Problems During Tablet Manufacturing & Its Solution
Problems During Tablet Manufacturing & Its Solution
Problems During Tablet Manufacturing & Its Solution
Table of Contents
Tablet Problems and Remedies........................................................................................................1
Table of Contents .........................................................................................................................1
Part A. Specific Tableting Problems and Remedies (Process Format) ........................................5
Dry Blending .............................................................................................................................5
Particle agglomeration .........................................................................................................5
Nonuniformity of mix ............................................................................................................5
Segregation after blending ..................................................................................................6
Wet Granulation (Massing) ........................................................................................................7
Doughy mass........................................................................................................................7
Moisture sensitive drugs ......................................................................................................7
Wet Screening...........................................................................................................................8
Screen clogging....................................................................................................................8
Drying ......................................................................................................................................9
Nonuniform drying ...............................................................................................................9
Granule case hardening (hard crust forms with incomplete drying inside granule) ................9
Color migration ....................................................................................................................9
Drug migration ...................................................................................................................10
Dry Screening (Dry Granulation) ..............................................................................................11
Excess fines .......................................................................................................................11
Difficult to screen................................................................................................................11
Poor color distribution .......................................................................................................12
Feed Hopper ..........................................................................................................................13
Poor flow.............................................................................................................................13
Flooding ..............................................................................................................................14
Particle segregation............................................................................................................14
Tablet Weight .........................................................................................................................15
Weight variation outside limits ..........................................................................................15
Punches and Dies...................................................................................................................16
Punch binding (powder adheres to punch edges and dies; punches may bind in dies) ......16
Punch filming or sticking (picking)(powder adhesion to punch faces, usually upper) ......17
Punch and die abrasion .....................................................................................................18
Capping and laminating .....................................................................................................18
Chipping/splitting ...............................................................................................................19
Score line or tablet imprint not sharp ................................................................................19
Layered tablets splitting .....................................................................................................20
Layers not sharply defined ................................................................................................20
1 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Low hardness .........................................................................................................................20
Variable hardness ...................................................................................................................21
High friability ...........................................................................................................................21
Disintegration too long ...........................................................................................................22
Mottling ...................................................................................................................................22
Tablets contain dirty specks ...............................................................................................23
Tablets uniformly discolored...................................................................................................23
Part B. General Tableting Problems and Remedies (Alphabetical Order Format) ......................24
Active ingredients ...................................................................................................................24
Adsorbents ............................................................................................................................24
Agglomeration of particles .....................................................................................................24
Aging of tablets.......................................................................................................................24
Air entrapment ........................................................................................................................25
Antiadherent ..........................................................................................................................25
Attraction of particles (aggregation or agglomeration) ............................................................25
Binder ....................................................................................................................................25
Binding (bonding or compressibility) .......................................................................................26
Binding in the die (punches) ...................................................................................................26
Bioavailability ..........................................................................................................................26
Bisected or debossed tablets (not sharp or well-defined) ....................................................26
Blending .................................................................................................................................27
Bonding .................................................................................................................................27
Bridging ..................................................................................................................................27
Brittle fracture .........................................................................................................................28
Bulk density ............................................................................................................................28
Capping and laminating .........................................................................................................28
Case hardening.......................................................................................................................29
Chipping/splitting ..................................................................................................................30
Clogging of screen (wet mass) ...............................................................................................30
Coarse particles......................................................................................................................31
Color distribution ....................................................................................................................31
Color migraton........................................................................................................................31
Compressibility .......................................................................................................................31
Content uniformity ..................................................................................................................31
Density, bulk (loose density) .........................................................................................................32
Density, tapped.......................................................................................................................32
Die fill (nonuniform) ..................................................................................................................32
Diluent ....................................................................................................................................33
Dilution potential.....................................................................................................................33
Direct compression.................................................................................................................33
Disintegrant ............................................................................................................................33
Disintegration too long or incomplete....................................................................................34
Disintegration during coating .................................................................................................34
Dissolution ..............................................................................................................................35
2 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Dosage variation.....................................................................................................................35
Doughy mass..........................................................................................................................36
Drug migration ........................................................................................................................36
Dry blending............................................................................................................................36
Dry granulation (by slugging or compaction)...........................................................................37
Dry screening..........................................................................................................................37
Dye migration..........................................................................................................................38
Ejection problem.....................................................................................................................38
Elastic material........................................................................................................................38
Entrapment of air ....................................................................................................................38
Excess fines (wet granulation) .................................................................................................38
Expanding tablets...................................................................................................................39
Filler ....................................................................................................................................39
Filming of punches .................................................................................................................39
Fines (direct compression) .......................................................................................................39
Fines (wet granulation).............................................................................................................39
Flooding ..................................................................................................................................39
Flow problem ..........................................................................................................................40
Friability (high) .........................................................................................................................40
Glidant ....................................................................................................................................41
Granulation, dry ......................................................................................................................41
Granulation, wet .....................................................................................................................41
Hard tablets ............................................................................................................................41
Hardness increases with time ................................................................................................42
Hardness, variable ..................................................................................................................42
High friability ...........................................................................................................................42
High relative humidity .............................................................................................................42
Hopper flow ............................................................................................................................42
Hygroscopic ingredients.........................................................................................................43
Hygroscopic tablets................................................................................................................43
Laminating ..............................................................................................................................43
Layered tablets splitting (poor bonding between layers; layers peel or split apart) .................43
Loss of hardness (with time) ...................................................................................................44
Loss of hardness ....................................................................................................................44
Low to medium level of active (in direct compression)...........................................................45
Lubricants ...............................................................................................................................45
Mixing ....................................................................................................................................45
Modified direct compression..................................................................................................46
Moisture sensitive actives ......................................................................................................46
Mottling ...................................................................................................................................46
Nonuniform die fill...................................................................................................................46
Nonuniform drying (tray drying) ..............................................................................................46
Nonuniformity of mix ..............................................................................................................46
Oleaginous or sticky actives ..................................................................................................47
3 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Ordered mixing (adhesive blending) ........................................................................................47
Overblending ..........................................................................................................................48
Oven drying ............................................................................................................................48
Overwetting of wet mass .......................................................................................................48
Partial direct compression......................................................................................................48
Particle density variation .......................................................................................................48
Particle size distribution .........................................................................................................49
Picking ....................................................................................................................................49
Poor binding ...........................................................................................................................49
Poor color distribution ............................................................................................................49
Poor flow (rat-holing or bridging) .......................................................................................49
Poor granule disintegration ....................................................................................................50
Poor layer demarcation ..........................................................................................................50
Poor tablet finish/appearance ................................................................................................50
Postgranulation addition ........................................................................................................50
Powder separation .................................................................................................................50
Precompression......................................................................................................................51
Punch and die abrasion .........................................................................................................51
Punch binding (powder adheres to punch edges and dies; punches may bind in dies) ..........52
Punch filming or sticking (picking)(powder adhesion to punch faces, usually upper) ..........52
Rat-holing ..............................................................................................................................53
Relative humidity (RH).............................................................................................................53
Roll compacting......................................................................................................................54
Score line or tablet imprint not sharp ....................................................................................55
Screen clogging (wet mass)....................................................................................................55
Segregation.............................................................................................................................55
Slugging ..................................................................................................................................55
Soft tablets ............................................................................................................................56
Splitting (tablets)......................................................................................................................56
Sticking to punch face ...........................................................................................................56
Sticky ingredients ...................................................................................................................56
Tablet binding in the die .........................................................................................................57
Tablets contain dirty specks ...............................................................................................57
Tablets uniformly discolored...................................................................................................57
Underblending .......................................................................................................................57
Variable hardness ...................................................................................................................57
Weight variation (outside limits)...............................................................................................58
Wet granulation.......................................................................................................................58
4 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Part A. Specific Tableting Problems and remedies (Process Format)
Dry Blending
5 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Nonuniformity of mix Low-level excipients Blend the low-level component
(continued) with a portion (5% to 10%) of an
excipient; screen (mill) if
necessary; reblend; add to an
equal quantity of excipient and
mix; screen or mill if necessary;
blend normally with remainder
of bulk
6 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Wet Granulation (Massing)
7 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Wet Screening
8 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Drying
Granule case hardening Too rapid evaporation Try recirculating oven air (damper
(hard crust forms with of water closed) for initial 15 to 30 minutes,
incomplete drying then open damper partially for a
inside granule) Oven drying short period, and finally open
conditions too efficient damper fully
9 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Drug migration Drug migrates to See remedies under Color
granule surfaces; migration
content uniformity
problems may result
as drug becomes part
of fines after dry
screening, or there is
a loss of drug with
subsequent low tablet
assays
10 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Dry Screening (Dry Granulation)
11 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Poor color distribution Dye migration to Use lakes instead of soluble dyes
granule surface (will minimize but not eliminate
(nonuniformity of problem)
color throughout
granule) Decrease the size of the wet
granules
12 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Feed Hopper
rat-holing
13 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Flooding Excessive flow Identify causative component and
properties (fluidization) exclude or modify particle size
of one or more
components (could be Select narrow range of particle
from an excess of sizes; avoid excess fines
glidant or lubricant)
Particle segregation Particle size range of Use a narrower particle size range
mix too wide of ingredients
14 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Table Weight
15 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Punches and Dies
16 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Punch filming or Poor finish on punch Polish punch faces; refinish
sticking (picking) faces
(powder adhesion to Avoid using certain letters
punch faces, usually Embossed letters (e.g., A, B, P, R)
upper)
Use shallow embossing with
tapered edges rather than edges
directly perpendicular to punch
face
17 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Punch and die abrasion Abrasive components Exclude or reduce to a fine particle
size
18 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Capping and laminating High level of Use precompression on tablet
(continued) ingredient with poor press
compression
properties (also Slow the speed of the tablet
sometimes ascribed machine
to air-entrapment by
powder bed)
19 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Layered tablets Poor bonding Use a stronger binder or higher
splitting between layers concentration
20 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Low hardness Moisture consent too Determine optimum moisture
(continued) high (granulation content
underdried or high
humidity in Use moisture adsorbent (e.g.,
compressing area) calcium silicate, Syloid)
Moisture content too Determine optimum moisture
low (granulation content
overdried or low
humidity in Add additional moisture
compressing area)
21 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Disintegration too long Tablet hardness too Reduce machine pressure for
high acceptable tablets
22 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Mottling In direct compression, Use microfine lake dye
(continued) uneven distribution of
lake dye Increase blending time
Tablets contain dirty Misaligned upper cam Check alignment of upper cam
specks tracks - rubbing of tracks
punches on cam
actually rubs off metal
which is introduced
into material being
compressed
No lubrication on
upper cam tracks
23 www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Part B. General Tableting Problems and Remedies
(Alphabetical Order Format)
See Density
24
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Air entrapment Very low density See Capping and laminating
materials with very
high porosity See Binding
(sometimes ascribed
as cause for tablet
capping, splitting,
or laminating)
See Blending
Direct compression -
substances which give
compressibility or
cohesiveness to the
powder mix
25
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Binding (bonding or Relative degree of See Blending
compressibility) cohesiveness
between particles or Be careful not to overblend or
granules overlubricate
26
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Blending Mixing of powders to Optimize blending or mixing time
obtain a homogeneous
mixture (for
compression)
Optimized blending
may depend on type
of mixer (low shear,
high shear, etc.)
Overblending is
probably more
common than
underblending
Overblending causes
overdistribution of the
lubricant which can
result in poor
disintegration/
dissolution, poor
compressibility,
demixing
(segregation)
27
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Brittle fracture Bonding mechanism See Section 2 for a discussion
of some materials of compression mechanisms
(e.g., lactose), in which
single particles fracture
under pressure to
produce multiple
particles having clean
surfaces, which then
bond with each other
to form a compact
28
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Capping and laminating High level of Use precompression on tablet
(continued) ingredient with press
poor compression
properties (also Slow the speed of the tablet
sometimes ascribed machine
to air-entrapment by
powder bed)
29
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Chipping/splitting Poor finish or worn Polish, reface, or replace punches
punches and dies and dies
See Binding/bonding
30
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Coarse particles Mottled appearance Design particle size distribution for
in direct compression optimum flow, color distribution,
binding
31
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Density, bulk Usually defined as the See Flow
(loose density) ratio of weight of a
powder (or mixture of See Die fill
powders) to its volume
on an as-is basis See Dry granulation
(not tapped)
Select higher density grades
Low bulk density often Avicel PH-301 and PH-302
related to poor flow
especially at high
dosage (active)
32
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Die fill (nonuniform) Dry granulate (by slugging or roller
(continued) compacting) with a mixture of
Avicel, Cab-O-Sil and magnesium
stearate
33
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Disintegration too long Tablet hardness too Reduce machine pressure for
or incomplete high acceptable tablets
34
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Dissolution Measure of the rate Use most soluble form of drug
and extent to which
an active component Micronize insoluble drugs - in
is released into general, use smallest particle
solution from a drug size possible
product
Consider using a wetting agent
See Bioavailability
See Disintegration
See Segregation
35
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Doughy mass Too much water Add granulating water slowly;
(often seen on mix well after each addition
scaleup)
36
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Dry granulation Method for See Section 2
(by slugging or compacting powders
compaction) by slugging or roller See Slugging
compaction and then
size reducing the See Roll compaction
compacts to the
desired particle size
for tableting
37
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Dye migration See Color migration
Results in capping,
lamination, splitting,
and lack of
compressibility in
general
38
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Expanding tablets See Elastic material
See Binding
39
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Flow problem Too many fines in wet Reduce fines (see Dry Screening-
granulation Excess fines)
40
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Friability (high) Overlubrication Decrease lubricant level
(continued) Blend lubricant for minimal time
required; establish optimum
blending time
See Section 2
See Section 2
41
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Hardness increases Probably more Optimize moisture consent
with time prevalent in wet of granulations
granulated products,
although it can Conduct preformulation studies,
happen in directly even though data at accelerated
compressed tablets temperature/ humidity conditions
may not always be relevant to
Can be caused by shelf-life conditions
water of crystal-
lization/hydration
interacting with
ingredients or other
kinds of interactions
between active
materials/excipients
See Segregation
42
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Hygroscopic Moisture pick-up Process under low humidity
ingredients conditions
See Lubricants
43
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Loss of hardness Tablets with Avicel PH See Hygroscopic ingredients
(with time) lose some hardness
with time at high See Hygroscopic tablets
humidity, but most of
the hardness is quickly
regained at normal
humidity
44
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Low to medium level Use 10% to 20% Avicel PH
of active (in direct combined with compressible
compression) lactose and/or dicalcium phosphate
If disintegration/dissolution is a
problem with magnesium stearate,
use stearic acid (1% to 2%)
45
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Modified direct Modification of direct Dissolve actives in volatile solvents
compression compression process and spray onto excipients
to assure good
dispersion of low-level Granulate a small portion of the
actives or for other formulation and directly compress
reasons this granulation with the remainder
(major part) of the formulation
Avoids granulation of ingredients
entire formulation
See Drying
46
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Nonuniformity of mix Low-dosage actives Use a more effective mixer (one
(continued) with increased shearing action)
Usually requires a
high-intensity mixer
47
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Overblending Can cause powder Optimize mixing times
separation
(segregation or See Blending
demixing)
Can cause
waterproofing of
tablet by lubricant
48
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Particle size See Binding (bonding or
distribution compressibility)
See Flooding
See Segregation
Small areas of
compressed powder
left on punch faces
(mostly upper) after
compression - tablet
surface is picked
49
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Poor granule Wet granulation Granules must be disintegrated
disintegration for prompt and full drug release
(dissolution)
Examples: disintegrant,
lubricant, additional
binder
See Demixing
See Overblending
See Segregation
50
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Precompression Application of a See Section 3
relatively small
amount of tableting
pressure immediately
prior to application of
main tableting
pressure
Aids in removing
entrapped air
Aids in preventing/
minimizing capping/
laminating of difficult-
to-compress materials
by allowing time for
relaxation between
compressions
Requires a rotary
tablet machine
equipped for
precompression
Punch and die abrasion Abrasive components Exclude or reduce to a fine particle
size
51
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Punch binding (powder Poor finish or worn Polish, reface or replace tooling
adheres to punch punches and dies
edges and dies, Increase or change lubricant; use
punches may bind Inadequate lubrication microfine lubricants; screen into
in dies) mix
52
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Punch filming or Inadequate lubrication Increase or change lubricant
sticking
(continued) Use microfine lubricants, screen
into mix
Relative humidity (RH) Ratio of the amount of Keep tableting area <55% RH-
water the air is holding higher RH can cause flow problems
to the amount it could and sticking depending on
hold (at saturation) at a materials present
given temperature
53
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Relative humidity (RH) Raising the Keep tableting area >40% to 45%
(continued) temperature, all other RH - lower humidity can cause flow
things remaining because of static and drying out of
constant, lowers the material being compressed with,
relative humidity but perhaps, some loss of
the absolute amount compressibility
of water present is
the same See Hygroscopic ingredients
54
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Score line or tablet Faulty punch Redesign using chamfered edges
imprint not sharp embossing design on the punch embossing
55
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Slugging (continued) Tablets milled to
produce granules
which can then be
used (after adding
additional lubricant,
disintegrant, etc.)
to produce uniform
tablets of desired
size, weight,
hardness, etc.
See Chipping/splitting
56
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Tablet binding See Punch binding
in the die
Tablets contain dirty Misaligned upper cam Check alignment of upper cam
specks tracks - rubbing of tracks
punches on cam
actually rubs off metal,
which is introduced
into material being
compressed
No lubrication on
upper cam tracks
57
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
Problem/Concept Cause/Definition Remedy/Suggested Solution
Weight variation Poor or erratic powder Correct powder flow problems
(outside limits) flow, flooding (See Feed Hopper in Part A)
58
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com
FMC logo, Avicel, Aquacoat and Ac-Di-Sol trademarks of FMC Corporation.
Aerosil trademark of Degussa Aktiengesellschaft.
Cab-O-Sil trademark of Cabot Corporation.
Fitz Mill trademark of Fitzpatrick Company, The Illinois Corporation.
Syloid trademark of W.R. Grace & Co. Connecticut.
59
www.pharmatechbd.blogspot.com