Effect of White LED DC-bias On Modulation Speed For Visible Light Communications
Effect of White LED DC-bias On Modulation Speed For Visible Light Communications
Effect of White LED DC-bias On Modulation Speed For Visible Light Communications
1. Introduction
Visible light communications (VLC) based on light-emitting diodes (LEDs) merges lighting
and data communications in applications due to their energy efficiency, small size and
reliability[1, 2]. Visible light spectrum provides a potential solution to the looming radio
frequency (RF) spectrum crisis for high speed wireless communications[1]. VLC using
lighting LEDs has attracted more and more attention since it can offer many advantages over
RF such as THz license-free bandwidth, free of electromagnetic interference (EMI), and
integration into lighting infrastructure.
However, the phosphor-based white-light LED has a limited modulation bandwidth of
about a few megahertz that is caused by the slow response time of phosphor. It restricts the
direct modulation speed of VLC systems[3]. There are several approaches to improve the
modulation bandwidth, such as using a blue filter to filter out the slow yellow component[3],
and equalization of the driving circuitry[4]. Using an optical filter will increase the
complexity and reduce the received optical power. Despite the bandwidth limitation of the
LEDs, techniques such as high-order modulation/multiplexing[5, 6], optical multi-input multi-
output (MIMO) [7-9] and parallel data transmission have enabled communications of up to 1
Gb/s using a single white light phosphor LED[3, 10] and up to 3.4 Gb/s using RGB LEDs[11].
These approaches have low bit-error-rate (BER) and high complexity in comparison with
simple on-off-key (OOK) direct modulation.
Moreover, VLC systems also suffer from the nonlinear modulation characteristics and the
limited linear dynamic range of LEDs that are determined by the DC bias points of LEDs[12].
For an ideal LED, if the injected carriers arrive instantaneously at the diffusion region, the rise
time of the spontaneous emission is governed solely by the differential lifetime of the
carriers[13]. However, for driving an LED, the junction capacitance cause delay in the arrival
time of the injected carriers at the recombination region[14]. Thus, the modulation bandwidth
and rise time of the spontaneous emission in an LED will be either material-limited by the
differential lifetime τs or circuit-limited by the time constant τc due to the junction capacitance
of LED[15]. In fact, LEDs are non-linear devices whose parasitic resistance and space-charge
capacitance depend strongly on the DC bias current. These induce nonlinear electrical-optical
properties and nonlinear modulation characteristics of LEDs that depend on the DC bias[16].
The limited linear dynamic range of LEDs will cause clipping noise and signal distortion. The
limited modulation bandwidth will cause inter symbol interference noise and data rate
degradation. The LED nonlinear modulation characteristics lead to distortion in signal-noise-
ratio (SNR) degradation in bit-error-rate (BER) performance of VLC system[17]. Therefore,
it’s necessary to investigate the effect of LED DC bias on nonlinear modulation characteristics
and optimize the DC bias to control the nonlinear effect and improve the VLC system
performance.
In this paper, we theoretically analyze and experimentally demonstrate the effect of white
LED DC bias on nonlinear modulation characteristics of the VLC system, including nonlinear
modulation bandwidth and nonlinear electrical-optical properties related to DC bias current.
The experimental results well match the theoretical model of LED nonlinear modulation
characteristics. We use the series-connected UWLED chips to enhance linear dynamic range,
and the RC post-equalization without a blue filter to extend the modulation bandwidth to 40
MHz. The results show that VLC system bandwidth increases with LED bias current, and a
60-Mbps NRZ transmission is achievable with a BER threshold of 10-3. Furthermore, the
optimized DC-bias current that corresponds to minimum BER increases with an increase in
data rate. This can help in controlling the dimmable illumination brightness of white LEDs to
match the modulation speed and enhance system performance.
2. Nonlinear modulation characteristics of white LED
2.1 LED modulation bandwidth due to carrier lifetime
The differential carrier lifetimes in InGaN-based LED can be described by the simple ABC
model. This rate equation model considers that the current through the device is made up of
three contributions: a non-radiative current IA due to Shockley-Read-Hall recombination at
defect sites, a current IB due to radiative recombination of electrons and holes, and an Auger
current IC due to cubic non-radiative recombination. The total current is thus[13]
I = I A + I B + I C = qsd ( AN + BN 2 + CN 3 ) (1)
where I is the operation current, q is the elementary charge, s and d are the device area and
total thickness of the quantum wells (QWs), N is carrier density, A , B and C are the
coefficients of Shockley-Read-Hall (SRH), radiative recombination and Auger non-radiative
recombination. This simple model is made under the assumption that A , B and C are
independent of N, and the carrier density is the same in all QWs. In fact, the radiative
coefficient B decreases with the carrier density N due to a reduction in the optical matrix
element for the inter-band transitions. An internal quantum efficiency is thus[18]
BN 2
IQE = (2)
AN + BN 2 + CN 3
Under small-signal modulation conditions, the luminescence decay is mono-exponential
with the differential time constant. The differential lifetime is then given by the derivative of
the recombination rate with respect to carrier density[18]
1
=A + BN + CN 2 (3)
τs
In the case that linear and quadratic terms dominate the recombination rate, the simplified
expression between carrier life time and bias current can be derived
1 4B
= A2 + I (4)
τs
2
qV
Thus, the LED electrical-optical 3-dB bandwidth related to the differential lifetime can be
obtained
1 1 4B
= fs = A2 + I (5)
2 πτ s 2 π qV
2.2 LED modulation bandwidth due to space-charge capacitance
The common feature of LED is that the large junction over the entire wafer presents a space-
charge capacitance of the junction in parallel with the diffusion capacitance of carrier lifetime.
Figure 1 shows the equivalent circuit for the transient behavior of LED. In addition to the
diffusion capacitance Cd of carrier lifetime, there is the space-charge capacitance Cs of the
depletion layer. The space-charge capacitance is given by[14]
C0
Cs =
(1 − vd / φ)
m
where C0 = sc0 , c0 is the zero-bias capacitance per unit area, ∅ is the barrier voltage, the
exponent m is 1/2. The LED resistance Rs in the equivalent circuit accounts for the series
resistance of the bulk material and the contact resistances. Thus, the time constant due to the
space-charge capacitance is given by
RsC0
=τ c Cs =
Rs (6)
(1 − vd / φ)
m
3. System Description
3.1 Experiment setup
Figure 2 presents a diagram of the experimental VLC system set-up. At the analogue
transmitter front-end, the output signal from the network analyzer (HP 4396B) or function
generator (AWG 4438c ESG) was first amplified with the purpose to increase the LED
modulation depth and then superimposed onto the LED DC bias current by the aid of a bias-
tee (HP 11612A). The DC current biased the white LED in its linear region and also provided
sufficient average optical power for illumination. The light source was a phosphorescent white
LED (Osram OSTAR), devised for general lighting. This module consists of four chips, each
providing a luminous flux of 520 lm with a 120° full opening angle when driving at 700 mA.
An aspheric lens was fixed to make sure the light transmits along the regular direction. The
modulated light emitted from the white LED was transmitted over an indoor VLC channel.
Fig. 2. Experimental setup of Visible Light Communication system using White LEDs.
Light from the white LED was imaged onto a high-speed PIN photodetector (PDA10A)
through an aspheric convex lens (25 cm focal length). The photodetector has a detection
wavelength range of 2000-1100 nm with a responsivity of 0.45 A/W and an active area of 0.8
mm2. It has a bandwidth of 150 MHz and a root mean square (RMS) noise of 1.5 mV. The
optical signal from the LED was converted to electrical current signal through the PIN
photodiode and then the current signal was amplified to voltage signal by a low noise
transimpedance amplifier (TIA). The low-pass filter with a cutoff frequency of 150 MHz can
reduce the high-frequency noise. A first-order analogue post-equalization was developed to
extend the VLC system bandwidth based on phosphorescent white LED. The received
electrical signal was then amplified by a wideband coaxial amplifier, which was connected to
a digital oscilloscope(HP 4396B) and a bit error rate tester (BERT).
3.2 LED DC-bias and dynamic range
We measured optical spectrum of different phosphor white LED chips (Osram Ostar) as show
in Fig. 3. It can be seen that a commercial warm white LED (CWLED) contains only 10%
blue component of the overall emitted power, while the emitted ultra white LED light
(UWLED) consists of 41% blue component and less slow yellow component from the
phosphor. As the modulation bandwidth of blue light is higher than that of yellow component,
the ultra white LED (UWLED) can be used to improve the modulation efficiency and
bandwidth for high speed visible light communications.
Fig. 3. The measured optical spectrum of different White LED chips, inset: Osram White LED.
We measured the electrical-optical properties of several LED chips. Figure 4(a) shows
the experimental and theoretical DC-bias current I against forward voltage v for a single LED.
Considering the nonlinear series resistances Rs and parallel resistance Rp of LED in Eq.(11),
the measured LED bias current I against the junction voltage vd characteristic well match
theoretical nonlinear I-vd model. Figure 4(b) shows output optical power against forward
voltage for a single LED. The LED output light is cut off below the threshold 10mA @ 2.7V.
Above the threshold voltage, the LED can output a linear optical power around the optimal
bias point of 450mA @ 3.3V within the modulation dynamic range of 600mV. However, the
electrical-to-optical conversion efficiency saturated and decreased, this because the internal
quantum efficiency of LED reduced and nonlinear thermal effect appeared when bias current
and forward voltage beyond 1100mA @ 3.7V. The DC and AC currents must be optimized to
ensure that the LED chip does not cutoff or overheat that leads to degradation and nonlinearity
in output optical power.
Fig. 4. The electrical to optical properties of different white LED chips. (a) DC-bias current
against forward voltage for single LED. (b) Normalized optical power against forward voltage
for single LED.
The DC-bias current and output optical power against forward voltage for two parallel-
connected and series-connected LED chips are shown in Fig. 5. It can be seen that nonlinear
region of parallel-connected LED chips fluctuates dramatically above 3000 mA @ 3.5 V due
to the larger forward current thermal effect, whereas the linear modulation dynamic range of
the series-connected LED chips increases to 1200 mV around the optimal DC-bias point 370
mA @ 6.4V due to the improved impedance. Thus, the series-connected LED chips can
enhance the linear dynamic range.
Fig. 5. (a) DC-bias current and normalized optical power against forward voltage for two
parallel connected LEDs. (b) DC-bias current and normalized optical power against forward
voltage for two series connected LEDs.
Fig. 6. The DC-bias current and voltage effect on VLC system response for (a) two series-
connected LED chips, (b) three series-connected LED Chips. Transmitter signal amplitude is
100 mV.
We evaluated VLC transceiver system response at the frequency of 10 MHz along the
distance of 1 meter. Using the same transmitter signal amplitude of 100 mV, we measured the
receive signal amplitude for different LED DC-bias power levels. The effect of DC forward
voltage and current on system AC signal response for two and three series-connected LED
chips are shown in Fig. 6. It is shown that the received signal and system response fluctuate to
decline gradually with the increase of LED DC-bias current and voltage, because high DC
power will lead to the nonlinear thermal effect that saturated output optical power and
degraded AC signal amplitude. As compared, larger number of series-connected LED chips
can mitigate the nonlinear fluctuation of system response.
4. Results and Discussion
We first evaluate the effect of LED DC bias power on frequency response and system
bandwidth, and then demonstrate DC power effect on VLC data transmission. The
configuration of the VLC system demonstration is shown in Fig. 2. A directed line of sight
(LOS) VLC link operates over a distance of 1 m resulting from the deployment of a single
LED chip, but this can be extended by using an array of LED chips.
4.1 Effect of LED DC-bias on system bandwidth
The effect of LED DC-bias current on electrical-optical-electrical (EOE) channel frequency
response of VLC transceiver is shown in Fig. 7. The magnitude of the channel frequency
response was measured by a network analyzer. It can be seen that the magnitude of frequency
response reduced when bias current is less than 100 mA due to clipping of the lower peaks at
the turn on point. Furthermore, VLC system frequency response magnitude decreased with an
increase in LED DC bias current for frequencies smaller than 10 MHz, because the high
magnitude of low frequency at the large bias current will lead to saturation and nonlinear
thermal effect on electrical-to-optical conversion efficiency. However, for high frequency
signals in Fig. 7(b), the system response improves with the increasing DC bias current due to
higher optical power detected at the receiver.
Fig. 7. (a) The measured EOE channel frequency response of VLC transceiver for different
LED DC bias currents. (b) Frequency response versus LED DC bias current for different
frequency.
The experimental and theoretical relationship between 3-dB bandwidth of the VLC
system and LED bias current are compared in Fig. 8. It is shown that the 3-dB bandwidth of
the VLC system increases with LED bias current, because the bandwidth due to carrier
lifetime fs in Eq. (5) increases significantly with carrier density and driving current.
Furthermore, the LED bandwidth saturates and approaches to 7 MHz when DC bias current is
larger than 250 mA, because the bandwidth due to space-charge capacitance fc in Eq. (7)
reduces apparently with bias current. It is shown that experimental measurement of LED bias
current related equivalent bandwidth well match the theoretical results in Eq.(14). Since the
receiver itself has a relatively large bandwidth (photo-detector 150 MHz, amplifier 1 GHz),
the system bandwidth (7 MHz) is limited by the LED module.
A first-order equalizer that consists of a capacitor in parallel with a resistor (R=1 kΩ, C=
30 pF) is developed to enhance the system bandwidth. Figure 9 presents the frequency
response of the equalizer and the corresponding equalized VLC transceiver system. It can be
seen that the optimized analogue equalizer can extend the bandwidth of the VLC transceiver
from 7 MHz to 40 MHz.
Fig. 8. The relationship between 3-dB bandwidth and average LED current.
Fig. 11. The relationship between VLC bit error rate and LED current for different date rate.
5. Conclusions
In this paper, we have theoretically analyzed and experimentally demonstrated the effect
of LED DC bias on modulation bandwidth and data rate of visible light communications
system, considering the LED nonlinear modulation characteristics due to carrier lifetime and
junction capacitance. We used the series-connected ultra white LED chips to enhance linear
dynamic range, and the RC post-equalization without a blue filter to extend the modulation
bandwidth to 40 MHz. The experimental results well match the theoretical model of LED
nonlinear modulation characteristics. The measurement results show that VLC system
bandwidth increases and saturates with an increase in DC bias current due to carrier lifetime
and junction capacitance of LED. Data transmission in VLC system shows that a 60-Mbps
NRZ transmission can be achieved with a BER threshold of 10-3 by properly adjusting the
LED DC bias point. Furthermore, the optimized DC-bias current of the LED driver that
corresponds to minimum BER increases with the increase of data rate. The modulation
bandwidth can be enhanced by reducing parasitic resistances and capacitances of LED, or
carrier sweep-out of the active region. This can help in controlling the dimmable illumination
brightness of white LEDs to match the modulation speed and improve system performance.
Acknowledgments
This research was financially supported by the Pennsylvania State University CICTR COWA
(http://cowa.psu.edu), through US National Science foundation (NSF) ECCS Directorate
under award (1201636).
References
[1] M. Kavehrad, "Optical Wireless Applications - A Solution to Ease the Wireless
Airwaves Spectrum Crunch," Broadband Access Communication Technologies Vii 8645
(2013).
[2] D. O'Brien, G. Parry, and P. Stavrinou, "Optical hotspots speed up wireless
communication," Nature Photonics 1, 245-247 (2007).
[3] A. M. Khalid, G. Cossu, R. Corsini, P. Choudhury, and E. Ciaramella, "1-Gb/s
Transmission Over a Phosphorescent White LED by Using Rate-Adaptive Discrete
Multitone Modulation," Ieee Photonics J 4, 1465-1473 (2012).
[4] L. Honglei, C. Xiongbin, H. Beiju, T. Danying, and C. Hongda, "High Bandwidth
Visible Light Communications Based on a Post-Equalization Circuit," Photonics
Technology Letters, IEEE 26, 119-122 (2014).
[5] J. Vucic, C. Kottke, S. Nerreter, K. D. Langer, and J. W. Walewski, "513 Mbit/s Visible
Light Communications Link Based on DMT-Modulation of a White LED," JOURNAL
OF LIGHTWAVE TECHNOLOGY 28, 3512-3518 (2010).
[6] B. A. Ranjha, M. A. Kashani, M. Kavehrad, and D. Peng, "Robust timing
synchronization for AC-OFDM based optical wireless communications," Integrated
Communication, Navigation, and Surveillance Conference (ICNS), B4-1-B4-10 (2015).
[7] A. H. Azhar, T. Tran, and D. O'Brien, "A Gigabit/s Indoor Wireless Transmission Using
MIMO-OFDM Visible-Light Communications," Photonics Technology Letters, IEEE 25,
171-174 (2013).
[8] P. Deng, M. Kavehrad, Z. W. Liu, Z. Zhou, and X. H. Yuan, "Capacity of MIMO free
space optical communications using multiple partially coherent beams propagation
through non-Kolmogorov strong turbulence," Optics Express 21, 15213-15229 (2013).
[9] P. Deng, and M. Kavehrad, "Real-time software-defined single-carrier QAM mimo
visible light communication system," in 2016 Integrated Communications Navigation
and Surveillance (ICNS)(2016), pp. 5A3-1-5A3-11.
[10] D. Tsonev, H. Chun, S. Rajbhandari, J. J. D. McKendry, S. Videv, E. Gu, M. Haji, S.
Watson, A. E. Kelly, G. Faulkner, M. D. Dawson, H. Haas, and D. O'Brien, "A 3-Gb/s
Single-LED OFDM-Based Wireless VLC Link Using a Gallium Nitride μLED,"
Photonics Technology Letters, IEEE 26, 637-640 (2014).
[11] G. Cossu, A. M. Khalid, P. Choudhury, R. Corsini, and E. Ciaramella, "3.4 Gbit/s visible
optical wireless transmission based on RGB LED," Optics Express 20, B501-06 (2012).
[12] H. Elgala, R. Mesleh, and H. Haas, "An LED Model for Intensity-Modulated Optical
Communication Systems," Ieee Photonic Tech L 22, 835-837 (2010).
[13] R. P. Green, J. J. D. McKendry, D. Massoubre, E. D. Gu, M. D. Dawson, and A. E.
Kelly, "Modulation bandwidth studies of recombination processes in blue and green
InGaN quantum well micro-light-emitting diodes," Applied Physics Letters 102 (2013).
[14] E. F. Schubert, N. E. J. Hunt, R. J. Malik, M. Micovic, and D. L. Miller, "Temperature
and modulation characteristics of resonant-cavity light-emitting diodes," Journal of
Lightwave Technology 14, 1721-1729 (1996).
[15] P. H. Binh, V. D. Trong, P. Renucci, and X. Marie, "Improving OOK Modulation Rate
of Visible LED by Peaking and Carrier Sweep-Out Effects Using n-Schottky Diodes-
Capacitance Circuit," Journal of Lightwave Technology 31, 2578-2583 (2013).
[16] E. F. Schubert, T. Gessmann, and J. K. Kim, Light emitting diodes (Wiley Online
Library, 2006).
[17] P. Deng, M. Kavehrad, and M. A. Kashani, "Nonlinear Modulation Characteristics of
White LEDs in Visible Light Communications," Optical Fiber Communication
Conference, W2A.64 (2015).
[18] B. Galler, P. Drechsel, R. Monnard, P. Rode, P. Stauss, S. Froehlich, W. Bergbauer, M.
Binder, M. Sabathil, B. Hahn, and J. Wagner, "Influence of indium content and
temperature on Auger-like recombination in InGaN quantum wells grown on (111)
silicon substrates," Applied Physics Letters 101 (2012).