Trial Preparation
Trial Preparation
Trial Preparation
TRIAL PREPARATION
(1) Disclosure
At your first appearance the Crown should give you copies of the material they
have about your charges.
If information is missing then send Crown a letter asking for it. (See form letter
on last page of the brochure: “Representing Yourself in a Criminal Trial” printed
by the Legal Services Society.)
Read everything and write down what you received and when you received it.
(2) Analysis
Make notes of any discrepancies, mistakes, or gaps in the witness statements or
police reports.
Make a note of anything that might suggest bias, inaccuracy or weakness in a
Crown witness.
Think about what information or detail may be used against you, and what you
may need to explain.
(3) Preparation
Write down your version of events.
Speak others who may be witnesses.
A Project supported by the Law Foundation of British Columbia February 25, 2002
Ask those who could be helpful to write a statement setting out their names,
addresses, telephone numbers, and observations.
Take this information to your consulting lawyer along with copies of the
Information and particulars from the Crown and any other materials that may
help explain your case, including pictures, diagrams, and maps.
USE THE LAWYER’S SUGGESTIONS to prepare an outline for your final
submissions. (See Legal Research/Resources - Law Centres, Lawyer Referral
Service, etc) This outline must be logical and there must be evidence to support
each point.
LIST THE WITNESSES, their addresses, their telephone numbers, and the
evidence each will give. GO OVER with each witness the evidence that you
expect them to give. Tell them that they will be subpoenaed and arrange to
subpoena them through the Court Registry.
PREPARE AN OUTLINE OF THE EVIDENCE and how you will present it. Any
evidence that does not add support to your final submission is unnecessary and
should be discarded.
DISCUSS WITH THE LAWYER the advantages and disadvantages of testifying.
If you decide to testify then make an outline of what you want to say.
PREPARE AN OUTLINE IN POINT FORM of your cross-examination of the
crown witnesses. List your version of the events alongside the points of their
evidence that you intend to challenge. Include any helpful evidence that the
witness may admit.
A Project supported by the Law Foundation of British Columbia February 25, 2002 2
NOTE TAKING
An accurate and complete note of the evidence is very important. A mis-statement
of the evidence would be a serious error that could undermine the reliability the
Judge attaches to your submissions as well as your evidence.
A Project supported by the Law Foundation of British Columbia February 25, 2002 3
best ensure the correct response. Use these notes as a guide to your examination
and, as each topic is covered, mark whether you established [check mark] or did not
establish [cross] each point or make a short note if something else happened.
Do not make comprehensive notes when you are questioning. This will make your
witness boring and difficult to follow and will allow the opposing witness to consider
the last answer and prepare for the next question. A slow tempo makes you lose the
rhythm that can make your questioning more effective.
Recording the Evidence: it will be difficult to write as fast as witnesses talk, or to
keep all the information straight if you try to record everything longhand.
a. Prepare a list of abbreviations like F= Father, M= Mother, C= Crown, dnr= did
not remember; dnk= did not know, etc.
b. Identify witnesses by their initials: Alan Ball=AB, Tom Jones=TJ. If you use
short forms, record them in the left column to remind yourself of what/who they
are.
c. Label the events: often, different events will be referred to in the evidence. For
example, if there were two assaults, you could name them "Assault 1 and
Assault 2", or "Kitchen Assault and Bedroom Assault". This will keep you from
confusing events and the testimony.
d. Number and record the order of witnesses with a short description. For
example, beside the name of the witness you could write: youngish, long blond
hair, etc. This will help you picture the witness when you try to remember his or
her evidence.
e. Number and record a short description of each Exhibit.
Make an index of witnesses and exhibits: on a separate piece of paper, record the
name and number of each witness and the page where his or her evidence begins.
Do the same for exhibits. This will help when you review the evidence.
Record the evidence word for word: if the witness testifies about the exact words
someone said, or if you intend to contradict the witness on that part of the evidence.
Review the evidence: after each witness testifies, or as soon as you can, record in
your impressions of the witness. If the hearing does not finish that day, summarise
each witness's testimony along with comments on how they presented themselves.
A Project supported by the Law Foundation of British Columbia February 25, 2002 4
Final Submissions: cross-reference your final submission with the witness and page
of your notes. Your submissions will be given greater weight if you can demonstrate
that you have accurately recorded the proceedings and that you can reliably support
your submissions with specific references to the evidence.
A Project supported by the Law Foundation of British Columbia February 25, 2002 5