants from different type of vehicles have been estimated under the same assumption by the
Indian Institute of Petroleum which is presented in Table2.}
I.
I
I .
.....
-..
-
f '
Types ofVebicle
TwoWhee1er
Cars
Three Wheelers
Buses-Urban
CO
HC
8.3
24.03
12.25
4.381
Trucks
3.425
5.16
3.57
7.77
1.327
1.327
0.5
NOs
1.57
8.281
6.475
2.5
SOS
0.013
0.053
0.029
1.441
1.127
0.4
Pb
0.004
0.0117
0.009
--
TSP
0.275
0.45
0.1 j
Based on these emission factors, the current loads of vehicular pollution in respective links of project
area for the year 2006 as well as those expected in 2012 have been estimated in Table 2.2.
Table 1-1: POUutiOD Load orpoUutants aloD& the project Route (ID TonslKm)
Link!
Route
MID
Panmete"
Year
CO
HC
2006
2012
0.007663
0.014258
0.003431
0.006002
NOs
SOx
Pb
TSP
0.001336 0.000271 0.000003 0.000065
0.002232 0.000426 0.000007 0.000100
Note: TSP: Total SuspeDded Particulate, CO: CarboD Moaoxlde, HC HydrocarboDI, NOs: Oxides orNItrOfleD, Sox:
2.1.1
.,.
Increased suspended particulate matter and emissions of gases like, oxides of sulpbur, oxides of
nitrogen, carbon monoxide and hydrocarbon will be generated during these stages due to enhanced air
pollution by the use of heavy equipments and machinery etc; diversion of traffic from the traffic
entoute. During loading and unloading of raw materials at sites; Emissions from the hot mix plant and
,
Chapter 2: Summaiy of Impacts
Scott Wilson
..
diesel generators; stone crushing unit operations in the stone quarries and Handling and storage of
aggregates and sand at locations of batch mixing plants
It can be observed from the ambient air quality of the project area except increase in suspended
particulate matter all other air quality parameters such as RPM, NOa, SOa, Pb, eo and He are within
the limits of ambient air quality standard.
2.1.2
Operation Stage
The introduction of new pavement will smoothen and widen the road, so the generation of fugitive
dust is reduced during the operation stage and suitable pitching and embankment turfing will control
the erosion and dust emission.
The levels of S02, He and NOx are likely to come down to a greater extent by the operations of new
roads with extensive savings in consumption of fuel. There will be reduction of toxic gases being
released. There may be localized impact from pollution with increase in number of vehicles nmning
on the road. adulterated fuel supply and poor maintenance of vehicles.
The measures for the avoidance and mitigation measures for controlling the air pollution are in table
3.1 Env:ronmental mitigation plan. The increase in the width of pavement and landscaping decreases
the dust levels created by traffic during operational phase .
Noise Environment
The baseline noise levels monitored in the project area indicate baseline noise level, which exceeds the
permissible limits for silence areas such as schools, courts and hospitals. For other land uses the noise
levels are well within the specified limits. But noise levels would increase significantly during
construction phase due to movement of construction machinery and vehicles during construction &
operation respectively. Thus, noise is a major area of concern, especially since a number of sensitive
receptors have been located within Jmpact zone and are close to RoW.
2.2
The impacts on noise due to the project will be of significance in both the construction as well as the
operation stagt".s.
2.2.1
....
Noise levels during the pre construction stage are mostly expected to be indicative of prevalent
baseline levels apart from localised noise levels at locations where pre construction stage activities
such as establishment of workers camps, stockyards are taking place. There will be increased noise
levels due diversion of traffic on unpaved roads only for a short duration during the pre construction
stage. Moreover, as these activities are not likely to be placed near settlement locatiOns the increased
noise impact is bound to be negligible.
Various activities of road construction will increase noise levels in impacts zone of the project
corridor. The construction activities includes the excavation for foundations and grading of the site and
the construction of structures and facilities. movement of heavy vehicles. loading. transportation and
unloading of construction materials and also~here will be indirect influence which will be cumulative
to ambient noise level due to activities such as blasting at stone quarry sites, crushing plants, asphalt
production plants. produce significant noise during construction stage.
Enhancement in noise levels depends on many key factors such as traffic intensity. type and condition
of the vehicles plying on the road, acceleration/deceleration/gear changes by the vehicles depending
on the level of congestion and smoothness of road surface (IRe: 104-1988).
Scott Wilson
,!
"
2.2.2
With the introduction of new pavement, road will be smoothened and widening of road at congested
locations, reduces the generation of noise level during the operation stage. However, there will be
negligible impact from usage of poorly maintained vehicles and old vehicles.
Based on noise level factor, the"current noise level of vehicular traffic as well as those expected in
future level have been estimated and given in Table 2.3
Table 1-3: Noise level due to Trame along the project Road
r"
!
LiDkID
Year
M7D
2006
2012
iJ
I
,i
"
"
"
I
I
.
,.
,
t"
i"
"
"
864
1500
36.0
62.5
d(m)
u (Miles /
Bour)
L(dB)
15
15
23.670
50.000
65.0882
73.9781
The adverse impacts from the increase of noise during construction phase on the near by community
will be reduced by several construction phase mitigation plans. All possible mechanical and
administrative controls will be practiced to reduce the adverse impacts on the wotXers. In unavoidable
situations personal protective equipments (PPE) such as ear muffs and earplugs will be provided to
the worlcers based on the nature of works.
Number of sensitive receptors for the c;onstruction of noise barriers has been identified and the details
are presented in Appendix -6. These locations have been identified based on proximity of the sensitive
receptors (Schools and Hospitals) to the road traffic and the absence of wall or the inadequate height
of the existing walls. Provision has been made for additional barriers identified during construction
phase. In all areas of identified noise barriers, public will be advised how the noise levels can be
reduced by barriers such as solid walls and vegetative noise barriers. The project does not recommend
expensive double glazed windows as an economically viable impact mitigation measure.
2.3
! .
....
-...
..
--
Water Environment
The water environment is generally good but is being polluted by the large-scale horticultuml
activities prevailing in the PIA. In the PIA area, agriculture is the main land use. Agriculture requires
application of pesticides and Fertilizers. This is a major contamination source for the Ground water in
the project road. Otherwise the water quality has been good in above road link.
There are no major rivers in the impact zone. There are only two minor river Dharma and
Varada in the influence zone. There are many ponds, lakes (lentic water bodies) across the
project road. To facilitate the cross-drainage cross-drainage structures have been proposed
including improvements in the existing structures not to affect the existing drainage system in
the project implementation area. The surface water flow in the project area is predominantly
from the west to east.
The local community is using these sources of water for their daily needs. Some of these will
be impacted during construction phase of project road. The general grolind water contours
varies from 400 to 600 Mt above Mean Sea Level. The project area has low ground water
table due to scanty rainfall and over extraction of ground water for irrigation utilities. Local
community is dependent on the hand pumps, tube wells and wells and those that are impacted
needs relocation before the construction starts. Number of water supply units likely affected
along the road link is given in Table 2.4.
Scott Wilson
J
1
Table 1-4: Water supply units likely affected along the project area
Link
ID
Location
Hand
Pump.
Water
cistern!
Bore
WeDs
Pump
House
Water
Taps
Water
Lines
Over
Head
TanklGL
Reservoir
Public
ToUetl
Man
hole
M7D
4
Hanagal to Tadasa
9
17
0
0
3
0
Cross
Contractor needs to keep a copy of the EA and EMP in the site office. Other than the construction
water issue, no major pollution points have been identified through out the length. No construction
waste shall be disposed off in to the water bodies. The construction vehicles are prohibited from
entering the water bodies for any purpose (including for cleaning) other than the legitimate
requirements to' avoid major pollution points due to oils and lubricants (POL) used in vehicles and
construction equipments.
It is very fundamental to conserve the water by way of constructing recharge pits wherever feasible in
the project road. These recharge pits harvest rainwater from road surface to improve the ground water
table. Refer Appen4ix -2 for typical drawing and location of recharge pits along the road.
The construction water requirement could be an issue during construction at certain stretches of the
prqlect road. As a part of the planning. contractor has to prepare construction water management plan
as per the guidelines provided in Appendix -15.
2.4
Land Environment
Most of the available stone material along the project area is basaltic trap, sand stone, shale, slate,
gneiss and granitic schist. These metals required for the road construction is available very close to
road enroute. Use of explosive is absolutely necessary to break open the aggregates in stone quarry. In
order to use these materials, contractor will have to establish a number of crushers along the project
routt~ impact will be very large and permanent in nature.
There will be exploitation of natural resources and it also reduces natural beauty of the landscape and
alten; contours of the geographical region. There will be foonation of deep and large depression from
.the (Iuarry operations. This will be fatal for both the animals and humans in case they fall in to
deprcsssions valley from surrounding habitat. Some times there is possibility of flying fragments of
stones from uncontrolled blasting using explosives surrounding to quarry area prevails.
Suspended particulate matter leads to degeneration of plant species and retards the growth of plant
species as it reduces the transpiration process and also there will be considerable impact over the
occupational workers in the quarries. During monsoon there will be collection of water in deep ditches
this serves as breeding sites for mosquitoes.
Borrow material includes gravel, murrum and sand Generally gravel is collected from the wasteland,
which is notified from Government or with the consent of farmers in case of farmland. Sand will be
collected from river valleys, altering the course of flow and velocity of flow of water in rivers.
Transport ''If the borrow materials to the construction sites is of significance, as almost all such areas
are acCCSSlble through dirt tracks. Spillage and compaction of soil along these tracks will be a
significant impact. Special transport facilities are required to transport bituminous material from the
refmeries to worle sites, as these require special measures to control accident spills, as this materials
are highly inflammable. Proper protection measures need to be worked out for the minimizing of such
impacts during the haulage of borrows materials. A major source of dust during the construction stage
is from stone crushing operations from the crushers and the vibrating screens. The dust. in addition
causes an eyesore, reduces visibility thereby increasing safety concerns. Rehabilitation of borrows
areas from which earth has been excavated, is a potential problem, which needs to be addressed and
.'
Scott Wilson
need to comply with management 'plan Appendix - 17. The major sites that likely affected from the
proposed road development are given in Table 1.5.
! .
, .
1
! .
Link
Quarry
ID
No
Nameoftbe
Quarry/Source
QU-IB-
Yalavatti stone
metal quarry
155
r:
f
Chainag
LoctnIDiitance
e(Km)
Locatedata
distance of 1.0lan
12.300
I.
QII-IB156
Locatedata
13.400
distance ofO.2km
M7D
QII-IB-
..
157
I'
QII-IB-
iI .
158
Addaguda stone
metal quarry and
crusher unit
26.400
26.400
Located ata
distance of
7.30Jcm from
Project road
Located ata
distance of
7.70Jcm from
Project road
Appx. Depth,
D(m). >
Type of
Below ~aterlal
BiDock
EGL
Grayis
S.Om
hblue
20Acrcs
below
Gramt
EGL
e
Grayis
IS.Om
hblue
below
IS Acres
Granit
EGL
e
Appx
Area, A.
>(Hec)
2.5 Acres
3 Acres
25.0
above
EGI
Fenugi
nous
IS.Om
below
EOL
Fenugi
Chert
DOUS
Chert
MURRUM LOCATIONS
i.
I.
I '
LlDk
Quarry
No.
MD-
i'
18-146
I '
MD-
18-147
Name of the
QuarrylSource
C.alDap
(Km)
Road Side
Morrum Borrow
Pit
3.300
RoadSide
Momun Borrow
Pit
13.400
M7D
18.000
41.800
MD-
MD-
, .
18-149
i _
LocatioD
At a distance of
0.1 Km from the
project road to
RHS
At a distance of
0.5 Km from the
project road to
RHS
located ata
distance ofO.Han
from project road
toRRS
located ata
distance ofO.3km
from project
RoadtoLHS
-...
ApPll;Deptb,
ApplI.
Area,
A(Ha)
HIIJOI:k
Murru
Murru
m
m)-
Type of
Belowr
Material
EGL
m
Murru
m
Murru
J
J
Quarry
ID
No.
M7D
SH-I881
Chalnage
(Km)
0.000
LocationIDistance
Type of
material
Sand
All borrow areas will be operated and redeveloped in accordance with the IRe 10:1961.MoRTH and
applicable EMP clauses (Appendix - 17) as provided in the contract documents including EMP.
Scott Wilson
In addition to the above arrangements, contractor will have to establish dedicated environmentally'
compatible crusher units to generate adequate sand and aggregates and effectively utilize the
excavated materials dlU'ing construction.
1.S
Biological Environment
1.5.1
Flora
Total number of trees to be felled in the project area for the road expansion is presented in Tllble 2.6
Table 2-6: List of Impacted Trees due to Proposed Project road
Link
ID
DesCription ~f Link
Girth
Girth
Girth
Link
Girth
(<3Ocm (<60cm (<90cm
Total
(>lSOcm)
Length
to60cm) to9Ocm) to 180cm'
737
1136
48.40
1240
1640
4753
All trees of girth size more than 30 cm cut and removed will be accoWltable as per the Forest laws and
efforts will be maintained to plant two times the number of trees cut according to compensatory
afforestation guidelines.
M7D Hanagal to Tadasa Cross
There is a forested section along the project road. The detail is as given in the following table.
Link
ID
M7D
0.8750
Remarks
The widening proposed in the non-forest locations will consume the productive agricultural
land, which has potential to grow crops. The increase in suspended particulate matter has
significant impact over the productivity of the crop during construction.
Scott Wilson
2.5.2
,.
Fauna
There are no notified National parks and Wild life sanctuary identified within the boWldaIy of 10 Ian
from the proposed road link. There are no endangered. critically endangered and threatened categories
of fauna in the near by vicinity of the project roads.
The common traffic - animal conflict or accidents by rash driving or break down of vehicles leads to
death of cattle and other domestic animals. These conflicts are minor in nature which can be resolved
with cash compensation pay to the owners. Some times there will be chemical spill or indiscriminate
disposal of bituminous materials in the area. These toxic foreign materials may enter surrounding
water bodies and prove detrimental to local fauna. It is necessary to comply with Hazardous Waste
Material Handling Rules. 1989 to protect animals by consuming such contaminated water.
2.6
The socio economic environment has considered the land use changes, impacts to drinking water
sources, impact to land & properties and impact to cultural properties.
..
A variety of utilities serving the regional needs are currently within RoW. The categories of such
utilities are as follows Table 1. 7
,.
i,
f '
I
i, .
..
i .
Unk
Number
Link Name
Electrical
Poles
Transformers
DP
Telephone Poles
MID
370
18
28
iii
The required mitigation measure would be to ask in advance the relevant owners of these utilities to
shift them before construction starts to avoid disruption of regional services. It is the PWD's
responsibility to make the land available for construction free of all encumbrances.
Project has integrated several mitigation, avoidance and enhancement plans relating to socio
. economic aspects that include provision for parking areas, bus bays. rain Shelters etc., in to the
engineering design to improve the quality of life in these areas.
! .
2.6.1
Cultural properties
I .
Temples and other community assets located alongtbe project roads (within RoW) are directly or
indirectly impacted from the road project. Those that require shifting will be dealt in the Resettlement
Action Plan (RAP). In order to avoid community conflicts, contractor will have to discuss with the
local community prior to taking up of the construction work at such sites. The community assets,
which are getting affected. are gi ven in the following table -1.8
Table 2-8: Community Assets Getting Affected alonl the proposed road
Link
10 11 12 13 14 15 Total
4
2
5
6
7
8
1
9
3
ID
0
0
0
4
0
1
0
0
0
33
57
3
8
8
0
MID 0
Codes of CommoDity Assets: J.Hlgh &hool. 2.Pnmary School. 3.Temple. 4.Shnne, 5.Ara/Jlcatte,
6.Bus shelter, 7.Handpump, 8.MWS tank. 9. Samadhi. lO.Anganwadi, llMosque. 12.Grazing land,
13. well, 14.Hospital,
IS. Otben: Basement, Bore well, Compound wall. Fence, Flag pole, Govt. Land. Public toilet, Pump
house, School toilet, Water tank. Water tap, Sign board. Grave yard, Statues. APMC check points.
2.6.1.2
oAnbaeological Structures
There are no notified archaeological properties identified along the project road.
Olapter 2: Summary oflmpacts
Scott Wilson
.,
1
II!'
_
,
2.7
I ...
This section summarizes impact of proposed improvements on existing environment. Keeping in view
traffic density, human (ruraJ/urban) congestion, socio economic viability, environmental safety,
religious structures, obligatory points . and other design parameters, options such as bypass,
realignment, formation and carriageway width have been given due consideration.
Table 2-9: Summary of Environmental impact. and Issues
Impactsl Issues
Tree removal
(flora)
EIosion
Otbrisdisposal
Religious and
Archaeological
sites &
Properties
....
..
Demolition of
Retaining wall,
breast wall etc.,
close to
structures
especially
houses.
Air pollution
.
"
Addressed in
Operation stale
Roadside trees, which are be A tree plantation programme has After planting check
impacted due to widening are been prepared to implement
its survival rate
mostly confined to the
existing RtJW, This is largely
unavoidable
protection
Identification of erodable Slope
measures Maintenauce of all
soils and erosion prone identified and incorporated in the drainage channels
. clean and slopes
stretches.
Treatment of design and BoQ.
embankment slopes.
identified
for
protection.
Debris disposal bas been The contractor shall prepare a The disposed areas
given adequate importance to Debris Disposal Plan.
need
to
be
the level it requires. There The excess excavated material maintained
by
are many number of disposal during the road construction strengthening
of
locations such as burrow would
safely
stored, turfing
be
and
areas identified along the transported and disposed of in the vegetation over the
proposed road in consultation identified debris disposal areas.
disposed site to
with the local communities.
avoid erosion of the
Guidelines
for
the
disposed materials.
preparation of the Debris
disposal plan prepared.
Cultural properties will be Provide ei:lhancement measures Other than the safety
impacted. Local community according to the cultural property monitoring
and
consultations & alignment rehabilitation programme. The maintenance of the
changes to minimize the project will follow up the parking area no other
impacts.
implementation
of
the action would be
enhancement measures with the required.
permission from Dept,
All such unstable areas will An effective sequencing of the No action required
be rehabilitated especially construction work would be
those in the vicinity of the required
residential buildings.
Addressed In Design
Addressed In Implementation
Traffic
emissions
oontrol as per the
legal requirements.
Regular air sampling
and
monitoring
during
operation
....
stage.
Noise pollution
lit'
.,.
jj)lt '
Water
Monitor
water
Scott Wilson
Impact" Issues
r-
I
I
Land
requirements
r'
1.
,.
!
l.
'
!
I'
I.
Aggregate and
sand
l.
r'
Borrow areas
I
1
I
l.
!.
iI
r '
J
I'
Addressed In Implementation
recorded as a benchmark.
Suitable measuJ'eS to prevent
the silt and other pollutants
from reaching the nearby
water bodies
The land requirement has
been considerably reduced by
b~ses.
,"
t.
Addressed in Design
Addressed In
Operation stage
! .
i. ..
,.
i._
."
-...
nbbon
Scott Wilson
....
quality parameteJS
periodically
to
understand
the
deviation from the
bencbmark.'1.
Need to monitor
developments. All
new
construction
shall be sufficiently
away from the
project road edge.
Monitor and evaluate
(M&E)
the
effectiveness of RAP
implementation.
i
!
J
J
till
Executive Summary
"0"
~
c
o
.s::.
"S
::J
(J)
~
is
.~
::c::J
a..
-.
",
E2436
V4
.-
,;
"0
Q)
C
0
.s::.
"S
::J
(J)
U(J)
is
.~
:g
'"
a..
",.
Prepared for:
-- .
" .-..~
.. -! ,'"
.......
-~.---
,,~ -~ ~
. ,,'\
.....
'"
Govt of Karnataka
Public Works
Dept.
(pIU, KSHIP)
. _______________________/______ ~__________________________
_
April 2009
'"
1_~
FILE COP..Y
2.
SUMMARY OF IMPACTS
The project impacts during various phases of the implementation on all the environmental parameters
like Air, Noise, Water, Land and Socio economic factors are discussed in brief in this chapter. The
Table 2.11 provides a Summary of the project impacts.
2.1
Air Environment
Air quality is generally good whole along the project road except along the poorly maintained areas.
These areas are highly dust prone and require sprinkling of water for suppression of the dust. There
are no polluting industries in PIA or adjoining areas. The project road has extensive agricultural areas
on both sides.
Air quality along the project road alignment will be adversely impacted at congested locations and
major urban settlements locations like Haveri. The area will be impacted by air pollution both during
construction and operation stages. Construction stage impacts will be of short term and have adverse
impacts on the construction workers as well as on the settlements adjacent to the alignment, especially
those in the downwind direction. Operation stage impacts will not be as severe as the construction
stage impacts and these will be confined generally to a ribbon development close to edge of the
pavement. However, there will be continued enhancement of air pollution due to increase in number of
vehicles in the road. It is difficult to predict the pollution level from vehicle since it is not known how
the adoption of new technology vehicles would proceed. It is however, possible to assess the future
pollution load on the assumption that the old technology vehicle would persist. The unit load of
pollutants from different type of vehicles have been estimated under the same assumption by the
Indian Institute of Petroleum which is presented in Table2.1
Table 2-1: Emission factors of different vehicles (glKm)
Types of Vehicle
CO
HC
Two Wheeler
8.3
5.16
Cars
24.03
3.57
Three Wheelers
7.77
12.25
Buses-Urban
4.381
1.327
Trucks
3.425
1.327
Light Commercial Vehicles
1.3
0.5
Source: IndIan InstItute of Petroleum, 1985
NOx
1.57
8.281
6.475
2.5
SOx
O.ot3
0.053
0.029
1.441
1.127
0.4
Pb
0.004
0.0117
0.009
TSP
0.275
0.45
0.1
Based on this factor, the current loads of vehicular pollution in respective links of project area for the
year 2006 as well as those expected in 2012 have been estimated in Table 2.2.
Table 2-2: Pollution Load of Pollutants along the project Route (In Tons/Km)
Link!
Route
T-8
Year
2006
2012
CO
0.033055
0.052764
HC
0.022797
0.038742
Parameters
SOx
Pb
NOx
0.007557 0.001462 0.000027
0.012921 0.002289 0.000050
TSP
0.0004
0.0006
Note: TSP: Total Suspended Particulate, CO: Carbon Monoxide, HC Hydrocarbons, NOx: Oxides of Nitrogen, Sox:
Sulpbur dioxide, Pb: Lead.
2.1.1
Increased Suspended particulate matter and emissions of gases like, Oxides of Sulphur, Oxides of
Nitrogen, Carbon monoxide and Hydrocarbon will be generated during these stages due to enhanced
air pollution by the use of heavy equipments and machinery etc; diversion of traffic from the traffic
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
enroute; during loading and unloading of raw materials at sites; emissions from the hot mix plant and
diesel generators; stone crushing unit operations in the stone quarries and handling and storage of
aggregates and sand at locations of batch mixing plants.
It can be observed from the ambient air quality of the project area except increase in suspended
particulate matter all other air quality parameters such as RPM, NOx, SOx, Pb, eo and He are within
the limits of ambient air quality standard.
2.1.2
Operation Stage
The introduction of new pavement will smoothen and widen the road, so the generation of fugitive
dust is reduced during the operation stage and suitable pitching and embankment turfing will control
the erosion and dust emission.
The levels of S02, He and NOx are likely to come down to greater extent by the operations of new
roads with extensive savings in consumption of fuel. There will be reduction of toxic gases being
released. There may be localized impact from pollution with increase in number of vehicles running
on the road, adulterated fuel supply and poor maintenance of vehicle which spread to down wind
direction depending on the wind speeds.
The measures for the avoidance and mitigation measures for controlling the air pollution are in table
3.1 Environmental mitigation plan. The increase in the width of pavement and landscaping decreases
the dust levels created by traffic during operational phase.
2.2
Noise Environment
The baseline noise levels monitored in the project area indicate baseline noise level, which exceeds the
permissible limits for silence areas such as schools, courts and hospitals. For other land uses the noise
levels are well within the specified limits. But noise levels would increase significantly during
construction phase due to movement of construction machinery and vehicles during construction &
operation respectively. Thus, noise is a major area of concern, especially since a number of sensitive
receptors have been located within Impact zone and are close to RoW.
The impacts on noise due to the project will be of significance in both the construction as well as the
operation stages.
2.2.1
Noise levels during the pre construction stage are mostly expected to be indicative of prevalent
baseline levels apart from localised noise levels at locations where pre construction stage activities
such as establishment of workers camps, stockyards are taking place. There will be increased noise
levels due diversion of traffic on unpaved roads only for a short duration during the pre construction
stage. Moreover, as these activities are not likely to be placed near settlement locations the increased
noise impact is bound to be negligible.
Various activities of road construction will increase noise levels in impacts zone of the project
corridor. The construction activities includes the excavation for foundations and grading of the site
and the construction of structures and facilities, movement of heavy vehicles, loading, transportation
and unloading of construction materials and also there will be indirect influence which will be
cumulative to ambient noise level due to activities such as blasting at stone quarry sites, crushing
plants, asphalt production plants,produce significant noise during construction stage.
Scott Wilson
Enhancement in noise levels depends on many key factors such as traffic intensity, type and condition
of the vehicles plying on the road, acceleration/deceleration/gear changes by the vehicles depending
on the level of congestion and smoothness of road surface (IRe: 104-1988).
2.2.2
With the introduction of new pavement, road will be smoothened and widening of road at congested
locations, reduces the generation of noise level during the operation stage. However, there will be
negligible impact from usage of poorly maintained vehicles and old vehicles.
Based on noise level factor, the current noise level of vehicular traffic as well as those expected in
future level have been estimated and given in Table 2.3
Table 2-1: Noise level due to Traffic along the project Road
Link ID
Year
Total Vehicle I
day
q (Vehicles I
Hours)
d(M)
u (Miles I
Hour)
L(dB)
T-8
2006
2012
5,812
9,907
242.2
412.8
15
15
24.438
50.000
73.6437
82.1779
The adverse impacts from the increase of noise during construction phase on the near by community
will be reduced by several construction phase mitigation plans. All possible mechanical and
administrative controls will be practiced to reduce the adverse impacts on the workers. In unavoidable
situations personal protective equipments (PPE) will be provided to the workers based on the nature
of works.
Number of sensitive receptors for the construction of noise barriers has been identified and the details
are presented in Appendix -6. These locations have been identified based on proximity of the sensitive
receptors (Schools and Hospitals) to the road traffic and the absence of wall or the inadequate height
of the existing walls. Provision has been made for additional barriers identified during construction
phase. In all areas of identified noise barriers, public will be advised how the noise levels can be
reduced by barriers such as solid walls and vegetative noise barriers. The project does not recommend
expensive double glazed windows as an economically viable impact mitigation measure ..
2.3
Water Environment
The water environment is generally good but is being polluted by the large-scale horticultural
activities prevailing in the PIA. In the PIA area, agriculture is the main land use. Agriculture requires
application of pesticides and Fertilizers. This is a major contamination source for the Ground water in
the project road. Otherwise the water quality has been good in above road link.
There is a major river namely, Varadha (ch. 12.000 km), in the impact zone. Also, there are a
number of ponds, lakes, canals and other streams across the project road. To facilitate the
cross-drainage the cross-drainage structures have been proposed including improvements in
the existing structures not to affect the existing drainage system in the project implementation
area. The surface water flow in the project area is predominantly from the west to east.
The local community is using water from Varada river and ponds for their daily needs. Some of these
(pond at ch. 22.180) will be slightly impacted due to curve smoothening realignment of road. The
general ground water contours varies from 500 to 800 Mt above Mean Sea Level. Local communities
are dependant on the hand pumps, tube wells and wells, which will be impacted due to widening and
needs to be relocated before the project starts. Number of water supply units likely affected in each
road links is given in Table 2.4.
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
Table 21: Water supply units likely affected along the project area
Link
ID
Description of
the link
Hand
Pumps
T8
Water
Water
Bore
cisternlPump
Wells
Taps
House
10
11
Water
Lines
OverHead
Tank/GL
Reservoir
Public
Toilet/Ma
nhole
Contractor needs to keep a copy of the EA and EMP in the site office. Other than the construction
water issue, no major pollution points have been identified through out the length. No construction
waste shall be disposed off in to the water bodies/valley/nala. The construction vehicles are prohibited
from entering the water bodies for any purpose (including cleaning) other than the legitimate
requirements to avoid major pollution points due to Petroleum oil and lubricants.
It is very fundamental to conserve the water by way of constructing recharge pits wherever feasible
along the project road. These recharge pits harvest rainwater from road surface to improve the ground
water table. Refer Appendix -2 for typical drawing.
The construction water requirement could be an issue during construction at certain stretches of the
project road. As a part of the planning, contractor has to prepare a contractors construction water
management plan as per the guidelines provided in Appendix -15.
2.4
Land Environment
Most of the available stone material along the project area is granites, gneiss and granitic schist. The
metals required for the road construction is available very close to road enroute. Use of explosive is
absolutely necessary to break open the aggregates in the stone quarry. In order to use these materials,
contractor will have to establish a number of crushers along the project route from which impact will
be very large and permanent in nature.
There will be exploitation of natural resources and it also reduces natural beauty of the landscape and
alters contours of the geographical region. There will be formation of deep and large depression from
the quarry operations. This will be fatal for both the animals and humans in case fall in to depressions
from surrounding habitat. Some times there is possibility of flying fragments of stones from
uncontrolled blasting using explosives surrounding to quarry area prevails.
Suspended particulate matter surrounding region will leads to degeneration of plant species and retards
the growth of plant species as it reduces the transpiration process and also there will be considerable
impact over the occupational workers in the quarries. During monsoon there will be collection of
water in deep ditches this serves as breeding sites for mosquitoes.
Borrow material includes gravel, murrum and sand. Generally gravel is collected from the wasteland,
which is notified from Government or with the consent of farmers in case of farmland. Sand will be
collected from river valleys this alters the course of flow and velocity of flow of water in rivers.
Transport of the borrow materials to the construction sites is of significance, as almost all such areas
are accessible through dirt tracks. Spillage and compaction of soil along these tracks will be a
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
significant impact. Special transport facilities with special measures are required to transport
bituminous material from the refineries to work sites, as they are highly inflammable and to control
accidental spills. Proper protection measures need to be worked out for the minimizing of such
impacts during the haulage of borrows materials. A major source of dust during the construction stage
is from stone crushing operations from the crusher and the vibrating screen. The dust, in addition
causes an eyesore, reduces visibility thereby increasing safety concerns. Rehabiiitation of borrows
areas from which earth has been excavated, is a potential problem, which needs to be addressed and
need to comply with management plan Appendix - 17. In addition to visual light, safety issues shall
also be considered. The major sites that likely affected from the proposed road development are given
in Table 2.5.
Table 21: Major Borrow Material Regions along the route
Link
ID
Quarry
No
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chainage
(Km)
Location
Appx Depth, D
(m), >
Appx
Area, A,
> (Ha)
Hillock
Below
EGL
Type of
Material
Qu1A68
Qu1A69
T8
Qn- 1A7O
Qo-IA-71
Government
Approved Nilogal
Stone Metal
Quarry
Unauthorized
Chattra Stone
Metal Quarry
Government
approved
Veerapura Murram
Government
approved Stone
Metal Quarry
0+000
At a distance of
4.6kmonLHS
5.0
10.0
Granite
Metal
0+000
At a distance of
18.5 km on IHS
20.0
5.0
Granite
Gnesis
0+000
At a distance of
6.0kmon LHS
30.0
8.0
Granite
Gnesis
31+900
At a distance of
10.0 kmon
RHS
5.0
15.0
Granite
Gnesis
Muurum Locations
Link
No
Quarry
No
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chainage
(Km)
M o-l A
63
6+000
M olA
64
6+000
Location
Located on
LHS ata
distance of 0.1
Kmfrom
project toad
Located on
RHS at a
distance of 0.1
Km from
T8
Appx
Area,A,
> (Hee)
Appx Depth, D
(m), >
Hilloc
k
Below
EGL
Type of
Material
10.96
2.56
Murram
8.56
3.14
Murram
~olectroad
Link
ID
Quarry
No
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chainage
(Km)
Location
Type of
material
Scott Wilson
Link
ID
T8
Quarry
No
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chainage
(Km)
Location
Sn-1A-38
Government
Approved Havanur
Sand
0+000
At a distance of
30.0kmon
LHS
Type of
material
Sand
All borrow areas will be operated and redeveloped in accordance with the IRe 10: 1961.MoRTH and
applicable EMP clauses (Appendix - 17) as provided in the contract documents including EMP.
In addition to the above arrangements, Contractor will have to establish dedicated environmentally
compatible crusher units to generate adequate sand and aggregates so as to effectively utilize the
excavated materials during construction.
2.4.1
The major land use in the project area is extensive agriculture and existence of settlement at locations
of village and small towns having active commercial and economic activity along the roadside. The
accurate surveys and accurate markings and negotiations will determine land use changes and finalize
the alignment to minimize acquisition procedure. Any additional land available must be put to use for
productive purposes. Mitigation related to land acquisition and resettlement will be undertaken as
specified by the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP).
2.5
Biological Environment
2.5.1
Flora
Total number of trees to be felled in the project area for the road expansion is presented in Table 2.6
Table 2-1: List of Impacted Trees due to Proposed Project road
Link
ID
Description of Link
Trees
Trees
Trees
Trees
Link
Girth
Girth
Girth
Girth
Length (<30cm to 60cm to <9Ocm to
(>180cm)
60cm)
90cm) 180cm)
31.78
516
423
467
1464
Total
2870
Scott Wilson
All trees of girth size more than 30 cm cut and removed will be accountable as per the Forest laws and
efforts will be maintained to plant two times the number of trees cut according to compensatory
afforestation guidelines.
There are no forest sections along the project road.
The widening proposed in the non-forest locations will consume the agricultural land, which has
potential to grow crops. The increase in suspended particulate matter has significant impact over the
productivity of the crop and plant growth during construction.
2.5.2
Fauna
There are no notified National parks and Wild life sanctuary identified within the boundary of
10 Ian from the proposed road link. There are no endangered, critically endangered and
threatened categories of fauna in the near by vicinity of the project roads.
The common traffic - animal conflict or accidents by rash driving or break down of vehicles leads to
death of cattle and domestic animals. These conflicts are in minor in nature which can be resolved
with cash compensation pay to cattle owners. Some times there will chemical spill or indiscriminate
disposal of bituminous materials in the forest area these toxic foreign materials may enter surrounding
water bodies and prove detrimental to local fauna. It is necessary to comply with Hazardous Waste
Material Handling Rules, 1989 to protect animals by consuming such contaminated water.
2.6
The socio economic environment has considered the land use changes, impacts to drinking water
sources, impact to land & properties and impact to cultural properties.
A variety of utilities serving the regional needs are currently within RoW. The Categories of such
utilities are as follows Table 2.7
Table 21: Shifting of electrical and telephone poles
Link
Number
Link Name
Electrical
Poles
Transformers
DP
Telephone Poles
T8
II
339
II
0
lHaveri (NH4) - Hangal
The required mitigation measure would be to ask in advance the relevant owners of these utilities to
shift those before construction start to avoid disruption of regional services. It is the PWD's
responsibilities to make the land available for construction free of all encumbrances.
Project has integrated several mitigation, avoidance and enhancement plans relating to socio
economic aspects that include provision for parking areas, bus bays, rain Shelters etc., in to the
engineering design to improve the quality of life in these areas.
2.6.1
Cultural properties
Scott Wilson
Link
1
2
3
4
5
7
6
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15 Total
No
0
0
1
3
7
24
6
8
10
0
0
0
0
0
0
T8
59
Codes of Community Assets: i .High School, 2.Primary School, 3. Temple, 4.Shrine, 5.Aralikatte,
6.Bus shelter, 7.Hand pump, 8.MWS tank, 9. Samadhi, 1O.Anganwadi, 1l.Mosque, i2.Grazing land,
l3.well, i4.Hospital,
15. Others: Basement, Bore well, Compound wall, Fence, Flog pole, Govt. Land, Public toilet, Pump
house, School toilet, Water tank, Water tap, Sign board, Grave yard, Statues, APMC check points.
Archaeological Structures
2.6.1.2
2.7
This section summarizes impact of proposed improvements on existing environment. Keeping in view
traffic density, human (rural/urban) congestion, socio economic viability, environmental safety,
religious structures, obligatory points and other design parameters, options such as bypass,
realignment, formation and carriageway width have been given due consideration
Erosion
Debris disposal
Religious and
Archaeological
sites &
Properties
Demolition of
Retainin~ wall,
Addressed in Design
Addressed in Implementation
Slope
protection
measures
identified and incorporated in the
design and BoQ.
Addressed in
Operation stage
After planting check
its survival rate
Maintenance of all
drainage
channels
clean and slopes
identified
for
protection.
The disposed areas
need
to
be
maintained
by
strengthening
of
turfing
and
vegetation over the
disposed
site
to
avoid erosion of the
disposed materials.
Scott Wilson
Impacts! Issues
Addressed in Design
required
Noise pollution
Water
Addressed in Implementation
Traffic
emissions
control as per the
legal requirements.
Regular air sampling
and
monitoring
operation
during
stage.
Use
best
equipments
and Monitor noise levels
machineries for reducing noise at periodically
to
construction sites. Follow all understand
the
procedures as per the legal norms. deviation from the
Use PPE wherever necessary. bench marks.
Siting of construction camps
away from sensitive recq>tors.
water
In acute water scarcity areas, the Monitor
use of potable water for dust quality parameters
to
suppression should be reviewed periodically
water understand
regularly.
Regular
the
sprinkling
required
for deviation from the
suppression of dust.
benchmarks.
implementation,
During
the Need to monitor
planned requirements will be ribbon
All
reviewed and implemented to the developments.
construction
actual requirement. Reinstate new
work areas on completion of shall be sufficiently
works.
away
from
the
project road edge.
RAP implementation to involve Monitor and evaluate
the
an NOO to ensure that the (M&E)
effectiveness of RAP
policies are adhered to.
implementation.
Addressed in
Operation stage
No action required
Scott Wilson
Kamataka State Highways Improvement Project Consultancy Services for Preparation of DPR, Bid Documents
and Associated Safeguard Instruments - EPC Packages Funded by World Bank
Impacts! Issues
Addressed in Design
Addressed-in Implementation
10
Addressed in
Operation stage
Scott Wilson
Executive Summary
-.
\'
..
E2436
V9
,\
...- ...-
.",;
.,
~
.,.
-... /
Prepared for:
Govt of Karnataka
Public Works
Dept.
(pIU, KSHIP)
. . ...
April 2009
/
FILE C.OP-V
2.
SUMMARY OF IMPACTS
The project impacts during various phases of the implementation on all the environmental parameters
like Air, Noise, Water, Land and Socio economic factors are discussed in brief In this chapter. The
Table 2.9 provides a Summary of the project impacts.
Air Environment
2.1
Air quality is generally good whole along the project road except along the poorly maintained areas.
These areas are highly dust prone and require sprinkling of water for suppression of the dust. There
are no polluting industries in PIA or adjoining areas. The project road has extensive agricultural areas
on bQth sides.
Air quality along the project road alignment will be adversely impacted at congested locations and
major urban settlements locations like Chinthamani. The area will be impacted by air pollution both
during construction and operation stages. Construction stage impacts will be of short term and have
adverse impacts on the construction workers as well as on the settlements adjacent to the alignment,
especially those in the downwind direction. Operation stage impacts will not be as severe as the
construction stage impacts and these will be confined generally to a ribbon development close to edge
of the pavement. However, there will be continued enhancement of air pollution due to increase in
number of vehicles in the road. It is difficult to predict the pollution level from vehicle since it is not
known how the adoption of new technology vehicles would proceed. It is however, possible to assess
the future pollution load on the assumption that the old technology vehicle would persist. The unit load
of pollutants from different type of vehicles have been estimated under the same assumption by the
Indian Institute of Petroleum which is presented in Table2.1
Table 21: Emission factors of different vehicles (glKm)
Types of Vehicle
CO
HC
Two Wheeler
8.3
5.16
Cars
24.03
3.57
Three Wheelers
12.25
7.77
Buses-Urban
4.381
1.327
Trucks
1.327
3.425
Light Commercial Vehicles
1.3
0.5
Source: IndIan Institute of Petroleum, 1985
NOx
1.57
8.281
6.475
2.5
SOx
0.013
0.053
0.029
1.441
1.127
0.4
Pb
0.004
0.0117
0.009
TSP
0.275
0.45
0.1
Based on this factor, the current loads of vehicular pollution in respective links of project area for the
year 2006 as 'well as those expected in 2012 have been estimated in Table 2.2.
Table 22: Pollution Load of Pollutants along the project Route (In TonslKm)
Link!
Route
67B
Year
2006
2012
CO
0.014178
0.02306
HC
0.010191
0.Q17570
Parameters
NOx
SOx
Pb
0.006507 0.001462 0.000013
0.010662 0.002276 0.000025
TSP
0.0004
0.0006
Note: TSP: Total Suspended Particulate, CO: Carbon Monoxide, HC Hydrocarbons, NOx: Oxides of Nitrogen, Sox:
Sulphur dioxide, Pb: Lead.
2.1.1
Increased Suspended particulate matter and emissions of gases like, Oxides of Sulphur, Oxides of
Nitrogen, Carbon monoxide and Hydrocarbon will be generated during these stages due to enhanced
air pollution by the use of heavy equipments and machinery etc; diversion of traffic from the traffic
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
enroute. during loading and unloading of raw materials at sites; emissions from the hot mix plant and
diesel generators; stone crushing unit operations in the stone quarries and handling and storage of
aggregates and sand at locations of batch mixing plants.
It can be observed from the ambient air quality of the project area except increase in suspended
particulate matter all other air quality parameters such as RPM, NOx, SOx, Pb, eo and He are within
the limits of ambient air quality standard.
2.1.2
Operation Stage
The introduction of new pavement will smoothen and widen the road, so the generation of fugitive
dust is. reduced during the operation stage and suitable pitching and embankment turfing will control
the erosion dust emission.
The levels of S02, He and NOx are likely to come down to greater extent by the operations of new
roads with extensive savings in consumption of fuel. There will be reduction of toxic gases being
released. There may be localized impact from pollution with increase in number of vehicles running
on the road, adulterated fuel supply and poor maintenance of vehicles.
The measures for the avoidance and mitigation measures for controlling the air pollution are in table
3.1 Environmental mitigation plan. The increase in the width of pavement and landscaping decreases
the dust emissions by traffic during operational phase.
2.2
Noise Environment
The baseline noise levels monitored in the project area indicate baseline noise level, which exceeds the
pennissible limits for silence areas such as schools, courts and hospitals. For other land uses the noise
levels are well within the specified limits. But noise levels would increase significantly during
construction phase due to movement of construction machinery and vehicles during construction &
operation respectively. Thus, noise is a major area of concern, especially since a number of sensitive
receptors have been located within Impact zone and are close to RoW.
The impacts on noise due to the project will be of significance in both the construction as well as the
operation stages.
2.2.1
Noise levels during the pre construction stage are mostly expected to be indicative of prevalent
baseline levels apart from localised noise levels at locations where pre construction stage activities
such as establishment of workers camps, stockyards are taking place. There will be increased noise
levels due diversion of traffic on unpaved roads only for a short duration during the pre construction
stage. Moreover, as these activities are not likely to be placed near settlement locations the increased
noise impact is bound to be negligible.
Various activities of road construction will increase noise levels in impacts zone of the project
corridor. The construction activities includes the excavation for foundations and grading of the site and
the construction of structures and facilities, movement of heavy vehicles, loading, transportation and
unloading of construction materials and also there will be indirect influence which will be cumulative
to ambient noise level due to activities such as blasting at stone quarry sites, crushing plants, asphalt
production plants, produce significant noise during construction stage.
Scott Wilson
Kamataka State Highways Improvement Project Consultancy Services for Preparation of DPR, Bid Documents
and Associated Safeguard Instruments - EPC Packages Funded by World Bank
Enhancement in noise levels depends on many key factors such as traffic intensity, type and condition
of the vehicles plying on the road, acceleration/deceleration/gear changes by the vehicles depending
on the level of congestion and smoothness of road surface (IRe: 104-1988).
2.2.2
With the introduction of new pavement, road will be smoothened and widening of road at congested
locations, reduces the generation of noise level during the operation stage. However, there will be
negligible impact from usage of poorly maintained vehicles and old vehicles.
Based on noise level factor, the current noise level of vehicular traffic as well as those expected in
future level have been estimated and given in Table 2.3
Table 21: Noise level due to Traffic along the project Road
Link
ID
67B
Year
2006
2012
3,300
5,545
137.5
231.0
d(M)
u (Miles
!Hour)
L(dB)
15
15
19.188
50.000
69.0849
79.6575
The adverse impacts from the increase of noise during construction phase on the near by community
will be reduced by several construction phase mitigation plans. All possible mechanical and
administrative controls will be practiced to reduce the adverse impacts on the workers. In unavoidable
situations personal protective equipments (PPE) such as ear muffs and earplugs will be provided to
the workers based on the nature of works.
Number of sensitive receptors for the construction of noise barriers has been identified and the details
are presented in Appendix -6. These locations have been identified based on proximity of the sensitive
receptors (Schools and Hospitals) to the road traffic and the absence of wall or the inadequate height
of the existing walls. Provision has been made for additional barriers identified during construction
phase. In all areas of identified noise barriers, public will be advised how the noise levels can be
reduced by barriers such as solid walls and vegetative noise barriers. The project does not recommend
expensive double glazed windows as an economically viable impact mitigation measure.
2.3
Water Environment
The water environment is. generally good but is being polluted by the large-scale horticultural
activities prevailing in the PIA. In the PIA area, agriculture is the main land use. Agriculture requires
application of pesticides and Fertilizers. This is a major contamination source for the Ground water in
the project road. Otherwise the water quality has been good in above road link.
There are no major rivers in the impact zone. However, there are a number of ponds, lakes,
canals and other streams across the project road. To facilitate the cross-drainage at these water
crossings cross-drainage structures have been proposed including improvements in the
existing structures not to affect the existing drainage system in the project implementation
area. The surface water flow in the project area is predominantly from the west to east
The local community is using some ponds and underground water for their daily needs. Some of these
within RoW will be slightly impacted during the construction phase of project road. The general water
contours varies from 500 to 800 Mt above Mean Sea Level. 67B has low ground water table due to
over extraction of ground water for irrigation utilities. Local community is dependent on the hand
pumps, tube wells and wells and those which will be impacted due to widening needs to be relocated
before the project starts. Number of water supply units likely affected is given in Table 2.4.
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
Table 21: Water supply units likely affected along the project area
Link
ID
Location
67B
Hand
Pumps
Water
Bore
cisternlPu
Wells
mp House
1
5
Water Water
Taps Lines
OverHead
TanklGL
Reservoir
0
Public
ToiletlMa
nhole
1
H Cross - Chinatmani
2
0
0
Bypass (cor 65 F -In)
Contractor needs to keep a copy of the EA and EMP in the site office. Other than the construction
water issue, no major pollution points have been identified through out the length. No construction
waste shall be disposed off in to the water bodies/valley/nala. The construction vehicles are prohibited
from entering the water bodies for any purpose (including cleaning) other than the legitimate
requirements to avoid major pollution points due to Petroleum oil and lubricants.
It is very fundamental to conserve the water by way of constructing recharge pits wherever feasible
along the project road. These recharge pits harvest rainwater from road surface to improve the ground
water table. Refer Appendix -2 for typical drawing.
The construction water requirement could be an issue during construction at certain stretches of the
project road. As a part of the planning, contractor has to prepare a contractor' s construction water
management plan as per the guidelines provided in Appendix -15.
2.4
Land Environment
Most of the available stone material along the project area is granites gneiss and granitic schist. The
metals required for the road construction is available very close to road enroute. Use of explosives is
absolutely necessary to break open the aggregates in the stone quarry. In order to use these materials,
contractor will have to establish a number of crushers along the project route from which impact will
be very large and permanent in nature.
There will be exploitation of natural resources and it also reduces natural beauty of the landscape and
alters contours of the geographical region. There will be formation of deep and large depr.ession from
the quarry operations. This will be fatal for both the animals and humans in case fall in to depressions
from surrounding . habitat. Some times there is possibility of flying fragments of stones from
uncontrolled blasting using explosives surrounding to quarry area prevails.
Suspended particulate matter generatedn leads to degeneration of plant species and retards the growth
of plant species as it reduces the transpiration process and also there will be considerable impact over
the occupational workers in the quarries. During monsoon there will be collection of water in deep
ditches this serves as breeding sites for mosquitoes.
Borrow material includes gravel, murrum and sand. Generally gravel is collected from the wasteland,
which is notified from Government or with the consent of farmers in case of farmland. Sand will be
collected from river valleys this alters the course of flow and velocity of flow of water in rivers.
Transport of the borrow materials to the construction sites is of significance, as almost all such areas
are accessible through dirt tracks. Spillage and compaction of soil along these tracks will be a
significant impact. Special transport facilities with special measures are required to transport
bituminous material from the refineries to work sites, as they are highly inflarnrnable and to control
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
Karnataka State Highways Improvement Project Consultancy Services for Preparation of DPR, Bid Documents
and Associated Safeguard Instruments - EPC Packages Funded by World Bank
accidental spills. Proper protection measures need to be worked out for the minimizing of such
impacts during the haulage of borrows materials. A major source of dust during the construction stage
is from stone crushing operations from the crusher and the vibrating screen. The dust, in addition
causes an eyesore, reduces visibility thereby increasing safety concerns. Rehabilitation of borrows
areas from which earth has been excavated, is a potential problem, which needs to be addressed and
need to comply with management plan Appendix - 17. In addition to visual light, safety issues shall
also be considered. The major sites that likely affected from the proposed road development are given
in Table 2.5.
Table 2-1: Major Borrow Material Regions along the route
Link
No
Quarry
No
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chainage
(Km)
Location
Appx
Area,A,
> (Da)
Appx Depth, D
(m), >
Below
EGL
Dilloc
k
Type of
Material
Kallahalli Stone
Metal Quarry
QII-1A134
67B
NeranakaJlu
Granite Metal
Quarry
Murugamala
Granite Stone
Metal Quarry
Qu-1A135
Qu-1A136
At a distance of
1.0 km on LHS
5+000
At a distance of
17.0 kmon
RHS
At a distance of
17.0 kmon
LHS
14+000
24+700
20.00
20.00
Granite
Metal
2.00
20.00
Granite
Metal
5.00
50.00
Granite
Metal
Muurum Locations
Link
No
67B
Quarry
No
MII-1-A118
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chainage
(Km)
13+500
Location
Located on
LHS ata
distance of 3.7
Kmfrom
jlro.Leet road
Appx
Area,A,
> (Dec)
8.50
Appx Depth, D
(m), >
Below
EGL
HiIIoc
k
2.85
Type of
Material
Murram
Link
No
67B
Quar~
No
Su-1A-65
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chitravathi River
Sand
Chainage
(Km)
Location
24+700
At a distance of
45 kmonLHS
Type of
material
Sand
All borrow areas will be operated and redeveloped in accordance with the IRC 10: 1961.MoRTH and
applicable EMP clauses (Appendix - 17) as provided in the contract documents including EMP.
In addition to the above arrangements, Contractor will have to establish dedicated environmentally
compatible crusher units to generate adequate sand and aggregates so as to effectively utilize the
excavated materials during construction.
Scott Wilson
2.4.1
The major land use in the project area is extensive agriculture and existence of settlement at locations
of village and small towns having active commercial and economic activity along the roadside. The
accurate surveys and accurate markings and negotiations will determine land use changes and finalize
the alignment to minimize acquisition procedure. Any additional land available must be put to use for
productive purposes. Mitigation related to land acquisition and resettlement will be undertaken as
specified by the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP).
Biological Environment
2.5.1
Flora
Total number of trees to be felled in the project area for the road expansion is presented in Table 2.6
Table 21 : List of Impacted Trees due to Proposed Project road
Fauna
There are no notified National parks and Wild life sanctuary identified within the boundary of 10 kID
from the proposed road link. There are no endangered, critically endangered and threatened categories
of fauna in the near by vicinity of the project roads.
Scott Wilson
The common traffic - animal confli~t or accidents by rash driving or break down of vehicles leads to
death of cattle and domestic animals these conflicts are in minor in nature which can be resolved with
cash compensation pay to cattle owners. Some times. there will chemical spill or indiscriminate
disposal of bituminous materials in the forest area these toxic foreign materials may enter surrounding
water bodies and prove detrimental to local fauna. It is necessary to comply with Hazardous Waste
Material Handling Rules 1989 to protect animals by consuming such contaminated water.
2.6
The socio economic environment has considered the land use changes, impacts to drinking water
sources, impact to land & properties and impact to cultural properties.
A variety of utilities serving the regional needs are currently within RoW. The Categories of such
utilities are as follows Table 2.7
Table 2-1: Shifting of electrical and telephone poles
Link ID
Link Name
Electrical
Poles
Transformers
DP
Telephone Poles
152
23
67B
The required mitigation measure would be to ask in advance the relevant owners of these utilities to
shift those before construction start to avoid disruption of regional services. It is the PWD's
responsibilities to make the land available for construction free of all encumbrances.
Project has integrated several mitigation, avoidance and enhancement plans relating to socio
economic aspects that include provision for parking areas, bus bays, rain Shelters etc., in to the
engineering design to improve the quality of life in these areas.
2.6.1
Cultural properties
Link
ID
67B
10
11
12
13
14
15
Total
15
36
Codes of Community Assets: i. High School. 2.Primary School. 3. Temple. 4. Shrine. 5.Arallkatte.
6.Bus shelter. 7.Hand pump. 8.MWS tank. 9. Samadhi. 1O.Anganwadi. ii.Mosque. 12.Grazing land,
i3.well. i4.Hospital,
15. Others: Basement, Bore well. Compound wall, Fence, Flog pole. Govt. Land, Public toilet. Pump
house. School toilet, Water tank. Water tap. Sign board, Grave yard. Statues, APMC check points.
2.6.1.2
Archaeological Structures
Scott Wilson
2.7
This section summarizes impact of proposed improvements on existing environment. Keeping in view
traffic density, human (rural/urban) congestion, socio economic viability, environmental safety,
religious structures, obligatory points and other design parameters, options such as bypass,
realignment, formation and carriageway width have been given due consideration
Table 21: Summary of Environmental impacts and Issues
Impacts! Issues
Tree removal
(flora)
Erosion
Debris disposal
Religious and
Archaeological
&
sites
Properties
Demolition of
Retaining wall,
breast wall etc.,
close
to
structures
especially
houses.
Air pollution
Noise pollution
Water
Addressed in Design
Addressed in Implementation
Addressed in
Operation sta2e
After planting check
its survival.rate
Maintenance of all
drainage
channels
clean and slopes
identified
for
protection.
The disposed areas
to
need
be
by
maintained
strengthening
of
turfing
and
vegetation over the
disposed
site to
avoid erosion of the
disposed materials.
Use
Traffic
emissions
control as per the
legal requirements.
Regular air sampling
monitoring
and
during
operation
stage.
Monitor noise levels
periodically
to
understand
the
deviation from the
bench marks.
best
equipments
and
for reducing noise at
construction sites. Follow all
procedures as per the legal norms.
Use PPE wherever necessary.
Siting of construction camps
away from sensitive receptors.
In acute water scarcity areas, the
~achineries
No action required
Monitor
water
Scott Wilson
Kamataka State Highways Improvement Project Consultancy Services for Preparation of DPR, Bid Documents
and Associated Safeguard Instruments - EPC Packages Funded by World Bank
Impacts! Issues
Addressed in Design
recorded as a benchmark.
Suitable measures to prevent
the silt and other pollutants
from reaching the nearby
water bodies
Land
The land requirement has
requirements
been considerably reduced by
proper planning to match the
requirements with in the
ROW with minimum land
acquisition, realignments and
bypasses.
Displacement of Minimized the displacement
PAPs
by proper planning in
selecting final alignment.
Compensation provision as
per the GOK approved R&R
policy for the project.
Road safety
Design has incorporated all
safety measures. Provide
safety barrier at bridge
approaches, crash barriers at
critical
locations,
and
included all safety proviSions
in the BOQ for lining and
signin.
EINEMP
Prepared during this phase
documents
required at the
contractors
office
Aggregate and
sand
Borrow areas
Addressed in
OPJlration sta2e
use of potable water for dust quality parameters
suppression should be reviewed periodically
to
Regular
the
regularly.
water understand
sprinkling
required
for deviation from the
suppression of dust.
benchmarks.
implementation,
During
the Need to monitor
planned requirements will be ribbon
All
reviewed and implemented to the developments.
construction
actual requirement. Reinstate new
work areas on completion of shall be sufficiently
from
the
works.
away
Qroject road ede.
RAP implementation to involve Monitor and evaluate
the
an NGO to ensure that the (M&E)
policies are adhered to.
effectiveness of RAP
implementation.
Addressed in Implementation
Implement
road
safety,
a
accidents and traffic management
plan that has been prepared and
approved by the CSC. Display
road safety board in the camp
with no of accidents till date and
the reason for the accidents.
Shall use during the phase. Must
keep one copy of all relevant
EINEMP documents including
the Environmental clearance
documents at the contractor's
project site office under direct
control of the Project manager.
Use the excavated materials
obtained during widening as far
as possible.
No action required
Scott Wilson
Executive Summary
"C
.~o
:5
:::J
~
en
o
.~
:::J L
0.
::0
-.
E2436
VB
"C
0)
:~
"S
...
0) "
:::J
en
<3
en
0 '
0 .~
::0 .
:::J
0.
Prepared for:
Govt of Karnataka
Public Works
Dept.
(PIU, KSIDP)
....
April 2009
ftE CO~V
2.
SUMMARY OF IMPACTS
The project impacts during various phases of the implementation on all the environmental parameters
like Air, Noise, Water, Land and Socio economic factors are discussed in brief in this chapter. The
Table 2.9 provides a Summary of the project impacts.
2.1
Air Environment
Air quality is generally good whole along the project road except along the poorly maintained areas.
These areas are highly dust prone and require sprinkling of water for suppression of the dust. There
are no polluting industries in PIA or adjoining areas. The project road has extensive agricultural areas
on both sides.
Air quality along the project road alignment will be adversely impacted at congested locations and
major urban settlement like Hosakote. The area will be impacted by air pollution both during
construction and operation- stages. Construction stage impacts will be of short term and have adverse
impacts on the construction workers as well as on the settlements adjacent to the alignment, especially
those in the downwind direction. Operation stage impacts will not be as severe as the construction
stage impacts and these will be confined generally to a ribbon development close to edge of the
pavement. However, there will becontinued enhancement of air pollution due to increase in number of
vehicles in the road. It is difficult to predict the pollution level from vehiCle since it is not known how
the adoption of new technology vehicles would proceed. It is however, possible to assess the future
pollution load on the assumption that the old technology vehicle would persist. The unit load of
pollutants from different type of vehicles have been estimated under the same assumption by the
Indian Institute of Petroleum which is presented in Table2.1
Table 2-1: Emission factors of different vehicles (glKm)
Types of Vehicle
HC
CO
Two Wheeler
8.3
5.16
Cars
24.03
3.57
Three Wheelers
12.25
7.77
Buses-Urban
4.381
1.327
Trucks
3.425
1.327
Light Commercial Vehicles
0.5
1.3
Source: Indian Institute of Petroleum, 1985
NOx
1.57
8.281
6.475
2.5
SOx
0.013
0.053
0.029
1.441
1.127
0.4
Pb
0.004
0.0117
0.009
TSP
0.275
0.45
0.1
Based on this factor, the current loads of vehicular pollution in respective links of project area for the
year 2006 as well as those expected in 2012 have been estimated in Table 2.2.
Table 2-2: Pollution Load of Pollutants along the project Route (In TonsIKm)
Link!
Route
67A
Year
2006
2012
CO
0.056979
0.092734
HC
0.040105
0.067888
Parameters
NOx
SOx
Pb
0,011878 0.003194 0.000049
0.019964 0.005003 0.000087
TSP
0.0010
0.0015
Note: TSP: Total Suspended Particulate, CO: Carbon Monoxide, HC Hydrocarbons, NOx: Oxides of Nitrogen, Sox:
Sulphur dioxide, Pb: Lead.
2.1.1
Increased Suspended particulate matter and emissions of gases like, Oxides of Sulphur, Oxides of
Nitrogen, Carbon monoxide and Hydrocarbon will be generated during these stages due to enhanced
air pollution by the use of heavy equipments and machinery etc; diversion of traffic from the traffic
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
enroute; during loading and unloading of raw materials at sites; emissions from the hot mix plant and
diesel generators; stone crushing unit operations in the stone quarries and handling and storage of
aggregates and sand at locations of batch mixing plants.
It can be observed from the ambient air quality of the project area except increase in suspended
particulate matter all other air quality parameters such as RPM, NOx, SOx, Pb, eo and He are within
the limits of ambient air quality standard.
2.1.2
Operation Stage
The introduction of new pavement road will smoothen and widen the road, so the generation of
fugitive dust is reduced during the operation stage and suitable pitching and embankment turfing will
control the erosion dust emission.
The levels of S02, He and NOx are likely to come down to greater extent by the operations of new
roads with extensive savings in consumption of fuel. There will be reduction, of toxic gases being
released. There may be localized impact from pollution with increase in number of vehicles running
on the road, adulterated fuel supply and poor maintenance of vehicle.
The measures for the avoidance and mitigation measures for controlling the air pollution are in table
3.1 Environmental mitigation plan. The increase in the width of pavement and landscaping decreases
the dust emission levels by traffic during operational phase.
2.2
Noise Environment
The baseline noise levels monitored in the project area indicate baseline noise level, which exceeds the
permissible limits for silence areas such as schools, courts and hospitals. For other land uses the noise
levels are well within the specified limits. But noise levels would increase significantly during
construction phase due to movement of construction machinery and vehicles during construction &
operation respectively. Thus, noise is a major area of concern, especially since a number of sensitive
receptors have been located within Impact zone and are close to RoW.
The impacts on noise due to the project will be of significance in both the construction as well as the
operation stages.
2.2.1
Noise levels during the pre construction stage are mostly expected to be indicative of prevalent
baseline levels apart from localised noise levels at locations where pre construction stage activities
such as establishment of workers camps, stockyards are taking place. There will be increased noise
levels due diversion of traffic on unpaved roads only for a short duration during the pre construction
stage. Moreover, as these activities are not likely to be placed near settlement locations the increased
noise impact is bound to be negligible.
Various activities of road construction will increase noise levels in impacts zone of the project
corridor. The construction activities includes the excavation for foundations and grading of the site
and the construction of structures and facilities, movement of heavy vehicles, loading, transportation
and unloading of construction materials and also there will be indirect influence which will be
cumulative to ambient noise level due to activities such as blasting at stone quarry sites, crushing
plants, asphalt production plants, produce significant noise during construction stage.
Scott Wilson
Karnataka State Highways Improvement Project Consultancy Services for Preparation of DPR. Bid Documents
and Associated Safeguard Instruments - EPC Packages Funded by World Bank
Enhancement in noise levels depends on many key factors such as traffic intensity, type and condition
of the vehicles plying on the road, acceleration/deceleration/gear changes by the vehicles depending
on the level of congestion and smoothness of road surface (IRe: 104-1988).
2.2.2
With the introduction of new pavement, road will be smoothened and widening of road at congested
locations, reduces the generation of noise level during the operation stage. However, there will be
negligible imi>act from usage of poorly maintained vehicles and old vehicles.
Based on noise level factor, the current noise level of vehicular traffic as well as those expected in
future level have been estimated and given in Table 2.3
Table 2-1: Noise level due to Traffic along the project Road
LinkID
Year
67A
2006
2012
Total
Vehicle/day
JNos.)
10,121
17,138
(VehicleslHr)
421.7
714.1
d(M)
u (MUeslHr)
L (dB(A
15
15
23.868
50.000
75.8477
84.5581
The adverse impacts from the increase of noise during construction phase on the near by community
will be reduced by several construction phase mitigation plans. All possible mechanical and
administrative controls will be practiced to reduce the adverse impacts on the workers. In unavoidable
situations personal protective equipments (PPE) will be provided to the workers based on the nature
of works.
Number of sensitive receptors for the construction of noise barriers has been identified and the details
are presented in Appendix -6. These locations have been identified based on proximity of the sensitive
receptors (Schools and Hospitals) to the road traffic and the absence of wall or the inadequate height
of the existing walls. Provision has been made for additional barriers identified during construction
phase. In all areas of identified noise barriers, public will be advised how the noise levels can be
reduced by barriers such as solid walls and vegetative noise barriers. The project does not recommend
expensive double glazed windows as an economically viable impact mitigation measure.
2.3
Water Environmei1t
The water environment is generally good but is being polluted by the large-scale horticultural
activities prevailing in the PIA. In the PIA area, agriculture is the main land use. Agriculture requires
application of pesticides and Fertilizers. This is a major contamination source for the Ground water in
the project road. Otherwise the water quality has been good in above road link.
There are no major rivers in the Impact zone. However, there are a number of ponds, lakes, canals and
other streams across the project road. To facilitate the cross-drainage at these water crossings crossdrainage structures have been proposed including improvements in the existing structures not to affect
the existing drainage system in the project implementation area. The surface water flow in the project
area is predominantly from the west to east.
The local community is using some ponds and under ground water for their daily needs. Some of these
which are within RoW will be impacted during the construction of road. The general ground water
contours varies from 500 to 800 Mt above Mean Sea Level. 67 A has low ground water table due to
over extraction of ground water for irrigation utilities. Local communities depend on the hand pumps,
Scott Wilson
tube wells and wells, which wiIl be impacted generating high demand for drinking water. Relocations
of the impacted water supply units. Number of water supply units likely affected is given in Table 2.4.
Table 21: Water supply units likely affected along the project area
Link
ID
67A
Location
Hoskote- H
Hand
Pump
s
Bore
Wells
Water
cistern/Pu
mp House
Water
Taps
Water
Lines
OverHead
Tank/GL
Reservoir
Public
ToiletIM
an hole
10
(Hindgnaia) Cross
Contractor needs to keep a copy of the EIA and EMP in the site office. Other than the construction
water issue, no major pollution points have been identified through out the length. No construction
waste shall be disposed off in to the water bodies/valley/nala. The construction vehicles are prohibited
from entering the water bodies' for any purpose (including cleaning) other than the legitimate
requirements to avoid major pollution points due to Petroleum oil and lubricants.
It is very fundamental to conserve the water by way of constructing recharge pits wherever feasible
along the project road. These recharge pits harvest rainwater from road surface to improve the ground
water table. Refer Appendix -2 for typical drawing.
The construction water requirement could be an issue during construction at certain stretches of the
project road. As a part of the planning, contractor has to prepare a contractor's construction water
management plan as per the guidelines provided in Appendix -15.
2.4
Land Environment
Most of the available stone material along the project area is granites, gneiss and granitic schist. The
metals required for the road construction is available very close to road enroute. Use of explosives is
absolutely necessary to break open the aggregates in the stone quarry. In order to use these materials,
contractor will have to establish a number of crushers along the project route from which impact will
be very large and permanent in nature.
There will be exploitation of natural resources and it also reduces natural beauty of the landscape and
alters contours of the geographical region. There will be formation of deep large depression from the
quarry operations. This will be fatal for both the animals and humans in case fall in to depressions
from surrounding habitat. Some times there is possibility of flying fragments of stones from
uncontrolled blasting using explosives surrounding to quarry area prevails.
Suspended particulate matter generated leads to degeneration of plant species and retards the growth
of plant species as it reduces the transpiration process and also there will be considerable impact over
the occupational workers in the quarries. During monsoon there will be collection of water in deep
ditches this serves as breeding sites for mosquitoes.
Borrow material includes gravel, murrum and sand. Generally gravel is collected from the wasteland,
which is notified from Government or with the consent of farmers in case of farmland. Sand will be
collected from river valleys this alters the course of flow and velocity of flow of water in rivers.
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
Transport of the borrow materials to the construction sites is of significance, as almost all such areas
are accessible through dirt tracks. Spillage and compaction of soil along these tracks will be a
significant impact. Special transport facilities are required to transport bituminous material from the
refineries to work sites, as these require special measures to control accident spills, as this materials
are highly inflammable. Proper protection measures need to be worked out for the minimizing of such
impacts during the haulage of borrows materials. A major source of dust during the construction stage
is from stone crushing operations from the crusher and the vibrating screen. The dust, in addition it
causes an eyesore, reduces visibility thereby increasing safety concerns Rehabilitation of borrows
areas from which earth has been excavated, is a potential problem, which needs to b~ addressed and
need to comply with management plan Appendix - 17. In addition to visual light, safety issues shall
also be considered. The major sites that likely affected from the proposed road development is given in
Table 2.5.
Table 2-1: Major Borrow Material Regions along the route
Link
No
Quarry
No
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chainage
Location
(Km)
Appx
Area,A,
> (Ha)
Appx Depth, D
(m), >
Type of
Material
Hillock
Below
EGL
20.00
Granite
Metal
Granite
Metal
Granite
Metal
67A
Qn-1A131
Narasapura granite
Stone Metal
Quarry
0+000
At a distance of
24.2 km on RHS
Qn-1A132
Bheemakannahalli
Stone Metal
Quarry
10+400
At a distance of
0.4 km on RHS
2.00
Depth
availabl
e as we
go
deeper
Qn-1A133
Byalanarasapura
Stone Metal
Quarry
18+300
At a distance of
5.5kmonRHS
10.00
10.00
to
20.00
40.00
MURRUM LOCATIONS
Link
No
Quarry
No
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chainage
Location
(Km)
MII-1-A114
10+400
MII-1-A115
14+000
MII-1-A116
15+500
MII-1-A117
19+200
67A
Located on RHS
at a distance of
0.4 Km from
project road
Located on RHS
at a distance of
0.1 Km from
project road
Located on RHS
at a distance of
0.1 Kmfrom
project road
Located on RHS
at a distance of
0.1 Kmfrom
project road
Appx Depth, D
(m), >
Appx
Area,A,
> (Hee)
Hillock
Below
EGL
10.98
4.36
Murram
8.50
4.32
Murram
9.50
4.00
Murram
10.65
4.11
Murram
Type of
Material
Scott Wilson
Link
No
67A
Quarry
No
Sn-1A-64
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Hettakki Nalla
Sand Quarry
Chainage
(Km)
Location
18+300
At a distance of
8.5 kmonRHS
Type of
material
All borrow areas will be operated and redeveloped in accordance with the IRe 10: 1961.MoRTH and
applicable EMP clauses (Appendix - 17) as provided in the contract documents including EMP.
In addition to the above arrangements, Contractor will have to establish dedicated environmentally
compatible crusher units to generate adequate sand and aggregates so as to effectively utilize the
excavated materials during construction.
2.4.1
The major land use in the project area is extensive agriculture and existence of settlement at locations
of village and small towns having active commercial and economic activity along the roadside. The
accurate surveys and accurate markings and negotiations will determine land use changes and finalize
the alignment to minimize acquisition procedure. Any additional land available must be put to use for
productive purposes. Mitigation related to land acquisition and resettlement will be undertaken as
specified by the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP).
Biological Environment
2.5.1
Flora
Total number of trees to be felled in the project area for road expansion is presented in Table 2.6
Table 2-1: List of Impacted Trees due to Proposed Project road
Hoskote - H Cross
(Hindgnala Cross)
23.50
454
703
264
135
Total
1,556
Scott Wilson
All trees of girth size more than 30 cm cut and removed will be accountable as per the Forest laws and
efforts will be maintained to plant two times the number of trees cut according to compensatory
afforestation guidelines.
There is a forested section along the project road. The detail is as given in the following table.
Chainage (Km)
Area of forested
Remarks
& Lene:th(M)
section (Ha)
16.030 to 16.190
0.24
Nandagudi Village,
67A
(0.160 Mt)
The widening proposed in the non-forest locations will consume the productive agricultural land,
which has potential to grow crops. The increase in suspended particulate matter has significant impact
over the productivity of the crop during construction.
Link
ID
2.5.2
Fauna
There are no notified National parks and Wild life sanctuary identified within the boundary of
10 Ian from the proposed road link. There are no endangered, critically endangered and
threatened categories of fauna in the near by vicinity of the project roads.
The common traffic - animal conflict or accidents by rash driving or break down of vehicles leads to
death of cattle and domestic animals. These conflicts are in minor in nature which can be resolved
with cash compensation pay to cattle owners. Some times there will chemical spill or indiscriminate
disposal of bituminous materials in the forest area these toxic foreign materials may enter surrounding
water bodies and prove detrimental to local fauna. It is necessary to comply with Hazardous Waste
Material Handling Rules, 1989 to protect animals by consuming such contaminated water.
2.6
The socio economic environment has considered the land use changes, impacts to drinking water
sources, impact to land & properties and impact to cultural properties.
A variety of utilities serving the regional needs are currently within RoW. The Categories of such
utilities are as follows Table 2. 7
Table 2-1: Shifting of electrical and telephone poles
Link
Number
67A
Link Name
1H0skote - H (Hindgnala)
k:ross
Electrical
Poles
Transformers
DP
Telephone Poles
410
20
21
36
The required mitigation measure would be to ask in advance the relevant owners of these utilities to
shift those before construction start to avoid disruption of regional services. It is the PWD' s
responsibilities to make the land available for construction, free of all encumbrances.
Project has integrated several mitigation, avoidance and enhancement plans relating to socio
economic aspects that include provision for parking areas, bus bays, rain Shelters etc., in to the
engineering design to improve the quality of life in these areas.
2.6.1
Cultural properties
Scott Wilson
Action Plan (RAP). In order to avoid community conflicts, contractor will have to discuss with the
local community prior to taking up of the construction work at such sites. The community assets,
which are getting affected, are given in the following table - 2.8
Table 2-1: Community Assets Getting Affected along the proposed road
Link
1
2
3
4
5
7
6
8
9
10
11 12 13 14 15 Total
No
0
0
3
2
67A
6
2
3
10
0
0
0
0
0
0
20
46
Codes of CommuDlty Assets: 1. High School, 2.Przmary School, 3.Temple, 4.Shrme, 5.Aralzkatte,
6.Bus shelter, 7.Hand pump, 8.MWS tank. 9. Samadhi, JO.Anganwadi, 1l.Mosque, 12.Grazing land,
13. well, J4.Hospital,
15. Others: Basement, Bore well, Compound wall, Fence, Flog pole, Govt. Land, Public toilet, Pump
house, School toilet, Water tank, Water tap, Sign board, Grave yard, Statues, APMC check points.
2.6.1.2
Archaeological Structures
2.7
This section summarizes impact of proposed improvements on existing environment. Keeping in view
traffic density, human (rural/urban) congestion, socio economic viability, environmental safety,
religious structures, obligatory points and other design parameters, options such as bypass,
realignment, formation and carriageway width have been given due consideration
Table 2-1: Summary of Environmental impacts and Issues .
Impacts! Issues
Addressed in Design
Addressed in Implementation
removal
Tree
(flora)
Erosion
Debris disposal
Religious and
Archaeological
sites
&
Properties
Demolition of
Retaining wall,
Slope
protection
measures
identified and incorporated in the
design and BoQ.
Addressed in
Operation sta2e
After planting check
its survival rate
Maintenance of all
drainage
channels
clean and slopes
identified
for
protection.
The disposed areas
need
to
be
maintained
by
strengthening
of
turfing
and
vegetation over the
disposed
site
to
avoid erosion of the
disposed materials.
Scott Wilson
Impacts! Issues
Addressed in Design
required
Addressed in Implementation
Addressed in
Operation sta2e
emissions
Traffic
control as per the
legal requirements.
Regular air sampling
monitoring
and
operation
during
staJ1;e.
Noise pollution
Baseline data monitored and Use
equipments
best
and Monitor noise levels
to
recorded as a benchmark.
machineries for reducing noise at periodically
Provision of noise barriers construction sites. Follow all understand
the
for sensitive receptors such procedures as per the legal norms. deviation from the
as schools, hospitals etc.
Use PPE wherever necessary. bench marks.
Siting of construction camps
away from sensitive recep_tors.
Water
Baseline data monitored and In acute water scarcity areas, the Monitor
water
recorded as a benchmark. use of potable water for dust quality parameters
Suitable measures to prevent suppression should be reviewed periodically
to
the silt and other pollutants regularly.
water understand
the
Regular
. required
from reaching the nearby sprinkling
for deviation from the
benchmarks.
water bodies
suppression of dust.
Land
The land requirement has During
implementation,
the Need to monitor
requirements
been considerably reduced by planned requirements will be ribbon
proper planning to match the reviewed and implemented to the developments. All
requirements with in the actual requirement. Reinstate new
construction
ROW with minimum land work areas on completion of shall be sufficiently
acquisition, realignments and works.
the
away
from
bypasses.
project road edge.
Displacement of Minimized the displacement RAP implementation to involve Monitor and evaluate
by proper planning in an NGO to ensure that the (M&E)
PAPs
the
selecting final alignment. policies are adhered to.
effectiveness of RAP
Compensation provision as
implementation.
per the GOK approved R&R
policy for the project.
Road safety
Design has incorporated all Implement
safety, Monitor and create a
road
a
safety measures. Provide accidents and traffic management data
base
for
safety barrier at bridge plan that has been prepared and accidents along the
with
very
approaches, crash barriers at approved by the CSC. Display road
critical
locations,
and road safety board in the camp specific details. As a
included all safety provisions with no of accidents till date and follow up carry out
in the BOQ for lining and the reason for the accidents.
corrective measures
signing.
to improve safety.
EIAIEMP
Prepared during this phase
Shall use during the phase. Must Shall review the
documents
keep one copy of all relevant effectiveness at this
required at the
EIAIEMP documents including stage.
contractors
the Environmental clearance
office
documents at the contractor's
project site office under direct
control of the Project manager.
Aggregate and Use materials only from Use the excavated materials No action required
sand
legitimate sources adhering obtained during widening as far
to best practices. Obtain all as possible.
permissions and approvals
necessary.
Borrow areas
In addition to the excavated Open and close borrow areas
Scott Wilson
Impacts! Issues
Addressed in Design
Addressed in Implementation
10
Addressed in
Operation sta2e
Scott Wilson
Executive Summary
"0
.~
S
4:
~
~
15
~
.2
:c
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
E2436
V6
-.
.
""
..-. .
o.
""
__ .....,-:;;a....:-r-
,.......~--
Prepared for:
. Govt of Karnataka
Public Works
Dept.
(PIU, KSHIP)
-'"
....
April 1009
at
,.
FILE COPaY
2.
SUMMARY OF IMPACTS
The project impacts during various phases of the implementation on all the environmental parameters
like Air, Noise, Water, Land and Socio economic factors are. discussed in brief in this chapter. The
Table 2.9 provides a Summary of the project impacts.
2.1
Air Environment
Air quality is generally good whole along the project road except along the poorly maintained areas.
These areas are highly dust prone and require sprinkling of water for suppression of the dust. There
are no polluting industries in PIA or adjoining areas. The project road has extensive agricultural areas
on both sides.
Air quality along the project road alignment will be adversely impacted at congested locations and
major settlements locations like Devadurga. The area will be impacted by air pollution both during
construction and operation stages. Construction stage impacts will be of short term and have adverse
impacts on the construction workers as well as on the settlements adjacent to the alignment, especially
those in the downwind direction. Operation stage impacts will not be as severe as the construction
stage impacts and these will be confined generally to a ribbon development close to edge of the
pavement. However, there will be continued enhancement of air pollution due to increase in number of
vehicles in the roads. It is difficult to predict the pollution level from vehicle since it is not known how
the adoption of new technology vehicles would proceed. It is however, possible to assess the future
pollution load on the assumption that the old technology vehicle would persist. The unit load of
pollutants from different type of vehicles have been estimated under the same assumption by the
Indian Institute of Petroleum which is presented in Table2.1
Table 21: Emission factors of different vehicles (g/Km)
Types of Vehicle
HC
CO
Two Wheeler
8.3
5.16
Cars
24.03
3.57
Three Wheelers
12.25
7.77
Buses-Urban
4.381
1.327
Trucks
3.425
1.327
Light Commercial Vehicles
1.3
0.5
Source: indIan Institute of Petroleum, 1985
NOx
1.57
8.281
6.475
2.5
SOx
0.013
0.053
0.029
1.441
1.127
0.4
Pb
0.004
0.0117
0.009
TSP
.
0.275
0.45
0.1
Based on these emission factors, the current loads of vehicular pollution in respective links of project
area for the year 2006 as well as those expected in 2012 have been estimated in Table 2.2.
Table 22: Pollution Load of Pollutants along the project Route (In TonsIKm)
Link
ID
13B
Year
2006
2012
CO
0.003989
0.006854
HC
0.002821
0.005255
Parameters
NOx
SOx
0.002222
0.000641
0.003818
0.001043
Pb
0.000004
0.000008
TSP
0.000206
0.000332
Note: TSP: Total Suspended Particulate, CO: Carbon MonOXide, HC Hydrocarbons, NOx: Oxides of Nitrogen, Sox:
Sulpbur dioxide, Pb: Lead.
2.1.1
Increased suspended particulate matter and emissions of gases like, oxides of sulphur, oxides of
nitrogen, carbon monoxide and hydrocarbon will be generated during these stages due to enhanced air
pollution by the use of heavy equipments and machinery etc; diversion of traffic from the traffic
enroute. During loading and unloading of raw materials at sites; Emissions from the hot mix plant and
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
diesel generators; stone crushing unit operations in the stone quarries and Handling and storage of
aggregates and sand at locations of batch mixing plal)ts
It can be observed from the ambient air quality of the project area except increase in suspended
particulate matter all other air quality parameters such as RPM, NOx, SOx, Pb, eo and He are within
the limits of ambient air quality standard.
2.1.2
Operation Stage
The introduction of new pavement and road will smoothen and widen the road, so the generation of
fugitive dust is reduced during the operation stage and suitable pitching and embankment turfing will
control the erosion and dust emission.
The levels of S02, He and NOx are likely to come down to a greater extent by the operations of new
roads with extensive savings in consumption of fuel. There will be reduction of toxic gases being
released. There may be localized impact from pollution with increase in number of vehicles running
on the road, adulterated fuel supply and poor maintenance of vehicles.
The measures for the avoidance and mitigation measures for controlling the air pollution are in table
3.1 Environmental mitigation plan. The increase in the width of pavement and landscaping decreases
the dust levels created by traffic during operational phase.
2.2
Noise Environment
The baseline noise levels monitored in the project area indicate baseline noise level, which exceeds the
permissible limits for silence areas such as schools, courts and hospitals. For other land uses the noise
levels are well within the specified limits. But noise levels would increase significantly during
construction phase due to movement of construction machinery and vehicles during construction &
operation respectively. Thus, noise is a major area of concern, especially since a number of sensitive
receptors have been located within Impact zone and are close to RoW.
The impacts on noise due to the project will be of significance in both the.construction as well as the
operation stages.
2.2.1
Noise levels during the pre construction stage are mostly expected to be indicative of prevalent
baseline levels apart from localised noise levels at locations where pre construction stage activities
such as establishment of workers camps, stockyards are taking place. There will be increased noise
levels due diversion of traffic on unpaved roads only for a short duration during the pre construction
stage. Moreover, as these activities are not likely to be placed near settlement locations the increased
noise impact is bound to be negligible.
Various activities of road construction will increase noise levels in impacts zone of the project
corridor. The construction activities includes the excavation for foundations and grading of the site and
the construction of structures and facilities, movement of heavy vehicles, loading, transportation and
unloading of construction materials -and also there will be indirect influence which will be cuml,1lative
to ambient noise level due to activities such as blasting at stone quarry sites, crushing plants, asphalt
production plants, produce significant noise during construction stage.
Scott Wilson
Enhancement in noise levels depends on many key factors such as traffic intensity, type and condition
of the vehicles plying on the road, acceleration/deceleration/gear changes by the vehicles depending
on the level of congestion and smoothness of road surface (IRe: 104-1988).
2.2.2
With the introduction of new pavement, road will be smoothened and widening of road at congested
locations, reduces the generation of noise level during the operation stage. However, there will be
negligible impact from usage of poorly maintained vehicles and old vehicles.
Based on noise level factor, the current noise level of vehicular traffic as well as those expected in
future level have been estimated and given in Table 2.3
Table 2-1: Noise level due to Traffic along the project Road
Link
ID
13B
Year
Total Vehicle
q
/day (No.) (VehicleslHr)
2006
2012
I,J55
2,033
48.1
84.7
(M)
u
(Miles! Hour)
(dB (A)
15
15
23.670
50.000
66.3488
75.2999
The adverse impacts from the increase of noise during construction phase on the near by community
will be reduced by several construction phase mitigation plans. All possible mechanical and
administrative controls will be practiced to reduce the adverse impacts on the workers. In unavoidable
situations personal protective equipments (PPE) such as ear muffs and earplugs will be provided to
the workers based on the nature of works.
Number of sensitive receptors for the construction of noise barriers has been identified and the details
are presented in Appendix -6. These locations have been identified based on proximity of the sensitive
receptors (Schools and Hospitals) to the road traffic and the absence of wall or the inadequate height
of the existing walls. Provision has been made for additional barriers identified during construction
phase. In all areas of identified noise barriers, public will be advised how the noise levels can be
reduced by barriers such as solid walls and vegetative noise barriers. The project does not recommend
expensive double glazed windows as an economically viable impact mitigation measure.
2.3
Water Environment
The water environment is generally good but is being polluted by the large-scale horticultural
activities prevailing in the PIA. In the PIA area, agriculture is the main land use. Agriculture requires
application of pesticides apd Fertilizers. This is a major contamination source for the Ground water in
the project road. Otherwise the water quality has been good in above road link.
There are a few tributaries in the impact zone .. There is only one major krishna river in the
influence zone. There are no ponds, lakes (lentic water bodies) along the project road. To
facilitate the cross-drainage cross-drainage structures have been proposed including
improvements in the existing structures not to affect the existing drainage system in the
project implementation area. The surface water flow in the project area is predominantly from
the west to east.
The local community is using canal water from the Bhima river for their daily needs. Some of these
will be slightly impacted during the construction phase of project road. The general ground water
contours varies from 400 to 600 Mt above Mean Sea Level. Local community is dependant on the
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
hand pumps, tube wells and wells and those which will be impacted due to widening needs to be
relocated before the project starts. Number of water supply units likely affected is given in Table 2.4 ..
Table 21: Water supply units likely affected along the project area
Link
ID
Location
Hand
Pumps
Bore
WeDs
Water
cistern
Water
Taps
Water
Lines
OverHead
Tank/GL
Reservoir
Public
Toilet!
Manhole
13B
Devadurga - Masarkal 16
1
0
0
0
20
2
Gabbur - Kalmala
Contractor needs to keep a copy of the EA and EMP in the site office. Other than the construction
water issue, no major pollution points have been identified through out the length. No construction
waste shall be disposed .off in to the water bodies. The construction vehicles are prohibited from
entering the water bodies for any purpose (including for cleaning) other than the legitimate
requirements to avoid major pollution points due to oils and lubricants (POL) used in vehicles and
construction equipments.
It is very fundamental to conserve the water by way of constructing recharge pits wherever feasible
along the project road. These recharge pits harvest rainwater from road surface to improve the ground
water table. Refer Appendix -2 for typical drawing.
The construction water requirement could be an issue during construction at certain stretches of the
project road. As a part of the planning, contractor has to prepare construction water management plan
as per the guidelines provided in Appendix -15.
2.4
Land Environment
Most of the available stone material along the project area is basaltic trap, sand stone, shale, slate,
gneiss and granitic schist. These metals required for the road construction is available very close to
road enroute. Use of explosive is absolutely necessary to break open the aggregates in stone quarry. In
order to use these materials, contractor will have to establish a number of crushers along the 'project
route impact will be very large and permanent in nature (Chapter Environmental Impacts of EIA
report).
There will be exploitation of natural resources and it also reduces natural beauty of the landscape and
alters contours of the geographical region. There will be formation of deep and large depression from
the quarry operations. This will be fatal for both the animals and humans in case they fall in to deep
valley from surrounding habitat. Some times there is possibility of flying fragments of stones from
uncontrolled blasting using explosives surrounding to quarry area prevails .
. Suspended particulate matter leads to degeneration of plant species and retards the growth of plant
species as it reduces the transpiration process and also there will be considerable impact over the
occupational workers in the quarries. During monsoon there will be collection of water in deep ditches
this serves as breeding sites for mosquitoes.
Borrow material includes gravel, murrum and sand. Generally gravel is collected from the wasteland,
which is notified from Government or with the consent of farmers in case of farmland. Sand will be
collected from river valleys, altering the course of flow and velocity of flow of water in rivers.
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
Transport of the borrow materials to the construction sites is of significance, as almost all such areas
are accessible through dirt tracks. Spillage and compaction of soil along these tracks will be a
significant impact. Special transport facilities are required to transport bituminous material from the
refineries to work sites, as these require special measures to control accident spills, as this materials
are highly inflammable. Proper protection measures need to be worked out for the minimizing of such
impacts during the haulage of borrows materials. A major source of dust during the construction stage
is from stone crushing operations from the crushers and the vibrating screens. The dust, in addition
causes an eyesore, reduces visibility thereby increasing safety concerns. Rehabilitation of borrows
areas from which earth has been excavated, is a potential problem, which needs to be addressed and
need to comply with management plan Appendix - 17. In addition to visual light, safety issues shall
also be considered. The major sites that likely affected from the proposed road development are given
in Table 2.5.
Table 2-1: Major Borrow Material Regions along the route
13B
Appx. Depth,
D (m). >
Appx
Area,A,
Belo
> (Hec) Hillock w
EGL
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chaina
ge (Km)
LoctnlDistanc
e
QulA-12
Veeresh Stone
Metal Crusher &
Quarry
1+000
At a distance of
2.1 kmon LHS
10.0
25.0
QulA-13
Kappur Stone
Metal Quarry
2+700
At a distance of
2.2kmon LHS
5.0
3.5
Qu
lA-14
Gabbur Stone
Metal Quarry
27+000
At a distance of
0.5 krn on LHS
10.0
10.0
Type of
Materi
al
Granite
Gnesis
Pink
Granite
Gnesis
Granite
Gnesis
Murrum Locations:
Appx Appx. Depth,
D m)
Type of
Area,
A
Below Material
Hillock
(Ha)
EGL
Link
ID
Quar
ry
No.
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chaina
ge
(Km)
Location
13B
Mu
I-A
14
Road side
Murrum borrow
pit
31+00
8.52
3.82
Murram
Quarry
No.
13B
Su- 1-A-8
Su- 1-A-9
Name of the
Quarry/Source
Chainage
(Km)
0+000
28+200
LocationlDistance
7.6 Km from the project road
2.7 Km from the project road
Type of
materia
I
Sand
Sand
All borrow areas will be operated and redeveloped in accordance with the IRe 1O:1961.MoRTH and
applicableEMP clauses (Appendix - 17) as provided in the contract documents including EMP.
In addition to the above arrangements, contractor will have to establish dedicated environmentally
compatible crusher units to generate adequate sand and aggregates and effectively utilize the
excavated materials during construction.
Scott Wilson
2.4.1
The major land use in the project area is extensive agriculture and existence of settlements at locations
of village and small towns having active commercial and economic activity along the roadside. The
accurate surveys and accurate markings and negotiations will determine land use changes and finalize
the alignment to minimize acquisition procedure. Any additional land available must be put to use for
productive purposes. Mitigation related to land acquisition and resettlement will be undertaken as
specified in the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP).
2.4.1.1
During construction phase contractor's activity will go beyond building line. Even in secondary
construction sites like borrow areas, quarry sites and water resource points, the contractor's activity
will cross the limit depending upon the demand for material availability. These will create demand and
disturbance to the near by agricultural area, built up area etc. In case of any such issues it should be
cleared within shortest period. Potential community impact related to economy growth are closely
related to land acquisition, aesthetic and landscape considerations; noise, air quality, etc. Other than
the mitigation in these areas, no additional mitigation actions are warranted.
2.4.1.2
Immediately after the construction phase. It is necessary to ensure that no further deterioration or
major land use change such as ribbon development will take place.
2.5
Biological Environment
2.5.1
Flora
Total number of trees to be felled in the project area for the road expansion is presented in Table 2.6
Table 21 : List of Impacted Trees due to Proposed Project road
Link
ID
Link Description
Girth
Girth 30cm Girth 60cm Girth 90cm
to 180cm)
(>180cm)
t060cm)
to 90cm)
Total
313
223
225
1370
609
All trees of girth size more than 30 cm cut and removed will be accountable as per the Forest laws and
efforts will be maintained to plant two times the number of trees cut according to compensatory
afforestation guidelines.
There are no forested sections along the project road
The widening proposed in the non-forest locations will consume the productive agricultural
land, which has potential to grow crops. The increase in suspended particulate matter has
significant impact over the productivity of the crop during construction.
2.5.2
Fauna
There are no notified National parks and Wild life sanctuary identified within the boundary of 10 km
from the proposed road link. There are no endangered, critically endangered and threatened categories
of fauna in the near by vicinity of the project roads.
The common traffic - animal conflict or accidents by rash driving or break down of vehicles leads to
death of cattle and other domestic animals. These conflicts are minor in nature which can be resolved
with cash compensation pay to the owners. Some times there will be chemical spill or indiscriminate
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
disposal of bituminous materials in the area. These toxic foreign materials may enter surrounding
water bodies and prove detrimental to local fauna. It is necessary to comply with Hazardous Waste
material Handling Rules, 1989 to protect animals by consuming such contaminated water.
2.6
The socio economic environment has considered the land use changes, impacts to drinking water
sources, impact to land & properties and impact to cultural properties.
A variety of utilities serving the regional needs are currently within RoW. The categories of such
utilities are as follows Table 2.7
Electrical
Poles
266
Link Name
Oevadurga to Kalmala
Transformers
DP
Telephone Poles
19
The required mitigation measure would be to ask in advance the relevant owners of these utilities to
shift them before construction starts to avoid disruption of regional services. It is the PWO' s
responsibility to make the land available for construction free of all encumbrances.
Project has integrated several mitigation, avoidance and enhancement plans relating to socio
economic aspects that include provision for parking areas, bus bays, rain Shelters etc., in to the
engineering design to improve the quality of life in these areas.
2.6.1
Cultural properties
Link
ID
10
11
12
13
14
15
Total
13B
16
28
62
Codes of Community Assets: I.High School, 2.Primary School. 3.Temple, 4.Shrine, 5.Aralikatte,
6.Bus shelter, 7.Hand pump, B.MWS tank, 9. Samadhi, 1O.Anganwadi, 1l.Mosque, 12.Grazing land,
13.well, I4.Hospital,
15. Others: Basement, Bore well, Compound wall, Fence, Flag pole, Govt. Land, Public toilet, Pump
house, School toilet, Water tank, Water tap, Sign board, Grave yard, Statues, APMC check points.
2.6.1.2
Archaeological Structures
There are no notified archaeological properties identified along the project road
2.7
This section summarizes impact of proposed improvements on existing environment. Keeping in view
traffic density, human (ruraVurban) congestion, socio economic viability, environmental safety,
Chapter 2: Summary of Impacts
Scott Wilson
religious structures, obligatory points and other design parameters, options such as bypass,
realignment, formation and carriageway width have been given due consideration
Table 21: Summary of Environmental impacts and Issues
Impacts! Issues
Addressed in
Operation sta2e
After planting check
its survival rate
Addressed in Design
Addressed in Implementation
Slope
protection
measures
identified and incorporated in the
design and BoQ.
Maintenance of all
drainage
channels
clean and slopes
identified
for
protection.
Noise pollution
Water
best
equipments
and
Use
machineries for reducing noise at
construction sites. Follow all
procedures as per the legal norms.
Use PPE wherever necessary.
Siting of construction camps
away from sensitive receptors.
In acute water scarcity areas, the
use of potable water for dust
suppression should be reviewed
regularly.
Regular
water
Traffic
emissions
control as per the
legal requirements.
Regular air sampling
monitoring
and
operation
during
stage.
Monitor noise levels
periodically
to
understand
the
deviation from the
bench marks.
Tree removal
(flora)
Erosion
Debris disposal
Religious and
Archaeological
sites &
Properties
Demolition of
Retaining wall,
breast wall etc.,
close to
structures
especially
houses.
Air pollution
No action required
water
Monitor
quality parameters
periodically
to
understand
the
Scott Wilson
Impacts! Issues
Addressed in Design
EIAJEMP
documents
required at the
contractors
office
Aggregate and
sand
Borrow areas
Addressed in
Operation sta2e
sprinkling
required
for deviation from the
suppression of dust.
benchmarks.
During
implementation,
the Need to monitor
planned requirements will be ribbon
reviewed and implemented to the developments. All
construction
actual requirement. Reinstate new
work areas on completion of shall be sufficiently
away
from
the
works.
project road edge.
RAP implementation to involve Monitor and evaluate
the
an NGO to ensure that the (M&E)
effectiveness of RAP
policies are adhered to.
implementation.
Addressed in Implementation
safety,
Design has incorporated all Implement . a road
safety measures. Provide accidents and traffic management
safety barrier at bridge plan that has been prepared and
approaches, crash barriers at approved by the CSC. Display
cri tical
locations,
and road safety board in the camp
included all safety provisions with no of accidents till date and
in the BOQ for lining and the reason for the accidents.
signing.
Shall use during the phase. Must
Prepared during this phase
keep one copy of all relevant
EIAJEMP documents including
the Environmental clearance
documents at the contractor's
project site office under direct
control of the Project manager.
Use materials only from Use the excavated materials
legitimate sources adhering obtained during widening as far
to best practices. Obtain all as possible.
permissions and approvals
necessary.
In addition to the excavated Open and close borrow areas
materials, identified few according to the borrow area
more borrow areas for the management plan.
contractors use.
Construction scheduling has Contractor needs to take extra
by care during construction phase.
been
carried
out
experienced
specialist. Insurance shall be extended to all
Detailed
assessment
of labour force working at site to
bridges
and
culvert face any un avoidable or
capacities. Replace under accidental eventualities. Provide
sized and damaged bridges drainage during construction even
and
Culverts.
Provide for temporary divisions. Keep all
additional
culverts
and drainage channels cleared during
improve channels
all seasons.
No action required
Scott Wilson