International Journal of Advanced Engineering Research and Studies E-ISSN22498974

Research Paper
WHITE TOPPING AS A REHABILITATION METHOD: A CASE
STUDY OF BUDHEL-GHOGHA ROAD
Mitesh D. Patel1, Prof. P.S. Ramanuj2, Bhavin Parmar3, Akash Parmar4

Address for Correspondence

1.
Assistant Professor, Civil Engineering Department, Gujarat Power, Engineering &Research Institute, Mehsana
2
Asst Professor S S Engg College Bhavnagar, 3Sai Consultancy, Ahmedabad,
4
Asst Professor, Venus International College, Kalol
ABSTRACT:
White topping is rehabilitation treatment on asphalt concrete. It is defined as Plain Cement Concrete overlay on asphalt
concrete. It provides a new innovative method of rehabilitation at a very low cost with very good results and low
maintenance cost. This method of rehabilitation/strengthening can be adopted for rural road network and district roads as
these roads have low to moderate traffic. Even on the State Highways and some recently declared National Highways, where
traffic is moderate, the above method of strengthening has a lot of promise. By adopting proper construction methods, we
can rehabilitate large network of roads at reasonable cost and we get additional long life. This paper presents a methodology
to adopt white topping as rehabilitation treatment and cost-effective rehabilitation alternative for preserving bituminous
pavements on long-term basis.
INTRODUCTION: strengthening by overlaying thus need to be
Road traffic is increasing steadily over the years. This discarded.
is an international phenomenon. An international Any alternative method of strengthening or repairing
forecast predicts that such increase will continue in of roads should, therefore, be based on their
near future. Even in case of developed countries, durability rather purely by initial cost. The cost
there is a shortage of funds required for new comparison for such alternative strengthening/repair
infrastructure projects, both for constructing them methods should be based on the concept of life-cycle
and more significantly towards their maintenance and cost. Alternative methods of strengthening/repairs
repairs. The position in the context of a developing should take care of the deficiencies of the existing
country like India is obviously far worse. As a result, bituminous layers. Rutting and cracking are
more and more roads are deteriorating and the overwhelmingly observed to be general nature type
existing pavement structure as a whole is often found of distress on most of bituminous pavements. This
to be inadequate to cope up with the present traffic. could be remedied by milling the existing surfaces.
The present total length of NHs is about 66,590 km. Milling significantly de-stresses the cracked/rutted
The State Highways provide linkages with the section. However, in isolated stretches, where the
National Highways, district headquarters, important pavement is badly distressed due to sub-grade failure
towns, tourist centres and minor ports. Their total etc., full depth repair needs to be resorted to.
length was about 1,37,711 km as at the end of March White Topping is a way of strengthening or
2002.[1] The proper strengthening and maintenance rehabilitating deteriorated asphalt pavements by Plain
of roads( is urgently required to ensure balanced Cement Concrete (PCC) overlay with or without
regional development and alleviation of poverty as fibres. Ultra Thin White Topping (UTWT) and Thin
they connect the villages and other small town White Topping (TWT) are being increasingly
centres harbouring backwardness. A majority of these practised in USA and West Europe. Demarcation
roads do not have traffic worthy pavement. The cost between Ultra Thin White Topping (UTWT) and
of strengthening and repair by Conventional method Thin White Topping (TWT) depends upon the
of this large network will need huge resources both thickness of the Plain Cement Concrete (PCC)
physical and financial which are quite scarce. overlay and degree to which it is bonded with the
Most of the existing flexible pavements in the existing underneath bituminous layer. For thickness
network broadly have thin bituminous layers. up to 100 mm, it is designated as Ultra Thin White
These bituminous pavements, in general, have a Topping (UTWT) and for thickness more than 100
problem that they get deteriorated with time. Most of mm but up to 200 mm; it is called Thin White
our roads exhibit, in general, the following Topping (TWT). Beyond 200 mm thickness, it is
deficiencies: called Conventional White Topping like our ordinary
Rutting PCC pavements. The governing design principles are
Fatigue cracking somewhat different than those of normal concrete
Block crack (D-cracking) pavements. In case of UTWT, the bond between the
Thermo cracking existing asphalt pavement and Plain Cement
Under the present rehabilitation programmes, Concrete (PCC) overlay is considered mandatory.
normally the overlays are being placed over such However, in case of TWT the bonding is desirable
cracked or rutted bituminous layer without making but not mandatory. Another difference is that for
any significant efforts to seal these cracks properly. these overlays joints are spaced close. Normal
Sometimes the cracks are so extensive and spacing of joints are at 0.6 m to 1.2 m and in some
widespread that it is not even possible to fully seal cases it is up to 1.5 m. These joints are normally not
them, with the result that such newly overlaid doweled. No tie roads are also provided in the
surfaces again exhibit rutting/cracks in a very short longitudinal joints. The thickness of UTWT is
time. Reflection cracks are one example frequently between 75 to 100 mm. A thickness of up to 150 mm
encountered with such overlay repairs. Such repairs is normally provided even in case of Thin White
do not enhance their expected life and bring Topping (TWT). A residual asphalt depth of at least
avoidable criticism from the public. Such practices of 75 mm is considered essential. [2]
IJAERS/Vol. I/ Issue IV/July-Sept., 2012/31-35
 International Journal of Advanced Engineering Research and Studies E-ISSN22498974

Background: Pavement patching--identify areas that require

The first white topping project constructed in the sub grade repair after the milling operation
United States was in 1918 in Terre Haute, Indiana Thickness design--considers the thickness of the
(Hutchinson, 1982). According to McGhee (1994), asphalt pavement, the thickness of the topping,
from 1918 to 1992, approximately 200 white topping traffic loads, and panel layout.
projects were done. Among them, 158 were jointed Longitudinal and transverse joints--determine
plain concrete pavement, 14 continuously reinforced joint spacing by the overlay pavement thickness
concrete, 10 fibre-reinforced concrete, and seven and the geometrics of the area to be paved.
were jointed reinforced concrete pavement. Normal practice is to saw the joints in the new
Construction of white topping is not limited to the pavement; tooled joints are also permitted for
U.S. only. Other countries including Belgium, some areas.
Sweden, Canada, Mexico, Brazil, the Republic of Profile correction--determine joint spacing by the
(South) Korea, Japan, France, Austria, and the thinnest concrete profile and carry this spacing
Netherlands have undertaken recent projects with throughout the project.
white topping (Rasmussen and Rozycki, 2004). Surface texture--texture is specified in relation to
Agencies are widely expected to use white topping as the speed of traffic. Drag (burlap or boom)
it is a cost-competitive technique, can be constructed textures are good for low-speed facilities; high-
with minimal interruption of the travelling system, as speed facilities should use more aggressive
well as be a means of green construction compared to textures.
asphalt concrete overlay. Traffic control--traffic can be detoured, shifted,
Life-cycle cost (LCC) analysis of white topping and or otherwise accommodated during construction,
AC overlays (Asphalt Concrete) were conducted by but there must be a plan before construction
Lowey (2005). From the analysis, it was found that starts.
initial cost of white topping is much higher than an Construction staging--stage the construction to
AC overlay. When user cost with initial cost is
cause the least disruption.
considered however, white topping is cheaper than
CASE STUDY:
AC overlay as white topping requires less
V.K. SINHA, SATANDER KUMAR & R.K. JAIN
maintenance during its service life.[3] (sultana, 2007)
have represented white topping as cost-effective
METHODOLOGY FOR PROPOSING WHITE rehabilitation alternative for preserving bituminous
TOPPING: pavements on long-term basis.
White Topping can be categorised as below:
Cost effectiveness of the white topping alternative in
1. Ultra thin white topping: Bonding mandatory,
Indian context is proposed by them for analysis.
milling required, thickness up to 100 mm,
A) Cost Computation of Bituminous Overlay
minimum thickness of the existing bituminous
Scenario:
surface 75 mm (net after milling), with short
1) Low Volume Road (C/W 7 m without Paved
joint spacing. It cannot be used on badly cracked
shoulders) Plain Terrain Current traffic =300 CVPD.
bituminous surfaces. Substantial surface
2) Projected design traffic at 7.5% annual growth for
preparation is involved Cost-efficient for
10 yrs =2.3 MSA
intersections, check-posts, parking lots and low
3) Characteristic BBD (Benkelman Beam Deflection)
volume roads frequent with rutting problems due
1.8 mm*assumed
to stop/start conditions. 4) VDF (vehicle damage factor) as per IRC: 81-1997
2. Thin white topping: Bonding desirable, though
(T-4) = 1.5
not mandatory, milling desirable but thin
i) Overlay Thickness Computation:
bituminous overlay of 25-50 mm in lieu of
Overlay Thickness has been computed for this
milling can be used, thickness between 100 to
scenario table 1 as per IRC: 81-1997[5]
200 mm, with short joint spacing. Used for low Table 1 Overlay Thickness
to moderate trafficked corridors. Computed overlay Design life for
3. Conventional white topping: Similar to a new Scenario thickness overlay
90 mm BM 10 years
concrete pavement. It can be directly laid on the
existing bituminous pavement without much ii) Basic rates used for analysis:
The basic rates assumed are current (as per analysed
surface preparation. Thickness usually is equal to
tender rates). These are given in Table 2 The rates are
or more than 200 mm. However, Thin White
topping and Conventional White topping do not applicable and used for computation of the cost of
have a very rigid demarcation line and a bituminous overlay as well as of White topping.
Table 2 Basic rates
thickness between 150 mm to 250 mm is quite S. No. Item of works Rate as on Oct. 2007(Rs)
common. 1 Tack Coat 11.20/sqm
The following procedure needs to be adopted for 2 BM 4480/cum
3 DBM 4930/cum
implementing White Topping as maintenance
4 SDBC 5040/cum
strategy [4] (Nasvik, 2004) 5 BC with CRMB 5820/cum
Design life--should be at least 15 years; 25 to 30 6 DLC 3490/cum
years is often projected for city streets. 7 PQC 5330/cum
DBM = Dense Bituminous Macadam
Cost alternatives--define initial construction SDBC = Semi Dense Bituminous Concrete
costs, maintenance costs, and the design life of BC = Bituminous Concrete
CRMB = Crumb Rubber Modified Bitumen
the topping. PQC = Pavement Quality Concrete
Drainage considerations - define the elevation of
crown sections to ensure good drainage.

IJAERS/Vol. I/ Issue IV/July-Sept., 2012/31-35

 International Journal of Advanced Engineering Research and Studies E-ISSN22498974

Table 3 Cost of bituminous overlays Table 8 Stress Ratio at Different Axle Loads under the
Category of Tandem Axle

B) Cost computation of white topping overlay Total fatigue consumed = 0.52 (single axle) + 0.02 (tandem
Scenario: Ultra Thin White topping axle) = 0.54 < 0.75 hence design is safe
1) Current Traffic= 300 CVPD(Commercial Vehicle Table 9 Computed Cost of Ultra Thin White topping
Per Day)
2) Design Period= 10 yrs
3) Projected Traffic
1.07510 x 365 x 300) = 225683
4) Design Traffic (0.25 x 225683) = 56420
5) Adopted 57500
6) Thickness provided = 100 mm
i) Design of ultra thin white topping: Thickness
adequacy has also been checked for fatigue life for
typically assumed axle load distribution vides Table 4
as per IRC 58-2002[6]
Table 4 Design Parameters
Pavement Layer Type and specification Ultra Thin White
Topping(100 mm)
Traffic 300 CVPD
Thickness Designed 100 mm
Life 10 Years
Design Axles ( 25% of the projected) 57,500
BBD (used as limiting Deflection) 1.8 mm
CBR 6%
Modulus of Sub grade Reaction 4.5 kg/cm3
Modified Modulus of Sub grade Reaction* 5.4 kg/cm3
Temperature Stresses (Delhi) 1.0 kg/cm2
Residual Stresses 66.5 kg/cm2
Edge Load stresses for 6 tones axle load 34.71 kg/cm2
0.75x 46.29 calculated from IITRIGID Prog
Stress ratio (for 6 tonnes axle load) 34.71/67.5 = 0.51 The overlay cost both of bituminous and white
Allowable repetition i.e. 0.75X485000 363750 which is > topping for 150 mm and 200 mm thickness is shown
57500, hence design is
safe for individual axle in table below.
load of 6 tones Table 10 Comparative Cost Of Bituminous V/S White
Table 5 Percentage of Axle Load for the Design of topping Overlay (Per Km Basis)
UTWT (Assumed Axle Load Distribution)

Table 6 Design from Fatigue Consideration Using CONCLUSION:

Programme (Iitrigid) From the case study it can be concluded that white
topping overlay saves:
For 90 mm bituminous overlay and 100 mm
white topping overlay saves 19.04 % cost.
For 150 mm bituminous overlay and 150
mm white topping overlay saves 20.32 %
cost.
For 200 mm bituminous overlay and 200
mm white topping overlay saves 30.04 %
Table 7 Stress Ratio at Different Axle Loads under
the Category of Single Axles
cost.
The cost savings shown on a kilometre basis suggests
that, White Topping will have long life and ensured
performance at a much lesser cost than that of
bituminous pavement. The only disadvantage is long
lane closure and perhaps additional provision for
diversion of traffic during construction. However one
should perform feasibility studies and life cycle
analysis before implementation to ensure proper
decision making.

IJAERS/Vol. I/ Issue IV/July-Sept., 2012/31-35

 International Journal of Advanced Engineering Research and Studies E-ISSN22498974

REFERENCE:
1. An Overview of Indian Road Network. Retrieved on
January 04, 2011, from MORTH :
http://morth.nic.in/writereaddata/sublinkimages/overvie
w_NH3244795
2. Sinha, V. (2007). Editorial. Indian Highways , p2-4.
3. Sultana, Sultana. (2007). Extending Asphalt Pavement
Life with Thin White Topping. Dissertation submitted
to Department of Civil Engineering College of
Engineering Manhattan, Kansas: Kansas state
university.
4. Nasvik, Joe. (2004). Ultra-thin concrete for IDOT's
parking lot.
5. Guidelines for Strengthening of Flexible Road
Pavements using Benkelmen Beam Deflection
Technique. IRC-81: 1997.
6. Guidelines for the Design of Rigid Pavement for
Highways. IRC-58: 2002.

IJAERS/Vol. I/ Issue IV/July-Sept., 2012/31-35