Chanting
Chanting
Chanting
THERAVADA BUDDHISM
AN AUDIO VISUAL DOCUMENTATION PROJECT AT BODH GAYA
YEAR 2008
1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
2
CONTENTS
Pages
Introduction 2
CHAPTER I
Theravada Buddhism : A Brief Note 6-7
CHAPTER II
Pali Tipitaka Chanting : An Introductory Note 8-10
CHAPTER III
Scope of Studies 11-12
CHAPTER IV
Field Documentation 13-214
Section 1: Bodh Gaya- the place of Enlightenment 13-21
Section 2: Beneath the Sacred Bodhi Tree : Gurukul and Buddhist Chanting
Tradition- an interactive session 21-24
Section 3: Inauguration of the 3rd Annual Pali Tipitaka Chanting
Ceremony at Bodh Gaya 24-25
Section 4: Chanting of Majjhima Nikaya 26-36
Section 5: The essence of the Majjhima Nikaya Suttas 36-163
Section 6: Chanting Tradition of the participating countries:
An understanding 163-210
6.1 Sri Lanka 164-176
6.2 Bangladesh 177-182
6.3 India 182-183
6.4 Nepal 183-185
6.5 Myanmar 185-189
6.6 Thailand 189-192
6.7 Cambodia 192-194
6.8 Laos 195-197
6.9 Chakma 197
6.10 Non-conventional countries : Australia, U.S.A. 197-199
6.11 International Meditation Centre 199-200
3
6.12 Dhamma Society, Thailand 200-202
6.13 Other Temples around Bodh Gaya 202-
203
Section 7. A day in a bhikkhus life 203-205
Section 8. Attire of a bhikkhu 205-207
CHAPTER V
In road to the Southeast Asian Theravada Buddhist Tradition 207-243
Summing up 244
Bibliography 245
4
PALI TIPITAKA CHANTING : ORAL TRADITION OF
THERAVADA BUDDHISM
AN AUDIO-VISUAL DOCUMENTATION AT BODH GAYA
11TH TO 22ND FEBRUARY, 2008
Indira Gandhi National Centre for the Arts (IGNCA), an autonomous body
under Ministry of Culture, Govt. of India, New Delhi had undertaken a detailed audio-
visual documentation programme of the 3rd annual Pali Tipitaka chanting ceremony
held in Bodh Gaya by the monks and lay devotees of eight South and South-East
Asian Theravada countries, viz. India, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Nepal, Myanmar,
Thailand, Cambodia and Laos and organized by the Maha Bodhi Society of India, in
view of research in the context of Buddhist chanting and oral wisdom, from 11th to
22nd February, 2008. In this regard, I, Arpita Sen, was involved in the project for co-
ordination, research and textual inputs of chanting.
As I was guided and instructed by Dr. Gautam Chatterjee of IGNCA, I am
enclosing a report of the said documentation as well as future perspective for further
detailed research.
5
INTRODUCTION
The audio-visual documentation of the Pali Tipitaka chanting ceremony in
Bodh Gaya is a continuation of the Pilot Project on Buddhist chanting tradition
commenced in Kolkata (22nd to 29th Nov. 2007). In that project, while we documented
a few suttas functioning mainly with healing and protection in Theravada tradition,
Kathina Chivara Dana festival celebrated in Theravada tradition, we could document
the chanting of a chapter of Japan.
Understanding a broader event going to be happen in Bodh Gaya, as eight of
the countries of Indian sub-continent and South-East Asia participating in the Pali
Tipitaka chanting in Theravada tradition in their respective style in one place, i.e.
under the Sacred Bodhi Tree- a rare opportunity to experience we have documented
this tradition in every aspect as far as possible.
Our main focus was to document Majjhima Nikaya of Sutta Pitaka (The
Basket of Discourses) of Tripitaka, canonical text of the Theravada Buddhist
tradition. The reason behind this documentation is mainly to preserve the hereditary
oral wisdom for the future generation, and also on the other hand, to open up a scope
for comparative and analytical study of different schools in Buddhist chanting
tradition. Tracing out the origin of the monastic training is also of our concern. The
study also focuses on whether any changes have come in the daily life of a monk, in
their monastic education and their style of chanting. In future, the study may extend to
the Mahayana tradition.
The literature of Theravada tradition remains in Pali and fortunately ninety
percent of the literature is published. But at the same time, we observe that though all
the Theravada countries follow the same tradition in chanting, but the phonetics,
speed, rhythm, punctuation while reciting vary drastically.
It is observed that the monks of India, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Nepal were
seated together. And there were different pandals or canopies for Thailand, Myanmar,
Cambodia and Laos.
Later on, it is found that out of 152 suttas of Majjhima Nikaya, Indian sub-
continent group has completed up to Cula-Assapura Sutta (no.40), whereas the
Cambodians have gone up to Bhaddali Sutta (no.65). The Thai monks have finished
Mahatanhasankhaya Sutta (no.38) and Laos up to Maha Assapura Sutta (no.39). The
6
Myanmar monks could only finish 152 suttas as well as a repetition of half of
Majjhima Nikaya.
Besides this, we have found that there is an effort going on to train the monks
in a uniform style of chanting, so that there will be no discrimination among the
Theravada traditions of different countries.
Apparently, it sounds great as it will be more uniformed, harmonious and in
one level more identified as Theravada tradition.
But, the danger lies under this whether indigenous culture of a country would
be influenced or superimposed by the others or forced to follow them or destroyed in
the future.
The necessity of preservation of the tradition lies here and that is one of the
objectives of IGNCA. The changes in daily routine of a monk, oral and textual
training in the monasteries or any new development in style of chanting are to be
reviewed in the concerned study.
We have done 52 hours of audio-visual documentation by multi-camera set up
and another 24 hours in a single camera.
On the 11th, the Maha Bodhi Society of India organized an interactive session
named Beneath the Sacred Bodhi Tree: Gurukul and Buddhist chanting tradition in
collaboration with the IGNCA. The session has seen a gathering of the learned monks
from different countries discussing about the chanting tradition as well as the
gurukul system. Though in Buddhism, the term gurukul is not found, but the
concept of the gurukul exists in a strong way to maintain the lineage and tradition.
The study points out the monastic education by which a monk is elevated from
the worldly life.
In the opening ceremony on 12th Feb. 2008, a colourful procession of the
Buddhist countries in their respective traditional way was seen which is a rare
phenomenon to be watched.
Apart from the chanting, we have documented the rituals performed in each
canopy during the chanting, the offerings by lay devotees to the temple or to the
monks. We could even document a pabajja ceremony (ordination) of a Thai young
man.
7
The ambience of the Mahabodhi Mahavihara is documented through various
ritualistic performances and chanting by Tibetans, Japanese, Taiwanese, Korean,
Vietnamese and many other countries.
The documentation also shows the full-moon day celebrations by each country
during this period. Specially, the Cambodian and Laotian monks chanted the gatha
related to the Buddha in their own language. The Sri Lankans observed the day by
chanting Dhammacakka pavattana sutta.
We have visited the temples of each participating country to realize the
architecture of the monastery, the religion of art and the daily activities of the temple.
We could interview the monks from each country and it has helped us to
understand how the transmission of oral wisdom goes through the generations,and,
also to understand if there are any changes coming in a monks life or in their
monastic education.
In this regard, we have taken valuable bytes of the veteran monks like Ven. U.
Nyaneinda Maha Thero, Chief Priest, Burmese Vihara, Bodh Gaya; Ven. Dr.
Phramaha Boondham Sucitto of Thailand; Ven. S. Dharmapal Maha Thero,
Sanghanayak of Bangladesh; Ve. Dr. Rastrapal Maha Thero, Sangharaj of India; Ven.
Pragyadip Bhikkhu, Treasurer, All India Bhikkhu Sangha.
We could interview Ven. P. Seewalee Thero, Dy. General Secretary, MBSI,
Ven. K. Gnanananda Thero, Precept Master of the monks from India, Bangladesh, Sri
Lanka and Nepal; Ven. Dr. M. Dhammajothi Thero, Senior Lecturer, University of
Colombo; Ven. Dr. Varasambodhi Bhikkhu, Secretary, International Meditation
Centre, Bodh Gaya.
Ven. P. Metta Thero, High Priest, Cambodian Temple, Bodh Gaya, Ven.
Oudorn Phetchampone Bhikkhu, Assistant Secretary, The Laos Buddhist Fellowship
Organisation and Ven. Bhikkhu Kondanya, Gen. Secy., All Nepal Bhikkhu
Association have enlightened us delivering their views.
We had among us Ven. Bhikkhu Sujato of Australia and Ven. Bhikkhuni
Tathaaloka of U.S.A. who have not come from the tradition by birth, but who are in
the Order for a long time. They have shared their experiences with us.
It is worthy mentioning here that apart from the Pali chanting, we could
document chanting of special suttas and gathas translated in the languages of a
country so to understand the indigenous incorporations in the respective tradition.
8
We have got the off-camera interactions with Ven. Pannarama Thero, In-
charge, Maha Bodhi Society of India, Kolkata, Ven. Wajirawamsa Thero, MBSI,
Kolkata, Ven. Buddharakkhita Thero, In-charge, Bidarshan Siksha Kendra, Kolkata,
Rev. Sraman Tissajyoti, Bidarshan Siksha Kendra, Ven. Ashin Theirinda Thero, In-
charge, Burmese Vihara, Kolkata, Ven. Wanna Thero, In-charge, Great Holy Land
Monastery, Bodh Gaya, Ven. Kusalacitta Thero, MBSI, Bodh Gaya, Ven. Phradev
Bodhivides, Abbot, Royal Thai Monastery, Bodh Gaya and Ven. Aggvanno Thero,
Royal Thai Monastery, Bodh Gaya.
Major S. Bunnag, Chancellor, Dhamma Society Fund, Thailand and Prof.
Toshiichi Endo, Prof. of Pali and Buddhist Studies, Univ. of Kelaniya, Sri Lanka have
given their views on the future projects of Tipitaka publications and training.
We have documented a day in a bhikkhus life and tried to understand the
monastic life he leads, the rules of vinaya he observes, the monastic education he
acquires, the society he interacts with.
The elderly monks have enlightened us by their valuable knowledge on the
dress code or the robe or civara of a bhikkhu. The colours, measurements, divisions,
stitches are vividly documented. Even, the dress code of a bhikkhuni of Taiwanese
tradition is documented.
Moreover, the temples of Bodh Gaya as a whole have been visited and some
have been documented from the outer side. The surrounding areas of Bodh Gaya like
Gaya Sisa, Dungeswari Mountain and Sujata village have been visited.
The concerned study incorporates all these unique features and draw a bigger
landscape to open up a scope for further study on the chanting tradition of Buddhism.
9
CHAPTER I
THERAVADA BUDDHISM : A BRIEF NOTE
10
Anuradhapura was sent there to establish the Nun Order in China. Then it was spread
to Korea.
In 1996, 11 selected Sri Lankan nuns were ordained fully as bhikkhunis by a
team of Theravada monks with the Korean nuns in India. There is disagreement
among the Theravada vinaya authorities that whether this ordination is valid. In the
last few years the Dambulla chapter of Siam Nikaya in Sri Lanka has carried out
ordination ceremonies for hundreds of nuns. This has been criticized by the other
Nikayas. Even the Burmese monks disagree with this ordination.
Though women in Thailand can not ordain as bhikkhuni, they can take part in
monastic practices at temples and practice centres. The female Theravada bhikkhuni
lineage was never established in Thailand. As a result, the women in Thailand are not
meant to play an active role in monastic life. A small number of women choose to
become Mae Ji, non-ordained religious specialists who permanently observe either the
eight or ten precepts.
Ordination
The minimum age for the first ordination or pabajja is seven and they are
ordained as samaneras or novices. The minimum age for ordaining as a monk or
bhikkhu is 20 years and the higher ordination is known as upasampada. The monks
follow 227 vinaya rules whereas the nuns follow 311 rules of discipline.
In most Theravada countries, it is a common practice for young men to ordain
as monks for a fixed period of time. In Thailand and Myanmar, young men ordain for
the three month Rain Retreat (vassa). Traditionally, temporary ordination was even
more flexible among Laotians. Throughout South-east Asia, there is little stigma
attached to leaving the monastic life.
In Sri Lanka, temporary ordination is not practiced, and a monk leaving the
Order is frowned upon.
11
CHAPTER II
PALI TIPITAKA CHANTING : AN INTRODUCTORY NOTE
The chanting tradition in Buddhism is one of the core factors in Buddhist way
of life. Both in Theravada and Mahayana schools, the chanting with a touch of ritual
remains as a dormant factor.
12
of Buddhist textual tradition. But this language is originated as the language of
Theravada school which encompasses scripts of Sinhalese, Burmese, Thai,
Cambodian, Tuatham of Laos. And it is noteworthy that ninety nine percent of Pali
literature is published. On the other hand, as Sanskrit remained the main language in
North India since the Gupta period of 1st century B.C. to the medieval era and which
spread up to Central Asia wherein the Buddhism travelled very deep at the conceptual
level, but unfortunately the literature is still unpublished.
Scholars say that most of the denominations of Buddhist religion which
flourished in India and countries far and near, have their own canons, divergent in
language and order. The Theravada sect succeeded in preserving their canons,
recorded in the Magadhi language in both oral and written traditions since the 1st cent.
B.C. Pali is a modern name of the language. It is still unknown whether Pali and
Magadhi are the same or not.
13
Atthakathas and the commentaries and an authentic edition of this vast literature was
subsequently printed and published in Burmese script.
Theravada Buddhism prevails in a small region of the eastern-most part of
Bengal, now in Bangladesh. They are much influenced by the adjacent areas of
Myanmar but later on the Sri Lankan monks took a leading role in the chanting
process.
In Nepal, Theravada tradition and chanting Pali Tipitaka is a very new
phenomenon. Here also, the monks are being guided by the Sri Lankan tradition.
Though, we find that there are many schools in Theravada countries like Sri
Lanka, Bangladesh, Thailand, Myanmar, Cambodia and Laos- who all chant in Pali,
yet their recitation with pause, punctuation, accent, phonetic style and rhythm vary
drastically.
14
CHAPTER III
SCOPE OF STUDIES
15
We can sumarise the above as follows:
i) To trace the tradition of chanting in different countries
ii) To document Buddhist chanting as a healing tradition
iii) To identify monks who can render chanting in Pali and also the incorporation of
gathas and Buddha Vandanas
iv) To document Pali chanting tradition as well as the indigenous incorporation of the
respective country
v) To document the changing trends in chanting tradition and incorporation of local
practices and absorption of the influence of Tibetan and other East Asian context
vi) To document a comparative study between the Tripitaka chanting (mainly
discourses) and Paritta chanting (protective suttas)
vii)To document different patterns and rhythms of sutta chanting according to the Pali
texts available specially in Sri Lanka
viii)To document banaka tradition of Sri Lanka
ix) To document religio-cultural celebrations in South and South-east Asian countries
x) To create a cultural mapping in North-eastern states of India
xi) To create the cultural mapping of Mahayana countries
xii)To document Buddhist chanting in view of Mahayana tradition
xiii)To collect all available literature, books in the context of chanting
16
CHAPTER IV
FIELD DOCUMENTATION
SECTION 1
BODH GAYA THE PLACE OF ENLIGHTENMENT
Prince Siddhartha of the Sakyan dynasty, then a young ascetic, worn out by
years of self-mortification, arrived at the outskirts of the small village of Uruvela by
the side of the river Neranjara. It was just before the full-moon day of Vesak about the
year 528 B.C.
He settled there for meditation. At the last watch of the full-moon day of
Vesak, he saw the Truth in all its glory and splendour. He had become the Fully
Enlightened One, the Fully Awakened One, the Compassionate One, the Supreme
Buddha.
The Buddha spent the next seven weeks near Uruvela after experiencing the
bliss of enlightenment. Then he set off for Isipatana near Varanasi to proclaim the
truth he had realized.
Bodh Gaya or Buddha Gaya has been known by several names over the
centuries. They are: Sambodhi, Bodhimanda, Vajrasana and Mahabodhi. The most
commonly used of these names was Sambodhi meaning complete enlightenment.
Even in the Eighth Asokan Rock Edict, we find that he went to visit Sambodhi
referring to his pilgrimage to Bodh Gaya.
Bodhimanda, another common name, refers to a circular area around the
Bodhi Tree.
17
The exact place where the Buddha sat when he was enlightened is called
Vajrasana, the Diamond Throne. It was called as Pathavinabhi, the Navel of the
Earth.
The most widely used name of Bodh Gaya was Mahabodhi meaning Great
Enlightenment. Originally a term for the Buddhas experience, it later came to be used
as a name for the place where that experience had happened.
The name Bodh Gaya was first used towards the end of the 18th century and it
appears on all Indian Geographical Survey maps.
Mahabodhi Mahavihara
The Mahabodhi Mahavihara is one of the shrines out of the 84,000 shrines
erected by King Asoka in the 3rd cent. B.C. It is still unknown how long it took to
create this magnificent structure or who had built the temple. This great Temple is an
example of classical Indian temple architecture.
Architecture: One large inward sloping spire (sikhara) 52 metres high and four
smaller ones tipped with amalakas rise from a rectangular base (pancayatana) inside
of which is the sanctum (gabhara). The Temple is built entirely of brick except for the
doorframes, the paving on the floor and the four pillars at the entrance which are
made of blue-black granite. The outer surface is covered with decorated moulded
plaster.
According to Hiuen Tsang, the Vihara was probably built in the early 5 th
century A.D.
It is widely believed that Bodh Gayas temples and monasteries were
destroyed during the Muslim invasion of India in 1199. There is, however, no
evidence to support this belief. On the contrary, the records show that Bodh Gaya
continued to function as a centre of Buddhist worship upto at least the beginning of
the 15th century, about two hundred years after the beginning of Muslim rule.
According to Dharmasvamin, there were 300 Sri Lankan monks in the
Mahabodhi Monastery in the year 1234.
The pilgrims from Burma, Tibet and other countries used to come to pay
veneration to the Buddha. However, with the decline of Buddhism in India and
downfall of royal patronage from different countries, the monks drifted away one by
one and the place was eventually deserted.
18
The Temple underwent several restorations, renovations and repairs in
subsequent periods by a number of devout kings and donors from home and abroad.
In 1874, by the deputations of the Burmese King Mindon-Min, and with the
permission of the Govt. of India, the thorough renovation of the Temple took place,
which completed in 1884 under the supervision of the British archaeologists Sir A.
Cunningham and J.D. Beglar and the Indian archaeologist Dr. Rajendra Lal Mitra.
Again in 1956, on the occasion of 2500th Buddha Jayanti celebrations, Govt. of
India did some repair works and enlarged the premises of the Temple.
19
The present tree is of course not the original one. Legend says that wife of
King Asoka cut down the Bodhi Tree out of jealousy but it sprouted again
miraculously. Another legend says that King Pusyamitra (187-151 B.C.) also tried to
destroy it.
Finally in about 600 A.D. King Sasanka certainly destroyed the Tree and it
must have died off and been replanted on at least several other occasions.
In 1880, Sir A. Cunningham took a seed and planted it in its place, so that the
Tree what we see today is a direct ancestor of the original one.
At the foot of the Bodhi Tree, there is a large stone originally placed on the
Vajrasana. This stone is 143x238x13.5 centimetres and has unusual geometrical
patterns on its upper surface and a line of geese around its sides. This is the oldest
antiquity still to be seen at Bodh Gaya.
Vajrasana (The Diamond Throne)
The Vajrasana or the Diamond Throne is the Seat of Enlightenment which was
made in the 3rd cent. B.C. by Emperor Asoka. It lies between the Temple and the
Bodhi Tree.
The Vajrasana is made out of red sandstone, 7 ft 6 inches in length, 4 ft 10
inches in breadth and 3 ft in height.
Aswaghosa in his Buddhacarita reveals that this place is the Navel of the
Earth. Fa-Hien, the Chinese traveller noted that it was at this place where all the past
Buddhas had attained Enlightenment and where all the future Buddhas must come to
achieve the same goal.
The Railing
Records show that the first railing around the Bodhi Tree was made of wood.
In the Sunga period (2nd 1st cent. B.C.), this was replaced by the richly carved
sandstone and granite pillars which had been donated by Queen Nagadevi and two
noblewomen, Kuarangi and Srima. In the early medieval period (6th-7th cent. A.D.),
some portions of the railing had been consecrated. The pillars have sculptured panels
and medallions representing themes from Jataka stories, life events of Lord Buddha,
zodiac signs, folk scenes etc. Some of the pillars also bear inscription. The carvings
are amongst the earliest examples of Buddhist art.
Nowadays, a railing stands surrounding the Temple, a cement copy of the
original.
20
Seven places of Meditation
Bodhi Pallanka (The Place of Enlightenment)
Prince Siddhartha attained Buddhahood (full enlightenment) in the year 623
B.C. on the Vaisakha full-moon day sitting under the peepul tree. He meditated the
first week under this Bodhi Tree and spent other six weeks in six other places in the
Temple premises.
Animesa locana (The Place of Unwinking Gazing)
After attaining enlightenment, the Buddha spent the second week in
meditation here gazing unwinking at the Bodhi tree. There is one caitya (shrine)
dedicated to this event and it is located north-east of the Temple. There is a different
opinion about this shrine. In about 11th century, this Spired Shrine was built to house
three statues of Tara and one of Avalokitesvara, the bodhisattva of compassion. The
statue of Avalokitesvara with a lion beside him can be seen in the shrine.
Cankamana (Cloister Walk)
The Buddha spent the third week here walking up and down in meditation. On
the platform, lotuses indicate the places where the Lords feet rested while walking. It
is located to the north of the Temple.
Ratanaghara (The Place of Basic Contemplation)
This is a small roofless shrine which is situated in the north-west corner of the
Mahabodhi Temple and is known as Ratanaghara or the Jewel house. The Buddha
spent the fourth week here in meditation reflecting on the Patthana or the Law of
Dependent Origination. While he sat here in deep contemplation the six rays of blue,
yellow, red, white, orange and a combination of all these colours together forming the
sixth colour emanated from his body. The colours are used in the Buddhist flag.
Ajapala Nigrodha tree (Banyan Tree)
The Buddha spent the fifth week under this tree in meditation after
enlightenment. The site is situated in front of the Temple, a little away from the last
step of the eastern gate. Here he replied to a Brahmana that only by ones deeds one
becomes a brahmana, not by birth.
Mucalinda Lake (The Abode of Snake King)
The Buddha spent the sixth week in meditation here. While he was meditating
severe thunder storm broke out. To protect him from the violent wind and rain, the
21
snake king of the lake Mucalinda came out of his abode and encircling the body of
the Buddha several times, held his hood over him.
Rajayatana Tree (A kind of Forest Tree)
It is under this tree the Buddha spent the seventh week in meditation. At the
end of meditation, two merchants from Burma, Tapassu and Bhallika offered rice
cake and honey to the Buddha and took refuge- Buddham Saranam Gacchami,
Dhammam Saranam Gacchami. Sangha was not founded then. They were the first lay
devotees in the Buddhist world. They took some hairs from the Buddha to be
worshipped in their country. According to the Burmese tradition, the hairs are
preserved in the famous Shwedagon Pagoda of Burma.
Stone Pillar
King Asoka is known to have erected a great pillar of stone with an elephant
capital at Bodh Gaya but this monument disappeared centuries ago. The present pillar
originally stood next to Sujatas stupa and was taken to Gaya in the 1820s then re-
erected inside the Temple premises in the year 1956.
22
He conceived the idea of restoring Bodh Gaya to its former glory. This immediately
put Dharmapala on a collision course with the Mahant and his minions.
In 1949, mainly due to the efforts of the Maha Bodhi Society, the organization
Dharmapala established, the Bodh Gaya Act was passed, making provision for the
setting up of a Committee of five Hindus and four Buddhists to manage the affairs of
the Temple.
Daily puja
At 5.00 am, the door of the Mahabodhi Mahavihara opens till 9.00 at night. At
10.00 am, kheer is offered to the Buddha in the main shrine in commemoration of
the great upasika Sujata.
At 5.30 in the morning and at 6.00 in the evening, the monks offer Buddha
Puja, sutta chanting and meditation.
The civara(robe) of the Buddha is offered by the devotees. There is no fixed
time for offering the civara. Whenever any devotee offers a civara, the monk-in-
charge puts it on the image. The colour of the robe should be yellow or its shades.
We went to document some of the places related to the life of the Buddha
around Bodh Gaya.
Gayasisa
After teaching his first two discourses at Sarnath, the Buddha returned to Bodh
Gaya where Gaya Kassapa, Nadi Kassapa and Uruvela Kassapa and their one
thousand followers became his disciples. In this place, the Buddha taught his third
discourse, the famous Fire Sermon or Adityapariyaya Sutta.
23
When Hiuen Tsang visited the hill, he saw a stupa on it that had been built by
King Asoka. Pilgrims were still coming to this place till 16th century.
Buddhaghosa says that the hills original name was Gajasisa, Elephants
Head because of its resemblance to a crouching elephant.
The hill is now called Brahmayoni and is considered sacred to the Hindus.
Pragbodhi Caves (Dungeshwari Hills)
The hill is situated about 3 miles to the north-east of Bodh Gaya on the eastern
bank of the river Phalgu. The hill had been identified by Sir Cunningham with the
Pragbodhi mountain of the Buddhist tradition. Here the Buddha spent six years with
severe austerity before he proceeded to Uruvela.
At present, there is a small temple that is maintained by the Tibetan monks
and just above the temple there is a cave which sheltered the Siddhartha during his
stay there.
Dharmaranya Vedi/ Lo Tu Kawa
According to the Mahayana sect, Siddhartha came here and meditated for six
years. In Tibetan Lo means year, Tu is six and Kawa denotes meditation.
Bakrour/Senani Village
Here is a banyan tree under which Sujata is to be believed to offer milk-rice to
Siddhartha.
Adjacent to this place, there is a temple named Matangarapi, a spot where
Hindus come and offer pindadana.
Sujata Garh
The Excavation Branch of the Archaeological Survey of India undertook
excavation at the ancient site of Bakrour (Sujata-kuti), near Bodh Gaya, located in the
right bank of the river Neranjana.
The stupa made out of brick was constructed to commemorate the residence
of Sujata. It has been established through excavations which welded an inscription of
8th-9th cent. A.D. reading as Devapala Rajasya Sujata Griha.Several plaques of the
Buddha, made probably of plaster and surprisingly light in weight, were found near
the damaged top of the stupa.
The excavation exposed the double terraced circular stupa with ayakas in
cardinal directions. It was constructed in three phases from Gupta to Pala period.
There was a wooden railing around the Pradakshina Path at the ground level.
24
The entire structure was originally plastered with lime. Some of the antiquities
unearthed during excavations are displayed in Bodh Gaya Museum.
SECTION 2
BENEATH THE SACRED BODHI TREE: GURUKUL AND BUDDHIST
CHANTING TRADITION: AN INTERACTIVE SESSION
An interactive session on Feb.11th, 2008 in collaboration with the Maha Bodhi
Society of India and Indira Gandhi National Centre for the Arts, Ministry of
Culture, Govt. of India
On 11th February, 2008, the Maha Bodhi Society of India (MBSI) organized
an interactive session Beneath the Sacred Bodhi Tree: Gurukul and Buddhist
chanting tradition in collaboration with Indira Gandhi National Centre for the Arts
(IGNCA), New Delhi.
The session commenced with the chanting of Buddha Vandana by Mr. Kiran
Lama, Secretary, Daijokyo Buddhist Temple, Bodh Gaya.
Dr. Kailash Prasad, member, governing body, MBSI gave a welcoming
address on the perspective of Buddhist oral tradition.
On behalf of IGNCA, Dr. Gautam Chatterjee, Research Associate & Script
Writer (Media Centre) paid his veneration to the Buddhist Order and told that he was
blessed and honoured in participating this occasion under the Sacred Bodhi Tree. He
spoke about the objective, purpose and necessity of documenting audio-visually the
celebration of Tipitaka chanting on behalf of the IGNCA and also welcomed the
members from different countries to co-operate in this regard with their learned
inputs.
Dr. Sanghamitra Basu, Coordinator, Publication, National Mission for
Manuscripts, IGNCA read a paper on the history of Buddhist oral tradition as well as
the textual tradition found from time to time. She highlighted on the languages of the
Theravada tradition also.
Dhamma Society, Thailand has taken an initiative to publish Tipitaka in
Roman script so to understand the phonetics of Pali properly. In this regard, they have
already printed the Tipitaka under the World Tipitaka Project. It uses the international
standard of diacritical marks. There is also e-Tipitaka service to guide how to use this
Tipitaka properly. A web service is also available regarding this.
25
Prof. Toshiichi Endo, Professor in Pali and Buddhist Studies, Univ.of
Kelaniya, Sri Lanka and also a member of Pali Tipitaka Project explained how this
oral wisdom is being transferred from generations to generations in a monastery. He
referred the first textual documentation occurred in the 1st cent. B.C. during the
Fourth Buddhist Council held in Sri Lanka. Also, the banaka tradition of Sri Lanka
has been referred by him.
Prof. Kanchana Ngorungsi, Prof. of Linguistics and also a member of
Dhamma Society shared her experience of working six years in completing the
Roman scripted Tipitaka.
The venerable monks from different countries were invited to talk about the
oral tradition existing in their respective countries.
Ven. Dr. M. Dhammajothi Thero, Senior Lecturer, Dept. of Buddhist Studies,
Univ. of Colombo, Sri Lanka focused on the rich oral tradition of Sri Lanka. Though
Mangala Sutta, Ratana Sutta and Karaniya Metta Sutta are chanted regularly in every
monastery and almost in every occasion, there are special pidith chanting of 33
hours. Nowadays, during one night, the paritta suttas are chanted. These suttas are
mainly protective in nature and also used in a healing cause.
There are Pali texts (e.g. Uttodaya) from where the monks can learn the proper
pronunciation or different rhythm pattern (tistup, anustup) and apply in their chanting
as there is no fixed pattern of chanting them. The monk students take lessons
following their teacher.
But, of course, there is a big difference in chanting the discourses like
Majjhima Nikaya suttas and the paritta suttas. The style is quite different.
The beauty of the Sri Lankan chanting lies in their proper pronunciation of
Pali and melodious and rhythmically balanced chanting.
Ven. Pragyadip Bhikkhu, Treasurer, All India Bhikkhu Sangha, told about the
lost tradition of India, the birth-land of Buddhism. Now, the Indian monks are mostly
trained in Sri Lanka. In the north-eastern part of the country, e.g. Arunachal, Tripura,
Meghalaya-where the Buddhist population is much more, have preserved their own
tradition and one can find the Burmese influence in their chanting style.
At the same time, he has told about the oral tradition in Theravada Buddhism.
But, India as a vast, multi-lingual, multi-cultural country cannot have a particular
26
tradition. The chanting of Mahayana sect is also very popular and exists in several
parts of the country.
There is a small pocket in the eastern most part of Bengal, Chittagong Hill
Tracts, which now lies in Bangladesh. The Buddhism flourished there once and still
the Bengali Buddhists have kept their tradition alive.
Geographically, the place is situated adjacent to Arakan, now in Myanmar.
Ven. Dr. Varasambodhi Bhikkhu, Secretary, International Meditation Centre,
Bodh Gaya represented Bangladesh.
It is interesting to note that though Burma influenced much on the revival of
Buddhism in Bangladesh, the monks follow the Sri Lankan style of chanting tradition.
The south-east Asian countries like Cambodia, Laos and Thailand have
originated a different style of chanting. They have Tipitaka written in their own script.
The local belief system and culture have incorporated the oral tradition from
generation to generation.
Ven. P. Metta Thero, High Priest, Cambodian Temple, Bodh Gaya,
highlighted the pronunciation of Pali in his demonstration. He clearly indicated the
difference of Pali pronunciation of the monks from Indian sub-continent and from his
country, which sounds very different.
Ven. Kamma Pannavicit Bhikkhu of Laos gave his important views on oral
tradition prevailing in Laos monasteries.
Ven. Sujato Thero from Australia added colour in this interactive session. An
Australian by birth, Ven. Sujato has been trained in Pali and both in Thai and Sri
Lankan tradition of chanting. With the increasing number of monks of Theravada
tradition in Australia, they hold workshops and seminars on all aspects of Buddhism.
In Nepal, we find that Mahayana school of Buddhism flourished much. But,
still, there was an effort by existing Nepalese Theravadin monks to keep their
tradition alive. Now, a good number of monks are being trained mainly in Sri Lanka
and they follow the Sri Lankan chanting system.
Ven. Dhammasobhan Bhikkhu, Secretary, All Nepal Bhikkhu Sangha has
conveyed this information to us.
At the end, Dr. Sanghamitra Basu summed up the views of the venerable
monks of different countries.
27
This interactive session worked as a prelude of the Tipitaka chanting
ceremony and opened eye towards an analytical approach of the oral tradition as well
as the textual tradition which go hand in hand. The unknown details inside the
tradition was exposed and the organizers may be given credit for this noble work.
SECTION 3
INAUGURATION OF THE 3RD ANNUAL PALI TIPITAKA CHANTING
CEREMONY AT BODH GAYA ON 12TH FEB. 2008
The opening ceremony of the 3rd annual Pali Tipitaka chanting in Bodh Gaya
commenced with a colourful procession of the venerable monks and lay devotees
from different countries showing their own cultural exposition. The procession
proceeded to the Mahabodhi Mahavihara and assembled under the Sacred Bodhi Tree.
The ceremonial lamps were lighted by His Holiness Ven. Dr. Rastrapal
Mahathera of the Supreme Sangha Council of India, President, International
Meditation Centre, Bodh Gaya; H.H. Ven. Dharmasen Mahasthavir, Sangharaj of
Bangladesh Supreme Buddhist Council; Most Ven. Satyapriya Mahasthavir, President
of Sangha Council of Bangladesh; Most Ven. S. Dhammapala Mahathera,
Sanghanayaka of Bangladesh Bouddha Mahasabha; Phra Dhammasiddhinayaka,
Official Secretary of H.H. Somdet Phra Buddhacariya, Acting Deputy of His
Holiness, Somdet Phrayanasanvor, the Supreme Patriarch of Thailand; H.H. Ven.
Somdej Phra Buddachan, Wat Saket/The Golden Mountain Buddhist Monastery, The
President of the Senior Committee Acting H.H. The Supreme Patriarch of Thailand;
Chief Priest, Tapovana Temple, Sri Lanka; Sangharaja of Cambodia and Sangharaja
of Laos.
Ven. P.Seewalee Thero, Dy. Gen. Secy., MBSI and in-charge, Buddhagaya
Centre of the Society welcomed the senior venerable monks by offering khada.
The khadas were offered to Major Suradhaj Bunnag, Prof. Kanchana
Ngorungsi, Mr. Junichi Konichi, Prof. Toshiichi Endo- members of Dhamma Society,
Thailand; Mrs. Milina Sumatipala, Mr. Jagat Sumatipala of Dhhammaduta
Foundation, Sri Lanka; Mrs. Wongmo Dixey of Light of Buddhadharma Foundation
International and to Dr. Gautam Chatterjee of Indira Gandhi National Centre for the
Arts.
28
600 sets of special edition of the Holy Majjhima Nikaya in Roman-script
chanting version printing were gifted to the MBSI to distribute among the monks in
memory of the late HRH Princess Galyani Vadhana.
A special dedication of merits towards HRH Princess was read out by Prof.
Kanchana Ngorungsi which was translated by Dr. Kailash Prasad.
Ven. Dr. D. Rewatha Thero, Gen. Secy., MBSI accepted the Dhamma gifts
from the Dhamma Society.
Major Suradhaj Bunnag, Chancellor, Dhamma Society and President, World
Tipitaka Project made aware the reasons behind this kind of publication.
Mr. Jagat Sumatipala, President, All Ceylon Buddhist Congress presented the
Holy Tipitaka in Sinhalese version to MBSI.
The speeches delivered on this occasion by Ven. Dr. D. Rewatha Thero, Gen.
Secy., MBSI, Ven. P.Seewalee Thero, Dy. Gen. Secy., MBSI, Mr. Rai Madan
Kishore, Addl. Dist. Magistrate, Gaya on behalf of Bodh Gaya Temple Management
Committee, Mr. Mahendra Singh, Spl. Secy., Finance Deptt., Govt. of U.P. on behalf
of Indian Buddhist community.
The Blessings were showered by His Holiness Ven. Dr. Rastrapal Mahathera
of the Supreme Sangha Council of India, President, International Meditation Centre,
Bodh Gaya.
The significance of Sutta Pitaka and Vinaya Pitaka were discoursed in precise
by Most Ven. Dr. K. Mahinda Sangha Rakkhita Thero, Abbot, Kelaniya Temple,
Colombo, The Head of Pali and Buddhist Studies, Kelaniya University and Most Ven.
Phra Suthivorayan, Vice Chancellor of Mahachula Univ., Bangkok, Thailand
respectively.
Ven. K. Gnanananda Thero, the Precept Master of Pali chanting gave the
discourse.
Vote of thanks was given by Mrs. Wongmo Dixey, Chief Executive, Light of
Buddhadharma Foundation International.
At the end of the ceremony, Jayamangala Gatha and Dhammacakka Pavattana
Sutta were chanted by the monks.
The ceremony concluded with the peace prayer followed by candle light
procession around the Mahabodhi Mahavihara.
29
SECTION 4
CHANTING OF MAJJHIMA NIKAYA
Three months after the passing of Gotama Buddha, according to the scriptures,
the First Council was held at Rajagaha by some of his disciples who had attained
Arahantship (Enlightenment).
At this point, Theravada tradition maintains that no conflict about what the
Buddha taught is to have occurred, and the teachings were divided into various parts
and each was assigned to an elder and his pupils to commit to memory.
The Council was held under the chairmanship of Mahakassapa where
Bhadanta Upali recited the Vinaya, i.e., the monastic rules and Bhadanta Ananda
recited the Dhamma, the discourses.
In the 3rd cent. B.C., Theravadin sources state that a Third Council was
convened under the patronage of Emperor Asoka, but no mention of this Council is
found in other sources- the Wikipedia Encyclopedia.
Though there are debates whether this Council can be counted or not in the
history, it is generally accepted that one or several disputes occurred during Asokas
reign, involving both doctrinal and vinaya matters.
The chairman of the Council, Moggaliputta Tissa, compiled a book named
Kathavatthu, which was meant to refute these arguments. The Council sided with
the Moggaliputta and his version of Buddhism as orthodox. It was then adopted by
Emperor Asoka as his empires official religion.
Tradition mostly says Buddhism split into 18 schools but unfortunately, with
the exception of the Theravada, none of early these schools survived beyond the late
medieval period, though a considerable amount of the canonical literature of some of
these schools has survived.
The version of the scriptures that had been established at the Third Council,
including the vinaya, sutta and the abhidhamma- collectively known as Tripitaka was
taken to Sri Lanka by Ven. Mahinda. It was then written in the 1st cent. B.C. in the
Fourth Council in the Pali language.
Tripitaka or Tipitaka
Tripitaka (Sanskrit) or Tipitaka (Pali) is the formal term for Buddhist canon of
scriptures. Many different versions of the canon have existed throughout the Buddhist
world, containing an enormous variety of texts. The oldest and most widely known
30
version is the Pali canon of the Theravada school. In the Mahayana, a mixed attitude
to the term Tripitaka developed.
The Tipitaka writings which were originally memorized and recited orally by
disciples, fall into three general categories and are traditionally classified in three
baskets (tri-pitaka).
1. Vinaya Pitaka- the Basket of Discipline or the Code of Ethics to be obeyed by
monks and nuns. It is recited by Bhadanta Upali. These were invented in a day-to-day
basis as the Buddha encountered various behaviour problems with the monks.
2. Sutta Pitaka- literally the Basket of Threads or the Basket of Discourses recited
by Bhadanta Ananda. It consists primarily of accounts of the Buddhas teachings. It
has numerous sub-divisions, viz., Digha Nikaya, Majjhima Nikaya, Samyutta Nikaya,
Anguttara Nikaya and Khuddaka Nikaya. The Sutta Pitaka contains more than 10,000
suttas.
3. Abhidhamma Pitaka- the Basket of higher knowledge or special teachings
recited by Bhadanta Mahakassapa. It consists of seven books. The Abhidhamma
Pitaka is a collection of miscellaneous writings including songs, poetry and stories of
the Buddha and his past lives. Its primary subjects are Buddhist philosophy and
psychology.
The Abhidhamma Pitaka is believed to be a later addition to the first two
pitakas, which, in the opinion of many scholars, were the only two pitakas at the time
of the First Buddhist Council. The Pali Abhidhamma is not recognized outside the
Theravada school.
Majjhima Nikaya
Majjhima Nikaya is the second book of the Sutta Pitaka. It is known as the
Middle Collection or the collection of discourses of medium length, compared with
the longer suttas of the Digha Nikaya which proceeds it, and the shorter suttas of
Samyutta and Anguttara Nikayas.
Structure
Majjhima Nikaya is divided into three parts each consisting of 50 suttas
(pannasas). The Pali Text Society edition contains 152 suttas, the third book
containing two suttas in excess of fifty.
Within each part, the suttas are further grouped into chapters or divisions
(vagga) of ten suttas each, the next to the last division containing twelve suttas.
31
The names of these divisions are often derived from the title of the opening
sutta, though a partial exception is the Middle Fifty, where the division titles usually
refer to the principal type of interlocutor in each of the suttas they contain.
The entire system of classification appears to have been devised more for the
purpose of convenience than because of any essential homogeneity of subject matter
in the suttas comprised under a single division.
Following is the structure of Majjhima Nikaya:
Part I (Mulapannasapali)
I. Mulapariyayavagga
1.Mulapariyaya sutta
2.Sabbasava sutta
3.Dhammadayada sutta
4.Bhayabherava sutta
5.Anangana sutta
6.Akankheyya sutta
7.Vatthupama sutta
8.Sallekha sutta
9.Sammaditthi sutta
10.Satipatthana sutta
II. Sihanadavagga
11.Culasihanada sutta
12.Mahasihanada sutta
13.Mahadukkhakkhandha sutta
14.Culadukkhakkhandha sutta
15.Anumana sutta
16.Cetokhila sutta
17.Vanapattha sutta
18.Madhupindika sutta
19.Dvedhavitakka sutta
20.Vitakkasanthana sutta
III. Tatiyavagga or Opammavagga
21.Kakacupama sutta
22.Alagaddupama sutta
32
23.Vammika sutta
24.Rathavinita sutta
25.Nivapa sutta
26.Ariyapariyesana sutta
27.Culahatthipadopama sutta
28.Mahahatthipadopama sutta
29.Mahasaropama sutta
30.Culasaropama sutta
IV. Mahayamakavagga
31.Culagosinga sutta
32.Mahagosinga sutta
33.Mahagopalaka sutta
34.Culagopalaka sutta
35.Culasaccaka sutta
36.Mahasaccaka sutta
37.Culatanhasankhaya sutta
38.Mahatanhasankhaya sutta
39.Maha-assapura sutta
40.Cula-assapura sutta
V. Culayamakavagga
41.Saleyyaka sutta
42.Veranjaka sutta
43.Mahavedalla sutta
44.Culavedalla sutta
45.Culadhammasamadana sutta
46.Mahadhammasamadana sutta
47.Vimamsaka sutta
48.Kosambiya sutta
49.Brahmanimantanika sutta
50.Maratajjaniya sutta
33
Part II (Majjhimapannasapali)
I. Gahapativagga
51.Kandaraka sutta
52.Atthakanagara sutta
53.Sekha sutta
54.Potaliya sutta
55.Jivaka sutta
56.Upali sutta
57.Kukkuravatika sutta
58.Abhayarajakumara sutta
59.Bahuvedaniya sutta
60.Apannaka sutta
II. Bhikkhuvagga
61.Ambalatthikarahulovada sutta
62.Maharahulovada sutta
63.Culamalukya sutta
64.Mahamalukya sutta
65.Bhaddali sutta
66.Latukikopama sutta
67.Catuma sutta
68.Nalakapana sutta
69.Gulissani/Goliyani sutta
70.Kitagiri sutta
III. Paribbajakavagga
71.Tevijjavacchagotta sutta
72.Aggivacchagotta sutta
73.Mahavacchagotta sutta
74.Dighanakha sutta
75.Magandiya sutta
76.Sandaka sutta
77.Mahasakuludayi sutta
78.Samanamandika sutta
79.Culasakuludayi sutta
34
80.Vekhanassa sutta
IV. Rajavagga
81.Ghatikara sutta
82.Ratthapala sutta
83.Maghadeva sutta
84.Madhura sutta
85.Bodhirajakumara sutta
86.Angulimala sutta
87.Piyajatika sutta
88.Bahitika sutta
89.Dhammacetiya sutta
90.Kannakatthala sutta
V. Brahmanavagga
91.Brahmayu sutta
92.Sela sutta
93.Assalayana sutta
94.Ghotamukha sutta
95.Canki sutta :
96.Esukari sutta
97.Dhananjani sutta
98.Vasettha sutta
99.Subha sutta
100.Sangarava sutta
Part III (Uparipannasapali)
I. Devadahavagga
101.Devadaha sutta
102.Pancattaya sutta
103.Kinti sutta
104.Samagama sutta
105.Sunakkhatta sutta
106.Anenjasappaya sutta
107.Ganakamoggallana sutta
108.Gopakamoggallana sutta
35
109.Mahapunnama sutta
110.Culapunnama sutta
II. Anupadavagga
111.Anupada sutta
112.Chabbisodhana sutta
113.Sappurisa sutta
114.Sevitabbasevitabba sutta
115.Bahudhatuka sutta
116.Isigili sutta
117.Mahacattarisaka sutta
118.Anapanasati sutta
119.Kayagatasati sutta
120.Sankharupapatti sutta
III. Sunnatavagga
121.Culasunnata sutta
122.Mahasunnata sutta
123.Acchariya- abbhuta sutta
124.Bakkula sutta
125.Dantabhumi sutta
126.Bhumija sutta
127.Anuruddha sutta
128.Upakkilesa sutta
129.Balapandita sutta
130.Devaduta sutta
IV. Vibhangavagga
131.Bhaddekaratta sutta
132.Anandabhaddekaratta sutta
133.Mahakaccanabhaddekaratta sutta
134.Lomasakangiyabhaddekaratta sutta
135.Culakammavibhanga sutta
136.Mahakammavibhanga sutta
137.Salayatanavibhanga sutta
138.Uddesavibhanga sutta
36
139.Aranavibhanga sutta
140.Dhatuvibhanga sutta
141.Saccavibhanga sutta
142.Dakkhinavibhanga sutta
V. Salayatanavagga
143.Anathapindikovada sutta
144.Channovada sutta
145.Punnovada sutta
146.Nandakovada sutta
147.Cularahulovada sutta
148.Chachakka sutta
149.Mahasalayatanika sutta
150.Nagaravindeyya sutta
151.Pindapataparisuddhi sutta
152.Indriyabhavana sutta
37
the kings and princes, the Brahmins and ascetics , simple villagers, erudite
philosophers, the earnest seekers and vain disputants.
In the Majjhima Nikaya, we see that it is not the Buddha alone who appears in
the role of teacher. The accomplished disciples he produced are also introduced in this
work.
Ven. Sariputta, the General of the Dhamma had spoken 9 discourses. Three of
them have become basic texts for the study of Buddhist doctrine. The Ven. Ananda,
the Buddhas personal attendant during last 25 years of his life, delivers 7 suttas and
participates in many. Four suttas are spoken by the Ven. Maha Kaccana, who excelled
in elaborating upon brief sayings of the Master, and two by Ven. Maha Moggallana.
There is a dialogue between the Ven. Sariputta and Ven. Punna Mantaniputta.
Scholars say that the stages of purification which have been explored through their
conversation, has formed the outline for Acariya Buddhaghosas Vissuddhimagga.
Another dialogue introduces the bhikkhuni Dhammadinna.
The formats of the suttas are also highly variegated. The majority of these are
in the form of discourses. A few among these are delivered in a series of instructional
propositions or guidelines to practice, but most of them are adorned with striking
similes and parables which impress deeply upon the mind.
Some of the suttas unfold in dialogue and discussion, and in some, the
dramatic or narrative element predominates, e.g., Angulimala Sutta (no.86) or the
story of Ratthapala (no.82).
Several suttas center upon debate and these highlight the Buddhas wit and
delicate sense of irony as well as his dialectical skills.
The Majjhima Nikaya also gives us the fullest canonical account of the
Masters early life as a Bodhisattva, a seeker of enlightenment. It shares the
miraculous story of his conception and birth and about his great renunciation.
It tells his discipleship under two accomplished meditation teachers of that
time, his mastery of their systems and his consequent disillusionment.
Majjhima also tells us his hard ascetic practices during six years and then his
attainment of enlightenment.
It takes us past the enlightenment to the decision to teach and the instruction of
his first disciples.
38
A commentarial text shows the Buddhas daily schedule which is divided
between periods of instructing the bhikkhus, giving discourses to the laity and
secluded meditation or in the attainment of great compassion.
The days single meal was always taken in the forenoon, either received by
invitation or collected on alms food and his sleep was restricted to a few hours at
night, except in the summer, when he rested briefly during noon.
The annual routine depended on the Indian climate- a cold season from
November to February, a hot season from March to June and a rainy season during
July and October.
The suttas also exposed what were the places the Buddha travelled or resided
specially during rain retreats.
Overall, the suttas of Majjhima Nikaya throw light not only on the life of the
Buddha and his disciples, but also on such subjects as Brahmin sacrifices, various
forms of asceticism, the relation of the Buddha to the Jains and other sects and the
social and political conditions prevailing at that time.
The Four Noble Truths of the Buddhism, the doctrine of form and action,
refutation of the soul theory, different modes of meditation etc. are discussed in the
Majjhima Nikaya.
Chanting tradition
Chanting the discourses of Majjhima Nikaya is not a regular phenomenon in
the Buddhist monasteries. Though in the monastic education, the samaneras and
bhikkhus learn all the Nikayas and suttas of the Pali canon, but these discourses are
not for regular chanting.
There is no hard and fast rule in chanting the discourses. But, traditionally, as
we have found that there is a big difference in the style of chanting between the
discourses and the paritta suttas. The paritta suttas are chanted regularly in the
temples while worshipping or during other social customs. The paritta suttas are
mainly protective in nature, sometimes it functions as the healer.
While the discourse of the Majjhima are mostly in dialogues thus composed in
prose pattern, the paritta suttas are composed mainly in verses. One can go through
the Pali texts for proper pronunciation or rhythm pattern in chanting the verses.
39
In some of the suttas in Majjhima Nikaya, we find beautiful compositions of
verses. The style of chanting varies definitely from the prose portion of the suttas.
It is noteworthy that Satipatthana Sutta, Isigili Sutta and Angulimala Sutta of
the Majjhima Nikaya are chanted as paritta suttas. Satipatthana is chanted for a
dying person. Angulimala sutta is believed to give relief the labour pain of a pregnant
lady. The Isigili sutta is commonly chanted for the protection from the evils in the
whole night pidith chanting, specially in Sri Lanka. It is interesting to note that these
suttas are chanted as an abridged version when they are used as paritta suttas.
The essence and summary of 152 suttas of Majjhima Nikaya are given in the
next section with a brief excerpt of Pali sutta in roman script in the beginning.
SECTION 5
THE ESSENCE OF THE SUTTAS OF MAJJHIMA NIKAYA
PART I
MULAPANNASAPALI
I. MULAPARIYAYAVAGGA
40
The sutta is proclaimed to be one of the deepest and most difficult suttas in
Pali Canon striking the keynote of the entire doctrine of Buddhism (sabbadhamma
mulapariyaya).
The popular aspect of this important discourse is found in the narrative of
Mulapariyaya Jataka.
The Blessed One said this:
Here, bhikkhus, an untaught ordinary person, who has no regard for noble
ones and is unskilled and undisciplined in their Dhamma, perceives earth as earth.
Having perceived earth as earth, he conceives (himself as) earth, he conceives
(himself) in earth, he conceives (himself apart) from earth, he conceives earth to be
mine, he delights in earth. Why is that? Because he has not fully understood it, I
say.
So, too, he perceives water as water, fire as fire, air as air.
In just the same way originate his ideas about-
i. bhuta (beings) [MA says that beings here signifies only living beings below the
heaven of the Four Great Kings, the lowest of the sense-sphere heavens, the higher
grades of living beings are covered by the terms to follow.]
ii. gods [MA says the gods of the six-sense-sphere heavenly worlds]
iii. Pajapati [According to MA, here is a name for Mara because he is the ruler of this
generation of living beings].
iv. Brahma [Here Mahabrahma, the first deity to be born at the beginning of a new
cosmic cycle and whose lifespan lasts for the entire cycle].
v. Abhassara deities (gods of Streaming Radiance)
vi. Subhakinna Deities (gods of Refulgent Glory)
vii. Vehapphala deities (gods of Great Fruit)
viii.Abhibhu (overlord)
ix. Base of infinite space
x. Base of infinite consciousness
xi. Base of nothingness
xii. Base of neither-perception-nor-non-perception
xiii.What is seen
xiv.What is heard
xv. What is sensed
41
xvi.What is cognized
xvii.Unity (ekatta)
xviii.Diversity (nanatta)
xix.All
xx. Nibbana
Then the Buddha tells about the disciple in higher training, sekha who is still
under training and has reached any of the three lower planes of sanctity- stream-
entry, once-returning or non-returning and not yet won Arahatship, the supreme
security from bondage.
Buddha says that a bhikkhu who is in higher training directly knows earth as
earth and he should not conceive himself as earth, in the earth, apart from earth,
should not think earth as mine and should not delight in earth. Because he must
bring himself to comprehend it.
Here follows the same about water, fire and etc.
Then the Buddha tells about the Arahant, with taints no more, who has lived
the holy life, whose task is done, laid down the burden, reached his own goal, whose
bonds to life are no more and has found Final Deliverance.
He has eradicated three unwholesome roots- lust (or greed), hate and delusion.
He is not merely without these unwholesome states but has destroyed it at the most
fundamental level.
An arahant too recognizes earth as earth but conceives no ideas of earth, in
earth, from earth, my earth, he does not delight in earth. Because he has come to
comprehend it.
So, too, he recognizes water as water and rest of the elements mentioned
earlier.
Finally, the Blessed One tells about the Tathagata. He is accomplished and
fully enlightened directly knows earth as earth. He does not conceive himself as earth,
an earth, from earth, my earth, he does not delight in earth. Because he has understood
that delight is the root of suffering, and when there is birth, there is decay. Tathagata
has awakened to supreme full enlightenment.
So, too, he directly knows water, fire, air and rest of the factors mentioned
earlier.
But those bhikkhus did not delight in the Blessed Ones words.
42
MA tells us that the bhikkhus were so adhered by their own views, they could
not get through the discourse in deep. The pride in them humbled when the Buddha
expounded to these bhikkhus the Gotamaka Sutta (Anguttara Nikaya) at a later time.
Summary :
In this sutta, the Buddha analyses the cognitive processes of four types of
individuals: the untaught ordinary person, the disciple in higher training, the arahant
and the Tathagata.
He has critically surveyed the real position of contemporary systems of
philosophy and belief. Thai sutta touches on the soul theory. An idea of Nibbana can
be gathered fairly from this sutta.
It further informs us that the greatly learned disciples of the Buddha knew
Pajapati, Brahma, Abhassara gods and etc.
43
what are the right things to be attended. He attends such things which arise sensual
desire in him, and it increases, then arises taint of being and further taint of ignorance.
But, a well-taught noble disciple, who respects noble ones and is skilled and
disciplined in Dhamma, understands what things are fit for attention and what are not.
44
sewer. He should avoid either sitting on unsuitable seats or wandering unsuitable
resorts, should avoid association of bad friends.
No taints or vexation would arise for him who knows how to avoid these
things.
45
Bhikkhus, be my heirs in Dhamma , not my heirs in material things.
The Buddha uttered this when he was living on one occasion at Savatthi in
Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas Park.
Majjhima Nikaya Atthakatha explains that the Buddha delivered this to the
bhikkhus because they were becoming proud of the accrued honour of the Sangha and
neglecting their spiritual training. He wanted to show the practice of the heirs in
Dhamma to those bhikkhus who were earnestly desirous of training.
In this sutta, the Blessed One distinguishes between the two classes of monks
(i) Amisadayada, who clings to the food to enable him to practice Dhamma. (ii)
Dhammadayada, who clings to the Dhamma. The Buddha praises the latter as he is
the keeper of real truth.
Next portion of the discourse was taken by Venerable Sariputta.
He explains that the disciples who live secluded do not train in seclusion; they
do not abandon what the Teacher tells them to abandon; they lead a luxurious and
careless life, keen in backsliding, neglectful in renunciation- are to be blamed.
In this, the elder bhikkhus (who have spent more then ten vassavasas since
ordination), the middle bhikkhus (who have spent between five to nine) and the new
bhikkhus (less than five rainy seasons) are to be blamed for these three reasons.
Then Sariputta speaks of the middle way for abandoning these evils, which
gives vision, knowledge, peace, enlightenment and leads to Nibbana.
The Middle Way is the Noble Eightfold Path: right view, right intention, right
speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness and right
concentration.
It is to be noted that this sutta has two parts. First is an introduction by the
Buddha and then Sariputta takes the thread of the discourse and explains the doctrinal
points involved in this sutta.
Summary:
Heirs of truth, solitude and the Middle Path are the topics of discussion in this
Sutta.
46
4. BHAYABHERAVA SUTTA: FEAR AND DREAD
EVAM ME SUTAM-EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
ESAHAM BHAVANTAM GOTAMAM SARANAM GACCHAMI
DHAMMANCA BHIKKHUSANGHANCA. UPASAKAM MAM BHAVAM
GOTAMO DHARETU AJJATAGGE PANUPETAM SARANAM GATANTI.
The Blessed One delivered this sutta on one occasion when he was living at
Savatthi in Jetas grove, Anathapindikas Park.
In reply to the questions set by the Brahmin Janussoni, the Buddha says that
recluses and Brahmins living in the jungles are beset with fear and dread if they are
without purity of act-of word-of-thought or of livelihood. They evoke fear and dread
if they are covetous, pleasure loving, corrupt by sloth and torpor, restless and
unpeaceful in mind, uncertain and doubting, exalting themselves and disparaging
others, being affrighted, desirous of gain and honour and renown, lazy and slack,
unmindful, unconcentrated or witless and driveling.
The Buddha then relates his attempts to conquer fear when he was striving for
enlightenment.
He secluded from sensual pleasures, from unwholesome states and entered
upon and abided the first jhana, which is accompanied by applied and sustained
thought, with rapture and pleasure born of seclusion.
Then he entered upon and abided in the second jhana, which has self-
confidence and singleness of mind without applied and sustained thought, with
rapture and pleasure born of concentration.
He abided in equanimity, mindful and fully aware, still feeling pleasure with
the body, and entered upon third jhana.
Abandoning pleasure and pain, he entered upon the fourth jhana which has
neither pain nor pleasure and purity of mindfulness due to equanimity.
In this state of mind, he attained the first true knowledge in the first watch of
the night. He could recollect his manifold past lives.
The middle watch of the night saw the second true knowledge attained by him
and he understood how beings pass on according to their actions.
Then came the last watch of the night when he attained the third true
knowledge.
47
His mind was purified, bright, unblemished, rid of imperfection, malleable,
wieldy, steady and attained to imperturbability.
He understood that his mind was liberated from the taint of sensual desires,
from the taint of being and from the taint of ignorance.
The Brahmin understood the Gotama as an Accomplished One, a Fully
Enlightened One. He goes to the Buddha, Dhamma and Sangha for refuge.
Summary:
The subject matter of this sutta is how terror may arise in mind. The real
value of this sutta consists the reminiscence of the fearless endeavours of the Buddha
previous to his enlightenment.
48
abandon the blemish, and he will die with lust, hate, delusion with mind defiled. A
blemished person who realizes it can correct himself.
Similarly, it can be said for the unblemished persons. Sariputta further
explains that blemish is a term for the spheres of evil unwholesome wishes. He has
given several examples and says repeatedly that the anger and bitterness come out of
these evil wishes are both a blemish.
Then a reference to a naked ascetic Panduputta as cited by Maha Mogggallana
in the course of the discourse shows that the naked ascetics as a sect were in existence
and they were not free from corruption. The two great disciples of Buddha rejoiced in
each others good words.
Summary:
The sutta points out that a man undepraved cannot be free until and unless he
himself sees that he is really far from depravation. He should know the pitfalls he may
fall into.
49
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha advises his disciples to observe strict rules of the sila
(precepts) and Patimokkha (code of monastic discipline consists of 227 rules) though
the longing of fame and reputation and supernatural power may be in their hearts.
According to the Buddha, the bhikhkus should only observe the rule, by
subdued and restrained and practise the precepts faithfully.
50
His mind is liberated from the defilement of sensual desire, being and
ignorance.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha exhorts the monks to be pure in mind and to wipe off
all impurities.
According to the scholars, there are two points worthy of notice:
i) the simile of cloth may be interpreted as an illustration of the popular Buddhist
conception of mind.
ii) it preserves a very ancient Pali couplet mentioning seven important rivers, e.g.
Bahuka, Adhikakka, Gaya, Sundarika, e.t.c., Gaya being represented the chief of
all.
51
resentment, contempt, insolence, envy, avarice, fraudulence, deceit, obstinacy,
arrogance, admonishment.
He should have good friends, he should be delightful, faithful, shameful and
energetic. He should establish mindfulness and possess wisdom.
These effacement can be practised even by inclination of mind towards whole-
some states, by avoiding the unwholesome state and extinguishing unwholesome
states.
Summary:
The main point in this sutta is to be noticed that each of the planes (the four
ecstasies, infinity space, of mind, of nothingness) is called by the Buddha not an
effacement but an excellent state. He has told in this sutta several ways of effacement
which should be practised to follow his discipline.
52
Sariputta then acknowledges the various ways leading to right view, namely:
i) understanding nutriment
ii) understanding suffering
iii) understanding ageing and death
iii) understanding birth
iv) understanding being (existence) [three kinds of being: sense-sphere being,
fine-
material being, immaterial being ]
vi) understanding clinging [four kinds: clinging to sensual pleasures, views, rules
and observances to a doctrine of self.
vii) understanding craving [six classes: craving for forms, sounds, odours, flavours,
tangibles, mind-objects]
viii) understanding feeling [six classes: feeling born on eye-contact, ear-contact,
nose contact, tongue-contact, body-contact, mind-contact]
i) understanding mentality materiality
ii) understanding consciousness [six types: eye, ear, nose, tongue, body and
mind]
iii) understanding formations [three kinds: bodily, verbal and mental formations]
iv) understanding ignorance
xiii) understanding taints [three kinds: sensual desire, taint of being, taint of
ignorance]
and its origin, is cessation and the way leading to its cessation.
Sariputta then narrates the way leading to right view is Noble Eight Fold
Path(Ariya-astangik magga), i.e. right view, right intention, right speech, right action,
right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness and right concentration.
Summary:
It is a very long and important discourse by Venerable Sariputta with separate
sections on the wholesome, unwholesome, nutriment, the four Noble Truths, taints
and etc.
53
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
This is one of the fullest and most important suttas delivered by the Buddha
when he was living in Kammasadhamma, a town of Kuru country.
The Buddha begins the sutta declaring four Satipatthanas (foundations of
mind-fullness), leading the way to Nibbana, e.g. to keep watch over body (kaya),
feeling or sensation (vedana), mind (citta) and mind-objects/phenomenon (dhamma).
The sutta deals with the meditation, with particular emphasis on the
development of insight.
In the fold of contemplation of the Body, he teaches
i) mindfulness of breathing
ii) contemplation of four postures
iii) full awareness
iv) attention to the foulness- the bodily parts
v) attention to elements
vi) to xiv) Nine charnel ground contemplations
In the fold of contemplation of Feeling/Sensation, a bhikkhu can understand
feelings as feelings. Whether it is pleasant or painful, or neither pleasant nor painful,
worldly, unworldly or neither worldly nor unworldly and etc.
In the fold of contemplation of Mind, a bhikkhu can understand his mind
whether affected by lust or not, affected by hatred or not, distracted or not, exalted or
not, concentrated or not, liberated or not and etc.
In the fold of contemplation of Mind-Objects, he teaches
i) Five Hindrances (sensual desire, ill will, sloth and torpor, restlessness and
remorse, doubt)
ii) Five Aggregates (affected by clinging)
iii) The six bases (eye, sound, nose, tongue, body, mind)
iv) The seven enlightenment factors (mindfulness, investigation of states, energy,
rapture, tranquility, concentration, equanimity).
v) The Four Noble Truths
Summary:
The structure of this sutta is fairly simple. The body of the discourse falls into
four parts by way of the four foundations of mindfulness.
54
1. Contemplation of the body: Fourteen exercises
2. Contemplation of the feeling: One exercise
3. Contemplation of the mind: One exercise
4. Contemplation of the mind-objects: which has five subdivisions.
Thus the sutta expounds altogether twenty one exercises in contemplation.
Buddha finally concludes that one can pass beyond sorrow and ills of body
and mind and attain Nibbana if he practices the Satipatthana.
The teachings of this sutta is considered as the corner-stone of the whole of
the Buddhist system of self-culture.
II. SIHANADAVAGGA
(THE DIVISION OF THE LIONS ROAR)
55
Summary :
This sutta declares that only in Buddhas Dispensation, the four grades of
noble individuals are found. He explains here how his teaching can be distinguished
and excelled from the votaries of other path:
1. Sattharipasada (faith in teacher)
2. Dhammepasada (faith in the law)
3. Silesu paripurakarita (strict observance of precepts)
4. Sahadhammika piyamanapagahattha ceva pabbajita ca (agreeableness in the
company of the fellow believers whether they are laymen or bhikkhus.)
56
(dhammacakka) in its twofold meaning: the knowledge penetrating the truth and the
knowledge of how to expound theteaching.
The Lomadhamsapariyaya is an alternative title suggested in this sutta. It is
referred by this name at Milindapanha 398 and in the commentary to the Digha
Nikaya.
Summary :
In this sutta, the Buddha relates the austerities practiced by him when he was
a bodhisatta as MA informs us that Sunakkhatta was a great admirer of extreme
asceticism.
57
punishment has also taken place, e.g. by flogging, by bludgeoning, by cutting off
hands, feet, ears, nose etc. or sprayed with boiling oil, or given to starved dogs to
devour etc.
There is a reference of sects other than Buddhist monks, for whom too sensual
pleasure was the main point to attack.
There is also a mention of various kinds of profession, e.g. conveyancing,
accountancy, appraising, agriculture, trade and commerce, cattle breeding, soldiery,
royal service, estate-agent, archer, member of the royal household etc.
Summary :
In this sutta, the Buddha explains the full understanding of sensual pleasures,
material form amd feelings.
58
works done by them in their past life for which they were to suffer and they believed
that through sufferings, one can attain happiness.
The Buddha had a conversation with Nataputta and he had explained how the
Gotama abides in great pleasure.
Summary:
Added to the preceding sutta, this sutta narrates conversation with Nataputta
on the pleasure and pain.
59
This sutta also enumerates offences and their punishments like the
Mahavagga and Patimokkha.
According to Buddhaghosa, this discourse was known to the ancients as
Bhikkhuvinaya or treatises on discipline.
60
It is to be noted that this sutta lays down some Vinaya rules and illustrates the
cases.
Summary :
In this sutta, the Buddha says about five wildernesses and five shackles, i.e.
mental enslavements or bondages of mind, from which every monk has to free himself
in order to achieve the highest goal.
61
18. MADHU-PINDIKA SUTTA : THE HONEYBALL
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAKKESU
VIHARATI KAPILAVATTHUSMIM NIGRODHARAME..
TASMATIHA TVAM, ANANDA, IMAM DHAMMAPARIYAYAM
MADHUPINDIKAPARIYAYO TVEVA NAM DHAREHITI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANO AYASMA ANANDO
BHAGAVATO BHASITAM ABHINANDITI.
The sutta was delivered by the Buddha when he was living in the Sakyan
country at Kapilavatthu in Nigrodhas Park.
Dandapani, the Sakya met the Blessed One and asked him what doctrine he
held. The Blessed One explained him that he held such a Doctrine that both Brahma
and Mara were unable to hold. At this Dandapani retired.
According to MA, Dandapani sided with Devadatta and his manner of asking
question was arrogant and deliberately provocative.
In the evening, the Buddha narrated this event to his disciples who also wanted
to know what doctrine the Blessed One held.
He then retired after telling them his doctrine in a nutshell that whatever be the
source, several obsessions and perceptions which beset a mans path, find neither
approval nor welcome nor adherence, then there is an end of all propensities to
passion, to resentment, to speculative ideas, to doubts, to pride, to passion for
continuing existence and to ignorance.
The bhikkhus then proceeded to Maha Kaccana who was declared by the
Buddha to be the most eminent disciple in expounding the detailed meaning of a brief
saying.
And here also, Maha Kaccana elucidated the Lords statement and bhikkhus
are satisfied and happy.
Summary :
In this sutta, the Buddha utters a deep but enigmatic statement about the
source through which perceptions and notions tinged by mental proliferation beset a
man. The statement is explained by Maha Kaccana further and is praised by the
Buddha.
62
19. DVEDHAVITAKKA SUTTA : TWO KINDS OF THOUGHT
EVAM ME SUTAM-EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
ETANI, BHIKKHAVE RUKKHAMULANI, ETANI SUNNAGARANI;
JHAYATHA, BHIKKHAVE, MA PAMADATTHA; MA PACCHA
VIPATTISARINO AHUVATTHA. AYAM VO AMHAKAM ANUSASANITI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
The sutta is delivered by the Blessed One at Savatthi in Jetas Grove,
Anathapindikas Park.
According to the Pali scholars, this sutta is very important in the history of
Pali literature. Maha Kaccanas exposition on Buddhas words briefly furnishes that
the system of Abhidhamma exposition based on philosophical thought and
explanation of what the Buddha had spoken may be found here. Here we may find the
genesis of Abhidhamma. The Maha Kaccana was the author.
In this sutta, the Blessed One explains to his disciples that he failed to achieve
the highest object so long for six years of struggle as he practiced the habit of dividing
things. It gave rise in his heart the thoughts of sensual desire, ill will and cruelty.
But when he thought more on renunciation, then the thoughts of craving
passed away.
MA explains that excessive thinking and pondering leads to agitation. To
overcome this, the Bodhisatta entered a meditative attainment, and he would emerge
from it and develop insight.
Summary :
This sutta refers the struggle of Bodhisattva and then the Buddha explains the
way to overcome unwholesome thoughts and replace them by wholesome thoughts.
63
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
The sutta is delivered by the Blessed One at Savatthi in Jetas Grove,
Anathapindikas Park.
The Buddha teaches five methods for dealing with the unwholesome thoughts
that may arise in the course of meditation.
i) If there arises in a bhikkhu bad and wrong thoughts associated with desire, hatred
and delusion, then he should divert his mind from that to another which is right. Then
the wrong thoughts will disappear, so that his heart stands firm, steadfast, focused and
concentrated.
ii) If after diversion of mind from bad to good, still arise in him wrong thoughts, then
he should study the perils these entail, marking how wrong such thoughts are and how
they ripen into ill. Then the wrong thoughts will disappear and his heart stands firm,
steadfast, focused and concentrated.
iii) If, for all his scrutiny of their perils, the wrong things keep on arising still, then he
should ignore them and not let his mind dwell on them. As he ignores them, the
wrong thoughts will disappear and his heart stands firm, steadfast, focused and
concentrated.
iv) After ignoring them, if these wrong thoughts keep on arising still, then he must
think how to alloy all those moulds and fashions thoughts. As he does so, these
thoughts will disappear and his heart stands firm, steadfast, focused and concentrated.
v) But, if allay as he may, these wrong thoughts continue to arise, then he should
with sheer force of mind, restrain, coerce and dominate his heart. As he does so, these
thoughts will disappear and his heart stands firm, steadfast, focused and concentrated.
Summary :
In this sutta, we find that the Buddha teaches five methods for dealing with the
taints arise in mind during meditation and how to overcome these thoughts.
64
III.TATIYAVAGGA OR OPAMMAVAGGA
( THE THIRD DIVISION)
65
encompassing world with a mind involved with loving- kindness, abundant, exalted,
immeasurable without hostility, without ill will.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha gave an advice to the bhikkhus on the need to
maintain patience even they were addressed with disagreeable words.
66
he would not come to death or deadly suffering because of the right grasp of the
snake. Buddha explained the right grasp means the right grasp of teaching.
Summary:
Through a simile of snake, the Buddha says how it is important for one
bhikkhu to grasp rightly of his Dhamma.
The sutta culminates in one of the most impressive disquisitions on non-self
found in the canon.
67
Summary:
In this sutta, a deity shows a monk an obscure riddle, which is revealed by the
Buddha.
68
Summary:
In this sutta, Ven. Punna Mantaniputta explains Ven. Sariputta about seven
stages of purification to reach and attain the goal of Nibbana.
69
Summary:
Through analogy of deer-trappers and bait, the Buddha instructs his disciples
how to avoid the sensual pleasures and thus become free from the control of Mara
and his train.
70
The Brahmin Janussoni was driving out of Savatthi in a chariot in the middle
of the day. On the way, he met Master Vacchayana who was coming from the
Buddhas recluse.
The Brahmin wanted to know about the Buddha and his teaching. In reply
Vacchayana said that one would surely have to be equal to Gotama, the Buddha to
know his lucidity of wisdom and he is praised as best among gods and humans.
It is as if an expert elephant-tracker came to an elephant forest and seeing
there a long and broad footprint of an elephant, assumed it was really a big elephant,
so seeing the four footprints of the recluse Gotama, Master Vacchayana concluded
that the Lord was all-enlightened, the Dhamma was well proclaimed and the Sangha
was practicing the good way.
Then he explained how it is big and why he had come to that conclusion.
Understanding this, Brahmin Janussoni went to the Buddha one day and
exchanged greetings.
The Buddha says as the wise elephant woodsman enters an elephant wood and
probe in various about the size of the elephant seeing its footprints and finally comes
to the conclusion that the elephant is big, so too, the Tathagata appears in the world,
accomplished, fully enlightened, perfect in true knowledge and conduct, sublime,
knower of worlds, incomparable leader of persons to be tamed, teacher of gods and
humans, blessed. The Buddha then narrates all the achievements of Tathagata to
Janussoni. This is the Tathagatas footprint.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha explains how a disciple arrives at complete certainty
of the truth of his teaching. He uses the analogy of an elephant woodsman in this
regard. The sutta gives a detailed description of the step-by-step training of the
Buddhist monk. According to the chronicles of Sri Lanka, this was the first sutta
preached by Maha Mahinda after his arrival in Sri Lanka.
71
IDAMAVOCA AYASMA SARIPUTTO. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU
AYASMATO SARIPUTTASSA BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
The sutta is delivered by the Blessed One at Savatthi in Jetas Grove,
Anathapindikas Park.
There the Sariputta addressed the bhikkhus. Sariputta says that just as the
footprint of elephant which is pre-eminent in size, the right states of mind comprised
within the Four Noble Truths, i.e. suffering, origin of suffering, cessation of suffering
and the way to cessation of suffering.
He then elaborates the truth of suffering for analysis into its various aspects
and enumerates the five aggregates affected by attachment.
He next dwells upon constituents of the attachment of material form.
It is the four great elements and the material form derived from it. The four
elements are: earth, water, fire and the air.
Each of the elements is expounded as a basis for insight meditation as well as
for developing patience, faith and equanimity.
He concludes by saying that what is true of visible objects is equally true of
sound, smell, taste, touch and mind.
Summary:
This sutta is attributed to Sariputta. He begins with a statement of the Four
Noble Truths,which he then expounds by way of contemplation of the four elements
and the dependent origination of the five aggregates.
72
It was soon after Devadatta left. Referring to Devadattas secession from the
Order, the Blessed One addressed to the bhikkhus that there are certain youths who
outwardly being allured by the life of monks leave household life. As monks, they
receive gifts, respect and repute. But they are so pleased and satisfied with their
aspirations that they start disparaging others.
Thus they grow a remiss and suffer in life.
The Buddha uses a simile of a heartwood. If a man needs heartwood from a
great tree, he has to cut off only heartwood, knowing it is heartwood. The sapwood,
the inner bark, outer bark, twigs and leaves do not serve his purpose.
So this holy life, does not have gain, honour and renown for its benefit, or the
attainment of virtue for its benefit, or the attainment of concentration for its benefit, or
knowledge and vision for its benefit. But it is this unshakeable deliverance of mind
that it is goal of this holy life, its heartwood and its end.
Summary:
Through a simile, the Buddha explains the unshakeable deliverance of mind
that is the goal of a holy life, its heartwood and its end.
73
repute, nor in a life of virtue, nor in rapt concentration, nor in mystic insight. It is the
unshakeable deliverance of mind that is the goal of this holy life, its heartwood and its
end.
Summary:
In the above mentioned two suttas, Buddha emphasizes on one proper goal of
holy life which is the unshakeable deliverance of mind and all the other benefits are
subsidiary.
IV. MAHAYAMAKAVAGGA
(THE GREAT DIVISION OF PAIRS)
74
32. MAHAGOSINGA SUTTA: THE GREATER DISCOURSE IN GOSINGA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA
GOSINGASALAVANADAYE VIHARATI SAMBAHULEHI ABHINNATEHI
ABHINNATEHI THEREHI SAVAKEHI SADDHIM-..
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE AYASMANTO
BHAGAVATO BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
Once the Blessed One was living in the Park of the Gosinga sala-tree wood
together with his elderly and well known disciples- Ven. Sariputta, Maha Moggallana,
Maha Kassapa, Anuruddha, Revata, Ananda and others.
On one moonlit evening these venerable bhikkhus went to Sariputta to listen to
the Dhamma. Sariputta asked Ananda that what kind of bhikkhu could illuminate the
Gosinga Sala-tree Wood when the Wood was beautiful by nature.
Ananda then speaks of one who treasures and consolidates what he has been
taught, learns by heart the ideas which declare the higher life in all its perfection and
purity.
Revata says about one who delights in meditation.
Anuruddha tells about the bhikkhus who has a divine eye.
Mahakassapa recommends of one who lives in solitude in the forest.
Then comes Maha Moggallana who speaks of a bhikkhu who holds discourse
on the Abhidhamma with another bhikkhu and gaining edification on it. Then
Sariputta tells about his view that a bhikkhu who is master of his heart can illuminate
the Gosinga Sala-tree Wood.
After that, all of them went to the Blessed One and told about their views. The
Buddha praised everybody and told that one whose heart is delivered from all
unwholesome desires can illuminate the Gosinga sala-tree wood.
Summary:
In this sutta, we find that the senior disciples of the Buddha were discussing
about what kind of bhikkhu could illuminate the wood. Each and everybody answered
according to their personal ideal. Then the Buddha provided his own answer.
75
33. MAHAGOPALAKA SUTTA: THE GREATER DISCOURSE ON THE
COWHERD
EVAM ME SUTAM-EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
VINAYE VUDDHIM VIRULHIM VEPULLAM APAJJITUNTI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
The sutta was delivered by the Blessed One at Savatthi in Jetas Grove,
Anathapindikas Park.
The Buddha says that there are eleven good or bad qualities which either
entitle a bhikkhu to progress in doctrine and rites or disable him from doing such.
He has put a simile of cowherd. As a cowherd not knowing how to keep and
rear a herd of cattle, so the bhikkhus not possesing eleven factors, they fail to go long
forth.
He has explained about these eleven qualities in detail possessed by a bhikkhu.
i.e. if a cowherd has no knowledge in form; is unskilled in characteristics fails to pick
out flies eggs, fails to dress wound, fails to smoke out the sheds, does not know the
watering place, does not know what to be drunk, does not know the road, unskilled in
pastures, milks dry, no extra veneration for the leaders and the elders.
What are these eleven factors?
i) ignorant of form- not really comprehending four elements
ii) unskilled in characteristics- does not comprehend what marks the doings of a fool
and wise.
iii) fail to pick out flies eggs when a thought of sensual desire has arisen and he
does not remove or abandon it.
iv) fail to dress wounds- when he fails to develop control over his faculty of all five
senses.
v) fail to smoke out the sheds- not expounding to others the doctrine which he has
heard and learnt
vi) does not know the watering place when he does not go from time to time to the
learned elder bhikkhus to learn the Dhamma, the disciplines, the codes
vii) does not know what is to drunk when he does not gain inspiration in the
meaning of the Dhamma
76
viii) does not know one road - does not understand the Noble Eight Fold Path
ix) unskilled in pastures - does not understand the four foundations of mindfulness
x) milking dry - does not know the moderation of accepting from the house holders
xi) show no veneration to the elders when he does not maintain bodily, verbally or
mentally acts of loving- kindness towards the elders and learned bhikkhus both openly
and privately.
When a bhikkhu possesses these eleven qualities, he fails to grow, increase
and fulfill the Dhamma.
On the other hand, if a bhikkhu is well-versed in (i) knowing four elements.,
xi) shows veneration to the leaders and learned bhikkhus, he is capable to grow,
increase and fulfill the Dhamma.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha teaches eleven qualities that prevent a bhikkhus
growth in the Dhamma and eleven qualities that contribute to his growth.
77
35. CULASACCAKA SUTTA: THE SHORTER DISCOURSE TO SACCAKA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA VESALIYAM
VIHARATI MAHAVANE KUTAGARASALAYAM...
YAM KHO, AGGIVESSANA, MADISAM DAKKHINEYYAM
AGAMMA VITARAGAM VITADOSAM VITAMOHAM, TAM TUYHAM
BHAVISSATITI.
The sutta was delivered by the Blessed One at Vesali in the Great Wood in
hall with the Peaked Roof.
In this sutta we find a conversation between Saccaka and the Buddha.
According to MA, Saccaka was the son of Nigantha (Jain) parents who both
were philosophical debaters. He had learned a thousand doctrines from his parents
and many more from the others. He is also referred as Aggivessana of his clan name.
The debater Saccaka boasts of debate by which he can shake the Buddha and
his Doctrine, but when he finally meets the Buddha with a large following of
Licchavis and tries to refute his Dhamma, the Buddha explains in detail about his
Dhamma. Understanding this, Saccaka bowed down to the Master and satisfied the
Sangha with his offerings.
Summary:
The debater Saccaka tries to refute the Dhamma preached by the Buddha but
hearing and understanding the Dhamma, bows down to the Blessed One and satisfies
the Dhamma with his offerings.
78
MA states that this time Saccaka has approached Buddha intending to refute
the Buddha and his doctrine in which he failed earlier (sutta no.35). He comes alone,
thinking that if he suffers defeat then no one would know about it.
He intends to ask many questions to the Buddha, even wants to refute with a
question about sleeping during the day, but he cannot ask it till the close to the end of
the sutta.
The sutta narrates the Buddhas triumph over Aggivessana Saccaka who later
agrees that on debate, when the Buddha is assailed by offensive and discourteous
speeches, his skin brightens and colour of the face clears as he is accomplished and
fully enlightened.
Summary:
In this sutta, we find a long conversation between the Buddha and Saccaka
about the doctrine of his teachings. It is to be noted that Mahavira (Nigantha
Nataputta) is said to have laid equal stress on manokamma and kayakamma
(interaction of the body and mind).
79
Ven. Maha Moggallana wanted to hear the discourse given to Sakka and
performed some feats of supernormal power to make Sakka agitated.
Then at last Sakka, king of gods told him word to word what the Blessed One
expounded. Hearing this, Ven. Maha Moggallana disappeared from there.
Summary:
The Buddha explains how a bhikkhu wins deliverance by the destruction of
craving, so as to reaching the ultimate end, ultimate security from bondage, ultimate
holy life, ultimate goal and become foremost among gods and men.
80
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
The sutta was delivered by the Buddha in the Angan country at a town of the
Angans named Assapura.
Here the Buddha enumerates the qualities which are essential for an ideal
recluse.
He explains that a recluse should be pure in deed, word and thought. He
should train himself to control the senses. He should be moderate in food. He should
be devoted to wakefulness. He should be mindful and full aware and live in a solitude
and sets his mind on mindfulness. He should remove five hindrances and abide in four
jhanas (ecstasies). Then only he knows directly three true knowledges.
According to Buddha, such a bhikkhu is called (i) recluse, (ii) brahmin, (iii)
washen, (iv) versed, (v) purged, (vi) noble and (vii) saintly.
(i) A bhikkhu becomes recluse by excluding evil and wrong states of consciousness.
(ii) He becomes a brahmin by precluding evil and wrong states.
(iii) He becomes washen by washing away evil and wrong states.
(iv)He becomes versed by being versed in all about evil and wrong states.
(v) he becomes purged because he is purged of evil and wrong states.
(vi) and (vii) he becomes noble and saintly because he keeps at bay evil and wrong
states
of consciousness which is a cause of rebirth and suffering.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha narrates the things that make one recluse covering
many aspects of the bhikkhus training.
81
The sutta was delivered by the Buddha in the Angan country at a town of the
Angans named Assapura.
As in the previous sutta (no.39), the Buddha explains the recluses regimen.
He should not do mere outward practice of austerities but the inward practice of
purifying defilement.
It is not the robe which makes him a recluse, nor intoning texts nor having
matted hair.
But if he can abandon greed, malice, wrath, revenge, hypocrisy, fraud, evil
desires and all the evil qualities, only he can be a true recluse.
Summary:
While in the previous sutta, the Buddha narrated the things that make one a
recluse, here he shows the way proper to the recluse.
V. CULAYAMAKAKAVAGGA
(THE SHORTER DIVISION OF PAIRS)
82
(iii) by harsh, hurtful, rough speech
(iv)by tattling or talking unbeneficial
As regards unrighteous thoughts, there are three:
(i) if a man is covetous
(ii) if he is malevolent or wicked of heart
(iii) if he is wrong in outlook and conceptions
For the above reasons, some creatures take rebirth in states of suffering and
woe.
In the contrary, if anybody is righteous bodily, verbally and in his thoughts, he
will be reborn after death at the bodys dissolution as a great noble.
Summary:
This sutta narrates how the Buddha advised to the Brahmins of Sala,
convincing them of the truth of what he said.
83
This sutta is in a form of discussion of these two great personalities on various
subtle points of Dhamma.
The topics are for example, understanding/ wisdom, consciousness, feeling,
perception, pure mental consciousness isolated from the five bodily senses, right
view, right understanding, types of rebirth, the first jhana, the five facilities, vital
formations and deliverance of mind.
Summary:
This sutta is a discussion between Maha Kotthita and Sariputta on various
topics such as, understanding/wosdom, consciousness, feeling, perception and etc.
84
45. CULADHAMMASAMADANA SUTTA: THE SHORTER DISCOURSE ON
WAYS OF UNDERTAKING THINGS
EVAM ME SUTAM-EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
The sutta was delivered by the Blessed One at Savatthi in Jetas Grove,
Anathapindikas Park.
The Master says that there are four ways to undertake things.
The first is pleasant for the time being but ripens to the pain afterwards;
The second is unpleasant for the time being and ripens to pain later;
The third one is unpleasant for the time being but ripens to be pleasant
afterwards; and the fourth is not only pleasant for the time being but also ripens to be
pleasant thereafter.
85
47. VIMAMSAKA SUTTA : THE INQUIRER
EVAM ME SUTAM-EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
The sutta was delivered by the Blessed One at Savatthi in Jetas Grove,
Anathapindikas Park.
The Buddha says that an enquiring bhikkhu who searches the heart of others,
should make a study of the Tathagata in order to find out whether or not he is fully
enlightened. He should study the Tathagata in respect of the two states of
consciousness which come through eye and ear.
He should see whether Tataghata is restrained in fearlessness or through fear
or whether he has eradicated all passions and removed all pleasures of senses.
Summary:
The Buddha invites the bhikkhus to make a thorough investigation of himself
whether he can be accepted as fully enlightened.
86
v) If a bhikkhu lives among his fellows in the higher life without flaw, spot or
blemish, virtues which bestow freedom and
vi) if a bhikkhu lives among his fellows in higher life with the noble and saving creed
which guides him to destruct all evil
These are six qualities which in endearing, friendly and respectful which
conduces to accord, harmony, concord and unity.
The Buddha also explains seven extraordinary knowledges possessed by a
noble disciple who has realized the fruit of stream-entry.
MA states these seven factors the great reviewing
knowledge(mohapaccavekkhananana) of a stream-enterer.
Summary:
This sutta of creating love, concord, harmony and respect among the fellows
of higher life has been advisable by the Master when they are in dispute for a simple
reason.
87
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha narrates his disciples about his conversation held
with Baka, the Brahma who has a pernicious view of permanency of this world. But
Buddha has explained him the truth.
88
PART II
MAJJHIMAPANNASAPALI
I. GAHAPATIVAGGA
(THE DIVISION ON HOUSEHOLDERS)
Summary:
The Buddha explains in various ways why he praises the one who does not
torment himself or others.
89
52. ATTHAKANAGARA SUTTA : THE MAN FROM ATTHAKANAGARA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM AYASMA ANANDO
VESALIYAM VIHARATI BELUVAGAMAKE...
AYASMANTANCA ANANDAM TICIVARENA ACCHADESI;
AYASMATO CA ANANDASSA PANCASATAVIHARAM KARAPESITI.
In this sutta, Ven. Ananda speaks of the steps to Nirvana when he was
dwelling at Beluvagamaka near Vaisali.
On that occasion the householder Dasama, who is a businessman of
Atthakanagara paid his visit to Ven. Ananda.
In reply to a question put by Dasama, Ven. Ananda has explained eleven
doors to the Deathless.
A bhikkhu divested of sensual pleasures and divested of wrong states of
consciousness, enters on and dwells on the first, second, third and fourth jhanas.
He pervades the four quarters of the world with radiant goodwill, pity and
sympathy and poised equanimity. He abides in the plane of infinity of space, the plane
of infinity of consciousness and the plane of nothingness by passing beyond
perception of material objects, perception of sense reactions and perception of
differences.
Summary:
In this sutta venerable Ananda teaches eleven doors to the deathless by
which a bhikkhu can attain nibbana.
90
In time, the Buddha went there and after washing the feet he entered the
assembly hall and sat down by the central pillar facing the east. The bhikkhus sat
down by the western hall. And the Sakyan took seat by the eastern hall facing west
with the Blessed one before them.
Then he instructed Ananda to talk about the disciple in higher training who
has entered upon the way.
Ven. Ananda then addressed Mahanama, the Sakyan and said how a disciple
of the Blessed One is virtuous, abandons all sensual pleasures, is temperate in eating
vigilant, established in seven virtuous qualities, having won the perfection of poise
and mindfulness out of four Ecstasy.
It is to be noted that the belief of having merit by inviting eminent religious
personage when a new home is built for the householder still continues in Buddhist
lands. They often invite bhikkhus to hold an all night recitation of paritta(protective)
suttas and dhammadesana in their new home before they enter.
Summary:
The Sutta is delivered by Ven. Ananda on the practices undertaken by a
disciple in higher training.
91
Then the Buddha explains that the way of cutting off all his affairs by Potaliya
is one thing but the Noble ones discipline of cutting off of affairs is different.
Then he explains Potaliya how to cut off of affairs in his Doctrine. This
includes abstention from killing, theft, lying, calumny, covetousness, taunts, anger
and arrogance.
The sutta offers a striking series of similes on the dangers in the sensual
pleasures. E.g. if a dog overcome by hunger and weakness waits by a butchers shop
and then a skilled butcher tosses the dog a well and clean hacked, skeleton of meatless
bones smeared with blood, the dog does not get rid of his hunger and weakness by
growing such meatless bones.
Similarly sensual pleasures are compared to a skeleton by the Blessed One.
They provide much suffering and despair while the dangers are great in them.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha narrates Potaliya, a householder the true meaning of
cutting off of affairs in his discipline.
92
1. Jivaka was the abandoned child of a courtesan brought up by the Prince
Abhaya, he studied medicine at Takkasila and was later appointed as physician of the
Buddha. He became a stream-enterer after hearing the Buddha Dhamma.
But in this sutta, Jivaka declares himself a lay follower who has gone to the
Buddha for refuge. Scholars say, that perhaps it is used as a means of reaffirming
ones dedication to the Triple Gem (Buddha, Dhamma, Sangha) and not restricted to
an initial profession of going for refuge.
2. This sutta states clearly the regulations on meat eating laid down by the
Buddha for the Sangha. Buddha does not require the bhikkhus to observe a vegetarian
diet, but permits them to consume meat when they are assured that the animal is not
killed specially to provide him. Such meat is called tikotiparisuddha, pure in three
aspects which are mentioned earlier.
Buddha has laid down the precept of abstaining from killing animals for the
lay devotes but does not prescribe purchasing meat prepared from animals which are
already dead.
Summary:
In this sutta, we find a clear explanation by the Buddha concerning meat
eating by the Sangha.
93
The rod or Danda, originally a stick or staff, acquires the meaning of rod as
an instrument of punishment. The Jains regard bodily, verbally and mental activity as
instruments by which the individual torments himself by prolonging his bondage in
samsara and torments others by causing them harm.
Among these three kinds of rods, Nataputta describes the bodily rod as the
most reprehensible for the performance and perpetration of evil action.
The Buddha then narrates that the Tathagata is accustomed to use the
description action- i.e. bodily, verbal and mental action. And among these,
Tathagata emphasizes on mental action as the most reprehensible for the performance
and perpetration of evil action.
Digha Tapassi went off and told to his Master about the incident. The
Nataputta was happy about him. Upali, the most prominent disciple of Nigantha
Nataputta proposed to go to the Buddha to refute his doctrine.
Upali went to the Buddha and was having various discussions about both the
Doctrines. The Buddha explained clearly about the mental action emphasized in his
Doctrine. Upali was moved and wanted to become his disciple. In reply, Buddha
advised him to investigate thoroughly his Discipline. Upali was more happy to learn
this. Buddha also advised him not to dissatisfy and displease the other sects as a
householder. Upali was moved by the Buddhas advice.
In this sutta, we notice some gathas uttered by Upali in praise of Buddha and
they are remarkable composition characterized by majestic and dignified tone.
Summary:
The Buddha explains about mental action described in his Dhamma to Upali,
a householder and a follower of Nataputta who came to refute Buddhas Doctrine.
Instead, he finds himself converted by the Buddhas converting magic.
94
Once the Buddha was living in the Koliyan country where there was a town of
the Koliyans named Haliddavasana.
Then Punna, Koliyaputta (son of Koliyans), an ox-duty ascetic and also
Seniya, a naked dog-duty ascetic went to the Blessed One.
MA states that Punna wore horns on his head, tied a tail to his backside and
went about eating grass together with the cows. Seniya performed all the actions
typical of a dog.
Both Punna and Seniya asked about their destination and future course to the
Enlightened One. In reply, the Buddha said that if someone develops duty, habit and
behaviour of an animal fully and uninterruptedly, he will reappear in the animal
kingdom after death. But if he develops all these qualities having in mind to become a
great god or lesser by the virtue of asceticism after death, then he will go to the hell.
Hearing this, both the Punna and Seniya were crying and repenting about their
action.
Then the Buddha explains them that there are four kinds of action:
i) actions which are dark with dark outcome
ii) actions which are bright with bright outcome
iii) actions which are both dark and bright with dark and bright outcome
iv) actions which are neither dark nor bright with an outcome of neither dark nor
bright
conducive to the destruction of Karma.
Both Punna and Seniya took refuge in the Buddha.
Summary:
It should be noted that a wrong ascetic practice has less severe consequences
when it is undertaken without wrong view than when it is accompanied by wrong
view.The Buddha has explained four kinds of action in this sutta.
95
Once the Blessed One was living at Rajagaha in the Bamboo Grove, the
Squirrels Sanctuary.
Prince Abhaya was one of the sons of King Bimbisara of Magadha, though
not the heir of the throne. He was a disciple of Nigantha Nataputta.
The Nataputta asked Abhaya to go and refute the doctrine of the Buddha. He
taughould Prince Abhaya a two horned question with which he could put debate
with the Blessed One.
Prince Abhaya goes to the Buddha and invites him to his house for the next
day.
On that day, after serving alms food to the Buddha the Prince asks him the
question what his teacher has taught to him. The question is that whether the
Tathagata utter speech that would be unwelcome and disagreeable to others.
Buddha shows a child lying on Princes lap and says whether he will not
attend to him if the child is to put a stick or a pebble in his mouth. In reply, the Prince
Abhaya says that he will take it out immediately as he has compassion for him.
The Buddha explains then the Tathagata does not utter such speech which
i) knows to be untrue, incorrect and unbeneficial and also unwelcome and
disagreeable to others.
ii) knows to be true and correct but unbeneficial and also unwelcome and
disagreeable to others.
iii) knows to be true, correct and beneficial but which is unwelcome and disagreeable
to others.
iv) knows to be untrue, incorrect, unbeneficial but which is welcome and agreeable to
others.
v) knows to be true, correct but unbeneficial and also welcome and agreeable to
others.
The Tathagata knows the time to use such speech which is true, correct and
beneficial and at the same time which is welcome and agreeable to others.
Learning this, Prince Abhaya takes refuge to the Buddha.
From this sutta, it is found that Nigantha Nataputta knew about the dissension
between the Buddha and Devadatta.
96
Summary:
Prince Abhaya who is a disciple of Nigantha Nataputta wants to refute the
Buddhas Doctrine by putting a two-horned question to him. But Buddha explains
what kind of speech he would and would not utter.
97
60. APANNAKA SUTTA : THE INCONTROVERTIBLE TEACHING
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA KOSALESU
CARIKAM CARAMANO MAHATA BHIKKHUSANGHENA SADDHIM YENA
SALA NAMA KOSALANAM BRAHMANAGAMO TADAVASARI
UPASAKE NO BHAVAM GOTAMO DHARETU AJJATAGGE
PANUPETAM SARANAM GATETI.
Once the Blessed One was travelling through the Kosalan country with a large
Sangha of bhikkhus and arrived at the village Sala.
The Brahmins of the Sala come to extend their greetings and reverence. MA
conveys that as the village was situated at the entrance to a forest, many recluses and
Brahmins of different creeds would stay, expound their views and turn down
opponents views. This has left the villagers perplexed and unable to commit
themselves in one teaching.
They convey that there is no teacher agreeable to them in whom they acquire
faith supported by reasons.
Summary:
The Buddha advises that his uncontroversial teachings may be undertaken as
it will lead to their welfare and happiness. And then he explains what is the
incontrovertible teaching.
II. BHIKKHUVAGGA
(THE DIVISION ON BHIKKHUS)
98
On that occasion, Venerable Rahula was living at Ambalathikka. One
morning, the Buddha went to visit Rahula. Rahula paid his homage, washed his feet
and sat down at one side.
Rahula was the only son of the Buddha, born on the day when his father left
the palace to seek enlightenment. He was ordained at the age of seven by Ven.
Sariputta on the occasion of the Buddhas first visit to Kapilavattu after
enlightenment. He was declared by the Buddha as the foremost disciple those desirous
of training.
MA states that this discourse was taught to Rahula when he was seven, shortly
after his ordination.
In this sutta, Buddha discourses about lying.
Summary:
The Buddha condemns the lie and advises the bhikkhus to win purity in action,
word and thought by constant reflection.
According to the scholars, this sutta is the Pali counterpart of the fact referred
in the Bhabru Edict under Laghulavada sutta, describing the Buddhas discourse on
the subject of falsehood.
99
perfection of the Master, who was his father also and happy with the reflection of that
beauty in himself. The Buddha could read his mind and decided to admonish at once
as those thoughts could misguide him further. The Buddha then advised him to
contemplate the body as neither a self nor the possession of a self.
Admonished by the Buddha, Ven. Rahula turned back and sat down under a
tree. Ven. Sariputta, his Master saw him and came to him.
Summary:
Sariputta teaches Rahula the meditation on the elements, on mindfulness of
breathing and other topics.
100
64. MAHAMALUKYA SUTTA : THE GRAETER DISCOURSE TO
MALUKYAPUTTA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
ETTHA KHO PANESAHAM, ANANDA, INDRIYAVEMATTATAM
VADAMITI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANO AYASMA ANANDO
BHAGAVATO BHASITAM ABHINANDITI.
The discourse was taught by the Buddha at Savatthi in Jetas Grove,
Anathapindikas Park.
Here the Buddha deals with the five lower fetters or bondages and suggests the
ways to eradicate these five bondages.
The five bondages (Orambhagiyani Samyojanani) explained by the Buddha as
follows:
Sakkayaditthi (false view of individuality)
Vicikiccha (doubt)
Silabbataparamasa (affection of rites)
Kamacchanda (desire for sensual pleasure) and
Byapada (malevolence)
They are so called because they lead to rebirth in the same sphere planes.
Summary:
The Buddha explains the ways to abandon these five fetters, i.e. to abide in
four ecstasies, plane of infinity of consciousness and plane of nothingness.
101
There a bhikkhu named Bhaddali publicly declared in the Sangha about his
unwillingness to undertake the training precepts.
This sutta refers to the Buddhas practice of eating a single meal in the
forenoon only. According to the Patimokkha, the bhikkhus are prohibited from meals
from noon till one next morning. Though this practice is only recommended but not
required.
Bhaddali did not present himself to the Blessed one for three month period of
rainy season. During the vassavasa (rainy period for three months), the bhikkhus were
engaged in making a robe for the Blessed One wearing which he again would wander.
(This continues till today and the occasion is celebrated as Kathina Chivara
Dana among the Buddhists).
The fellow bhikkhus of Ven. Bhaddali suggested that he should give proper
attention to the Dhamma otherwise he would suffer.
Ven. Bhaddali came to the Buddha and paid his homage and begged pardon
for his transgress.
The Buddha then explains the ten qualities of a bhikkhu, i.e. right view, right
intention, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness,
right concentration and right knowledge and the right deliverance of one beyond
training.
When a bhikkhu possesses these qualities, he is worthy of gifts, of hospitality,
of offerings, of reverential salutation and an unsurpassed field of merit for the world.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha admonishes Bhaddali to be obedient and to conduct
himself according to the Buddhas teachings.
102
The Buddha and his disciples used to take alms from that town. Ven. Udayin
was one of them.
One day Ven. Udayin, rose from his evening meditation and paid his visit to
the Buddha.
Their conversation shows that the Buddha restricted the allowable time for
bhikkhus meals in two successive stages. He first prohibited only the afternoon meal
and allowed a night meal. According to the Vinaya account (Pacittiya 37), no mention
is made of this successive prohibition.
In this context, the Buddha explains four kinds of persons to be found in this
world.
One who progresses towards giving up acquisitions but his progress is assailed
by the thoughts and ideas into which these acquisitions enter.
One who progresses similarly is similarly assailed but dispels, ejects and
annihilates the thoughts and ideas which assail in his progress.
One who is similarly progressing but distraction of mindfulness comes from
time to time in his progress, so that mindfulness is slow of growth but he dispels,
ejects and annihilates the distraction.
One who recognises that bondages are root of all evils and frees himself from
them and is Delivered by destroying these bondages.
Summary:
The Buddha says that there are foolish people who thinks that giving up
certain matters is easy. They do not give it up. But this insignificant thing grows into
a bond strong enough to hold them fast.
This particular sutta is illustrated in the Latukika Jataka.
103
resident bhikkhus, preparing resting places and putting away their bowls and the outer
robes, they were very loud and noisy.
Hearing this, the Buddha inquired to Ven. Ananda. The bhikkhus were called
on by the Buddha. And they were dismissed from the Sangha by the Blessed One.
The bhikkhus departed. On the way, they met the Sakyans of Catuma. They
heard the incident of their dismissal by the Buddha.
They came to pay homage to the Blessed One and tried to restore his
confidence about those newly ordained bhikkhus. Then the Brahma Sahampati
appeared before the Blessed One.
The Sakyans and the Brahma Sahampati were able to restore the Buddhas
confidence on the dispelled bhikkhus.
The Buddha asked Ven. Sariputta and Maha Moggallana what they thought
when the Sangha was dismissed by him.
MA states that reply of Sariputta did not show his responsibility as he thought
that the Blessed One did not want to be troubled just then but to enjoy present bliss
and they would also do the same. The Buddha rebuked him.
On the other hand, Ven. Maha Moggallana replied that the Blessed One did
not want to be troubled just then but to enjoy bliss and accordingly he and Sariputta
would look after the confraternity.
The Buddha praised him and told that either he or they would lead the Sangha
of bhikkhus.
In this context, the Buddha then mentions the four terrors to be expected by
bhikkhus who have gone forth from the home to homelessness in the Dhamma and
discipline.
i) fear of waves- here waves is a term for angry despair
ii) fear of crocodiles here crocodiles is a term for gluttony
iii) fear of whirlpools here whirlpools is a term for the five cords of sensual
pleasure
iv) fear of sharks here sharks is a term for woman
Summary:
The Buddha mentions about four fears or terrors to be overcome by the one
who have gone forth into homelessness.
104
68. NALAKAPANA SUTTA : AT NALAKAPANA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA KOSALESU
VIHARATI NALAKAPANE PALASAVANE..
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANO AYASMA ANURUDDHO
BHAGAVATO BHASITAM ABHINANDITI.
Once the Buddha was living in the Kosalan country at Nalakapana in the
Palasa Grove.
During that time, many distinguished young men had gone forth from home to
homelessness Venerable Anuruddha, Nandiya, Kimbala, Bhagu, Kundadhana,
Revata, Ananda and others.
The Buddha wanted to know whether these clansmen are delighted in their
holy life. He asked them. Ven. Anuruddha responded positively in reply.
Then the Buddha narrates that the Truth finders object is that such and such
a bhikkhu by tearing five bonds, has been translated to a heaven never coming back to
earth, by tearing the three bonds, he is safe from future states of suffering, is not to
delude talk, nor to get for himself gains or fame.
For a popular illustration one must turn to Nalakapana Jataka.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha explains why, when his disciples die, he declares
their level of attainment and plane of rebirth.
105
eating. He should not be rough tongued and loose spoken. He should be easy to
correct and should associate with good friends. He should guard the doors of his sense
faculties. A forest dwelling bhikkhu should be devoted to wakefulness. He should be
energetic. And he should be established in mindfulness, concentrated, wise, and apply
himself to the higher Dhamma. A forest dwelling bhikkhu should be liberated and
abide in peaceful, immaterial, transcending forms. He should apply himself to the
superhuman state.
Summary:
The Venerable Sariputta gives a discourse on the proper way of life to be led
by a forest dwelling bhikkhu.
106
Summary:
The Buddha admonishes two disobedient monks and then narrates an
important seven fold classification of noble disciples.
III.PARIBBAJAKAVAGGA
(THE DIVISION ON WANDERERS)
107
Once the Blessed One was living at Savatthi in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas
Park.
The wanderer Vacchagotta visited him and exchanged greetings with him.
Vacchagotta then puts questions on the speculations about the past and the
future.
With a simile of the extinguished fire, which cannot be described as having
gone to any direction, so the Tathagata who has attained to Nibbana cannot be
described in terms of the four alternatives. The Tathagata has abandoned the feeling,
perception, formation and consciousness by which one can describe the Tathagata.
Summary:
The Buddha explains to Vacchagotta why he does not hold any speculative
view with the simile of an extinguished fire he tries to indicate the destiny of the
liberated being.
108
74. DIGHANAKHA SUTTA : TO DIGHANAKHA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA RAJAGAHE
VIHARATI GIJJHAKUTE PABBATE SUKARAKHATAYAM..
ESAHAM BHAVANTAM GOTAMAM SARANAM GACCHAMI
DHAMMANCA BHIKKHUSANGHANCA. UPASAKAM MAM BHAVAM
GOTAMO DHARETU AJJATAGGE PANUPETAM SARANAM GATANTI.
Once the Buddha was living at Rajagaha in the Boars Cave in the mountain
Vulture Peak.
There came the wanderer Dighanakha to pay visit to him.
Dighanakha was Ven. Sariputtas nephew. At the time he appeared to Buddha,
Sariputta had entered the Order for only two weeks and was still a stream- enterer.
MA states that Dighanakha was an annihilationist (ucchedavadin) which
explains the assertion : No (mode of ) rebirth is acceptable to me.
In reply to Dighanakhas questions, the Buddha says that i) there are some
persons who are satisfied with all, hold a view which is allied to passion, bondage,
pleasure and attachments. ii) There are some who are dissatisfied with all, hold a view
allied to passionlessness and freedom, aloof from pleasure and attachments. iii) There
are some who partly take the former and partly the latter view.
The Buddha then teaches the Doctrine leading to liberation.
Summary:
The Buddha teaches the sceptic Dighanakha the way of liberation through the
contemplation of feelings.
109
One day after the Blessed One departed for alms food, the wanderer
Magandiya came to the place. Knowing that there lived the recluse Gotama, he started
to dispraise him.
With the divine ear the Buddha came to know everything and in the evening
asked Brahmin Bharadvaja about the conversation held between him and
Magandiya.
Then came again the wanderer Magandiya. Buddha explained him he was not
a repressionist (Bhunahu) as described by the Magandiya. The Tathagata has tamed
the ear, the nose, the tongue, the body , consciousness and their respective functions.
He preached the Doctrine subjugating these. The attainment of Nibbana can be
obtained by destroying all these.
Knowing this, the wanderer Magandiya received full admission under the
Blessed One and the Order. And soon after his admission he became one of the
Arahants.
Summary:
The Buddha meets the hedonist philosopher Magandiya and points out to him
the dangers in sensual pleasures, the benefits of renunciation and the meaning of
Nibbana.
110
Ananda refers to the four ways that negate the living of the higher life.
Firstly, there is the teacher who holds that it does not matter whether actions
are good or bad.
Secondly, there is the teacher who holds that no evil is done by him who either
acts himself or causes another to act.
Thirdly, there is the teacher who holds that there is no cause or reason for
either depravity or purity.
Fourthly, there is the teacher who holds the Sattakaya Doctrine.
Ananda then narrates the four kinds of holy life without consolation.
First, there is the teacher who is all-knowing and all-seeing.
Secondly, there is the teacher who preaches a doctrine which is traditional and
scriptural.
Thirdly, there is the teacher who is a rationalist of pure reason and criticism.
Fourthly, there is the teacher who is dull and confused.
All these are false guides to holy life. Then Ananda explained the higher life
that is fruitful.
Summary:
Venerable Ananda teaches a group of wanderers about the ways which negate
the living of higher life and four kinds of higher life without consolation. The true
essence of higher life is then taught to them.
111
and noisily talking of baseless things. Seeing the Buddha, Sakuludayin and quieted
down his assembly.
Then he welcomed the Buddha and paid homage to him.
When the Blessed One wanted to know the topic of their discussion,
Sakuludayin asked him about the sophistic activities made by some other sects and
what were the reasons to honour, respect, revere and venerate the Buddha by his
disciples.
Then the Buddha explained about five qualities of him for what his disciples
honour, respect, revere and pay veneration to him. They are :
i) the higher virtue
ii) knowledge and vision
iii) the higher wisdom
iv) the Four Noble Truths
v) the way to develop wholesome states by
a) The four Foundations of Mindfulness
b) The four Right Kinds of Striving
c) The four Bases for Spiritual Power
d) The Five Faculties
e) The Five Powers
g) The Seven Enlightenment factors
h) The Eight Liberations
i) The Eight Bases for Transcendence
j) The Ten Kasinas
k) The four Jhanas
l) Insight Knowledge
m) The Mind-Made body
n) The Kinds of Supernormal Power
o) The Divine Ear Element
p) Understanding the Minds of Others
q) The Recollection of Past Lives
r) The Divine Eye
s) The Destruction of the Taints
112
Summary:
The Buddha teaches a group of wanderers led by Sakuludayin the reasons
why his disciples honour him and how a teacher can command the respect of his
disciples.
113
vi) right effort of one beyond training
vii) right mindfulness of one beyond training
ix) right concentration of one beyond training
x) right knowledge of one beyond training
xi) right deliverance of one beyond training
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha enumerates ten qualities of a recluse who has
attained to the Supreme attainment.
114
preached him two long suttas to provide him with condition of future attainment. He
attained Arahantship as the elder Assagutta during the reign of Asoka.
This sutta informs us that according to Mahavira, the four precepts and self-
privation are the recognized roads to the blissful state of the soul.
Summary:
The Buddha points out the follies of the Doctrine of Sakuludayin, a wandering
ascetic and explains his Dhamma.
115
IV. RAJAVAGGA
(THE DIVISION ON KINGS)
116
THULLAKOTTHIKAM NAMA KURUNAM NIGAMO TADAVASARI
.
ETAMPI DISVA PABBAJITOMBHI RAJA, APANNAKAM
SAMANNAMEVA SEYYOTI.
Once the Blessed One was travelling in the Kuru country with a large Sangha
of bhikkhus and arrived at a town named Thullakotthita.
The brahmin householders of Thullakotthita went to the Blessed One and paid
their homage. Then they were gladdened, instructed and roused with talk of the
Dhamma.
After their departure, Ratthapala, son of the leading clan of the town came to
the Buddha and told about his desire to go forth to homelessness.
The Buddha asked him to seek his parents permission. As he was only one
son of the parents and coming from a wealthy family, his parents were not giving
permission first but Ratthapala sought their permission at any cost.
Then he went to the Buddha and received full admission in the Order. MA
says Venerable Ratthapala became one of the arahants after twelve years of striving.
This sutta states that a monk follows four propositions enumerated by the
Buddha, i.e.
i) the world is in continual flux and change;
ii) the world is no protector or preserver;
iii) the world owns nothing;
iv) the world lacks and hankers being enslaved to craving;
If a monk goes forth from home to homelessness for old age, failing health,
impoverishment and death of kinsfolk that is not called a true renunciation.
The gathas uttered by Ratthapala gives his highly religious experience. It is
interesting to note that these are prototypes of the poems in Theragatha.
Summary:
This sutta narrates the story of a young man goes forth into homelessness
against the wish of his parents, later return to visit them and also about his higher
religious experiences.
117
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA MITHILAYAM
VIHARATI MAGHADEVA-AMBAVANE..
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANO AYASMA ANANDO
BHAGAVATO BHASITAM ABHINANDITI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Mithila in the Maghadeva Mango Grove.
There he recounts a story of Maghadeva, King of Mithila. The king was very
righteous and conducted himself by the Dhamma. To enjoy divine sensual pleasures,
he went forth from home life to homelessness.
At the end of many years, his son also enjoyed fully worldly pleasures and left
the worldly life.
Nimi was the last of the kings who enjoyed their lives like this.
Nimis son Kalarajanaka broke this tradition. He did not go forth into
homelessness.
Summary:
This sutta was mentioned in the Cullaniddesa as one of the four earliest
examples of Jatakas. In Maghadeva and Nimi jataka, King Maghadeva and King
Nimi were earlier births of the Buddha Gotama.
118
85. BODHIRAJAKUMARA SUTTA : TO PRINCE BODHI
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA BHAGGESU
VIHARATI SUSUMARAGIRE BHESAKALAVANE MIGADAYE...
UPASAKAM MAM BHAGAVA DHARETU AJJATAGGE PANUPETAM
SARANAM GATANTI.
Once the Blessed One was living in the Bhagga country at Sumsumaragira in
the Bhesakala Grove, the Deer Park.
On that occasion, Prince Bodhi, who was the son of King Udena of Kosambi,
his mother was the daughter of King Candappajjota of Avanti invited the Buddha for
a meal.
The Buddha went to the Kokanada palace, residence of Prince Bodhi.
The prince welcomed him and proceeded to the palace but the Buddha stopped
at the lowest step of the staircase seeing a white cloth lying down. Ven. Ananda told
the prince to remove it as the Blessed One would not step on a strip of a cloth.
MA explains that Prince Bodhi was childless and desired a son. He had heard
that people can fulfill their wishes by making special offerings to the Buddha. He then
thought of spreading a white cloth having an idea that if he had to have a son, the
Buddha would step on the cloth, otherwise not.
The Buddha knew that they would be childless for evil kamma in the past and
did not step on the cloth.
Later he laid down a disciplinary rule prohibiting the bhikkhus to do so, but
subsequently modified the rule to allow bhikkhus to step on a cloth as a blessing for
householders.
The Buddha explains Prince Bodhi about the aptness in a bhikkhu, to learn. He
says that there are five factors of striving.
i) If a bhikkhu has faith in the Tathagatas enlightenment
ii) If he is free from illness and affliction
iii) If he is honest and sincere
iv) If he is energetic to abandon unwholesome states
v) If he is wise and possesses wisdom regarding the origin of suffering and how to
destruct it.
119
Summary:
The Buddha teaches that pleasure is to be gained through pain with an
account of his own quest for enlightenment.
120
MA explains that Angulimala had just realized that the monk before him was
none other than Buddha himself and had come to the forest for the purpose of
transforming him.
The Buddha set back to Savatthi with Angulimala as his attendant.
Hearing this, King Pasenadi came hurriedly to the Buddha and inquired about
Angulimala. A yellow robed, shaven head monk was introduced to him as
Angulimala. He was frightened but the Buddha assured him not to be.
One morning bhikkhu Angulimala wandered on the way of Savatthi for alms.
He saw a woman in difficult and painful labour. Though he was never given rise to
thought of compassion, now with the power of ordination, compassion arose in him.
The woman and the infant became well by the truth delivered by Angulimala.
In the course of time, Angulimala became one of the Arahants.
One morning, when he was wandering for alms, someone threw sticks to his
body, someone threw a potsherd and hit his body. With blood running from his cut
head, with his bowl broken, with his outer robe torn, Ven. Angulimala came to the
Buddha.
MA explains that any volitional action (kamma) is capable of yielding three
kinds of result: a result to be experienced in the same life when the deed is
committed; a result to be experienced in the next existence; a result to be experienced
in any life subsequent to next.
Because of attaining arahantship, Angulimala had escaped the two latter types
of result but not the first, because even arahants are susceptible to experiencing one
present- life results of actions they performed before attaining arahatship.
Summary:
The sutta elaborates the story of the bandit Angulimala and how the Buddha
subdued him with compassion and led him to the attainment of arahantship.
Once the Buddha was living at Savatthi in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas Park.
121
A householder came to him whose only child had died. The Buddha referred
to the dear ones do bring sorrow and lamentation. The householder was displeased on
this and went off.
Eventually this story reached the Kings palace to the King Pasenadi of Kosala
and his queen Mallika. Mallika engaged the Brahmin Nalijangha to inquire properly
about this matter from the Tathagata.
The Blessed One points out the actual facts how the dear ones do bring sorrow
and lamentation, pain, suffering and tribulation.
The brahmin was rejoiced and informed the Queen Mallika about the
Buddhas explanation.
Then the Queen Mallika, the devout of Buddha, enlightened the King with the
Blessed Ones references.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha teaches that sorrow and grief arise from those who
are dear.
88. BAHITIKA SUTTA : THE CLOAK
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
YAM RAJA PASENADI KOSALO LABHATI ANANDAM
DASSANAYA, PABHATI PAYIRUPASANAYATI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
Once the Buddha was living at Savatthi in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas Park.
One morning when Ven. Ananda was coming from the Eastern Park, the
Palace of Migaras Mother, the King Pasenadi of Kosala met him and paid his
veneration.
On the bank of river Aciravati, they came. The king conversed with Ananda
on the behaviour of the Buddha. MA explains that the king asked this question with
reference to a case of murder of Sundari, a female wanderer. Wishing to discredit
Buddha, some wanderers persuaded Sundari to visit Jetavana at night and return at
dawn, so the people would become suspicious. After some time they had murdered
her and accused Buddha for it. After a week the false report was exposed when the
kings spies found out the real story.
122
This sutta teaches us the behaviour whether of act or of word or of thought is
wrong which is blame-worthy, malevolent and which ripens into ill and which
conduces to the harm either of ones self or of others or of both. That behaviour is
right which is divested of all these evils.
Delighting with the teaching, the King offered Ananda a cloak of sixteen
hands long and eight hands wide presented by King Ajatasattu of Magadha, so that
Ven. Ananda could make triple robe out of it and shared out his robe among his
companions of holy life and the offering would thus overflow.
Ven. Ananda accepted the cloak and went to the Blessed One, informed the
entire conversation with the King and presented the cloak to the Blessed One.
Summary:
In this sutta, Venerable Ananda answers King Pasenadis questions on the
Buddhas behaviour.
123
Soon after his departure, the Blessed One addressed the bhikkhus to learn,
master and remember the monuments of Dhamma which are beneficial and belong to
the fundamentals of holy life.
Summary:
In this sutta, King Pasenadi commends the doctrine in the monumental words.
124
V. BRAHAMANAVAGGA
(THE DIVISION ON BRAHMINS)
125
92. SELA SUTTA : TO SELA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA
ANGUTTARAPESU CARIKAM CARAMANO MAHATA
BHIKKHUSANGHENA SADDHIM ADDHATELASEHI BHIKKHUSATHEHI
YENA APANAM NAMA ANGUTTARAPANAM NIGAMO TADAVASARI
.
BHIKKHAVO TISATA IME, TITTHANTI PANJALIKATA;
PADE VIRA PASAREHI, NAGA VANDANTU SATTHUNOTI.
Once the Blessed One was travelling through the country of Anguttarapans
with a large number of bhikkhus and arrived at a town named Apana.
There the matted-hair ascetic Keniya came to visit him and invited the Sangha
of one thousand and fifty bhikkhus for meal the next day to his hermitage. The
Buddha consented in silence.
The ascetic Keniya went to his own hermitage and instructed the friends,
companions, kinsmen and relatives to prepare for the invitation.
There lived a brahmin Sela, who was a master of three Vedas, fully versed in
natural philosophy and in the marks of a Great Man and was teaching the recitation of
the hymns to three hundred brahmin students.
Sela came to know that the Buddha was coming with one thousand and fifty
disciples to take a meal to the hermitage.
On the day, he went to Buddha and saw more or less thirty two marks of a
Great Man on his body, except two. Knowing this, the Buddha performed act of
supernatural power and Sela saw that the Blessed Ones male organ was enclosed in
a sheath and the length of his tongue.
Seeing this brahmin Sela and his assembly received the going forth under the
Blessed One and they received the full admission.
In course of time, Ven. Sela and the assembly together became Arahants.
Summary:
In this sutta, we find that the brahmin Sela questions the Buddha and knowing
him as a Great Man, takes refuge in the Buddhist Triad.
126
93. ASSALAYANA SUTTA : TO ASSALAYANA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
EVAM VUTTE, ASSALAYANO MANAVO BHAGAVANTAM
ETADAVOCA-ABHIKKANTAM, BHO GOTAMA..PEUPASAKAM MAM
BHAVAM GOTAMO DHARETU AJJATAGGE PANUPETAM SARANAM
GATANTI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Savatthi in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas
Park.
At that time five hundred brahmins from different regions were staying at
Savatthi for some business or other.
On that occasion, there was a brahmin student named Assalayana aged about
sixteen years, master of the three Vedas, fully versed in natural philosophy and in the
marks of a Great Man.
The brahmins forced Assalayana to put a debate on the superiority of the
brahmins.
This sutta deals with the same subject depicted in the Madhura sutta (no.84)
and the Buddha repeatedly talked against the brahmanical pretensions that the
brahmins are superior to all other castes.
The importance of this sutta lies in its allusions to Yona and Kamboja region
where the caste system of the Brahmins did not prevail.
Summary:
In this sutta, Assalayana approaches to the Buddha to argue on the
superiority of the brahmins but Buddha talks against the Brahmanical pretensions.
127
Once the Ven. Udena was living at Benares in the Khemiya Mango Grove.
On that occasion, the brahmin Ghotamukha arrived there to meet Ven. Udena.
In this sutta, we find that the revered Buddhist monk, Ven. Udena, explains
Ghotamukha about the inefficiency of self torture.
Kaudaraka Sutta (no. 51) also deals with the same subject.
Being satisfied and pleased with the Ven. Udenas words, Ghotamukha built
an assembly hall for the Sangha at Pataliputta and that is now known as the
Ghotamukhi.
Summary:
Venerable Udena explains Ghotamukha about the inefficiency of self-torture.
128
Once the Blessed One was living at Savatthi in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas
Park.
There came the brahmin Esukari to exchange greetings with the Buddha.
Esukari considers the services rendered to all class of people prescribed by
Brahmins is correct. He also considers the birth as the criterion of division of people.
But Buddha speaks against it and explains how a man of any caste is capable
of developing his mind.
129
1. VASETTHA SUTTA : TO VASETTHA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA ICCHANANGALE
VIHARATI ICCHANANGALAVANASANDE
.
UPASAKE NO BHAVAM GOTAMO DHARETU AJJATAGGE
PANUPETAM SARANAM GATETI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Icchanangala, in the wood near
Icchanangala.
On that occasion a number of well known brahmins were staying there, e.g.
brahmin Canki, Tarukkha, Pokkharasati, Janussoni, Todeyya and others.
One day, while discussion between brahmin students Vasettha and Bharadvaja
one could not convince the other about how a brahmin should be. It created a dispute
between them.
They decided to go to the Buddha for this reason.
The Buddha expounded to these young brahmins, as to who is a real brahmin.
According to him, one who has abandoned clinging, overcome all bondages,
whose shaft is lifted, who endures without a trace of hate and violence, who does not
flare up with anger, who is deep in understanding, whose speech is free from
harshness, has no more inner yearning, has no more indulgences, who is truly wise
and other qualities- he is called a brahmana.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha resolves a dispute between two young brahmins on
the qualities of a true brahmin.
130
On that occasion, the brahmin student Subha, Todeyyas son, came to meet the
Buddha.
On various questions put by Subha, the Buddha explained the real union with
brahma and teaches him the way to rebirth in the Brahma-World.
131
PART III
UPARIPANNASAPALI
(THE FINAL FIFTY DISCOURSES)
I. DEVADAHAVAGGA
(THE DIVISION AT DEVADAHA)
132
102. PANCATTAYA SUTTA : THE FIVE AND THREE
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
CHANNAM PHASSAYATANANAM SAMUDAYANCA
ATTHANGAMANCA ASSADANCA ADINAVANCA NISSARANANCA
YATHABHUTAM VIDITVA ANUPADAVIMOKKHOTI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
This sutta was delivered by Buddha at Savatthi in Jetas Grove,
Anathapindikas Park.
The Buddha here refers to the various schools of thought.
Some of them do the speculation about the past and future, hold views about
the past and future and assert various doctrinal proposition concerning the past and
future.
Some assert that the existing self is unimpaired after death and while others
deny it; some describe annihilation and the destruction of the existing beings while
the others do not. Some hold misconceptions about Nibbana.
The Buddha does not support these speculations. The supreme state of sublime
peace has been discovered by the Tathagata, i.e. liberation through not only clinging,
by understanding as they actually are the origination, disappearance, the gratification,
the danger and the escape in the case of six bases of contact.
It is noteworthy that this sutta is a middle length counterpart of the longer
Brahmajala Sutta, included in Digha Nikaya.
Summary:
In this sutta, we find various speculative views of different schools of thought
about the future and the past and lastly it describes the Buddhas Doctrine of
attaining the Nibbana.
133
DHAMMASSA CANUDHAMMAM BYAKAROTI, NA CA KOCI
SAHADHAMMIKO VADANUVADO GARAYHAM THANAM AGACCHATITI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
The sutta was delivered by the Blessed One at Kusinara, in the Grove of
Offerings.
The Buddha states clearly that he teaches the Dhamma out of compassion, not
for anything else.
He teaches the bhikkhus four foundation of mindfulness, four right kinds of
striving, four bases for spiritual power, five faculties, five powers, seven
enlightenment factors, Noble Eightfold Path and these things should be trained in
concord, with mutual appreciation, without disputing.
He further teaches the bhikkhus if there is any dispute between a bhikkhu and
the other on the Abhidhamma, if a bhikkhu is guilty, everything should be settled
amicably.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha admonishes the bhikkhus to resolve disagreements in
between them about the Dhamma amicably.
134
Patimokkha, but a dispute should not arise in the Sangha about the path or the way
because it would cause harm, unhappiness and suffering for the gods and human.
He also explained about six roots of disputes.
i) If a bhikkhu is angry and resentful
ii) If a bhikkhu is contemptuous and insolent
iii) If a bhikkhu is envious and avaricious
iv) If a bhikkhu is deceitful and fraudulent
v) If a bhikkhu has evil wishes and wrong views
vi) If a bhikkhu adheres to his own views -
he does not fulfill the training and unbeneficial towards the Teacher, the
Dhamma and the Sangha.
There are four kinds of litigation. Litigation because of dispute, because of
accusation, of offence and litigation concerning proceedings.
There are seven kinds of settlement of litigation. It should be settled by :
removal of litigation by confrontation, removal of litigation on account of memory,
removal of litigation on account of past insanity, the effecting of acknowledgement of
an offence, the opinion of majority, the pronouncement of bad character against
someone and covering over with grass.
To maintain the harmony in the Sangha, the Buddha suggested six principles
of cordiality that create love and respect. They are:
i) a bhikkhu should maintain bodily act of loving- kindness both in public and
private.
ii) a bhikkhu should maintain verbal act of loving- kindness both in public and
private
iii) a bhikkhu should maintain mental act of loving kindness both in public and
private
iv) a bhikkhu should enjoy things in common
v) a bhikkhu dwells both in public and private possessing in common with his
companion
vi) a bhikkhu who leads the one to complete destruction of suffering.
This sutta testifies the fact that Nigantha Nataputta Mahavira predeceased
Buddha by few years.
135
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha lays down disciplinary procedures for the guidance
of Sangha to ensure its harmonious functioning after his demise.
136
In this sutta, the Buddha talks about the real permanence. He also explains
several paths leading to permanence, e.g. abandonment of sensual pleasures.
He further explains the way directed to the imperturbable, the way directed to
the base of nothingness, the way directed to the base of neither perception nor non-
perception, the dependent origination and noble liberation.
These are the approaches to various levels of higher meditative states
culminating in Nibbana.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha explains the real permanence.
137
Gradually, he is to abandon five hindrances and follow the teachings of the
Blessed One.
When asked by the Brahmin that whether every disciple do attain Nibbana, the
ultimate goal, the Buddha said that some of them do not.
The Tathagata is one who shows the way. He has explained it with a beautiful
simile.
Summary:
The Buddha explains the Ganaka Moggalana about the gradual training of
the Buddhist monk.
138
Then he explained the path what the Blessed one traced out and his disciples
followed him in the path which had come down from him.
In this context, we can refer Digha Nikaya. The Sangha is governed by the
personal judgments of its members but by the dhamma and disciplinary code laid
down for it by the Buddha. In this, the bhikkhus follow the Buddhas final injunction:
what I have taught and explained to you as Dhamma and Discipline will, at my
passing, be your teacher.
Summary:
Venerable Ananda explains how the Sangha maintains its unity and internal
discipline after the passing away of the Buddha.
139
On the questions put by a bhikkhu, the Buddha explained on five aggregates,
clinging, personality view and the realization of non-self.
II. ANUPADAVAGAGA
(THE DIVISION OF ONE BY ONE)
140
The Blessed One delivered this sutta praising Venerable Sariputta at Savatthi
in Jetas grove, Anathapindikas Park.
The Buddha says that Sariputta is wise, he has great wisdom, wide wisdom,
joyous wisdom, quick wisdom, keen wisdom, penetrative wisdom.
He further says that Sariputta has gone through the complete course of training
as laid down by the Master. And he is assured that the matchless Wheel of Dhamma
set rolling by the Tathagata is kept rolling rightly by Sariputta.
Summary:
The Buddha praises Sariputta for his development of insight when he was
training for the attainment of arahatship.
141
AYAM, BHIKKHAVE, BHIKKHU NA KINCI MANNATI, NA KUHINCI
MANNATI, NA KENACI MANNATITI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
This sutta was delivered by The Blessed One at Savatthi in Jetas grove,
Anathapindikas Park.
In this sutta, the Buddha narrates the characters of a true man and an untrue
man.
A true man neither lauds himself nor disparages others because of his
aristocratic family, influential family, because of his renown, of his gain, because he
is learned, is expert in Discipline, is a preacher of the Dhamma, because he is a forest-
dweller, refuse-rag wearer, open-air dweller, one- session eater and so on.
He never lauds himself nor disparages others because of his attainment of Four
Ecstasies and one planes of infinite space, of nothingness, of neither perception nor
non-perception and he enters upon and abides in the cessation of perception and
feeling.
On the other hand, an untrue man lauds himself and disparages others for all
these reasons. He does not conceive anything in regard to anything, in anyway.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha distinguishes the character of a true man from that of
an untrue man.
142
In this regard, the Buddha sets up three brief outlines of what are the things to
be cultivated and what are not.
In the first exposition, the Buddha has told about of bodily conduct, verbal
conduct, inclination of mind, acquisition of perception, acquisition of view,
acquisition of individuality- which are of two kinds : to be cultivated and not to be
cultivated.
In the second exposition, the Buddha narrates the cognizable forms, sounds,
odours, taste, tangibles and mind-objects are of two kinds : to be cultivated and not to
be cultivated.
In the third exposition, the Buddha speaks on the robes, alms food, resting
places, villages, towns, cities, districts, persons are of two kinds : to be cultivated and
not to be cultivated.
Summary:
The factors which cause unwholesome states to increase and wholesome
states to diminish in one who cultivates them, should not be cultivated. Such factors
which cause unwholesome states to diminish and wholesome states to increase in one
who cultivates them, should be cultivated.
143
In this sutta, the Buddha expounds in detail the elements, the bases, dependent
origination and the possible and impossible kinds of situations in this world.
144
The Buddha expounds to the bhikkhus right concentration. Its supports and
requisites are right view, right intention, right speech, right action, right livelihood,
right effort and right mindfulness. Unification of mind equipped with these seven
factors is called noble right concentration with its support and its requisites.
Summary:
The Buddha defines the factors of the Noble Eightfold Path and explains their
inter-relationships.
145
This sutta was delivered by the Buddha at Savatthi in Jetas Grove,
Anathapindikas Park.
In this sutta, the Buddha deals with meditation on the body-how is
mindfulness of the body cultivated and developed so as to abound in fruit and
blessings.
In reality, like Anapana, the Kayagatasati sutta is only a portion of
Satipatthana sutta.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha teaches about the rebirth.
146
III. SUNNATAVAGGA
(THE DIVISION ON VOIDNESS)
147
The Buddha inquired Ven. Ananda about the matter. MA states that Ananda
told that the bhikkhus were in delight because of making robs.
Then the Blessed One explained the true solitude to be mastered by the
bhikkhus.
He says that if a bhikkhu delights in company, takes delight in company,
devotes himself to delight in company or in a society, it is not possible for him to
obtain the bliss of renunciation, bliss of seclusion, the bliss of peace, bliss of
enlightenment.
So it is discovered by the Tathagata to enter and abide in voidness internally
by giving no attention to all signs.
Summary:
In this sutta we find that by seeing that the bhikkhus have grown fond of
socializing, The Buddha emphasizes the necessity of seclusion in order to abide in
voidness.
148
Summary:
In this sutta, Ananda expounds fully the marvellous and wonderful events that
preceded and attended the birth of the Buddha.
124. BAKKULA SUTTA : BAKKULA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM AYASMA BAKULO
RAJAGAHE VIHARATI VELUVANE KALANDAKANIVAPE
.
YAMPAYASMA BAKULO MAJJHE BHIKKHUSANGHASSA
NISINNAKOVA PARINIBBAYI, IDAMPI MAYAM AYASMATO BAKULASSA
ACCHARIYAM ABBHUTADHAMMAM DHAREMATI.
Once the Venerable Bakkula was living at Rajagaha in the Bamboo Grove, the
Squirrels Sanctuary.
Acela Kassapa, a former companion of Ven. Bakkula came to visit him and
asked how many years Ven. Bakkula had gone forth into homelessness.
Ven. Bakkula said that it was eighty years that he had gone forth.
In reply to another question, he told that he did not recall any perception of
sensual desire to have arisen in him.
And also, we find that Ven. Bakkula did not recall any perception of ill will,
any thought of cruelty. He also did not recall ever having accepted a robe from
household, ever having accepted an invitation to a meal, ever having accepted grasped
at the signs and features of woman, ever having given the going forth, ever having
bathed in a bath house, and so on.
MA states that Ven. Bakkula became a monk at the age of eighty. This sutta
took place when he was in his one sixtieth year. He was declared by the Buddha to be
the foremost disciple with respect to good health.
Summary:
The elder disciple of the Buddha, Ven. Bakkula enumerates his practices
during his eighty years of monastic life and passes away respectably.
149
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANO ACIRAVATO
SAMANUDDESO BHAGAVATO BHASITAM ABHINANDITI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Rajagaha in the Bamboo Grove, the
Squirrels Sanctuary.
On that occasion the novice Aciravata was living in a forest hut. Prince
Jayasena went to meet him. MA identifies Prince Jayasena as a son of king Bimbisara.
On the request by Jayasana, novice Aciravata told him about the Dhamma but
Jayasena was not satisfied with the words of Aciravata.
When Aciravata went to the Buddha and narrated the incident, the Buddha
then spoke of discipline. He says it is impossible for one who lives in luxury and
enjoyment to know what is to known by renouncing worldliness.
As a wild elephant is being tamed by discipline, he should be under training if
he likes to see what is to be attained by giving up worldliness.
Summary:
The Buddha here expounds how he trains his disciples with an analogy of
training an elephant.
150
127. ANURUDDHA SUTTA : ANURUDDHA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
LABHA TE, GAHAPATI, SULADDHAM TE, GAHAPATI, YAM
TVANCEVA TAM KANKHADHAMMAM PAHASI, MAYANCIMAM
DHAMMAPARIYAYAM ALATTHAMHA SAVANAYATI.
Once the Buddha was living at Savathti in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas Park.
Venerable Anuruddha is one of the senior disciples of the Buddha.
This discourse is given to Pancakanga, the carpenter of the king by Ven.
Anuruddha.
The boundless and immeasurable deliverance of mind and the exalted
deliverance of mind are explained to Pancakanga.
If a bhikkhu dwells with radiant thoughts of love pervading all the quarters of
the world, the whole length and breadth of the world, above, below, around,
everywhere- this is termed the deliverance of the mind that is immeasurable. If the
bhikkhu pervades with the idea of vastness, that is termed exalted deliverance of the
mind.
Anuruddha then speaks of four states of rebirth, among the Parittabha gods,
the Appamanabha gods, the Sankilitthabha gods and the Parisuddhabha gods.
Summary :
In this sutta, Ven. Anuruddha clarifies the difference between the
immeasurable deliverance of mind and the exalted deliverance of mind.
151
On that occasion the bhikkhu at Kosambi were deep in disputes.
The Buddha tried to settle the dispute, but he failed. He then retired to the
village of Balakalonakara. Ven. Bhagu was living there at that time. The Blessed One
instructed, urged, roused and gladdened the Ven. Bhagu with talk on the Dhamma. He
then went to the Eastern Bamboo Park and met Ven. Anuruddha, Ven. Nandiya and
Ven. Kimbila who were living with concord, with mutual appreciation, without
disputing, blending like milk and water, viewing each other with kindly eyes.
The Blessed One inquired about their way of living and was happy.
He then discussed the various impediments to meditative progress he
encountered during his quest for enlightenment, with particular reference to the divine
eye.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha discusses the meditative progress he developed
during his quest for enlightenment.
152
In this sutta, the Buddha speaks about the sufferings of hell and animal life
into which a fool is reborn whereas the pleasures of heaven for a wise man.
IV. VIBHANGAVAGGA
153
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANO AYASMA ANANDO
BHAGAVATO BHASITAM ABHINANDITI.
133. MAHAKACCANABHADDEKARATTA SUTTA : MAHA KACCANA
AND A SINGLE EXCELLENT NIGHT
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA RAJAGAHE
VIHARATI TAPODARAME.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
154
Once the Brahmin student Subha, Todeyyas son, came to pay veneration to
the Buddha.
He asked the Buddha that what is the cause and condition for the human
beings are seen to be inferior and superior, short-lived and long-lived, sickly and
healthy, ugly and beautiful, unfluential and influential, poor and rich, low-born and
high- born, stupid and wise.
The Buddha then says that their deeds are their possessions and heritage. Their
parents and their deeds which divide the beings into high and low.
According to MA, The Brahmin Todeyya was reborn as a dog in his own hour
because of his extreme stinginess. The Buddha identified him to Subha by getting the
dog to dig up the hidden treasure Subhas father buried before his death. This inspired
Subhas confidence in the Buddha, so he inquired about the workings of kamma.
Summary:
The Sutta explains how Kamma accounts for the fortune and misfortune of
the beings.
136. MAHAKAMMAVIBHANGA SUTTA: THE GREATER EXPOSITION OF
ACTION
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA RAJAGAHE
VIHARATI VELUVANE KALANDAKANIVAPE
ATTHI KAMMAM BHABBANCEVA BHABBABHASANCA, ATTHI
KAMMAM BHABBAM ABHABBABHASANTI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANO AYASMA ANANDO
BHAGAVATO BHASITAM ABHINANDITI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Rajagaha in the Bamboo Grove, the
Squirrels Sanctuary.
On that occasion, Ven. Samiddhi met the wanderer Potaliputta, where
Potaliputta misinterpreted the Dhamma. Ven. Samiddhi further came to the Blessed
One and narrated the incident.
The Buddha tells about four kinds of persons existing in the world. (1) The
person kills living beings, (2) takes what is not given, (3) misconducts himself in
sensual pleasures, (4) speaks falsehood. But on the dissolution of the body, after
death, he reappears in an unhappy destination, even in hell.
155
He can see some people who abstain from killings, from taking what is not
given, from misconduct in sensual pleasures and from false speech, he reappears in a
happy destination, even in the heavenly world.
Summary:
As in the previous sutta, in this sutta the Buddha reveals subtle complexities in
the workings of Kamma that overturn simplistic dogmas and sweeping generalization.
.
137. SALAYATANAVIBHANGA SUTTA : THE EXPOSITION OF THE
SIXFOLD BASE
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
ITI YAM TAM VUTTAM IDAMETAM PATICCA VUTTANTI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Savatthi in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas
Park.
There he expounded the six fold base, six internal bases, six external bases, six
classes of consciousness, six classes of contact, eighteen kinds of mental exploration,
thirty six positions of beings should be understood.
Then he has explained the six fold base. These are six spheres of sense more
or less of the Abhidhamma type. This sutta is the sutta counterpart of the
Abhidhamma exposition of ayatanas in the Vibhanga.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha has explained the six internal and external sense
bases and other related topics.
138. UDDESAVIBHANGA SUTTA : THE EXPOSITION OF A SUMMARY
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
EVANCA NAM DHAREYYATHATI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
156
Ven. Maha Kaccana elaborates upon a brief saying of the Buddha which was
delivered at Savatthi in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas Park.
Mahakaccana says that an almsmans thinks should always be so conducted
that, as he thinks, his mind may not either be externally diffuse and dissipated or be
internally set, and through non-dependence he may be imperturbed, so that, with his
mind thus secure, birth, old age and death and the arising of all ill do not happen.
Summary:
The Venerable Maha Kaccana elaborates upon a brief saying of the Buddha
on the training of consciousness and the overcoming of agitation.
139. ARANAVIBHANGA SUTTA: THE EXPOSITION OF NON- CONFLICT
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
SUBHUTI CA PANA, BHIKKHAVE, KULAPUTTO
ARANAPATIPADAM PATIPANNOTI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Savatthi in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas
Park.
In this sutta , the Buddha teaches an exposition of non conflict. A man should
neither pursue sensual pleasure, nor give himself over to self mortification . Buddha
says him to follow the Noble Eightfold Path for complete deliverance .
The Middle Way discovered by the Thathagata avoids both the extremes and
it is giving right vision , giving right knowledge , showing right way . Therefore this
is a state without conflict .
Summary:
In this sutta , the Buddha gives a detailed discourse on things that lead to
conflict and things that lead away from conflict.
157
Once the Blessed One was travelling through the Magadhan country and
arrived at Rajagaha.
There he went to Bhaggava , the potter and wanted to stay one night in his
workshop. On that occasion a clansman named Pukkusati who had gone forth out of
faith in the Blessed One was already staying there. At that time, Pukkusati had never
seen the Buddha before .
According to MA, Pukkusati had been the king of Pakkasila and had entered
into a friendship with king Bimbisara of Magadha through merchants who travelled
between the countries. In an exchange of gifts Bimbisara sent Pukkusati a golden
plate inscribed with the description of the three jewels and various aspects of the
Dhamma. When Pukkasati read the inscription , he was filled with joy and decided to
renounce the world.
Without taking formal ordination , he shaved his head, yellow robes and left
the palace.
He went to Rajagaha to meet the Buddha who was then at Savatthi , about
three hundred miles away.
Knowing Pukkusatis capacity to attain the paths and fruits, the Buddha
journeyed alone on foot to Rajagaha to meet him. To avoid being recognized, the
Buddha concealed the marks of a Great Man and appeared just like an ordinary
wandering monk. He arrived at the potters shed shortly after Pukkusati had arrived
there.
To the revered Pukkusati the Buddha expounded the six elements- earth,
water, fire, air, space and consciousness .
This forms the Suttanta counter part of the Abhidhamma exposition of dhatus
in the Vibhanga.
Summary:
The Buddha gives Pukkusati a profound discourse on the elements
culminating in the four foundations of arahantship.
158
IDAMAVOCA AYASMA SARIPUTTO. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU
AYASMATO SARIPUTTASSA BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Benares in the Deer Park.
There he addresses the bhikkhus about the noble truth of the origin of
suffering, the cessation of suffering , the noble truth of the way leading to the
cessation of suffering. In the Deer Park at Isipatana, the Tathagata set rolling the
matchless wheel of the dhamma which cannot be stopped by any recluse or Brahmin
or god or Mara or Brahmin or anyone in the world.
The Buddha also advises the bhikkhus to cultivate friendship of Sariputta and
Moggallana. He narrates that Sariputta is like a mother, Moggallana is like a nurse.
Sariputta trains others for the fruit of stream entry, Moggallana for the supreme
goal.
Thereafter he has instructed the bhikkhus to listen to the Four Noble Truths
from Sariputta .
The Ven. Sariputta expounds elaborately the Noble Truths to the Sangha .
This sutta corresponding to the Saccaniddesa in the Mahasatipatthana Sutta of
the Digha Nikya .
Summary:
In this sutta, the Venerable Sariputta gives a detailed analysis of the Four
Noble Truths.
159
Mahamapajapati Gotami was the younger sister of the queen Mahamaya, the
Buddhas mother and was also the wife of king Suddhodana. After Mahamayas
death, she became the Buddhas foster mother. The present sutta takes place at an
early point in the Buddhasasana. After the death of king Suddhodana, Mahapajapati
pleaded the Buddha to admit her into the Sangha. Her acceptance marked the
beginning of the Bhikkhuni Sangha, the Order of Nuns.
MA states that the Buddha asked Mahapajapati to give the gift to the Sangha
because he wanted her volition of generosity to be directed both to the Sangha and to
himself and it would inspire the next generations how to show respect towards the
Sangha and supporting the Sangha with the four physical requisites towards the
longevity of the Dispensation.
The Buddha states here about alms giving. Donations to individuals are ranked
in fourteen grades, e.g. a truth finder, Arahat, All-enlightened, Pacceka Buddha, non-
returner, Truth-finders arahat disciples and so on.
There are seven kinds of offering to the Sangha.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha enumerates fourteen kinds of personal offerings and
seven kinds of offerings made to the Sangha.
V. SALAYATANAVAGGA
(THE DIVISION OF THE SIXFOLD BASE)
143. ANATHAPINDIKOVADA SUTTA : ADVICE TO ANATHAPINDIKA
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
YAVATAKAM KHO, ANANDA, TAKKAYA PATTABBAM,
ANUPPATTAM TAM TAYA. ANATHAPINDIKO SO, ANANDA,
DEVAPUTTOTI. IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANO
AYASMA ANANDO BHAGAVATO BHASITAM ABHINANDITI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Savatthi in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas
Park.
On that occasion, the householder Anathapindika was gravely ill. He sent a
messenger to pay his veneration to the Buddha and to Sariputta a request if he would
come to his residence.
160
Venerable Sariputta consented in silence and went to the householders
residence accompanying Venerable Ananda.
Sariputta exhorted the householder not to be a creature of sight, hearing, smell,
taste, touch and mind. He should not cling to the elements such as earth, water, fire,
wind, space and consciousness. He should not cling to the plastic forces, of the realm
of infinity of space, of the realm of nothingness, of the realm of neither perception nor
non-perception.
Soon after the departure of Sariputta and Ananda, the Anathapindika died and
reappeared in the Tusita heaven.
Summary:
In this sutta, Venerable Sariputta gave a stirring sermon on non-attachment to
Anathapindika on his death bed.
161
still an ordinary person, he was aroused and developed insight. Then he attained
arahantship just before he expired.
Summary:
The Venerable Channa, gravely ill, takes his own life despite the attempts of
two brother-monks-Sariputta and Maha Cunda to dissuade him.
162
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Savatthi in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas
Park.
On that occasion, Mahapajapati Gotami together with five hundred bhikkhunis
requested the Blessed One to advise, to instruct and to talk on the Dhamma to the
bhikkhunis.
The elder bhikkhus were taking turns in advising the bhikkhunis but Ven.
Nandaka did not want to advise them when his turn came.
We find one of the eight important rules laid down by the Buddha when he
established the bhikkhuni Sangha that every fortnight the bhikkhuni should request
the bhikkhus to send a bhikkhu for the purpose of giving them an explanation.
MA states that in a previous life Ven. Nandaka had been a king and those
bhikkhunis were his concubines. He wanted to avoid his turn as he thought the other
bhikkhu possessing the knowledge of past lives would think that still he could not
separate himself from his former concubines if he had been surrounded by the
bhikkhunis.
But the Buddha saw that Ven. Nandakas discourse would benefit the
bhikkhunis and he requested him to instruct them.
Then Ven. Nandaka gave his discourse to the bhikkhunis on impermanency of
sight, forms and six groups of perception.
Summary:
In this sutta, Ven. Nandaka gives the nuns a discourse on impermanence.
163
One morning, he accompanied Rahula to the Blind Mens Grove as he thought
that the states that ripen in deliverance have ripened in Rahula and supposed to lead
him on further to the destruction of the taints.
Then he speaks of transitoriness of things material and advises Rahula in order
to school him in the eradication of defilements.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha gives Rahula a discourse that leads him to the
attainment of arahantship.
164
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA SAVATTHIYAM
VIHARATI JETAVANE ANATHAPINDIKASSA ARAME
VIJJA CA VIMUTTI CA- IME DHAMMA ABHINNA
SACCHIKATABBATI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANA TE BHIKKHU BHAGAVATO
BHASITAM ABHINANDUNTI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Savatthi in Jetas Grove, Anathapindikas
Park.
There he has taught a discourse to the bhikkhus on the great sixfold base.
They are : sense of sight, sense of hearing , sense of smelling, sense of taste,
sense of touch and the sense of comprehending.
He also speaks the if one abides inflamed by lust, fettered, infatuated,
contemplating gratification, then ones bodily and mental troubles increase, ones
bodily and mental torments increase, ones bodily and mental fevers increase and one
experiences bodily and mental suffering.
At the same time, if a view of a person is right view, intentions is right
intention, effort is right effort, mindfulness is right mindfulness, concentration is right
concentration and thus the Noble Eightfold path comes to fulfillment in him.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha narrates that wrong view about the six kinds of sense
experience leads to bondages whereas the right view leads to liberation.
165
The Buddha delivered a discourse on what kind of recluses and Brahmins
should not be honoured, respected, revered and venerated and what kind of recluses
and Brahmins should be honoured., respected, revered and venerated. He explained
that those who should get honour had shed all lust, hate and delusion in connection
with the six domains of sense.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha has explained to a group of brahmin householders
what kind of recluses and brahmins should be honoured.
151.PINDAPATAPARISUDDHI SUTTA : THE PURIFICATION OF
ALMSFOOD
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA RAJAGAHE
VIHARATI VELUVANE KALANAKANIVAPE.
TASMATIHA, SARIPUTTA, PACCAVEKKHITVA
PACCAVEKKHITVA PINDAPATAM PARISODHESSAMATI- EVANHI VO,
SARIPUTTA, SIKHITABBANTI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANO AYASMA SARIPUTTO
BHAGAVATO BHASITAM ABHINANDITI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Rajagaha in the Bamboo Grove, the
Squirrels Sanctuary.
On one evening, he told Sariputta that the recluses and brahmins in the past
have purified their alms food reviewing thus : whether on the path he used to go for
alms food there was desire, lust, hate, delusion or aversion in mind, and so the five
cords of sensual pleasure arises in mind. If he can abandon these, he can abide happy
and glad, training day and night in wholesome states.
And a bhikkhu should make an effort to achieve the four foundations of
mindfulness, five faculties, five powers, seven enlightenment factors and the Noble
Eightfold Path.
Thus a bhikkhu can purify the alms food by repeatedly reviewing himself.
Summary:
The Buddha teaches Sariputta how a bhikkhu should review himself to make
worthy of alms food.
166
152.INDRIYABHAVANA SUTTA : THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE
FACULTIES
EVAM ME SUTAM- EKAM SAMAYAM BHAGAVA GAJANGALAYAM
VIHARATI SUVELUVANE..
ETANI, ANANDA, RUKKHAMULANI, ETANI SUNNAGARANI,
JHAYATHANANDA, MA PAMADATTHA, MA PACCHA VIPPATISARINO
AHUVATTHA. AYAM VO AMHAKAM ANUSASANITI.
IDAMAVOCA BHAGAVA. ATTAMANO AYASMA ANANDO
BHAGAVATO BHASITAM ABHINANDITI.
Once the Blessed One was living at Kajangala, in a grove of mukhelu trees.
There came Uttara, a pupil of the Brahmin Parasariya.
Asking about how the development of the faculties is being taught by
Parasariya, the Blessed One said the supreme development of the faculties in the
Noble Ones Discipline made it different from other doctrines.
According to the Buddha, a bhikkhu is indifferent to something agreeable or
disagreeable which results either from his seeing forms with the eyes or from his
hearing sounds with the ears.
Summary:
In this sutta, the Buddha explained the supreme development of control over
the sense faculties.
SECTION 6
CHANTING TRADITION OF THE PARTICIPATING THERAVADA
COUNTRIES : AN UNDERSTANDING
As told earlier, the countries participated in this Pali Chanting Ceremony are
Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, India, Nepal, Thailand, Myanmar, Cambodia and Laos.
The study deals with the chanting tradition of these countries. It is observed
that Ratana Sutta, Mangala Sutta and Karaniya-metta Sutta are the three suttas
chanted on almost every occasion in the Theravada Temples. Before the sutta
deliverance, the monks chant Buddha Vandana (Invocation to the Buddha),
Trisaran (Three Refuges), Pancasila (Five Precepts), Buddhanussati (9 qualities of
the Buddha), Dhammanussati (6 qualities of the Dhamma) and Sanghanussati (9
qualities of the Sangha). This is the general order of chanting.
167
There are suttas in Theravada tradition which are used as healing purpose or
for protection from the evils, such as, Angulimala Sutta (to diminish the labour pain
of a pregnant lady), Bojjhanga Sutta (mantra for prevention of diseases), Supubbana
Sutta (mantra of protection from fear), Jinapanjara Gatha (mantra for long life),
Atanatiya Sutta (invocation to Buddha with his disciples, healer for disturbances,
fear, worries etc.), Seewalee Paritran (to develop business and other monetary
transactions), Bhumi Sutta (for land purification), Khanda Parittan (to destroy
poison of snakes and other poisonous creatures), Jalanananda Sutta (for any
problem of a girl), Atavisi Piditha (28 names of Buddha), Satipatthana Sutta (for a
dying person) and etc. Jayamangala gatha, Mahajayamangala gatha are chanted
on the occasion of marriage, entering a new house or any other good occasions. It is
believed that any problem can be solved by the power of a sutta if chanted properly.
We have visited the temples of the participating countries in Bodh Gaya. The
countries like Laos and Nepal have no temples in Bodh Gaya. The Cambodian temple
is under construction. We have interviewed a few number of monks from different
countries. It has helped us to realize the tradition prevailing in their monastery as well
as in the respective country.
Though the concerned study mainly focuses on the chanting tradition and its
origin in different countries, but at the same time, tries to understand the architecture
of the temple to some extent, religion of art, the activity of the temple and activity of
the resident monks.
168
The Sri Lankans observe the Poson (June) full-moon day as the arrival of
Maha Mahinda to their country.
The Pali Canon, preserved as an oral tradition, was first written in Sri Lanka
around 1st cent. B.C.
Sri Lanka has the longest continuous history of Buddhism of any Buddhist
nation, with the Sangha having existed in a largely unbroken lineage since its
inception in the 2nd century.
During periods of decline, the Sri Lankan monastic lineage was revived
through the contact with Myanmar and Thailand. The repeated revivals and
resurgences- most recently in the 19th cent.- have kept the Theravada tradition alive
for over 2000 years in the island.
Nikayas
In the course of time, the Buddhasasana was nearly to abolish from the
country. There was no upasampada or the process of higher ordination existed at
that time in the island. During the Kandyan period, a samanera named Saranankara
was sent to Siam (Thailand) and he brought upasampada from there. The
govigama (people involved in agriculture), renowned as the highest caste in Sri
Lanka influenced the Buddhist clergy at that time. The tradition was then named after
Siam Nikaya.
This Nikaya is again divided into six sub-chapters- viz. Asgiriya, Malwatta,
Kelaniya, Dambula, Kotte etc.
Later on, we see the influence of Myanmar tradition in the Buddhist Sangha.
Amarapura and Ramanna Nikaya are the results. Amarapura Nikaya is further
divided into 21 branches.
These Nikayas differ in customary disciplines though the vinaya rules are the
same, e.g. the monks of Siam Nikaya use umbrella when they go out, shave eyebrows,
wear ekansika (one-sided) way of wearing the civara (attire), whereas the monks of
other Nikayas never shave their eyebrows. Amarapura monks also carry umbrellas.
Ramanna monks use a special type of umbrella made out of white palm tree which
169
looks like a snakehood. The monks of both these Nikayas wear the robes in dvajika
(both sided) style.
The monastic tradition is of two kinds in Theravada Buddhism.
Temple tradition- where the monks are engaged in Puja, daily activities of a temple,
dhammadesana to the laity, social gathering etc.
Forest tradition- where the monks prefer seclusion and mainly abide in meditation.
Monastic education:
The monks of Sri Lanka are educated in the Pirivena (institute of monastic
training). There are three types of Pirivena:
Moulika Pirivena- training centre for the monks only
Vidyayatana Pirivena- laypersons can be trained with the monks
Visvavidyalaya Pirivena- advanced training centre for the monks as well as lay
persons
The educational structure is as follows:
a) Basic course for 5 years
Exam: Pirivena Avasana which is equivalent to O level (school certificate) of
general education
b) Pracheena (1yr. course)
Prarambha (1 yr. course)
Exam of Prarambha is equivalent to A level (10+2)
c) Madhyama (2 yr. course)
Exam is equivalent to graduation.
d) Rajakiya Pandita
Highest degree conferred in a Pirivena
In the basic years, a student has to study Sinhala, English, Mathematics,
Science, History, Geography, Health Science, Craft etc. apart from Pali and Buddhist
Culture and Sanskrit.
From the Pracheena level, the course focuses only on Pali, Buddhist Studies,
Sinhala and sometimes Sanskrit.
The Pirivenas are residential strictly for the monks. Apart from the textual
education, they follow the Gurus instruction, learn the vinaya rules of the Order,
learn the rituals and the chanting of suttas.
170
It may be noted that laypersons if joined in the Pirivena are not given training
like the monks. They go through the textual studies only. And there lies the difference
in oral training or knowledge.
Though the Prarambha is equivalent to A level (10+2), the students of
Pirivena cannot join directly to the University. They have to pass A level in the
mainstream education and join there.
Sometimes the monks who have joined the Order at the later age finishing
their education, come to the Pirivena for monastic training.
There is no age bar in taking admission to the Pirivena.
Most of the temples have their own Pirivena. If not, the samaneras and the
monks of those temples are sent to the nearest Pirivena for education. In the vacations,
they can come to the temple and serve there.
In Sri Lanka, the Pirivenas are aided by the govt.
Chanting tradition
As we have mentioned the different Nikayas, it is observed that the differences
between these Nikayas are only on customary disciplines, the vinaya rule or the
style of chanting the suttas are quite same.
Since the chanting of the Theravada canon practically originated in Sri Lanka,
the monks have learnt it from an unbroken tradition of two millennia and the locally
spoken idioms belong to the Indo-Aryan family of languages, the pronunciation,
rhythm and intonation of chanting Pali suttas, as prevalent in Sri Lanka, have a claim
of purity and authenticity.
The slower rhythm of chanting, a pause between the phrases and melodious
tunes are the characteristics of this tradition of chanting.
Mangala Sutta, Ratana Sutta and Karaniya Metta Sutta are three main suttas
chanted regularly in each temple on every occasion. They are called Mahapidith
when chanted together.
Apart from these, sarvaratrika paritranadesana or whole night chanting of
suttas is another feature of Sri Lankan tradition. Previously, the monks used to chant
for 33 hours. Nowadays, it has come down to few hours of a night.
171
Before the beginning of chanting, devatas, yakkhas, gandharvas, pretas, asuras
and all beings of the world are invited through a gatha. The instruments such as vera
(drum), horanewa (shehnai type instrument) are played during this time.
Then followed Buddha Vandana, Jayamangala Gatha and the Mahapidith.
The first phase (pathanakavanavara) begins with Saranagamana followed by
Dasasikkhapada, Samanerapanna, Dvattinsakar, Moraparittha, Candaparittha,
Suriyaparittha etc. The second phase (dutiyakavanavara) begins with Mahakassapa
thera bojjhanga parittha, Mahamoggallana thera bojjhanga parittha etc. This
concludes with Atavisi parittha, Jinapanjara Sutta, Bhavatu sabba mangalam.
Then merit is transferred to the devas, Brahmins, bhutas through Akasattha. It is
noted that in the middle of Dhammacakkapavattana sutta, drums, flutes and horns
are being played.
The Sri Lankan monks use different types of rhythm in their chanting.
172
c. The Buddhas first sermon after his enlightenment- Dhammacakkapavattana at
Isipatana, Magadaya near Varanasi.
d. The bhikkhus Wassupagamana or Wass-Elabima (an annual ceremony in
connection with bhikkhus taking residence for the rainy season).
4. Nikini (August): Annual ceremony in connection with the bhikkhus taking
residences in the second rainy month.
5. Binara (September): The Buddha inaugurates Bhikkhuni Sasana.
6. Vap (October):
a. Bhikkhus receiving Kathina civara after the end of pavarana or the
observation of Rainy-Retreat.
b. The Buddha sent out his first disciples to preach the Law.
c. Prince Arittha was sent to King Asoka to bring a branch of the Sacred Bodhi
Tree to Sri Lanka.
d. Thera Mahinda entered Parinibbana.
7. Il (November):
a. Some says, the Buddha commenced his Ministry on this full-moon day, not in
Vap. And, he himself went to Uruvela and delivered an important discourse
Aditya Pariyaya Sutta to the Kassapa brothers.
b. Thera Moggaliputta Tissa, Head of the Sangha during King Asoka sent out
missionaries to different countries.
c. The bringing of the First Relics to Lanka.
8. Unduvap (December): The Theri Sanghamitta arrived in Lanka with Sacred
Young Bodhi Tree.
9. Durutu (January): The first visit of the Buddha to Sri Lanka.
10. Navam (February):
a. Sariputta and Moggalana became two chief disciples of the Buddha.
b. The preaching of Ovada Patimokkhadsana: this means a disciplinary code, based
on advice (ovada), which on all full moon and new moon days is to be recited in
the presence of the assembled community of monks who have received higher
ordination. This code of discipline was meant to be observed by the monks during
his first twenty years of the forty-five tear long Buddhahood.
11. Medin (March):
173
a. Charikava of the Buddha- the Buddha had opened for King Suddhodana,
Yasodhara and Rahula and many others the gates to Nirvana.
b. The Tooth Relic was brought to Lanka.
12. Bak (April): Buddhas second visit to Sri Lanka.
All the Poya days are being observed with Pancasila, Astasila, sutta chanting
and meditation.
Perahara is a festival of Kandy with the Tooth Relic exposition. This goes
on for 10 days in the month of August. Kandyan dance performed in this festival is
dedicated to the Buddha. The content of this religious dance are taken from Buddhist
stories.
174
The arches of the building is thus seen in the churches and the cross signs are
also to be noticed in the temple structure.
This is the first Buddhist establishment in Bodh Gaya and still serves many
pilgrims from different countries.
In February, 2007, this old building has been converted into Jaya Shri
Mahabodhi Temple. A portion of the Sacred Relics of the Buddha from Kandy, Sri
Lanka and those of his two chief disciples, Arahant Sariputta and Maha Moggallana
from the custody of the Maha Bodhi Headquarters were brought here and enshrined.
There are five statues in the Shrine Hall. The seated Buddha is the main statue
and the statues of Maitreya and Avalokitesvara installed on the both sides. The statues
of Sariputta and Maha Moggallana are also installed here.
The ceiling of the Temple has been painted in geometrical floral designs
beautifully. The interior sidewalls have been depicted with the scenes of the important
life events of the Buddha. At the right of the Temple entrance a Peace Bell is
installed. An Eternal Lamp Stand has been fixed and it will be kept lighted constantly.
All this work have been done by the Sri Lankan artists.
The fans and umbrellas used by the monks have been documented. In the
opening ceremony, we have observed the umbrellas are hold on the head of an elderly
chief monk. Umbrella is believed to be a good sign for all Buddhist rituals in Sri
Lanka.
Interviews
We have taken a few interviews of the monks of this school on and off the
camera.
175
Maha Thero of Siam Nikaya. At the same temple, he took upasampada or the higher
ordination.
Ven. Seewalee got his first education from a Moulika Pirivena and for further
study he came to famous Vidyalankara Pirivena at Colombo. After finishing the
course there, Bhante went to Galle and took admission in Revata Vidyayatana which
is a type of Visvavidyalaya Pirivena. At the same time, he completed the A (10+2)
level also.
Bhante stated very clearly that the govt. should take more care about the
educational standard of Pirivenas. The monks should be trained in other subjects also
apart from Pali and Buddhist Studies as it is very necessary nowadays to
communicate with the people and the world.
While he was telling about his childhood, he told that in earlier days, by seeing
a childs horoscope or knowing the family, the elder monks used to decide whether he
could come to the Sangha, as nowadays it is not the custom. Sometimes people join
the Sangha for the sake of their own benefit or for poor economic condition of the
family. As a monk, they get many facilities from the govt. It should be handled very
carefully otherwise the Sangha will be deteriorated.
Ven. Seewalee came to India to study Pali and Budhist Studies in the
Sampoornanand Sanskrit University in Varanasi and completed his Masters.
He used to give training to the samaneras from time to time and thus joined
Maha Bodhi Society.
Now, he is serving as the bhikkhu-in-charge of the Societys Buddhagaya
Centre about six years. During his tenure, we have seen the Pali chanting ceremony
commenced annually since 2006. The Jaya Shri Mahabodhi Temple was opened in
Feb. 2007.
As an organizer, Bhante has highlighted some points on the ceremony.
Firstly, the Societys aim to get all the Theravadin monks under one umbrella
and as a pioneering Buddhist organization, it is a responsibility of the Maha Bodhi
Society.
Secondly, the countries should share their views and Pali Tipitaka chanting
can be the common thread in binding them together.
Thirdly, during the Rain -Retreats, the Society has arranged a Precept Master
to train the monks for chanting Tipitaka in proper Pali pronunciation and phonetics.
176
Fourthly, the Society has already taken a project to train the monks from
different countries in a uniform way.
2. Venerable Dr. Medawachchia Dhammajothi Thero
Senior Lecturer, Pali and Buddhist Studies Unit, University of Colombo
Colombo-03, Sri Lanka
Ph: 0112735801, E-mail: dhammajothi@yahoo.com
As a scholar monk, Ven. Dr. M. Dhammajothi Thero has enlightened us about
the chanting tradition of Sri Lanka.
Uttodaya is a Pali book for rhythm system for the Pali gathas, but,
unfortunately, it is a copy of Sanskrit Uttaratnakaraya. The tistup, anustup pattern
of rhythm can be found in Pali verses.
Bhante says that there is a big difference in chanting of discourses of Tipitaka
and the paritta suttas. These paritta suttas are mainly taken from the books of
Khuddaka Nikaya which in the scholars opinion, a later incorporation in the
Buddhist Canon.
The monks use samudraghosa rhythm (as ups and downs of the waves) for
the gathas, e.g. Jayamangala Gatha.
Atanatiya Sutta , which is an invocation to the Buddha with his disciples to
triumph over disturbances, fear, worries etc. is recited in a vigorous and demanding
voice as if to chase the devils.
Sasapulutu is another rhythm of chanting the suttas where the rhythm goes
faster like a jump of a rabbit.
The practice of these styles among the monks is decreasing as the new
generation monks are not studying carefully about these rhythm systems.
The subodhalankar is another Pali book where alankar of Pali can be
found.
Ven. Dr. Dhammajothi, now in his late 30s, took pabajja at the age of ten in
Sri Dharmapala Ramaya Temple in Colombo. His Guru Most Ven. P. Dharmavasa
Anunayaka Thero was a famous scholar monk in Sri Lanka.
As a monk of Amarapura Nikaya, Bhante has given an account of Amarapura
Nikaya. There are 21 branches of Amarapura and each branch head is known as a
Mahanayaka. In the recent past, these 21 branches together formed Amarapura
Sangha Council.
177
The Anunayaka is in the second position of the Nikaya after Maha Nayaka.
In this Nikaya, each of the 21 branches has a particular place for giving
ordination to the samaneras. There is only once in the history where 21 samaneras
together have been higher ordained in one place. Bhante had been very much
fortunate to be selected as one of the samaneras and achieved monkhood.
178
He took his first pabajja at the tender age of ten in the Sri Somananda
Pirivena under the preceptorship of Ven. M. Dhammissa Maha Thero of Ariyawansa
Saddhamma Yuttika Amarapura Nikaya.
Out of six brothers and six sisters, Ven. Kusalacitta was the eleventh one.
Though his parents were not agreed to make him a monk, he had forced them to
change their mind.
He had joined the Pirivena when he was only seven as a lay boy. Gradually, he
passed Moulika Pirivena Avasana and entered in the Pracheena. During prarambha
course, he left the Pirivena and also the robe for ten days.
He came to Mahamevnawa Monastery and became a disciple of Ven. K.
Gnanananda Thero of the Kalyanawamsa Mahanikaya of Amarapura and Head Monk
of the Mahamevnawa Monastery.
This monastery has 35 branches all over the country. The monks are given
training in Forest tradition. The young monks are been transferred each four months
and the chief monk resides in one branch for one year.
The monks of this tradition concentrates on meditation. They dont go for
paritta chanting for dead persons or any kind of paritta chanting arranged in the
private houses. They wear the attire made by themselves and dye the clothes in a
mixed colour of brown, red, maroon and yellow.
The daily routine is as follows:
3.00am: get up and meditation
6.00am: breakfast
6.30am: study
8.00-10.00am: meditation together with the Sangha
10.00-11.00am: own work
11.00am: lunch
12.00noon: going together to the Temple for sutta chanting, each day one sutta
12.30pm: study
2.00-4.00pm: group meditation
4.00-5.30pm: study
6.00-7.00pm: puja, vandana both in Pali and Sinhala
7.30pm: hearing dhammadesana
9.00pm: going to bed
179
The monks give dhammadesana to the laymen once in a month (8am-4pm),
generally on a Saturday or a Sunday.
The full-moon days are kept for children and young students for giving
dhamma discourses.
180
Having been trained in Galauda Pirivena at Ampara and Urukoduwa Pirivena,
Colombo, he stated about a disciplined routine of a samanera or a monk in the Sri
Lanka temples.
Generally, at 4.00 in the morning they get up and clean their room. Then they
study. At 7.00 there is puja in the temple following meditation. Then at 8.00, there is
breakfast following study. In the meantime, they have to clean the temple and its
premises. Samaneras are engaged in plantation sometimes. They take lunch before
noon. After lunch, they go to Pirivena for study. In the evening at 6.00, there is puja in
the temple. The teachers teach them the rituals, the chanting of suttas and also
dhamma talks apart from the textual study. At about 10.00, they go to bed.
6.2 BANGLADESH
Bangladesh, a part of historical Bengal has a unique place in the history of
Buddhism, mainly for two reasons.
Firstly, Bengal was the last stronghold of Indian Buddhism where it could
survive as socio-cultural force until the 12th century, despite its disappearance from
other parts of the Indian sub-continent.
Secondly, it is believed that Bengal has given birth to the Tantric Buddhism.
The decline of Buddhism, did not totally disappear from the land of its birth,
and it is continued to survive in various forms of popular worship, rites and rituals
until its resurgence in modern India.
In the districts of Chittagong Hill Tracts, the south-eastern parts of
Bangladesh, a Buddhist minority had been practicing Therevada long before the
Mughals and the British arrived in Bengal. In course of time, these Buddhists
reformed their Sangha and in 1887 founded the Chittagong Buddhist Association,
believed to be the first Buddhist Society to be formed in the South Asian sub-
continent.
Nikayas
In the year 1864. Ven. Saramedha Mahasthavir, the Sangharaj of Arakan
visited Chittagong and found no pure Theravada tradition existing in the land. From
181
that time, Bangladesh Buddhist Sangha had been divided into two- Sangharaj
Nikaya- those who followed the revived and purified Upasampada. The other one is
Mahasthavir Nikaya- those who retained in the old tradition.
These two Nikayas follow the same Theravada tradition, yet the customary
disciplines are different in them.
Monastic education
The educational tradition dating back to the Vedic age followed up to the
medieval period is based on an individual teacher. The ancient term gurugriha (the
teachers house) refers to the fact that the religious leaders and organization devised
their own educational system. In such a way, the tradition of Buddhist education is
also prevalent in the monastery. This system is known as Antevasika (a pupil under
a teacher). The Doctrine (Dhamma) and Discipline (Vinaya) are being taught here.
The samanera (novice) used to receive oral wisdom from Bhikkhu (a fully ordained
monk). Now also in Bangladesh we find the monasteries where this tradition is
followed.
Kadalpur Bhikkhu Training Centre at Raozan, Chittagong is a famous training
centre for the bhikkhus.
The Pali Tols are found in Bangladesh. Previously, Pali Sanskrit Educational
Board was existing and any person could sit for the examination Adya, Madhya
and Upadhi of Pali. Nowadays, there is a rule that no one can sit for the Adya or
the basic examination until he passes the class X or School Certificate Exam. in the
general stream.
The monks of Bangladesh get education in the general schools together with
the laypersons. For the higher monastic training, they go to Sri Lanka or Myanmar.
182
the Mahasangha by the devotees), Punnanumodana mantra (for transferring merits),
Vivaha mantra (for marriage) etc.
Vaisakha Purnima and Kathina Civara Dana are two main festivals
celebrated in Bangladesh.
The Buddhas, birth, enlightenment and passing away are observed on the full-
moon day of Vaisakha.
During vassavasa or rainy season (Ashadi Purnima to Ashwin Purnima), the
monks do not go out of viharas and give dhammadesana to the devotees. They
follow all the orders of vinaya with Dasasila being in the temple. The devotees also
follow Astasila during this time. One month during Ashwin and Kartik Purnima, each
and every temple celebrates the Kathina Civara Dana festival. The devotees offer a
civara (robe of a monk) to the Mahasangha which is purified through vinaya and
sila. There are certain rules and regulations for making this civara. And one temple
can celebrate this dana only once a year. The Kathina Civara Dana is an important
event in the Theravada tradition.
Besides these two, Bangladesh celebrates Madhu Purnima during the month
of September (full-moon day of Bengali month bhadra). It is believed that a devoted
monkey offered honey to the Buddha on this day.
Interviews
1. Most Venerable Sanghanayaka Sasanajyoti S. Dharmapal Maha Thera
Chief Patriarch of the Buddhists of Bangladesh
Dharmarajika Buddhist Mahavihara
Atish Dipankar Sarak, Dhaka 1214, Bangladesh
Tel: 0189806507, Fax: 8802 9558757, E-mail: falguni@1postbox.com
183
The Most Venarable Sanghanayaka of Mahasthavir Nikaya of Bangladesh at
first refutes the divisions of the Nikayas. He clearly states that all are in the same
under the Buddhasasana. There is no difference in that. The Nikayas should act as
different organizations, not more than that.
As a Tripitaka Visharad, Ven. Bhante has explained us the chanting tradition
in Bangladesh monasteries and the transmission of oral wisdom to the next
generation.
He has also emphasized on the educational qualities of a monk so that they can
enrich the Sasana in a better way.
Bangladesh monasteries are keeping on trying to revive the Pali Tol
traditions.
184
Ph: 09433210505
A senior meditation teacher of Vipassana Research Institute, Igatpuri, Ven.
Buddharakkhita Bhikkhu has come to the Buddhasasana in a matured age of 29.
Born and brought up in a Bengali Buddhist family of Midnapore district of
West Bengal, Bhante had a long association with the Buddhist monasteries. He in his
lay life was a good athlete, an NCC cadet with many awards in his credit. He was
looking after a small business also.
One fine morning, Bhante decided to join the Sangha and took permission
from his parents who were very much happy with his decision.
In the year 1989 on 14th May, he took pabajja in the Midnapore Temple and
observed all the precepts of a samanera for four years.
On 19th April, 1993, he took upasampada in udaka-seema(the place, here in
a place in water where upasampada is given) and came to Vidarshan Siksha Kendra
under the preceptorship of Vidarsanacariya Ven. Prajnajyoti Mahasthavir of
Sangharaj Nikaya of Bangladesh.
Bhante went to Maharagama Pirivena, Sri Lanka for higher training. There he
had studied deeply the Buddhist texts. He joined Vipassana course conducted by
Vipassana Research Instt., Igatpuri and now he has become a senior meditation
teacher.
Throughout the year, Ven. Buddharakkhita is engaged in conducting courses
of meditation and dhamma teachings in several parts of the country.
He has enlightened us about the processes of Vipassana and emphasized that it
is necessary for each and every individual to experience the Vipassana meditation.
Man has to be aware of himself, analyse himself then only he can serve the society.
Bhante states that only self-culture through meditation can give peace to one,
then to the family, the surroundings and to the society.
According to him, participation in the Majjhima Nikaya chanting ceremony is
a nice experience. The study of Majjhima Nikaya is very much important to
understand the Buddha Dhamma. At the same time, chanting the suttas purify the
sound waves created by the vibration. The teaching of the Buddha spread worldwide
through purified soundwaves.
185
Resident Sraman, Vidarshan Siksha Kendra, Kolkata
Born in a Buddhist family of Bowbazar, Kolkata, Rev. Tissajyoti Samana was
simply a boy from the next door. As there is a tradition in the Buddhist families, that
one should be ordinated and follow the Precepts atleast for a few days in his lifetime,
Rev. Tissa took pabajja in his 16 years in the International Meditation Centre, Bodh
Gaya. He states honestly that he did not like the state of novice that time and came
back after 11 days.
He was working as a chef in an international hotel. One day, at the age of 28,
when he saw a boy from the neighbourhood was going to take pabajja, he also
wanted to join. But this time, he could not go back home, left everything and
continued to stay in the Vihara.
It is interesting that during his seven years samana (novice) life, he has never
wished to take upasampada as he thinks the time has not come as yet for him to
become a monk.
6.3 INDIA
There are various reasons for the decline of Buddhism in India, the land of its
birth. But after independence, the leadership of the new nation was not only
expressive in recognizing the importance of the Buddha and his teachings but also
symbolized this admiration by the incorporation of Buddhist symbols in state
insignia: the dhammacakka in the national flag, the Lion Capital of the Asokan Pillar
of Sarnath as the state seal and the installation of the Mathura Standing Buddha in the
Lok Sabha in New Delhi.
Babasaheb Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, the first Law Minister of India and the author
of the Constitution embraced Buddhism on Oct. 14, 1956 with a large number of
followers and thus gave a new life to Indian Buddhism.
All India Bhikkhu Sangha is founded by Ven. Jagadish Kashyap who
contributed a lot in the revival of Buddhism.
There is no temple in the premises of the Sangha, only a beautiful bronze
statue is installed in the premises of the Sangha.
The Bhikkhu Sangha provides facilities to the newly ordained bhikkhus, gives
Dhamma training to them to understand the Buddha Dhamma.
186
Interview
Venerable Bhikkhu Pragyadeep
Treasurer, All India Bhikkhu Sangha
Bodh Gaya, Bihar
Ph: 0631 2201199
Ven. Bhikkhu Pragyadeep is a veteran bhikkhu in India. As there is no
bhikkhu training centre as such, he agrees that a bhikkhu training centre is very
essential, specially in Bodh Gaya.
As for Indian chanting tradition, Ven. Pragyadeep highlights that the bhikkhus
follow mostly the Sri Lankan or Burmese style of chanting the suttas. It is an irony
that the tradition originated in India but it is lost in its origin. The All India Bhikkhu
Sangha is trying to teach Pali to the monks so they can pronounce Pali properly.
The north-eastern provinces of India is influenced by the Burmese tradition of
chanting. The other parts of India follow the Sri Lankan style. Apart from that, India
has a tradition of Mahayana chanting also.
The Venerable Bhante also states that Hindi translation of Pali gathas and
suttas is very much necessary in propagating the Dhamma.
For the rituals of upasampada, the monks use the seema of the nearby
Burmese Temple.
6.4 NEPAL
Nepal, the land of birth of the Buddha, has been officially a Hindu state but an
active Buddhist minority, identified as Newari Buddhists, has preserved the Vajrayana
Tradition through the leadership of non-monastic Vajracaryas and Sakya bhikkhus.
There was also a small population of Tibetan Buddhists led by the lamas.
According to the recorded history, after the social reforms carried out by King
Jayasthiti Malla, Buddhism was on decline. Ven. Mahaprajna, a Hindu by birth, then
became the first person to be ordained as the Buddhist monk in 1924 by Ven. Tsering
Norbu, a Tibetan Lama.
During the Prime Ministership of late Chandra Shamsher Jung Bahadur Rana,
the law of Nepal strictly banned conversion or prosetylization. Ven. Mahaprajna was
expelled from the country along with other four Buddhist Lama-monk. The Ven.
Mahaprajna in exile became the Theravadin monk in 1928 at Kushinara with the most
187
Ven. U. Chandra Mani Mahathera (Burmese). Late Ven. Bhikhhu Mahaprajna Thera
is the first Nepalese Theravadin Buddhist monk of modern Nepal.
In 1943, Ven. Dhammalok established Anandakuti Vihara, the first
Theravadin Buddhist monastery in Modern Nepal. In 1946, a goodwill mission from
Sri Lanka, headed by Ven. Narada Mahathera visited Nepal. The mission was allowed
to visit the places of Buddhist pilgrimage but did not have the permit to preach the
Dhamma and not to interact with other Buddhists.
All Nepal Bhikkhu Association (Akhil Nepal Bikshu Mahasangh) was
founded by Ven. Dr. Amritananda in 1951.
Now, there are many temples constructed in Nepal. There are only four
Seemas (place where higher ordination takes place) throughout Nepal.
Monastic education
Mostly senior monks of Nepal completed their study from Sri Lanka and
Myanmar. Besides that, the monks go to Thailand and Taiwan R.O.C.
Ven. Ashwaghosh Bhikkhu started Sangharam Bhikshu training Centre at
Chhetrapati-Dhalko. It is the first monk training school. Ven. Bhikkhu Gnanapurnika
established Vishwa Shanti Bauddha Shikshalaya where teenaged samaneras are given
training in the Dhamma. They are students of govt. school.
188
Meditation, lecture and special programme are held in every Uposatha Day
(full-moon day, half-moon day).
Interview
Venerable Bhikkhu Kondanya
General Secretary, All Nepal Bhikkhu Association
Buddha Vihara Bhrikuti Mandapa
Kathmandu 31, Nepal
Ph: 4226702, 9851046188; E-mail: ravikunnu@hotmail.com, sukhi@ntc.net.np
The General Secretary of All Nepal Bhikkhu Association, Ven. Bhikkhu
Kondanya has given a brief history of the Theravada Buddhism in Nepal and the
development of the tradition. He has also informed us the activities in Nepal in the
recent past.
It is good to listen from Bhante that there is no Nikaya exists in Nepal. He
states that as the monks put their full effort to revive and develop the tradition, it is
very important to keep unity among the Sangha.
Ven. Kondanya has enlightened us about the chanting tradition in Nepalese
language. According to him, though they follow the Pali texts mainly, but the
scholarly monks from Nepal have composed gathas in Nepalese language for the
convenience of Napalese people, e.g.
Jhyalanam Phaye Vala
Jhyalanam phaye vayu mata jaka sita yoma
Jyha tigu gaye..
Raguni Nugale
Raguni nugale gunhu gunhu nwayeka.
6.5 MYANMAR
189
Since 1948, when the country gained its independence from Great Britain,
both civil and military governments have supported Theravada Buddhism. The
Ministry of Religious Affairs, created in 1948, was responsible for continuing
Buddhism in Burma. In 1954, the Prime Minister, U Nu, convened the Sixth Buddhist
Council in Rangoon (Yangon), which was attended by 2500 monks and the World
Buddhist University was established.
Nikayas
In Myanmar, nine Nikayas are recognized. They are:
Shwegyin, Sudamma, Veluvan, Muladvara, Mahadvara, Satubumika, Dvara,
Mahayin and Ganavimutti. Among them, Shwegyin, Sudamma and Dvara are the
most common.
Like other countries, these Nikayas differ from each other in customary
disciplines, e.g. in the Shwegyin Nikaya, the monks wear very deep maroon colour
robe, always walk in bare foot, use fan made out of palm tree. They dont touch
money, so a lay boy wearing white dress always accompany them. They never chew
bettle leaves nor they smoke. The monks of other Nikayas are not that much strict in
the customary rules.
Monastic education
There are three types of Temples in Myanmar:
1. Phon Gyi Kyaung- only temple
2. Sarthantaik- temple with education centre
3. Kamathan Kyaung- meditation centre
The monks are taken pabajja and upasampada in the Phon Gyi Kyaung and
are educated in Sarthantaik.
The structure of the education is as follows:
Basic or Primary or Patthamange
Middle stage or Patthamalat
Higher stage or Patthamagyi, equivalent to 10+2
Dharmacariya which is 3yr. course, equivalent to graduation
190
Tipitaka, the highest degree conferred
In parallel, the monks can study in the schools and colleges.
Chanting tradition
Myanmar has its own style of chanting suttas. The rhythm is much faster than
others. They pronounce tha instead of sa, sa instead of ch and etc., e.g.
Buddham saranam gacchami, the Burmese pronounces Buddam tharanam gassami.
The novice or the koyin take lessons from ashin or the fully-ordained
monks. Sayadaw is the Maha Thera.
Like other Theravada countries, the paritta suttas are chanted for several
causes, e.g. Mangala Sutta for marriage; Pancasila, Metta, Atanatiya for a dying
person; Bojjhanga Sutta for anyone who suffers from diseases. Mora Oaritta is
chanted for danger of fire, Angulimala Sutta for pregnant women; Khanda Paritta for
snake bites and etc.
Besides that, Sambude Gatha and Surasmi Gatha are very special chanting
in Myanmar. Sambude Gatha is chanted while one goes out, Surasmi is for any good
occasions.
Rituals and festivals
As in Sri Lankan tradition, Myanmar monks also use thread while chanting.
Mostly they give purified threads to the sick persons to get well soon. Using fans or
yat and umbrella or shwet are the special features of Myanmar tradition. Veteran
monks hold the fans in front of their mouth while chanting. The umbrella is hold on
their head.
Vaisakha Purnima is the main festival. Vassavasa or the three months Rain-
Retreat is observed in a very pious way. They observe three full- moon days during
these months. Kathina Civara Dana is another big occasion to be celebrated. The
Burmese New Year in April is also celebrated throughout the country.
191
The fans used by the monks are generally inscribed by Arya Astangika Magga
(Eightfold Path) or twenty four Paticca Samuppada (Dependent Origination).
The chanting beads or japamala (Burmese pidi) are used in Burmese
tradition for chanting any Buddha mantra.
The Temple under review in Bodh Gaya is Burmese Vihara. It is built in a
typical Burmese architectural style. The walls of the temple are nicely covered with
the painting in Burmese style. The stories are taken from the life of Buddha.
There are variety of Buddha images seen in the Burmese temple. The Buddha
under the Bodhi tree is one of them. There is another image of Sheeva Koda with
the begging bowl depicting a myth in Myanmar. The Buddhas feet are also a
common religion of art in the country.
Interview
1. Venerable U. Nyaneinda Maha Thera
Chief Priest, Burmese Vihara
Bodh Gaya, Bihar 824231
Ph: 0631 2200721
Ven. Nyaneinda Maha Thera is living in India for the last forty four years.
From his vast experience, Ven. Maha Thera has shared his views with us. As for
Buddhagaya, he told there were only four monasteries. Burmese Vihara is one of the
oldest among them. Now, there are more than forty monasteries from different
countries. But, there is no training school in Bodh Gaya. It should be built atleast for
the Indian monks.
As a veteran monk, Ven. Maha Thera says that Nikaya divisions are not
necessary. It is a barrier among the monks to be unified under one umbrella.
Ven. Maha Thera has explained forty types of meditation. And, in Myanmar,
japamala or pidi is very common. Both the monks and laypersons use this and chant
Buddhanussati, Dhammanussati or Sanghanussati. He has chanted Patthana from
Abhidhamma, which is very popular in Myanmar with his disciple Ashin Sareikta.
2. Venerable U. Wanna Thero
Asstt. Bhikkhu-in-charge, Great Holy Land Monastery
Bodh Gaya, Bihar
Ph:06312200671,E-mail:Wanna2008@gmail.com
192
This Holy Land Monastery is a traditional temple of Arakan, constructed only
seven-eight years back.
According to Ven. U. Wanna Thero, tradition and culture of Arakan is almost
similar as in mainland Burmese tradition, only the dialect is different. The culture of
Arakan goes more with the Bengali Baruas of Chittagong, as Rakhaine in Arakan is
the place in northern Myanmar which is adjacent to Chittagong Hill Tracts.
Ven. U. Wanna has taken pabajja when he was ten years old in his village
Zeetaw Monastery under the preceptorship of Ven. Indawansa Maha Thera. He was
moved to Rangoon after six years and put into Sasana Mande Monastery in Bogo.
While studying there, he took upasampada in King Oo Monastery under the
preceptorship of Ven. Gnanasara Maha Thera.
Bhante has completed the Dharmacariya course in the monastery and he was a
teacher of Patthamagyi for seven years before coming to India. As a Masters from
Magadh University, Ven. Wanna has emphasized on the education of monks. He told
that there are only fifteen monks in Myanmar who has passed Tipitaka.
His vision in life is to look after the poor people in Myanmar, specially for
their education.
3. Venerable Ashin Thireinda
In-charge, Myanmar Buddhist Temple
10A, Eden Hospital Road, Kolkata 700 073
Ph: 033 2234 5039, 033 2237 3731, E-mail:uthirein@rediffmail.com
At the age of fourteen years, Ven. Ashin Thireinda has joined the Order in the
Thukhitayan Monastery at Bogo Dist. under the preceptorship of Ven. Ashin Gambira
Bodhi of Shwegyin Nikaya.
Bhante stated about his daily life in Myanmar. Early in the morning at 4.00
oclock, he would start his day. At 4.30, there was prayer. The monks of Myanmar go
out for begging alms at 5.30 and then they used to take breakfast. After that, he would
study. At about 9.00, they go out again for almsfood. In Bhantes temple, the food is
served by the householders. They did not have to go out for almsfood. In the
forenoon, the monks take lunch. Then from 1.00 to 4.00, he used to study in the
monastery. From 4.00 to 6.00 the monks look after the work in the temple. At 6.00,
there is prayer and meditation. From 7.00 to 9.00, again he used to study. And then,
193
he used to retire for the day. In between, they go to Dhammadesana. Sometimes they
translate the suttas of Pali into Burmese. But they dont chant in Burmese language.
6.6 THAILAND
By the third century B.C., Buddhism had spread widely in Asia, and divergent
interpretations of the Buddhas teachings had led to the establishment of several sects.
Theravada Buddhism was made the state religion only with the establishment of the
Thai Kingdom of Sukhothai in the 13th cent. A.D.
The details of the history of Buddhism in Thailand from the 13th to the 19th
century are obscure. Among the chief characteristics of Thai kingdoms in the
centuries before 1800 were the tendency to expand and contract, problems of
succession and the changing scope of the kings authority. The kings who expanded
their power also had a greater control over the Sangha and when a king was weak, the
protection and supervision were also weakened and the Sangha declined.
In the year 1851, when King Mongkut came into power and who himself was
a monk for 27 years, the Sangha became more centralized and hierarchical in nature
and its links to the state more institutionalized.
The most visible influence is that of the Theravada school of Buddhism,
imported from Sri Lanka.The second major influence on Thai Buddhism is Hindu
beliefs received from Cambodia, particularly during the Sukhothai period.
Nikaya
King Mongkut was a distinguished scholar of Pali Buddhist scripture.
Moreover, at that time the immigration of numbers of Mon from Burma was
introducing the more rigorous discipline characteristic of the Mon Sangha. Influenced
by the Mon and guided by his own understanding, Mongkut began a reform
movement which became the basis of the Dhammayuttika Nikaya.
Under the reform, all practices having no authority other than custom were to
be abandoned, canonical regulations were to be followed not mechanically but in
spirit, and acts intended to improve an individuals standing on the road to nirvana but
having no social value were rejected. This more rigorous discipline was adopted by
only a small number of monks. The Mahanikaya Order, was somewhat influenced
by Mongkut but with less exacting discipline.
194
Monastic education
There are Pariyattidharma school under Thai monasteries where the monks are
taught Dhamma studies. They are upto three guides. History, Philosophy, Vinaya and
other subjects related to Buddhism are taught there.
Parallel to this education, there are Pali Studies School where only Pali is
taught. There are nine stages, which is called Prayak. Now, this Pali IX is equivalent
to B.A.
These schools under monasteries are run by the monks. Apart from the
monastic study, one can join the general school and further to the university.
Rituals and festivals
Vedic Hinduism played a strong role in the early Thai institution of kingship,
so it has influenced the Thai society as well as Thai religion. Certain rituals practiced
in modern Thailand, either by monks or Hindu priests, are either explicitly identified
as Hindu in origin, or are easily seen to be derived from Hindu practices. Though the
influence of Hinduism has been diminished during the Chakri dynasty, particularly
the shrines to the god Brahma continue to be seen in and around Buddhist institutions
and ceremonies.
Vaisakha festival, Vassavasa and Kathina Civara Dana are the most
important events in Thai culture.
195
1. Venerable Dr. Phramaha Boondham Sucitto
Wat Chamnihatthakarn
119 Rama 1 Road
Bangkok, Thailand
Ph: 02 613 7741, 087 029 3700
As a veteran monk, Dr. Phramaha Sucitto has enlightened us about the
Buddhist culture developed in Thailand.
Serving the monasteries in U.S.A. for a quite long time, Ven. Sucitto finds that
general education is not enough for a nation, the education on Dhamma can complete
ones goal in life.
He told about the similarity of Indian and Thai culture and it is originated from
India. At the same time, he emphasized repeatedly that the younger generations of
India should be guided in a right way as they are the people who can preserve the
tradition and transmit it to the next generation.
Ven. Sucitto talked about the Disciplines shown by the Buddha and those
Disciplines of Dhamma can only guide us to lead our life in a proper way.
2. Venerable Aggvanno Thero
Resident Monk, Royal Thai Monastery
Bodh Gaya, Bihar
Ph: 09934019577, E-mail: yanroiet@yahoo.com
Working in a car company in Thailand, Ven. Aggvanno Thero has come to the
Sasana at the matured age of 24. In his village temple Wat Nikornbumrung he was
given training by his preceptor Ven. Phrakhru Vimondhammavatr. He explains that
Thai phra means noble or who is a teacher of the monks and dhammavatr is the
one who is good in Dhamma. In his 28th year, Ven. Aggvanno became a fully-
ordained monk.
Having a graduation from Mahamakut Vidthyalaya in Thailand and a Masters
from Magadh University, Ven. Aggvanno is doing his research in Kolkata University
on The strategy in ethical cultivation for Thai youth: the School of the Buddhist way
of life.
According to him, the monks in Thai tradition are very social. They run the
village shops even. They are very much active in social affairs. And, they can leave
196
their robes at any time, if they find that it is not suitable for him. It is not a shameful
act in Thailand.
6.7 CAMBODIA
Buddhism has existed in Cambodia since at least the 5th cent. A.D., with some
sources placing its origin as early as the 3rd cent. B.C. Theravada Buddhism has been
the Cambodian state religion since the 13th cent. A.D. excepting the Khmer Rouge
period.
Buddhism entered Cambodia through two different streams. The earliest forms
of Buddhism, along with Hindu influences, entered the Funan kingdom with Hindu
merchants. Later, Buddhism entered Khmer culture during the Angkor empire when
Cambodia absorbed the various Buddhist traditions of the Mon kingdoms of
Dvaravati and Haripunchai.
Nikaya
As in Thailand, there are two Nikayas. Dhammayuttika, which is influenced
by the reform movement of Thailand and the other one is Mahanikaya, which
maintains the ancient tradition of the country.
Monastic education
In Cambodia, there are educational centers for the monks in the monasteries.
Up to class IV Pathama I, it can be found everywhere in the country
Class V VIII Pathama II, it is found in the Provinces
Class IX XII Dutiya, only found in the capital Phnom Penh equivalent to 10+2
Tatiya 4 years course which is equivalent to B.A.
Uttama 2 years course which is equivalent to Masters Degree
Chanting Tradition
From the 6th to 7th century A.D., the south Indian variety of Brahmi script went
to Cambodia where it developed into Khmer script from which Burmese, Thai, Laos
and Indonesian scripts evolved. These scripts were written in Pali as well as the
regional languages. It help to spread the Buddhist religion and culture in those
197
regions. Buddhism virtually brought literacy to these regions in the field of literature,
art and socio-religious cultural exposition.
Cambodian chanting tradition is based on the oral wisdom transferred in the
monasteries. Besides the Pali suttas, Cambodians have translated some suttas and
gathas in their language.
Religion of art
The Cambodian Temple in Bodh Gaya is under construction. But, we have
observed the Buddha images of different pattern. The Buddha under the head of
Muchalinda is very common one. There is another image which has foue head like
Brahma which depicts the influence of Hinduism in Cambodian culture. The Maitreya
Buddha is also worshipped.
Interview
Venerable Poeuy Metta Thero
Chief Priest, Cambodian Buddhist Monastery
Bodh Gaya, Bihar
Ph: 0631 2200882
Ven. P. Metta Thero has come to Buddha Gaya ten years back to study M.A.
in Nalanda University. He is the Chief Priest of this monastery since its inception in
2004.
Ven. Metta has enlightened us about the Buddhist history in Cambodia, the
monastic education and chanting tradition.
According to his view, the Nikayas in Cambodia differ only in a few
customary disciplines and in pronunciation of Pali, e.g. he states that the
Dhammayuttika monks chant: namo tassa bhagavato arahato sammasambuddhassa,
whereas the Mahanikaya monks will chant: neark motassa bheark geark veark tou
arahatou samma samput tassa.
Bhante has shared his memorable events with us when he took pabajja at the
age of nineteen only in the Patuma Monastery in Phnom Penh under the preceptorship
of H.H. Ven. Maha Sumedhear Noun Nget Thero. The pabajja is celebrated in the
Cambodian families in a grand way. This is called Pithi Bombousneark.
198
Bhante remembered that he had come to the temple riding on a horse with a
white coloured cloth wrapped on his body, with a crown on his head and adorned with
gold and diamond jewelleries.
His parents invited the relatives and neighbours to participate in the ceremony.
He was taken to the temple in a procession and made three rounds to the temple. Then
he entered the temple and paid veneration to the elderly monks. He was offered a
civara and alms bowl. After the ceremony, he became a novice. In the age of 21, he
became a full-ordained monk.
Bhante has also told about the festivals of Cambodia. They are:
Makha Bochjear celebrated on the March full-moon day
Visakha festival The Buddhas birth, enlightenment and Mahaparinirbana
Vassavasa Rain-Retreat
Chumben festival celebrated the last three days during Vassavasa
Kathina Civara
6.8 LAOS
Theravada Buddhism is believed to have first reached Laos during the 7th-8th
centuries A.D. through the kingdom of Dvaravati. During the 7th cent., tantric
Buddhism was also introduced to Laos from the kingdom of Nan-chao, an ethnically
Thai kingdom centered in modern day Yunnan, China. The Nan-chao kingdom also
likely introduced the political ideology of the king as defender and protector of
Buddhism, an important ideological tie between the monarchy and the Sangha in
much of Southeast Asia.
In the later period, subsequent alliances with Burma and Thailand helped
Theravada Buddhism to become one of the primary unifying features of Lao culture.
Nikaya
The Laos Buddhist Fellowship Organisation is the only one under which the
Lao Sangha is unified.
Monastic education
During the 1920s, the administration of Buddhism in Laos was reorganized by
Prince Phetsarath, who established a system of schools for providing instruction to
the Lao clergy.
199
The monastic school in Laos is called Hong Hien Wat. The structure is as
follows:
Hong Hien Pathom Song or Primary school- Class I-V
Hong Hien Maddhayom Ton or Secondary school- Class VI- VIII
Hong Hien Maddhayom Pai or Upper Secondary school- Class IX-XI
After each part, there is an examination. In these schools, besides sutta, vinaya
and abhidhamma the subjects such as Maths., Geography, History, Lao, Biology,
Physics, Chemistry and English are taught. The syllabus in a monastic school and in a
general school is same. Only the monastic schools are restricted to the monks. The
syllabus is kept same as if a monk leaves his robe, then as a layperson he can
immediately join the general school. And it often happens in Laos. The Laotian
education system is somewhat advanced than in other countries.
Interview
Venerable Phra Maha Oudorn Phetchamphone
Wat That Foun
Chantabooly Dist., Vientiane, Laos
Ph: 856 20 9770502, E-mail: oudorn@mail2world.com
Assistant Secretary of Laos Buddhist Fellowship Organisation, Ven. Oudorn
enlightened us about his vast knowledge on Laos Buddhism, the chanting tradition
and the festivals of Laos.
He took his first ordination in the age of 15 years in the Nonesavang Wat
under the preceptorship of Ven. Kambai Bhikkhu. He has done his B.A. and M.A.
from Myanmar. He has visited Sri Lanka and Thailand also and gathered experience.
According to him, the chanting tradition of Laos is quite different from Sri
Lanka and Myanmar. It is more similar to Thai tradition, but the rhythm is different.
The suttas are chanted in Pali but in Laotian pronunciation. Apart from traditional Pali
suttas, the monks chant the suttas translated from Pali in to Lao language. They also
chant the composition of great Masters of Laos. Mahajaya and Culajaya are two
suttas taken for example.
According to Bhante, Laos follows the Buddhist era. The festivals are as
follows:
200
Maga buja or full-moon day of Vesak
Maga buja in February- It is told that in Veluvanarama, Rajagaha, one thousand
Arahat monks led by the Kassapa brothers and two hundred fifty led by Sariputta
and Maha Moggallana, altogether 1250 arahats had come there to participate in
the assembly presided over by the Buddha and took refuge.
Maga buja in Asalaha (Khaopansa festival)- celebrating dhammacakka day
Khao Padabdin festival and Khao Salakapatta festival- offerings for the
departed ones
Ork Pansa festival- ending of vassavasa
Kathina civara dana- in this time boat racing or Boun Suang Heua is held
Lao New Year in April- famous water festival is held
Vessantara festival- celebrated in March. It is one of the oldest tradition of Laos.
The story of the Vessantara Jataka are narrated by the monks. The festival
encourages the people to receive the ten paramitas. At night, sutta chantings held
in the temples. Next morning, the story is told in Lao language.
6.9 CHAKMA
The Chakmas are a tribe dwelling in the north-eastern part of India and Bangladesh.
They have their king who lives in Bangladesh and the community chief and custodian
of the customary law.Chakmas have their own scripts. They follow the Theravada
tradition of Buddhism.
Interview
Venerable Priyapal Bhikkhu
In-charge, Chakma Buddhist Temple Bodh Gaya, Maya Sarovar Area, Bihar
Ph: 0631 2200298, E-mail: priyapal5@yahoo.com, P_bhante@hotmail.com
As a monk from Chakma tribe, Ven. Priyapal Bhikkhu has given a brief
account on Chakma culture. According to him, there are two traditions prevailing in
the Chakma Sangha. One is Temple tradition under which the socio-religious
institutions exist, and the other one follows the Forest tradition.
The chakmas have their own language. Agartara is a book which is a
compilation of different suttas in Chakma script. According to him, the present
201
generation does not know the Chakma script as it is of no much practice. Recently,
Meghalaya govt. has introduced chakma as a language in the schools.
Bhante informs us that an effort is being made about translation of Pali suttas
into Chakma lnguage so as to preserve the language as it will reach the common
Chakma people.
AUSTRALIA
Venerable Bhante Sujato
Santi Forest Monastery
6 Coalmines Road, Bundanoon
NSW 2578, Australia
E-mail: sujato@gmail.com
An Australian by birth, Ven. Sujato was attracted to the Order when he once
travelled to Thailand and visited a meditation retreat. He joined the Sangha in his 26th
year of life in Wat Pa Nanachat in Thailand. Ven. Ajahn Brahmavamso from England
and Ven. Ajahn Chah of Thailand inspired him in Buddhism and became the
preceptors in his life.
Ven. Sujato conveys that the position of Theravada Buddhism in Australia is
good and day by day the number of followers are increasing.
Santi Forest Monastery holds seminars on different aspects of Buddhism and
workshops for the training of the monks from time to time.
Ven. Sujato plays a key role to revive the Bhikkhuni Order as he finds that the
upasikas in the society go very often to the temple and they must communicate with
the bhikkhunis there. Bhante says then only the Sangha and the society will be
complimentary for each other. Sometimes the upasikas cannot speak out their
202
problems to the residing bhikkhus. The bhikkhunis will be of great help to them. The
Bhikkhuni Order is also very important besides the Bhikkhu Sangha. In this regard,
Ven. Sujato holds a regular training programme for the newly-ordained bhikkhunis.
Ven. Sujato is a scholar in Pali. He is well trained in Pali sutta chanting both in
Thai and Sri Lankan tradition. And he enjoys both the styles.
He has become a fully-ordained monk for the last 14 years. As an
instrumentalist in his lay life, he was much busy with performing with his troupes.
Somehow, there was no peace in mind. Bhante tells us that within the chanting of
suttas, he gets eternal peace and touched by the bliss of the Dhamma.
U.S.A.
Venerable Ayya Tathaaloka Bhikkhuni
Dhammadharini Vihara
(Buddhist Womens Monastic Residence)
37959 Essanay Place, Fremont, CA 94536, U.S.A. E-mail: tathaaloka@msn.com
An American by birth, Ayya Tathaaloka Bhikkhuni took pabajja or the first
ordination as a samaneri in Un Mun Sa, a south Korean Temple under the precept of
Ven. Bhikkhuni Myeong Seong Sunim at the age of 19 only.
In February, 1997, she has taken upasampada or higher ordination under the
precept of Ven. H. Ratanasara Sangha Nayaka Thera of Sri Lanka at the International
Meditation Centre at Los Angeles, U.S.A.
Born of her scientist parents, Ven. Tathaaloka was a student of medicine in her
lay life. Now, she is doing research on the history and development of the Bhikkhuni
Order. When asked her the reasons behind joining of a Buddhist Order, she conveyed
that she did not want to suffer in life and do not want the rebirths, and in Buddhism
she has found the ways for cessation of sufferings and that was the only cause for
what she had come to this path.
According to her view, the seed of the Bhikkhuni Order must exist
somewhere. It cannot be lost. Though in China, Taiwan and other Mahayana countries
the bhikkhunis are being accepted as bhikkhunis, but there should be consciousness
among the Theravadin practitioners on this matter.
Ven. Tathaaloka is now engaged in training the juniors or novices in the
Dhamma.
203
Interestingly, she has stated the Pali suttas with the English translation. It is
observed that how one Pali sutta can be interpreted in so many languages.
Apart from these countries, we have taken interviews of some important
personalities. They are as follows.
Interview
1. Venerable Dr. Varasambodhi Bhikkhu
Secretary, International Meditation Centre
Bodh Gaya, Bihar
Ph./Fax: 0631 2200707, Fax: 0631 2200407
Born in Banskhali village in Chittagong, Bangladesh, Ven. Dr. Varasambodhi
Bhikkhu took pabajja in his seventh year of age in the Thagorpuni Temple under the
preceptorship of Ven. Subudhiratna Mahasthavir, Dy. Sangharaj of Bangladesh. He
studied up to B.A. in Bangladesh. Thereafter, he went for higher training to
Maharagama Bhikkhu Training Centre, Sri Lanka for four years. In the meantime, he
had been well versed in Vipassana meditation and went to California for five years as
a meditation teacher.
On the invitation of Ven. Dr. Rastrapal Maha Thera, he joined in this Centre
of Bodh Gaya as a meditation teacher.
An M.A. from Nalanda University and a Ph.D from the Sampoornanand
Sanskrit University of Varanasi, Ven. Dr. Thero highlighted that chanting remains a
core factor in Buddhism and it is also one way for purifying the mind. But, in the
204
Vipassana, silence plays a vital role for controlling the chaotic thoughts of mind. It is
purely a contemplating method of mind and not in action level.
2. Most Venerable Dr. Rastrapal Maha Thera
Sangharaj, Indian Supreme Sangha Council
President, International Meditation Centre
Bodh Gaya, Bihar
Ph./Fax: 0631 2200707, Fax: 0631 2200407
An erudite scholar of Buddhism, Most Ven. Dr. Rastrapal Maha Thero was
requested to give a message to the new generation. In his message, Ven. Maha Thero
has conveyed that the peace and harmony of the Buddhas teachings can only guide
the younger generation to find the right way. It is more necessary for the leaders of
the country, so that they can guide the people towards non-violence.
6.12 DHAMMA SOCIETY, THAILAND
Dhamma Society of Thailand has published a complete set of Tipitaka in
Roman script. Under the World Tipitaka Project, they have opened their website and
also e-Tipitaka service to propagate the Tipitaka and teach how to use this Tipitaka in
a proper way. We have taken two interviews from the members of the Dhamma
Society.
Interview
1. Major Suradhaj Bunnag
Chancellor, Dhamma Society Fund, Thailand
E-mail: worldtipitaka@dhammasociety.org
Major S. Bunnag has enlightened us about the World Tipitaka Project. In the
year 1999 (B.E. 2542), the M.L.Maniratna Bunnag Dhamma Society Fund under the
patronage of H.H.Somdet Phra Nadassadvara, the Supreme Patriarch of Thailand,
initiated the commemorative Romanised Pali Tipitaka Project, upon request from
abroad to support the printing of the sacred texts of the Buddhas word in script. It is a
complete set of 40 volume Romanised edition of the 25-century old Tipitaka.
The Tipitaka Project took six years to complete the full volume and many
scholars from different parts of the world contributed in this Project. In the Tipitaka,
they have used international standard of phonetical signs and the Dhamma Society
branches in Sri Lanka and Japan are working regularly to teach the common people
on this.
205
He has informed us that still now there are some difficulties about using the
Roman scripted Tipitaka specially in Thailand, Cambodia and Laos. They are
surveying on the matter on this Pali chanting ceremony and try to solve the problems.
Further, he conveys that this Tipitaka is not for sale as they donate the
Tipitaka who are worthy to accept this.
206
Interview of Mr. Kiran Lama
Secretary, Daijokyo Buddhist Temple
Bodh Gaya, Bihar
Ph: 0631 2200747, 0631 2200407, E-mail: daijokyotemple_bg@yahoo.co.in
The Great Buddha statue of 80 ft. in height has been constructed on a 2 acres
land is a mark of symbol for World Peace and Happiness. It is built of pink Chunar
stone seated on a lotus built of yellow chunar stone. The statue is in the meditation
posture with eyes half closed.
The statue is erected on a solid concrete hollow pedestal (height 10 ft) and the
statue too is hollow type with a spiral stair-case from the groundfloor to the chest of
the statue- which makes four storeys.
Mr. Lama shows us the floors excluding the ground floor there are wooden
shelves made surrounding the inner-walls of the statue for enshrining small Buddha
images made of bronze measuring 5 in height.
The Great Buddha statue and the pedestal has been designed by Shri Thiru V.
Ganapati Sathpati, Principal, Govt. College of Architecture and Sculpture,
Mahamallapuram in Tamil Nadu. In the year 1989, the statue was unveiled by H.H.
the 14th Dalai Lama.
The statues of ten great disciples were designed by Most Ven. M.Wipulasara
Maha Thero, the renowned sculptor-monk. The ten disciples are: Ananda, Sariputta,
Punna, Maha Kaccana, Rahula, Anuruddha, Maha Moggallana, Maha Kassapa, Upali
and Subhuti. The statues were unveiled in the year 1986.
Mr. Lama informs that the Daijokyo Sect of Japan which is a sect of laymen
(Dai means great and Jokyo means the Wheel of Law) financed this work. They are
maintaining a temple also in the same premises.
SECTION 7
A DAY IN A BHIKKHUS LIFE
The Vinaya Pitaka of the Tripitaka deals with the disciplinary rules of the
monks and nuns. One can find in detail the regulations relating to the moral, ethical
and religious aspects of the lives of the monks. In the Patimokkha, there are 227 rules
for the monks whereas 311 rules for the nuns.
207
The minimum age for ordaining as a Buddhist monk is 20 years. The boys
under that age are allowed to ordain as novices (samanera). Novices shave their
heads, wear the yellow robes and observe ten basic precepts. They are:
Abstaining from killing
Abstaining from stealing
Abstaining from sexual misconduct
Abstaining from false speech
Abstaining from intoxicants
Abstaining from afternoon meals
Abstaining from musical entertainments
Abstaining from perfumes and garlands
Abstaining from sleeping in decorated beds
Abstaining from handling gold, silver and monetary transactions
Although no specific minimum age for novices is mentioned in the scriptures,
traditionally boys as young as seven are accepted. The tradition follows the story of
the Buddhas son, Rahula, who was allowed to become a novice at the age of seven.
The first admission is called pabajja which means leaving the world. The
family, wealth, sensual enjoyments and everything is left for the cause of the
Dhamma by the monks.
The upasampada or the higher ordination is given to a novice when his
teacher finds him suitable.
Whereas the pabajja can take place in any temple, the place for
upasampada is a specific one and it is called seema. Minimum ten monks should
be present for upasampada. Before the ceremony takes place, monks purify the
place by performing rituals and chanting the suttas. They are named after bhikkhu
karmavacha. A seema can be the temple premises or a tank or a river.
There are many vinaya rules to be observed by the bhikkhus, e.g. a bhikkhu
should not do any plantation whereas the samanera can do it. A bhikhu cannot touch a
full-bloom tree but a samanera can touch. Likewise there are many rules to be
observed.
A bhikkhus life starts from the morning by meditation. Then service to the
guru is essential. A bhikkhu has to memorise all the suttas by daily chanting in the
208
temple. Cleaning the temple premises is another duty of a bhikkhu. In between, he has
to study.
A bhikkhu takes lunch in the forenoon. And, he abides in meditation. After
meditation, he goes to study.
In the evening, he goes to the temple and does Buddha Vandana. He meets
people from various walks of life and listen to them carefully. He gives
dhammadesana to the laity and it is very much important in a bhikkhus life.
A bhikkhu retires for the day after meditation.
Through his life, a monk maintains the discipline and without the discipline,
the Order or the Sangha cannot exist. The discipline in eating, the discipline in sitting,
the discipline in speech and discipline of mind through meditation are things to learn
from a bhikkhus life.
In the recent past, we have found that a bhikkhus life has been influenced by
some other factors. As several institutions and organizations are coming up and the
bhikkhus are to take charge of these. The system under which they have been brought
up in the monasteries is often broken. This, of course, changes a bhikkhus life
pattern, e.g. pindapata or begging alms food have now become a symbol only.
SECTION 8
ATTIRE OF A BHIKKHU
Atapirikara or eight things are essential for a bhikkhu. They are: alms bowl,
razor, needle and thread, sieve, waist-belt and three civaras (Uttarasangha, Sanghati
and Antarvas).
Civara may have derived from cira which means the torn cloth or rags.
i. Alms bowl used for begging of alms food
ii. Razor- used for shaving
iii. Needle & thread used for stiching the civara
iv. Sieve used for taking purified water
v. Waist belt or katibandhani used to tie up the robes in the waist
vi. Uttarasangha the cloth used as a wrapper to cover the upper portion of the
body
vii. Sanghati the cloth kept on the shoulder, it can be used as a shawl in the winter
or used as a seat for meditation
209
viii.Antarvas the cloth worn to cover the lower portion of the body
Characteristics of a civara
It is not a single plain cloth but pieces of clothes stitched together used as a
single cloth. Secondly, the civara is stitched in its periphery as a border. There are no
loose threads hanging from the ends. Specific measurement and stitching are there to
make a civara.
Uttarasangha It is measured as 4 x 5 arm size. Uttarasangha is made out of
minimum 15 pieces to 21 pieces.
Sanghati It is measured as (4 x 5 arm size) x 2. It is made out of minimum 15
pieces with no upper limit. Even 1000 pieces of clothes can be stitched.
Antarvas It is measured as 2 x 5 arm size. Antarvas is a single cloth used to
cover the lower parts of the body. Two ends of an antarvas are not joined.
The three civaras are basically wrappers in form.
Stitching of a civara is also very special. It is said that one day when the
Buddha was walking over the borders of a land, he was charmed by its beauty and
instructed the Sangha to stitch the civaras like land-borders. Moreover, if the clothes
are stitched into pieces, it cannot be robbed.
Colours
There are seven common colours of a robe or civara. They are : gold, orange,
yellow, mustard, dark red or maroon, brown and dark brown.
It is observed that while the Burmese monks prefer dark brown robes, Thai
monks wear generally the gold or mustard colour. The Sri Lankans wear orange or
dark red. Cambodians generally wear the brown and the Laotian monks prefer orange.
It is a general custom while the young monks wear the bright colours like orange and
yellow, he elders wear little bit dark colour. Also, the forest tradition monks wear
very dark colour robe.
210
2. wearing cover one shoulder without tie at the chest for paying respect to the elders
and when stay in the monastery premises.
3. wearing cover two shoulders is for going outside
Whereas the Burmese monks prefer always to wear covering both the
shoulders, the Sri Lankan monks from Siam Nikaya never put the robe like that. The
Amarapura and the Ramanna Nikayas always use the Burmese style. Though the
Laotian monks sometimes wear the robes covering both the shoulders, the style is
different from Myanmar. The documentation is done with the explanation. The Thai,
Cambodian and Laotian monks put the waist belt in such a way that it can be seen
from outside. It is a belt made out of cloth. The monks from other countries put the
waist belt inside and it is not to be seen. The material of the belt is not a cloth.
The pictures in the following pages show a description of different types of
wearing the robes.
Bhikkhunis in the Theravada tradition also wear the civaras like the monks.
We have documented the attire of a bhikkhuni of Fokuangshan Sect of Taiwan. The
photograph shows the tradition in the following page.
Hi Ching or the black dress can be worn by the laywomen also when taking
five precepts. But, the nuns wear Chhi I of brown colour which is made out of 21
pieces. The orange colour robe is called Cho I or Chayasa made out of 27 pieces.
Chhan Tsang or the brown dress shown in the picture is also worn by a nun.
The shoe they wear is called Lo Han she. It has six holes which denote six
paramitas.
CHAPTER V
IN ROAD TO SOUTH EAST ASIAN THERAVADA BUDDHIST
TRADITION
211
Following is a list of important temples of Theravada tradition of Buddhism of South-
east Asian countries. There are some addresses of Mahayana temples also which are
worthy to be mentioned. The phone and fax numbers are requested to be checked.
INDIA
212
Tel: 2224018, E-mail: sadhanavihara@yahoo.com
213
Kushinagar Dist., Padarauna, U.P. 274404
214
30. Vajra Bodhi Society
P.O.Box 8, Bodhgaya, Gaya, Bihar 824231
Tel: 0631 2330576, 2330577, Fax: 0631 221904
E-mail: vajrabodhi_buddhagaya@yahoo.com
BANGLADESH
215
7. Bangladesh Rakhaing-Marma Sangha Council
Asoka Buddhist Temple
Nilla Chowdhury Para, P.O. Ranghikhali, P.S. Teknaf
Dist. Coxs Bazar, Bangladesh
Mailing address: S.Ahmed Building(3rd Floor),
House # 135, Road # 1, CDA R/A
Agrabad, Chittagong, Bangladesh
Tel: 88 031 714320, Fax: 88 031 710057
E-mail: info@upandita.org, asoka@gononet.com
Affiliation: World Fellowship of Buddhists
216
Chittagong 4212, Bangladesh
Tel: 880 31 671587, 018 845215, Fax: 880 31 624912
E mail: swarupbarua@yahoo.com
Affiliation: World Fellowship of Buddhists Youth
217
E mail: pratimbarua@hotmail.com
218
Vill. Pata Bari, P.S. & P.O. Ukhiya
Dist. Coxs Bazar, Bangladesh
Tel: 03427 366
NEPAL
219
6. Lotus Research Centre
Mahapal, P.O.Box 59
Lalitpur, Nepal
E-mail: lrc@wlink.com.np
220
16. World Peace Temple
Bishwa Santi Vihara
Naya Baneshwara, Min Bhawon
Kathmandu, Nepal
Tel: 977 1 226984, 482984
SRI LANKA
221
5. Buddhist Centre (Dharmodaya Pirivena)
Girandurukotte, Mahiyanganaya, Uva
Tel/Fax: 0094 27 54312
222
E-mail: goldentemple@email.com
223
Gunasinghapura, Colombo 12, Sri Lanka
Tel: 0094 1 324900, E-mail: dahampg@singnet.com.sg
31. Sri Dalada Maligawa (Temple of the Sacred Tooth Relic of Lord Buddha)
Kandy, Sri Lanka
Tel: 94 08 225571, 94 035 65858, 94 01 889342
E-mail: sdm_dn@sri.lanka.net
224
Colombo 7, Sri Lanka
Tel: 94 1 691695, 610813, Fax: 94 1 449069
44. Vajiraramaya
Vajirarama Mawata
Primrose Gardens, Kandy, Sri Lanka
Tel: 0094 08 225353, E-mail: Primerose@col7.metta.lk
225
Affiliation: Maharagama Bhikkhu Training Centre
MYANMAR
226
55A Kaba Aye Pagoda Road, Kaba Aye P.O. Yangon 11061
Tel: 01 661479, Fax: 01 667050
E-mail: chanmyay@mptmail.net
227
13. The State Pariyatti Sasana University (Mandalay)
62 St. Aungmyethazan Township, near Atumashi Monastery
Mandalay Hill, Myanmar
Tel: 0095 2 61114
THAILAND
2. Wat Chamnihatthakam
199 Wat Chamnihatthakam, Rama 1 Rd
Rongmaung, Patumwan, Bangkok 10330, Thailand
3. Wat Chandaram
276 Therdthai Rd, Thonburi, Bangkok 10600, Thailand
5. Wat Mahaprutharam
517 Wat Mahaprutharam, Bangkok 10500, Thailand
6. Wat Mahathat
Section 7, Phranakorn, Bangkok 10200, Thailand
7. Wat Nalaung
T. Kamdung, Banphua, Udonthani, Thailand
8. Wat Srisongthamma
Bannongdinji, T. Phon-ngam
Nonghan, Udon, Thailand
9. Wat Mahapurttaram
Bangrag, Bangkok 10500, Thailand
228
11. Wat Chonglom
Chongnonthree, Yannana, Bangkok, Thailand
229
Nakhon-pathom 73000, Thailand
E-mail: chatsumarn@hotmail.com
230
Khet Pasicharoen
Bangkok 10160, Thailand
Tel: 2869 1699, 2467 2380
E-mail: watnakprok@hotmail.com, poonsak@wanakprok.org
231
E-mail: webmaster@wat-thaton.org
CAMBODIA
232
Phnom Penh 7, Cambodia
Tel/Fax: 855 23 26594, E-mail: ivcc@forum.org.kh
4. Wat Samrong-Andeet
Khum Phnom Penh Thmey, Srok Reusseykeo
Phnom Penh, Cambodia
Tel/Fax: 855 23 368 223
5. Wat Koh
Monivong Blvd.
Phnom Penh, Cambodia
6. Wat Sompoumeois
Sangkat bung bralit Khan
7 Makara, Phnom Penh, Cambodia
LAOS
1. Khoualuang Temple
Chanthabooly District, Vientiane, Laos
Tel: 00856 20 215789, 00856 20 5937930
2. Nakhoonnoy Temple
Naxaithong District, Vientiane, Laos
INDONESIA
233
Central Java
1. Kabupaten Ambarawa
Vihara Dharma Dharsana
Jl. Bendungan Ambarawa
Jawa Tengah
Kabupaten Banjar Negara
9. Cetiya Djoyodinomo
Jati Roto, Kel. Sumbung
Kec. Cepogo, Kab. Boyolali, Jawa Tengah
234
12. Cetiya Mbeduk Kulon
Mbeduk Kulon, Kec. Ampel, Kel. Sido Kulon
Kab. Boyolali, Jawa Tengah
235
24. Cetiya Dharmakusala
Ds. Karang Tawang, Kec. Nusa Wungu
Kab. Cilacap, Jawa Tengah
236
36. Vihara Dewa Ruci
Jalan Kudus, Desa Mranak, Wanosalam
Demak, Jawa Tengah
237
Sidorajo Rt. 6/II, Kel. Ujung Watu
Kec. Keling, Kab. Jepara, Jawa Tengah
EAST JAVA
1. Jawa Timur
Mahavihara Mojopahit
Desa Bejijong, Trowulan, Mojokerto, East Java
Tel./Fax: 62 818 300183, 962368, E-mail: Fredrik@rad.net.id
Affiliation: Sangha Agung Indonesia & MBI
238
Jl. Soekarno Hatta kav
Malang, East Java 65111
Tel: 62 0341 495612, E-mail: kmbm@plasa.com
WEST JAVA
1. Kabupaten Bandung
Kadamchoeling, Bandung, West Java 40132
E-mail: kadamchoeling@telcom.net
4. Vihara Dhammacakkhu
Jln. Dahlia II No. 17, Perumahan Pakuan Bogor
Tel: 0251 328719, E-mail: selamat@bogor.wasantara.net.id
JAKARTA BARAT
3. Vihara Dharmasagara
Jl. Taman Sari Raya No. 78
Jakarta Barat 11140
Tel: 62 21 6492254, Fax: 62 21 6291941
E-mail: dharmasagara@dharmasagara .com
239
4. Vihara Pitakananda
Jl. Pada Mulya VI No. 176
B. Jmbatan II, Jakarta Barat
Tel: 639-8852/639-6094
5. Cetiya Dharmaratna
Jl. Kamal Raya Lingkungan III, Rt. 0010/09, No.30 Tegal Alur
Cengkareng, Jakarta Barat
JAKARTA PUSAT
5. Vihara Sakyaputta
Jalan Dwi Warna Gang
A.No.2 Jakarta 10750
240
Jakarta Utara, DKI Jakarta 14450
Tel./Fax: 62 21 66604038
E-mail: budiman@forumbuddha.com
JAKARTA TIMUR
4. Vihara Mudhita
Jalan Rawa Jaya Pondok Kopi
Jakarta Timur
BORNEO
1. Vihara Ma Yong
Rt.1 Rk1, Kel. Karang Buat, Mampawah Hilir
Pontianak, Maubi
241
3. Vihara Maitreya Murti
Jalan Parit Wasalim No. 2
Pontianak, Mapanbumi
4. Vihara Maitreya
Jalan Darat Seleip, Gg. Beringin No. 12A
Pontianak, Mapanbumi
MAUBI
5. Vihara Dharmayana
Jalan D.I. Panjaitan Nomor
27, Mentawai Baru, Hulu Sampit
Kotawaringing Timur, Kalimantan Tengah
242
7. Vihara Duta Praba
Jalan Ratauan, Keliling Nomor 65
Banjarmasin, Kalimantan Selatan
BENGKULU
JAMBI
1. Vihara Buddhayana
Jalan Sri Soedewi Nasehun, Kuala Tungkal
Kab. Tanjung Jabung, Jambi
2. Vihara Sakyakirti
Jl. P. Diponegoro No. 56, Jambi
SUMATERA SELATAN
2. Cetiya Indra
Jl. Yos Sudarso, Rt. V No.26
Lubuk Linggau Barat, Sumatera Selatan
243
5. Vihara Bhakti Vihara
Jalan Talang Buruk Ds. Sukaramsi
Palembang, Sumatera Selatan
RIAU
BALI
244
Jalan Raya Kuta, Kuta Banjar Denpasar, Bali
MALAYSIA
245
Lot 297, Kampung Seberang Sungai 09600 Lunas
Kedah Darulaman, Malaysia
Tel./Fax: 04 4844027, E-mail: budherm@tm.net.my
246
17. Malaysian Fo Guang Buddhist Association
2, Jalan SS3/33, Taman University
Petaling Jaya, Selangor, Darul Ehsan 47300
Tel: 60 3 78776512, Fax: 78776511, E-mail: fokuang8@tm.net.my
247
26. Wisdom Audio Visual Exchange (W.A.V.E.)
Publisher of Dhamma books for free distribution
No.2, Jalan Chan Ah Tong
Off Jalan Tun Sambathan 50470 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Tel: 603 2749509, Fax: 603 7833198, E-mail: hockchai@tm.net.my
SUMMING UP
During the concern period, our main focus was to document the Majjhima
Nikaya suttas of Theravada Tipitaka. We have found that 152 suttas of the Majjhima
could not be completed by the monks. We could document the available suttas during
this period. The interviews with the monks and scholars have guided us to study
further on the tradition. We have documented a few examples of localized gathas.
Apart from chanting, we have documented the temples of different countries
in and around Bodh Gaya to have an understanding of the architectural pattern of the
respective countries. The religion of art was also another area of our concern.
Through this audio-visual documentation we intended to get through the
overall Theravada tradition of Buddhism.
At the same time, we have observed that the countries like Japan, Korea,
Taiwan, China, Vietnam celebrate the religion in their own ways. To understand the
Buddhist tradition as a whole in different countries with various indigenous
incorporations, one must study the chanting tradition of all the schools of Buddhism.
IGNCA has taken the initiative to document the chanting tradition with the
gurukul studies and it is just the beginning. Indeed, the field work for this
documentation would help as references for further study.
248
Arpita Sen
F/7, Belgachia Villa
Govt. Housing Estate
Kolkata 700 037
Ph: 033 2558 5111
E-mail: sen.arpita@yahoo.co.in
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Further Dialogues of the Buddha, vol.1, Lord Chalmers, Oxford University Press,
1926
2. ibid. vol.2
3. A History of Pali Literature,vol.1. B.C.Law, London, 1933
4. The Middle Length Discourses of The Buddha, tr. Bhikkhu Nanamoli, tr. ed. &
revised by Bhikkhu Bodhi, Wisdom Publications, Boston, 2001 (2nd ed.)
5. Sutta Pitake Majjhima Nikayo, vol.1,2,3, Vipassana Research Instt., Igatpuri, 1995
6. Majjhima Nikaya Atthakatha, Vipassana Research Instt., Igatpuri, 1995
7. Dhammagiri Pali Ganthamala, Suttapitake Majjhimanikayo, Dharma Publishing,
U.S.A.
8. Maha Pirit Pota:The Great Book of Protections, tr. Lionel Lokuliyana, Mrs.
H.M.Gunasekera Trust, Colombo
9. Daily Buddhist Devotions, Ven. K.Sri Dhammananda, Buddhist Missionary
Society, Malaysia, 1993 (2nd ed.)
10. Navel of the Earth, the History & Significance of Bodh Gaya, S.Dhammika,
Buddha Dhamma Mandala Society, Singapore, 1996
11. Buddha Gaya Temple:Its History, Dipak K. Barua, Buddhagaya Temple
Management Committee, 1981
12. Maha Bodhi Mahavihara, Buddhagaya Temple Management Committee, 2005
249
13. A Guide to Bodh Gaya, S. Dhammika, Maha Bodhi Society of India, Bodh Gaya,
2006
14. Let the Full Moon Shine, Danister I Fernando, Colombo, 2004
15. Poya Days, M. Musaeus Higgins, Colombo,1925
16. Anagarika Dharmapala & the Buddhagaya Centre, Ven. P. Seewalee Thero,
Maha Bodhi Society of India, Bodh Gaya , 2007
17. A flower for the Buddha, tr. Sunthorn Plamintr, Buddhadharma Meditation Centre,
U.S.A., 2005
18. Getting Closer to Reality, tr. Dhammika Bakmiwewa, Mahamevenawa
Monastery, Sri Lanka, 2008
19. Thailand Today, Valentin Chu, New York, 1968
20. The Buddha & His Teachings, Colombo, 1964
21. Buddhopasana, Dikpal Bhikkhu, IBMC, Kolkata, 2007
22. Buddha Vandana, Dikpal Bhikkhu. Kolkata, 2003
23. Aryopasana Niti, Arun Chandra Barua, Santiniketan, 2007
24. Jagajjyoyi, 2550 Buddha Jayanti Volume, ed. H.B.Chowdhury,The teachings of
Buddha, Ven. Piyadassi, Bauddha Dharmankur Sabha, Kolkata
25. Jagajjyoyi, 2550 Buddha Jayanti Volume, ed. H.B.Chowdhury, Monks must lead
pure lives, Dr. Susunaga Weeraperuma, Bauddha Dharmankur Sabha, Kolkata
26. Jagajjyoyi, 2550 Buddha Jayanti Volume, ed. H.B.Chowdhury, Worldwide
Buddhist revival traceable to 2550 Buddha Jayanti, Dr.Ananda W.P.Guruge,
Bauddha Dharmankur Sabha, Kolkata
27. Jagajjyoyi, 2550 Buddha Jayanti Volume, ed. H.B.Chowdhury, 50 years of
Indian Buddhism (1956-2006), D.C.Ahir, Bauddha Dharmankur Sabha, Kolkata
28. Jagajjyoyi, 2550 Buddha Jayanti Volume, ed. H.B.Chowdhury, Women in North
American Buddhism, Prof. Charles S. Prebish, Bauddha Dharmankur Sabha, Kolkata
29. Hundred years of the Bauddha Dharmankur Sabha (1892-1992), ed.
H.B.Chowdhury,Growth and Development of Buddhist Studies in Bangladesh,Dr.
Sumangal Barua, Bauddha Dharmankur Sabha, Kolkata
30. Discover India, May 98, Interview of Dr. Satkari Mukhopadhyay,Buddhism in
India: a view from rare Indian scripts, taken by Dr. Gautam Chatterjee
31. Discover India, May 98, Buddhist Cosmic Conundrum, Dr. Gautam Chatterjee
250
Oral references
Ven. P.Seewalee Thero, Sri Lanka
Ven. K. Gnanananda Thero, Sri Lanka
Ven. K. Medhankara Thero, Sri Lanka
Ven. M. Dhammajothi Thero, Sri Lanka
Ven. Buddharakkhita Bhikkhu, Bangladesh
Ven. Shantha Thero, Sri Lanka
Ven. Wajirawamsa Thero, Sri Lanka
Ven. G. Pannarama Thero, Sri Lanka
Most Ven. S. Dharmapal Maha Thero, Bangladesh
Ven. Mahinda Thero, Sri Lanka
Ven. Wimalarathana Thero, Sri Lanka
Ven. Kusalacitta Thero, Sri Lanka
Ven. Ajahn Ananda, Thailand
Ven. Aggvanna Thero, Thailand
Ven. Kalyan Priya Bhikkhu, Bangladesh
Ven. Bhikkhu Jayanta, Myanmar
Ven. U. Wanna Thero, Myanmar
Ven. Prajna Thero, Myanmar
Ven. P. Metta Thero, Cambodia
Ven. Saralonto bhikkhu, Cambodia
Ven. Oudorn Bhikkhu, Laos
Ven. Bhikkhu Tapassi Dhamma, Nepal
Ven. Ashin Nyanacakka, Myanmar
Ven. Ashin Thireinda, Myanmar
Website references
www.wsu.edu
www.bbc.co.uk
www.dharmanet.org/infoweb Therv.htm
251
www.tbsa.org
www.enabling.org
www.vipassana.com
www.theravadabuddhism.org
www.enabling.org/ia/vipassana/vipwoman.html
252