In Vitro Mitotic Inhibition of Job's Tears
In Vitro Mitotic Inhibition of Job's Tears
In Vitro Mitotic Inhibition of Job's Tears
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 1
Krizza Katrina Mae D. Antiporda, Kevin George D. Calugay, Serasingha Pathiranage Dumindu
Gajanayaka, Shiela Mae M. Gutierrez, Abrik Manandhar, Shrijana Pakhrien, Hanna Marie D.
ABSTRACT
The antimitotic property of Job’s tears seed extract was determined by using onion (Alium cepa).
Job’s tears seed was subjected into phytocytochemical testing for its components. The roots of
the onion were used and were placed into different concentrations of the Job’s tears extract,
together with a positive and negative control. They were measured and analyzed macroscopically
in the seventh day and in the 14th day. After 14 days, the roots were processed for microscopic
examination. The different phases of mitosis were counted and computed by getting the mitotic
index (MI= number of dividing cell counted divided by 1000). The study used ANOVA method
Based on the result of the computed Mitotic Index, Job’s tears extract proved its anti-mitotic
activity. The results showed that with an increased concentration of the Job’s tears extract the
mitotic activity in the root tip of the onion was decreased. 100% concentration of the extract
VIRGEN MILAGROSA UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
Martin P. Posadas Avenue, San Carlos City Pangasinan
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 2
showed much of its anti-mitotic property among the other concentrations. The result of the
present study will provide a new perspective and wider horizon in utilizing the seed extract of the
Job’s tears in medical field. Furthermore, the outcome of this study may serve as fundamental
reference on the development of this plant anti-mitotic property that will aid for the natural
Keywords: Mitotic Index (MI), Analysis of Variance (ANOVA), Onion (Alium cepa), Job’s
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 3
Chapter 1 of 75. And there are 59,000 people dying
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 4
focus on developing new anticancer drugs used for adornment and decoration.
from organic or natural origins and plant- Ornamental beads were produced out of the
derived drugs to achieve less side effects various seed colors (e.g., yellow, white,
and moreover to provide cheaper and purple). The species name of the
cancer patients (American Cancer Society, and commonly known as “Coïx”, “Larmes
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 5
edge of rice fields in Java and Celebes are assumed to cause cancer. (International
malignancy prompts the formation of tumors human body to generate new cells. The
(2015), “as cells become more and more homologous pairs of chromosomes. These
abnormal, old or damaged cells survive chromosomes are split into two equal sets
when they should die, and new cells form when the DNA of the nucleus of the cell is
when they are not needed. These extra cells divided during the course of mitosis in the
can divide without stopping and may form cell cycle. The one cell (mother) fragmented
growths called tumors” (p. 1). into two (daughter) explains the genetic
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 6
The life of a cell undergoes a process chromosomes, likewise, prepares for the last
called cell cycle which systematically phase of interphase. Lastly, the G2 phase
consists of its creation from the preceding which gives the finale for the cell to
cell cycle division up until its own division continuously grow before undergoing
in order to produce two new cells. One division into two independent cells. Aside
complete series/cycle of cell cycle entails from these succeeding phases, the G0 phase
two major phases, named as interphase and exists outside the cell cycle, elaborated by
mitotic phase (OpenStax College, 2013). OpenStax College (2013) as “a resting phase
These two phases indicate the onset of of the cell cycle. Cells that have temporarily
cellular growth in the former while cellular stopped dividing and are resting (a common
division in the latter, then followed by the condition) and cells that have permanently
First, the interphase which is be in G0.” (p. 114), hence an inactive state.
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 7
halves. Cytokinesis occurs, and dividing the attach, when the identical partner was
cytoplasm and the cell body into two new already attach the forming of the familiar X-
cells. The mitosis is divided into four major shape of sister chromatids will disappears
stages that take the place after interphase and this early phase, The nucleolus and the
and the next is prophase, metaphase, nuclear envelope also disintegrates. Near the
anaphase, and telophase. The process is end of prophase there may be an invasion of
followed by cytokinesis. The one type of a the nuclear location by microtubules from
cell division is mitosis that can result in two the mitotic spindle. The nuclear membrane
daughter cells. Each of them has the same has disintegrated, and the microtubules
number and kind of chromosomes as the connect themselves to the centromeres that
parent nucleus, typical of ordinary tissue adjoin pairs of sister chromatids. The
There are four basic phases of chromatids. This stage is referred to as late
anaphase, and telophase. The first phase is transition between prophase and metaphase.
Prophase, this stage was the loosely packed Metaphase is the second stage of
chromatin coils and condenses to make mitosis. Throughout this stage, the sister
prophase stage, the chromosome becomes microtubules, line up along a linear pathway
visible and that’s why their identical partner within the center of the cell. A metaphase
VIRGEN MILAGROSA UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
Martin P. Posadas Avenue, San Carlos City Pangasinan
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 8
plate then forms in between the centrosomes formed nuclei that surround the genetic
which can be seen on the ends of the cell. material, uncoils in a way that the
The microtubules work to pull apart the chromosomes return to its loosely packed
sister chromatids and bring one from each chromatin. The nucleoli then reappear, and
pair to each side of the cell. then the mitotic spindle breaks and each new
As the microtubules shorten, these Forms around the midline of the cell
chromosomes are pulled to opposite ends of during cytokinesis is a contractile band
the cell through their kinetochores. Every which is made up of microfilaments, this
end of the cell receives one partner from band namely, the cleavage furrow, squeezes
every pair of sister chromatids, making sure the two cells apart until they separate. New
that the two new daughter cells will contain cells are now formed and one of these cells,
same genetic material. the stem mobile, enters its own cell cycle;
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 9
Furthermore, not all cells that impact cell cycle regulation”. Proper
undergo mitosis also undergo cytokinesis regulation of the cell cycle therefore plays a
which is the finals step in cell division. major role and importance to human health
According to Normand & King (2010), “as a because cancer usually arises from the
Schafer (1998) mentioned that, “the which have a property of inhibiting the
cell cycle is a complex process that involves cancer cell to grow and to divide more. The
numerous regulatory proteins that direct the object of this study is to observe the Anti-
cell through a specific sequence of events mitotic activity of Job’s tears in root tip of
culminating in mitosis and the production of onion under the microscope. This study aims
two daughter cells. Furthermore, this cycle to identify what phase of the mitosis thus the
can be altered to the advantage of many viral Job’s tears inhibits the most. To differentiate
agents and is often dysregulated due to the result using different concentration of
alterations either in oncogenes that the Job’s tears. The clinical significance of
indirectly affect the cell cycle or in tumor the different concentration of the extract.
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 10
What its specific component of Job’s tears develop cancer (Ludington & Diehl, 2006).
Cancer continues to be one of the Surgery can be used to prevent, treat, stage
the widely proven adverse effects of kind of cancer treatment that uses drugs to
studies have extensively geared toward chemotherapy affects the entire body, not
looking on medicinal plants that have just a specific part. It works by targeting
therapeutic value for cancer treatment. therapy uses certain types of energy to
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 11
According to the National Institute initiate this disease.
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 12
and vegetables, tea and red wine are the damaging effects of free radicals (Redmod,
main factors for the observed efficacy of 2007). Vitamin C and vitamin E helps to
these foods in reducing the incidence of quench the free radicals. While in the past
chronic diseases including heart disease and studies it was demonstrated and proven that
some cancers (Miller & Rigelhof, 2000). the antioxidant and vitamin E may also help
vegetables, tea and red wine are the factors Application of Solvent Extraction
disease and cancers (Miller & Rigelhof, pharmaceutical industries. According to the
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 13
extracting the solvent depending on the to College of Pharmacy Laboratory for
plants’ and their natural characteristics, both Phytocytochemical test and Extraction.
chemically and biochemically. Some plants The onion is obtained from San
that they used are heated because the plants Carlos local market. Six onions are
cannot be exposed to a higher temperature prepared, the first four are placed in
like for example boiling because it will different concentration of Job’s tears 25%,
destroy the active component of the plant, 50%, 75% and 100% and labelled as A1,
thus the obtained results can lead to false A2, A3, and A4 respectively. The 5th onion
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 14
following concentration
- 25%
- 50%
- 75%
Figure 1: Paradigm of the Study
- 100%
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 15
NULL HYPOTHESIS conducted at VMUF Research Center.
Bioassay eliciting data for analysis served As of today, cancer is the leading
as the basis in finding some proofs in order cause of death of some countries in the
to validate the written facts suggesting its world. Medical sciences continue to strive
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 16
The researchers find this study Medicine and Allied Medical
important evidence based findings regarding gathered will open more doors that aim to
the potential anti-mitotic property of Job’s promote knowledge and awareness for the
The Country: This study will provide a familiarity of the students towards the anti-
new perspective and wider horizon in mitotic cpotential of Job’s tears seed extract
outcome of this study may serve as of scientific community inside the university
of this plant anti-mitotic property that will innovation outside the institution.
cancer.
VIRGEN MILAGROSA UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
Martin P. Posadas Avenue, San Carlos City Pangasinan
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 17
Chapter 2 effects of the solutions of varying
plant material, extraction present in the job concentrations of job tear’s extracts; 25%,
tear’s as well as formulation and 50%, 75% and 100% were designated as
preparation of the culture media utilizing four treatments of this study. Each
natural crude drugs and the statistical treatment was replicated two times.
treatment of data used in this study. Treatment with 0% level was designated as
extract. Experimental method of research Job tear’s extract using bulbs - Allium cepa,
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 18
The experiment will be conducted to VMUF the Job’s tears’ (Coix lacryma-jobi) whole
college of Pharmacy laboratory. plant will be cleaned and air dried at room
Data Gathering Procedures temperature for at least one week. The plant
Collection and identification of plant will then be authenticated by the San Andres
Laboratory Apparatus
Test Reagents
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 19
Glacial acetic acid Benzene
steam bath. Dissolve the residue in filtrate, shake and then refilter.
Place 1ml of the filtrate into each of 4 second, 3 drops of Mayer’s reagent
small test tubes. To the first test tube, add 3 (Mercury iodide TS). In the third, 3 drops of
(Mercury Potassium Iodide TS). In the Finally in the fourth, 3 drops of Bouchard’s
VIRGEN MILAGROSA UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
Martin P. Posadas Avenue, San Carlos City Pangasinan
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 20
reagent (2% Iodide and 4% Potassium essentially dehydration reactions and
water bath. Cool the residue to room 0.3ml of acetic anhydride and mix
temperature and add 15ml of light gently. Add one drop of concentrated
petroleum ether. Mix well and filter. sulfuric acid. Observe any color
Combine the ethereal filtrates, set Run this test concurrently with 5ml
ethereal filtrates to dryness and then B2. Salkowski Test – transfer 5ml of
dissolve the residue in 15ml of the filtrate to a dry test tube and
filtrate and divide equally into three minutes and note the color change.
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 21
B3. Color control – add 5ml of the temperature for 1 hour before
filtrate to the third test tube. Add no recording the result as negative.
the filtrate in each of the three test formed, cool and dilute with an
To Test tube #1, add 0.5ml of 1.0ml of octyl alcohol. Shake and
minute and observe the color change. aglycones while the color in the
leucoanthocyanidins. Color
the test solution to stand at room D. Screening for Steroid (Cardio active)
Glycosides
VIRGEN MILAGROSA UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
Martin P. Posadas Avenue, San Carlos City Pangasinan
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 22
D1. Presence of Unsaturated Sterols extract in an evaporating dish and
Lactones – since the following three 50mL of glacial acetic acid), stir to
test involve color reactions, it is mix well and transfer to a small test
necessary to run concurrent test with tube. With the test tube held at 45⁰
of the 80% ethanoic extract in an down the inside wall of the test tube.
evaporating dish. Add 5ml of Kedde Avoid shaking or agitating the test
acid in 100ml of ethanol) and mix purple ring at the interface which
well with a glass stirring rod. To the would indicate the presence of 2-
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 23
bark with 10ml of ethanol) in a solutions to the decanted
stand and observe over a period of precipitate. Add 3ml of the filtrate to
F. Screening for Tannins and Phenolic To test tube #1, add 2-3 drops
steam bath. Remove the evaporating chloride); and to test tube #3, add
dish from the steam bath and add several drops of ferric chloride TS.
residue. Mix well with a stirring rod with chloride indicates the absence
Centrifuge the cooled extract for color after the addition of ferric
half from each tube used. Add 3-4 precipitation on the gelatin-salt black
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 24
tannins of the catechol type. A blue and filter into small
on the gelatin salt black test and allow the two phases to
color change.
a. Borntrager test. Transfer 5ml 0.5 N potassium hydroxide and 1ml of dilute
evaporating dish and dry over and acidify 5ml of the filtrate with
residue in the dish with 5- and partition wit 10ml of benzene. Filter the
10ml of petroleum ether. Add benzene phase and transfer 5ml to a test tube
50ml of distilled water to the containing 2.6ml of ammonia TS. Mix well
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 25
stopper on the tube, use cork
the crushed plant sample in a paper strip must not touch the
test tube. Moisten with water inner sides of the test tube.
The crushed seed of Job’s tears (200 obtained from the local vegetable market at
gm) was soaked into 300ml ethanol for 3 San Carlos, Pangasinan, Philippines. 6
days in an incubator shaker (at 50 °C) to Onion is prepared into 6 Erlenmeyer flask.
obtain the ethanol extract. The solution was The first 4 flask is labelled as A1 A2 A3 A4
filtered and the filtrate was subjected to with concentration of 25%, 50%, 75% and
the extraction solvent. The extract obtained Flask containing was distilled water is
Preparation of the Alium cepa Erlenmeyer Flask . The onion bulbs were
VIRGEN MILAGROSA UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
Martin P. Posadas Avenue, San Carlos City Pangasinan
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 26
kept at room temperature for 14days over ANOVA was also utilized to determine if
until the roots have grown. there is significant difference in the length
dividing cells
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 27
Chapter 3 vitamin c which is 2.5 mm. The same result
This chapter presents the data gathered, extract) and treatment 3 (75% jobs tears
analyzed and interpreted based on the extract) with 2mm and 2mm onion root
specific problems of the study. growing rate, which is lower than that of
Anti-mitotic Activity of jobs tears Extract vitamin C. Negative control has the least
concentration of jobs tears should inhibit the 2.5mm average root growing length
vitamin c.
As presented in table 1.a, where the Seventh Days of Onion root growing
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 28
Different (Onion root Average (negative
Concentration Length in
s mm)
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 29
levels of growing e (mm) As gleaned from Table 1.b, 100% jobs tears
(negative 6mm 6mm 6mm to or lower than that of the positive control
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 30
(prophase, metaphase, anaphase and
activity.
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 31
Concentration Stages of Mitosis Total Mitotic
Trial Index
Number of
Cells
25%
1 10 10 8 5 33 0.033
2 12 12 7 7 38 0.038
Total 22 22 15 12 71 0.071
50%
1 13 11 6 5 35 0.035
2 14 11 8 4 37 0.037
Total 27 22 14 9 72 0.072
75%
1 7 6 3 2 18 0.018
2 6 4 3 2 15 0.015
Total 13 10 6 4 33 0.033
100%
1 3 2 2 1 8 0.008
2 2 2 2 1 7 0.007
Total 5 4 4 2 15 0.015
VIRGEN MILAGROSA UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
Martin P. Posadas Avenue, San Carlos City Pangasinan
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 32
Positive control
1 5 4 4 2 15 0.015
2 6 6 3 3 18 0.018
Total 11 10 7 5 33 0.033
Negative control
1 14 11 7 6 40 0.040
2 13 13 6 5 41 0.041
Total 27 24 13 11 81 0.081
positive negative
25% 50% 75% 100%
control control
1 5 2 2 2 3 6
2 5 2 2 1 4 5
n 2 2 2 2 2 2
Xave 3.250
VIRGEN MILAGROSA UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
Martin P. Posadas Avenue, San Carlos City Pangasinan
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 33
source Df SS MS F P-value
total 11 30.250
positive negative
25% 50% 75% 100%
control control
1 4 2 2 2 3 6
2 4 3 2 1 4 6
n 2 2 2 2 2 2
3.250
Xave
VIRGEN MILAGROSA UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
Martin P. Posadas Avenue, San Carlos City Pangasinan
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 34
source Df SS MS F P-value
total 11 28.250
Clastogenecity Bioassay
positive negative
25% 50% 75% 100%
control control
n 2 2 2 2 2 2
Xave 0.025
source df SS MS F P-value
VIRGEN MILAGROSA UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
Martin P. Posadas Avenue, San Carlos City Pangasinan
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 35
treatments 5 0.002 0.000 90.2408 0.0000
total 11 0.002
VIRGEN MILAGROSA UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION
Martin P. Posadas Avenue, San Carlos City Pangasinan
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 36
DISCUSSION Tannins
glycosides were absent from the analysis. Job’s tears have anti mitotic activity in
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 37
value. The effect of increasing concentration of 25% concentration which having 2.5mm
the Job’s tears extract. Experiment used different also, the 25% concentration is having same
concentration of Job’s tears extract, 25%, 50%, value with the positive control means that
75%, 100%. In 25% concentration the mitotic
has antimitotic activity. For the 50%, 75%
index of 0.033 trial 1, and 0.038 trial 2 total of
and 100% which is below the positive
0.071. In 35% concentration have a 0.035 trial 1
control value has also having antimitotic
and 0.037 trial 2 total of 0.072. In 50%
activity. The negative control has a greater
concentration 0.018 trial 1 and 0.015 trial 2 total
value than the positive control.
of 0.033. In 100% 0.008 trial 1 and 0.007 trial 2
extract the more it lessen the mitotic activity in examination 25% concentration onion root
the root tip of the onion. length is 4mm, 50% concentration onion
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 38
control means that has less antimitotic antimitotic activity. The negative control has
activity. For the 50%, 75% and 100% which a greater value than the positive control.
The results of the study proved that anti- can serve as groundwork for further studies
mitotic activity of Jobs tears, seed extract on in Genetics specifically in cellular division,
the root tip of the onion. Specifically the growth and related diseases.
however its anti-mitotic effect is more From the above conclusions the following
Furthermore, the effect of Jobs tears is 1. All doses and concentrations must be
positive control using vitamin C. Most determine the claimed anti-mitotic property.
importantly, the mitotic activity is directly 2. A systematic research study of the Job
reduced by the presence of these active tear’s utilizing other essential parts.
alkaloids and tannin. In addition to these, study on the use of Job tear’s extract as an
these active components having anti mitotic alternative use to commercial drugs as anti-
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 39
References
American Cancer Society. (2015). Cancer Facts & Figures Atlanta: American Cancer
Society
Arber, Agnes. (1965). The Gramineae--A Study of Cereal, Bamboo, and Grass. Wheldon
Armstrong, W. P. (1999). Job's Tears: A Wild Grass That Produces Nature’s Most
Arora, R.K. (1977). Job's Tears (Coix lacryma-jobi)--a Minor Food and Fodder Crop of
Asis, Consuelo V., (1996). Plants of the Philippines (2nd Edition), Manila, Island
https://www.nature.com/scitable/topicpage/cell-division-and-cancer-14046590
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 40
Forni, G. (2006). Prevention of Cancer through Vaccination, Nature Publishing Group,
Vol. 7.
Philadelphia.
9780702033889
International Agency for Research on Cancer (2012). Chemical Agents and Related
https://www.feedipedia.org/node/472
Kerscher, A and Slack, F. J., (2006). mRNA Mutations, Nature Publishing Group, Vol. 8.
Laudico, A. V., Mirasol-Lumague, M., Medina, V., Mapua, C. A., Valenzuela, F. G., &
Pukkala, E. (2015). 2015 Philippine Cancer Facts and Estimates (pp. 1-79) (Philippines,
IN-VITRO MITOTIC 41
Normand, G., & King, R. W. (2010). Understanding Cytokinesis Failure. Advances in
4419-6199-0_3
OpenStax College. (2013). Anatomy & physiology. Houston, TX: OpenStax CNX.
Pagoso, C. M., et.al. (2004). Introductory Statistics, Rex Book Store, Inc.
https://www.khanacademy.org/science/biology/cellular-molecular-biology/mitosis/a/phases-of-
mitosis
Schafer, K. A. (1998). The Cell Cycle: A Review. Veterinary Pathology, 35(6), 461-478.
doi:10.1177/030098589803500601
https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/understanding/what-is