Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 834 views

    Assignment Shannon and Transactional

    Uploaded by

    Myl Magrata
    The document compares the Shannon-Weaver model and transaction model of communication. Both models introduce potential hindrances to effective communication, such as noise in the Shannon-Weaver model and differences in positions or contexts between communicators in the transaction model. However, they differ in that the transaction model includes feedback between communicators and captures face-to-face dynamics and non-verbal communication, while the Shannon-Weaver model is linear without feedback and was created before considering interpersonal communication. The transaction model also considers how the communication context and experiences of communicators affect the sending and receiving of messages.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Assignment Shannon and Transactional

    Uploaded by

    Myl Magrata
    834 views3 pages
    The document compares the Shannon-Weaver model and transaction model of communication. Both models introduce potential hindrances to effective communication, such as noise in the Shannon-Weaver model and differences in positions or contexts between communicators in the transaction model. However, they differ in that the transaction model includes feedback between communicators and captures face-to-face dynamics and non-verbal communication, while the Shannon-Weaver model is linear without feedback and was created before considering interpersonal communication. The transaction model also considers how the communication context and experiences of communicators affect the sending and receiving of messages.

    Original Description:

    hw

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document compares the Shannon-Weaver model and transaction model of communication. Both models introduce potential hindrances to effective communication, such as noise in the Shannon-Weaver model and differences in positions or contexts between communicators in the transaction model. However, they differ in that the transaction model includes feedback between communicators and captures face-to-face dynamics and non-verbal communication, while the Shannon-Weaver model is linear without feedback and was created before considering interpersonal communication. The transaction model also considers how the communication context and experiences of communicators affect the sending and receiving of messages.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    834 views3 pages

    Assignment Shannon and Transactional

    Uploaded by

    Myl Magrata
    The document compares the Shannon-Weaver model and transaction model of communication. Both models introduce potential hindrances to effective communication, such as noise in the Shannon-Weaver model and differences in positions or contexts between communicators in the transaction model. However, they differ in that the transaction model includes feedback between communicators and captures face-to-face dynamics and non-verbal communication, while the Shannon-Weaver model is linear without feedback and was created before considering interpersonal communication. The transaction model also considers how the communication context and experiences of communicators affect the sending and receiving of messages.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    You are on page 1of 3

    School Year 2019-2020

    Gordon College – Senior High School


    Gr. 11 HUMSS (Block A)

    Oral Communication in Context

    Group 3
    Aranda, Donna
    Caseja, Dana
    Layora, Juan Rafael Lim
    Loyola, Frelin
    Magrata, Blessy Myl
    Mayoyo, Mae
    Ravina, Leann Veatrice
    Rodriguez, Icko
    Sebastian, Kiana
    Compare Shannon-Weaver Model and the Transaction Model of Communication by
    answering the question:

    1.What are their Similarities?


     Shannon-Weaver Model and the Transaction Model of Communication have a similarity because
    both of them introduces a hindrance for effective or successful communication. In Shannon-Weaver
    Model it introduces the “Noise” one of the hindrance for effective communication and example of
    hindrance in Transactional model, is that the employee cannot comprehend or understood the
    message of the employer because the employer cannot go down to the level of the employee so that
    is why the communication is a failure. That the position or the context of communication could be
    one of the hindrances for successful communication.

     The Shannon-Weaver Model and the Transaction Model of Communication have a same purpose
    and that is there similarity, is that they both have the ability to transmits the message or information
    to the receiver.

    2. What are their Difference?


     Shannon-Weaver Model doesn’t have Feedback because in this model the communication occurred
    when the message has been sent and received including the fact that here there is a sender and a
    receiver, while in Transactional Model the persons are both Senders and Receivers means that they
    both giving each other Feedbacks that’s why this model also called Circular Model while the other
    is Linear Model.

     Shannon-Weaver Model doesn’t capture the “Face to Face Dynamic” because the model reflects
    the time in the place where it was created, on 1940’s both Shannon and Weaver came up with this
    model and working in the telephone industry, so it has this technology angle where it helps explain
    texting well and some kind of information on technology but is doesn’t capture the “Face to Face
    Dynamic” also in here it’s missing the Non-Verbal Communication. So, after some years, Barnlund
    and Watzlawick made the transactional model which helps people to understand the “Face to Face
    interaction” because here we can both use Verbal and Non-Verbal communication.

     Shannon-Weaver is a one process consisting of five elements: Source, Transmitter, Channel,


    Receiver and a Destination. While Transaction Model is a two-way process. This model is more
    interactive because there is a collaborative exchange of messages between communicators.

     In Transactional Model, the sending and receiving the message are affected by the Context (setting
    of work) because it shape how you send and receive the message and Field of Experience this
    means that we all have value and believe that also affect how our interpretation on the message and
    how we send a message, some factor may also be a noise. While in the Shannon-Weaver the
    message may be interfere with only the “Noise” that affects how the receiver received it clearly.
    Shannon-Weaver Model of Communication

    Transaction Model of Communication

    You might also like