Reaction Mechanism D
Reaction Mechanism D
Reaction Mechanism D
Session - 2009-10
ORGANIC CHEMISTRY
TOPIC :
REACTION MECHANISM
CONTENTS
1
2.
3.
:
Nucleophile
Leaving Group
Nucleophilic substitution (SN1) of RX. ROH, ROR
NUCLEOPHILE : It is the e rich species having atleast one lone pair of electrons. It can be neutral
or vely charged it is always a lewis base.
BASICITY : It is the tendency to donate e pair to
ion.
All bases are nucleophiles, but all nucleophlies are not base all the time.
(i)
(ii)
1.1
NUCLEOPHILICITY :
The tendency to give e pair to an electron deficient carbon atom is defined as nucleophilicity.
(i) Criteria for Nucleophilicity :
1.
The factors which increases e density at donor atom increases nucleophilicity.
2.
The more polarisable donar atom is a better nucleophile. Therefore, large size of donor atom
increases nucleophilicity.
(ii) Periodicity :
Nucleophilicity decreases from left to right in a period.
In a group, nucleophilicity increases from top to bottom due to increases in size of donor atom, but
basicity decreases from top to bottom.
Acid strength : HI > HBr > HCl > HF
Basic strength : F > Cl > Br > I
Nucleophilicity : F < Cl < Br < I
(iii) Steric effects on nucleophilicity
>
>
Page # 2
This effect is related to the strength of the interaction between nucleophile and solvent molecules of polar
protic solvent forms hydrogen bond to nucleophiles in the following manner :
(vi)
>
>
>
>
>
> H2 O
Comparative chart
Nucleophilicity
Basicity
Remarks
1.
2.
3.
In a group nucleophilicity
increases while basicity
decreases. on moving top to
bottom.
4.
OH < SH
OH > SH
,,
5.
RO < RS
RO > RS
,,
6.
RO > HO
Same
7.
Same
,,
Same
,,
8.
>
HO > H2O
NH2 > NH3
Same
Page # 3
>
>
>
2.
3.
SH > OH
4.
>
Page # 4
2.1.
Types of solvents
(a) Non polar
(b) Polar (These solvents are of two type - polar protic and polar aprotic)
Solvents
Polar
Protic
Aprotic
1.
H2O
2.
CH3OH
3.
CH3CH2OH
4.
HCOOH
5.
CH3COOH
6.
NH3
7.
8.
9.
DMF
Dimethyl formamide
10.
DMA
Dimethyl acetamide
11.
12.
13.
CCCCCC
Page # 5
3.1
Kinetics:
Rate [Alkyl halide]
# It is unimolecular, two step process.
# It is first order reaction.
# Rate of SN1 reaction is independent of the concentration and reactivity of nucleophile.
+
H
R OH + HX
R O H
H
(iv) Effect of the solvent : the ionizing ability of the solvent :
Because to solvate cations and anions so effectively the use of a polar protic solvent will greatly
increase the rate of ionization of an alkyl halide in any SN1 reaction. It does this because solvation
stabilizes the transition state leading to the intermediate carbocation and halide ion more than it does
the reactant, thus the energy of activation is lower.
OH2
R X + H2O R+
R X
(Solvolysis)
Solvated ions
(v) The nature of the leaving group In the SN1 reaction the leaving group begins to acquire a negative
charge as the transition state is reached stabilisation of this developing negative charge at the leaving
group stabilizes the transition state and ; this lowers the free energy of activation and thereby increases
the rate of reaction.
leaving ability of halogen is
>
>
> >
Examples :
1.
2.
3.
H2 O acetone
H O / Ag
CH OH / Ag
+ HBr
+ AgI
(carbocation rearrangement)
Page # 7
4.
5.
S 1
+
F
N
R X + AgF
R F + AgX ppt + (R OH + ROC2H5 minor products)
R
Note : Only AgF is soluble among all silver halides
To prepare alkyl flouride
7.
Br2 / h
AgF / H2 O
H O acetone
H shift
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
MeOH / Ag
Page # 8
13.
Q.1
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Sol.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Q.2
Predict the compound in each pair that will undergo solvolysis (in aqueous ethanol) more rapidly.
Sol.
(a) II > I
(d) II > I
Q.3
Ans.
(b) II > I
(e) II > I
(c) I > II
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
A>B>D>C
Page # 9
SN1
( - Prime)
The substitution of alkylic system under SN1 conditions proceeds with rearrangement.
X
RCH=CHCH2X R CH=CH C H2
R C H CH=CH2
RCH=CHCH2Y
3.2
(A)
and
ions.
(iii) Concentrated hydrobromic acid rapidly converts t-Butyl alcohol to t-Butyl bromide. The strong acid
protonates the hydroxyl group, converting it to a good leaving group. The hindered tertiary carbon
atom cannot undergo SN2 displacement, but it can ionise to a tertiary carbocation. Attack by
bromide ion gives the alkyl bromide. The mechanism is similar to other SN1 mechanism.
(iv) 1-Butanol reacts with sodium bromide in concentrated sulfuric acid to give 1-Bromobutane by an SN2
displacement.
NaBr, H SO
2
4
Protonation converts the hydroxy group to a good leaving group, but ionization to a primary carbocation
is unfavourable. The protonated unbranched primary alcohol is well suited for the SN2 displacement.
(v) Secondary alcohols also react with HBr to form alkyl bromides usually by the SN1 mechanism.
e.g.
HBr
(vi) HCl (Hydrochloric acid) reacts with alcohols in much the same way that as the hydrobromic acid.
(vii) Chloride ion is a weaker nucleophlile than bromide ion because it is smaller and less polarizable.
Lewis acid, such as ZnCl2, is sometimes necessary to promote the reaction of HCl with primary and
secondary alcohols.
Lucas Reagent
(i) A mixture of concentrated hydrochloric acid and anhydrous zinc chloride is called the Lucas reagent.
(ii) Whether an alcohol is primary, secondary or tertiary i.e. identify by the Lucas test, which is based
upon the difference in reactivity of the three classes of alcohol towards hydrogen halides.
(iii) Alcohol (of not more than six carbons in their molecule) are soluble in the Lucas reagent. The
corresponding alkyl chlorides are insoluble.
Page # 10
(iv) Formation of a chloride from an alcohol is indicated by the cloudiness that appears when the chloride
separates from the solution hence, the time required for cloudiness to appear is a measure of the
reactivity of the alcohol.
(v) A tertiary alcohol reacts immediately with the Lucas reagent, a secondary alcohol reacts within five
minutes and a primary alcohol does not react appreciably at room temperature.
e.g.
Mechanism :
R OH
e.g.
e.g.
Reactivity of
HX :
Reactivity of
ROH :
CH3 CHCH3
|
OH
Isopropyl alcohol
CH3
|
CH3 C CH2 OH
|
CH3
R O H2 R
H2O
R X
CH3 CHCH3
|
Br
Isopropyl bromide
CH3
|
CH3 C CH2 CH3
|
Br
Example :
Ex.1
Ex.2
Page # 11
Ex.3
CH3 CH = CH CH2OH
HBr
Ex.4
HI
Ex.5
Ex.6
Why is ZnCl2 (Lewis acid) required with HCl in its reaction with 1 and 2 alcohol. Where as reaction with HBr
proceeds without any Lewis acid.
Sol.
Because the chloride ion is a weaker nucleophile than bromide or iodide ions. HCl does not react with 1 or
2 alcohols unless zinc chloride or some similar Lewis acid is added to the reaction mixture as well. ZnCl2
is a good Lewis acid, forms a complex with alcohol through association with an unshared pair of electrons on
the oxygen atom. This provides a better leaving group for the reaction than H2O.
Ex.7
Ans.
(a) II > I
3.3
(A)
Reaction with HX
(b) II > I
(c) II > I
Ethers are unreactive towards most bases, but they can react under acidic conditions. A protonated
ether can undergo substitution or elimination with the expulsion of an alcohol. Ethers react with conc.
HBr and HI because these reagents are sufficiently acidic to protonate the ether, while bromide iodide
Page # 12
X
(3) R` X
ROH
e.g.
HCl
(CH3)3COC(CH3)3 (CH3 )3 C O C(CH3 )3
|
H
(CH3 )3 C
+ (CH3)3COH
(CH3)3CCl
HBr (1eq.)
e.g.
HBr (1eq.)
e.g.
(B)
H3O
ROR`
ROH + R`OH
H
ROR`
e.g.
H O
e.g.
H O
Page # 13
LECTURE NOTES
Session - 2009-10
ORGANIC CHEMISTRY
TOPIC :
REACTION MECHANISM
CONTENTS
4.
5.
6.
7.
:
Nucleophilic substitution (SN2) /RX. ROH, ROR
Elimination Reaction (E1)/ RX. ROH, ROR
Elimination Reaction (E2)/ RX. ROH, ROR
Elimination Reaction (E1cB)
# No intermediates are formed in the SN2 reaction, the reaction proceeds through the formation of
an unstable arrangment of atoms or group called transition state.
Kinetics :
rate [alkyl halide] [nucleophile]
rate = k[alkyl halide] [nucleophile]
# It is bimolecular, one step concerted process
# It is second order reaction because in the RDS both species are involved
Inversion
A stronger nucleophile attacks upon -carbon with faster rate than the rate of departing of leaving
group.
R > NH2 > OH > F
RO > ROH
NaOH > H2O
NH3 > H2O
Table :
(iii) The effect of the solvent: Polar aprotic solvent have crowded positive centre, so they do not solvate
the anion appreciably therefore the rate of SN2 reactions increased when they are carried out in polar
aprotic solvent.
(iv) The nature of the leaving group Weaker bases are good leaving groups. A good leaving group always
stabilize the transition state and lowers its free energy of activation and thereby increases the rate of
the reaction. Order of leaving ability of halide ion F < Cl < Br < I
Examples :
aq.KOH
Ex.1
CH3Cl
Ex.2
KOH DMSO
CH3CHCl
CH3CH2OH + Cl
Ex.3
NaOH DMF
CH3CH2CH2Br
CH3CH2CH2OH + Br
Ex.4
(CH3)2CHCH2CH2 OH
(CH3)2CHCH2CH2 Br
Ex.5
MeOH
CH3OH + Cl
KOH
H2O
Na
PhCH Br
CH2 O CH3
Benzylmethyl ether
Ex.6
Page # 16
KOH DMSO
Ex.7.
2 RX, [D]
[] 0 = x (Assumed)
2 ROH, [L]
[] 0 x (optically pure only one enantiomer is obtained)
KOH DMSO
Ex.8.
KCN
Ex.9.
Acetone
R Cl + NaI
R I + NaCl ppt in acetone
R Br + NaI
Note:
Acetone
Ex.10. H
CH3
I + NaI*
C6H13
(reactant)
[] = x
Transition state
H + NaI
C6H13
(product)
[] = x
Polarimeter can detect difference between H and D, but not isotopes of higher elements.
For polarimeter reactants and products are mirror image in the above example.
(1) In this reaction, the nucleophile and the LG are the same species (I).
(2) The reaction is an equilibrium reaction and at equilibrium rate of forward reaction = rate of backward
reaction.
(3) In this reaction the optically pure reactant loses its optical activity and net result is a racemic
mixture.
(4) Since Nu:- and LG are same species, so the reactant and product are enantiomers. Although it is
an SN2 reaction, but racemisation shows there is complete inversion of configuration in forward reaction.
Page # 17
Q.1
Sol.
What will be the retationship between rate of I* exchange and rate of racemisation.
2 Rate of I* exchange = Rate of racemisation
or, Rate of Racemisation = 2 Rate of reaction.
Q.2
Na
Sol.
Q.3.
+ CH3I
KOH
?
1 eq.
Sol.
Q.4.
+ Ph CH2Cl
Sol.
Q.5.
CH3 CH2 I
Na
X
CH3 C CH
Y
Sol.
Q.6.
salt
Sol.
Q.7.
Ans.
Q.8.
Ans.
(D) OCOCH3
CH3CH2
CH3CH2CH2CH2Cl
CH3CH2CH2
CH2Cl
CH3
CH2CH2Cl
Page # 18
Q.9.
Draw a fischer projection for the product of the following SN2 reaction
(a)
Sol.
NaI / Acetone
(b)
(a)
(b)
NaOH
(i)
(ii)
Na
(Wurtz reaction)
ether
int ramolecula r
S 2 reaction
N
(iii)
Na
(iv)
Na
(v)
Mg / ether
(vi) Write mechanisms that account for the product of the following reactions :
NH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 Br
Sol.
Page # 19
SN2 Mechanism
Nucleophilic substitution on allylic system may proceed also via SN2 mechanism, in which the rearrangement does not take place. By the same concepts allylic rearrangement may proceed via an SN2 like
mechanism called the SN2 mechanism.
Conditions for SN2
(1) A nucleophilic attack on the -carbon
(2) A Concerted movement of three e pair occurs.
Ex.
SH
Ex.
The SN21 mechanism has also been demonstrated in propargyl systems, which results in an allene.
PhCCCH2OTs + CH3MgBr
Characteristics
S N1
1.
Energetic
2.
Kinetics
r [RX] [NU:]
r [RX]
3.
Stereochemistry
inversion
racemisation
4.
Rearrangement
not possible
possible
5.
Activation energy
Ea S
less
6.
Nature of R X
7.
Nucleophile
strong anionic
Weak neutral
N2
> Ea SN1
8.
Leaving group
(same)
9.
Solvent
Polar aprotic
Polar protic
10.
Temperature
High
Low
Page # 20
Example :
+
1.
2.
3.
4.
4.2
(A)
Reaction with HX : The protonated unbranched primary alcohol is well suited for the SN2 reaction.
Mechanism :
R OH
e.g
X
R O H2 R X + H2O
Page # 21
(B)
3R X + H3PO3
Mechanism :
Step : 1
Step : 2
RCH2X+ HOPX2
e.g.
CH3
|
CH3 CH2 CH CH2 OH
2 Methyl 1 bu tan ol
e.g.
CH3 CH2 OH
Ethyl alcohol
P I2
PBr
CH3
|
CH3 CH2 CH CH2 Br
2 Methyl 1 bromobutane
CH3 CH2 I
Ethyl iodide
e.g.
e.g.
(C)
O
||
R OH + Cl S Cl
Heat
Pyridine
R Cl + SO2 + HCl
Mechanism :
.. ..
R O
.. S
H
..
O:
+ HCl
Cl
Chlorosulphite ester
R Cl + SO2
In the first step, the nonbonding electrons of the hydroxy oxygen atom attack the electrophilic sulphur
atom of thionyl chloride. A chloride ion is expelled a proton and gives test of chloro sulphite ester.
Second step is an SN2 mechanism
Page # 22
SOCl 2
Py
e.g.
(D)
.. ..
R O
.. S
H
..
O:
+ HCl
Cl
Chlorosulphite ester
R Cl + SO2
Cl
H
C
CH3(CH2)4CH2
e.g.
CH3
(R)
2-Chlorooctane
84%
4.3
(A)
Reaction with HX
Ethers are unreactive toward most bases, but they can react under acidic conditions. A protonated ether
can undergo substitution reaction. Ether react with conc. HBr and HI because these reagents are
sufficiently acidic to protonate the ether. If R or R is 3 then mechanism will be SN1 otherwise SN2.
Mechanism :
+
X R
HX
X R + X R
alkyl halide
e.g.
HBr
(i) CH3CH2OCH2CH3 2CH3 CH2Br
excess
Mech.
Br
|
CH3 C H
|
H
ethyl bromide
CH3CH2Br
Ex.1
Ex.2
CH3CH2 O CH3
excess HBr
Page # 23
Ex.3
Ex.4
Ex.5
Ph
CH3
HBr
2
CH3 C O CH2 CH3 CH3 C OH + CH3 CH2 Br (S N )
major
H
H
Me
Me
Me
Me
CH3
HBr
H
1
(SN )
O
D
Et
2
Ex.6
1
4.4
D
(Retention)
2
HI
1
(S N ) I
H + Ph
OH
Me
Br + Br
Et
(Racemisation)
Ph
Et
4
3
OH
SN Reaction of Epoxide
Epoxides are much more reactive than ether because of angle strain in three membered ring therefore
epoxide readily undergo nucleophilic substitution reaction.
(a) In basic medium mechanism is SN2. Nucleophile atacks on less hindered carbon.
Mechanism :
Nu
|
R CH CH2
|
O
Nu
|
R CH CH2
|
OH
H
e.g.
(b) In acidic medium mechanism is SN1 type. Nucleophilic attacks on more substituted carbon.
Mechanism :
e.g.
Nu
|
R CH CH2
|
OH
H O18
e.g.
Page # 24
5. ELIMINATION REACTIONS
In an elimination reaction two atoms or groups (YZ) are removed from the substrate and generally
resulting into formation of bond.
|
|
CC
|
|
Y Z
E lim ination
YZ
-elimination : When two groups are lost from the same carbon atom to give a carbene (or nitrene).
This is also called 11 elimination.
CC:
XY
-elimination : When two groups are lost from adjacent atoms so that a bond is formed. This is also
called 12 elimination.
C=C
E1 Reaction :
Proton and leaving group depart in two different step.
(a) First step : - Slow step involves ionisation to form carbocation
(b) Second step : Abstraction of proton
5.1
Step 2 : Base (
# In the second step, a base abstracts a proton from the carbon atom adjacent to the carbocation, and
forms alkene.
# Reaction intermediate is carbocation, so rearrangment is possible
Kinetics
Rate [Alkylhalide]
Rate = k [Alkylhalide]
# It is unimolecular, two step process.
# It is a first order reaction.
Page # 25
Energetics
The free energy diagram for the E1 reaction is similar to that for the SN1 reaction.
Reactivity Order :
# Similar to SN1 becuase Carbocation Intermediate is formed in the rds step.
SN1 vs E1 :
In case of alkyl halide SN1 product is always more than E1 product
Example :
Ex.1
CH3
|
CH3 CH2 C CH3
|
Br
Ex.2
and
[JEE 2000]
Note : The minor product formed before the carbocation rearrangement is not consider.
Ex.3
CH OH,
Sol.
CH OH
or
Page # 26
#
#
Et OH is not a stronge base, not strong enough to break C-H bond and hence attack at positive
charge site.
In such reactions, SN1 is major and E1 minor so, alkenes are not prepared by this method. water or
MeOH do not cause E1 (very weak base)
Ex.4
(X) + (Y)
(W) + (Z)
Rearranged Carbocation :
Y (d/) mixture of
and
5.2
E1 Reaction of Alcohol
Dehydration requires an acidic catalyst to protonate the hydroxyl group of the alcohol and convert it to
a good leaving group. Loss of water, followed by loss of proton, gives the alkene. An equilibrium is
established between reactants and products. For E1 mechanism reagents are (i) H3PO4/
(ii) H2SO4 / 160
| |
| |
acid
C C
C C
| |
H OH
Mechanism :
+ H2 O
Step 1 :
Step 2 :
Step 3
Page # 27
Remarks
In first step, an acid-base reaction a proton is rapidly transferred from the acid to one of the unshared
electon pairs of the alcohol.
In second step the carbon oxygen bond breaks. The leaving group is a water molecule :
Finally,in third step the carbocation transfers a proton to a molecule of water. The result is the formation
of a hydronium ion and an alkene.
CH2
CH2OH
Ex.1
Conc.H2SO 4
(I)
Minor
Ex.2
Ex.3
Ex.4
Ex.5
Ex.6
Ex.7
Ex.8
Ex.9
H SO ,
4
2
Ex.10
Page # 28
Pinacol-Pinacolone rearrangement
Mechanism
Examples :
H SO /
4
2
Ex.1
Ex.3
5.3
H SO /
4
2
Ex.2
Ex.4
E1 Reaction of Ether :
Elimination is not a favourable reaction for ether, but however few reactions have been observed.
E1 Elimination takes place via formation of stable carbocation.
Ether undergoes dehydration reaction in the presence of conc. H2SO4 /
Conc.H 2 SO 4 /
e.g.
Ethers dissolve in concentrated solutions of strong inorganic acids to from oxonium salts, i.e. ether behave
as bronsted Lowry bases.
+
(R O R) HSO4 R OH + R O SO 2 OH
alkyl hydrogen
|
sulphate
H
R2O + H2SO4
H SO
4
2
Ex.2
1
Page # 29
(ii) NaNH2
(iii) t-BuO K
in t-BuOH
Mechanism :
+ BH
Kinetics :
Rate [R X] [Base] ; Rate = k [R X] [ ]
# This is a single step, bimolecular reaction
# It is a second order reaction
# Rearrangment is not possible
# For the lower energy of activation, transition state must be stable
# E2 follows a concerted mechanism
# The orientation of proton & leaving group should be antiperiplanar.
# Here H is eliminated by base hence called elimination
Reactivity order:
R I > R Br > R Cl > R F
Page # 30
Examples :
e.g.
CH3
|
e.g.
+ H2 O +
CH3 C Br +
|
CH3
Formation of the Hoffmann product
Bulky bases can also accomplish dehydrohalogenations that do not follow the saytzeff rule. Due to
steric hindrance, a bulky base abstracts a less hindered proton, often the one that leads to formation
of the least substituted product, called the Hoffmann product.
H CH3
| |
CH3 C C CH2
| | |
H Br H
Stereochemistry of E2 Reaction :
1. It is a stereospecific reaction.
2. In the T.S., the L.G. and hydrogen are anti-parallel (or, anti-periplanar) to each other.
3. In the anti conformation, the T.S. is most stable due to minimum electronic repulsion.
4. So the product alkene of E2 reaction has one of the two possible orientations (i.e., either cis or
trans)
5. Stereospecificity is observed only when one stereoisomer of reactant R X is used.
6. Stereospecific reaction means the one stereoisomer gives one stereoisomer as a product
7. In the T.S., 5 atoms lie in the same plane
, H, C, -C, g.)
Ph Ph
Ph
Ph
CH3
H
Br
CH3
H
Br
CH3
Ph
Ph
Ph
CH3
Trans
Ph
Examples :
Page # 31
Ex.1
Ex.2
Ex.3
Alc.KOH
No. reaction
Ex.4
Ex.5
Ex.7
Ex.6
Alc.KOH
Alc.KOH
Ex.8
Ex.9
Page # 32
Ex.10
E1
E2
(i) Base
W eak base
(ii) Solvent
(iii) Substrate
3 > 2
3 > 2 > 1
Characteristics
(i) Kinetics
K [R X] Ist order
(ii) Orientation
Saytzeff alkene
Saytzeff alkene
(iii) Stereochemistry
No special geometry
is required
transition state
must be co-planar
6.2
E1:
X:
E2:
1 rds
RCH=CH
2
RCH=CH2
Elimination of alcohol :
Reagent : Al2O3, P2O5, ThO2
Cyclic Transition state is formed and rearrangement is not possible
Ex.1
Ex.2
Page # 33
7. E1cB Reaction
E1cB Reaction (Unimolecular conjugate base reaction)
In the E1cB, H leaves first and then the X. This is a two step process, the intermediate is a carbanion.
Mechanism :
H
|
|
(Conjugate base)
CC X
|
|
Step - II : Carbanion looses a leaving group to form alkene
C C
|
|
Remark :
(i) The strong base abstracts B H (Significantly acidic) in 1st fast rev. step.
As a result a carbanion intermediate (cb) is formed.
(ii) In the 2nd slow step the leaving group is eliminated.
(iii) molecularity = 1, order = 1.
(iv) Elcb is unimol . 1st order wrt. cb.
Overall order = 2
Kinetics :
Rate
Evidence :
A:
R:
When the leaving group is strongly electronegative (i.e. exerts strong - effect on H)
F,
Note:
(b)
Presence of EWG ( m) at c
(c)
if EWG is attached to c,
in E1cB
(Hofmann elimination)
Ex.1
Page # 34
Ex.2
Ex. 3
R2C=O
Ex.4
Note :
Ex.5
1. CH I excess
Ex.6
Ex.7
2. AgOH /
1. CH I excess
2. AgOH /
Ex. 8
Ex.9
Page # 35
Faculty Remark
Your suggessions / deficiencies are invite regarding this lecture note in detail.
please submit to the R & D coordinator (Organic chemistry)
S.No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Page # 36