5 The Analysis of The Crime Scene PDF
5 The Analysis of The Crime Scene PDF
5 The Analysis of The Crime Scene PDF
5
The Analysis of the Crime
Scene
78
05-Holmes(PVC)-45761:Holmes Sample 8/4/2008 7:33 PM Page 79
Perhaps one of the most difficult things for investigators to accept is the
need to look beyond the physical evidence. Homicide detectives are
generally trained to reconstruct a crime based on the physical evidence
found at the scene, such as blood spatters, fingerprints, and semen.
This kind of evidence is often mistakenly thought to hold the key to the
successful resolution of any criminal case.
While lecturing in classrooms and across the country on psycho-
logical profiling we repeated tell our students that when they begin to
profile a case, they should disregard the physical evidence and concen-
trate on nonphysical factors. Often times, students and law enforcement
officials are reluctant to do so. We say this, however, because it helps the
investigator tie the nonphysical evidence with the physical evidence,
once introduced, to produce a total picture of a crime scene. We have
found that many people become too caught up in the physical evidence
and it limits their ability to think outside the box to reconstruct the total-
ity of a crime scene. However, once they are able to ignore the physical
evidence, they can oftentimes deduce information about a suspect,
including race, sex, employment status, residence, and so on. Thus from
our point of view, it is the interrelationship of physical evidence and
nonphysical evidence that is the key to the profiling process.
has dropped the words nonsocial and asocial from the labels in its typol-
ogy, but, as explained, we retain both terms here because we believe
they have important meanings.)
This typology can be useful when the crimes at issue involve sex as
a primary motive. The offenders who commit such crimes as rape,
sexual assault, mutilation, necrophilia, and picquerism are particularly
amenable to categorization as organized nonsocial or disorganized
asocial offenders.
Personal Characteristics
As the list of characteristics in Table 5.1 shows, the personality of
this kind of offender is reflected in the label. The disorganized asocial
offender, who is almost always male, is disorganized in his daily activ-
ities as well as in his general surroundings, including home, employ-
ment (if he is employed), car or truck, clothing, and demeanor. In other
words, he is a totally disorganized person in all areasappearance,
lifestyle, and psychological state. We should note that this is a general
description, and it has not been empirically validated. Nonetheless, in
the cases where a pure such personality has been found, these gen-
eral characteristics have proven to be amazingly accurate.
According to the FBIs research data, the typical offender with a
disorganized asocial personality tends to be a nonathletic, introverted
White male. As children, many of these offenders have been victims of
physical or emotional abuse. Their fathers were often absent; if the
fathers were present and employed, their work was unstable. During
their childhoods, these offenders had few real playmates; they tended
to have solitary hobbies, to have imaginary and secret playmates, and
to take part in few social activities. The disorganized asocial offender is
a loner. The reason for this aloneness, however, is fundamentally dif-
ferent from that behind the aloneness of the organized nonsocial
offender. The disorganized asocial offender is a loner because he is per-
ceived by others to be weird or strangehis neighbors are often
aware of his strangeness.
This perpetrator has usually experienced a great deal of difficulty
in educational pursuits. While in high school, he participated little in
extracurricular activities, and he probably dropped out of school as
soon as legally possible. He is possibly below average in IQ (the FBI
estimates the IQ of the typical disorganized asocial offender to be
05-Holmes(PVC)-45761:Holmes Sample 8/4/2008 7:33 PM Page 81
between 80 and 95), but this may be more a product of his social and
cultural experiences than his native intelligence.
His status in his community is the product of several components
of his personality. Limited intelligence, involvement in unskilled work
(often as a menial laborer), and few dates or other social contacts with
women all reflect a person who is alone not by choice but because of
societal segregation.
05-Holmes(PVC)-45761:Holmes Sample 8/4/2008 7:33 PM Page 82
Post-offense Behavior
According to the researchers at the Behavioral Science Unit (BSU)
of the FBI, the disorganized asocial offender will tend to exhibit certain
behavior patterns after he has committed a crime. First, he will need to
return to the scene of the crime relatively soon afterward, to envision
and relive what has taken place. He may attend the funeral services of
his victim, even the burial ceremony. It is not unheard of for such an
offender to place an in memoriam message in the newspaper for
his victim.
This offender may keep a diary in which he records his activities
and victims. With the widespread availability of instant photography
and videotape equipment, this type of offender will often keep visual
collection collage of his criminal events. Included in collage may be
pictures or videos he took of the victim before, during, or after the
crime. A part of this type of offenders diary, in addition to accounts of
his acts, may be devoted to stories of his fantasies. One serial rapist
related the following fantasy:
You really blew it, but you were inexperienced. The first thing is to
get a house with a windowless, underground basement. Equip it
with steel cages [for holding victims], and make sure to sound-
proof it. Only then will we go out and hunt.
But not just for anyone. Take your time, and find exactly what you
wantyou dont want to be attracting attention by snatching up a
05-Holmes(PVC)-45761:Holmes Sample 8/4/2008 7:33 PM Page 83
new one every little while. Find one thats perfect. Then well keep
her locked up before you kill her and grab another. But if we tor-
ture, wed best grab two so that we will always have one recover-
ing while were busy on the other. (Authors files)
Interviewing Techniques
Once in custody, the disorganized asocial offender may respond
differently to questioning than would the organized nonsocial
offender. This perpetrator may be more likely to respond to an inter-
rogator who uses a relationship-motivated strategy. It may be a good
idea for the interrogator to appear to empathize with him. For example,
if an offender says that he has seen a demon and that the demon
demanded that he kill, it might be wise for his questioner to tell him
that although the questioner has not personally seen this demon, if the
killer says it exists, it does indeed exist.
Because this kind of offender is not used to lengthy personal con-
tacts with others, it may be beneficial for interrogators to keep up a con-
stant stream of conversation, perhaps introducing something into the
conversation that has to do with the crime scene. The establishment of
a positive personal relationship may also prove beneficial in securing
some statement concerning the involvement of the suspect in the case.
Another characteristic of the disorganized asocial offender that
may be useful for interrogators to know is that he tends to be a night
person. Considering this, the interviewer might take the opportunity to
interview this person when he is at his bestat night.
Personal Characteristics
Personal Characteristics Post-offense
Post-offense Behavior
Behavior Interview Techniques
Interview Techniques
One night I finally got a date with a young woman I had been try-
ing to date for 6 months. We went out for a drink before dinner. We
were sitting at the bar when a guy walked by. She watched him as
he walked down the bar. I felt that she should not look at him
while she was with me. So, what could I do? I killed her.
The young woman who was this killers victim had challenged his
sense of self-importance. The killer believed he had no choicehe
had to kill to regain his rightful position. Although the damage this
offender perceived the woman had done him was only imagined, it
was enough.
Another attribute of the organized offender includes average intel-
ligence; some such offenders may have done well in school, and many
are at least high school graduates. (Ted Bundy was a college graduate
and a law school student.) These offenders are socially competent, have
sex partners, and some are married. Many come from middle-class
families and are high in the birth order. Their fathers held stable jobs
and were often inconsistent about discipline. For many such offenders
there is a history of some drug use, especially alcohol and marijuana.
Bundy, again as an example, was a heavy user of alcohol and marijuana
during his crimes.
The organized offender feels comfortable venturing away from his
home. He is able to work and carry on personal, although superficial,
relationships. He also is psychologically able to widen his network of
relationships and can travel farther and farther away from his home
and work to cruise for victims, and, more important, to hinder his
apprehension.
Because of his personality, this type of offender has no trouble
making friends. He is also able to change employment as often as he
chooses because he makes such a good impression and appears to have
qualifications that he may in reality not possess. Many have good posi-
tions. John Gacy owned a construction company. Chris Wilder was a
race car driver. Ken Bianchi was a psychologist and security officer.
05-Holmes(PVC)-45761:Holmes Sample 8/4/2008 7:33 PM Page 86
Post-offense Behavior
For the organized nonsocial offender, the crime becomes, at least
partially, a game. Such an offender will often return to the scene of the
crime for the purpose of reliving the sensations he felt there. Some, like
Edmund Kemper, will be tempted to return to the scene but will not
because they have seen one too many stories of one too many people
who have been caught by the police when they did soa piece of infor-
mation Kemper picked up from watching television. The organized
nonsocial offender often learns many details of police work from tele-
vision and other sources. He may even associate with police or other
law enforcement agencies, because the police talk about the cases that
are special to them. As Kemper said of his relationships with police, I
became a friendly nuisance (Horvath, 1984).
In interviewing one serial killer, we mentioned to him that
although the man was suspected of killing scores of young women,
only a few of the bodies had ever been found. The killers reaction was,
You only find the bodies they [the serial killers] want you to find.
When asked why a killer would want some bodies to be found and not
others, he said, To let you know hes still there.
Because of his charm and charismatic personality, this person may
be the last to be suspected of a crime. Even if suspected, because he often
05-Holmes(PVC)-45761:Holmes Sample 8/4/2008 7:33 PM Page 87
Interviewing Techniques
The BSU recommends that this kind of offender be confronted
directly during the interviewing session. Offenders of this type respect
competence, even when it may lead to their arrest and conviction.
However, when using such confrontation in the interrogation, the
interviewer must be absolutely confident about his or her information.
If the interviewer presents the facts, he or she must be certain that
they are true and accurate. This type of offender will know immedi-
ately when he is being conned, and he will understand immediately
that if false evidence is presented to him the police actually have no
case. This can close the door on the successful resolution of a case,
because the offender will never volunteer any information that can be
taken as any kind of admission of guilt. This type of offender will
admit to only what he must. The interrogator should not hope that
once he is confronted with all the known facts the floodgates of infor-
mation will open.
Some believe that a single-interviewer strategy is best. In the Ted
Bundy case, Donald Patchen and Steven Bodiford (personal communi-
cation, 2000) interrogated Bundy frequently during a short period. The
interviews took place mostly at night. Finally, after several sessions,
Bundy admitted, Theres something deep inside me, something I cant
control. However, after he had the chance to sleep and psychologi-
cally regroup, Bundy denied having admitted even that.
The profile suggested that the offender was a Black male, early
20s, single, living within the immediate neighborhood, and living
05-Holmes(PVC)-45761:Holmes Sample 8/4/2008 7:33 PM Page 89
Within 6 weeks, three other elderly women were attacked. All had
lived within a 1-mile radius of the original attack. Of these three
women, the first was 70 years old. She was stabbed 21 times in the
neck with such force and rage that a half-inch of the scissors was
left lodged in her neck. The next victim, who was also attacked in
her home, was stabbed in the neck 11 times. The last victim suc-
ceeded in warding off the attacker and called the police. A suspect
was apprehended.
The profile in this case was accurate. The amount of evidence, the
chaos evident in the crime scene, the weapons belonging to the
victim as well as its being left at the crime scene, the violence done
to the victim, the lack of restraints, the body left at the death
sceneall suggested a profile that did indeed narrow the scope of
the investigation. (Authors files)
But just how conscious was this selectivity and why did roughly
three-quarters of my victims fit this mold? In answer to the first
question, I would have to say that it was not entirely conscious in
that I didnt hold a general picture of an 18-year-old adolescent,
White female in my mind. Certainly more and more often than
not, I was roaming the streets in search of females in general, but
with no specific age group in mind. Yet 75% of the time the person
who clicked and registered in my mind was the girl I
described above. More accurately, I was reacting to the click in
my gut, more so than to predetermined, sought-after characteris-
tics. Yet the predisposition toward victims of that general descrip-
tion, subconscious or not, was there. (Authors files)
CONCLUSION
into account the chaos or lack of chaos in a crime scene, the presence or
absence of a weapon, the presence or absence of mutilation of the
victim, and other details. Of course, not all crimes are lust killings. In
the next chapter we will address arson and the types of individuals
who commit these crimes.
REFERENCES
Crime scene and profile characteristics of organized and disorganized murders. (1985).
FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 54, 1825.
Horvath, I. (Director). (1984). Murder: No apparent motive [Motion picture]. United States:
Vestron Video.
Ressler, R., Burgess, A., & Douglas, J. (1988). Sexual homicide: Patterns and motives.
Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.