Spaghetti Syndrome
Spaghetti Syndrome
Spaghetti Syndrome
Managing Spaghetti
Syndrome in Critical Care
With a Novel Device:
A Nursing Perspective
Jay Haynes, MD
Kelly Bowers, MPH
Richard Young, MD
Trudy Sanders, PhD
Karen E. Schultz, MPH
Background Managing spaghetti syndrome, the tangle of therapeutic cables, tubes, and cords at
patients bedsides, can be challenging.
Objectives To assess nurses perceptions of the effectiveness of a novel banding device in management of
spaghetti syndrome.
Methods A simple color-coded elastomeric banding strap with ribbed flaps was attached to bed rails of
adult critical care patients to help organize therapeutic cables, tubes, wires, and cords. Nurses were surveyed before and after use of the bands and after the nursing shift to assess the burden of spaghetti syndrome and the effectiveness of using the bands.
Results Use of the bands decreased the time spent untangling cords, reduced the frequency of contact of
tubing with the floor, and diminished disruptions in care.
Conclusions Use of a simple flexible latex-free elastomeric band may help organize therapeutic tubing at
patients bedsides and may promote improvements in nursing care. (Critical Care Nurse. 2015;35[6]:38-45)
ritical care patients often have numerous therapeutic connections (eg, cords, cables, and tubes)
at the bedside that can easily become disorganized and tangled, leading to contamination of the
connections, nurses confusion, a physical hazard that increases the risk for falls for both nurses
and patients, and the possibility of damage of medical devices.1-6 This phenomenon, known as spaghetti
syndrome, makes caring for patients challenging and difficult1,2 (Figure 1). Multiple instances of patients
deaths, permanent injury, and life-threatening situations related to entanglement with the cords of medical devices have been reported.5,7-14 Ensuring the organization of cords and tubes at a patients bedside
may reduce adverse outcomes such as entanglement of the patient, backflow in tubing, falls by both
patients and health care personnel, and connection errors or damage of medical equipment.5-7,12
38
CriticalCareNurse
Haynes12_15pgs.indd 38
www.ccnonline.org
11/9/15 5:07 PM
Before
After
Figure 1 Managing spaghetti syndrome: flexible sleeved-strap banding devices are used to secure therapeutic tubing, wires,
and cords, keeping them off the floor and organized in a manageable state.
Therapeutic tubing, cables, wires, and cords are a fundamental aspect of daily health care for delivery of medications and fluids to patients. The often disorganized
tubing and cords at the bedside increase the possibility of
inadvertently connecting the wrong syringes and tubing
and then unintentionally delivering medication or fluids
via the wrong route. In 2006, the Joint Commission issued
Authors
Jay Haynes is the senior medical director for health and wellness,
JPS Health Network, John Peter Smith Hospital, Department of
Family Medicine, and an adjunct assistant professor, Department
of Medical Education, University of North Texas Health Science
Center, Fort Worth, Texas.
Kelly Bowers is a biostatistician, Department of Biostatistics and
Epidemiology, University of North Texas Health Science Center.
Richard Young is director of research and associate program director, family medicine residency program, JPS Health Network, and
a clinical associate professor of family medicine, University of
Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, Texas.
Trudy Sanders is the vice president of patient care services, JPS
Health Network.
Karen E. Schultz is a research assistant and epidemiologist in
Dallas/Fort Worth, Texas.
Corresponding author: Jay Haynes, MD, MSc, Senior Medical Director, JPS Health
and Wellness, Department of Family Medicine, John Peter Smith Hospital, JPS
Health Network, 1350 S Main St, Ste 1250, Fort Worth, TX 76104 (e-mail:
jhaynes@jpshealth.org).
To purchase electronic or print reprints, contact the American Association of CriticalCare Nurses, 101 Columbia, Aliso Viejo, CA 92656. Phone, (800) 899-1712 or
(949) 362-2050 (ext 532); fax, (949) 362-2049; e-mail, reprints@aacn.org.
www.ccnonline.org
Haynes12_15pgs.indd 39
alerts on tubing misconnections; interventions and procedures to manage and protect medical cords, tubes, and
cables as a standard of care, but only a few devices are
available to aid in this task.11,13,15
Few bedside devices for cord control are commercially available, and they vary in complexity and design.
The purpose of this study was to test use of a novel simple, sleeved-strap banding device in the management of
spaghetti syndrome in a critical care unit and to assess
nurses responses to use of the band. Before the study,
no devices or standard protocols were being used to
manage the syndrome.
Methods
After a comparison of commercially available products, a novel sleeved-strap band crafted from elastomeric
latex-free material (JanaBand, JMC Global Technologies)
was chosen for the study. This device was selected because
of its relative value, flexibility, and ease of application
(Table 1, Figures 1 and 2). The color-coded sleeved banding devices were donated for the study by their creator
and manufacturer, JMC Global Technologies, Keller, Texas.
In tests of the effectiveness of the device in an inpatient setting, 2 colors (red and blue) were used to distinguish between afferent tubing carrying medications or
fluids into the patient and efferent tubing removing fluids
from the patient or holding wires and cables (Figure 2).
CriticalCareNurse
39
11/9/15 5:07 PM
Table 1
Feature
Comparison devices
Cost
Design
Clasp: securing holes are the same size and accommodate 3-4 tubes, cords, and/or wires, prefitted
Material
Attachment
Afferent
Efferent
Figure 2 The JanaBand strap device system (JMC Global Technologies, Keller, Texas).
40
CriticalCareNurse
Haynes12_15pgs.indd 40
www.ccnonline.org
11/17/15 9:54 AM
www.ccnonline.org
Haynes12_15pgs.indd 41
Results
Before Use of the Bands
A total of 43 surveys (58%) were collected before use
of the bands. The results suggested that nurses were concerned about the management of spaghetti syndrome
in the critical care unit (Tables 2-4). All 43 respondents
acknowledged that a system for organizing therapeutic
CriticalCareNurse
41
11/9/15 5:07 PM
Table 2
Survey questions and responses before and after use of strap band device: agree vs disagree questions
Agree
Disagree
Agree
Disagree
44%
(n = 19)
56%
(n = 24)
80%
(n = 24)
20%
(n = 6)
.04
37%
(n = 16)
63%
(n = 27)
77%
(n = 23)
23%
(n = 7)
.007
91%
(n = 39)
9%
(n = 4)
37%
(n = 11)
63%
(n = 19)
<.001
98%
(n = 42)
2%
(n = 1)
69%
(n = 21)
31%
(n = 9)
.005
100%
(n = 43)
0%
(n = 0)
70%
(n = 21)
30%
(n = 9)
<.001
84%
(n = 36)
16%
(n = 7)
63%
(n = 19)
37%
(n = 11)
.08
98%
(n = 42)
2%
(n = 1)
73%
(n = 22)
27%
(n = 8)
.53
After question
Cords, tubes, and cables are well organized around the patients bed.
When the strap band device was on a patients bed, the cords,
tubes, and cables were well organized.
Our hospital has an effective solution for organizing bedside
cords, tubes, and cables.
Compared with our hospitals current method for organizing bedside cords, tubes, and cables, using the strap band device could
be an effective solution.
Patient bedside cords, tubes, and cables are often on the floor.
When the strap band device was used, patient bedside cords,
tubes, and cables often fell on the floor.
A system for bedside organization of cords, tubes, and cables
would provide a comfortable and calming environment for the
patient and the patients family.
Using the strap band device as a system for organizing therapeutic tubing provided a comfortable and calming environment for
patients and their families compared with not using a banding
device.
A consistent system for the organization of cords, tubes, and
cables would lead to improved efficiency for patient bedside care.
Using the strap band device system for the organization of cords,
tubes, and cables would lead to improved working conditions
during administration of patient bedside care.
At shift change, I have to spend time reorganizing patients cords,
tubes, and cables.
When strap band devices were being used, I had to spend less
time at shift change reorganizing patients cords, tubes, and cables.
An organized, clean, and calm bedside environment contributes
to a valuable health care experience.
The strap band devices helped create a more organized, clean,
and calm bedside environment and helped to contribute to a
better health care experience.
42
CriticalCareNurse
Haynes12_15pgs.indd 42
www.ccnonline.org
11/9/15 5:07 PM
Table 3
Survey questions and responses before and after use of a strap band device: how likely questionsa
Question
How likely do you think it is that the tubing, wires,
and cables may become tangled at the bedside?b
Extremely likely
Very likely
Somewhat likely
Not very likely
Not at all likely
P
.03
44% (n = 19)
37% (n = 16)
12% (n = 5)
7% (n = 3)
0% (n = 0)
10% (n = 3)
17% (n = 5)
26% (n = 8)
47% (n = 14)
0% (n = 0)
<.001
23% (n = 10)
37% (n = 16)
21% (n = 9)
19% (n = 9)
0% (n = 0)
3% (n = 1)
7% (n = 2)
30% (n = 9)
53% (n = 16)
7% (n = 2)
<.001
67% (n = 29)
26% (n = 11)
7% (n = 3)
0% (n = 0)
0% (n = 0)
6% (n = 2)
6% (n = 2)
47% (n = 14)
40% (n = 12)
0% (n = 0)
The categories extremely likely, very likely, and somewhat likely were combined to make a category, and the categories not very likely and not at all likely were combined to make a category for the statistical analysis.
Percentage of group
Question
Banding device used
Yes
No
Total
sample
(N = 404)
55
45
53
17
15
15
Statistically significant difference (P < .05) between the group that used the
banding device and the group that did not.
www.ccnonline.org
Haynes12_15pgs.indd 43
Discussion
Introduction of a new process in health care usually meets some resistance and questioning. The results
CriticalCareNurse
43
11/9/15 5:07 PM
Limitations
Although the banding device was initially tested
in several small internal pilot studies, with favorable
results, the findings in this larger study are limited
because the data are from a single critical care unit and
44
CriticalCareNurse
Haynes12_15pgs.indd 44
Conclusion
Our findings indicate that a simple flexible sleevedstrap banding device can be used in the intensive care
unit to organize therapeutic tubing, cables, and wires at
patients bedsides and that use of the device may promote improvements in nursing care.
www.ccnonline.org
11/9/15 5:07 PM
8. World Health Organization. Avoiding catheter and tubing mis-connections. Patient Safety Solutions. Vol. 1. Solution 7. http://www
.who.int/patientsafety/solutions/patientsafety/PS-Solution7.pdf. Published May 2007. Accessed August 26, 2015.
9. Sullivan C. IV tubing poses strangulation hazard, hospitals warned.
CMAJ. 2002;167(5):529.
10. Guenter P, Hicks R, Simmons D, et al. Enteral feeding misconnections: a
consortium position statement. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf. 2008;34(5):
285-292, 245.
11. Joint Commission. Tubing misconnectionsa persistent and potentially
deadly occurrence. http://www.jointcommission.org/assets/1/18/SEA
_36.PDF. Sentinel Event Alert, Issue 36. Published April 3, 2006. Accessed
September 1, 2015.
12. Goodin HJ, Ryan-Wenger NA, Mullet J. Pediatric medical line safety:
the prevalence and severity of medical line entanglements. J Pediatr Nurs.
2012;27(6):725-733.
13 Clark C. TJC warns hospitals of deadly medical tubing mistakes. Health
Leaders Media, August 22, 2014. http://www.healthleadersmedia.com
/page-4/FIN-307729/TJC-Warns-Hospitals-of-Deadly-Medical-Tubing
-Mistakes. Accessed August 25, 2015.
14. Garros D, King WJ, Brady-Fryer B, Klassen TP. Strangulation with
intravenous tubing: a previously undescribed adverse advent in children. Pediatrics. 2003;111(6, pt 1):732-734.
15. Sentinel Event Alert 53: Managing risk during transition to new ISO
tubing connector standards. Published August 20, 2014. http://www
.jointcommission.org/sea_issue_53/. Accessed September 10, 2015.
16. Ofek E, Pizov R. From a radial operating table to a self-contained operating
table. Anaesthesia. 2006;61(6):548-552.
17. Wallin M, Wajntraub S. Evaluation of Bluetooth as a replacement for
cables in intensive care and surgery. Anesth Analg. 2004;98(3):763-767.
Acknowledgments
The authors thank the Tarrant County Hospital District, Fort Worth, Texas,
nursing staff and administration, Gary Floyd, MD, Josephine Fowler, MD, Dan
Casey, MD, Mark Oltermann, MD, and Daniel Ziegler, MD, for their essential
help and guidance.
Financial Disclosures
None reported.
Now that youve read the article, create or contribute to an online discussion about
this topic using eLetters. Just visit www.ccnonline.org and select the article you want
to comment on. In the full-text or PDF view of the article, click Responses in the
middle column and then Submit a response.
d tmore
www.ccnonline.org
Haynes12_15pgs.indd 45
CriticalCareNurse
45
11/9/15 5:07 PM