Problems During Tablet Manufacturing & Its Solution

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 59

Section 5

Tablet Problems and Remedies


By George E. Reier, PhD

Table of Contents
Tablet Problems and Remedies........................................................................................................1
Table of Contents .........................................................................................................................1
Part A. Specific Tableting Problems and Remedies (Process Format) ........................................5
Dry Blending .............................................................................................................................5
Particle agglomeration .........................................................................................................5
Nonuniformity of mix ............................................................................................................5
Segregation after blending ..................................................................................................6
Wet Granulation (Massing) ........................................................................................................7
Doughy mass........................................................................................................................7
Moisture sensitive drugs ......................................................................................................7
Wet Screening...........................................................................................................................8
Screen clogging....................................................................................................................8
Drying ......................................................................................................................................9
Nonuniform drying ...............................................................................................................9
Granule case hardening (hard crust forms with incomplete drying inside granule) ................9
Color migration ....................................................................................................................9
Drug migration ...................................................................................................................10
Dry Screening (Dry Granulation) ..............................................................................................11
Excess fines .......................................................................................................................11
Difficult to screen................................................................................................................11
Poor color distribution .......................................................................................................12
Feed Hopper ..........................................................................................................................13
Poor flow.............................................................................................................................13
Flooding ..............................................................................................................................14
Particle segregation............................................................................................................14
Tablet Weight .........................................................................................................................15
Weight variation outside limits ..........................................................................................15
Punches and Dies...................................................................................................................16
Punch binding (powder adheres to punch edges and dies; punches may bind in dies) ......16
Punch filming or sticking (picking)(powder adhesion to punch faces, usually upper) ......17
Punch and die abrasion .....................................................................................................18
Capping and laminating .....................................................................................................18
Chipping/splitting ...............................................................................................................19
Score line or tablet imprint not sharp ................................................................................19
Layered tablets splitting .....................................................................................................20
Layers not sharply defined ................................................................................................20

1 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Low hardness .........................................................................................................................20
Variable hardness ...................................................................................................................21
High friability ...........................................................................................................................21
Disintegration too long ...........................................................................................................22
Mottling ...................................................................................................................................22
Tablets contain dirty specks ...............................................................................................23
Tablets uniformly discolored...................................................................................................23
Part B. General Tableting Problems and Remedies (Alphabetical Order Format) ......................24
Active ingredients ...................................................................................................................24
Adsorbents ............................................................................................................................24
Agglomeration of particles .....................................................................................................24
Aging of tablets.......................................................................................................................24
Air entrapment ........................................................................................................................25
Antiadherent ..........................................................................................................................25
Attraction of particles (aggregation or agglomeration) ............................................................25
Binder ....................................................................................................................................25
Binding (bonding or compressibility) .......................................................................................26
Binding in the die (punches) ...................................................................................................26
Bioavailability ..........................................................................................................................26
Bisected or debossed tablets (not sharp or well-defined) ....................................................26
Blending .................................................................................................................................27
Bonding .................................................................................................................................27
Bridging ..................................................................................................................................27
Brittle fracture .........................................................................................................................28
Bulk density ............................................................................................................................28
Capping and laminating .........................................................................................................28
Case hardening.......................................................................................................................29
Chipping/splitting ..................................................................................................................30
Clogging of screen (wet mass) ...............................................................................................30
Coarse particles......................................................................................................................31
Color distribution ....................................................................................................................31
Color migraton........................................................................................................................31
Compressibility .......................................................................................................................31
Content uniformity ..................................................................................................................31
Density, bulk (loose density) .........................................................................................................32
Density, tapped.......................................................................................................................32
Die fill (nonuniform) ..................................................................................................................32
Diluent ....................................................................................................................................33
Dilution potential.....................................................................................................................33
Direct compression.................................................................................................................33
Disintegrant ............................................................................................................................33
Disintegration too long or incomplete....................................................................................34
Disintegration during coating .................................................................................................34
Dissolution ..............................................................................................................................35

2 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Dosage variation.....................................................................................................................35
Doughy mass..........................................................................................................................36
Drug migration ........................................................................................................................36
Dry blending............................................................................................................................36
Dry granulation (by slugging or compaction)...........................................................................37
Dry screening..........................................................................................................................37
Dye migration..........................................................................................................................38
Ejection problem.....................................................................................................................38
Elastic material........................................................................................................................38
Entrapment of air ....................................................................................................................38
Excess fines (wet granulation) .................................................................................................38
Expanding tablets...................................................................................................................39
Filler ....................................................................................................................................39
Filming of punches .................................................................................................................39
Fines (direct compression) .......................................................................................................39
Fines (wet granulation).............................................................................................................39
Flooding ..................................................................................................................................39
Flow problem ..........................................................................................................................40
Friability (high) .........................................................................................................................40
Glidant ....................................................................................................................................41
Granulation, dry ......................................................................................................................41
Granulation, wet .....................................................................................................................41
Hard tablets ............................................................................................................................41
Hardness increases with time ................................................................................................42
Hardness, variable ..................................................................................................................42
High friability ...........................................................................................................................42
High relative humidity .............................................................................................................42
Hopper flow ............................................................................................................................42
Hygroscopic ingredients.........................................................................................................43
Hygroscopic tablets................................................................................................................43
Laminating ..............................................................................................................................43
Layered tablets splitting (poor bonding between layers; layers peel or split apart) .................43
Loss of hardness (with time) ...................................................................................................44
Loss of hardness ....................................................................................................................44
Low to medium level of active (in direct compression)...........................................................45
Lubricants ...............................................................................................................................45
Mixing ....................................................................................................................................45
Modified direct compression..................................................................................................46
Moisture sensitive actives ......................................................................................................46
Mottling ...................................................................................................................................46
Nonuniform die fill...................................................................................................................46
Nonuniform drying (tray drying) ..............................................................................................46
Nonuniformity of mix ..............................................................................................................46
Oleaginous or sticky actives ..................................................................................................47

3 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Ordered mixing (adhesive blending) ........................................................................................47
Overblending ..........................................................................................................................48
Oven drying ............................................................................................................................48
Overwetting of wet mass .......................................................................................................48
Partial direct compression......................................................................................................48
Particle density variation .......................................................................................................48
Particle size distribution .........................................................................................................49
Picking ....................................................................................................................................49
Poor binding ...........................................................................................................................49
Poor color distribution ............................................................................................................49
Poor flow (rat-holing or bridging) .......................................................................................49
Poor granule disintegration ....................................................................................................50
Poor layer demarcation ..........................................................................................................50
Poor tablet finish/appearance ................................................................................................50
Postgranulation addition ........................................................................................................50
Powder separation .................................................................................................................50
Precompression......................................................................................................................51
Punch and die abrasion .........................................................................................................51
Punch binding (powder adheres to punch edges and dies; punches may bind in dies) ..........52
Punch filming or sticking (picking)(powder adhesion to punch faces, usually upper) ..........52
Rat-holing ..............................................................................................................................53
Relative humidity (RH).............................................................................................................53
Roll compacting......................................................................................................................54
Score line or tablet imprint not sharp ....................................................................................55
Screen clogging (wet mass)....................................................................................................55
Segregation.............................................................................................................................55
Slugging ..................................................................................................................................55
Soft tablets ............................................................................................................................56
Splitting (tablets)......................................................................................................................56
Sticking to punch face ...........................................................................................................56
Sticky ingredients ...................................................................................................................56
Tablet binding in the die .........................................................................................................57
Tablets contain dirty specks ...............................................................................................57
Tablets uniformly discolored...................................................................................................57
Underblending .......................................................................................................................57
Variable hardness ...................................................................................................................57
Weight variation (outside limits)...............................................................................................58
Wet granulation.......................................................................................................................58

4 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Part A. Specific Tableting Problems and remedies (Process Format)

Dry Blending

Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution


Particle agglomeration Occurs with fine Fine-screen cohesive compound
cohesive powders, into bulk mix
which cause balling
up and poor Use a more effective mixer (one
distribution with increased shearing action)

Blend the cohesive powder with a


portion (5% to 10%) of an excipient;
screen (mill) if necessary; reblend
and add to the bulk; blend normally

Note: For direct compression excipient


blends do not use a screen size or a
mixer, which will change the excipient
particle size distribution

Nonuniformity of mix Improper blender load Use recommended powder load in


blender

Insufficient mixing Increase mixing time

Inefficient (improper) Use alternative mixer with


mixer increased shearing action

Wide particle size Select more uniform particle sizes


distribution of components

Overblending Reduce blending time

Establish optimum mixing


conditions

Low-dosage actives Use a more effective mixer (one


with increased shearing action)

5 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Nonuniformity of mix Low-level excipients Blend the low-level component
(continued) with a portion (5% to 10%) of an
excipient; screen (mill) if
necessary; reblend; add to an
equal quantity of excipient and
mix; screen or mill if necessary;
blend normally with remainder
of bulk

Dissolve drug in a suitable solvent


and add or spray onto a portion
of the bulk or an excipient; blend;
remove solvent

Note: For direct compression


excipient blends do not use a screen
size or a mixer, which will change the
excipient particle size distribution

Segregation after Particle size Use a narrower particle size range


blending distribution too wide of components

6 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Wet Granulation (Massing)

Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution


Doughy mass Too much water Add granulating water slowly;
(often seen on scaleup) mix well after each addition

Overmixing during Reduce water or mixing time


granulation step

Wrong binder Change binder

Component of mix If possible, use alcohol/water or


(e.g., active drug or alcohol as granulating fluid - select
excipient) appropriate binder; use of Avicel
PH-101 gives 1) less sticky or
doughy mass which is easier to
screen; and 2) allows a wider
range of solvent volume

Moisture sensitive Instability with water If possible, use ethyl alcohol


drugs or isopropyl alcohol (if latter,
determine acceptable residual
solvent by GC or other appropriate
method) as granulating fluids,
ethyl cellulose and PVP as binders

Try slugging or roller compaction


as dry granulation methods

7 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Wet Screening

Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution


Screen clogging Doughy or sticky wet Avoid oscillating granulator
mass
Use extrusion-type granulator
or Fitz Mill without screens
Reduce granulation time

Add 5% to 20% Avicel PH-101


(gives less sticky or doughy mass,
easier to screen)

Too much water in Reduce water content; add water


mass gradually and mix well after each
addition

Mass sensitive to Incorporate 5% to 20% Avicel


water content PH-101 (allows a wider range
of solvent volume)

Gummy binder Change binder

Component or active Use diluted or anhydrous ethyl


ingredient or isopropyl alcohol (if latter,
determine acceptable residual
solvent level by GC or other
appropriate method); change
binder

8 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Drying

Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution


Nonuniform drying Poor air circulation Have oven air circulation checked
(tray dryer) and corrected

Dryer overload Reduce number of trays

Reduce thickness of wet mass


on the trays (tray load)

Try fluid bed dryer

Granule case hardening Too rapid evaporation Try recirculating oven air (damper
(hard crust forms with of water closed) for initial 15 to 30 minutes,
incomplete drying then open damper partially for a
inside granule) Oven drying short period, and finally open
conditions too efficient damper fully

Reduce drying temperature

Add Avicel PH-101 to formulation


(gives more even water
evaporation and uniform granule
moisture content)

Use a fluid bed dryer

Color migration Colors migrate to Use lakes instead of soluble dyes


granule surfaces (wet (will minimize but not eliminate)
granulation); tablets
have mottled Decrease the size of the wet
appearance granules

Decrease thickness of granulation


bed; stir granulation bed frequently
during drying to expose fresh
surfaces at the top of the wet
mass

Use Avicel PH-101- reduces or


eliminates dye migration in wet
granulation

9 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Drug migration Drug migrates to See remedies under Color
granule surfaces; migration
content uniformity
problems may result
as drug becomes part
of fines after dry
screening, or there is
a loss of drug with
subsequent low tablet
assays

10 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Dry Screening (Dry Granulation)

Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution


Excess fines Granulation overdried Decrease drying time/temperature

Establish optimum moisture


content

Screen size too small Use larger screen size

Rotor/screen clearance Adjust rotor clearance


too close

Overloading of mill or Slow feed of material to mill


granulator or granulator

Weak granules Increase granulating fluid

Increase binder content

Increase wet massing time

Difficult to screen Granules too hard Decrease drying temperature


(case hardening)

Decrease water content


(use alcohol/water)

Decrease binder content

Use weaker binder

Moisture in granulation Increase drying time

Establish optimum moisture


content

11 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Poor color distribution Dye migration to Use lakes instead of soluble dyes
granule surface (will minimize but not eliminate
(nonuniformity of problem)
color throughout
granule) Decrease the size of the wet
granules

Decrease thickness of granulation


bed; stir granulation bed frequently
during drying to expose fresh
surfaces at the top of the wet
mass

Use Avicel PH-101- reduces or


eliminates dye migration in wet
granulation

12 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Feed Hopper

Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution


Poor flow Too many fines in wet Reduce fines (see Dry screening:
granulation Excess fines)

rat-holing

bridging In direct compression, Select larger particle size; use


particle size of drug or Avicel PH-102 or PH-200 in place
excipients too small of PH-101 or other excipient
and/or of shape that
will not flow Add glidant (0.1% to 0.5%)
(e.g., Cab-O-Sil, Aerosil

Use induced or force-feed


mechanism on press

Change particle shape of active


ingredient to one that is more likely
to flow

Poor inherent flow Add 0.1% to 0.5% glidant

Dry granulate (by slugging or roller


compacting) with a mixture of
Avicel PH-101, Cab-O-Sil ,
and magnesium stearate

Atmospheric moisture Process in low humidity


adsorption atmosphere

Add moisture absorber (e.g.,


0.1% to 0.5% calcium silicate,
Cab-O-Sil, Syloid)

13 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Flooding Excessive flow Identify causative component and
properties (fluidization) exclude or modify particle size
of one or more
components (could be Select narrow range of particle
from an excess of sizes; avoid excess fines
glidant or lubricant)

Flow is erratic and Use an induced or force-feed


feed frame is flooded mechanism on press, which may
at times control flow

Particle segregation Particle size range of Use a narrower particle size range
mix too wide of ingredients

See Dry screening: Excess fines

Too wide a density Control differences in density of


difference in mix particles
particles

Mixer too vigorous; Use a mixer with a gentler mixing


produces fines action

Use of vibrators Use force-flow feed mechanisms


(to promote flow from rather than hopper vibrators
hopper)

Excessive machine Isolate hopper from tablet machine


vibration

14 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Table Weight

Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution


Weight variation Poor or erratic powder Correct powder flow problem
outside limits flow, flooding (See Feed hopper)

Particle size range too Narrow the particle size range;


wide avoid excess fines
Use Avicel PH-200 to minimize
weight variation

Particle size not Adjust particle size range to


suitable for die recommended optimum for die
diameter diameter

Punches not within Examine punch length dimensions


specifications

Particle segregation as Narrow the particle size range


press RPMs increase
Compress at slower RPM

Lower punch hang up Clean; improve dust collection


(material between lower
punch and die wall or Check for proper clearance
lower punch and punch between die wall and lower punch
guide)
Increase lubricant concentration
in formulation

Remove below 200 mesh fines

15 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Punches and Dies

Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution


Punch binding (powder Poor finish or worn Polish, reface, or replace tooling
adheres to punch punches and dies
edges and dies Increase or change lubricant; use
punches may bind in Inadequate lubrication microfine lubricants; screen into
dies) mix
Increase lubricant blending time

Too many fines or Design better particle size range;


coarse particles in mix use tapered dies

Wet granulation Dry granulation to satisfactory


insufficiently dried moisture limits

Hygroscopic Process under low humidity


ingredients conditions

Use moisture scavengers (e.g.,


calcium silicate, Syloid,
Cab-O-Sil)

Adhesive components Increase lubricant level

Add 0.5% Cab-O-Sil or Syloid

Add 5% to 10% low moisture


grades Avicel PH-112 and
PH-113

16 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Punch filming or Poor finish on punch Polish punch faces; refinish
sticking (picking) faces
(powder adhesion to Avoid using certain letters
punch faces, usually Embossed letters (e.g., A, B, P, R)
upper)
Use shallow embossing with
tapered edges rather than edges
directly perpendicular to punch
face

Punch tips burred Refinish or replace

Punch concavity too Reduce punch concavity or use


great flat face punches

Poor binding between Increase binder (wet or dry)


surface granules or
particles

Low melting point Adsorb low melting point


ingredient ingredient on Avicel, replace with
higher melting point ingredient

Inadequate lubrication Increase or change lubricant

Use microfine lubricants, screen


into mix

Increase lubricant mixing time

Insufficiently dried wet Dry granulation and establish


granulation moisture limits

Hygroscopic Process under low humidity


components conditions

Use moisture adsorbent


(e.g., calcium silicate, Syloid)

Adhesive components Increase lubricant level

Add 0.5% Cab-O-Sil or Syloid


or 5% to 10% Avicel PH-101

Tablets too soft Increase compression pressure

17 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Punch and die abrasion Abrasive components Exclude or reduce to a fine particle
size

Increase lubricant level

Blend abrasive component directly


with the lubricant

Use minimum tableting pressure


possible

Use more wear-resistant tooling


(harder metal)

Capping and laminating Inadequate bonding Use a stronger binder or additional


of the powder binder
Capping is separation of particles (direct
the top or bottom from compression) or Avicel PH-101 and PH-102
the main body of the granules (wet are particularly effective direct
tablet. granulation) to form compression binders (15% to
cohesive tablets 25%) and as auxiliary binders
Laminating is transverse in wet granulation (5% to 15%)
cracking and separation
of the tablet into two or
more layers.
Poor finish or worn Polish, reface, or replace
punches and dies
Chrome plate punch faces
Too many fines in
granulation Modify granulation process for
minimum fines
Granulation too dry
Adjust moisture level and establish
optimum moisture limits

Granulation too wet Continue to dry and establish


(usually associated optimum moisture limit
with sticking or
picking)

Overlubrication of Decrease lubricant level


final tableting mix
Blend lubricant for minimal time
required; establish optimum mixing
time

18 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Capping and laminating High level of Use precompression on tablet
(continued) ingredient with poor press
compression
properties (also Slow the speed of the tablet
sometimes ascribed machine
to air-entrapment by
powder bed)

Punch concavity too Change to standard concave


deep or flat face punches

Punch edges worn or Refinish or replace


damaged

Lower punch too low Adjust lower punch flush with


at tablet take-off die face

Compression too low Compress in upper portion of


in die cavity die

Excessive tableting Decrease pressure


pressure

Die wall binding Use sufficient lubricant

Use tapered dies

Chipping/splitting Poor finish or worn Polish, reface, or replace punches


punches and dies and dies

Lower punch setting Adjust lower punch flush with


too low at tablet die face
takeoff

Tablet sweep-off Adjust setting


blade on feed frame
set too high

Score line or tablet Faulty punch Redesign using tapered sides


imprint not sharp debossing design on the punch debossing

Chrome-plate punch face

Granulation too Reduce particle size of granulation


coarse

Binder not strong Use a stronger binder


enough

19 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Layered tablets Poor bonding Use a stronger binder or higher
splitting between layers concentration

Compression Compress at lower pressures


pressure too high

Overlubrication Decrease lubricant level

Blend lubricant for minimal time


required; do not blend for long
periods of time

Layers not sharply Granulation too Reduce particle size of granulation


defined coarse - less than 16 mesh

Too many fines Remove fines below 200 mesh

Low hardness Compression force Increase pressure (caution: do not


(pressure) too low exceed recommended pressure
for punch size used)

Overlubrication Decrease lubricant level

Blend lubricant for minimal time


required; establish optimum mixing
time

Replace metallic stearates with


other lubricants (e.g., stearic acid)

Granulation too soft Use additional binder

Direct compression - use


additional Avicel PH
Excipient (i.e., too Reduce level of causative
much starch can give excipient
a soft tablet)

20 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Low hardness Moisture consent too Determine optimum moisture
(continued) high (granulation content
underdried or high
humidity in Use moisture adsorbent (e.g.,
compressing area) calcium silicate, Syloid)
Moisture content too Determine optimum moisture
low (granulation content
overdried or low
humidity in Add additional moisture
compressing area)

Variable hardness Tooling Examine punch lengths

Uneven diefill See Table Weight: Weight


variation

Overblending Optimize blending time to


minimize creation of fines

High friability Inadequate bonding Increase binder level or change


of the tablet mix to stronger binder

Add or increase Avicel PH-101


or PH-102 (10% to 20%)

Avicel PH gives low friability at


lower hardness/machine pressures

Too much or too little Adjust pressure for acceptable


compression pressure friability

Overlubrication Decrease lubricant level

Blend lubricant for minimal time


required; establish optimum mixing
time

Replace metallic stearates with


other lubricants (e.g., stearic acid)

21 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Disintegration too long Tablet hardness too Reduce machine pressure for
high acceptable tablets

Use less binder in granulation

Overlubrication Decrease lubricant level


(waterproofing) Blend lubricant for minimal time
required; establish optimum mixing
time

Replace metallic stearates with


other lubricants (e.g., stearic acid)

Requires additional Consider a super disintegrant


disintegrant or a (e.g., Ac-Di-Sol, 2% to 5%)
different disintegrant
Include Avicel PH-101 or PH-102
(added dry), about 10% as an
auxiliary disintegrant

Consider adding a surfactant (e.g.,


DOSS, 0.1%)

Tablet hardness too Increase hardness to allow


low swellable disintegrant to function

Mottling Uneven distribution of Increase mixing time or use high


the dye in colored shear mixer
tablets

Dye migration during See Drying: Color migration


drying process
See Dry screening: Poor color
distribution

Preferential Replace causative component


absorption of soluble
dye by component of Replace soluble dye with microfine
mix lake pigment

High level of Reduce quantity of additives


uncolored additives
(e.g., fillers, lubricants, Color additives with soluble dye
disintegrants) or mix with lake pigment

22 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Mottling In direct compression, Use microfine lake dye
(continued) uneven distribution of
lake dye Increase blending time

Mill lake dye with 5% excipient,


then blend with bulk

Reduce size of larger particles


of excipient or active

Use lower drying temperature

Tablets contain dirty Misaligned upper cam Check alignment of upper cam
specks tracks - rubbing of tracks
punches on cam
actually rubs off metal
which is introduced
into material being
compressed

No lubrication on
upper cam tracks

Excessive or improper Use dust caps on upper punches


lubrication on upper
punch shanks (no dust
caps on punches) -
dust mixes with excess
oil or grease and falls
into material being
compressed

Tablets uniformly Feed frame rubbing Check clearance between feed


discolored on die table frame and die table

Feed hopper rubbing Check clearance between feed


on turret hopper and turret

Abrasive materials Check for presence of abrasive


wearing screens, materials
scooper, etc.

23 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Part B. General Tableting Problems and Remedies
(Alphabetical Order Format)

Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution


Active ingredients See Sticky ingredients

See Low to medium level


of active

See High percent active

See Attraction of particles

See Dosage variation

See Density

See Elastic material

Adsorbents Materials used to Use starch, Avicel PH-101,


overcome oiliness or silicon dioxide (Syloid) or
stickiness of tablet tribasic calcium phosphate
ingredients

Agglomeration of Occurs with fine Fine-screen cohesive compound


particles cohesive powders into bulk mix
causing "balling" or
lump formation and Use a more effective mixer (one
poor distribution of with increased shearing action)
the powder
Blend the cohesive powder with
a portion (5% to 10%) of an
excipient; screen (mill) if
necessary; reblend and add to
the bulk; blend normally

Note: For direct compression


excipient blends do not use a
screen size or a mixer, which will
change the excipient particle size
distribution

Aging of tablets See Loss of hardness (with time)

24

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Air entrapment Very low density See Capping and laminating
materials with very
high porosity See Binding
(sometimes ascribed
as cause for tablet
capping, splitting,
or laminating)

Antiadherent Materials that aid in See Section 4 for a description


preventing the tablet of excipients and their uses
mix from sticking to
punch faces

Attraction of particles Fine cohesive Modify particle size distribution


(aggregation or powders
agglomeration)
Static electricity Mechanically disperse

Drain off static charge

Low relative humidity Slightly increase moisture level

See Blending

Densify as last resort

Binder Wet granulation - See Section 4 for a description


substances which are of excipients and their uses
added in solution
(usually) or sometimes
dry, followed by
granulating solvent to
glue a powder mix
into granules for solid
dose preparation

Direct compression -
substances which give
compressibility or
cohesiveness to the
powder mix

25

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Binding (bonding or Relative degree of See Blending
compressibility) cohesiveness
between particles or Be careful not to overblend or
granules overlubricate

Compressibility of Optimize particle size and particle


active ingredients size distribution of active and
determines (to some excipients
extent) the percent
that can be Use excipients which are
incorporated into a compressible and designed for
direct compression direct compression process
formulation
Determine that granulation and/or
Particular binder and other excipients have proper
concentration moisture content
influences degree of
binding and tablet
hardness

Binding in the die See Punch binding


(punches)

Bioavailability The rate and extent to See Dissolution


which an active
ingredient is absorbed Use up to 50% soluble filler
in-vivo (lactose, dextrose) with insoluble
drugs (direct compression)

May or may not be


correlated with
dissolution

Bisected or debossed Poor design on Redesign tooling, consult tooling


tablets (not sharp or tooling supplier
well-defined)
Increase binder in formulation

26

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Blending Mixing of powders to Optimize blending or mixing time
obtain a homogeneous
mixture (for
compression)

Optimized blending
may depend on type
of mixer (low shear,
high shear, etc.)

Overblending is
probably more
common than
underblending

Overblending causes
overdistribution of the
lubricant which can
result in poor
disintegration/
dissolution, poor
compressibility,
demixing
(segregation)

Bonding See Binding

Bridging Lack of powder See Die fill


fluidity; actual
stoppage of powder See Flow problems
flow as powder
compacts in hopper
or feed-frame

27

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Brittle fracture Bonding mechanism See Section 2 for a discussion
of some materials of compression mechanisms
(e.g., lactose), in which
single particles fracture
under pressure to
produce multiple
particles having clean
surfaces, which then
bond with each other
to form a compact

Bulk density See Density, bulk

Capping and laminating

Capping is separation of Inadequate bonding Use a stronger binder or additional


the top or bottom from of the powder binder
the main body of the particles (direct
tablet. compression) or Avicel PH-101 and PH-102 are
granules (wet particularly effective direct
Laminating is transverse granulation) to form compression binders (15% to
cracking and separation cohesive tablets 25%) and as auxiliary binders in
of the tablet into two or wet granulation (5% to 15%)
more layers. Poor finish or worn
punches and dies Polish, reface, or replace

Chrome-plate punch faces

Too many fines in Modify granulation process for


granulation minimum fines

Granulation too dry Adjust moisture level and establish


optimum moisture limits

Granulation too wet Continue to dry and establish


(usually associated optimum moisture limit
with sticking or
picking)

Overlubrication of Decrease lubricant level


final tableting mix
Blend lubricant for minimal time
required; establish optimum mixing
time

28

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Capping and laminating High level of Use precompression on tablet
(continued) ingredient with press
poor compression
properties (also Slow the speed of the tablet
sometimes ascribed machine
to air-entrapment by
powder bed)

Punch concavity too Change to standard concave or


deep flat-face punches

Punch edges worn or Refinish or replace


damaged
Lower punch too low Adjust lower punch flush with
at tablet take-off die face

Compression too low Compress in upper portion of die


in die cavity

Excessive tableting Decrease pressure


pressure

Die wall binding Use sufficient lubricant

Use tapered dies

Case hardening Rapid evaporation of Try recirculating oven air (damper


water, which forms closed) for initial 15 to 30 minutes
hard outer crust often then open damper partially for a
associated with short period and finally open
incomplete drying damper fully
inside granules
Reduce drying temperature
Oven drying
conditions too efficient Add Avicel PH-101 to formulation
(gives more even water evaporation
and uniform granule moisture
content)

Use a fluid bed dryer

29

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Chipping/splitting Poor finish or worn Polish, reface, or replace punches
punches and dies and dies

Lower punch setting Adjust lower punch flush with


too low at tablet take- die face
off

Tablet sweep-off Adjust setting


blade on feed frame
See Capping and laminating

See Binding/bonding

Clogging of screen Doughy or sticky wet Avoid oscillating granulator


(wet mass) mass
Use extrusion-type granulator
or Fitz Mill without screens
Reduce granulation time

Add 5% to 20% Avicel PH-101


(gives less sticky or doughy mass,
easier to screen)

Too much water in Reduce water content; add water


mass gradually and mix well after each
addition

Mass sensitive to Incorporate 5% to 20% Avicel


water content PH-101 (allows a wider range of
water volume, gives shorter,
less doughy, less sticky mass)

Gummy binder Change binder

Active ingredient Use diluted or anhydrous ethyl


or isopropyl alcohol (if latter,
determine acceptable residual
solvent level by GC or other
appropriate method); change
binder

30

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Coarse particles Mottled appearance Design particle size distribution for
in direct compression optimum flow, color distribution,
binding

Segregation Some fines are needed for good


binding

Color distribution Dye migration leading In direct compression, preblend or


to mottling mill color with portion of excipient

In wet granulation, use a dye


soluble in the granulating solution

May help to use a lower


temperature for tray drying; use a
fluid bed dryer

See Color migration

Color migration Colors migrate to Use lakes instead of soluble dyes


granule surface (will minimize but not eliminate)
(wet granulation);
will cause mottling Decrease the size of the wet
tablets; often granules
associated with
case hardening Decrease thickness of granulation
bed; stir granulation bed frequently
during drying to expose fresh
surfaces at the top of the wet
mass

Use Avicel PH-101- reduces


or eliminates dye migration

Compressibility See Binding (bonding or


compressibility)

Content uniformity See Dosage variation

Demixing Segregation/ Optimize blending times specific


separation, usually to mixer (blender) employed
caused by overmixing
rather than See Overblending
undermixing
See Segregation

31

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Density, bulk Usually defined as the See Flow
(loose density) ratio of weight of a
powder (or mixture of See Die fill
powders) to its volume
on an as-is basis See Dry granulation
(not tapped)
Select higher density grades
Low bulk density often Avicel PH-301 and PH-302
related to poor flow
especially at high
dosage (active)

Density, tapped Usually defined as the See Segregation


ratio of weight of a
powder (or mixture of
powders) to its volume
after being tapped or
caused to consolidate
(settle) in some way

Too dense can


cause segregation

Die fill (nonuniform) Lack of consistent Adjust particle size range to


powder flow into dies, recommended optimum for die
causing variations in diameter
tablet weight, hardness,
and disintegration/ Reduce fines
dissolution
Select larger particle size; use
Avicel PH-102 or PH-200 in place
of PH-101 or other excipient

Add glidant (0.1% to 0.5%) (e.g.,


Cab-O-Sil, Aerosil)

Use induced or force-feed


mechanism on press

Change particle shape of active


ingredient to one that is more likely
to flow

32

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Die fill (nonuniform) Dry granulate (by slugging or roller
(continued) compacting) with a mixture of
Avicel, Cab-O-Sil and magnesium
stearate

Process in low humidity atmosphere

Add moisture absorber (e.g.,


0.1% to 0.5% calcium silicate,
Cab-O-Sil, Syloid)

Diluent Inert material(s) See Section 4 for a description


added to give the of excipients and their uses
necessary bulk for
solid dosage
preparation

Dilution potential The percent of an Avicel PH has a very high dilution


active (usually poorly potential when used as a binder
compressible such
as ascorbic acid or
APAP) that can be
compressed with an
excipient to form a
tablet having 1% or
less friability

Direct compression Method of See Sections 2 - 4


manufacturing tablets
by compressing
directly a dry blend of
active and excipient
powders; the powders
are neither wet or dry
granulated

Disintegrant Material added to See Section 4 for a description


tablets to aid them in of excipients and their uses
breaking apart so that
particles of drug can
dissolve

33

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Disintegration too long Tablet hardness too Reduce machine pressure for
or incomplete high acceptable tablets

Use less binder in granulation

Overlubrication Decrease lubricant level


(waterproofing)
Blend lubricant for minimal time
required; establish optimum
blending time

Replace metallic stearates with


other lubricants (e.g., stearic acid)

Requires additional Consider a super disintegrant


disintegrant or a (e.g., Ac-Di-Sol, 2% to 5%)
different disintegrant
Include Avicel PH-101 or PH-102
(added dry), about 10% as an
auxiliary disintegrant

Consider adding a surfactant


(e.g., DOSS, 0.1%)

Tablet hardness too Increase hardness to allow


low swellable disintegrant to function

Disintegration during Caused by soft cores Increase tablet strength (increase


coating or rapidly binder, add better binder,
disintegrating tablets compress harder)

Apply a seal coat


(Aquacoat ECD)

If possible, lower spray rate of


aqueous coating

34

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Dissolution Measure of the rate Use most soluble form of drug
and extent to which
an active component Micronize insoluble drugs - in
is released into general, use smallest particle
solution from a drug size possible
product
Consider using a wetting agent

May or may not be Add additional disintegrant or a


correlated with different disintegrant - granules
bioavailability must disintegrate for good
dissolution

Poor dissolution Optimize tablet hardness versus


friability and disintegration/
dissolution

Conduct preformulation studies


to be certain there is no
active/excipient interaction
(binding)

Use a soluble filler with insoluble


actives

Use less lubricant, establish


optimum blending time

See Bioavailability

See Disintegration

Dosage variation Improper See "Blending, overblending


mixing/segregation and demixing"

See Flow problem

See Segregation

See Die fill (nonuniform)

See Nonuniformity of mix

35

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Doughy mass Too much water Add granulating water slowly;
(often seen on mix well after each addition
scaleup)

Overmixing during Reduce water or mixing time


granulation step

Wrong binder Change binder

Component of mix If possible, use alcohol/water


(e.g., active drug or or alcohol as granulating fluid -
excipient) select appropriate binder, use of
Avicel PH-101 gives 1) less sticky
or doughy mass, which is easier
to screen; and 2) allows a wider
range of solvent volume

Drug migration Drug migration to See Color migration


surface of granulation

May lead to content


uniformity problems
as drug becomes part
of fines after dry
screening, or there is
a loss of drug with
subsequent low tablet
assays

Dry blending See Section A: Dry blending

36

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Dry granulation Method for See Section 2
(by slugging or compacting powders
compaction) by slugging or roller See Slugging
compaction and then
size reducing the See Roll compaction
compacts to the
desired particle size
for tableting

Often preferred when


1) it is difficult or
impossible to directly
compress; and 2) the
actives are unstable
when subjected to wet
granulation

Dry screening Granules too hard Decrease drying temperature


(case hardening)

Decrease water content (use


alcohol/water)

Decrease binder content

Use weaker binder

Moisture in Increase drying time


granulation
Establish optimum moisture
content

Drying Overdrying can cause Set in-process moisture


static flow, case specifications on wet granulated
hardening, drug/color materials
migration, lamination/
capping/splitting See Section A: Drying

Underdrying can See Section A: Drying


cause weak granules
filming, and sticking Control moisture in direct
of punches compression excipients for proper
compressibility

37

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Dye migration See Color migration

Ejection problem See Punch binding

Elastic material Actives or excipients Use materials that have plastic


that are deficient in flow (low in elasticity) and that,
plastic flow properties, once compressed, stay
and therefore lack compressed (do not spring
bonding or binding back), such as Avicel PH
properties

Often are springy or


spongy and have
spring back:
characteristics (i.e.,
return to original
size/shape)

Results in capping,
lamination, splitting,
and lack of
compressibility in
general

Entrapment of air See Air entrapment

Excess fines Low moisture in Decrease drying time; establish


(wet granulation) granulation optimum moisture content

Screen size too small Use larger screen size


(dry screening)

Rotor/screen Adjust clearance of rotor


clearance too close

Overloading Feed granulator gradually


granulator or mill

Weak granules Increase binder content/


granulating fluid

Increase wet massing time

Use stronger binder

38

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Expanding tablets See Elastic material

See Capping and laminating

See Active ingredients

See Binding

Filler Inert material(s) See Section 4 for a description


added to give the of excipients and their uses
necessary bulk for
solid dosage
preparation

Filming of punches See Punch filming or sticking


(picking)

Fines (direct Poor flow An optimum percent of fines


compression) serves a useful purpose of dusting
Improper die fill the actives, especially oleaginous
ones or those with elastic
Poor binding deformation properties, and aids in
in bonding and filling voids within
the tablet

Too many cause segregation

Fines (wet granulation) See Excess fines (wet granulation)

See Fines (direct compression)


above

Flooding Excessive flow Identify causative component and


properties exclude or modify particle size
(fluidization) of one or
more components Select narrow range of particle
(could be from an sizes; avoid excess fines
excess of glidant or
lubricant) Induced or force-feed mechanism
on press may control flow
Flow is erratic and
feed frame is flooded See Flow problem
at times

39

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Flow problem Too many fines in wet Reduce fines (see Dry Screening-
granulation Excess fines)

In direct compression, Select larger particle size; use


particle size of drug or Avicel PH-102 or PH-200 in place
excipients too small of PH-101 or other excipient
and/or of shape that
will not flow Add glidant (0.1% to 0.5%), e.g.,
Cab-O-Sil, Aerosil

Use induced or force-feed


mechanism on press

Change particle shape of active


ingredient to one that is more
likely to flow

Poor inherent flow Add 0.1% to 0.5% glidant

Dry granulate (by slugging or roller


compacting) with a mixture of
Avicel, Cab-O-Sil, and
magnesium stearate

Atmospheric moisture Process in low humidity


absorption atmosphere

Add moisture absorber (e.g.,


0.1% to 0.5% calcium silicate,
Cab-O-Sil, Syloid)

Friability (high) Inadequate bonding Increase binder level or change to


of the tablet matrix stronger binder

Add or increase Avicel PH-101


or PH-102 (10% to 20%), which
give low friability at lower
hardness/machine pressures

Too much or too little Adjust pressure for acceptable


compression pressure friability

40

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Friability (high) Overlubrication Decrease lubricant level
(continued) Blend lubricant for minimal time
required; establish optimum
blending time

Replace metallic stearates with


other lubricants (e.g., stearic acid)

Glidant Excipient used to See Section 4


improve fluidity of
powders Add 0.1% to 0.5% Cab-O-Sil or
Aerosil fumed silica to improve
flow

Small increase in lubricant may be


necessary to offset slight punch/die
binding effect of glidant

Granulation, dry See Dry granulation

See Section 2

Granulation, wet See Wet granulation

See Section 2

Hard tablets Use Avicel to obtain hard tablets


with low machine pressure - also
to reduce tablet friability

See Binding (bonding or


compressibility)

Decrease compressing speed


to increase tablet hardness

41

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Hardness increases Probably more Optimize moisture consent
with time prevalent in wet of granulations
granulated products,
although it can Conduct preformulation studies,
happen in directly even though data at accelerated
compressed tablets temperature/ humidity conditions
may not always be relevant to
Can be caused by shelf-life conditions
water of crystal-
lization/hydration
interacting with
ingredients or other
kinds of interactions
between active
materials/excipients

Hardness, variable Tooling Examine punch lengths

Uneven die fill See Weight variation

Overblending Optimize blending time to minimize


creation of fines

High friability See Friability (high)

High level of active Direct compression High percentages of actives can be


directly compressed depending on
physical form (low density,
entrapped air, etc.), flow, and
compressibility properties

Dry/wet granulation If unable to compress directly, dry


granulation or wet granulation are
possible alternatives depending on
active's physical properties

High relative humidity See Relative humidity

Hopper flow See Die fill

See Flow Problem

See Segregation

42

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Hygroscopic Moisture pick-up Process under low humidity
ingredients conditions

Compress with low moisture grades


Avicel PH-112 and PH-113
Use moisture scavengers (e.g.,
calcium silicate, Syloid,
Cab-O-Sil)

Hygroscopic tablets Moisture pick-up Compress and package underlow


humidity conditions (to maintain
tablet hardness and active
ingredient stability)

Use moisture scavengers (e.g.,


calcium silicate, Syloid,
Cab-O-Sil)

Keep tablet containers well closed


(use adequate closures especially
if plastic or blister packed)

Laminating See Capping and laminating

Layered tablets Poor bonding Use a stronger binder or higher


splitting (poor bonding between layers concentration
between layers; layers
peel or split apart)
Compression Compress at lower pressures
pressure too high

Overlubrication Decrease lubricant level

Blend lubricant for minimal time


required; establish optimum mixing
times

See Capping and laminating

See Lubricants

43

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Loss of hardness Tablets with Avicel PH See Hygroscopic ingredients
(with time) lose some hardness
with time at high See Hygroscopic tablets
humidity, but most of
the hardness is quickly
regained at normal
humidity

Low hardness Compression force Increase pressure (caution - do not


(pressure) too low exceed recommended pressure for
punch size used)

Overlubrication Decrease lubricant level

Blend lubricant for minimal time


required; establish optimum mixing
times

Replace metallic stearates with


other lubricants (e.g., stearic acid)

Granulation too soft Use additional binder

Direct compression - use additional


Avicel PH

Excipient (i.e., too Reduce level of causative excipient


much starch can give
a soft tablet)

Moisture content too Granulation underdried


high
High humidity-use moisture
scavenger or moisture adsorbent
(e.g., calcium silicate, Syloid)

Moisture content too Granulation overdried


low
Low humidity-direct compression
excipients too low in moisture
content

44

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Low to medium level Use 10% to 20% Avicel PH
of active (in direct combined with compressible
compression) lactose and/or dicalcium phosphate

With higher levels of Avicel PH use


less magnesium stearate, since
Avicel PH is self-lubricating

At low-dosage level-blend or mill


active with part (e.g., 10% of
excipient) and then blend with
remainder of formulation

At very low-dosage levels (<1%),


dissolve active in solvent and spray
on excipients

Lubricants Materials added to See Section 4 for a description of


reduce friction excipients and their uses
between the die wall
and the tablet mix, See Punch binding
and hence facilitate
ejection of the tablets Add lubricant at end of blending
from the die operation-do not overblend

Screen into bulk powders through a


40- to 60-mesh screen prior to final
mixing

If disintegration/dissolution is a
problem with magnesium stearate,
use stearic acid (1% to 2%)

With higher levels of Avicel PH use


less magnesium stearate (since
Avicel PH is self-lubricating)

Mixing See Blending

See Section A, Dry blending

45

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Modified direct Modification of direct Dissolve actives in volatile solvents
compression compression process and spray onto excipients
to assure good
dispersion of low-level Granulate a small portion of the
actives or for other formulation and directly compress
reasons this granulation with the remainder
(major part) of the formulation
Avoids granulation of ingredients
entire formulation

Moisture sensitive Unstable in the Use direct compression or dry


actives presence of water granulation

Use low moisture grades Avicel


PH-112 and PH-113

Use nonaqueous granulating


solvent (flammability and residual
solvent cautions must be observed)

Mottling See Color distribution

Nonuniform die fill See Diefill (nonuniform)

Nonuniform drying Poor air flow Correct air circulation pattern


(tray drying) (circulation)
Reduce number of trays

Overloaded trays Reduce tray load

See Drying

Nonuniformity of mix Improper blenderload Use recommended powder load


in blender

Insufficient mixing Increase mixing time

Inefficient (improper) Use alternative mixer with increase


mixer shearing action

Wide particle size Select more uniform particle sizes


distribution of components

Overblending Reduce blending time

Establish optimum mixing


conditions

46

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Nonuniformity of mix Low-dosage actives Use a more effective mixer (one
(continued) with increased shearing action)

Low-level excipients Blend the low-level component with


a portion (5% to 10%) of an
excipient; screen (mill) if necessary;
reblend; add to an equal quantity of
excipient and mix; screen or mill if
necessary; blend normally with
remainder of bulk

Dissolve drug in a suitable solvent


and add or spray onto a portion of
the bulk or an excipient; blend;
remove solvent

Note: For direct compression excipient


blends do not use a screen size or a
mixer which will change the excipient
particle size distribution

Oleaginous or sticky See Punch binding


actives
See Sticky ingredients

Ordered mixing Small-sized (drug) See Section 2


(adhesive blending) particles adhesively
held on the surface of
larger-sized
(excipient) particles

Segregation does not


occur

Usually requires a
high-intensity mixer

47

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Overblending Can cause powder Optimize mixing times
separation
(segregation or See Blending
demixing)

Can cause particle


size reduction leading
to other problems

Can cause
waterproofing of
tablet by lubricant

Oven drying See Drying

Overwetting of A common problem in See Clogging of screen


wet mass wet granulation

Some actives alone


and in combination
with excipients are
more sensitive than
others (due to
solubility)

Partial direct See Modified direct compression


compression

Particle density See Density, bulk (loose density)


variation
See Density, tapped

See Die fill (nonuniform)

See Punch binding

48

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Particle size See Binding (bonding or
distribution compressibility)

See Die fill (nonuniform)

See Fines (direct compression)

See Flooding

`See Flow problem

See Nonuniformity of mix

See Ordered mixing (cohesive


blending)

See Segregation

Picking Tablet surfaces See Punch filming or sticking


pitted

Small areas of
compressed powder
left on punch faces
(mostly upper) after
compression - tablet
surface is picked

Often associated with


punch filming and
sticking

Poor binding See Binding (bonding or


compressibility)

Poor color distribution See Color distribution

See Color migration

Poor flow (rat-holing See Flow problem


or bridging)

49

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Poor granule Wet granulation Granules must be disintegrated
disintegration for prompt and full drug release
(dissolution)

Include a portion (50%) of the


disintegrant (Ac-Di-Sol) for this
purpose in the materials being
granulated (disintegrant inside
the granulation)

Poor layer demarcation Granulation too Reduce particle size of


course granulation - less than 16 mesh

Too many fines Remove fines below 200 mesh

Poor tablet Picking See Filming of punches


finish/appearance
Mottling See Color distribution

Coarse particles See Coarse particles

Postgranulation Excipients added after See Sections 2 and 4


addition drying the granules
and screening them

Examples: disintegrant,
lubricant, additional
binder

Powder separation See Coarse particles

See Demixing

See Fines (direct compression)

See Flow problem

See Nonuniformity of mix

See Overblending

See Segregation

50

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Precompression Application of a See Section 3
relatively small
amount of tableting
pressure immediately
prior to application of
main tableting
pressure

Aids in removing
entrapped air

Aids in preventing/
minimizing capping/
laminating of difficult-
to-compress materials
by allowing time for
relaxation between
compressions

Requires a rotary
tablet machine
equipped for
precompression

Punch and die abrasion Abrasive components Exclude or reduce to a fine particle
size

Increase lubricant level

Blend abrasive component


separately with the lubricant

Use minimum tableting pressure


possible

Use more wear-resistant tooling


(harder metal)

51

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Punch binding (powder Poor finish or worn Polish, reface or replace tooling
adheres to punch punches and dies
edges and dies, Increase or change lubricant; use
punches may bind Inadequate lubrication microfine lubricants; screen into
in dies) mix

Increase lubricant blending time

Too many fines or Design better particle size range;


coarse particles in mix use tapered dies

Wet granulation Dry granulation to satisfactory


insufficiently dried moisture limits

Hygroscopic Process in low humidity conditions


ingredients
Use moisture scavengers (e.g.,
calcium silicate, Syloid,
Cab-O-Sil)

Use low moisture grades


Avicel PH-112 and PH-113

Adhesive or Increase lubricant level


oleaginous
components Add 0.5% Cab-O-Sil or Syloid

Add 5% to 10% Avicel PH-101

Punchfilming or Poorfinish on punch Polish punch faces; refinish


sticking (picking) faces
(powder adhesion to Avoid using certain letters (e.g.,
punch faces, usually Embossed letters A, B, P, R)
upper)
Use shallow embossing with
tapered edges rather than edges
perpendicular to punch face

Punch tips burred Refinish or replace

Punch concavity too Reduce punch concavity or use


great flat-face punches

Poor binding between Increase binder (wet or dry)


surface granules or
particles

Low melting point Adsorb low melting point ingredient


ingredient on Avicel PH, replace with higher
melting point ingredient

52

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Punch filming or Inadequate lubrication Increase or change lubricant
sticking
(continued) Use microfine lubricants, screen
into mix

Increase lubricant mixing time

Insufficiently dried wet Dry granulation and establish


granulation moisture limits

. Hygroscopic Process under low humidity


components conditions

Use moisture adsorbent (e.g.,


calcium silicate, Syloid)
Adhesive components Increase lubricant level

Add 0.5% Cab-O-Sil or Syloid


or 5% to 10% Avicel PH-101

Tablets too soft Increase compression pressure

Rat-holing Limited flow of a See Bridging


powder or mixture
directly over the See Die fill (nonuniform)
discharge of a hopper,
leaving a hole in the See Flow problem
center of the powder
as flow slows or stops See Glidant

Part of the remaining


powder, which is
around the hole, may
fall into the hole with
the net result being
an uneven flow of
powder and/or lumps
from the hopper

Relative humidity (RH) Ratio of the amount of Keep tableting area <55% RH-
water the air is holding higher RH can cause flow problems
to the amount it could and sticking depending on
hold (at saturation) at a materials present
given temperature

53

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Relative humidity (RH) Raising the Keep tableting area >40% to 45%
(continued) temperature, all other RH - lower humidity can cause flow
things remaining because of static and drying out of
constant, lowers the material being compressed with,
relative humidity but perhaps, some loss of
the absolute amount compressibility
of water present is
the same See Hygroscopic ingredients

See Hygroscopic tablets

Roll compacting Forcing powder See Section 2


(almost always a
formulation containing Use Avicel PH-101
filler, lubricant, and
disintegrant) between
two oppositely turning
rolls in order to form a
dense compact in the
form of a relatively flat
sheet as it exits the
rolls

The sheet (which often


breaks under its own
weight as it exits the
rolls) is milled to form
granules, which can
then be used for
tableting after adding
additional lubricant,
disintegrant, etc.

54

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Score line or tablet Faulty punch Redesign using chamfered edges
imprint not sharp embossing design on the punch embossing

Chrome-plate punch face

Granulation too Reduce particle size of granulation


coarse

Binder not strong Use a stronger binder


enough

Screen clogging See Clogging of screen (wet mass)


(wet mass)

Segregation Particle size range of Use a narrower particle size range


mix too wide of ingredients

Limit the amount of the fines present

Too wide a density Control differences in the density


difference of particles

Mixer too vigorous, Use a mixer with a gentler mixing


produces fines action

Use of vibrators (to Use force-feed mechanisms rather


promote flow from than hopper vibrators
hopper)

Slugging Use of relatively large See Dry granulation


punches and dies to
produce tablets from
a poor flowing powder
mix

Tablets usually not


well-controlled with
respect to weight
and hardness

55

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Slugging (continued) Tablets milled to
produce granules
which can then be
used (after adding
additional lubricant,
disintegrant, etc.)
to produce uniform
tablets of desired
size, weight,
hardness, etc.

Soft tablets See Binding (bonding or


compressibility)

See Capping and laminating

See Coarse particles

See Die fill (nonuniform)

See Elastic material

See Excess fines (wet


granulation)

See Friability (high)

See Hardness, variable

See Loss of hardness (with time)

See Low hardness

Splitting (tablets) See Capping and laminating

See Chipping/splitting

Sticking to punch face See Punch filming or sticking

Sticky ingredients Fines in excipient mix (especially


Avicel PH) aid in drying up
oleaginous actives, giving better
flow and tableting

See Punch filming or sticking

See Punch binding

56

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Tablet binding See Punch binding
in the die

Tablets contain dirty Misaligned upper cam Check alignment of upper cam
specks tracks - rubbing of tracks
punches on cam
actually rubs off metal,
which is introduced
into material being
compressed

No lubrication on
upper cam tracks

Excessive or improper Use dust caps on upper punches


lubrication on upper
punch shanks (no dust
caps on punches) -
dust mixes with excess
oil or grease and falls
into material being
compressed

Tablets uniformly Feed frame rubbing Check clearance between feed


discolored on die table frame and die table

Feed hopper rubbing Check clearance between feed


on turret hopper and turret

Abrasive materials Check for presence of abrasive


wearing screens, materials
scooper, etc.

Underblending See Blending

Variable hardness Tooling Examine punch lengths

Uneven die fill See Weight variation

Overblending Optimize blending time to


minimize creation of fines

57

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Weight variation Poor or erratic powder Correct powder flow problems
(outside limits) flow, flooding (See Feed Hopper in Part A)

Particle size range too Narrow the particle size range;


wide avoid excess fines

Particle size not Adjust particle size range to


suitable for die recommended optimum for die
diameter diameter

Punches not within Examine punch length dimensions


specifications
Narrow the particle size range
Particle segregation
as press RPMs Compress at slower RPM
increase
Clean; improve dust collection
Lower punch hang
up (material between Check for proper clearance
lower punch and die between die wall and lower punch
wall or lower punch
and punch guide) Increase lubricant concentration
in formulation

Remove below 200 mesh fines

Wet granulation Process whereby See Section 2


active drugs and
excipients are wet
massed (wet with
a solvent containing
a binder in solution,
usually), screened,
dried, and screened
again

Used for high-dose


active drugs which
have poor flow and
either cannot be or
are difficult to directly
compress

Used for active drugs


which are very fine
and/or low density

58

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
FMC logo, Avicel, Aquacoat and Ac-Di-Sol trademarks of FMC Corporation.
Aerosil trademark of Degussa Aktiengesellschaft.
Cab-O-Sil trademark of Cabot Corporation.
Fitz Mill trademark of Fitzpatrick Company, The Illinois Corporation.
Syloid trademark of W.R. Grace & Co. Connecticut.

1998 FMC Corporation. All rights reserved. RS

59

www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com

You might also like