Total Quality Management: A Continuous Improvement Process
Total Quality Management: A Continuous Improvement Process
Total Quality Management: A Continuous Improvement Process
A management style that focuses on customer satisfaction, the elimination of waste, and
continuous improvement
A method for upper management leadership to demonstrate its commitment to the new style of
management with the involvement of all employees
An understanding of how the new style of management applies to owners, designers, prime
contractors, specialty contractors, and suppliers
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
Recognizes that everyone in the organization has owners/customers who are either internal or
external
Views an organization as an internal system with a common aim rather than as individual
departments acting to maximize their own performances
Focuses on the way tasks are accomplished rather than simply what tasks are accomplished
TQM beliefs
Presented here are universal total quality management beliefs.
Analyzing the processes used to create products and services is key to quality improvement
Measurement, a skilled use of analytical tools, and employee involvement are critical sources of
quality improvement ideas and innovations
Sustained total quality management is not possible without active, visible, consistent, and
enabling leadership by managers at all levels
If we do not continuously improve the quality of products and services that we provide our
owners/customers, someone else will
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
The quality principles that successful TQM companies recognize and attempt to continually
incorporate into their actions are the following:
People will produce quality goods and services when the meaning of quality is expressed daily in
their relations with their work, colleagues, and organization.
Inspection of the process is as important as inspection of the product. Quality improvement can
be achieved by the workers closest to the process.
Each system with a certain degree of complexity has a probability of variation, which can be
understood by scientific methods.
Workers work in the system to improve the system; managers work on the system to improve the
system.
Total quality management is a strategic choice made by top management, and must be
consistently translated into guidelines provided to the whole organization.
Envision what you desire to be as an organization, but start working from where you actually are.
Studies have indicated that people like working on a quality-managed jobsite especially due to
the cleaner site and safer place to work.
Accept the responsibility for quality. Establish datums for measurement.
Use the principle of get it right, the first time, every time.
Understand that quality is a journey, not a destination. It consists of steps that form a process that
is continuous.
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
The goal of management is to create a culture of quality across the entire project site--get the job
done right, the first time, every time. As in the airline industry where 99-percent quality is not
good enough, the construction industry also needs to strive for 100-percent quality. Today, the
number of contractors being considered for projects by some owners is growing smaller, and
only those contractors who can produce quality work are being asked to bid by these owners.
Every effort to incorporate the above principles into the companys actions will further quality
production.
Management indicate
complete commitment
to Continuous
Improvement (CI)
Quality can only be achieved when management gives CI a high priority and a clear need.
Productivity in the construction industry is estimated to be, at best, 50 percent, with some sources
placing it at 35 percent, leaving room for improvement.
Identify stages
The objectives of continuous improvement are to reduce waste, reduce costs, and increase
productivity. The starting point is simple but radical. The work at any construction site can be
sliced into a series of stages. The stages can begin with groundbreaking and end with
completion. At each stage, a team goes to the jobsite and accomplishes its own work. When the
work is completed, it can be handed over to another crew or another contractor. This chain of
events can be identified as a process.
Establish responsibility
The next step is to establish responsibility for the work. If we define what each team does and
establish responsibility for who is to accomplish the task, we have defined a product and an
owner/customer. This is the heart of the matter with CI: to define the product and the
owner/customer. Each team or crew is responsible for providing a first-class product to its
owners/customers. The product must be supplied with no hassles, no concealed errors, and no
botched work.
CI goes well beyond the concept of quality assurance. Merely relying on a quality product is not
the only responsibility of management. Traditional quality assurance simply fixes the product;
however, it is not enough that supervisors simply accept or reject faulty work. CI maintains that
when something goes wrong, we must find the root cause of the error and correct that cause.
What CI means is the setting of a datum so everyone can evaluate his or her work or product by
measuring against the datum. CI then becomes everyone working together to improve the way
work is actually completed.
Pre-Plan
The chain actually starts before breaking ground for the building. It actually starts with an
owner/customer who wants the building. We must know what our owners/customers who are
going to use the building actually want. We can do this by doing a great deal of pre-planning.
The pre-planning involves creating a team that is capable of doing the project. We have to
ensure that the process used to analyze job segments is in place so we can make the right
decisions at the right time and that the flow of information needed to make decisions is in place.
A revolutionary idea here is that even the designer can become part of the process of CI from the
conceptual stage of the project.
We can learn something from each project when we regard each project as part of a cycle.
Each worker becomes his or her own quality inspector. In efforts to increase productivity and
lower costs, each worker becoming a quality inspector is vital.
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
Establish organizational
performance goals that will
provide a benchmark for
success.
Reward quality-focused
behavior.
Remove cold middle
management.
For Management
For Employee
Reducing rework to zero is achievable: Using quality management and CI to reduce rework to
nearly zero is an achievable goal. The negative cost of quality, which includes errors, delays,
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
rework, etc., is estimated to be 30 percent of the cost of construction. This figure does not include
dissatisfied owners/customers who do not come back for repeat business.
Positive results were obtained in accounts payable and invoicing. Time was wasted on invoices due
to errors from vendors. The results were that the contractor and vendors were paid promptly, thus
improving cash flow. A supplier now warehouses safety equipment for the company.
A General Contractor with a volume of $200M/yr. This company embarked upon the
implementation of the TQM process by hiring a consultant to work with a key person in the
company to start TQM. The objective of the process was to provide a more participative
management-oriented company. The process is customer-driven and the company has worked hard
to involve all employees. Task teams have been formed and are producing solutions to problems.
The company feels that a Continuous Improvement Process has been reached. The positive result
that has been obtained through TQM is that morale is much improved, helping the company to
weather a declining market.
A large General Contractor - volume over $500M/yr. This contractor is using TQM to improve
quality in daily work. The contractor has 80 teams trained and functioning, and a seven-step
problem solving technique to solve problems. All participants have been trained in group
dynamics.
A large General Contractor with a volume of $700M/yr. A quality circle program was initiated
nine years ago and has resulted in creating a company environment that is conducive to partnering.
The companys ability to conduct business using partnering has led to successful new contracts and
has
been
responsible
for
turning
poor
jobs
into
profitable
ones.
The key to the companys successful partnering process is the utilization of an outside facilitator (a
professional psychologist).
The facilitator conducts preconstruction sessions on how to
communicate with different personalities with varying styles of communication. Partnering has
enabled them to obtain significant new amounts of work.
Wal-Mart The expansion of Wal-Mart Stores has been successfully accomplished with the
application of the principles of TQM to their Design and Construction process. Wal-Mart could not
have expanded with their past system that allowed change orders to average $1.00/SF. They
brought in a designer who committed to them a team of design professionals, and equipment which
produce complete construction documents that are biddable and buildable. Decisions on design and
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
construction are now made at the lowest possible level. The result is that change orders were
reduced to less than $0.12/SF.
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
Bechtel TQM was started in 1987 and has recently been reorganized into CCI (an acronym for
Commitment to Continuous Improvement). The initiatives for their TQM process were obtained
from their customers by using a simple questionnaire. They use Baldrige criteria to measure
success in the CCI process. They do not seek the award, just the benefits of the process. Bechtels
facilitator has worked under the Deming philosophy for four years and has told top management
that he does not want to go back to the old way of doing business. Neither do their customers or
their employees.
Indianapolis Department of Public Works The Indianapolis Department of Public Works started
a TQM process that was modeled after the Florida Power and Light (Qualtec) process. All
department employees are involved (approximately 900 people). The process has recently been
updated to meet their needs. The result of their TQM process has improved employee morale.
Motorola Motorola has a successfully working TQM process. Motorolas fundamental objective
(everyones overriding responsibility) is Total Customer Satisfaction. They have won the Baldrige
award and are corporate leaders in TQM. They will tell you that implementing TQM was a sound
business decision and a matter of survival for them. Similar cases are available from other large
corporations. They require a working TQM process of all contractors doing work for them.
Rogers-OBrien Construction Co. - volume of $30M/yr. This Dallas-based contractor started a
TQM process due to exposure to Texas Instruments TQM process. Texas Instruments is their
major client. Rogers-OBrien feels that TQM has been largely responsible for reducing overall
rework expenditures from approximately 7 percent to approximately 1.5 percent of construction
costs.
Built-Rite The Built-Rite way is an example of labor-management cooperation using the principles
of TQM. Built-Rite is managed by the Philadelphia Area Labor-Management Committee (PALM).
PALM is an alliance of construction users, contractors, and building craftspersons who are
committed to labor-management teamwork at the jobsite. In the past five years, over $6 billion in
construction projects has been completed without any work stoppages.
Successful companies who have received the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality award
The Malcolm Baldrige National Quality award was established by an act of Congress in 1987. In
several ways, it is modeled after the Deming Prize of Japan. The award is jointly administered by
the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and the American Society for Quality
Control (ASQC).
The 1992 Award Criteria stipulate that awards are presented annually to recognize those US
companies that excel in quality management and quality achievement. Up to two awards may be
presented in each of three eligibility categories of manufacturing companies, service companies,
and small business firms.
Past award recipients are
1991
1990
Marlow Industries
Solectron Corporation
Zytec Corporation
Cadillac Motor Car Company
IBM Rochester
Federal Express Corporation
Wallace Co., Inc.
1989
1988
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
However, with total commitment and constancy of purpose, these hazards can be overcome.
Misconceptions regarding the implementation of the continuous improvement process
Common misconceptions which appear at the beginning of the following paragraphs are
discussed.
Every site is different -- A common mistaken notion about TQM is that it does not readily apply to
construction because every site is different, and that construction is a one-time-only industry.
This notion is not true, because the plain fact is that wherever you work, the processes are the
same, and so are the methods and techniques.
Errors and delays are different -- Some maintain that errors and delays can be controlled on a
large job [versus a small job]; however, this is not true. Errors and delays are the same on large
and small projects, and they have the same negative effects. One example involves a concrete
project with the improper placement of anchor bolts. Improper placement of anchor bolts results
in a delay in erecting the structural steel. Someone has to pay for this delay that will affect
everyone at the jobsite, whether it is a large jobsite or a small jobsite.
It is a typical jobsite problem -- One might be tempted to say that the delay in the above example
is no big deal, that it is a typical jobsite problem, but that is precisely the point: Typical problems
must be eradicated at jobsites.
It costs too much -- The cost of implementing quality results from (1) training and (2) the cost
associated with transforming a company into the quality mode to follow common ideas and goals.
The profits incurred for implementing a continuous improvement process far outweigh the profits
gained while not using a continuous improvement process.
Its time to get started on Continuous Improvement.
Your competitors may have already started.
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
10
Continuous Improvement
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
11
1
2
Element
Number
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Total Quality Management, by Marshall Sashkin and Kenneth J. Kiser, 1991, Ducochon Press.
Upon completion of upper managements commitment and training, a steering committee must
be created to guide the company through the process of implementing TQM. The role of the
steering committee and the processes the committee follows are listed here.
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
12
Appoint task process improvement teams and ensure they receive proper training.
Owner/customer Satisfaction
Improved Safety
Elimination of errors and defects
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
13
Sample Vision
Statements
Brown + Root
We will consider ourselves successful when we are the preferred
provider of project services and the favored employer in our
industry, and when all of our businesses produce financial results
superior to those of their leading competitors.
Sample Mission
Statements
Sample Guiding
Principles
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
14
be met for the company to continue to exist and serve the needs
of its clients and employees.
A mechanical contracting firm created the TQM flow diagram illustrated in the figure below to
implement quality processes within the company.
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
15
Degree of communications
Accident experience
Planning
Attitude
Administrative procedures
Timeliness
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
16
12. Overall, how would you rate the appearance of our facilities, products, communications, and
people?
13. Can you list any specific instances where we have fallen down?
14. Overall, how would you rate the quality of our service?
15. What could we do to improve our service to you?
16. Overall, how would you rate the quality of service provided by our competitor?
17. How willing would you be to recommend us?
18. How willing would you be to buy from us again?
19. Are we doing or not doing anything that bugs you?
20. What do you like best about what we do?
21. What parts of our service are most important for you?
22. What parts of our service are least important to you?
Many of these questions are from LeBoufs, How to Win Owners/Customers and Keep Them for
Life.
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
17
In order to conduct an analysis of the internal processes within the company, the following steps
should be applied to the internal processes within a company.
Choose one of these owners/customers to focus on for the application of this technique
Determine the Outputs (products, services, information) that must be provided to this internal
owner/customer
Determine the work Processes your company uses to produce these Outputs
Learn how your customers expectations are met and how satisfaction is measured
Upper Management
Remaining Management
Front-Line Supervisors
Non-Supervisory Employees
Team Training
Suppliers
Continuous Training
To train employees in the order presented above, the following is recommended.
Areas of Training
Topics to cover
A, B, C
Management
Training
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
18
owner/customer concept
Steps in implementing TQM
Structure needed, i.e., steering committee, process
improvement teams, facilitator(s), trainer(s), possibly a
corporate coordinator
Principles of team building
Formalized process improvement
understanding variation
measurement what, why, how
the seven tools of quality
quality improvement teams
Owner/customer and employee surveys
Employee empowerment
Malcolm Baldrige Award criteria
D
Front-Line
Supervision
Training
E
Training of NonSupervisory
Employees
F
Team Training
Training of
Subcontractors and
Suppliers
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
19
Informed Employees
Technical Training
Quality Training
Employee Suggestions
Employee Participation
Personal Development
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
20
The quality improvement team (QIT) is responsible for planning and managing the TQM
implementation process for the organization. The QIT is responsible for making TQM happen.
The QIT must take the lead in managing the cultural changes that TQM will require.
At least one member of the Senior Management Team (SMT) should be a member of the QIT.
The QIT reports to the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) and the SMT.
The QIT and SMT should hold a joint meeting to review the TQM effort at least quarterly.
Quality improvement team structure is . . .
A quality improvement team (QIT) meets on a regular basis. During the first months of the
TQM effort, the QIT will probably wish to meet once per week for 3 to 5 hours. In addition,
QIT members will spend an additional 6 to 10 hours per week on training, education, and QIT
assignments. After the TQM implementation plan is complete and underway, the QIT should
meet once or twice per month.
The QIT determines and defines the duties of each QIT member. Typical positions for members
are TQM Director or Coordinator; Communications, Education, and Training Coordinator;
Quality Measurement; Customer Satisfaction; and Employee Involvement and Satisfaction. The
types of quality improvement teams are permanent, temporary, preparation, planning, and
implementation. Facilitators hold an extremely important role in the success of implementation.
In the order presented here, the QIT plans the ongoing TQM education for: (1) QIT and SMT
members, (2) facilitators and supervisors, and (3) all employees.
The QIT reviews, approves and helps implement quality improvement plans, establishes the
TQM organizational structure and team structure for the company, procures (from management)
and manages the resources required for TQM implementation, solicits and evaluates Quality
Improvement Opportunities (QIOs), selects and commissions teams to work on QIOs, and
proffers rewards and recognition.
The permanent teams of the quality improvement process are based on the following areas of
concern:
TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT: A CONTINUOUS
1996 PHCC EDUCATIONAL FOUNDATION
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
21
The facilitators of the quality improvement process should retain the following characteristics:
Qualities of a good facilitator:
Is respected by people at all levels of the organization
Is organized
Is a good listener and communicator
Understands TQM principles and philosophies
Is objective and open-minded
Is a team player, one who likes to accomplish things
through others
TIME
LOCATION
SCHEDULE
STEERING
COMMITTEE
It must oversee and nurture, not drive, the program. An analogy to this
is how do you bring up your children to be confident, respected and
healthy, and to eventually become independent and make wise
decisions.
UNIONS
PATIENCE
VOLUNTEER
ADVERTISE
TRACKING
Some form of tracking is required but can become another paper mill
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
22
LOYALTY
TRAINING
10
Employee involvement
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
23
Process Improvement
Suggested areas where quality improvement could begin are presented below.
Administrative
Project Management
and Engineering
Payroll
Invoices
Personnel
actions
Investme
nts
Insurance
Marketin
g
Training
(safety, quality,
technical)
Subcontracts
Partial
payment requests
Progress
review meetings
Estimating
Scheduling
Interfacing
with
architect/engineer
Shop drawing
review
Survey and
layout
Testing
11
Logistical
sing
ance
Construction
Storage
Layout
Warehou
Rough
grading
Delivery
Forming
Mainten
Placing
concrete
Placing
reinforcing
Erecting
precast panels
Framing
drywall
Pulling
electrical cable
Hanging
ductwork
Seven classical tools of quality and process improvement, plus one, are presented below.
Tool
Flowchart
Cause and Effect
Diagram
Control Chart
Histogram
Check Sheet
Pareto Diagram
Scatter Diagram
Run Chart
Use
Portrays all the steps in a process. Helps understand the
process.
Portrays possible causes of a process problem. Helps
determine root cause.
Shows if a process has too much variation.
Portrays the frequency of occurrence.
Tabulates frequency of occurrence.
Visually portrays problems and causes in order of severity
or frequency. Helps determine which problem or cause to
tackle first.
Helps determine if two variables are related.
Shows variation and trends with time. Provides baseline
data, and helps to determine if a process is improving or
not.
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
24
Top-Down Flowchart
Simple, easy-to-construct charts that
emphasize the major steps of a
process. First, list the most basic steps
in a process or project. Then, below
each one, list the major substeps.
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
25
Detailed Flowchart
Describe most or all of the steps in a
process, with varying levels of detail.
When needed, have the team as a
whole develop a top-down version,
then have smaller groups add levels of
detail.
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
26
Control charts are time plots that also indicate the range of variation built into the system. They
are used to monitor a process to see whether it is in statistical control.
A histogram is a bar graph of a frequency distribution in which the widths of the bars are
proportional to the classes into which the variable has been divided and the heights of the bars
are proportional to the class frequencies.
Checksheets are structured forms that make it easy to record and analyze data. The best
checksheets are simple to use, make use of your operational definitions, and visually display the
data to reveal underlying patterns.
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
27
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
28
12
Cost of Nonconformance
Cost Prevention
Rework
Recalls
Expediting
Removal of punch list items
Time extensions
Litigation costs and damages
Penalties and liquidated damages
Increased insurance costs
Accidents
Omissions
Errors
Poor Product Quality
Being Late
Lead us to
Areas where savings can be derived by making improvements are noted here.
Rework/revisions
Write-offs
Complaint resolution
Unbilled charges
Insurance premiums/coverage
Overdue receivables
Remove/replace
Claim defense
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
Ineffective interdisciplinary
coordination
Ineffective trade
coordination
29
Invoice errors
Call-backs
Disputed invoices
Unpaid invoices
Unrecorded time
Unpaid time
Summary
The highly competitive economic conditions that exist in todays construction industry require
that construction companies seek to achieve excellence to remain competitive. This excellence
can be achieved with a new style of management that focuses on customer satisfaction, the
elimination of waste, continuous improvement, and employee involvement.
To be competitive in todays market, it is essential for construction companies to provide more
consistent quality and value to their owners/customers. Now is the time to place behind us the
old adversarial approach to managing construction work. It is time to develop better and more
direct relationships with our owners/customers, to initiate more teamwork at the jobsite, and to
produce better quality work.
Such goals demand that a continuous improvement (CI) process be established within the
company in order to provide quality management.
Meeting owner/customer requirements (providing customer satisfaction) is a primary objective
of quality management, and contractors who are the suppliers of construction services must
address owner/customer requirements if they are to succeed. The construction industry exists to
provide a service to its owners/customers who are becoming more demanding and are seeking
higher quality, better value, and lower costs. These owner/customer requirements mirror the
economic pressures they face in their own businesses. Implementing total quality management /
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
30
IMPROVEMENT PROCESS
31