Design Calculation-Print A4
Design Calculation-Print A4
Design Calculation-Print A4
You can edit this page by selecting Cover Page settings... in the report menu.
1/50
Deficiencies Summary
No deficiencies found.
2/50
Nozzle Schedule
Materials
Nozzle Service Size
mark Fine Fine
Nozzle Impact Norm Pad Impact Norm Flange
Grain Grain
SO A240
SA-240
MW manhole 386.40 IDx10.00 SA-240 304L No No No No No No 304 Class
304L
150
SO A240
SA-312 TP304
N1 inlet 4" (Thk = 0.281") DN 100 No No No N/A N/A N/A N/A 304L
Wld pipe
Class 300
SO A240
SA-312 TP304
N2 outlet 4" (Thk = 0.281") DN 100 No No No N/A N/A N/A N/A 304L
Wld pipe
Class 300
3/50
Nozzle Summary
Reinforcement
Shell
Nozzle OD t Req t Pad Corr A /A
n n A1? A2? a r
mark (mm) (mm) (mm) (mm) (%)
Nom t Design t User t Width t
pad
(mm) (mm) (mm) (mm) (mm)
MW 406.40 10.00 7.65 Yes Yes 10.00 7.65 100.00 10.00 0.00 100.0
N1 114.30 7.14 6.02 Yes Yes 10.00 6.17 N/A N/A 0.00 100.0
N2 114.30 7.14 6.02 Yes Yes 10.00 6.17 N/A N/A 0.00 100.0
N3 28.58 3.62 3.38 Yes Yes 12.00* N/A N/A N/A 0.00 Exempt
N4 28.58 3.62 3.38 Yes Yes 12.00* N/A N/A N/A 0.00 Exempt
N5 28.58 3.62 2.73 Yes Yes 10.00 N/A N/A N/A 0.00 Exempt
4/50
Pressure Summary
Pressure Summary for Chamber bounded by F&D Head #1 and F&D Head #2
P T T Total Corrosion
MAWP MAP MAEP e MDMT MDMT Impact
Identifier Design Design external Allowance
( bar) ( bar) ( bar) (°C) Exemption Test
( bar) (°C) (°C) (mm)
F&D Head #2 15.00 100.0 19.25 19.39 8.11 100.0 -196.0 Note 1 0.00 No
Cylinder #1 15.00 100.0 17.17 17.30 5.90 100.0 -196.0 Note 2 0.00 No
F&D Head #1 15.00 100.0 19.25 19.39 8.11 100.0 -196.0 Note 1 0.00 No
Legs 15.00 100.0 15.00 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
manhole (MW) 15.00 100.0 15.65 18.96 5.90 100.0 -48.0 Nozzle Note 3; Pad Note 2 0.00 No
inlet (N1) 15.00 100.0 15.20 15.27 4.34 100.0 -196.0 Note 4 0.00 No
outlet (N2) 15.00 100.0 15.20 15.27 4.34 100.0 -196.0 Note 4 0.00 No
savety valve (N3) 15.00 100.0 34.43 34.68 8.11 100.0 -196.0 Note 5 0.00 No
drain (N4) 15.00 100.0 34.43 34.68 8.11 100.0 -196.0 Note 5 0.00 No
pressure indicator (N5) 15.00 100.0 24.53 24.71 5.90 100.0 -196.0 Note 5 0.00 No
5/50
Revision History
6/50
Settings Summary
Units: MKS
Design
Hydro/Pneumatic Test
Code Cases\Interpretations
UG-22 Loadings
7/50
UG-22 (f) Wind reactions: No
UG-22 (f) Seismic reactions: No
Note: UG-22 (b),(c) and (f) loads only considered when supports are present.
8/50
Thickness Summary
F&D Head #2 SA-240 304 1105.00 ID 241.99 12.00* 9.35 0.8500 Internal
F&D Head #1 SA-240 304 1105.00 ID 241.99 12.00* 9.35 0.8500 Internal
Load
internal: Circumferential stress due to internal pressure governs
external: External pressure governs
Wind: Combined longitudinal stress of pressure + weight + wind governs
Seismic: Combined longitudinal stress of pressure + weight + seismic governs
9/50
Weight Summary
* Shells with attached nozzles have weight reduced by material cut out for opening.
F&D Head #2 0.00 0.00 0.16 0.16 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.44 0.00
Cylinder #1 0.00 0.00 191.10 191.10 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
F&D Head #1 0.00 0.00 0.16 0.16 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Legs 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
TOTAL: 0.00 0.00 191.42 191.42 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.44 0.00
Vessel Capacity
10/50
Hydrostatic Test
Shop test pressure determination for Chamber bounded by F&D Head #1 and F&D Head #2 based on design P
per UG-99(b)
Shop hydrostatic test gauge pressure is 19.5 bar at 21.11 °C (the chamber design P = 15 bar)
The shop test is performed with the vessel in the vertical position.
Notes:
(1) PL stresses at nozzle openings have been estimated using the method described in PVP-Vol. 399, pages 77-82.
(2) savety valve (N3) limits the UG-99 stress ratio.
(3) VIII-2, AD-151.1(b) used as the basis for nozzle allowable test stress.
The field test condition has not been investigated for the Chamber bounded by F&D Head #1 and F&D Head #2.
11/50
Vacuum Summary
Elevation
Component Line of Support Length Le
above Datum
(mm)
(mm)
Note
For main components, the listed value of 'Le' is the largest unsupported length for the component.
12/50
Cylinder #1
Component: Cylinder
Material specification: SA-240 304 (II-D Metric p. 90, ln. 4)
Rated MDMT per UHA-51(d)(1)(a) = -196 °C
P = S*E*t/(R + 0.60*t) - Ps
= 1370*0.70*10.0000 / (552.50 + 0.60*10.0000) - 0.0000
= 17.1710 bar
P = S*E*t/(R + 0.60*t)
= 1380*0.70*10.0000 / (552.50 + 0.60*10.0000)
= 17.2963 bar
13/50
Pa = 4*B/(3*(Do/t))
= 4*203.4677/(3*(1125.0000/4.373313))
= 1.0342 bar
Pa = 4*B/(3*(Do/t))
= 4*507.2859/(3*(1125.00/10.0000))
= 5.8960 bar
Pv = W / (2*π*Rm) + M / (π*Rm2)
= 736.27 / (2*π*557.5000) + 107.30 / (π*557.50002)
= 3.2008 kg/cm
α = Pv / (Pe*Do)
= 3.200773 / (1.0342*1125.0000)
= 0.0270
n = 4
m = 1.23 / (L/Do)2
= 1.23 / (1678.324341/1125.0000)2
= 0.5527
Ratio Pe = (n2 - 1 + m + m*α) / (n2 - 1 + m)
= (42 - 1 + 0.552661 + 0.552661*0.026978) / (42 - 1 + 0.552661)
= 1.0010
Ratio Pe * Pe ≤ MAEP design cylinder thickness is satisfactory.
External Pressure + Weight Check at Bottom Seam (Bergman, ASME paper 54-A-104)
Pv = W / (2*π*Rm) + M / (π*Rm2)
= 736.27 / (2*π*557.5000) + 0.00 / (π*557.50002)
= 2.1019 kg/cm
α = Pv / (Pe*Do)
= 2.101904 / (1.0342*1125.0000)
14/50
= 0.0177
n = 4
m = 1.23 / (L/Do)2
= 1.23 / (1678.324341/1125.0000)2
= 0.5527
Ratio Pe = (n2 - 1 + m + m*α) / (n2 - 1 + m)
= (42 - 1 + 0.552661 + 0.552661*0.017716) / (42 - 1 + 0.552661)
= 1.0006
Ratio Pe * Pe ≤ MAEP design cylinder thickness is satisfactory.
Allowable Stress
Req'd Thk Due
Before UG-23
Pressure P ( Temperature Corrosion C Req'd Thk Due to to
Condition Stress Increase ( Location Load
bar) (°C) (mm) Tension (mm) Compression
kg/cm2)
(mm)
St Sc
15/50
F&D Head #2
M (Corroded)
M (New)
16/50
Design thickness for internal pressure, (Corroded at 100 °C) Appendix 1-4(d)
A = 0.125 / (Ro/t)
= 0.125 / (964.6/2.87)
= 0.000372
Pa = B/(Ro/t)
= 347.8108/(964.6/2.87)
= 1.0342 bar
A = 0.125 / (Ro/t)
= 0.125 / (964.6/12)
17/50
= 0.001555
Pa = B/(Ro/t)
= 651.6971/(964.6/12)
= 8.1074 bar
18/50
F&D Head #1
M (Corroded)
M (New)
19/50
Design thickness for internal pressure, (Corroded at 100 °C) Appendix 1-4(d)
A = 0.125 / (Ro/t)
= 0.125 / (964.6/2.87)
= 0.000372
Pa = B/(Ro/t)
= 347.8108/(964.6/2.87)
= 1.0342 bar
A = 0.125 / (Ro/t)
= 0.125 / (964.6/12)
20/50
= 0.001555
Pa = B/(Ro/t)
= 651.6971/(964.6/12)
= 8.1074 bar
21/50
manhole (MW)
tw(lower) = 10 mm
Leg41 = 10 mm
tw(upper) = 10 mm
Leg42 = 8 mm
Dp = 606.4 mm
te = 10 mm
22/50
The attached ASME B16.5 flange limits the nozzle MAWP.
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary (cm2) Thickness
For P = 15.65 bar @ 100 °C Summary
The opening is adequately reinforced
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
Weld load Weld load Path 1-1 Weld load Path 2-2 Weld load Path 3-3
W W1-1 strength W2-2 strength W3-3 strength
weld size is
Nozzle to pad fillet (Leg 41) 6 7 adequate
weld size is
Pad to shell fillet (Leg 42) 5 5.6 adequate
weld size is
Nozzle to pad groove (Upper) 7 10 adequate
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary (cm2) Thickness
For P = 18.96 bar @ 21.11 °C Summary
The opening is adequately reinforced
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
23/50
Weld load Weld load Path 1-1 Weld load Path 2-2 Weld load Path 3-3
W W1-1 strength W2-2 strength W3-3 strength
weld size is
Nozzle to pad fillet (Leg 41) 6 7 adequate
weld size is
Pad to shell fillet (Leg 42) 5 5.6 adequate
weld size is
Nozzle to pad groove (Upper) 7 10 adequate
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary (cm2) Thickness
For Pe = 5.9 bar @ 100 °C Summary
The opening is adequately reinforced
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
weld size is
Nozzle to pad fillet (Leg 41) 6 7 adequate
weld size is
Pad to shell fillet (Leg 42) 5 5.6 adequate
weld size is
Nozzle to pad groove (Upper) 7 10 adequate
24/50
inlet (N1)
tw(lower) = 10 mm
Leg41 = 8 mm
25/50
The opening is adequately reinforced Thickness
Summary
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 5 5.6 adequate
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary (cm2) Thickness
For P = 15.27 bar @ 21.11 °C Summary
The opening is adequately reinforced
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 5 5.6 adequate
26/50
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 5 5.6 adequate
27/50
outlet (N2)
tw(lower) = 10 mm
Leg41 = 8 mm
28/50
The opening is adequately reinforced Thickness
Summary
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 5 5.6 adequate
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary (cm2) Thickness
For P = 15.27 bar @ 21.11 °C Summary
The opening is adequately reinforced
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 5 5.6 adequate
29/50
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 5 5.6 adequate
30/50
savety valve (N3)
tw(lower) = 12 mm
Leg41 = 4 mm
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary Thickness
(cm2) Summary
For P = 34.43 bar @ 100 °C
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
31/50
Weld Failure Path Analysis Summary
The nozzle is exempt from weld strength
calculations per UW-15(b)(2)
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 2.53 2.8 adequate
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary Thickness
(cm2) Summary
For P = 34.68 bar @ 21.11 °C
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 2.53 2.8 adequate
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary Thickness
(cm2) Summary
For Pe = 8.11 bar @ 100 °C
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
32/50
This nozzle is exempt from area
2.96 3.17
calculations per UG-36(c)(3)(a)
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 2.53 2.8 adequate
33/50
drain (N4)
tw(lower) = 12 mm
Leg41 = 4 mm
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary Thickness
(cm2) Summary
For P = 34.43 bar @ 100 °C
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
34/50
Weld Failure Path Analysis Summary
The nozzle is exempt from weld strength
calculations per UW-15(b)(2)
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 2.53 2.8 adequate
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary Thickness
(cm2) Summary
For P = 34.68 bar @ 21.11 °C
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 2.53 2.8 adequate
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary Thickness
(cm2) Summary
For Pe = 8.11 bar @ 100 °C
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
35/50
This nozzle is exempt from area
2.96 3.17
calculations per UG-36(c)(3)(a)
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 2.53 2.8 adequate
36/50
pressure indicator (N5)
tw(lower) = 10 mm
Leg41 = 4 mm
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary Thickness
(cm2) Summary
For P = 24.53 bar @ 100 °C
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
37/50
Weld Failure Path Analysis Summary
The nozzle is exempt from weld strength
calculations per UW-15(b)(2)
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 2.53 2.8 adequate
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary Thickness
(cm2) Summary
For P = 24.71 bar @ 21.11 °C
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 2.53 2.8 adequate
UG-45
Nozzle Wall
UG-37 Area Calculation Summary Thickness
(cm2) Summary
For Pe = 5.9 bar @ 100 °C
(mm)
The nozzle
passes UG-45
A A A
A1 A2 A3 A5 treq tmin
required available welds
38/50
This nozzle is exempt from area
2.39 3.17
calculations per UG-36(c)(3)(a)
weld size is
Nozzle to shell fillet (Leg 41) 2.53 2.8 adequate
39/50
Legs
Note: The support attachment point is assumed to be 25.4 mm up from the cylinder circumferential seam.
40/50
Weight operating corroded
Weight empty corroded
Weight test new
Weight vacuum corroded
Weight
test
new
240 1,012.6 0.0 44.212 0 0 0.0321 0.0291
Moment = 0
107.3 kg-m
Axial end load, P1 (Based on vessel total bending moment acting at leg attachment elevation)
41/50
P1 = W/N + 48*Mt/(N*D)
= 2,656.27/ 3 + 48*1e3*8.9/( 3*1,125)
= 1,012.59 kgf
Cc = Sqr(2*π2*E/Fy)
= Sqr(2*π2*2,038,900/2,531.048)
= 126.0993
F'ex = 1*12*π2*E/(23*(Kl/r)2)
= 1*12*π2*2,038,900/(23*(34.7686)2)
= 8,685.098 kg/cm2
F'ey = 1*12*π2*E/(23*(Kl/r)2)
= 1*12*π2*2,038,900/(23*(12.7887)2)
= 64,194.2 kg/cm2
Fb = 1*0.66*Fy
= 1*0.66*2,531.048
= 1,670.492 kg/cm2
fa = P1/A
= 1,012.59/22.9032
= 44.212 kg/cm2
Bending stresses
fby= F*sin(α)*L/(Iy/Cy)
= 0*sin(120)*675.4/(100*919.87/76.58)
= 0 kg/cm2
42/50
3, W 6x12 legs are adequate.
R = 48*M/(N*BC) - W/N
= 48*8.9/(3*1.1758) - 903.75/3
= -179.58 kgf
There is no net uplift (R is negative).
Check the leg to vessel fillet weld, Bednar 10.3, Weight test new governs
Note: continuous welding is assumed for all support leg fillet welds.
The following leg attachment weld analysis assumes the fillet weld is present on three sides (leg top closure plate is
used).
Zw = (2*b*d + d2)/3
= (2*15.3162*7.46 + 7.462)/3
= 94.7231 cm2
E = d2/(b + 2*d)
= 74.62/(153.16 + 2*74.6)
= 18.41 mm
f1 = P1/Lweld
= 1,012.59/30.2362
= 33.49 Kgf/cm (VL direct shear)
f2= fy*Lleg*0.5*b/Jw
= 0*675.4*0.5*153.16/134,876.3395
= 0 Kgf/cm (VL torsion shear)
f3 = fy/Lweld
= 0/30.2362
= 0 Kgf/cm (Vc direct shear)
f4 = fy*Lleg*E/Jw
= 0*675.4*18.41/134,876.3395
= 0 Kgf/cm (Vc torsion shear)
f5 = fx*Lleg/Zw
= 0*67.54/94.7231
= 0 Kgf/cm (ML bending)
f6 = fx/Lweld
43/50
= 0/30.2362
= 0 Kgf/cm (Direct outward radial shear)
Required leg to vessel fillet weld leg size (welded both sides + top)
tw = f / (0.707*0.55*Sa)
= 100*3.35 / (0.707*0.55*1,407.207)
= 0.61 mm
fp = P/(B*N)
= 100*1,007.09/(203.2*254)
= 1.951 kg/cm2
m = (N - 0.95*d)/2
= (254 - 0.95*153.16)/2
= 54.25 mm
n = (B - 0.8*b)/2
= (203.2 - 0.8*101.6)/2
= 60.96 mm
tb = Largest(m, n, L)*Sqr(3*fp/Sb)
= 60.96*Sqr(3*1.951/1,687.366)
= 3.59 mm
Check the leg to vessel attachment stresses, WRC-107 (Weight test new governs)
Applied Loads
44/50
Maximum stresses due to the applied loads at the leg edge (includes pressure)
Rm/t =55.75
C1 = 76.58, C2 = 59.21 mm
The maximum local primary membrane stress (PL) is within allowable limits.
Stresses at the leg edge per WRC Bulletin 107
Figure value β Au Al Bu Bl Cu Cl Du Dl
3C* 7.2116 0.1197 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1C 0.0902 0.1298 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1A 0.0818 0.1419 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Pressure stress* 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669
Total circumferential stress 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669
Primary membrane
1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669
circumferential stress*
2C 0.0615 0.1231 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2A 0.0433 0.1366 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Pressure stress* 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3
Total longitudinal stress 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3
Primary membrane
554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3 554.3
longitudinal stress*
Shear from M t 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
45/50
Long shear from V L 0 0 0 0 -42.747 -42.747 42.747 42.747
Combined stress (P L+Pb+Q) 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,108.669 1,111.974 1,111.974 1,111.974 1,111.974
46/50
Lifting Lug #1
Minimum report
Geometry Inputs
Intermediate Values
47/50
1404.734
Allowable Stress, Tensile, σt
kg/cm²
936.489
Allowable Stress, Shear, σs
kg/cm²
2107.101
Allowable Stress, Bearing, σp
kg/cm²
1560.893
Allowable Stress, Bending, σb
kg/cm²
936.489
Allowable Stress, Weld Shear, τallowable
kg/cm²
Allowable Stress set to 1/3 Sy per ASME B30.20 No
Summary Values
48/50
Lifting Lug #2
Minimum report
Geometry Inputs
Intermediate Values
49/50
1404.734
Allowable Stress, Tensile, σt
kg/cm²
936.489
Allowable Stress, Shear, σs
kg/cm²
2107.101
Allowable Stress, Bearing, σp
kg/cm²
1560.893
Allowable Stress, Bending, σb
kg/cm²
936.489
Allowable Stress, Weld Shear, τallowable
kg/cm²
Allowable Stress set to 1/3 Sy per ASME B30.20 No
Summary Values
50/50