ISSN 2091-2889 (Online)

ISSN 2091-2412 (Print)

CH
I TW A N M E D
IC Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2018;8(26):54-57
Available online at: www.jcmc.cmc.edu.np
OF

AL
JOURN AL

COL
LEGE
JCMC

ORIGINAL RESEARCH ARTICLE

ESTD 2010

LATERAL THROAT FORM CLASSIFICATION USING A CUSTOMIZED GAUGE AND NEIL’S METHOD
– A COMPARATIVE STUDY
Sabina Poudel1, Minu Dhungana2, Rajani Karki3 ,Prabhat Shrestha4
1,2
lecturer, 3Dental surgeon, 4Associate Professor, Department of Prosthodontics, KIST Medical College Imadole, Lalitpur.
*Correspondence to: Dr. Sabina Poudel, Lecturer, Department of Prosthodontics, Kist Medical College and Teaching Hospital, Imadol, Lalitpur, Nepal.
Email: sabinapoudel@hotmail.com

ABSTRACT
Introduction: Lateral throat form (LTF) is the critical area which has to be recorded properly for obtaining proper
retention and stability in complete denture especially in geriatric patients with resorbed ridges. Popular method
used for determining LTF is Neil’s method which depends on the forces applied by the floor of mouth when
the tongues protrude out. Since the perception of the forces differs among different operators, there are high
chances of error in the classification. So, customized instrument was fabricated to prevent this inter-observer
variation. The aim of the study was to compare the inter-observer accuracy between Neil’s method of classifi-
cation and classification done by customized gauze. Methods and methodology: Total 30 edentulous patients
were taken. Two observers measured the LTF depth by customized tool and also by Neil’s method. Cohen’s
kappa test was used to evaluate the agreement between two operators in two different classifications. Result:
The agreement between the two observers was evaluated by means of Cohen’s kappa value. There was good
agreement between observers in proposed classification done by customized tool with kappa value 0.658 and
fair inter-observer agreement with kappa value 0.0492. Conclusion: The method of measuring the depth of LTF
with fabricated instrument was more accurate and reliable than Neil’s method.

Key words: Lateral throat form, Neil’s classification, Retention, Stability.

INTRODUCTION
area as available. This can be done by incorporating
Most of the patients visiting to the prosthodontic
the distal part of the alveolingual sulcus (LTF). It is
department for complete denture prosthesis are old
an area located below and behind the retromolar
aged with resorbed ridges and with high expectations.
Because of the tongue and other muscular forcesregion and is bounded anteriorly by mylohyoid
muscles, laterally by retromolar pad, posterolaterally
acting during various functions, such as chewing,
by superior constrictor muscles, posteromedially
talking, and swallowing, stability and retention
in lower denture are hampered.1 This problem isby the palatoglossus muscles, medially by tongue.3
Mandibular dentures are shallow in premylohyoid
magnified due to less available mandibular denture
region, and turn towards the tongue in mylohyoid
bearing area (14cm2) than maxillary denture bearing
area (24cm2).2 The above constraints contributeregion and deep in the retromylohyoid region. This
area provides larger vertical height for the denture
towards the challenge in fabricating stable, retentive
and satisfying lower denture. Recently, more which in turn increase the retention and horizontal
support of the lower denture.4 The extension of the
retentive option like implant supported fixed and
denture into this area can resist horizontal forces,
removable dentures are available. However, due to
increases border seal, prevents tongue from returning
the medical conditions, costs and fear of surgery,
not all of them prefer implant. to denture’s polished surface, act as a displacing
lever on the denture border and contribute in the
The method for increasing the stability and neuromuscular control mechanism.5 Beside these,
retention is including as much denture bearing glandular triangle (lower part of retromylohyoid

54 JCMC/ Vol 8/ No. 4/ Issue 26/ Oct-Dec, 2018

space) is the soft structure. So, if the margin of the depth. Stopper was fabricated on the vertical arm
lingual flange is continued posteriorly to the LTF of the pipe so that it rests on the retro molar pad.
area, flange is snugly fitted providing appreciable Patients were instructed to keep the tongue 1/4th
seal.6 inch ahead of the lower lip (Figure 2). The tongue
was retracted and the reading was taken. It was then
Till date, Neil’s classification is considered, the classified according to the classification purposed by
most appropriate for recording lateral throat form Kalavathy et al.4
depth.4 As classified by Neil’s, an index finger is
placed in retromolar region and patient is asked to
protrude the tongue 1/4th inch beyond the lower lip.
If appreciable displacing force is felt in the finger, it
is Class I, if the force felt is negligible it is considered
as class III. If the force felt is in between, it is class
II.7 It is a subjective method of classification and
depends upon the tactile sensation experienced by
the observer. This may result in inaccurate recording Figure 1: Customized instrument used to measure
of depth of LTF which ultimately prevents proper LFT
extension of the lingual flange to the proper limit.

Due to these several drawbacks in Neil’s method,

many clinicians used different technique and
fabricated new tools to record depth of LTF. In this
study, a simple customized gauze was designed
and fabricated to take the measurement of LTF and
interobserver variation between the Neil’s method
and customized gauze was compared.

METHODS
This study was done in the department of
Prosthodontics and Implantology in KIST medical
college and hospital which included 30 edentulous
patients between age 50-85 years from different Figure 2: During measuring of LFT
places of Kathmandu. Patients with completely
edentulous mandibular arch and in whom easy RESULTS
recognition of retromolar pad was possible were
included in the study. Those patients who had
undergone hemimandibulectomy or glossectomy, Table 1: LTF left and right side observer I
uncooperative patients, patient having congenital
defect and patients with impaired neuromuscular LTF left LTF right
coordination were excluded from the study. Classification
Frequency Frequency
range
Simple and economical instrument was designed. (Percent) (Percent)
Hollow ‘L’ shaped pipe was fabricated with acrylic 0.5-1.4 18 (60 %) 15 (50 %)
resin. Flexible wrought wire was inserted inside it.
1.5-2.4 12 (40 %) 15 (50 %)
This wire was freely movable inside the acrylic pipe.
Both ends were extended outside the pipe. One end Total 30 (100 %) 30 (100 %)
had small acrylic ball that rest on the floor of the
mouth. Extension on the other side would move
on a scale attached to the acrylic pipe (Figure 1).
The reading in this side gave the lateral throat form

JCMC/ Vol 8/ No. 4/ Issue 26/ Oct-Dec, 2018 55

Table 2: LTF left and right side observer II.

Classification range LTF left Frequency (Percent) LTF right Frequency (Percent)
0.5-1.4 17 (56.7 %) 17 (56.7 %)
1.5-2.4 13 (43.3 %) 13 (43.3 %)
Total 30 (100 %) 30 (100 %)

Table 3: Neil’s LTF observerI and observerII

Neil’s classification Observer I Frequency (Percent) Observer II

Frequency (Percent) 17 (56.7 %) 17 (56.7 %)
Class I 3 (10 %) 5 (16.7 %)
Class II 15 (50 %) 18 (60 %)
Class III 12 (40 %) 7 (23.3 %)
Total 30 (100 %) 30 (100 %)
Table 4: Neil’s LTF observer I, Neil’s LTF observer II cross tabulation:

Neil’s LFT observer II

Total
Class I Class II Class III
Class I 3 0 3 3
Neil’s LTF Class II 2 12 1 15
observer I Class III 0 6 6 12
Total 5 18 7 30
DISCUSSION
Study was conducted among 30 patients. Observer
I classified 60% of patients as class C, 40% as class
The attachment of the mylohyoid muscles extends
B on left side. Whereas observer II classified 56.7%
about 1cm distal to the end of the mylohyoid ridge.
as class C and 43.3% as class B on left sides.0n right
This anatomy prevents the denture from locking
side observer I classified 50% as class B and 50% against the bone in the LTF region. Extension of
as class C According to Neil’s method observer flange in distal end of alvelolingual sulcus (LTF) makes
I classified 10%, 50% and 40% as class I, class II the border seal continuous from the retromolar
and class III respectively. observer II classified pad to the middle region of the alveolingual sulcus.
16.7%,60.0%,23.3% as class I, class II and class III.
Secondly, the distolingual flange is shaped so that
it will guide tongue on top of the flange of the
denture. This contour assists the patient to control
Agreement between the observers for these the denture without interfering with the functions of
methods were analyzed using kappa statistics. When the soft tissues which in turn enhances the retention
customized gauze was used, right side agreement and stability of complete denture.8
between observers was found good with kappa
value 0.658 (p=0.01). Similarly, agreement between In the present study, according to the Neil’s
observer I and observer II on left side was good classification observer I have classified 3 patients as
with kappa value 0.600 (p=0.01). Whereas in Neil’s class I, 15 patients as class II and 12 patients with
method the agreement between two observers class III LTF. Observer II have classified 5 patients
were less with kappa 0.0492 (p=0.01). as class I, 18 patients as class II and 7 patients as

56 JCMC/ Vol 8/ No. 4/ Issue 26/ Oct-Dec, 2018

class III. So inter-observer variation was seen in the REFERENCES
Neil’s classification. When measurement was done
with customized gauze, more consistent result was 1. Heo Y-R, Kim H-J, Son M-K, Chung C-H. Contour of
obtained. Our result is consistent to the study done lingual surface in lower complete denture formed
by Sadvi et al, who used a customized instrument by polished surface impression. The journal of
for LTF readings intraorally and reported about advanced prosthodontics. 2016;8(6):472-478.
consistent result.9 In present study, class II followed
by class III was more common than class I. This 2. Zarb GA, Bolender CL, Eckert SE. Prosthodontic
finding was not consistent with the study performed Treatment for Edentulous Patients: Complete
by Parajuli et.al in which class I LTF was maximum.5 Dentures and Implant-supported Prostheses. 12
Similar result was found by Ajay Sharma with Class ed: Mosby; 2004.
I being the maximum and class III the least.10 Huang
et al also reported class I as maximum and class III 3. Rastogi I. Evaluation of lateral throat form-an in
as minimum.9 This finding can be explained by the vivo study. 2014. 2014;2(2):5.
statement that their studies were done on dentulous
young patients and anatomy is best at younger age 4. Kalavathy N, Kumar PR, Gupta S, Sridevi J, Shetty
and decreases as the age increases.5 In our study the M, Sanketh AK. Lateral throat form re-classified
study participants were of advanced age and were using a customized gauge: A clinical study. The
wearing denture after long period of edentulism. Journal of the Indian Prosthodontic Society.
2016;16(1):20.
In the present study, economically fabricated tool
has helped us to overcome the commonly practiced 5. Parajuli P, Shetty TB, Shenoy V, Rodrigues SJ.
subjective method and also the inconsistency Comparative evaluation of the lateral throat
between the examiners. However, there is only form and the border extension of mandibular
one study in which attempt has been made to complete denture in the distolingual region
classify the LTF based on measurement made by among the south coastal Karnataka population:
customized tool.4 This study aims to see the accuracy An in vivo study. Journal of Nepal Dental
between interobserver by using the Kalavathy et al 4 Association. 2010;11(2):121-125.
classification and compare it with Neil’s classification.
6. Barrett SG, Haines RW. Structure of the mouth
in the mandibular molar region and its relation
A variety of clinical situations like inexperienced to the denture. Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry.
clinicians who is unable to position the instrument 1962;12(5):835-837.
properly, excessively large tongue which hampers
the visibility of metal ball, patients with OSMF and 7. Huang P-S, Chou T-M, Chang H-P, et al. The
other fibrotic and degenerative conditions were not proportion of 3 classes of lateral throat form.
justified by the relatively small sample size in this International Journal of Prosthodontics.
study. 2007;20(6).

8. Swenson MG, Boucher CO. Complete Dentures:

CONCLUSION Edited by Carl O. Boucher. Mosby; 1964.

Fabricated instrument gives the consistent result 9. Sadhvi K, Nair C, Shetty J. Lateral throat
and helps in the proper selection of stock tray which form‑design of a measuring instrument. KDJ.
in turn results in the proper extension of custom 2010;33:18-19.
tray. Thus, extension of lingual flange can be taken
to proper limit. This method of LTF measurement is 10. Sharma A. Distolingual Vestibule And
more beneficial in edentulous patient with advanced Retromylohyoid. Worlds Journal Of Dental
age with resorbed ridge. Science. 2016;1(1).

JCMC/ Vol 8/ No. 4/ Issue 26/ Oct-Dec, 2018 57