Burnout Syndrome: A Disease of Modern Societies?: A. Weber and A. Jaekel-Reinhard
Burnout Syndrome: A Disease of Modern Societies?: A. Weber and A. Jaekel-Reinhard
Burnout Syndrome: A Disease of Modern Societies?: A. Weber and A. Jaekel-Reinhard
512-517, 2000
Copyright © 2000 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins for SOM
Printed in Great Britain. All rights reserved
0962-7480/00
In the light of social change and a transformation in the work situation, interest in the
found predominantly in caring and social professions Contrary to earlier observations regarding the epide-
(e.g. social workers, teachers, nurses, doctors, dentists).3 miology of burnout, it has been noted that the syndrome
A later definition based on the MBI and which is in is not associated with certain workplaces, circumstances,
widespread use today, describes exhaustion, depersona- sex or age. The occurrence of burnout syndrome has
lization, and reduced satisfaction in performance as the been described in diverse occupations, e.g. in social
decisive elements of burnout syndrome.2'9 In the 10th workers, advisors, teachers, nurses, laboratory workers,
revision of the International Classification of Diseases speech therapists, ergo therapists, doctors and dentists,
(ICD 10) the term 'burnout' was described under Z.73.0 police and prison officers, stewardesses, managers, and
as 'Burnout-state of total exhaustion'.10 In addition to even in housewives, students and unemployed peo-
the question of a uniform, generally accepted definition, ple. 2 ' 11 ' 13 " 18 Psychological explanations assume that in
aetiological and pathogenetic aspects are the subjects of most of these occupations the combination of caring,
much controversy. It is generally believed today that advising, healing or protecting, coupled with the
'negative stress' (distress) probably represents a key demands of showing that one cares, is of central
importance.4'8
individualization • mechanization
loss of traditional • globalization/competition
support systems
• increased work complexity
anonymity
• job uncertainty ('hire and
educational fire')
expectations
• mobility/flexibility
lack of time Economization • specialization
multiple stress factors
work, as well as mobbing, economic pressures, and Figure 2. Burnout: a dynamic process ('burnout cascade').
multiple tasks such as job, family and leisure activities. In
addition, the importance of personal competence, parti-
1. Hyperactivity
cularly in the so-called tertiary sector, is continually
increasing (e.g. communicability, being able to work in a
team, frustration tolerance, service orientation, flexibility). 2. Exhaustion - chronic fatigue, loss of energy
According to the job-strain model, which has been
established for many years in occupational medicine as a 3. - withdrawal, resignation
Reduced
stress - strain concept, a high level of strain can result activity
from the cumulation of psycho-mental/psycho-social
stress and a lower level of stress tolerance, which in this 4. Emotional - aggression
reactions - negativity
context is to be regarded as 'negative stress'. When - cynicism
'negative stress' becomes chronic and is not dealt with
5. Breakdown - cognitive function
The symptoms of burnout patients are usually multi- In view of the mainly unspecific symptoms, when it
dimensional with several psychiatric, psychosomatic, comes to the diagnosis of burnout syndrome a differ-
somatic and social disorders. The main psychiatric entiated, all-encompassing approach is necessary. Good
symptoms are, in addition to chronic fatigue and interdisciplinary co-operation and communication be-
continuous exhaustion, above all described as 'mental tween the parties involved in the diagnostic process
dysfunction'. This includes concentration and memory (patient, GP, specialist, works physician, psychologist,
disturbances (a lack of precision, disorganization), a other disciplines) is just as essential as medical expertise.
lack of drive and personality changes (a lack of Box 2 shows a diagnostic approach for diagnosing
interest, cynicism, aggressiveness). Severe disturbances burnout syndrome from social and occupational medi-
are anxiety and depressive disturbances, which can cine points of view.
culminate in suicide. Also the development of addic- Valid objectification and quantification of health
tions (e.g. alcohol, medicines) has been associated impairments and/or functional disturbances must be
with burnout. Common somatic symptoms are head- carried out. This requires medical expertise and should
aches, gastro-intestinal disorders (irritable stomach, not be carried out by non-medical personnel, even if they
diarrhoea), or cardio-vascular disturbances such as are very enthusiastic about the subject. In addition to a
tachycardia, arrhythmia, and hypertonia. Figure 2 general anamnesis to evaluate previous and accompany-
illustrates the dynamic process of developing burnout ing illnesses, a problem-oriented social and occupational
syndrome. anamnesis in particular should be carried out. This
A. Weber and A. Jaekel-Reinhard: Burnout syndrome 515
of prevention can be divided into primary preventive in knowledge could be expected, based on well-founded
measures (avoidance/removal of factors that make the observations.34"36
patient ill), secondary measures (early recognition—in- In times of limited resources, acceptance and feasi-
tervention of manifest disease), and tertiary measures bility also play an important role in the development and
(coping with the consequences of disease—rehabilitation implementation of preventive strategies. In addition, it
and relapse prophylaxis).32 The concepts for behavioural should not be forgotten that effective and efficient
preventive measures presented in the literature focus on prevention requires adequate knowledge of the aetio-
primary prevention and are the 'domain' of psychology. pathogenesis. The closing of gaps in our knowledge
Some of the measures are: would also be a great improvement for the prevention of
burnout.33'37
• improvements in dealing with stress,
• the learning of relaxation techniques,
• the delegation of responsibility (learning to say 'no'), CONCLUSIONS: PROSPECTS
medical care to the best of our abilities. Burnout patients 18. Spiessbach B, Knebelau M, Bender S. Callcenter—Hoff-
need competent help and should feel that their com- nungstrager oder Belastungstra'ger? ErgoMed 1999; 23:
plaints are taken seriously. Even in times of limited 246-252.
resources, comprehensive clarification of the complaints, 19. Scheuch K, Vogel H. Pravalenz von Befunden in ausge-
wahlten Diagnosegruppen bei Lehrern. Soz Prdventivmed
while avoiding the too early fixation with certain causal
1993; 38: 20-25.
relationships, is important. 20. Bourbonnais R, Comeau M, Vezina M, Dion G. Jobstrain,
On the threshold to the 21st century burnout is a psychological distress and burnout in nurses. AmJIndMed
challenge to both research and practice, and not only 1998; 34: 20-28.
because doctors can potentially be affected. Specialists of 21. Lehnert G, Valentin H. Arbeits—und Betriebsmedizin
social medicine and occupational medicine should not zwischen Selbstverantwortung und Fremdbestimmung.
miss the chance of acting in interdisciplinary teams with Arbeitsmed Sozialmed Umweltmed 2000; 35: 14-20.
psychologists to investigate together the problem of 22. Valentin H. Gesundheit und Krankheit an den Arbeitsplat-
burnout syndrome. zen der Zukunft. Zbl Arbeitsmed 1991; 41: 182-192.