Probability of Cases being Appealed and Reversed for each Court

Common Pleas Court

Total Cases Appealed Cases Reversed Cases
Judge Disposed
Fred Cartolano 3037 137 12
Thomas Crush 3372 119 10
Patrick 1258 44 8
Dinkelacker
Timothy Hogan 1954 60 7
Robert Kraft 3138 127 7
William Mathews 2264 91 18

William Morrissey 3032 121 22

Norbert Nadel 2959 131 20

Arthur Ney, Jr. 3219 125 14
Richard Niehaus 3353 137 16
Thomas Nurre 3000 121 6
John O’ Connor 2969 129 12
Robert Ruehlman 3205 145 18

J. Howard 955 60 10
Sundermann
Ann Marie Tracey 3141 127 13

Ralph Winkler 3089 88 6

Total 43,945 1762 199

Domestic
Relations Court
Total Cases Appealed Cases Reversed Cases
Judge Disposed
Penelope 2729 7 1
Cunningham
Patrick 6001 19 4
Dinkelacker
Deborah Gaines 8799 48 9
Ronald Panioto 12,970 32 3
Total 30,499 106 17

Municipal Court

Total Cases Appealed Cases Reversed Cases

Judge Disposed
Mike Allen 6149 43 4
Nadine Allen 7812 34 6
Timothy Black 7954 41 6
David Davis 7736 43 5
Leslie Isaiah 5282 35 13
Gaines
Karla Grady 5253 6 0
Deidra Hair 2532 5 0
Dennis Helmick 7900 29 5
Timothy Hogan 2308 13 2
James Patrick 2798 6 1
Kenney
Joseph Luebbers 4698 25 8

William Mallory 8277 38 9

Melba Marsh 8219 34 7
Beth Mattingly 2971 13 1
Albert 4975 28 9
Mestemaker
Mark Painter 2239 7 3
Jack Rosen 7790 41 13
Mark Schweikert 5403 33 6
David Stockdale 5371 22 4
John A. West 2797 4 2
Total 108,464 500 104

1
 Probability of Cases being Appealed and Reversed for each Court
Court Total Cases Total Cases Total Cases Probability of Cases Percentage Probability of Cases Percentage
Disposed Appealed Reversed being Appealed being Reversed

Common Pleas 43,945 1,762 199 0.040095574 4.0095574013 0.0045283878 0.4528387757

Court

Domestic 30,499 106 17 0.0034755238 0.3475523788 0.0005573953 0.0557395324

Relations Court

Municipal Court 108,464 500 104 0.0046098245 0.4609824458 0.0009588435 0.0958843487

Appealed Cases Reversed Cases

3.75

2.5

1.25

0
Common Pleas Court Domestic Relations Court Municipal Court

2
 Probability for EACH Judge

Probability of Case
Total Cases Probability of Cases Probability of Cases being Reversed
Appealed Cases Reversed Cases being Appealed Percentage Rank
being Reversed
Percentage Rank
given that the Case
Percentage Rank Total Rank
Judge Disposed
is Appealed

Fred Cartolano 3037 137 12 0.0451103062232466 4.51% 14 0.0039512677 0.40% 6 0.0875912409 8.76% 5 25

Thomas Crush 3372 119 10 0.0352906287 3.53% 4 0.0029655991 0.30% 4 0.0840336134 8.40% 4 12

Patrick Dinkelacker 1258 44 8 0.0349761526 3.50% 3 0.0063593005 0.64% 12 0.1818181818 18.18% 15 29

Timothy Hogan 1954 60 7 0.0307062436 3.07% 2 0.0035823951 0.36% 5 0.1166666667 11.67% 9 16

Robert Kraft 3138 127 7 0.040471638 4.05% 10 0.0022307202 0.22% 3 0.0551181102 5.51% 2 15

William Mathews 2264 91 18 0.0401943463 4.02% 7 0.00795053 0.80% 15 0.1978021978 19.78% 16 38

William Morrissey 3032 121 22 0.0399076517 3.99% 6 0.0072559367 0.73% 14 0.1818181818 18.18% 14 34

Norbert Nadel 2959 131 20 0.0442717134 4.43% 13 0.0067590402 0.68% 13 0.1526717557 15.27% 12 38

Arthur Ney, Jr. 3219 125 14 0.0388319354 3.88% 5 0.0043491768 0.43% 9 0.112 11.20% 8 22

Richard Niehaus 3353 137 16 0.0408589323 4.09% 11 0.00477184610796302 0.48% 10 0.1167883212 11.68% 10 31

Thomas Nurre 3000 121 6 0.0403333333 4.03% 8 0.002 0.20% 2 0.0495867769 4.96% 1 11

John O’ Connor 2969 129 12 0.0434489727 4.34% 12 0.0040417649 0.40% 7 0.0930232558 9.30% 6 25

Robert Ruehlman 3205 145 18 0.0452418097 4.52% 15 0.0056162246 0.56% 11 0.124137931 12.41% 11 37

J. Howard Sundermann 955 60 10 0.0628272251 6.28% 16 0.0104712042 1.05% 16 0.1666666667 16.67% 13 45

Ann Marie Tracey 3141 127 13 0.0404329831 4.04% 9 0.0041388093 0.41% 8 0.1023622047 10.24% 7 24

Ralph Winkler 3089 88 6 0.0284881838782778 2.85% 1 0.0019423762 0.19% 1 0.0681818182 6.82% 3 5

Total 43,945 1762 199 0.0400955740129708 4.01% - 0.0045283878 0.45% - 0.112939841089671 11.29% - -

Probability of Case
Total Cases Probability of Cases Probability of Cases being Reversed
Appealed Cases Reversed Cases being Appealed
Percentage Rank
being Reversed
Percentage Rank
given that the Case
Percentage Rank Total Rank
Judge Disposed
is Appealed

Penelope Cunningham 2729 7 1 0.0025650421 0.26% 2 0.0003664346 0.04% 2 0.1428571429 14.29% 2 6

Patrick Dinkelacker 6001 19 4 0.003166139 0.32% 3 0.0006665556 0.07% 3 0.2105263158 21.05% 4 10

Deborah Gaines 8799 48 9 0.0054551654 0.55% 4 0.0010228435 0.10% 4 0.1875 18.75% 3 11

Ronald Panioto 12,970 32 3 0.0024672321 0.25% 1 0.000231303 0.02% 1 0.09375 9.38% 1 3

Total 30,499 106 17 0.00347552378766517 0.35% - 0.0005573953 0.06% - 0.1603773585 16.04% - -

Probability of Case
Total Cases Probability of Cases Probability of Cases being Reversed
Appealed Cases Reversed Cases being Appealed Percentage Rank
being Reversed
Percentage Rank
given that the Case
Percentage Rank Total Rank
Judge Disposed
is Appealed

Mike Allen 6149 43 4 0.006993007 0.70% 20 0.0006505123 0.07% 7 0.0930232558 9.30% 4 31

Nadine Allen 7812 34 6 0.0043522785 0.44% 9 0.0007680492 0.08% 11 0.1764705882 17.65% 10 30

Timothy Black 7954 41 6 0.0051546392 0.52% 12 0.0007543374 0.08% 10 0.1463414634 14.63% 6 28

David Davis 7736 43 5 0.0055584281 0.56% 15 0.0006463289 0.06% 6 0.1162790698 11.63% 5 26

Leslie Isaiah Gaines 5282 35 13 0.0066262779 0.66% 19 0.0024611889 0.25% 20 0.3714285714 37.14% 18 57

Karla Grady 5253 6 0 0.0011422045 0.11% 1 0 0.00% 1 0 0.00% 1 3

Deidra Hair 2532 5 0 0.0019747235 0.20% 3 0 0.00% 1 0 0.00% 1 5

Dennis Helmick 7900 29 5 0.0036708861 0.37% 6 0.0006329114 0.06% 5 0.1724137931 17.24% 9 20

Timothy Hogan 2308 13 2 0.0056325823 0.56% 17 0.0008665511 0.09% 13 0.1538461538 15.38% 7 37

James Patrick Kenney 2798 6 1 0.0021443888 0.21% 4 0.0003573981 0.04% 4 0.1666666667 16.67% 8 16

Joseph Luebbers 4698 25 8 0.0053214134 0.53% 14 0.0017028523 0.17% 18 0.32 32.00% 16 48

William Mallory 8277 38 9 0.0045910354 0.46% 11 0.0010873505 0.11% 14 0.2368421053 23.68% 14 39

Melba Marsh 8219 34 7 0.0041367563 0.41% 8 0.0008516851 0.09% 12 0.2058823529 20.59% 13 33

Beth Mattingly 2971 13 1 0.0043756311 0.44% 10 0.000336587 0.03% 3 0.0769230769 7.69% 3 16

Albert Mestemaker 4975 28 9 0.0056281407 0.56% 16 0.0018090452 0.18% 19 0.3214285714 32.14% 17 52

Mark Painter 2239 7 3 0.0031263957 0.31% 5 0.0013398839 0.13% 16 0.4285714286 42.86% 19 40

Jack Rosen 7790 41 13 0.0052631579 0.53% 13 0.0016688062 0.17% 17 0.3170731707 31.71% 15 45

Mark Schweikert 5403 33 6 0.0061077179 0.61% 18 0.0011104942 0.11% 15 0.1818181818 18.18% 12 44

David Stockdale 5371 22 4 0.0040960715 0.41% 7 0.0007447403 0.07% 9 0.1818181818 18.18% 11 27

John A. West 2797 4 2 0.0014301037 0.14% 2 0.0007150518 0.07% 8 0.5 50.00% 20 30

Total 108,464 500 104 0.0046098245 0.46% - 0.0009588435 0.10% - 0.208 20.80% - -

Largest 0.006993007 0.0024611889 0.5 0.351950019