Cement Slurries of Oil Wells Under High Temperature and Pressure: The Effects of The Use of Ceramic Waste and Silica Flour
Cement Slurries of Oil Wells Under High Temperature and Pressure: The Effects of The Use of Ceramic Waste and Silica Flour
Cement Slurries of Oil Wells Under High Temperature and Pressure: The Effects of The Use of Ceramic Waste and Silica Flour
a a a b c b
Souza, P. P. 1; Soares, R. A.; Anjos, M. A.; Freitas, J. O.; Martinelli, A. E.; Melo, D. F.
a
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Cement Laboratory, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil
b
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Chemistry Institute, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil
c
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Department of Materials Engineering, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil
ABSTRACT
This study evaluates the behavior of a ceramic waste material in partial and total substitution of a mineral
additive, commonly used in oil well cement slurries, when exposed to high temperatures and pressures.
The samples were submitted to a cycle of low temperature (38°C) for 28 days, followed by exposure to
280ºC and 6.5MPa (1000 psi) for 3 days. The evaluation was made by compression testing and X-ray
diffraction (XRD). The results showed that cement pastes containing ceramic waste, when combined with
silica flour, produced hydrated products of low Ca/Si ratios which maintained the compressive strength at
satisfactory levels.
KEYWORDS
ceramic waste; silica flour; high temperature; high pressure; strength retrogression
1
To whom all correspondence should be addressed.
Address: Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Instituto de Química, Laboratório de Cimentos, Campus Universitário –
Natal - Rio Grande do Norte - Brazil - CEP 59072-970
Telephone: +55 84 8718-2725 | E-mail: pdpsouza@hotmail.com
doi:10.5419/bjpg2012-0009
105
BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF PETROLEUM AND GAS | v. 6 n. 3 | p. 105-113 | 2012 | ISSN 1982-0593
106
BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF PETROLEUM AND GAS | v. 6 n. 3 | p. 105-113 | 2012 | ISSN 1982-0593
polishing process. This process provides desirable The silica flour selected is a commercial product
properties such as waterproofness, cleanability, commonly used for cementing operations in high-
stain resistance, mechanical strength and abrasion temperature oil wells. The chemical properties of
resistance to a certain class of ceramic tile, along those materials were determined or estimated by
with an improved aesthetic appeal (Kummer et al., energy-dispersive X-ray fluorescence (XRF) as
2007). During this process, the ceramic’s body is shown in Table 1.
reduced up to 90% of its original mass (Wiggers et
al., 2007). A single Brazilian company is responsible The high concentration of silicon in the ceramic
for about 30 tons of waste daily, which is disposed waste, 62.01%, is essential for such application,
entirely in landfills (Souza, 2007). The product since to form low Ca/Si ratio phases in the cement
produced is incorporated into the water to assist in it is necessary to add materials with high
the polishing process. Subsequently, the residue is concentration of this element. A high
submitted to a physiochemical treatment for its concentration of aluminum, 21.77%, can lead to
removal, and the treated water returns to the additional improvements. The conversion of
process. The waste will remain in the storage yard Tobermorite into Xonotlite that occurs around
until reaching its final destination (Souza, 2007). 150oC in cement slurries with silica-based materials
The material used in the study was collected from a can create shrinkage and cracks in the hardened
storage yard. cement, resulting in unsafe operation. However,
the presence of some aluminum atoms can replace
others of silicon in that phase, causing an
insignificant amount of shrinkage in the hardened
paste (Jupe et al., 2007).
107
BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF PETROLEUM AND GAS | v. 6 n. 3 | p. 105-113 | 2012 | ISSN 1982-0593
The ceramic waste was the one with the lowest The cement-slurry mixtures were carried out in
average particle size, 5.13 μm, against 24.73 μm a mixer in accordance with API SPEC 10 (American
from the cement and 8.26 μm from the silica flour. Petroleum Institute, 2000-a). The experiment
The particle size distribution is a good feature molded cubic test-samples with edges of 5.0cm.
because the smaller the particle size of the mineral The samples were submitted to a hydrating process
additive, the greater will be the area available for (cure) in a thermal bath at 38oC for 28 days. This
reactions. Also, mineral additive particles do not temperature was chosen to be near to downhole
react chemically and can fill existing gaps, reducing temperatures of oil wells that use the steam
the porosity and permeability, thus increasing the injection technique for oil recovery. This technique
compressive strength of cement paste (Mehta and is used in wells up to 800m depth, approximately,
Monteiro, 1994). because to greater depths the injected steam loses
effectiveness.
2.2 Cement slurries formulation
After this step, a sample of each formulation
To determine the mass of the components of a was collected for compressive testing. Others
given oil well cement slurry, initially, the specific samples were placed in a pressurized chamber and
weight or water/cement ratio and concentration of subjected to 3 additional days of cure under high
additives solid and liquid are fixed. Then, the mass temperature (280oC) and pressure (6.5MPa). Then,
of the components is determined. The calculations the samples were tested mechanically. All samples
of the components mass were made according to were also analyzed by X-ray diffraction using CuKα
the recommendations of the API RP 10 practices radiation, a voltage of 30 kV, and a current of 30
(American Petroleum Institute, 2000-b). mA. The data collected from 10 to 60o 2θ degrees.
108
BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF PETROLEUM AND GAS | v. 6 n. 3 | p. 105-113 | 2012 | ISSN 1982-0593
o
Figure 3. Compressive strength – 28 days, 38 C.
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 34.10, and 47.12 2θ degrees) of all slurries with any
addition had lower intensities than those of the
Initially, it was verified the influence of the reference slurry. This reduction confirms the
ceramic waste and the silica flour in the samples existence of a pozzolanic reaction between calcium
just subjected to the simple cure (38oC for 28 days) hydroxide (Ca(OH)2), formed during hydration of
to serve as reference for subsequent comparison C3S and C2S phases of Portland cement and the
with patterns of those undergoing high addition rich in silica.
temperatures and pressures. Figure 3 shows the
mechanical properties of those samples. The
cement slurries that contained only ceramic waste
presented compressive strength directly
proportional to its concentration. The formulation
containing silica flour (40SF) also presented a little
increase in compressive strength. The blended
samples, ceramic waste and silica flour, showed
slight reductions when compared with the
reference formulation.
109
BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF PETROLEUM AND GAS | v. 6 n. 3 | p. 105-113 | 2012 | ISSN 1982-0593
110
BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF PETROLEUM AND GAS | v. 6 n. 3 | p. 105-113 | 2012 | ISSN 1982-0593
4. CONCLUSIONS
Ca/Si ratios equal to or lesser than 1.0 in any The ceramic waste presented characteristics of
cement paste with addition of ceramic waste. Thus, the pozzolanic material used in the characterization
the elevated Ca/Si ratio of the hydrated products by X-ray diffraction. The samples containing
formed is responsible for the drastic reduction in incremental additions of the additive, cured at 38°C
compressive strength observed after the steam for 28 days, exhibited a consumption of calcium
injection simulation. hydroxide in the presence of the additive. The
waste’s reactivity was confirmed through
Moreover, all blended pastes, ceramic waste compressive testing of the samples, which showed
and silica flour, showed low strength loss (Figure that compressive strength is directly proportional
7). Particularly, 25CW-25SF and 30CW-20SF to the presence of waste.
suffered losses of 18.75 and 25.12%, causing the
compressive strength to remain at 21.06 and All formulations suffered strength retrogression
20.06MPa, respectively. These values were after the steam injection simulation, if compared to
superior to the sample containing 40% silica flour, the post initial cure strength. The formulations with
which had a loss of 10.32% after the simulation, the addition of ceramic waste presented the
maintaining its strength at 28.25MPa. greatest losses, reaching 85%, phenomenon that
was justified by the presence of C-S-H phases with
Cement pastes used in oil wells need to present Ca/Si ratios equal to or greater than 2.0. However,
a compressive strength of at least 17 MPa. Such the formulations 25CW-25SF and 30CW-20SF, as
strength levels can bear the mechanical stresses well as the cement slurry containing 40% silica
generated in the wells. Therefore, based solely on flour, maintained the strength at satisfactory levels
the compressive strength, it is possible to classify (above 17MPa). This was justified mainly by the
the samples 25CW-25SF and 30CW-20SF with total consumption of Portlandite and the presence
having potential for use in oil wells subjected to of phases with Ca/Si ratios equal to or smaller than
thermal recovery by steam injection (Smith, 1980). 1.0.
111
BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF PETROLEUM AND GAS | v. 6 n. 3 | p. 105-113 | 2012 | ISSN 1982-0593
Through the experiments, it was possible to Griffith, J. E.; Lende, G.; Ravi, K.; Saasen, A.;
conclude that the use of the ceramic waste isolated Jordal, O. H. Foam cement engineering and
is not enough to prevent the strength retrogression implementation for cement sheath integrity at high
of cement pastes used in oil wells subjected to temperature and pressure. In: IADC/SPE Drilling
steam injection. However, when this product was Conference, Texas, 2004.
added to partial replacement of silica flour, in
certain proportions, were obtained satisfactory Herianto; Fathaddin, M. T. Effects of additives
results. The formulations developed present a and conditioning time on compressive and shear
reduction of just over 5% of cement mass, while bond strengths of geothermal well cement.
the reduction of silica flour reached 52% in mass, Proceedings World Geothermal Congress. Antalya,
when compared with the slurry containing 40% of Turkey, 2005.
silica flour, the most common formulation used for
Jauberthie, R.; Rendell, F.; Tamba, S.; Cisse, I.
cementing operations of wells subjected to high
Origin of the pozzolanic effect of rice husks.
temperatures.
Construction and Building Materials, v. 14, p.419-
423, 2000.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0950-0618(00)00045-3
5. REFERENCES
Jupe, A. C.; Wilkinson, A. P.; Luke, K.;
Aigbodion, V. S.; Hassan, S. B.; Ause, T.; Nyior, Funkhouser, G. P. Class H cement hydration at 180
G. B. Potential utilization of solid waste (bagasse °C and high pressure in the presence of added
ash). Journal of Minerals & Materials silica. Cement and Concrete Research, v.38, p. 660-
Characterization & Engineering, v. 9(1), p.67-77, 666, 2007.
2010. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cemconres.2007.12.004
American Petroleum Institute. API SPEC 10: API Kummer, L.; Bassetti, F. J.; Hiella, H. G.,
SPEC 10B – Recommended practice for testing well Azevedo, J. C. R. Reutilização dos resíduos de
cement, 2000(b). polimento de porcelanato e feldspato na
fabricação de novo produto cerâmico. Cerâmica
American Petroleum Institute. API SPEC 10: API Industrial, v.12(3), p.34-38, 2007. (In Portuguese)
SPEC 10A – Specifications for cements and
materials for well cementing, 2000(a). Lavat, A. E.; Trezza, M. A.; Poggi, M.
Characterization of ceramic roof tile wastes as
Anjos, M. A. S.; Renovato, T.; Souza, P.; Melo, pozzolanic admixture. Waste Management, v.29,
D.; Melo, M.; Freitas, J. Cement slurry with silica p.1666–1674, 2009.
flour and metakaolin for cementation of oil-wells http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2008.10.019
subject to high temperature. Journal of Materials
Science and Engineering, v. 4(12), 2010. Luke, K. Phase studies of pozzolanic stabilized
calcium silicate hydrates at 180oC. Cement and
Anjos, M. A. S.; Martinelli, A. E.; Melo, D. M. A. Concrete Research, p.1725-1732, 2004.
Effect of sugarcane biomass waste in cement http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cemconres.2004.05.021
slurries submitted to high temperature and
pressure. Materials Science and Engineering A, Mehta, P. K.; Monteiro, P. J. M. Concreto:
v.529, p. 49-54, 2011. estrutura, propriedades e materiais. São Paulo:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2011.08.056 Pini, 1994. (In Portuguese)
Eilers, L. H.; Root, R. L. Long-term effects of high Menezes, R. R.; Neves, G. A.; Souza, J.; Melo, W.
temperature on strength retrogression of cements. A.; Ferreira, H. S.; Ferreira, H. C. Atividade
In: Proceedings of the Annual California Regional pozolânica dos resíduos do beneficiamento do
Meeting of the Society of Petroleum Engineers of caulim para uso em argamassas para alvenaria.
AIME, Long Beach, California, 1976. Revista Brasileira de Engenharia Agrícola e
Ambiental, v.13(6), p.795–801, 2009. (In
Portuguese)
112
BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF PETROLEUM AND GAS | v. 6 n. 3 | p. 105-113 | 2012 | ISSN 1982-0593
Nelson, E. B. Well Cementing. Sugar Land. Smith, D. K. Silica flour - Mechanism for
Texas: Dowell Schlumberger Educational Service, improving cementing composition for high-
1990. temperature well conditions. Petroleum Engineer
International 52 (1980) 43-48.
Paya, J.; Monzó, J.; Borrachero, M. V.;
Velázquez, S.; Bonilla, M. Determination of the Snellings, R.; Mertens, G.; Elsen, J. Calorimetric
pozzolanic activity of fluid catalytic cracking evolution of the early pozzolanic reaction of
residue. Thermogravimetric analysis studies on natural zeolites. Journal of Thermal Analysis
FC3R–lime pastes. Cement and Concrete Research, Calorimetry, v.101, p.97-105, 2010.
v.3, p.1085-1091, 2003. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10973-009-0449-x
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/S1415-43662009000600019
Souza, P. A. B. F. Estudo do comportamento
Queiroz, G. O.; Barillas, J. L. M.; Dutra Jr., T. V.; plástico, mecânico, microestrutural e térmico do
Mata, W.; Barros Neto, E. L. Influência da cota de concreto produzido com resíduo de porcelanato.
vapor no processo de injeção cíclica de vapor. In: 232f. Tese de Doutorado. Programa de Pós-
3º Congresso Brasileiro de P&D em Petróleo e Graduação em Ciências e Engenharia de Materiais,
Gás, Salvador, 2005. (In Portuguese) Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte,
Natal, Brazil, 2007. (In Portuguese)
Rogers, M. J.; Dillenbeck, R. L.; Bray, W. S. Use
of non-API cements for critical oilwell applications. Taylor, H. F. W. Cement Chemistry. London:
In: IADC/SPE Asia Drilling Technology Conference Academic Press, 1990.
And Exhibition, Thailand, 2006.
Wiggers, W. S.; Santos, R. A.; Hotza, D. Evolução
Shvarzman, A.; Kovler, K.; Grader, G. S.; Shter, da Superfície do Porcelanato ao Longo do Processo
G. E. The effect of dehydroxylaton/amorphization de Polimento. Cerâmica Industrial, v.12(1-2), p.27-
degree on pozzolanic activity of kaolinite. Cement 30, 2007. (In Portuguese)
and Concrete Research, v. 33, p.405-416, 2003.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0008-8846(02)00975-4
113